Skip to main content
Loading video...

11 Board Games Ranked - Episode 33

Transcript 20:12

hey everybody and welcome to another chairman of the board ranking video so in this series I take a look at the last 10 board games that I've played and I ranked them from my least favorite up to my most favorite now this episode is going to be slightly different because I'm talking about 11 games rather than the 12 because I played two new ones on the same day and I didn't want to over spill into the next episode now before I get started on today's episode I want to give a shout out to the show sponsor kenderc K who my goto online retailer and if you use the link in the show notes or the QR code then you can get 5% off your first order okay so at number 11 I have paragon's age of Champions now this is an upcoming Kickstarter game and that was of course provided to me by the publisher now this is a jeweling game it's actually um plays up to three players which is quite unusual um as you'd expect you have your kind of your hero class you could be like a mage uh like a ranger or a warrior and you have um a partially constructed deck made up of those class types but before the game starts you also do a draft where you're using these kind of neutral cards to Pat out your deck um after you finish your draft you're going to co down your deck to to a fixed number of cards and then commence the jeweling and you have this kind of layout system where you are allocating your kind of summons to different spots on the board where you can block each other and stuff cast bigace

and all the stuff you'd expect with a kind of a magic jeweling Style game now this is quite similar to Magic the Gathering but I suppose the USP about this one is that it is a self-contained box so that you're not paying paying to uh to win this style game um these type of games aren't generally for me and this was an example of that um I'm not too interested in constructing a deck before playing I'd much rather have a fixed deck and just say you know you're the ranger you get this bunch of cards you're the wor you get this bunch of cards and then get going now I'm not again I'm not kind of interested in constructing a deck as part of the game because I'd rather just jump straight in um so not quite for me I suppose it's quite a niche audience because I think if you if you like these styles of games you're probably going to be a fan of Magic the Gathering anyway that being a lifestyle game you're not really going to find the the need to own this one I feel but maybe I'm wrong on that you know these games are are massively popular but I'm just struggling to find the audience for this one at number 10 I have the Ming Dynasty now this is um one that's quite hard to explain because the rules are quite fiddly um and the rule pick book itself was one of the worst um I've ever seen we really did have to work quite hard to um to force our way through uh this one but it's kind of an old school Euro a bit of area control there a bit of car drafting essentially you're trying to spread your presence um on this map by drafting these different kind of kind of um transport cards it did have quite a cool mechanism where

you could deploy your kind of Pawns on these different spots which would kind of broaden your scope to giraffe the cards that you want but you had to be able to deploy from these different zones to put them onto the board in the first place then you can even allocate them to different spots within the spots it was quite a convoluted and fiddly game that I'm not quite sure um I'm not quite sure resonated with me I I I didn't really feel like the rules fixed in place and I couldn't really extract the fun for this one because it was such um such a chore to work your way through the rules and how the mechanisms actually worked so you know I think there is a game here is there probably is a somewhat decent game here but I think the game really did hamstring Itself by not being not being able to convey the rules cohesively um and that really did hurt the game so it also went on quite long I think it outstay is welcome by 30% or so so I couldn't really recommend this one with so many other games out there it just tried a bit too hard to be different I think and um just ended up being a bit of a mechanical mess at number nine I have flamecraft so a very popular game from last year it's kind of a I'd say a mediumweight maybe a medium lightweight worker placement game as you are deploying your workers onto this kind of um Street I suppose and these shops are popping up you're playing these very cute Dragon cards in order to get extra abilities and essentially it's a contract fulfillment game collect a bunch of resources cash them in for these public contracts and um hopefully

get a lot of points for doing so now these kind of medium lightweight worker placement games normally leave me feeling very numb I don't get much from them because I always feel they somewhat rinse and repeat this one despite having a lovely aesthetic left me feeling the exact same way um I just don't really feel this game does anything different to the glut of other games of a similar ilk so um just despite looking wonderful you know the artwork is quite spectacular a real Charming kind of aesthetic to it some really funny names and some really cool images um but the gameplay itself left me wanting for more um and I'm I'm not quite sure why this one really did take off so much because I think the game play is is average at best so that is flamecraft at number nine at number eight I have kenin so kenin a game I really didn't know anything about um my brother picked this one up and we played it the the other day now this is a kind of a a hidden ability Style game as you have a fixed deck of cards each of these cards have special powers or strengths on them and then you're deploying them to these different battlefields but similar to a game like between two cities you always competing with your neighbors on either side I'm trying to compete over these particular zones the zones have special restrictions and um and powers on them which can you change your strategy and it's all about trying to play the cards in the right order trying to get into the head of your opponent to understand what they're likely going to be playing a bit of mind

reading a bit of bluffing um and this is really one of those games that would reward repeated plays as you become more familiar with the characters and understand how they interact with one another um yeah I definitely think a meta game would build up here if you invested the time into it now I thought the game was fine and again I thought there is a game there if you really look for it um I'm not quite sure if I'm willing to put in the the time to really get the most out of this one because I think there are a better games out there that are quite similar games like Kier pop to mind um and even if you want like a you know a character driven card game or an ability driven card game I'd probably rather play something like valara as well so this one I think it's fine um I just I can see why it has kind of faded Into Obscurity because this is a game that's you know 8 years old now and nobody is talking about it so not bad but um nothing special either at number seven I I have dominion so despite all the games that I've played um this is the first time I've played the ever famous Dominion so really was the grandfather of the deck building um style of game and this one really is Back to Basics just collect cards um tried to get currency and then trade those currency in for points now this game is remarkably smooth um turns are lightning quick which I definitely think are massive or big upside um for this game and actually had one of the coolest catch up mechanisms that I've seen

because when you are spending this money to get those points those points actually go into your hand as kind of dead cards I suppose and I really like the way that works because you know if you are starting to steamroll it and get really ahead on points your deck isn't going to be as efficient as someone who hasn't got as many points cards in their hand so definitely one of the coolest catchup mechanisms um that I've ever seen now I have only played with the base game and it is very basic and you know this you know I'm trying to put my mind in a in a place where this was new at the time I could see how this really did kind of take off but now I've played so many deck builders that have kind of cherry-picked all the best bits from the minion this one just kind of feels like well I've seen it all before but I did like the purity of it I would I would be intrigued to try some of the better rated expansion to see how much it is elevated but it's game I can definitely appreciate I can see how influential it is um but you know deck building isn't my thing anyway and if I'm going to play Deck Builders I'm probably going to play something a bit more modern um so that is Dominion a good game and I'm finally glad I've um I've played it after all these years at number six I have my shelfie so this is a puzzly kind of tile placement game um as you are filling up a kind of a CAC shelf I suppose full of all these different tokens and building patterns trying to score points on different criteria and the drafting system in this one was quite cool it reminded me a bit of um the game called Citrus where you have a big communal grid of these tiles and you can basically slide a bunch of tiles

depending on different restrictions um and then put them into your board in a in a certain order um so I did like that drafting system it did kind of elevate it a little bit from a fairly basic kind of you know a puzzly Style game but it was good and I did like the fact that the boards themselves are vertically stacked like a almost like a Connect Four and board so you do have that gravity aspect when you are placing these tiles they are sinking to the bottom which again adds another wrinkle to the to the game play and you know it was perfectly fine perfectly inoffensive and a game that's doesn't take too long and I kind of like these puzzle style games anyway so I'm never really going to turn down a game like this but um I have played better ones but I've certainly played worse ones as well so that is my shelf Fe at number six at number five I have forever home now this is a game that came from nowhere for me because this was sent to me by uh the publisher I knew nothing about it really um and it was surprisingly good so this is another puzzly Style game fairly abstract in the way that it works um where you essentially drafting these little dog tokens putting them on this little grid and trying to puzzle them out matching these scoring cards but the Twist on this one is that when you score one of those scoring cards you are removing the tokens or at least one or two of the tokens from that pattern and then putting them on these different scoring categories to score extra points so it's quite cool how the game woulde almost like kind of metamorphosize as the game goes on and you could kind of

build patterns take things off that will build a new pattern and so on so really did kind of flow very nicely and this is like a true efficiency puzzle you don't want to waste any movement in this game at all very simple mechanically where all you're doing is drafting the tokens you're drafting a new scoring card or you are moving an existing dog on the board already so you do have that little bit of leeway to um to move things that you've already placed which I thought was a really nice touch but you're doing that at the expense of efficiency um lovely look again another game that looks um very Charming gorgeous artwork um and again another game that's perfectly in offensive very quick I mean this is like a 20 minute game it almost feels slightly too quick because when you get the the ball rolling the game ends quite abruptly so I be prepared for that but I mentioned my my in my review that it's a a fairly easy house rule to change that if you want to play with with a higher objective or higher a higher amount of score cards to prolong the game a little bit more to to sink your teeth into that pattern building but um yeah I like this one a lot um it's gone down really well with who I've played it with and um I'll play it some more for sure so that is forever home at number five okay so we actually have four recommendations at this episode so four commendations coming here the first of which at number four is wild til West now if you were to say to me that that I would um give a quite a strong recommendation to another polyomino game

I would probably call you crazy because poly omino games as you know have been done to exhaustion but this one has kind of taken it to the next level because not only are you filling up your border poino shapes trying to cover certain regions trying to cover up negative points all those things you'd expect all these tows have a bunch of different things on them as well like for example they could have cows on them which you are trying to Wrangle to to get points or you have like Bandits and sheriffs which you are kind of using to counteract each other and collecting these bullets to shoot the bandits in the same row or column you're collecting these ace cards um so it has quite a cool thematic tie to this one and I've mentioned before that I tend to like these polyomino games where the polyomino part of the game is like the base level but you're playing a game on top of that as well so you have that layered kind of gameplay which I think works really well here lovely Aesthetics again the theme comes through quite nicely ly and the the actual way you draft the tiles is different in this one as well because you are actually rolling dice placing them on these kind of um really cool game trays where all the different tiles are sat and then you can draft from the same kind of row on column where these dice have been placed so you know you have got some quite strong restrictions here um and even you got other things as well such like a little little Powers you can use and utilize hidden objectives and so on so you definitely got a lot of sinky teeth into here and a lot of different kind of Point scoring categories to try and mul over so that is wild TI West a really

nice kind of family weight Plus game that I would recommend for sure at number three I have Forest Shuffle so I'm pretty sure any other episode this game could be at a number one easily because this is a fantastic set collection game um where you are really tying together a bunch of sets at the same time very simple C drafting either taking them from you know face down from the top of the stack or from this communal pool because in order to play cards you need to pay other cards so and I love the way that when you pay for these cards with other cards those cards that you paid with are going into that shared pool ready to be drafted by the other players so you have some of passive player interaction there which I really like and you have to be quite careful about what you give up because those cards could be very important and they're kind of key piece to their strategy and tons of different ways to score points here all the cards kind of cross contaminate and score with each other and it's another kind of efficiency game as you don't want to be wasting cards um where you could be extracting more points by playing other cards now um I did hear some comments on my video of this one that there's complaints of imbalance there's complaints of it going on too long I haven't felt that at all for what I've seen yes some cards are worth more than others but you normally have to pay more cards to play them and I suppose the scarcity in order to get the most from them are you know are thin in a deck so I I don't really see a problem here it's all about trying to score as much as you can and hell if there is a category that that worth more

points then be sure you get your fair share of that cake so of the pie so um yeah I think this game is one of the best set collection games I've played in a long time um it's going to be a candidate for a top 10 game of the year maybe even top five and certainly a top three card game um I think it is that good so that is Forest Shuffle check out my review because it's I've done quite a comprehensive one um and it's already been uploaded at number two I have the rich and the good so I've been waiting for a long time for this one to get delivered to me it's actually a reprint of an older game back from 2008 now this is an economic game a commodity speculation game as you trying to buy stocks low sell them high and manipulate that stock market in your favor now the way you do that that in this game is very cool because you have a bunch of cards that are positioned between you and your neighbors so obviously people on the other side of the table can't really see what you can see so you have a fairly accurate knowledge of what these stocks could be worth but of course your opponents could have the polar opposite of that and could really tank the stocks that you're looking to raise and all you're doing is you're choosing to buy one to three stocks sell one to three stocks and um it has this twist where at certain points in the game you want to be stashing money away because if you do not stash this money away then you're going to fall behind and the player who's kind of um donated or know um yeah

donated the least amount of money will be automatically eliminated from the game so it almost has this reverse system to a game like high society which adds a whole new dimension to the game flows wonderfully extremely simple rule set and it's probably one of the best styles of games like this that I've seen you know I've played a ton of them your acquir your raccoon tycoons and your be raids this one I think is the best one and ironically it's the simplest one as well that is the rich and the good I'm hopefully I'll get a review of that one up very soon and finally at number one I have dragon Keepers by Michael Menzel actually so this is another very light card game that is deceptively deep so all you're doing in this game is you're trying to play a certain amount of these Dragon cards and depending on this book um configuration that's on the table but those books are basically the reverse side of the deck that you're drawing from and one will say a number and one will say a dragon type and that is going to be what you're trying to play in order to get points but the Twist on this one is that when you're drafting these CS that book state is constantly going to change and you have one chance to manipulate that book State um and then hopefully pay some cards out to score points the way you score points in this game is very interesting because you are kind of taking these little amulet pieces and when you get three of them they'll create this perfect circle and you'll get a gem to put in the center of it which is kind of a random denomination of points and there's other

scoring categories you can get as well such as these golden eggs and if you have the majority you'll get some bonus points uh and so on and there's further restrictions as well because once you play I think it's your third set of Dragon cards out there one of your sets can no longer be played um so you it does have this kind of chicken mechanism where when do I want to give up on scoring a certain type and you are even incentivized to do that because as soon as you've played your fourth type of dragon then you get a quite a hefty um chunk of points for doing so so again that push and pull of do I want to keep my options open or do I want to go for those points and I'm hopefully um do without playing those other types check out my review for this one I think it should be uploaded by now um I was blown away with this one instantly fell in love with it um and it's definitely one of those games where when you first play it you're not quite sure where the game play lies but the more and more you play you kind of think oh I've made mistakes here I should have done this I should have done this I should approach it this way and those are the kind of games that sing to me and stick around very pure rule set again simple as just drafting cards changing the book if you want to and then playing cards out and hopefully scoring some points um so yeah mechanically beautifully simple good depth good player interaction good turn angst and um yeah all wrapped up in a 20 minute package that looks beautiful as well so yeah definitely very very impressed um with dragon Keepers and that's two fantastic card games that I've played in the last couple of weeks with with Forest Shuffle and dragon

Keepers so yeah quite spoiled in 2023 so far so there we have it that concludes uh the video as been a joy talking about some of these games been very lucky uh this last month or so to play some absolute cra ERS now if you have enjoyed the video please be sure to hit like And subscribe uh to the channel and check out my other content too but for everybody else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye-bye

Progress saved