TCbH's Top 10 Games Over 5 Years Old
Transcript
you know on this channel we pay a lot of attention to the latest and greatest the hotness because that's what's coming out and that's what people want to know about but occasionally we look back at our forebears in the tabletop dimension and appreciate games that have come out a while ago and as a great man once said the old that is strong does not wither so today we're taking a look at my 10 favorite games that are at least five years old because they're just still so good and before we get into the actual list i had a surprising revelation that came to me when i finally penciled down what these games were in the order in which i put them in and i'm interested to see if you can guess what that pattern is before we get to the end i will definitely talk about that on the outro so with that said let's go ahead and dive in with number 10 being suburbia this is the greatest tabletop simulation of city building that i've played today nothing has rivaled it of course it draws immediate comparison to sim city and other city building games on the pc that i grew up with but as a tabletop game alone it just has awesome synergies the feeling of adding a new towel to your burrow and having about five things go off the amount of sculpting and leaning into specific strategies that you can do the
development and reaction that you have to all the different burrows that are happening along with a lot of really fresh and still modern ideas like hidden scoring and variable end game scoring conditions and just the the presentation of it just works all so well it's still one of my favorite games to this day i love playing at two players i love playing at higher player accounts because of the reactionary stuff between burrows and it is one of the games where i think it has an iconic expansion with suburbia inc it's awesome number nine is actually an interesting position because i did not want to discount any number of worker placement games and i was trying to struggle and decide which one i wanted to recognize in this slot there are so many awesome games that i could put here i could put viticulture agricola caverna but ultimately i decided to lean into the personal fave the thing that you know really makes me feel like i'm at home you know the comfort food of board games and that would be lords of water deep i am actually not that huge of a dungeons and dragons guy i know much about the lore and i've played rpgs a plenty but that's not really my area of expertise but this game just captures a different perspective in the fantasy realm kind of having this nice victorian meets high
fantasy shtick about it it has an excellent addition with the scoundrels of skullport uh corruption token mechanic and it's just a really solid nice mid-weight worker placement that is enjoyable which is about anyone that i play it with it's a game that i've played a million times and it's a game that i still look forward to having on the table now and it has one of the best maps in all of tabletop gaming on the board you can fight me on that number eight is game of thrones second edition this is the primo area control game one of my favorite big heavy let's spend all afternoon playing it games it was hugely influential on me and it's still a game that i look forward to playing whenever i can safely get six gamers together who actually want to be playing a full afternoon of game of thrones the hidden order mechanic had such a great thematic resonance to the mechanical carrying out of different actions the sort of betrayals and upheavals that are iconic to the story that it's based on happen all the time in the board game itself the exchanges between who has all the different positions it's all there it's incredibly rich it's thematic it's dynamic and if you really want something to kind of modernize it a little bit the mother of dragons expansion has done a lot in order to bring some new concepts
to a game that has been out for quite a long time but you don't need it it's totally good as is number seven castle's a burgundy it's just one of the best games it's the best stephen feld game it's one of the best euro games it's pretty much the best dice allocation game out there and it is an incredibly good two player game like it is easily one of the most recommendable hey i want to play more games with my partner it's mainly just us playing games but we like things that are a little bit more in depth but are too intimidated to get into food chain magnate and all that well hey get castles of burgundy it's affordable it is a incredibly fun game tons of replayability and scales to about any player count awesomely it's a shame that the new edition of it doesn't really improve upon the overall look and aesthetic but it does include a bunch of expansion material and even if you get the og version it is perfectly fine it is a fantastic game number six is a game that you don't see on a lot of lists anymore in fact this is a game that even at the time that it came out was kind of controversial where people were like is this really a game what's up with this because it was the follow-up to dominion but nonetheless it did win a spiel that year that's kingdom builder my favorite donald x game and one of my favorite abstract games of all time and people are like yo does this actually mean anything i draw a card and i just
play a couple things yes yes if you reduce the game to just drawing a card and putting down three settlements then yeah it's not much of a game but as soon as you see that the entire concept that you must play adjacent to existing settlements if possible the strategic ramifications go through the roof and you start making all kinds of important decisions in order to eliminate possible adjacency to hop all over the board capitalize on all the special powers and the amount of replayability the variety from mixing up all the boards and all the powers and eventually through later expansions having all the different scoring conditions yeah there are a variety of scoring conditions in the base game but they came out with even more later on there's so much to love about kingdom builder it's a game that i think is an unsung hero of the tabletop gaming world and could use more love i certainly am going to give it here number five is five tribes did i pick it because it's number five and it has five in it well i was going to pick it for the list anyway a lot of these games probably could have been shifted around in different ways depending on how i was just feeling that day what was in my coffee that morning i guess this morning because i wrote out this list this morning but maybe i put this in number five just because it would have an interesting synergy there anyway bruno catala is one of my favorite designers who i have a huge amount of admiration for in how he
structures his games and creates decision space and while this is not the typical reserved bruno catala where it's a few small but really important decisions because in five tribes you could do about a million different things in your turn it still has the the same vibe that bruno tends to bring and it looks bright it looks inviting and interesting on the table with loads of pieces and the mancala meets euro gaming shtick about it is really good when you can pull off a turn or even a successive back-to-back turn in a two-player game it just feels like nothing else five tribes is easily one of the most played games in my collection and i don't see that trend ending anytime soon number four is seven wonders duel again this is kind of like the whole castle's a burgundy thing if you wanted to know what one of the just easiest to recommend best games out there is it's 7 wonders duel it's so much better than 7 wonders itself i mean it's a very different game which trades on the same excellent theme but you know does away with it being seven wonders and is actually a really good game it's smart it has tons of variety to it it's a bruno catala code design which adds some of that flavor that i was just talking about and it's one of these games that actually made two-player drafting make sense it's a game where every decision that you make not just what you take but
what you're potentially going to reveal has immediate ramifications and it's not that hard to conceptually understand what you're doing so it's a very accessible game nonetheless the decisions are very meaningful and there's a high level of strategy to it it's a great theme it's a great look the three-way tug of war aspect about it is incredible what more can i say it's seven wonders duel number three is maybe because i'm playing a current campaign of this revisiting a game that i actually hadn't played in a while but has been revitalized in some ways and that's star wars imperial assault this is the best of the best when it comes to the descent system what i'm talking about descent first edition second edition imperial assault and even the brand new descent legends of the dark this is the best of them it has the most refined mechanics it has a ton of great synergy between characters and strategies if you want to play the 1v all version of it it's awesome if you want to play the new app assisted version of it that came out a couple of years ago i know this is supposed to be games that are at least five years old and so i really shouldn't be including that app in here but nonetheless it's a new addition to an already great game so you could play foley co-op yeah it's there and it is just a beautiful game to behold even if you're like me and star wars is just kind of okay to you this game is just one of the best dungeon
crawl games that is out there number two is another game that you may say that i'm cheating because there's a brand new version of it that just came out and that is eclipse because a new dawn for the galaxy came out last year and that's really good but even if we didn't have a new version the iconic original version is absolutely one of my favorite games and the new version is really mostly cosmetic in nature just revitalizing everything and kind of putting it together in a better organized box i do recommend the new version of it but fundamentally that it's still the same game and even if that never came out eclipse would still be one of my favorite games out there it nails the 4x thing where you're exploring you're expanding your territories you're exterminating your enemies and you're extracting resources or potential gain it has a dynamic system for upgrading your ships which has this really great organic feel to it as everyone else is making decisions about how they upgrade and you react to it outfitting yourself in order to better attack them or defend against others the whole exploration and fighting against npc ships so that way you still can engage in combat even if you're not particularly aggressive as a player and just the the combat the dice space combat which normally i kind of abhorred dice bass combat but you're dealing with probabilities here and
modifiers and it gives you so many tools in order to seek the results that you want that you can deal with it in a somewhat reliable fashion it keeps things exciting it looks great out the table it's an incredibly immersive and thematic game and the strategy is just it feels so good it's the best space opera game out there more on that in a bit and it's the best 4x game that i've ever played it feels so good what more can i say about eclipse and that brings me into my number one which if you thought eclipse was the best space opera game then maybe that qualifier gave you some indication i have talked so much on this channel about terraforming mars one of my favorite games in fact my favorite game in some instances of all time is fantastic and yes it hit five years old this year it is now growing a little bit long in the tooth when we compare it to the general discussion about board games online but nonetheless it holds up fantastically well it is so damn good it is an incredible engine builder the number of different strategies that you can lean into seeing the development of your economic empire on an entirely different planet all of the different asymmetric abilities from player to player and it has a great solo mode which is a different take changes the whole thing on its head and has you
reevaluating the value proposition of pretty much everything in the game it's easily one of the games i talk most about on this channel so without a doubt it is my number one favorite game that is at least five years old and that's our list i'd love to hear your list and when you were watching through all this did you notice something something missing from all this list for me talking so much about loving cooperative games there wasn't a single cooperative game on this list when actually in my favorite games cooperative games make up a pretty big chunk of that the games i have on my shelf the games i turn to the games that i play a lot there are some great iconic cooperative games that came out over five years ago but it really made me think about how the current trajectory of board games is evolving in order to be more accessible more accommodating and bring in more players and while i think there's always going to be a place for competitive games that's always going to be a huge drive a huge point of interest for so many gamers in our industry the advent of so many interesting exciting and different cooperative games has just brought in a whole new audience and given alternatives for an audience that already was immersed and i think that's great and i think that means that it's time to revisit and just kind of look at the greatest cooperative games
of all time so that's the list and that's going to do it for us as always thank you so much for watching i've been jack for the cardboard herald you