Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top 5 Games We Enjoy But Are Hesitant to Recommend

Transcript 47:44

hey I'm Ryan this is my brother Daniel and this is rolls and the family and today we are talking about games we love we really do like these games but we find that we are hesitant to recommend them to people and we'll see the different ways that we interpret that topic and what the reasons are that we might be hesitant to recommend these games that we clearly enjoy a lot um but maybe you'll through this decide it is the right yeah maybe we'll do a bad job of of of I mean we're going to explain why we're hesitant which might in some ways make it really clear if you are in the you know demographic that would be right for it in which case you should check out the links in the description below you know any purchases through those links do support the channel we we appreciate that oh my gosh um you know it's one of the few ways to to support the channel at this this juncture in time um besides you know liking the video subscribing tell all your friends telling all your friends oh my gosh think you think you sending out our our website of board game recommendations to people that might benefit from some guided guided board purchasing yeah okay I I I lied you can really support us in a lot of ways um but we also would love to hear in the comments below if there's as you listen to kind of our our entries here if there's a game that comes to mind for you that you really love but you find that it's hard to recommend it to other people MH um I'm very interested to jump into this one cuz I didn't give dingo a whole lot of Direction so I'm I'm interested to see uh interested to see where our our uh

results land here but let's have dingo kick it off uh there's no greater content than Daniel with no direction on this channel which is yeah there's been there's not been too many videos that you know it's getting to entry number four three and I'm going yeah Daniel didn't really uh view this the way I was you know what you're doing great D than you thank you yeah no I think I think I've got some good ones here so uh number five game that we both love but I find it's hard to recommend is a game that U we man we've had this one I actually don't currently own it uh it's in your collection but we have played this uh a long time have so many incredible memories of this game um but a game that maybe is uh dep dependent I think on a grp on the right group in order for it to to hit uh this is going to go to Cosmic Encounter so I was thinking about uh really when I think of like top board game like Memories Cosmic Encounter is up there I mean we played the heck out of Cosmic Encounter we really during a season of Life had you know this same group that just loved it and so I mean we we got all you know a bunch of the expansions you know it's a game where uh the variety of the aliens is just incredible and and it just you know the aliens are just wild they let you just break the game in an incredible way um but then even the you know just the game play of

uh you know uh playing cards going trying to get your colonies on other planets and the first one to get to five colonies on another planet uh wins the game so great game but I find a lot of the enjoyment of the game isn't actually the like mechanics of what's happening but a lot of what's happening between players at the table and and the inter action uh between players and I don't know I cuz I was actually thinking about Ryan when we first got this game we played it I think and and maybe the problem was we were only playing it like three player or whatnot but we I think it was the main problem it might have been the main problem but like we were playing it you know several times and it it felt like yeah you know this is good and I felt like we were you know more just kind of focused on on the mechanics of it but then when we got that group that just not only loved it but the interactions during games well it got to the point where everybody knew the game so well so everybody has an awareness of like everybody knows what artifacts could be in play and like and it just takes it to kind of another level in the types of interesting interactions you have when everybody like is pretty well versed in the systems and situations that can come up and understands kind of like the implications of allying and kind of the The Arc of the game and it just yeah definitely amps that's actually a great Point yeah the know knowled of what can be played what's in the game is is huge for the enjoyment so

I just think about you know recommending this game of someone I mean there still is a lot of variety even in just the the base box so that's not that's not the issue but I I think it's just one that you need not only maybe the same group to kind of play it over and over and really learn it cuz you maybe your first few plays it'll be fun but it may not blow you away I think the way it did for after playing it so many times so it just takes it it takes a while and and I you know I think you add that to also I think you just need a group that likes interacting with each other you know if everyone's just kind of sitting back kind of quietly and just playing their CS it would be very it would be very boring honestly mostes I know so I I think it's pretty group dependent um and so if you have a group that loves the above the table interaction um and is willing to play a game multiple times and kind of learn the ins and outs of it uh it can be great but that's what puts it at uh number five for one that I'm hesitant slightly hesitant to recommend nice my number five is one that uh you might find surprising Maybe not maybe it'll be on your list but um it's one that uh you know it didn't immediately pop to mind uh when I thought of this topic but the more I thought about about it even though I so recommend this game it's because it's like such a specific person like

situation I'd recommend it to there's just like a lot of conditions with that recommendation that kind of put that on this list and that is teu so teu I like want to recommend tiu to almost anybody that like really likes traditional card games or these types of things yeah but you start to think about okay tachu you need four people like exactly four that are going to want to play a card game that's got a little more going on for a traditional card game and you're going to have that group repeatedly because this isn't like a pull it out and play it once with a group type again this is like a put in a little investment and get a lifetime of enjoyment out of this type of game um and and we've seen this even when I'm there to teach new players I mean it usually takes a little while for them to start cck with them and even after a couple games I can still I'm like encouraging them like if you liked this you're only going to like it more the more you play like it really is one that just keeps rewarding your understanding of the game um and so that does just make it harder to recommend to a specific person because it's like well do you have all those things are you going to have four people that are going to play it a lot of times um because that's really the only way you're going to get the full potential a lot of T and that's what we've seen I mean I met over a hundred plays of T and if most of those plays were with people that knew the game and had played it quite a few

times um and so you know from my perspective it's like this is the best in class in the kind of more traditional card game type of thing I mean even outside of traditional card games this is a game that's landed in my top 20 games of all time for like the last decade um as a small little card game that's hardly different than a standard deck of cards um so yeah it's it's that weird balance between like I so want to recommend it but then find myself you know hesitant which I guess is why IED it I guess that's why I included it on this that's why it's on this video um no I actually Ryan that's a that's a really good one I have actually gotten to play tachu a couple times in in the last month oh my goodness so great I just love that game but you know the the first time it was with uh newer people to it and I agree the teach is not easy um you know especially if they don't have a background of trick taking games I mean then you're you're having to you know start at when I've taught it I usually do it in like I like I'll do a hand where we don't do any special cards and it's like okay this is like the core system and like no bombs or anything and then it's like okay here's the special cards here's the bombs here's calling tiu and like I mean there's just some layers thing and then the fact that it's partnership play and there's a lot of strategy in the partnership the fact that it isn't unlike some other there there's some

other games like uh president is a common like card game that's pretty similar to teach you and kind of a climbing get rid of your cards but tiu is very different in that like you can't just be thinking of getting rid of all your cards or you often times will'll get stuck yeah um and that's something that's hard to kind of like help a new player understand that it's like okay be think of how many things you think you could win a lead with CU if you we leave yourself with all cards that aren't winning leads you're going to have a pretty hard time yeah if you if someone you know is drop playing triples it may not be the smartest thing to drop triple Aces right trips or triple Kings because you you know singles it's yeah the strategy of it is so much deeper which I think but the same time you're like I know this other person is like counting on that winning them a trick and so there's times where it's like how much am I their hand if I kind of unexpectedly beat something um it's it's fascinating and we love it and there people probably watching this that would love it too but there's also ones that it like probably just wouldn't be the right pick it's good value too we talked about that in another great value very nice Ryan moving to my number four uh this is my only uh kind of the outlier on the list in that it is a uh more of a party game it is uh shorter so you know that's not that's not the reason it's not expensive none of that um but one that again this is you need the right group for this to

hit and I can just imagine groups where this does not go over well yeah this is going to go to the crypto yeah you know what I I didn't actually think about this one that much but this is a good pick yeah it's so you know in this game you're each in each in teams and you're trying to it's this back and forth of you've got these words four words in front of you one person on your team gets a code of you know three numbers and is writing Clues to try to get your team to guess the order of the words but the other team is hearing those Clues and overtime trying to intercept the code um and you know guess the code of of the other team with the right group and we've experienced this this game is phenomenal like and we we have kind of it's at this point like our de crypto Group which is our uh once a year with our family I know which we've got you know we're I think here in a here in April we're going to be all all back together so we got to get another game of De crypto in cuz man the just Back in Forth escalation of giving clues that are good for your team but are not obvious for the other team and then like I just love the pressure when a team is like on you they've you know got you pinned down on like they maybe feel like they know one of the things so how can you give a clue that throws someone off it is so fun but man if you this is what well and

actually I've had this happen if if you one just have someone who's not very good at this not very good at the the clue giving like maybe they just give something that's really obvious you know and it just gets inter you know you just you get intercepted Tak two intercepts or two Mis communic to lose the game yeah and so there's on that end you could just be super obvious and ends and the person who did that feels not great or on the other end you are trying so hard to throw them off that you just give a terrible clue for your team and they have no idea and and so it's a challenging game like it's it's it's a you know we talk about party games uh on kind of a you know a scale of uh just more like strategy laughter being the focus and and ones where it is more strategic and skill in the party game and this one definitely is closer uh closer to that so yeah a hard one to just say yeah go get to crypto because yeah man I you know it's you do need the the right group for it to right group and there's like this thing that needs to click in your brain about how the game works which is that you're not trying to like throw they can't see your words but they can see the previous Clues so I've seen times where people have done a clue that's like oh yeah that would be hard for them to connect to the real word but it fits closely

with the category of Clues we've already done with that word and it's like well they're going to be able to see that it goes in that category and that's really what you're trying to throw them off and it is so fun when you you think they think they're on to you and you do a clue that they're like yep that for sure is in here and then it's not and they're like how can it not like you know it goes in there but like the fact that your team you can be so much more like lenient with your Clues because you can see the words you don't have to be that close to a word to get your team to guess it you just need to be maybe a little closer to it than the other three words right um so yeah it's a fascinating one and it is one that is hard to and honestly not just hard to recommend it's hard for to pull it out like we say we don't play it that often I mean party games usually are the types of games you feel comfortable pulling out with a lot of different groups to crypto is a tricky one but it's it's a really good one it is my number four is hard to recommend I will say it's gotten easier to recommend as we've entered this era of like really high quality video tutorials online and the fact and that's what I would recommend this something i' be like get this game and then go watch like several different yeah like how to plays before you ever open the rule book but back in the days where you would have had to just buy this and learn it from the rule book I would have been even more hesitant to recommend Mage Knight and that's simply Mage Knight is a beast to learn from the rule book I mean I joke you know my my wife makes fun of me when that like you

know I'm sitting on the couch recreationally like reading these like really complex rule books and stuff and it's like is that fun and like Mage Knight's like a poster child for it with like four Columns of like eight point font down the not a lot of pictures come on and so it is one that like man I I can't re it's hard to recommend like knowing how that learning experience is going to be um and it certainly would get a lot better if you you know watch videos and stuff but there's still a lot going on with this game and so you just got to like know that the person you're recommending to is like going to put in the the effort to learn it on top of it already being you know is it a good game for them mhm um and so it it's a complex one and and that's a lot of that complexity is what we love about the game like the experience it delivers once you kind of know it uh is great um but I mean we've even experienced like after not playing it for a while I mean dang dangel now owns it and is too afraid to play it because he's never he's never had me always handled the rule book I'm scared to open it yeah I will play it it's it's a lot going on it's one of those games that it's like you you just accept the fact that at the end of the game it's like we probably got something wrong at some point 50% of the rules I am I am absolutely notorious for us finishing the final battle and then afterwards

remembering that we didn't the cities have like specific effects that you're supposed to add on to the monsters and we never remember it yeah and so it's like we spent 20 minutes figuring out the final battle celebrating and then like oh no which to clarify for people we always play this game cooperatively do that is our that's our preferred when we first got it we we which is another thing if I we first played it competitively and then once we play co-op we never went back no um it is another game that um if I was to recommend it I would be recommending it like purely as Co-op or solo like the the competitive is fine but it's just not there's other games I'd probably recommend for a it's too long I think for how it's too snowballing like to where you pretty much know who's ahead like with a game that long if it's Cooperative I can I'm invested in your turn like I I care you know I get excited when you're be some long terms somebody goes and fights a group of enemies they could be sitting there for 10 or more minutes just trying to figure out how they can solve this little puzzle and so when it's competitive you're just they're over there you know on the other side of the map doing something and you don't want to help them and so you're just sitting there and you're like okay I'm waiting for my turn yeah yeah it was a g huge game changer for us to play this one Co-op for sure very nice Ryan moving to my number three uh this is a game that I

owned it's one of my favorite games of all time don't currently own but will soon own a another version of this game um a little risky um but this is uh this is one that is such an amazing experience but could also be a disaster and you just have to be okay with that uh and this is going to go to Nemesis um this I still say is one of the best thematic board games I've played I've just I've NE like the way it makes you feel the honestly Terror of I'm in this you know ship with these terrifying aliens creeping the corridors and the noise and all that like they just did a phenomenal job with it and I I love it and I love the uh kind of semi Coop nature of it where it's it's not pure like good and bad but everyone has you know kind of these objectives and some objectives are maybe a little more focused on the team and others you know know potentially are you might you know want someone to die so um uh but this game can can absolutely just because of and and this is the case with a lot of games that have you know luck and stuff stuff like that um oh my gosh you could just get you could get absolutely just wiped out and and and that's that's hard to

swallow with a long game you know like and you kind of just have to be okay with it be and typically we are okay with that because we know what the game can deliver you know in it in in games like these um but I've had a game you I've had a game of this where it was like oh man we just got annihilated like totally destroyed and um and that's and I I like that that's possible because it again it feeds into the theme of the game of this is hard this is you know I'm not just walking out here big and mighty and rolling makes the stakes feel high like that tension is high cuz you know how quickly things could spiral exactly so it's like it's a feature of the game that I like but it's hard to just say go get nemesis because you know one it's a just it's a long game but but you could you know get a group together and have a not great experience um in it so that was ultimately yeah kind of why it why it landed on on the list for me um probably also you know you have to be okay with uh the the semi Co-op nature like someone's objective could be they want you not to survive so they might you know randomly shut a door on you and like I guess for this game to hit you

have to care I found you have to care less about winning the game like you still are trying to but more that what we're going into is a narrative exper a a story and we're here to just experience the story of what happens and I found like when I care less about I need to win the game and more about let's just like play this and see the and just we're able to laugh at the things and see kind of see it unfold like that so yeah and the game is designed such that if everybody is trying to win that's what delivers that Nar and that's what makes it like a good game is you get to be in this narrative and you get to try to win it's just that you can't hang all of your enjoyment on whether you had a fair chance in that you know or whatever because there's just so much else going on yeah um yeah this is one um I probably would have considered it more strongly for this list if I'd played it more than once um at this point but I totally agree with what you're saying and it's actually a good segue into my number three which is almost all the same reasons I consider this one as uh and this is eldrich horror yeah um and so this is a game again it's long it's got a lot going on so there's some of those reasons that I'd be hesitant but it's also a game that is very swingy in its experiences we've had games that are some of our highest board gaming moments ever we've had games that have pushed 4 hours and we're all kind of just like it'd be we

knew we lost this three hours ago but I know and and we stick with it cuz we've had games where we thought we lost it three hours ago and somehow you would never call a game early are you are you ever are you ever call a game early I don't think we' call it game early uh it helps that eldrich is a bit better about like keeping the game like back when we played Arkham hor that game could have like a gate burst oh you get a gate burst and you're like this we just added an hour like every gate burst one hour to the fly um so like you know it's going to get there eventually um but yeah it's so hard recommend when you know somebody who gets it they could have that as their first experience like a very just in fact I would say it's almost like more likely that they will because you don't have a group that like kind of has knows the game and like is going to have that element of it you're probably not going to have any expansions and so you're playing pretty vanilla ancient ones like with pretty vanilla Mysteries cuz some of the expansions even add new mysteries for the existing ones I actually am to the point where I don't usually play the aith one which is the very first one in the base set cuz I think they went too far in making it to vanilla that it's kind of like a little what is that one again he doesn't have like any special ability it's just if he wakes up you instantly lose like destroys the world and like game shorter oh yeah all the Mysteries are just like the most vanilla Mysteries it's like you

know pick up these Clues and this many Clues and spend them to like there's a lot of different ancient ones that have kind of some of these pretty standard ones um and the thing is I know that like a lot of people are going to get the game and they're going to play aith first because it's like the simplest one and it's kind of the first one and so you are kind of setting yourself up to you're really lowering the ceiling of like how good that game could be MH and so I just can picture people playing this game for the first time and coming away really really underwhelmed and feeling like it was way too long and way too lucky and and for some people they're going to be right that it's not for them for those reasons but I know there's probably people that like if they had the opportunity to play it more play with some better setups and with people that knew the game like it really could grow for them the way it grew for us um we also came into eldrich having already played Arkham Horror second edition over 50 times and so we already had such a strong you know group and experience with this big long epic game that that was no if anything we went into eldrich we're like this is so streamlined like nothing there's going to be no gate bursts to add an hour to the game look at this yeah so um it's one we obviously recommend like we have it very high in our personal ratings our review for it I would say was very glowing in our personal ratings but it it is a hard one to encourage somebody

to go out and get at least if you get it just get the Forsaken lore expansion right away and just just play those two cuz don't play and don't play aith as your first be my recommendation play with four people the box says what like one to eight like do not please for so help me if someone's trying to play I might try that this year let's see let's see if we get an eight player game of ELD be painful like yeah it would be awful yeah that's that's rough can you imagine someone's like look at this versatile game goes up to eight yeah I don't have a lot of games to go to eight this would be a good one to pick up Publishers you owe it to your players to be given an honest uh maybe that's what they'll do in the the new uh the new Agricola that they're revising go up to eight players he'll he'll take that hey I didn't believe in six and I am converted keep going yeah the trend suggests that it only keeps getting better very nice uh my number two has already been mentioned um I am terrified to play this game and yet it's one of my favorite board games of all time that's a weird statement to to say but this one is just yeah it is a incredible doozy of a board game and this goes to Mage KN you got to you got to take off the training I've been the training wheels for you Daniel it's time for ride the Mage Knight bike

on your own I'm scared I have over the year I Mage Knight it's been my I'm not sure if it's ever been my number one but for sure been my number two of all time um I've never played a game with as awesome of a just Arc and exploration and the upgrading like from the beginning to the end you just feel like a so powerful and and customized with the your your your abilities are a reflection of the journey that you've been on and and all of that so the game is Just aazing and I need to get it to the table but man like you said that rule book is just so dense and hard it's not an elegant design like there's a lot of little Rules and Things you have to remember and I've always relied on Ryan to just carry the carry all that and I'm just over here and I can ask questions time you know I uh you know you know what I should try Ryan they uh they I've I think it was the dice tower that talked about how you can use the new um Google's notebook LM uh AI thing yeah I should put the Mage KN rule book in there and and then I can at least like you know ask questions and see if that see if that helps I might try that out but uh yeah I mean it's it's like I just don't even know how you I mean recommending this

game it's you just have to worn up front and say are you ready to put in the hard hard work to learn this thing mhm if you are you're going to have one of the greatest board game that there are you know like we love this game oh my gosh I want to play this game again but man when you just have a barrier to entry like that um and then it's you know the game's already long but you're you're going to be throughout the game needing to check yeah back into a that's hard to figure out long you know you have to ask them like how often do you think you're going to play this 4H hour game because the bigger the Gap is between your plays the more this thing we're describing becomes a problem because you're not going to remember the rules I know oh gosh yeah it's it is such an amazing board game but yeah they could really use a a I don't know just better rule book or I mean it's not even I I we keep saying the rule book I don't even think it's that the rule book's that bad like a lot of it is just the design is complex and so there's a lot of rules to document in the rule book um but yeah it's uh it's a doozy maybe they could have done like a bet like a big like player you know sheet or something like do they or player guide or might have something like maybe they have something like that I don't know I haven't played it in a while but I do need to play it again cuz

man oh man it's a good game it's good stuff well we're going to stay on the train of basically the very similar reasons of why this game is my number two that I'm most hesitant to recommend um but I think this one even goes further than Mage Knight in difficulty to learn kind of complexity work you have to put up front and that's too many Bon you think it's more than Mage Knight I think so and honestly the thing that puts it over the edge is the fact that every gear lock is a whole rule book of itself to learn how to play and understand how it works um and again it's not a elegant design I mean we're talking a game that like I've played it what like seven times and I've still I have not yet experienced this dangerous darts mini game that there's like a whole page in the rule book dedicated to this you know so there's it's a game that leans into like oh what if you have this oneof thing happen and it's like this whole other mini game there's the whole lockpicking kind of mini game like they really threw the kitchen sink in this one um and we know that there's games we really enjoy that the fact that the kitchen sink is thrown in is part of what we really like about it is because it can give these really unique and varied experiences and I love too many bones but man it is is a good thing that there exists video big video tutorials

on how to play like each gear lock and stuff um there's still like 45 minutes of you like watching how to just play your character um you know and if you're playing with somebody else for the first time like there there and then you add in like the fact that the enemy abilities there's a whole glossery of keyword words you know that this person has lashback and this person has this and this and this and this and if the first time you play every single enemy you pull out is going to be followed by you searching the reference thing and being like okay that's what that thing does and that's what that thing does and if you don't play again for a year you're going to be doing the exact same thing over again so people who love and play too many bones a ton they get to the point where they know these keywords and they don't have to check the rule book but I you know have still needed you don't see all of them in every game and you know remember ex I remember that was like something like this like oh flight I remember they like go away and they come back but like I'm not confident enough to like do it without referencing exactly how it works again um so yeah this is a pretty I think even more than Mage KN it's one that like I would hope that you're playing it more frequently so you don't just like forget all the stuff um cuz it then you're just it's yeah I mean even with how frequently I've been playing it yeah you got to experience that right like that was my experience of it of like I I mean we we had played it once and then it was I don't know was it a

year later close to it yeah basic that I played it again and it was yeah it was so hard because it was like I gosh I can tell I'm like would love this game but oh my goodness I have no idea what's going on in terms of like look like I can't look at the board or the the you know the grid and know what I should be thinking because there's all these keywords that I have no idea what they are and you know and you're explaining them and stuff so it improved over time but man that is a that's a big barrier it is a big barrier so it's not the right game for a lot of people but there's a lot of people that this is like their favorite game of all time it's it's definitely I enjoy a lot so um just know what you're getting yourself what you're getting yourself into very nice rhyme well we're going to move to my number one game that I do truly love but is quite hard to recommend you know I uh you know talk with people about our uh love for playing board games and talk about you know some of our favorite games and sometimes they'll ask you know oh how long is are is that game and you know a lot of games you know hour two hours maybe if it's a you know if if you're getting to like 3 hours I mean that's a that's a long game that's that's that you're spending a lot of time that's a that's on the long side of things and then I tell them about this game that is 8 hours long and uh this is going to go to

Twilight's Imperium fourth edition uh I love this game this was at one point my number one board game of all time um it is unlike any experience that I've you know had in a board game it you know in some ways combines you know we talked about with Cosmic the kind of above the table um diplomacy interaction with each other this game has that in Spades um I love the exploring the the you know the how the game isn't just run out and fight but it's you know it's all objective the objectives are and getting victory points are what are driving you I think that's the game the game is fantastic but I just don't know how I can say go get this when especially to buy it like to be the person cuz it's one thing to be like oh if you get the opportunity to play this like you should try it for sure yeah I would much ra go go find a group that you know has this and and you know get in on that but man it's expensive you know this is a massive game it is in the most hard the most difficult game to get to the table I mean you you really if you're going to play this game you I mean there's ways you can play with less but you really want six people like that's the ideal that's the ideal like if you're if you're going to already set aside a full day you might as well try to get the full player count so you need a lot of people this is a game you need to prep

before the like it's not even just the8 hours of the game you're sending people things uh ahead of time of uh you know to like first you send them the I forget who's the is it Shay is that his name he did the RTM incredible how to play video a great video to learn but you must send them that and you tell the I I remember sending this in the group text you cannot show up unless you have watched this video like this is because otherwise you're adding at least another hour to the game if not more with the teach so you need everyone to already come in with an understanding a base understanding of it um so there's just so much that had the conditions to be right for this game yeah it's it's so difficult this is why it's one of the hardest games to get to the table but if the conditions are right Ryan yeah it is phenomenal it is just it again in some ways you know it's unlike any other because I'm not it's not even just like a you're sitting down to play a board game it is it's an event it's a it's an all day experience that you get to share with these other people that leaves you with stories and memories that uh you'll never forget and so you know I I think on top of that also you know you need people that like you know negotiating diplomacy are

okay with combat you know being ATT like there's just there's a lot of things that's like you got to be okay you got to be okay with the time you got to be okay with the this you got to be okay with that there's a lot of things like that but man if you can check all those boxes I highly recommend Twilight that you go click that link down below yeah for Twilight emperium fourth edition a wonderful game that rarely gets played I especially for me yeah no kidding um I considered this one it did not make my list um probably partly cuz I my uh it's not quite as high for me in my own personal joyment as you I do like it a lot yeah um I also haven't played in a long time so maybe I'm just like forgetting you are um but it makes a lot of sense it makes a lot sense uh my number one has actually been mentioned by you oh and I went back I knew this one was going to be on the list it was one of the first ones I thought of but the more I thought of it the more it Rose to the top and this is Cosmic encoun oh my gosh you're number one okay and which is a little weird cuz at Cosmic Encounter in recent years has actually like gone down for me in my own personal rankings but like I don't blame the game too much for that just because it's like okay I've played it like almost 200 times and like had so many highs it's a lot to ask of this game for me to you know yeah um but I just more

and more have realized over the years how easy it is for this game to fall flat even with players that are more experienced and like I have taught this to people in the last 5 years and had it just like not land quite the way you wanted and again that's with me feeling like I did a really good job of like teaching and like giving the spirit of the game and like having multiple people in the game that have played it before and so I'm just picturing somebody buying this game and playing it cold with like a new group I just feels like the odds of it falling flat are like too high like it's just like hard to and you know like it's a terrible feeling to recommend a game to somebody and have them be like really underwhelmed by it yeah um which is kind of a theme on this list is like we don't want to set people up for failure with like there safer safer games um and honestly Cosmic is one that probably Falls more into a tribe before you buy ideally but even that's hard because are you trying it in the right condition to really tell yourself if it's a game that you're going to enjoy so what what type of group should consider almost it's kind of a Gamers party game is kind of how I think about it okay because the game is very wild very above the table

in what you're happening you know a lot of the enjoyment of it is just like seeing these weird situations that you've never seen before of like oh my gosh like because of this alien power and this alien power and like that flare what we know about what's in this person's hand and like you get in these situations that while the game is very Rand like there's a lot of Randomness and honestly like does the most skilled player win every time not necessarily somebody's going to squeeze out at the end but you do get to make a lot of interesting decisions like you get to be in this bizarre strategic landscape and try to figure out how can I position myself and I love a lot of these decisions the decisions of like how do I work with this hand or like this hand is garbage I don't want anybody to know my hand is garbage like so there's a little bit of like bluffing but I also got to be like what is my path to getting to a hand that's not garbage do I need to just like let somebody get onto my Planet so I can just throw my hand at them as compensation so I can get rid of cards um there's so many interesting decisions in this game that the right group that learns it and knows the game is going to just lo I mean there's certain groups that this will be their favorite game of all time um and we you know we've talked about how our highs that we've had with this game with that particular group like really were high like I mean it really was like very memorable that if you like it your group

is just going to want to play it over and over and over again yeah it's infinitely replayable with just all the different alien combinations um but yeah the the just the chances of it falling flat really is what it boils down for me and how those chances go up if you're a new group if you you know like it just makes it and it's so different from other games I mean the game came out originally in like 1977 um almost every aspect of the game is like okay that's the fact that you don't get to pick who you attack like it's Destiny and then there's like this allying and like the way the card play works and then the like the base system is all very unique and then you're on top of that throwing these crazy powers that are doing Wild Things um which is part of what makes me want to recommend it to people cuz I'm like this is a fascinating this is unlike anything you've played before but then there's the voice in the back of my head there or remembering some of these sessions I've had of it and just being like ah there's just too high of a chance that's going to be their experience with it yeah um and so yeah it's an interesting one it's it's one I don't get to the table as much anymore I I have this conflict between wanting to introduce it to people and also being like well only makes sense to introduce it to them if I'm going to like play it play it a lot multiple times with them get enough shots on gold that they see

the highs you know cuz once you see the potential of the game you're much more we talked about this with ELD you're much more forgiving of the lows but a lot of people you know they play a game once or twice and like that's the opinion on it which is fair there's a lot of games to play and you don't want to be spending tons of time if you don't think you think you like something yeah this one's tricky cuz in some ways you know you think about it we got this earlier on in our board gaming uh Journey which is kind of the perfect time to get it when you don't have a lot of games because if you love it man you can just keep playing it over and over again you know we're in a season now where we're not playing the same game over and over and over we play so in some ways you like almost want to recommend it to someone maybe like that but then also it's like it's such a gamble you know I mean you have to ask them you be like okay this is a game that you ideally want five people maybe four maybe six I guess you need the expansion to go to six but but like ideally five people and you want to are you going to play this game it's not a super long game I we're talking like 45 minutes to an hour usually um but are you going to play this game you know at least five times within like a the first few months of getting it are you going to you know play this with a consistent group a certain number of times in a year and if you know about yourself that that's not

how you usually operate with games like maybe someone who gets a lot of games and you're only playing these new games a few times you know and there's big gaps between playing it then like I do not recommend cosic encounter like I don't think it's the right choice um but we both have the memories and like those memories like I know that other groups could have that experience and I have to recommend that right like like it's like for the right group this could be the best recommendation I could possibly give to them that's my problem about even considering owning it for myself is I almost feel like I'm chasing these like high memories that I'm almost like can I can I even hit that again or was that just the perfect condition I feel like you would need like a new group that's the right group and you get to like almost like start this new chapter of like with that group um and I I honestly like I mean it's one of those games I'm like never going to get rid of um because it's so unique I have so many memories with it and like even though it doesn't get played a lot um you know there's nothing competing with itg really and it's very nostalgic um but yeah it it is uh I guess in my opinion the game that I am most hesitant to recommend despite you know how many highs I've had with it hey thanks for watching even though these are games we

are hesitant to recommend they might be the perfect game for you and if you think that might be the case we've got links down below uh you can check them out down there and it's also a way to support the channel which we appreciate we have more videos tons of more videos and there's a couple right here we'll see you in the next one

Progress saved