Tier Ranking our Entire Board Game Collection | 580+ Games Ranked
Transcript
little bean little bean little bean hello everyone welcome back to Foster the meele a Channel all about board games and ranking those board games 583 of them to be exact we are here today to tier rank our entire board game collection it's not our entire collection well it's the games that we've played now for anybody that doesn't know what tier ranking is I don't really know what it is either to be honest with you but it's like giving your games a grade like a letter grade it's not it's it's a system of ranking I think that might have started in like video games and S tier is like top tier tier A B C D I think exactly so uh basically we're going to be putting all of our games into one of those ranks s being like ultimate like this game will never leave our collection it does something really special like we feel lots of good feelings about it a is a great game like super amazing B really good game c game good game okay it's fine it's it's a game it's fine it's a fine game d
is like it's a game yeah let's keep in mind we don't like the slag off games we don't and we do like the majority of most games true exactly high percentage of games so our D in this instance is still like good objectively good right we aren't going to have any FS because generally speaking like if a game is really bad we usually don't keep it yeah and we haven't really encountered that many games like that but this is just a good exercise for Jeff and I because as you know we have so many games and it might kind of be one of those things where it's like you know we're running out of shelf space we might look at the games in the D tier and be like do these need a new home or do they need to go to a different section of the house because we keep games for many reasons but one of them is for future planning of things stuff and things to be exact um anyways we're going to be doing this collectively and if we disagree yeah on something we have to come to some sort of agreement between the two of us that is going to happen probably a lot because Jeff and I have we're different people we like different things so anyways there are she just mentioned this doesn't include any games we've only played the Prototype version of you have to have played a full production copy of the game exactly uh and I've also clumped together some things like
all of Disney villainesses together however I did separate Marvel Star Wars Disney yeah like all of final girl is together all of Simo those types of things unded all of undaunted and no expansions okay and we have to an unmatched yes and we have to own the game currently so there's a lot of games we played that aren't on this list this is our collection of games that we've played um let's do it are you ready okay so I have taken I've taken all of the cover images from BGG so that we can do this live this needs to be Snappy 580 so going we ain't deep diving no don't need to know what the games are about but the first one is actually going to be an interesting one and that is yak which is cute kids game it's a yeah that's the thing with Yak for me also it's it's very much a familywe kids game yes I could see a family pulling this out and having a ton of fun playing it with their kids yeah but for us where would we put this I'm between C and D I'm also between C and D leaning D I would lean D so Yak is GNA go to D okay I was like is it not going to let me pick up these are going to get so like if everybody can just look this is what we have to get through so Yak has gone to D it's it's a cute
game but it is one that's been sitting on the shelf that I'm like I don't know if we need to own this it's got its place in a certain collection and ours probably isn't that collection probably uh worms span so for me I really like worms span I'm sitting this around an a I also have it an A okay cool so worm span look at us go Jeff we're just crushing it worm holes from AEG so I also want to caveat like some of these will just say like we haven't played all of these games at optimal player counts so we might rank them lower than what they probably we would with optimal it's our ranks man yeah it's our ranks it's all subjective nothing matters our ranks wormholes I have wormholes at a c I was thinking C too I thought it was really fun and I would like to play it again I would also like to play it again it's been a while but I remember like oh I really like this and then not enough to I love pickup and deliver um but that's one I think I need to try again yeah because it just yeah just it was okay yeah next thing uh Rec Raiders only I have played jackon play so there's some in here that I've played and some only you have so I'm going to put Rec Raiders at a b um I think it's really fun I've only played the solo version and I really want to play the two-player version because I think that would Jack it up word traveler how are we feeling about word traveler I have word traveler at a d only because it's very kid game I think the mechanism and system of the game is really smart yeah like having to deduce
and figure that word play out but it's just too light for me I'm just wondering we've only played it at two players I think this game would shine at a higher player I would put it at a c I will I will I will seed you to a c okay I'd like to play it more players wonderlands War that's s tier that's an S tier okay pH I was like wonderlands war is an S tier no not a doubt in my mind yeah um next one we have Wonder Tales which is a button shy game you've played this once I is that the carrot no no it's the one with the Wonder uh the fairy tale characters and you have to it's like a grid and if the little pig goes here then it you know can move this one and one player plays blue and red yes I remember so I like this game solo I would put it at a B I would put it at a b as well Jeff you and me same page uh Wonder Woods which is a little mushroom game from blue orange that we've only played once I don't remember it and you don't remember it I remember that we were both like oh this is good but it would be better more so I probably stick it at a c yep okay go with that um winter which is a two-player only kind of mean card tile placement game super simple um I think it's a c for me yep that's where I had it perfect look at us are we ever going to disagree wizards of grimoire H another
one we've only played it once and I enjoyed it and I feel like if I played it more I'd like it more I think I have it at a B yeah I think I do B with the potential of that being an aame yeah I've seen more people play it and I'm like this looks really good you can play it on BGA wingspan wingspan's an a game for me I I know that some of the like these these bigger boys are where we're going to probably disagree on again I'm fine if you want to put wingspan at S I get it I'm fine with it I've played so much Wings ban I just think at this point I prefer W worms ban so I have a hard time putting it above worms span I know it's spicy but I think and it's not because I think it's only a product of I've played so much wingspan and worm span was different and I was like okay now I like worms span more I think I'm comfortable to put it at what I mean though yeah I'll put it at an a yeah okay next up is wild Tales which only I have played it's a button shy solo only Legacy game which I would put at a B it's very clever I really liked it uh Wild Style real time spray paint game it's a c game for me it's a c game for you I I can I would have put it at a B but I I'll go see it's like we don't love Real Time games but that one we had a lot of fun with but to Fair we we don't pull it out no so um wildt West I think it's a yeah On The Fringe
of s oh I put it at an a I love that game you do yeah I I'm fine with it sitting at an a for now okay we'll do a ask me again next year it's so good though Wicked and wise I'm going D yeah I'm also going D um we only played it at two players which is definitely not how you should play it that is like you need least four for that game to be good and we didn't enjoy it too Western Legends I have Western Legends at a B okay i' i' put it at a c but I could go B okay um it is a good G oopsies little snake trying to sneak into the a wavelength d d i put it at an F if there was an F Nick and Mike had it on their top 100 I'm not going to tell anybody where it is cuz you got to go watch it for yourself I understand some people absolutely adore wavelength and I get it it's just I don't I do not enjoy it I see its place but just it's got its place it's just not I think wavelength would be really good at a office party office party I agree yeah or like your family party or whatever Wayfair is of the South Tigress I'm going a yeah a a all day whirling witchcraft I like whirling Rich I'm probably a B on that one I think I would be a B on that one too a good game it's tough sometimes with those ones cuz like you're only playing it during Halloween really War of the ringer I haven't played it so Jeff gets to just put that wherever he wants yeah H then we have Watergate
which we're playing right now in BGA I have that at an a I think so too Watergate it's a really good two-player game well tug of war yeah wacky racist okay first time I played it I have an at an a last time we played it like I think it's like a b or a c game yeah I really like the minis I really like that built a game in that world yeah Hannah Barbara or whatever because there's not a lot of them I think it's a BC somewhere I think it depends on how many players but based on our last play I would do a c yeah I'm I'm with that which sucks we really liked it that first time but uh next up is walkie-talkie which I know we're both putting at a d no of the small boox Dee games that is by far our least favorite one it's just not our style of party game votes for women's an a yep votes for women is definitely a if you haven't played it you should Vivid memories see yeah this game was fine like I think it's there's a place for it viticulture I'm obviously at least an a for vulture a for me not an S I don't think it's an S we we would play it way more if it was an S I do play it a lot on BGA Village rails you haven't played but I have I have played vill you played aisle of trains um I would put vill drills at a B it's very good right uh theano tough we only played it at two everybody plays at more says It's amazing I I just think based we can only
base it on our experiences and I think I would have it at like a b a b okay I was going to say C I'm fine with C okay I want to play this with way more people though yeah villagers we've played I also have that at a sea I would too I like Moon more same okay veiled fate we're gonna differ uh I have veiled fate at an a I would put it at a B I think you would have it at an a if you played with the same group I played it with I I would agree so all can see just uh for context I played veiled fate with our good friends over at table knots and it was an absolute riot and I think Jamie was there if Jamie was there and had that experience she would probably have it a or S it's like a hidden like deduction Style game so you can't play any more people hi roll kind of deal verdant that's your favorite of the thing yeah I really do like burdent um it's an A or a B I'm I'm leaning B I'll go B I really like it but it's not I'm gonna that's your fav but it's not my favorite I don't think it is my favorite I think Calico is still my favorite yeah Calico is amazing vagrant song which we just started replaying the campaign it's tough cuz with a campaign game we're only like a couple of scenarios in I have it's between a I think it's a B I think it's a b yeah that could change once we continue on with the campaign I agree vast Crystal cabin S no competition unmatched I do think unmatch is s tier do you I think it is
too I mean there are the whole system the whole system there are I'm dying there are sets that we would prefer if you hear Chom Chom Chom Juno's Juno's CH Chomp her nails I don't know if anybody knew that huskys trim their own Nails great time to do it Juno unicorn fever I I will say my piece after you say yours because I don't want to influence you because you have a different opinion of this game than I I I'm actually sitting at a c I was going to say C or B I was going to let you have either or yeah it's a c game for it's a c i just it's a game that I want to love so much more than I do also once again C is still are good games just have undaunted s s for me yeah it's an S undaunted it's amazing vampire Village I think it's a c for me I think it's a c for me too I think it's a good little game for I need to season but I would not be pulling that out any other time of year ugly Griffin in for me is it's an a you haven't played it Tessy musy well Buton shy I do like Tessy musy uh it's a B for me I think so we haven't played it in a while uh unlock we've only played one M of the unlock I think it's a I think it's a b it was fun cuz it uses like digital yeah yeah veggies which is a small box I do like veggies I love veggies I think veggies is a b or an a for me I'll let you determine that
I'm leaning B yeah I think but if you want to put it in a i' I think it's fair at a B if I think about other small box card games trick shot trick shots an a for me trick shots an a trick shot's so unique so it's so good and it's hockey and we're in Canada turning machine I might have to I'm a B on turing machine and I know you're an a I knew you were an a um you you can have the a because I I know it's objectively a popular game it's a really good my brain just struggles Transmissions uh I think Transmissions is a c I don't think it's a d only because again it falls in a similar realm for me as word traveler that's fair it's it definitely has it has it place as a really good intro game for kids yeah and it's got really cute minis so cute I just wish that it was a bit more robust yeah it's just it's a very simple Rundell game yeah track 12 I very much like it's a i it's an a um however that being said we've never played a phys this game is onga and honestly I think that might be one yeah we play that on BJ twisty tracks a game that I want it to love I think it's a c for me a c I was going to say d but I'm fine with it being in D if you want to put it in I once again twisty tracks it's a game that would be amazing if you
have kids yep it's just really simple yeah I think you're going to find a trend here of games that are in our D category that are yeah maybe just too light where we are as Gamers yeah turbo and we don't have kids so we don't have kids turbo drift's A D for me turbo drift's A D for you I'll concede because I know how much you don't like turbo drift but it would be a c for me it's a little card button shy racing game Tribes of the wind tribes of the wind was really good solid be for me solid B I did very much like it I love the theme too I think if you want to put her in an a I wouldn't no I think I need to play it again we only played it once yep too many bones s tier yeah it's a steer for me dragon and tiger dragoner dragon and tiger um it's I think that's floating in a b it's a good b game for me I thought you were gonna go a it's it's up there it's not quite an a I give it a B+ yeah B plus but that's not an option so we'll go B it's an oink game but it's bigger box oink tiners Trail I don't like it you have it at D I'm assuming but to be fair we only played it on BGA and I didn't know what I was doing I have I have it at a B so let's throw it in C all right C it is we need to play that wolves it's a b game for me it's a B for you I was going to say C I'm fine with C I think wolves it's so beautiful it plays the
theme plays really well for the area control piece like your wolves trying to take over territory Walking Dead the dice games that's sitting at an a for me a for me too actually yeah it's so good I just love that it's so silly H Thunder Road Vendetta I'm an a I'm an a for that it's not s tier no I don't think so although who knows with the new expansion true tranquility tranquility is an a for me me too I love that game Tranquility the better crew T I've Loved T of course it's trick taking I loved T I did too I'm an A on T2 T2 is like a lifestyle game yeah Royal limited solo only button shy game one of my favorites that's an a turns and taxis I very much that's a that's an a game for me I'll I'll let you have it because I honestly I don't remember Ticket to Ride H Ticket to Ride h i play a lot of ticket it's one of those it's see now here's the thing Ticket to Ride family game rather I play I'm constantly in a game on BG I'd rather play like I know we're talking about all tick to ride it's just hard because like I really like the two-player one uh Poland is that the two-player one no am I making that up or Europe maybe I don't remember I don't remember which one I do like the two player specific Maps I think ticket to Rod's an a man I think it is considering how much we play it we play it all the time still like it's a classic uh the reckoners I think reckoners is a B for
me I would agree we got to play it again though yeah uh three sisters Three Sisters is a c for me just because my brain does not it's an a for me take it or do we want to just go B I think you can I I get why it's an a though I like I think I think if we're going to do this and it's going to like one of us is going to pull like the other person has to have I don't have a reason it's just not for you it's just not my type of game but it's my type of game Trailblazers I do B for Trailblazers yeah I'm a c but you can give it a be okay uh I haven't played it solo yet and I think that could even raise it for me uh quest for El Dorado very much like quest for El Dorado it's been a hot minute it's been a very I would say it's a solid b game yeah I think I think a lot of people would disagree and put it higher but yeah road to Canterbury is an a game that's an a game for me too yeah I like nobody talks about this game and it's super weird I feel like a little bit of weird tiny towns that's a solid b game I think so tiny towns has so much necess Nostalgia attached the mole we really like we really like the mole it depends on who you're playing with yeah I would say that's a b that's a b tier game we really do like it uh Maiden in the forest solo only button shy that I would give a b the night cage we like this one I very much like night cage I think it's probably a b a b yeah
I'd give it a B plus mhm uh Town 66 I'm a B on Town 66 I'm a B plus so I'll go B I wish that there was B pluses the loop the loop is good but it's very hard I'm tired but I'm another it's I'm another bee on yeah I think we're gonna have a lot of bees yeah bees are still good the perfect wave this is a good game I liked it even though we played it completely incorrectly the first time the first time do be like I'm a b or c on that one I'm fine with either I'm leaning C I think I'm meaning sea because the waves are in the sea prodal club prodical club is a we if we played it again I think I think it can make its way to the S tier I agree I think it's it's hovering at s s has to be like these are special games you know Tides uh I'm actually putting that at a c solo button chugging I think it's fine aisle of cats I'm at an a you're probably way lower I have Isa cats at C I think so we could do B yeah that one I'd fight you on because I just think there's so many better tile placement games I think that one is a Nostalgia factor for me uh blood of an Englishman I think that's a c game yeah it's good it's good well two-player like asymmetric card game
yeah I love the theme mhm uh fall of the Mountain King here's the thing I like it but we only played it at two and I think this game will be it's area control it better at four I think it's probably a c yeah just based off of what we played I'd like to play a higher player count that's pretty clever I think it's a B I know You' probably have it at an A but I love that game but okay I just like I've gotten the 300 score yeah so now we don't play it as much once you hit that the crew d d people are going to freak about that dud if you like the crew try Tranquility I'm just saying yeah I'm just saying uh the initiative that's an a for sure that game is great Fox experiment I think is an a for me I have it at B I'll give you the a okay fox experiment's really good uh The Godfather I have Godfather then a I would have it at a B but willing to I gave you fox experiment so you give me Father you can have uh Haunted Mansion call of the spirits I actually like that game I do to I put it at a B I think it's a b yeah of all those Disney games I was just about say that one all Disney games what's that really hard one it's it's not Disney though never mind oh the three sisters one oh Hocus Pocus yeah is that dis disy oh I really like that one the grizzled I think that's a B for now I would have put it an A but I'll
give you B cuz we we've only played it once we only played it once yeah but I do think that's a game that we would love any parks it's tough I have it at a d or a c I have it at a d although I'm fine with it at a d we need to play it again because I know this game is better than the experience that we had the first time I don't know man I think um terra cotta Army I liked terra cotta Army um I just don't think I'll ever want to set up Terracotta Army again I'd put it at a c i put it at a c also okay tapestry a tapestry is floating at s tier for me um but I would say a is good yeah o do you think for S tier we both need to consider I think it has to be strong considerations for both of us to put it at s tier yeah the hunger I like the hunger I do too but I would put it as a strong be I think it's a strong be as well okay uh tanr city which you haven't played yet but I have I'm going a I think you're really going to like it um taco cat go cheese pizza it's a d right I don't know it's fun but like when are we pulling out there's a very very specific group that we would play that with and have an amazing time yeah I think it's a c for me okay I'll go just because like yeah it is silly fun I think tap's an a I think tap's an a yep I'm fine with taple at an a it's almost an S for me honestly tatuo I really like Tatu it's trick Tak um Tatu
is probably I'm just I need to be careful ranking trick taking games because like probably we got a lot anytime you pull a trick taking game I'm immediately like oh it's an a yeah let's put Tatsu at a B yeah God that doesn't feel good takenoko takenoko would have been an a for me in the past but I think it's probably a b now I think it's a I'm fine with it as a b okay I do love it I'm excited for whatever the new one is at the adventures of Robin Hood which is campaign game that we actually finished which means it must be an a I'm B+ on it I think I am too um I think I do wonder if we had played it more players we really liked it though I think it's a b okay I'm okay with that how about that SN ha that's an a game that's an aame so group dependent but yes so group dependent tainted Grail that's all me eh that's all you e see you would ask me this a year ago go I would say it's an A D would put it as it's an a I have to give it credit for what it is it's just it's a lot but it's an a experience I haven't played it taals from the loop it's a solid B solid B very it's like a campaign we've only played like one that show's so good scenario if you haven't watched a TV show watch it targy I didn't love targy unpopular opinions I know I know everyone loves
targi but it just did not fly with me I think I'm GNA it might be a d on it I put it at a c okay yeah Sunrise Lane simple I don't think we'll ever play it again simple Breezy Riner kitzia game uh got to have them I think it's a c or a d but not because it's not good like I enjoyed playing it but it's just so simple yeah keeping in mind we have no FS except for the crew that' probably go in f um d yeah I think so I just think like it was pretty we had a good time while we played it we'll never Play It Again agreed because there's so many Riner kitti games but see that's one that's a good one to have in the collection I would not get rid of that game just for if you had people that didn't play games come over yep super skill pinball a for me ramp it up a for me too honestly that's our favorite rolling right yeah I think right I think so uh sweet and spicy I did like sweet and spicy I think it's a yeah sunny day sardines it's a c it's it's just like a simple little set collection I Like It Strike is strike a game strikes an a yeah uh stranger things the upside down it's a b game for me just because it's so freaking hard it's so hard stockpile stockpile is an a for me me too stifling dark see I I don't love it compared to other hidden movement games I think it's
a b or a c I think I put it a c y I'm fine with that I like it but yeah if you're comparing it to all the other hidden movement games which you can't help not not yeah steam steam is an A G steam is an a for sure love trains love them Stellar two-player only little card I like Stellar I was really bad at it I think it's probably a B for me B yeah I'm comfortable with B startups I thought it was fine um see I would say c yeah I don't I don't love the the board game barrage crew loves startups yeah they love the stock exchange type game though they do and they love negotiation and all that stuff uh stardy Valley that's s yeah I knew it Jeff I freaking knew look at that look at that little collection up there you love to see it stew I like stew really like stew a I think it's probably an A or a B yeah it's a great little button shy villainous C some of these are going to be villainous is an a for me I see I was leaning s oh I could do s I just didn't think that you would I mean it's fundamental to what we do it is you know it is like it is like if we're putting s games at like games that mean something to us like villain means something to us yeah and this isn't the these things I don't view this the same as like ranking my games from one to whatever this is like I'm not
thinking about sitting down and playing villainess I'm like what has vainness done invoked felt you know yeah s um yeah I think I have it at an S too nice uh Star Wars unlimited that's an a with the possibility being an S yeah we really Star Wars unlimited Disney lurana I think I also have lorana at an a I do too um but for different reasons yeah I think that Star Wars unlimited is A+ yeah and lurana is an a teetering B+ I think that's fair a minus because we love the cards and stuff but the the mechanisms in Star Wars unlimited are Star Wars is a deck building game very good yeah I'd say a yeah we love board games Marvel villainous however I'm doing a d yeah I have it at a d as well uh Star Wars Imperial assault not insult I would say a mhm Star Wars villainous uh that's s because it's my favorite vill in this version okay unless you disagree I do but it's fine I just think if I'm going to put Disney villainess up Star Wars is villain Star Wars villainous is my favorite version and Disney is my favorite version and obviously Marvel villainess is nobody's favorite version uh Star Wars rebellion an ass tier mhm uh Star Trek ascendancy Star Trek
ascendancy would be an a for me if I could play it with the right group but I've only played it solo Jamie has not played it so I'm going to put it at a B okay that's fair Stock Exchange I like Stock Exchange really it's a good game I think it's a solid b game for me me too Star Realms I don't really care which is weird because it's somewhat similar to Star Wars unlimited but I just every time I've played it I'm like this is fine I feel like it's one of those foundational games that we we were already Beyond it at the point that we played it yeah I think it's a c for me yeah I would agree definitely has its place uh squabbling goblins that's an a I think for me I you know how much I love that game spots we're gonna be different on this one a spots is a d for me oh shoot I I'm fighting on this one okay can we do B no oh come on really don't like spots I really love this game so H here's what we're going to have to do yeah I'm giving you this okay but you owe me one where you yeah completely disagree cuz I I'm just saying I completely disagree on this okay so I'm just writing out spots so I'll put it at a B you put it where you want but you owe me one no I'll put it at a b no no no no no you got to put it where you want to put it I want to put it at me I feel like I'm alone there sparkle kitty like sparkle kitty but it's probably a c or a d oh I put it a d yeah it's fine I
think it's just like a simple silly game Splinter duel I've played it on BGA big on Splender I don't think Splender is that great of a game I know we doing C hot hot take I think it's think it's not a d I think it's good better than a d okay split here's the thing I don't remember this game I know we played it and I looked at pictures and I was like oh right but I don't I remember it being in of me and I think that means it's probably a c yeah I remember having fun but I the fact that I can't remember um space Empire space Empires 4X is an a game for me YY dookie we're only on the s's holy shoot uh song birds I played solo very cute I'll give it a b spaceship I've only played solo I would give it a c uh okay this is space Park remember the key master I like it yeah I like I like it see see I like it I like it so back two players SOC when I first was playing it was like it uh floating around an a yeah I've played it so much now that I've started to see some of the problems with it um I don't play it anymore I think it's probably a c game I would do Sil Clover at an a Sil Clover's an a it could also be an S it's up there for me should we it might be my favorite party game it's what we always pull out all
right we're doing it it's our list space base love a little Spas bass I think it's a it's a solid b game yeah I I like it a lot it's just it does what it does now I think like this was one of our games that like I freaking loved uh smok in mirrors I'm doing a c you didn't get to play it skulls of sedlic I like skulls of sedlick it's an a for me yeah I'm fine with that I like it all right uh sleeping Gods it's a tough one sleeping Gods is probably an aame but for us but right now it's not because we need to play it yeah so and it's not ideal at two players we've played uh my issue with sleeping Gods is like the world is beautiful the stories are incredible but the management is just yeah we only played at two I would do a B for right now I would be it yeah I would also put a b i' be it I kind of want to just make my own host rules for that game yeah and just be like all right we're not going to like manage 13 characters between the two of us no unless we can play with Kyle and Tiffany at some point at four that might be better uh Sky tear horde that's an a for me that's an a for you I have that's an uh solo game I I very much enjoy that uh tower defense game snow Tales one of my biggest appointments yeah it was a bit we played it at two also not ideal I would stick
it at a c for right now I think it's a c it was unique I liked how you had to like kind of like like drift around the turns and stuff the silicone Vania I would do a solid B I think it's a b yeah I agree I really like that game ship rights of the North Sea redex very much enjoyed that a for that I think I'm fine with an a yep smile I'd probably do a b yep in there too so good skate summer I very much like skate summer it's an A or a B I'm leaning B oh I'm leaning a okay I'm fine with that uh Sky Team Jeff hasn't played but that is definitely an a skyrise skyrise is an a I would agree Skull King SK King is s tier okay I just need to say I played it at Canada plays and I'm not going to name names but two people that I was with that I were friends with don't like it it's so fun you just got to get into it skullking top tier trick taking game shards of infinity was good when we played it Juno do you have to be chomping nails so loud um I'm see on it yeah simolo I love Simo Simo is a b yeah sheepy times an a for me I do yeah I I agree I'm fine with sheepy time sheepy time underrated H set of watch I would put at an
a haven't played it Septima I'd do a b yep shelfie stacker it this is tough because we got my shelfie and shelfy stacker around the same time and my shelfy is better yeah I think shelfy stacker is probably a b yeah Silver Bullet Silver bullet's an a silver bullet's an a uh and I'm think all the silvers but silver bullets the best one C's of strife that's a good little trick taking game is all right I think it's I think it's a c a c okay I could do that uh shores of Tripes an a a for sure yeah look at this uh shipwreck Arana I would do a b or c I think it's B uh shades of ink I loved wait that's no that's not the one I'm thinking of shades of income doing a c it's a solo only RPG game and I'm just not super into RPGs Seaside a yeah seaside's so good it's so good it's not out yet but when it comes out don't sleep on it it's very very good it's incredible search for lost Spees that's an a haven't played it could be an S someday secret santa yeah it's a d it's a d it's an F if I'm being honest do you remember yes what was the point of that I don't know put around teacups uh Seno battle for Japan I probably do a b I'm fine with B yep I very much like it but I think it's
fair Santa's workshop's an A A for me too we love that one uh okay so this is going to be interesting we have side rise of fen yeah are you separating that from I've separated them because I think that they're going to be ranked different rise rise of Fenris is s tier for me yeah that's what I thought um just since we're already here let's just do side yeah yeah rise of Fenris might be the best campaign game we've ever played I I would be up there sagani is an A A yeah Siege storm I like Siege storm I do too I think it's C though I do too yeah a SE Sal and you think it's s i I'm I'm with you if you want to throw an S I want to do an S sea salt and paper's an S I don't know that there's a card game we play more yeah I just it's so good uh salt and C were going to be different I think I think if I played it again I'd have it at an A but right now I'm at a B I'm comfortable with B savac forest for me is a solid B I think it's a B for me too Scot Scot's an a for me sc's an a see sea salt and paper before that came along mhm scull could have been an S yep more Rove it's all you it's all you buttercup really all right do your thing no because there's
one that's definitely going s root S what are you even asking I would put an A but that's Jeff wins uh Sheriff of notingham we just haven't played in so long I think it's good think is good a b game it's a b game it's all right sure we haven't played in Forever uh Sr is a bee for us I think yeah I like sarata not one I'm ever gonna River Wild a see for me you haven't played it role player I think is an a that's an a yeah yeah I just think that role player is the classic me too uh rurick ru's an a for me it's very good rolling Realms I like rolling Realms rolling Realms is a be for me we just bought a bunch of new sheets for it mhm Romy Romy I do like it I love Romy Romy but I think it's a B I think it's a I think it's a B+ yeah Roar and right was good I think it's a c I think it's a c yeah riversides probably a B I think it's a B for me too yep now these ones Rhino hero Rhino heroes are A's both of them we have Rhino hero and Super Battle you want to have a good time yeah see this is the other thing like oh this is kind of a kids game sure but Rhino have you played Rhino hero it's freaking amazing uh Red Rising I have red I really do
like Red Rising it's a B+ for me same I'm doing a b because fantasy Realms is I'm Not Gon to say anything but raron is s for you it is s for me but I could I I'll go s I think that's fine because there's going to be some that are s for me I think reeside a c yeah I know a lot of people like reeside but rise I did like rise rise bumping tracks I think we haven't Revisited it redwood's a sea for me yeah I know a lot of people like how uh different it is different it is and like unique but too much management really Roco is an a yeah I'm fine with that Roco uh this is red cathedral which I love there's so many people that are like I'm I'm probably an A on red I I am too I always have a good time always Rift Force I like Rift Force I'd say it's a c though I would put it at a c raising robots is an a I think if we played it more that could be an S I'm getting hungry just so everybody knows H return to Dark Tower it's an a for me I'll give it to you it would be a B for me I want to sit and play it together mhm Quicky pyy Jeff did not like that game that's a d for me I I would put it a C I'm fine with you giving it a c okay uh rtis R is an a for me rice is great um Robin of Loxley we wanted it to
be yeah we wanted it to be better than it was I think yeah revolver nor is s tier s I'm fine with it being an S tier game I thought for sure like listen I just again I want to be careful with what we put up in us but I just think like if we're both agreeing that quick then I'm think like revolver Noir hidden movement you play in your hands there's nothing like you don't have to convince me that nothing it Raptor raptor is a great I I think it's an a game for me I think it is too yeah um rage more solo button shy I'll do B because it's freaking impossible to win Ready Set bet it's a b game for me I think so it's really fun very group dependent very group dependent project L that's another bat game for me I've introduced that to some people know I fun it about project l M all the hype remember everyone's like I can't get it I can't get it I can't get it nobody talks about it I think you say that about a lot of games though what up with that project is really good it is very good yeah we don't reach for it anymore uh quacks this is we're GNA be very different I love quacks I'm an a for quacks quack is probably a c game for me okay I owe you one though if you want to owe me too I'll fight you on this one because that's no I'm saying I owe you do you want to use your no I'm not using for quacks do you want to do B you want to put quacks at a I'll go B all right if you put it at B then you won't owe me because I know that this next one's going to be a fight Quantum Quantum is an a game for me it's a c for me but
I'll give you the a okay we're even okay we're even Jamie okay uh psychic Pizza deliverers go to the ghost town a game it's an a it's teetering on an S for me I'm just going to say it out loud because this game is unlike anything it's so good and don't let the silly long name fool you ra is an a yeah raw ra um koal kali's an a for me Kali is an a for me too we just got the Mini version I'm very excited priorities is a fun party I do like priorities um it's a probably a high B I think yeah I would put a B plus plus I think uh it's one of those party games that I don't think is group dependent no I think anybody can have fun playing that game uh power plants is probably a B for me yep I agree potion class that was a button shy we played I'd put it at a c we were both kind I'll defer to you because you know those better than I do Point salad might be a be for me yep you good with that yep Planet unknown Planet unknowns after Wild Child West came out it's slipped I know you have it as an A and I'm fine with you putting as an a cuz it is very good I it's also so good solo uh pitch car what a silly little I like pitch car it's kind of dumb but I think it's a b
yeah uh photograph or wind the film is definitely an a patchwork I've grown I that's why play so much Patchwork now Patchwork is an a yeah pass pass I like pass pass it's a b it's a b new game go check it out uh Parks is an a for me I'm fine with that I like Parks parks and I'll tell you why though like this game came out whenever it came out and I'm still playing this game all the time y so good I do like perks parade Parade's an a with the right group yeah if I have somebody to do to help me uh papon Gardens it's probably it's like a stamp and right it's very unique but I think I'd put it at a c yep I'm fine with that okay uh paper app dungeon you haven't played I'm doing B paint the Roses I'm B on pain the Roses I would be an a I'm fine with that okay um we have overboss and overboss duel I have overboss duel higher than overboss okay just because there's more more going on more attacking each other mhm um I will defer overboss to you I love overboss um I could do overboss duel in a I I honestly was sinking both of them at a okay good because that's where I would put them I love over boss everybody knows that um that's like a Nostalgia thing I
think ouch that's it's a solid C game it's a solid c oros d for me I'll give that one to you I actually liked oros but I know you really didn't I really didn't oron God is that s nah a it's not you haven't made it to S quite yet oron uh Oracle of delphy is an a yeah strong a strong a strong uh Oni Rim I would probably give a b oh my brain I it's an a we love this that's an a game uh yeah oceans um oceans is an a for me me I don't know how you I have it at a B I'll give you the a okay I think I have it at an a because the solo mode is very good M obsessions s tier okayed so many games e oath sworn I have Oath sworn at an A but I think it deserves to be in B right now I would agree we've only played three stas Oak I did not like Oak you did not I'm trying to put it in C I have a c yeah okay uh numers yeah it's funny when I say I didn't like it that's it's not I'd play it again yeah npers is my S tier button shy I figured that game is so good uh Nan Nish n and Nish TIG is my
favorite trick taking game uh I think it probably belongs in s for me S mhm okay if I get one trick taking game that's put in s it's not ltic what about skulling but that's yeah I guess that's true all right fine put it in there no if you want it no you're right you're right you're right you're right it's just those two games are so different yeah I know they're both trick taking but what about n c nil C is a good a game I would agree I love no thanks um okay then we have nalia which I think is a soft solid C+ B it's a b game for me it's a b okay all right we have uh Nightmare Before Christmas marry Madness we also have food fight we also have Dion alley I think they're all in here those are all d games they're all d games they're fun they're super fun but they're just silly MH uh night of the Ninja it's an a game for me I think for me too night of the Ninja is great yeah uh next station London is I think it's a B for me yeah I'll put it at B plus New York Su is an a for me it's the best uve there is New Salem that D for me it was a d disappointment but you have to play up more players yeah that's the problem
Nima hex is that's a B for me yeah uh neotopia is probably a B for I like that game yeah I'd say b b plus yeah that the category doesn't exist Nemesis lockdown the more I play Nemesis the more I dislike it same um I would say right now it's a c for me I would agree listen if you like Nemesis yeah good for you I get it but uh neropolis is your favorite button shy isn't it no squin goblins I me no I'm doing a for neopolis all I'm combining all of the opalis is Nana pretend that says Nana not Trio okay uh Nana is an S tier yeah just pretend this says Nana and not Trio okay myth wind yeah was disappointed in that game we were very disappointed but I think this is a game that you need to play like as a solo Quest yeah I honestly I think I have that at like a d I was going to say C okay it's fine I know a lot of people really like it Mythic Mischief yeah okay it's a B for me but I'll put it at an a for you I'm really bad at it um mysterium Park had to have it at a SE I would put it at a B I'll give you the B C+ uh my celium a mushling game I
really like that really like that game I would have it at an A or a B hm I think like if I'm looking at a does it belong in a probably not we'll put it at a B+ it's very good little root building my Celia is also a yeah little kidsy but it's cute my shelfie might be an a for me I would have it at B no you're right it's good it's very I'll give it a a uh my little everell I like that a lot me too but I think it's a b same game uh murder of crows was just a fine Halloween kind of party game I would probably stick it at a d though yeah I'm fine with that you haven't played this one Mr cabbage head's Garden that's an a it's super weird moving pictures see sure mountains out of mole Hills I probably do a C I'm fine with c y it's super unique and I really enjoy it but it's not something we reach for Mosaic a story of civilization would be higher if it didn't have all just based on the setup yeah it's a great game though Moon Moon's a b b it's awesome for what it does though monsters on board I'd probably do a b yep fine with that uh monikers now monikers for me is s tier but for you it's
not it might be though I just did I can plays again I always give Max and them a hard time because they love monikers but I also do love monikers how many do we have left oh My Sweet Lord we got to start picking it up mumii is a d for me do you remember it's just like yeah so forgettable modern art the card game a yeah yep um mission control I really like it me too b b okay I'd do a but I'll put it in B B+ um marrying of Mary King that's an a for me I'll give it to you I would have said B uh mind Management in a for sure Millie fi Millie fur is an a for me I think it is for me too the first time we played it I was like oh this is good and then we played it again like no this is like really good MH uh micro macro Crime City I love that game same it's an A A yeah yeah I really want to play that again me too uh this is that Mickey and Minnie's Food Fight that's going in a d merchants of the dark Road I know a lot of people didn't like that game I actually did we did I have I have that A or B I think I want to put it in a b because we're about to replay it and I think that that is going to new expansions coming merchants of newer we liked b b um Merchants Cove I'll defer to you on that one this one of my favorite games
yeah you like it more than I do I'll do a I don't think it's quite an S for me just based on the setup and taked down uh memor 44 is an a for me yeah me as well I love chucking them dice it's very random butand I like chucking them dice medium medium is you like medium a lot yeah uh Meadow is a B for me yep I'm fine with that Maui is probably a c for me yeah maskman I want to like that game I just can't wrap my brain around it doesn't get it I put it at a B okay I'm fine with that uh Mech versus minions that game might be S tier by the time we're done but right now it's an a we just started it it's definitely an a yeah uh Marvel remix it's a B sure I put it at a c um Marvel Champions that's you I'm not I'm not even getting involved
oops I dropped it in s tier I was wondering if you were gonna uh maps of myera I liked it I think it's a b game for me it'd be a c game for me if you want to put it in C put it in C manes of Madness I think I'm an A on it not s okay I think that's fair based on like I don't know like Nostalgia alone would make me put it into an S but I think that's fair Maple Valley is an a for me yeah I'm fine with that my freaking I'm also fine if you want to put Mansions madis an S because like there is a lot of history and story there oops I dropped it an S um make the difference it's fine it's fine I think it's c for me yeah I would agree lucky numbers B for me I'll allow it even though it' probably be an a for me uh Lord of the Rings Journeys in Middle Earth I put it an A but again it's another one we need to play more it's probably s tier by the end it Marvel United is probably a c I think it's a c for me too LS are an X and A for me I've played it a lot more recently and I'm super into it so I agree okay uh confrontations in s yeah for me especially I don't know if you would I I would put it an S there's something very special about that game lose caboo Loose Caboose honestly is a b game I think so too I just love yelling Loose Caboose taboos
London I'm between an A and A B me too I'm leaning a okay I'm fine with it London's a great game uh long shot the dice game is a beef for me for me yeah it sound like you said beef beef for me lock up b b llal land B mandala Stones is a b b uh life of the Amazon is a honestly so good it's so good please try it uh Leaf that's such a cute little game it's probably a c though um Land versus C is a b okay you you're going a no I was between B and C I think it's B okay I think if you played it again you would agree it's a b uh Kaku I have played I really like it but I'll put it in a c pbon
I guess I'll leave it that in a even though I really love it but Jeff didn't even put it in his top 10 heavy games kire do is an an a for sure um we did not like K Sugi D yeah yeah that was a button shy game uh King Domino's an a it's got to be like it could I could make a case for an S tier for that one but uh libertalia TNS of Gil Crest is probably a b or an A I was leaning a I very much like liell I will go I think like I can't I don't know if I like the original better but anyways um kapow uh good game c I was going to go D but I'll do c no it's a good game uh kitchen Rush probably a c floating around for me real real Time games just ones in a yeah Real Time games just aren't for us you know what I mean Jelly Bean uh King Domino Origins I I I think I prefer it now like yeah all the extra stuff interesting so we'll do it in a yeah an a Jurassic Parts c c this is one when I was like putting all the cover photos in I was like yeah I could probably part with that game mhm we don't play it uh king of 12 I really like king of 12 are you doing b or a I I think B is the fair
thing but I think it's probably an a game we got to play it more knockdown a d yeah uh it's a small world is a d it's a d but I will never get rid of it I'm keeping all and jungle cruise is a d but we're keeping the Disney ride games Nar that's an a probably a yeah I love that game great game yeah Jamaica I I still love Jamaica would you b or or a I think it's a B I think so yeah it's a great little racing game horrified um I did both of them I probably didn't need to I no there's no point you got to do them all the same so well I'll have to put them both up but they're an a they're an A okay I wasn't sure if you would go a yeah no they're good I'm just going to put the other one I don't love them like you do but they love hor rived um okay Jackal versus Hyde I very much like that it's an a game for me it's an a for you yeah can't allow it um horos I really like horos you did I would say it's beat oh I was like i' I've dropped it I've dropped it somewhere there we go uh inveno Mort inveno morte I was like did you do that on purpose I put it at a B Sure very group dependent Isle of Sky I like aisle of Sky um I think it's a b though okay yeah I would put it at a B yeah I feel like I want to like it more than I do Fair uh honey Buzz honey Buzz is probably an a for me but yeah I agree
I like honey Buzz a lot business bees holotype I think it was good I it's uh we only played the Prototype should not be in there got to remove it I don't know how okay we'll just leave it at the bottom oops uh inkling I like inkling I think it's a c though did I play it though I watched you guys play it I don't think you played it I C em might Tap The Duel I didn't like it I thought it was very fine C sure Innovation I've cool on Innovation so hard I you have do you want to do I think it's a B for me right now we'll do B objectively great game kfire Council or kfire Chronicles is yeah I would put it at a B we're just not into the campaigns you know not right now anyway inside jobs an a for me a game yeah um hidden leaders is probably a B for me I think it's a B for me as well breaking uh hulao I don't even know what that is we played it in the uh at packs in the hotel room it was that like random card game that I got where you need way more players you didn't like it yes d f I'll put it a d but I think it'd be better with more people uh hi season so this is the Grand Asher Roland right I I like it but I want the actual game I'll do B
yeah uh inheritors I very much like that but I think it's a B I think it's a b because we haven't played it enough we should play it again Hickory Dickory is a B for me yep I'm fine with that a very adorable B+ yeah um hemony that's an a it's an A and it's going to be an S it'll it'll be an S someday yeah uh Hocus Pocus we LED that's an a game for me I really like it it's really hard else seems to like it but so hard it's really hard uh uh hey that's my fish I like hey that's my fish it's a solid be game for me I think so um hookie hookie s tier for me do it it's so not s tier for you though no what would you rate it after my last play yeah cuz I feel like I started to get it a little bit more I'd probably have it at like a B+ but hookie is one of the greatest games that was ever created I'm so glad you found that randomly if anybody you didn't bu ever I know if anybody ever wants to play hookie with me I will never say no that'd be a really good uh actually no you wouldn't be able to do it on PJ no uh Holly Jolly was cute cute little card game um Hugh is probably a c uh Happy City c c I think I like it though Great Western Trail a it's a c that's the one you're giving me then okay fine that game's absolutely
incredible that's what you get for hookie mhm hero Quest I really like hero Quest it's probably a yeah you if you had the the people you needed to play it yep that's a lifestyle game holler tows and a yep agreed um what about Hanabi hanab is fun probably a c yeah I'm fine with that Gods love dinosaurs we love it uh next up is going to be Halls of hegra Jeff where Halls of hegra is an a is an A A yeah uh solo game solo game harmonies is an a a God that was good it's so good I played again at Canada plays I gota play the solo game ghosts of Christmas honestly how complicated that game was even though it's not I'm I think it's a c game part it took so long to figure out how to play that game I made me feel like it was so much more confusing than it needed to be just the verbiage Heat's an a game he an a for me as well uh glass Road glass road is you played it on BGA it's proba yeah it's been a while since I played BGA though complic complicated it more than it really is classic gasha that's fine I put it at a c Grand Austria is an S yeah I think it's an S Grand AER is an S this game is a great game this game is a great uh oh great
game um okay uh herbaceous this is where we differ big time you didn't like it I liked it you can take it I'll do a b um genopis I just played this again yeah um it's a b game for me I think it's a b game goris Maximus see Uno's here seemed like it was going to be awesome I know at gravwell I very much like gravwell I think it's a high B I think it's a high b as well it you need lots of players Gap I really like Gap is might be an a game I think gap's an a game it's a quick simple card game you got to try it and it's beautiful for a little card game good poppers is probably a Beery for me I'm whatever you want there I'll do see gargoyles uh unfortunately probably a c I think so but also a game I did enjoy great little intro for like Skirmish Skirmish Terin stuff Galaxy trucker it's a c for me I'll be fine with that F it'd be a B for me nice little tile placement Fuji flash we s we s tier in it I'm just saying all those people that are like playing Fuji F like this is boring play it with us boring they the best you ever crazy nonsense fun fair I liked you were met i' do a c yeah I like it though um hagga care I liked it even
though I wasn't feeling well only taught it would you do be or C I think it's a c I think it's a c as well it's kind of like a trick-taking game uh Gaia project I'm a be on Gaia right now I'll allow it I haven't played it in so long I've played it a few times on BGA and I just I can't do good at it get on board I like get on board B yeah I agree Glenmore 2 Chronicles that's probably a b right now with the potential to be an a I feel like our first play we were very like oh no no no no I think you're getting that confused you are you're remembering it wrong remembering it wrong uh Game of Thrones board game yes the S tier game the possibly the OG game for us DSE d d I was going to fight you on that one you con seeed gear Works uh I did like gearworks I haven't played it um I think it's probably a b yeah I haven't played it and Jeff told me there's a lot of math involved yeah Jamie would not like that game uh there is a lot of math fun facts I think fun facts is a b game a b yeah FTW I liked it I do too B yeah little fredman card game furnace furnace is a b game for me okay I've just seen it break to many people's brains yeah it's painful to watch ghost stories is an a for me I'm fine with that yo is everybody still here we lost you
yet Friday Friday gonna give you a solid a oop um Freelancers Freelancers is an Freelancers is an a for me it's an a for me too I would put forgotten Waters above Freelancers but I think they're both A's I think they're both A's um oops Free Ride B I liked it yeah I think B is fine be fox in the forest B be that used to be like MH go back way back on our Channel yeah and you can watch us play fox in the forest while we eat uh Bernie Bots every flavored beans you get super grossed out fossiles I think was our least favorite the it's good for kids like picking the things up yeah too much dexterity uh for big thingies over here for I don't have big fingers I have long fingers let's get it straight they're bigger than mine I do I have very large hands I have very large hands for a girl uh fort's an a for me I yeah I'm fine with that I like Fort and then uh forgotten Waters is an A A yeah we love Crossroads games uh then we have forever home which I've been playing a lot on BGA and it's quite good but I put it at a B I think yeah whatever you want to do there whatever uh Forest sky was little button shy Bird game probably a oh I remember yeah yeah
for sale I think I put an a it's a B for me I'll go B then uh fool I do like fool it's a be though yeah put it right next oh never mind uh food chain Islands in a where are we are we in A's um fog of love it's probably a d for me I think it might be for me too I think that we could probably part with that game yeah I agree it's just not for us we're not into role playing uh this floor plan game Jeff didn't play but it's a d flip ships a for sure I thought going to say s maybe s it's teetering yeah we love a good flicking game flick of Faith that's an a for you too yeah okay good Fleet the dice game is probably a c for me sure yeah I'm fine with that you too yeah uh flam Rouge you really like it I know it's an a game for you is it a B for you it's a B for me I'll give you the a though gracias I love flame flam rou not just because I get to say that flamecraft it's a B for me I would agree there's a lot of people that are quite surprised that it's not like one of my favorite games but it's it's it's very simple it's beautiful holy smokes it's don't get me wrong because I quite love it fit to print fit to print's an a for me but I don't know what it is for you it's a B for me I'll give you the
a because I think I I always reason this like more people would probably lean your way than my way with that game right fishing lessons is a be you haven't played it uh Fisheries of GL gloss that I think it's a B for now it's a B I don't know how to say it people will correct me and that's okay uh oh fire and stone Siege of VI I would really like to play that game again I would too I think it's a B for now B for now but it's probably an aame uh fine sand yeah it's a c game a c game Yeah final girls s tier disclose I work for Van Rider games but it influences me 0% when it comes to find even though you're going to say it does if you know you know yeah oh my God there's so many people don't be Dingus this Fe I like f it's probably a c yeah yeah feather light C it's just trying to be fantasy Realms uh fearsome floors that's an a game for that's an a game it's a real weird one it's so freaking fun fast loss of s tier yeah fast L is s tier yeah this is I like I just find lisser so funny um far away so good have you played it yet no oh it's an a we have to play it I think it would break your brain but I really do it's very good fantasy Realms it's probably an a I don't think it's S I don't think so either but my heart wants it to be but
it's not it's just not familiar Tales is probably like B at this point yep um fake artists I think it's an a for me I think so it's great little party game uh exploring Galapagos is a d we played it you didn't like it Expeditions is a for me yeah I liked Expeditions but we've never returned to it no because we have size ex libris is probably a B+ I think it's a B for me as well um everything ever is a d for us yeah unfortunate everdell I I don't know if I can rank that one right now I'm happy to put it at like a b I'm fine with it at a B so context uh we haven't liked everdale for a long time yeah you do I I always liked it yeah we played it very early on in the hobby when we were in The Hobby and we haven't ever returned to it but then we played my little everell and I had a really good time with it I just smash my I had a really good time with it um so we want to return to everdell and we just got a copy mhm uh so I think it's probably a b or an a for argument sake yep uh espan is an a do you think yeah I I would agree we need to play it more but those war games
are always going to be up there uh endless winter this is a big difference I would put it at a B I have it at a C I'm comfortable with the c just based on setup and tear down alone empires of the north z a yeah it's got to be it's freaking got to be um eminent domain might be a d for me yeah I would agree it was a Disappointment Island something shiny I'm going to do a B plus uh Earth We're different I would game for me and I would do a but I'll no you take the a okay because again more people would agree with you than me uh dwellings elderil uh b b yeah we have to Play It Again Play it again yeah it's been too long dwarves winter is probably a sea for me I yeah win winter is the one I think I liked more yeah and then I put fall at a d I think they get better every time um dungeons Dice and danger I really like that game really like that game that might be an a that's an a that's an a i' like to play play that again uh Dolce or do DOL I don't know I liked it more than you did yeah I find wherever you want to put that one I think I do a c I think it's a good game dubious that's a c for me see the problem is we play dubious and then we played Phantom Inc right after yeah Phantom in Phantom Inc was better Dr
poter whatever you want to put that freaking game at I want to put it at a B Jeff hates it um oh Dreadful Meadows is probably an a for me yeah I'm good with that um and then we have dragon Prince battle charged it's a b it's a b it's it's a straightforward easy simple Skirmish game if you like the IP you probably like a more drafo is probably an a yeah yeah God I play that so much yep um what about Dracula versus van you've not played it oh I'm doing uh I'm going to put it at a B we do own it so downtown Farmers Market I think it's a B I think it's a B plus so good um downforce is uh now with heat I think it's a b yeah I love downforce but I think you're right uh dorf romantic is it' be an a for me but probably a B for you and I think I'm comfortable with that because we haven't played enough of it doodle Dash that's an a game for me doodle Dash so fun chaos um um don't get got really group dependent yeah honestly just with how group dependent is it's probably a c for me dominant species s glad we agree Jeffrey yeah um Jesus and you're including the other one in that yes dog park see you think okay that's not the
one in New York right because I like that one more no dog park was the treats one mhm h no I'd say it's a B I would give it like C plus b um dog lover I don't think you've played I would give that one a c distant Suns we really liked it B yeah um Sorcerers Arena I think it's a B for me I think so too I think we'd like it if we played it more Disney dick it I did like Disney dick it freaking loved it are we doing B I think it's a b y um Disney villains the card game also loved weo be yeah we do be uh okay here's all the dinosaur roen rri world and Island I think raren right is like the the the version I want to play the most of just because of what it is I think in terms of experience world is the best but it's the setup that bugs me I think here's I'm just going to throw it out go ahead roren right and world are A's yeah islands a B I think I agree and you're probably like why do you have all three and I I say it I've said it once I'll say it again mind your business I love dinosaurs and I can't give them up Dinosaur Island we probably could get rid of at this point because we'll never play that game again but I just love the way it looks dinogenics it's just I like more than
you it's not as fun looking it isn't uh I have it at a B I'm assuming you have it at a I'll do B I was thinking B die of the Dead I really like it probably a b or c i do be diced veggies I really like diced veggies it's an A or a B for me I think it's an a for me yeah I'll give you the a it's such a simple fun little game dice town oh are you doing s i could I won't but I could we'll do a yeah but that is teetering on that's A++ um dice Throne s s transparency I was gonna say disclaimer I now work for dice Throne yeah we I mean if you watched the channel you've seen our tournaments for years uh dice minor is an a high a high a teetering s yeah um Destinies is a d for me no that's not fair I would say it's probably a B for me so throw it in C okay okay I just I lost really badly so deep dive is probably a c for me I really like it but it's just like a cute little D crypto is probably a c for me yeah it's very confusing um decorum in true thematic sense of decorum I'm probably a B on it I'd be comfortable putting it in a b okay I
like it way more than Jeff does uh deception murder in Hong Kong's an a for sure fax she's um Death Valley Jeff hasn't played I'll put it at a c deadly dowagers that's an a that's I put it an a I think we're gonna play it again next weekend so um dead reckoning an a if we had played it more but it's probably sitting at a B yeah it's just a beast you know yep uh dead of winter a long night a lean night it's probably similar it's probably a b yeah um Dale of merchants that's a d for me I just didn't I really wanted to like it C quarts an a cur quarts an a easy a it's a movie um cuphead's probably an a for me me too I love cuphead it's I it's our favorite Real Time game like not even close um we're so close Jeff folk you've never played I'm putting it at a b birds is a b yeah CU Birds is a b although I don't fully understand still how to play Kuba is an S Cuba's s for sure I'm going to have a smoothie when we're done okay just so everybody knows uh cthulu is an it's probably an a for you yeah it's probably a low a I'll give it to you I think i' put it at a very high B yeah Cry Havoc is a d for me I have it a c I'll give it to
you uh this is Pretend This is Critters at War land land and SE uh b b Creature Comforts it's an a game for me it's an a game yeah I like it uh cover your assets it's fine I think it's c c oh yeah I'm fine with d if you want to put in DF coup C is a Nostalgia but I probably do c I think it's c y c is another game I'm not getting rid of yeah it's so easy to introduce to people cosm octopus I'mma see your a d on that okay I'll do see I liked it more than Jeff Cosmic frog I've never played a possibly s tier col Express is an a for sure yeah I like I like Colts Express uh then we have Coffee Rush probably a be yeah I love it Coden names do it Coden names are both these for me um I've don't think I've ever shied away from this I do not like code names I never have it's just not my thing so hate on me all you want I've played it so much so don't be like you need to play it more it's just not my thing I like it more but I'll allow the D's uh clearing coffins Jeff hasn't played it's a solid C Clank clanks a a b yeah claim two-player only trick- taking
game see okay Circle the wagon you remember that one mhm I do be yeah I'm fine with that okay uh Chomp Jeff hasn't played so we're going up to be a great little dino game Chicken push your luck be I did like chicken yeah it's B Challengers The more I've played Challengers the more I like challengers challengers might be an a game I think it is Challengers don't sleep on that one it's on BGA if you want to try it but you need a lot of people to play it to make it be fun I actually prefer it on BGA I think I do too kis 1303 easa game easa uh we have Cathedral world that's an S tier s yeah I'm fine with that I was going to say Cathedral world is just it's it's like a chess like puzzle game it's so good yeah um catacombs was one of my biggest disappointments I think it's a d unfortunately uh cat in a box I don't think we like it as much as everybody else but I'd give it a B I think it's a b yeah I liked it I liked it too but like everyone like loved it castles of burgundy is s tier for me I agree just just in terms of how much I've played it and so good um we have Castle party that's a strong AB game for me I'll put it in a I love it I really like Castle party castle party super fun Cascadia a yeah cartographers probably a b right
now but I think if we played it more it' be an a I would agree with that are we in B uh Cartagena I liked it you need to play it with more people I think it's a c right now yeah Carnival of monsters again another game we used to love a lot I would say it's probably a c right now though oh heartbreaking I would put at a B uh Captain flip I really like Captain flip have you played it yet only with you that once um Captain Flip's probably a b right now but I think it's probably going to become one of yours that's like a kid game super fun Cape May I would say a c it was it was simple easy it reminded me very much of Sunrise Lane yes but better than Sunrise Lane agreed uh canvas I like canvas it's Unique I think it's B yeah um stop okay you want s I'm fine with s okay yeah we do play that a lot I will never ever ever ever ever forget sitting and playing that with my mom never and we'll never get rid of it yeah campy creatures is great I love campy creatures it's probably an eight game for me yeah yeah um camel up the card game c c camel up s s yep G up it just is what it is uh Call to Adventure I think Call to Adventure is probably a strong B I would agree we haven't played epic Origins yet
Cal calico's an a yeah calico's an a um burn cycle burn Cycle's a d it's a d unfortunately I'm glad that you agree bunny K I just played this again twice and I really liked it yeah um I would put it at a B for me yeah I think if you played it more I think you would like it m it could go up uh bullet heart bullet heart's an a for me it's very good I will give that that's also a real time real time yeah mhm uh this one's you broken and beautiful you play I did not like it uh D it is H Brian Bor is in a yeah agreed people disagree with us but I think primarily Nick but he's wrong on a lot of Stu bre B Bru and a Bru and a with the right people people also disagree with us about that but Brew bab is great uh brass Burmingham brass is still an a still an a um bottom the nin's and a a yeah easy we got some bangers right here we do top letters top of the list boss Monster original boss Monster not super boss monster I think it's a b yeah for Nostalgia alone yeah uh Boop boops o s no I'm fine with a were you going to do s I was close I do you know how you want to no you know how much Boop I play a lot a lot
uh I have both of the boomerangs but we only need to do Australia as an a yeah uh but if we were to do the other one uh Europe I would put it at a B blood rage is an a for me it's a c for me definitely you owe me for something I'm sure all right that checks out um Bonsai I think might be a d for me really or C I think it might be a c I don't think it's a d i I'm fine with c d is aggressive I just like remember I'm like this is this is good cuz your bond Dr tree was yeah I probably because I lost uh Bonanza yeah see yeah don't come at us Blood on the clock tower I okay I always crap on Max Blood on the clock tower I do like blood on the clock tower but we just don't have anyone to play that game with so I think it's put it in B for potential I think it would sit at a c for me uh Blitz cre I really liked and I really wish you could try Caesar me too I'm fine wherever you want to put that b blazon is a d for me d blank slate C I'm fine with that blackon is an a Jeff's never played it a solo hidden movement game are you kidding me crazy uh between two castles and mad king lug Wick where you want it b i it's a d for
me c so we'll put it C buried treasure that's a b game for me yeah a b is fair it's fun I love pie beast beast is an a game for me but I know it's not for you so it would be more like I'm fine if you want to put it in b b okay yeah uh I almost said business bees Bears and the bees I actually like Bears and the bees I think it's probably a b yeah thematically uh by you bash uh probably a c same uh Battle of Westeros probably a B I would agree actually it was my least favorite of it's my least favorite of them as well I would say c yeah it's it was a little bit more comp batt battle L is a b and then the other one I think an a yeah um they're all the same system battle Crest is a d yeah we did not like that uh baseball highlights 2045 it's an a for me I'm fine with it being an A okay you got it better the last I did I understood better last time uh then we have barrage never played uh I I don't know I have a love hate relationship barrage I think it's probably a low B low beep uh then we have Bark Avenue I really liked Bark Avenue I put it at like a B plus I it's a B+ for me too B plus um Bargain Basement bisphere is a c
haven't played it Barcelona I did like Barcelona probably a c for me though banish the snakes banish the snakes is an a for me I would agree banish the snakes is an a um bamboo is an a this is almost two hours yeah bamboo is an a yeah everybody are you still here Bad Company was really fun I think it's a B I think it's a b too still think I like space base more mhm but uh Back to the Future back in time is probably a c yeah it's soos so hard uh Babylonia babon that's an a game for me I really like Babylonia I feel like we didn't have as much fun last time all right we'll do B are you sure yeah I'm fine with B okay uh aul is an a game yeah again another game I've been playing so much of I I'm always in a game of AO um W AAR guess yep game's amazing I did back the second one possibly an S but uh Aon Clash of popes I liked it B yeah um at the helm you've never played I like it a B's worth uh at the gates of L Yang's probably an a yeah I didn't do it did I where is it I don't know where you put it oh no I lost it where'd it go I don't know
it's gone start it all over got to start over Astra is a d for me I don't disagree it just hurts I know I really want it to like it so much more Ash's reborn it's a b a minus for me right now I just find I can't wrap my brain around it sometimes the games go on for too long that's the problem with it I agree of swend veil is probably a d for me it's probably a d it's more of a it's too much reading it's just more of a story than uh art Society I like art Society it's probably an a game for me I like it a lot yep uh then we have Arkham wh the card games in a you've never played it yes I have you do you remember it yes I didn't like it I already put it in a Ark Nova okay so I've played this probably way more than you have um I'm just getting kind of I don't know it's fine I think it like I know people love this game it's a b or c I found out the gates of lyang you decide I'll put it up here I think aric NOA is a b yeah I put it at a c but that's just me you've played it more uh architects of the West kingdom is probably a B for me at this point would Age we haven't played it in so ones that are out now and stuff arum is probably a b yep very mean tree game uh aquatic is an A Y I'm fine with that God
that game's good I probably put Aqua at a B yep fine with that uh appropo movies and board games both these for me I really like them I can do C's uh Apple Jack I love Apple Jack Apple Jacks I think so too I'm also always in a game of Apple Jack on BGA uh apiary apiary is I really I think apiary is a a but not yet it's a b because that's more thematic I need to play it more because it's about be's H antomy that's one you really liked it was like that push and pull probably a b it's a button shy game you don't remember it no okay uh ano 1800 I really like ano 1800 squash my brain are we being being it or aing it I think it's a B+ okay B+ uh Android Netrunner probably an a I don't think so I think it's a b just because we don't play it ancient knowledge is really good A B B an Acron is an a an acon is an a teetering on S tier for me pop we have so few left and Otter one is probably a little C game I like that one do you want higher than C no I think that's fine almost inant I really like yeah I'm I'm fine with that what b or a I'm I
think it's a b game for me but okay uh Acro tiri I liked more than you yeah I think for me it's probably in the C tier but I'm fine if you put it in B yeah uh Acropolis I like Acropolis it's another b game for me yep uh aoy uh probably a b right now just because we haven't played it enough but probably an a by the end of it agria All Creatures big and small D sucks uh agrica d a i will leave this room if you don't let me have this one that hurt physically that one hurt probably an ass really age of Comics that's a good B+ game for me okay I'm fine with it art Society that's such a good game probably B+ I'd say B+ yeah um 3,000 Scoundrels such a unique little game I would say it's a B I would agree yeah uh 20 strongs in a mhm sure sure um Seven Wonders that's you it's a c at this point I put it in a d six Ned is an a game for me why is Dice Town on there twice uh I made an accident I'm fine you want to rank it again all of these these ones uh Planet fall age of uh something is that a b game it's a B minus I think yeah um three ring circus is an aame a
game yeah Y game yeah and the rest of these we've already done yeah and one's a prototype oh boy 1 hour and 43 minutes good luck that let's just like very quickly just so everybody can see these are our games solid list if we could only have games those would be the ones uh this is our a list which is probably the biggest list I would say B is probably the biggest oh yeah B is for sure the biggest B and then a then we've got I think it's b a c d s yeah or s d d is probably the smallest yeah okay that my friends genuinely go back up the S okay look at that what a solid group of nam I just want to go over our ass games quickly yeah wonderlands War amazing War of the Ring vast Crystal Caverns revolver Noir final girl undaunted unmatched uh sea salt and paper stardo Valley root too many bones villainous Skull King so Clover rise of Fenris burgundy castles of burgundy burgundy uh Star Wars rebellion can't stop camel up Cathedral world fast loso kual Libre dice Throne Game of Thrones Fuji flush Star Wars villainous Obsession numers Grand Austria Hotel Nana monikers Marvel Champions florid of the Rings confrontation Mansions of
Madness res Arcana Domin species and hookie that's a if those were the only games we had that's a pretty that's a pretty Banger list right there so that my friends was a long- winded way for us to tell you what we thought about every game our collection uh but that was our tier ranking love to know your thoughts below but just keep in mind this is our list and it's completely subjective and none of this matters in the grand scheme of Life 100% it's just Bo gam we are just adults playing with toys you love to see it but that is everything that we have for you today if you're interested in board games like any of the hundreds that we mentioned today you should first start by checking your friendly local gaming store and for us that is boardroom Game Cafe and if you like what you see Please Subscribe we hope to see you again again soon and now we say goodbye goodbye lat it is 3 two one level up level up level up level up level up this is going to be fun did the camera just move it almost just like slid that was weird
that's Alby Alby cling around was there any food left around because he'll eat it remember when we saw that Hawk with a stick yeah that was cool he's building his nest oh my God know so tired we're not filming anymore today you know what this means Hero's like let's go yeah look the camera's moving what it's like readjusting
what are you talking about it was it's like it was like readjusting go come over this side and see if it moves with you you're not moving you're just doing this what do you mean like come all the way over here maybe I'm crazy I think you're crazy man am I crazy I don't know I might be crazy