Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top 5 Traitor Board Games! The Best Games To Play When You Really Want to Betray Your Friends.

Transcript 28:36

Matt it's your turn to die I am the traitor no wait I'm the traitor what do you mean you're the traitor the cards I'm the traitor but M says I'm the traitor no me I think we need to reshuffle Dam it hello and welcome to board stupid my name is wne and I'm mad we're no longer traitors no not not let to Res Shuffle and we're the good guys now yeah we are we are good guys good guys always the good guys for you guys and uh Matt what is this video this is our top five traitor games top five traitor games if you are a fan of the traitors which you can see on whatever your one of my favorite show hether Matt loves it I don't really watch TV but Matt loves trait I love it so much so and it is available everywhere and if you like that then we thought this would be a cool video to do to talk about all those games where you're backstabbing people um but what you shouldn't backstab in front you should front yeah it's the with on your screen with a knife you like the screen breing to start our thought but we don't accept liability B breaking screens stabbing screens but Press thank you very much and let's talk about some amazing traitor games yeah let's go it's a Vibe for two all we need be G for human and me what what what you

see wayne so for this lease we're talking about um gains with a traitor mechanism in it um how did you build your list so traitor mechanisms can cover a few different things um and what I've tried to do for my list is have games where you have a role which is actively trying to shaft the rest of the team trying to tank the team yes break the game whatever it is there is got to be someone that's working actively against everyone else yeah because there's lots of games with hidden roles um but sometimes that hidden role is quite passive or is doing something different isn't necessarily trying to you know Force everything to lose um and there's lots of examples of that which I might cover in honorable mentions but Matt is there anything uh M said it's got a lot of like hidden information specifically okay interesting that all yeah okay perfect so should we start with number five let's start with number five mat what's your number five the least stabby uh my number five is the kind of like only um party game in the in my selection uh of course controversial because I'm talking about secret Hitler ah the edgiest bo games um again the theme cannot be for everyone uh there is a Harry Potter version as well that is Marvel one as well I think yeah I think

they done a few few version but the most famous ones well of original secret Hitler and then is the um uh the Harry Potter one that I hate more than Hitler so but well I just say it um in secret hler um you play the the more the better I think it's up to eight players where everybody is kind of like um the good guys uh but two one two three people are going to be Hitler and the fascist they're going to try to um uh to demolish democracy and take over the the power while the the good guys are going to try to kill Hitler or to stop the fascist stom take control um it how does it happen every every round there's going to be some motions some laws that needs to pass and the you're going to be given two cards each person and you will have to vote for passing or not passing depending on what cards you you're going to be given uh these cards can be the the good gu card the blue cards or the fascist card the problem is that if you're a good guy but you've been given randomly two fascist C there's nothing you can do beside playing one of the Fist carard but then that is where the the games get in more interesting is like trying to explain to the other player that no you're not a fascist you're not itler you've just been given those few back exactly or maybe not or

maybe notbe yeah so secret Hitler um was a kind of not a genre explosion right because it was so popular partly because of the edgy theme and and and the production um amazing best production really great production but I remember I did a print and play of okay when it was out like years and years and years ago originally and I took it with me like on holidays and played it with a bunch of people and it's was really fun and what it does is it plays with uh giving everyone bad information right like you said even if you're a bad guy you've got to be ah God damn it I've got to play this bad but if you're you know it's great it's it's it's really cool and it still stands up as being a pretty decent social deduction game yeah I do I do really like it and uh definitely got some traitors in it you're trying to oh yes real good oh yes what about you my number five is uh I suppose slowly becoming a classic I still really like it it's got out of fashion but it's dead of winter uh dead of winter is a fantastic game still I think so because I love the feeling that it gives you as you're literally putting zombies on the board it feels terrifying because you you've got your your compound trying to keep everything out of you've got zombies attacking the gates constantly you've got zombies like going to all of the outer locations that you're trying to search through to get you know useful gear to try and fight them off and all the while someone might be trying to just T the tra be the traitor exactly like doing something bad and they've got their own secret hidden agenda and um dead of winter was one of those games

that really sort of popularized the semi Cooperative game yes where you are cooperating to an extent and the way it manages the sort of taking the heat off the full train is that everyone's being a little bit weird because everyone has a secret agenda and it might be that you need to ho all of the medicine so you might be taking all the men you might be a good guy but you might be holding try to win in the game yeah you want to but you can't win unless you collaboratively win and then also do your own personal win right that's how the game works some people don't like that because they feel like oh why why should I have like a hidden agenda if I'm trying to cooperate well the point of it is to make sure that the the the traitor isn't getting all the heat yeah cuz otherwise we'll be too easy to spot out of the of the traitor to be to be immediately o you yeah I mean the the the main critique is it's quite heavily group dependent but if you've got a cool group that are into it you can really have a great time with a great atmosphere if you if you're fan of The Walking Dead uh this is the the perfect game is what brings that sh actually on the um on the table um yeah it's not just the the undead that are the problem but it's the people around people as well so um it brings down as well very very good um with the expansions as well even more it's it's I love it there is a it used to be uh there used to be an app that you could get which did the um the crossroads CS oh and they were voice acted and they were absolutely amazing I don't even know if you can get it now but if you can download it somewhere get the app

because it's even better than using the crosss cards and spicy take still the best Crossroads game you can buy uh we agree on that number fours win let's go win number four what what the game is what the traitors the traitors uh my number four is a classic that isn't in print which makes me sad and I'm sorry because I don't normally do that for these kind of lists but I think it has to go here and it Shadows over Camelot ohow is absolutely fantastic game it's by days of Wonder um it must be du a reprint like 20 years old now it is so so good and I think games that are that good can't not be reprinted so I think it has to happen soon and it's a fantastic game especially uh I remember the production for the year it was what with the meis and the round table and the map and the uh a new version would be even better yes yeah but it uses a really cool hand management system where you need to go to different places spend cards to do different quests and of course you have a backstabbing traitor Black Knight trying to go Black Knight ruin everyone day ruin all of the quests and it's really cool you can play it with a maybe Black Knight or you can play it with a definite Black Knight and that's probably the more fun way to play is where you know someone is a bad guy and I think that's pretty cool it's such a cool theme and it's such a cool game and it's a very simple game where you basically just playing cards but while you playing cards it feels you're doing

way more than just simply playing a card um yeah I really like it I haven't played it in ages long long time yeah i' it's been it's been probably at least a year and a half my question for you is going to be so the traitor in the game is the Black Knight but what about the fact that Lancelot was with the queen well you know they had an affair oh did they really yeah well well he it's a little bit traitor as well I guess so man a lot yeah naughty naughty mat what about you what's your um my number four um we got a game that um I really like and or do you really like a but it doesn't come on the table ever because it's a mess to put it on the table that is Nemesis a it's such a massive game um so cinematic though it's very cinematic is alien but like on on the ball game without being aliens yeah um legally distinct distinct um yeah well what I love about the Nemesis um sort of challenges the roles that you get is you get given two roles right you get given either sort of a a relatively less traiter one and the more traiter one the thing that you need to go and do I think it's the the corporate agenda you can go and fight for the which typically involves crashing the ship or killing someone specific exactly which I love because it's the game is like go kill player three oh damn okay that's the game from now on that's to kill that

guy but then he might have one like go kill player two which might be you that's really fun the um the only problem with the game itself is the game itself is the is the fact that it takes ages to set up it takes ages to explain you need to play with people that already play the game to actually fully enjoy the um the traitor experience cuz otherwise for the first games it's probably better to just play co completely Cooperative which you can do yeah because the the rules are bit of a pig frankly but once you get into the game and you everybody start playing with their own agendas and everybody's a little bit of a trait of themselves or more or less but that it feels like a movie every time it really does it's super cinematic when you get a great game of nesis it is so so evocative of those great space sci-fi horror movies um and then like a small percentage of the time you might get like a game that's kind of a bit of a Duff but that's the nature of these types of games but when you when it when it kicks off it is really really cool Nemesis so number threes now mat and for my number three there's not much more that I like in terms of themes than cyber Punk okay and so cyber Punk with hidden traitors it's just a great mechanism yeah especially blended with Fantasy Flight and this is a game called new Angeles so new Angeles was

introduced to cool yeah 2015 2016 say new Angeles is really cool it is a relatively heavy um again semi Cooperative game where you are building and investing in the city of New Angeles a dystopian cyber Punk news of La uh and all of the trappings that that might uh be but one of you might secretly be uh working for the government trying to make them uh like more successful and shut down all of these independent corporations just trying to be successful in the American way by treading on on the little man sorry American people sorry Amic but fact of fact uh but yeah and it's it's such a really cool game it's got such a cool Vibe um it is pretty long uh ideally you really need to play it with six players as well it's one of those games that works better with more but when you do play it with six players you got a strap in for like a 4our s um but it is a really cool game and I I not enough games do like that cyber Punk Vibe really particularly well especially in with like a traitor mechanism and not other ones that I really know that do it like like that I think is really super good and it does similar to what you in some other games that you might mention where you're using cars to either make certain projects go live or not work uh accordingly um but yeah really really cool game uh with cool art that's by fanasy flight in it's new Angeles cool um I'm going to go fantasy fly again

okay even heavier heav um okay I'm talking about baa galatica BSG baby um so basa galatica mine was a classic yours is a classic mine is a mine is a real classic that um I promise I'm never gonna play again because it's impossible to find copy right now but um in bad galatica s is based on the on the TV show of 2000 one of your favorites right yeah definitely one of my favorite IP ever um where you basically try you are on the butter star that is the on the Galactica that is the ship and everybody needs to play together to to um resolve uh problems or um Anything could happen in space basically and try to stay alive try to stay with to to keep the humanity alive and some of you might be silen that are the traitor um now exactly as in the show they is is very very heavily thematic with the show so you kind of like need to know the show to enjoy the game fully uh you need to be in six people you need to every everybody needs to know the rules cuz there's a lot there's a lot going on there but um the fact that each one plays a specific character with their own agenda and their own special powers some can do this some can do that and then secretly someone of you or more one of you are going to be silence or the traitor they're trying to um basically

make the missions fails or trying to plant bombs or trying to basically trying to do everything to let the other people um uh dies or or or or lose is very very highly thematical and uh I I love the feeling of being in the in the being in the show uh again it's another one of those games that is a high Play account uh long hours cuz probably like four five hours is going to be is going to be the game um quite of a not easy rules so you want to enjoy the games you want people to to really know what they're doing cuz otherwise if I start asking oh what this card does what the cards don't you kind of like break the magic yeah break the magic um but once you get all these things together it's not easy but the experience that you get playing that game is absolutely fantastic there you go battar Galactica um new version is UNF funable MH that I haven't played yet but you played UNF fundable right did play unfathomable yeah did you enjoy that I loved unfathomable might talk about it we'll see maybe Matt moving to number two we number two U another classic okay that is Happ now with the Third Edition for I think Third Edition is BET at house on the hill what a classic my goodness um so is in this like culu style World um you basically um explore a mansion so with you with

your with your the player it starts uh everybody's Cooperative so everybody plays together um you start exploring the house so there's going to be some tile placement on the on the border you form the this mansion that you are um you are visiting and um a certain point after some specific rules you have to pick up certain objects you need to be unlucky to roll this or that dies in a certain way but one of you is going to become the monster it's going to betray everyone and become whatever Monster the book is going to tell will happen and basically it will be a combination of the thing that you picked up I think and then where you are and then you got look in this giant book of haunts yes and then suddenly the rules go out of the window EXA then and then you become the game's completely change so from an exploration simple ones game it becomes where one of the guys around the the table is going to become the monster H the cool things is like as you say you got a book that is this stick so every time you can't see them all I've been playing for years and it's it's every time it's a new is a new monster and um with specific rules for that specific scenario and the monster is everything from a giant octopus space octopus that Undead name or um simply a murderer like a crazy murderer that runs around and stabs people I think I had one where I had like an undead marriage that went

wrong and there was like a a bride that was she killing real and then there was one where like I think the tower start the the house started falling away and you had to to get parachutes I think I remember that and there was not enough parachutes for everyone it's crazy it's really crazy if you like if you're into the culu style games uh this is games it's become mythical at this point it's the third edition um and it's absolutely a joy to play every time the more player the best but one of you will definitely betrayed every one and it's going to be really clear who almost the perfect Halloween game mm Wayne what about you for my number two my number two is unfathomable everything that matter said about Galactic if you like the sound of that but you'd like it more streamlined and you'd like it with rules that are easy to read then that's for you and if you like cthulu yes it is it is that bit in a cthulu uh Mythos so you are going to be instead of the on of the Galactica you're going to be on a ship uh traveling across the Atlantic uh and while you're traveling across the Atlantic some people are getting a little bit tentacle uh and not in a weird way not a weird anime way it's not one of those crew not those Crews you no no uh family show but in your hidden role you might be uh one of the sort of

evil hybrids um which is amaz it's so cool it's so atmospheric uh it uses the same framework but it's been updated forar Galactica I think it's a better it's a better game I think it's a better game than the original but it doesn't have the magic from the theme from the show yeah if you don't if you really missed that magic of the theme then you're not going to get that here uh but if you like cthulu and the love crafting Mythos like I do then you're going to get an entirely different type of Joy uh from that yeah and un funable you can buy right now Galactica can't so and it has great production uh for the fairly good price point as well it's an excellent game still relatively rules heavy but slightly easier to pass uh than BSG that's my number two Wayne do you have some horriable mention before I do have some horrible mentions and the horrible mentions are really good actually they are Classics like uh Avalon slash the resistance the only reason I hate yeah I know well you but the only reason I didn't include these games it's the same game with a different theme I prefer the resistance because cyber Punk yeah um is I've played the hell out of it mate I've played so much resistance I can't play anymore but I've got to mention it because it's still classic and if you are new to things like traitor games it's a great one to pick up because it's relatively easy to learn and get everyone shouting each other and accusing them of being a a naughty nasty bloody betrayer yeah um we talked about about these games in our video games we

will never play again and this one one of mine just because I used to play with these games with a few lawyers and it's not fun when someone can talk them out of everything law and just just don't don't do it but these are amazing games if you like hidden roles then those are two that you certainly need to check out perfect let's go to number one then let's go Matt it's time for the number ones time for number one number one traitor number one trait number one traitor game I'll start because is um he a double up oh is it yes and he is dead of winter dead of winter there you go I simply love that game it's so good this your number one as well it is my number one um I love that winter it's it's one of the games that and you still love it as well and I still love it's one of the games no one else does when it came out it started like reintroducing me uh to the to the B gaming and and everything is the ball gaming the more than ball gaming scene um and uh since then I I really love it it's just like that zombie apocalypse scenarios that yeah you can find in the Walk The Walking Dead or 28 Days Later or all that all the stuff on a board game with the with the fact that you don't know if you're if Wayne is going to bet that me at any point because it's just like I love it so much the tension and the uh and the stories that you create around the board

with the with that where you're not sure about anyone everybody could could be tray anyone at any moment it um always tell people to really lean into those secret things if you're good or not whatever it tells you do that with 100% conviction it makes the game so much better yes yeah in all these kind of games all these traiter games needs a little bit more of um uh pocket face or or it need to you need to be involved uh cuz otherwise you ruin the the magic for every body else basically and it's not for everyone either no no no but but when you get the right group of people and everybody is is getting in there oh my God what what a game it's so much fun with a great exploration mechanism I I simply love it I simply love it we might be alone on this island but we think it's great let us know if you you agree with us but um and when what about your number one it's the most recent one that I've played okay and it is blood on the clock tower I knew it that's why put it on my list I had to put it on my list so I play in Blood The Clock Tower thanks to Rob friend of the show uh and his wonderful partner uh Kylie who came and ran uh Blood on the clock tower for me and I I rented a smoke machine yeah well you all played Without Me F my girlfriend went to play as well at work I was at work everybody was having fun and I wasn't work we were having fun and we all dressed up for it as well it was great fun the game was so atmospheric

and what the the great thing about this game is is if you are familiar with games like Mafia SL werewolf from back in the day back in a long long time ago it's that but done with a little bit more and with a better framework and with interesting roles where everyone has a specific role and all of those roles help give piece of a bigger puzzle yeah where you just have this little one simple power that you've got and using that little power you might get a little bit of information which means nothing by itself but this is where the shines you are forced to go and talk to people and then find out what they know and try and share that information to try and find out who the demon is who is slowly killing you all over the course of the evening so the the the the role playing in the game is essential so it's again we talked about it just now you really need to go in with both your your your shoes and like all right I'm playing this game otherwise you ruin the magic but if you can find yeah the with the right people with the right setup and everything is is an experience more than a game yeah it's a great experience you get 10 people around uh it's you need a lot of people you can't really play this with three or four is fantastic um and it's so very social and uh you can make a great party out of it I mean I had an absolutely magical time and I can't wait to play again it was fantastic uh it is like uh it's all of these games but you know just cranked up to 11 it's it's it's exactly that so that's my number one

Blood on the clock tower Matt let take it to the outro let's go so those were our picks for our top five traitor games and I do like a traitor game M I've got to be in the mood for it I'm not always in the mood for a traitor game but when I am they can be real spicy yeah yeah and as we say the group is important so when you approaching one of these games is uh if you are in a larger group trying to to go for it just just through trying don't take it seriously nothing's personal it's just a game and you need to kind of put that face on because you know if you're it makes it magical it's it creates an experience um that is that is more than the game itself it creates a Love or a story that you're going to tell your friends for ages because that's that's what happened with these kind of games it is absolutely fantastic I remember one of these times we play one of the Nemesis sequels and my buddy Chris where we were just about to escape a moon base and then he literally took the Moon Lander the only one left and left me in the Bas like right the what come with me buddy we'll get out together I like you kidding me but it's so good I still remember that like it was yesterday and those kind of stories uh some of the great things that board games can deliver absolutely absolutely we can't wait to play more we got one coming in the future uh talking about under our son we going to do a proper review um in if check out

we are going to dive deep into that game hell yeah so if you liked this video then please comment and let us know your favorite straighter game which games do you like where you get to be a backstabbing G do you enjoy being the bad guy or would you rather just be like the good guy and try and work out who the bad guys are would you prefer uh twer all being bad so you know the St no else knows it's really really cool um not that I'm good Weir did but yeah Fair uh but is f absolutely fantastic but you should also like this button trait her or not and of course hit the Subscribe button don't don't backstab us no just subscri just subscribe be a good guy be nice be a good guy subscribe uh if you like that then check out theirl videos and we're going to catch you again pretty soono

Progress saved