Social Deduction Games - Which One is for You?
Transcript
hi it's Stella from people University and this is Luke hello hello how's it going hello good thank you how are you pretty good thanks for being here I bring Luke again after you match in Luke as in the video in Quest video or Avalon video versus an Avalon which I will link in the description because Luke has got a really fast experience in Social deduction games so you flight I want to know like 100 maybe of social deduction games thousands of Everlong games werewolf a lot yeah a lot a lot so here we are Luke is the social social deduction division of Miguel University that will be able to hopefully help you in deciding what games to play with or what type of players you are and what you think like what we think you like this particular game than the other uh socially Latin game because of what so we're gonna explain it we're gonna delve into that uh we're gonna show a few games that you might be interested or not interested or try to avoid because that's probably not your game but again this is based on our opinion that's right yeah it's it's subjective all this is subjective but you know the reason it's it's not like a top 10 you know social deception games is because
it is highly subjective and it depends on so many different circumstances the types of players you're playing with where you're playing it you know how long you want to play for all those kinds of things so you know there's just a a good selection of games that you might want to play uh depending on what type of player you are and if we have the video like instructional or reveal other things we'll Link in the video description as well so if you're interested in a particular game that you want to dwell uh digging fair then and you'll be able to refer that to our other videos hopefully that will help and what's very important thing here is hopefully you will enjoy your play that's what we want right this is social deduction games thing can get a little a little heated at times as we've you've witnessed I've witnessed you'll witness more because you play more and this is just a game at the end of the day you want to have fun with your friends right exactly right all right with that let's get into the first one okay so the first one I want to talk about is a game called deception murder in Hong Kong and um I love this game I think it's I think it's a great um social deduction game on its own um but importantly why I wanted to put it in here and what makes it kind of a standout and unique is that it's in a lot of social deduction games you'll find that they can be quite confronting for new players especially players new
to social deduction we're not used to or not usually play that sort of game yeah you'll get you'll get players who are you know making very direct accusations and very very full-on accusations against other players and as a new player to be on the receiving end of that it can be really confronting and really hard to deal with and it can you know I've seen a lot of people say you know I don't play social deduction games you know I played secret Hitler once and I never again yeah yeah right away in tears and you know I often think yes there's some people you know different people like different types of games there's also some people who I feel like have just had a bad experience and just didn't have the right introduction to it I feel like murder uh like uh deception in Hong Kong is the perfect introduction to social deduction games you get the sense that you get the theme of it you get the idea of that night phase and who's good and who's evil but importantly when you're playing the game it's not so confrontational when you're you're looking at the at the Tableau in front of each player and you're making accusations you're not so much accusing the player you're accusing the Tableau in front of them yeah and it's it's less confrontational and you know players can more easily say oh no I think it's more likely to be them or it's more likely to be that or you know and it's it it really takes the personal element out of
it while still just being a really fun game to play and you absolutely right about the non-confentional bid but also there are information so you can accuse that person based on that so there's more information that you can go by it's unlike some others that are based on body language or like different types tips that you know you have to like if you learn by playing the games more often but this is like absolutely for new players and more informations in there out there that you can go base on and it's just more beginners friendly exactly yeah yeah and also I should add that playing the forensic investigator it's so fun okay I love that one it's it's probably the most fun you'll have in a social deception game more so than any other game I can think of but um yeah that's kind of why that's that's here yep so this is we're not going to go through um the rules in details by the way but uh the session made in Hong Kong is the game about good versus evil and you're trying to find the murderer and the accomplished accomplish is that well you're trying to the good team is trying to accuse the murderer yes and know what what the murder weapon was and what the clue left behind the scene was the accomplice will be trying to help the murderer by throwing off suspicion yes
in this game I've I've played it quite a few times and the it's rare it's very rare that the murderer gets away with it okay um but it's still fun because you were the um the forensic story The forensic investigator that's that's a fun part for you and that is you know maybe you wanna play a few times until you become forensic investigator rather than they'll randomly right yeah I think that the main thing though here is that um it's a game that you can introduce people who are kind of new to the genre too for sure yeah next up uh we're going to talk a little bit about spyful and for those who haven't played spyfall before um it's a game it's got similar themes to other social interaction games everyone gets a hidden role at the start of the game but the role is not about you the role is a location so everyone except for one player at the table gets a location could be an amusement park it could be a police station it could be a space station and one player just gets a card that says spy and through a series of questions directed around the table um it's up to the Spy to work out where we are and it's up to the other players to work out who the Spy is so that's kind of generally how the game plays out and it's really it's a really fun game because you get to be very creative with how you ask and how you answer questions um it was
um uh it really tests your ability to think outside the box oh absolutely and to work out when people are just being a little bit too vague yeah you can't be too fair you can't be too accurate and if you're the Spy if I'm the Spy I'll be so panicked oh my God no because there's only one spy yeah that's right and I think for me spyfall is um uh that Perfect Blend of kind of those of party games and um and social deduction okay that's right it's it's a really easy game to bring out to explain really quickly yeah you can play through it really quickly and um yeah it's it's uh it takes a lot of boxes a lot of games a lot of social deduction games take place really quickly I enjoy as well because it plays really quickly so if you stuff up that's it the end of the game is soon the next one right so that is spy fall that's by fall okay next up we've got a similar kind of game um fake artist goes to New York and um this is um I suppose if you think about it if um if spy 4 was kind of a little bit like um I don't know like um social deduction meets code games oh yeah yeah um then uh fake artist goes to New York is a little bit like social deduction
meets telestrations oh yeah yeah yeah so the way it works is everyone has a um everyone has a pen and there is a little whiteboard that's passed around and everyone is just adding a line to or a dots or whatever yeah and then you pass it off and the the objective is very similar to that in spiteful where you've got a lot of people who know what we're trying to draw but you've got one person who doesn't and that one person their job is to determine what it is we're trying to draw and the job of everyone else is to work out who the Spy is so very similar kind of setup but um for those people who like to have a little bit of fun with drawing withdrawing yeah I found that it's a little bit less stressful people as the spy in fake artists because you can just follow it rather than question questions like oh are you gonna get tall or not so it's a little bit more timid for um fake artists and it's mainly like it's the drawing it's less conventional as well rather than the spyful that's right it's a very easy game to get new players into yeah and it's how fun this is like but I know Terran always throws obstacle things it's consistently obsecure that's probably a good thing for him he does I I always think he's a spy in those games I'm always wrong um but um there you go so that is it's highly recommend it by the way it's um one of
the fun games that keep we we keep bringing to the Meetup and I have to share one more story where you were the person that was Distributing the fake artist and everyone yeah come on tell that story everyone okay okay okay okay so so sometimes um I'm just a shitster right so what I what I so normally in the game you see someone gets the spy uh someone's determined to be the spider everyone else gets the where where you know what we're trying to draw yeah so the person gets a spy gets a blank slate right yeah so I took up all the slaves I just actually something yeah pretended to write on each of them but they were all blank and so I just passed them each around just to watch what would happen to watch everyone pretend to know where we were but no one knows about you drawing hilarious that was hilarious I was like when we were real like who's the fake artist we point at the person and then we reveal everyone is blank everyone what that was really fun and I was like I thought of that but like I didn't think that you would do that in that game but that was really fun so yeah that's that's recommended this world do that if you want to bring a little bit of Tails and a fake artist game if you want your friends to hate you we're still friends that tells you something right all right next up um we're going to talk about um one of the one of the oldest social deduction games uh that I can think of
and that's werewolf that's also Mafia I think it's called yeah it's called Mafia in some places although technically they're slightly different but you know they're essentially the same and this is not One Night Ultimate the way off this is correct the what is it actually called well the more modern version they call Ultimate Werewolf ultimate werewolves um but essentially you know you've got your common social deduction tropes you've got a good team we're the villagers and you've got the evil team who are the werewolves and there's lots of special roles so there are some uh roles in the good team that when they when they're when they die they're allowed to take other players out with them or there's a SEO who gets to check players and find out where they're a werewolf or not we've got video on that by the way so check that out I'll link it below and um so the reason I bring out werewolf is because I find it's a it's just a great game to get together people socially for um it's not very heavy you can get people together you can get a large group of people together right so you can play I've played games of werewolf well um you can do all that right it's not going to be your very tight uh game full of strategy and Nuance where you have to pay close attention to but it doesn't need to be right it's a game where you can just get together maybe you go out to a pub and you have a large group of people and you play together and it's it's a good time
um it's good just to get people together socially they don't need to pay very close attention to the game it's a nice little um a little uh thing just to get people together and talking indeed and I think there is a host as well in werewolf it's like yeah um a narrative narrator yeah there's there's someone who administers the game yes their job to keep track of of who has what role and to make sure that the night rolls are called out in the right order and to determine who's dead and who's not and is that a story it's a slightly a slight story that you you mentioned the pub so at one time in the pub you know you order drinks and food and whatever so in werewolf there are night faces right so there's that right moment where the waiter the waiter was bringing a whole lot of food and drink and that was a night face so here comes the waiter and then look around everyone's close their eyes and then he had no idea what's going on they're like and then went went back oh my god well that's the game um and that was in I think that was here in Melbourne so we've got somebody who runs it like once a month now that's right um for anyone in Melbourne yeah um look up the Melbourne what's it called Melbourne Melbourne werewolf something like that you'll find you'll find a
meet-up for a group that meets monthly in St Kilda and um that's where we are is that where people can find you get your signature um yeah okay so uh yeah check that out if you are in happen to be Melbourne or visiting Melbourne wants to play werewolf but I've seen werewolves played online as well because Tom vassal um I don't know if he still does that I Join one or two of his online werewolf games so he's the moderator it was quite fun like when you cross your eyes you like open your eyes that works in video video call so that's that's interesting so is that that was during lockdown so that was a a quite interesting werewolfly online all right next game to talk about I think is two rooms in a boom um and um I'll get to why I'm talking about this one in a second but essentially for those of you who haven't played it before um it's a it's another very very light uh social action game air very easy to explain very easy to get into essentially what it is you can have as many players you want this is one of those games where you can play with hundreds of people if you want to right but as the name suggests there are two rooms they're all the players are separated out into two separate rooms and there is a boom so everyone gets a special roll card which will tell you which team they're on they're either one of the good guys one of the bad guys
um and one of the bad guys has the boom they have the bomb one of the good guys is the president um the very U.S Centric game obviously um and the objective of the good team is to make sure at the end of the game the bomb is in the different room to the president the objective of the bad guys is to make sure at the end of the game the bomb is in the same room as the president and that determines the winning team there's some special roles that do various things but essentially the way it works is they're in each room you'll vote on which players you want to change rooms so every round there'll be a change people will change different rooms it's different information will be revealed and so then that's kind of how you work out how you want to get your players positioned in the right way and the reason I'm talking about it is just because it's such an easy game to teach such an easy game to play doesn't require everyone to be 100 committed you can go in there and and be chatting and and easy like that it's it's something I really think would make a really great kind of um uh like corporate game like a little Icebreaker team building Icebreaker building being good for people just to kind of you know at an event just to have a little bit of fun with you know it doesn't get too heated doesn't doesn't require any great understanding of the game or anything like that and um yeah and it's just a
really fun little game for a large group of people to get into in the same way that werewolf is but much much shorter to play and much much easier to yeah to administer very true okay next up um I think it's important with to recognize with social deduction games usually you get games which have a large Play account right and require a large player account right like you think about games like Avalon where you're talking five players minimum absolute minimum right and often you know we don't have that many players to play with so what can you do then there's there's two games in that vein that I want to call out here one is uh don't mess with Cthulhu which is a very fun game where you've got a set of tiles that you're trying to play or not play in certain ways and the um the the good guys are trying to get uh the the Elder signs played and the bad guys are trying to get Cthulhu played and you can play this with I think it's minimum of four players um and maximum of six so it's like it's really low play and really works really well very quick easy to play a lot of a lot of fun gives you that um that social deduction you know scratches that social deduction each year without uh without you needing 10 players to to play it right and the
other one I'll call out as well is um One Night Ultimate Werewolf which is a great game not only because it accommodates a low Play account I think you can actually play that one with three I don't know that I recommend it with three but you can definitely play it with lower player accounts um and it's also just really quick right you can play I think games take five or ten minutes each to play um and uh yeah it's it's really a really great way to get some quick social deduction done with potentially a low Play account okay next up um I want to talk about secret Hitler and the secret Hitler stands out to me just because it is the game that has come closest In My Mind in my heart to knocking off Avalon as the premier social deduction which we're going to talk about later spoilers um so secret Hitler is um is played in a very similar way you've got good teams bad teams bad the the good team slightly outnumbers the bad team bad team kind of know who each other are but there's a few there's there's enough different about it that after playing Avalon for three hours and going oh I'm exhausted I don't think I can play anymore and someone says hey you want to play secret I go oh yeah okay uh so you know it's it's um it is kind of refreshing to play secret Hitler even though it has those
same kinds of things associated with it IT addresses some of the issues that are present in Avalon right so in Avalon you'll often particularly with experienced players you'll have a long voting phases where you'll have one for you know one rejected vote after another rejected vote after another rejected vote before you'll finally get a mission to go through and games can really drag on whereas secret Hitler you it really forces the the players to play more quickly with you know a maximum of three rejected uh missions before a a random policy will be flipped on the table right and also it adds a lot of interesting plays as well with secret and you know with special powers that uh that the president can use when mission or when when fascist policies are played and also you know it's got that really fun mechanic of Hitler as well where if Hitler can fly under the radar to the end of the game and and get elected Chancellor then yeah they can throw their hands up and say I have won the game yeah so it's it's um it's a lot of fun really does some unique stuff but at the same time you know he's very solid game really good mechanics really um really requires all players to be involved and every player kind of has a role to play in ensuring their team's Victory um but yeah it's it's it's not really for a beginner though no it is one of those games where it can get quite heated yeah um and you know if you don't if you
don't play with the right people you might not have a good time right so it's one of those games where if you've got a group of people who are into social deduction it's definitely one of the ones that you'll be playing okay next up I want to talk about blood on the clock tower um the only game that we actually bring it up because this is the biggest social deduction game ever in history and but it is beautiful and uh I can't even take it off can you pick it up and split this yet there you go so it's a like a fake book sort of thing and it opens like I haven't actually not let's not open that for um completely because it might be a mess inside yeah beautiful so it is gorgeous it's beautiful it's got like the most components paper and thick and heavy and all of the above but that is part of the game as well let me get this one look for the game yeah production quality second time yeah yeah and um it's an interesting game to play it's um so I've played it a few times now it's it's similar oh it's I would say it's kind of like werewolf werewolf and Avalon had a baby um it would be Blood on the clock tower okay um in that it has that variable player count you can adjust uh the roles depending on how you feel at the time but also more so than well if it has some structure yeah to it right it has
um some more um a more structured play so that each play it's more likely that each player has a or each team has a reasonable chance winning the game but at the same time every player has an important role to play in the game which you know you don't necessarily always get in werewolf so the kind of no player elimination um compared to werewolf but werewolf you get blaze eliminations sort of oh yeah yeah in werewolf you get that player elimination problem where players will be out of the game early and if the game goes on for another hour they're just sitting there twiddling their thumbs whereas Blood On the Clock Tower actually deals with that really well where you lose your special power but you maintain the ability to um to talk to other players to sway decisions and you maintain an a vote to play in the game so that's that's kind of a really interesting way to deal with that player elimination side of things but otherwise yeah it's it's very plays very similar to to werewolf I would say um in terms of who this is for that's an interesting question because it's a game with a lot of complexity to it um more so than any other game uh any other social production game I can think of and it's all in the roles right
whereas you think about a game like Avalon and you've got kind of the vanilla good guy the vanilla bad guy and then just some special roles in vitamin cocktail everyone has a special role and everyone's role does something different and as a result what you end up with is a game where if you're playing it with experienced players then that kind of high level play style there's a there's a it's got really quite a high ceiling as to how far it can evolve whereas if you get then some new players coming into that it's quite difficult for them to break in if they're playing with a lot of experienced players so that's one of the challenges that I think it has but for those who are you know fully into social deduction and they're they're really willing to you know get over that learning curve and watch the game a few games first yeah it's um it's it really does give you a really um a really um it gives you a lot to think about yeah in a social production game it's also made by um on Australian uh publisher which they are in Sydney there you go London the clock tower have you played this let us know and what let us know what you think as well for this one what am I going to talk about next Stella uh that's your favorite game ever or maybe not what is that terraforming Mars you 'll say yes
we've got to talk about Avalon yeah we have to talk there you go there you go for anyone who's seen the other videos University you knew this was coming right yeah but we're gonna talk about Avalon I'll link it into this video description below so you can see all the tips all the rules and even how to play okay so Avalon is it's just it is the game that I keep coming back to no matter how many times I've played it it still creates those memorable experiences for me every single time I play it uh you play it with different you could you the game is entirely different depending on who you're playing it with regardless of the the exact setup of the game and that's really what makes it unique and uh it's it's really tight in terms of its mechanics in terms of how it plays out and it's it's it's really well balanced I would say um between the the good team and the evil team obviously depending on the roles that you pick um and as a result it's it's a game that I think has really captured the essence of what social deduction is about and I think in for most people who play a lot of social deduction they probably think of Avalon as the the archetype of a social deduction game and so I I think of it as
I really enjoy playing it obviously um but I think that it has a lot of a lot of good things going for it um it is not as difficult I would say as Blood on the cocktail for new players to get into with experienced players um it's pretty it's pretty quick to explain but then there's quite some complex strategy that evolves yeah that's evolving that um that's why we had that tips for roles and for generic tips of how to play and how to enjoy playing Avalon because it's you know if for someone who's a little bit timid it might be what's going on I know nothing so what do I do so that could be a bit like that for the first experiences of Avalon yeah yeah so it might not be forever might not be for everyone but with the you know after a few plays then that becomes like a really good game and more so than any other social deduction game it's really stood the test of time uh Avalon's been out for 10 years and you'll still go to board game events and I'd say you see Avalon more commonly than any other social probably you probably you hosting it Luke um but it is it is just it is ubiquitous it is everywhere and it's for a good reason right like it's it's still fun to play many have have tried to improve on the formula to to emulate it we've talked about secret Hitler which does a
good job of it but does it's it's a different game it's not a not necessarily a better game um and indeed the the the designer um Donna switch has made a follow-up to Avalon to try and improve on it again which is called quest which is essentially Avalon 2 and even that I enjoy Quest but I think it's I would still recommend Avalon oh over it just because Avalon is just easier to get new players into and so Avalon for me is you know is the one game that if you're into social deduction if you start playing it more and more it's the one game that's going to be uh you know in everyone's collection I've enjoyed playing many games of Avalon I've learned a lot from Luke of Avalon and play with Luke poor me I know I know and I I really actually like I really learn a lot from like as a as a beginner I can seem me myself playing Avalon and it's okay it's not that intimidating like I made a lot of mistakes but with the right players like look here or be able to help me if I made a mistake oh okay so that's that's what I did wrong so to make it also still enjoyable um although I was I was new in the game does that make sense so that's really important and if you are new and you are interested a
really really high highly recommended to watch looks and our Avalon dips guide that is very well we've got like The Beginner's tip and the intermediate and the advanced tips so whether you're beginner or advanced because you covered don't worry and that's it that is fine if you want us to cover any like obviously there are so many other social deduction games we just pick select few to kind of like represent the the genre of the type of social deduction and more coming so if you want us to Maybe cover a particular one maybe we'll be able to please write in the comment sections below um I would really personally like to thank Luke for coming over and helping me with helping you to choose the right social deduction game hopefully this has been helpful thank you Luke thank you and um if you find this helpful if you can please hit the like button that'll be really helpful and subscribe to us if you haven't already done so we do things like this review other videos different type of games how to play and lifelike 2 on the weekend um I'm also on social so find me there as well don't find a look look won't be on socials we will ignore you're not beginning he's not a social person in a type of social media person and hopefully oh thanks for watching and hopefully we'll see you next time bye