"A Portrait of the Game Designer as a Young Man" Top 100 Board Gamess 60-51
Transcript
hi i'm adam porter and this is my board gaming vlog and we're looking at my top 100 table top games so that's board games card games dice games uh i'm not including any of my own games that i've designed like doodle rush and picoco and quasil and zuligans and compromat these are eliminated from the list uh but i'm looking for games which really connect with me and and and which i have an emotional sort of reaction to and actually i think you'll find in this 10 that we're going to look at today there are quite a few that are in there because of nostalgia more than anything else so we're looking at the games from number 60 down to 51 so completing the first half of the list and the first game at number 60 is the game blitz bowl from games workshop now blitz bowl is a reworking of the old game blood bowl uh and i really loved blood bowl as a child i suppose i started playing blood bowl when i was about 12 years old played it a lot uh never really got involved with all the campaigns and all that sort of stuff but i enjoyed painting the figures and and playing one-off games here and there i liked the spin-off game dungeon bowl as a kid and all that sort of thing um so i was quite excited a few years ago when games workshop re-released blood bowl in i think it was 2016 something like that there was this new edition of blood bowl and uh you know i bought in i painted up my miniatures and i played it and actually the game went on and on and on it took like three hours to play a match it was crazy um and it really wasn't the experience that i was looking for i enjoyed it but
it was going to be really hard for me to get this to the table and certainly to play all those campaign rules where your players are upgrading and you're getting new players and players are dying that was going to mean playing multiple games with the same people over and over again and i was never going to achieve that so i was really pleased when blitzball came out shortly afterwards and blitzball was an american exclusive unfortunately i believe it was also in germany but not in the uk um and it's a really really quick version of blood bowl much smaller teams cheaper package don't have any sort of campaign or anything like that plays in about half an hour i mean and it's silly it's got all the silly crazy fun of blood bowl but in a much smaller package so this one really connected with me um i wish it was available in the uk um there's been a season two which essentially is the same game just a slightly updated package that you can get i believe in america but still nothing in the uk blitzball though great game if you can get hold of it i personally got mine shipped in from america it didn't cost too much at the time from barnes and noble i don't know whether that situation would be different now but um you know if you really really love blood bowl then i think you're doing yourself a favor by getting this because you're going to find it much easier to get it to the table and it has a lot of the same fun in it number 59 on the list is fantasy realms now fantasy realms is a game by whiz kids and wizkids produced my game throne um last year i think 2019 i think throne came out
early 2019 and i realized i hadn't actually got many wizkids games they tend to be games that are full of sort of fantasy themes and um you know and and those aren't necessarily the themes that automatically although my statistics i've shown you tend to tell you otherwise but i'm not drawn to that sort of dungeon and dragon sort of style artwork particularly but i thought you know they've published my game i wanted to have a look at a couple of their games and one of the games i picked up was fantasy realms because i'd heard that it was really good and uh i was quite put off by the cover of the game but then when i played it it was fantastic okay this the rule set was so simple um i i mean there's barely any rules to it and essentially what you're trying to do is just put together the best possible hand of cards so you're putting cards down you're picking up other cards and they all combo in so many different ways to create these scoring opportunities um i just found it absolutely fascinating so much fun to play putting together this hand of cards and then at the end of the game when that comes around you just lay out your hand and say this is how much i've scored based on the different cards and how they com combine with each other um really really clever i'm very very impressed by the designer of this one number 58 on the list is the game quarto now if you're uh if you've watched my other videos earlier in this top 100 you'll have seen the game goblet and this is a similar sort of game again we've got nice wooden pieces uh a really attractive thing that you could leave out on a table top and it would look like a little ornament you could
just pick up and play from time to time it's a two player abstract game where you're trying to create four in a row in this game uh when i it's my turn to go my opponent chooses which piece i get to place now i can put it wherever i like but they choose the piece that i have to play um and that was really intriguing to me um i i found that fascinating you've got to create four in a row they could be four matching colors or they could be four of the set of um matching size or matching shape you know there's a variety of different categories that you can match in but you want to get four in a row your opponent's trying to prevent you from doing that by giving you different pieces now um it's reminiscent when i played this it reminded me of my game picoco where which is a trick taking game where when i play a card it's chosen by my opponents rather than me getting to play it myself i don't know that there are that many games that do that but uh but quarto is a really really good uh simple example of that mechanism number 57 is the game san juan now san juan is a card game re-implementation really of the game puerto rico which was extremely popular in the early 2000s um so san juan followed on with the same designer andreas safarth and i prefer it to puerto rico i think it takes everything that's good from puerto rico and does away with all the sort of extra stuff so in san juan you've got these multi-use cards so each card can be played either as a building which will give you some
sort of ability or you can uh discard cards and use them as money to pay for buildings or you can tuck cards under production buildings and then they count as the resources so if you you've got a something that's creating silver for example any tucked cards under it as pieces of silver that you can then trade in order to score points depending on varying sort of stock prices i suppose for how much silver is worth at that point in the game so really clever use of multi-use cards it's got that follow mechanism uh which we saw previously in the game skylands where if i take an action everybody else gets to take that action as well immediately i just get a better version of it okay and so that's the way that the game sort of functions in a similar way to the game puerto rico it's one of the earliest games i got when i first got into you know really got into these sort of designer games or what are we calling these games now hobby games i suppose and out of my old mass market sort of approach that i i would have followed in my in my twenties and as a teenager and as a kid um so san juan was quite pivotal for me in uh in getting into this hobby really number 56 is flickr up which is a cowboy western game which comes in a big wooden box and essentially it's full of wooden pieces uh building blocks really so you can create a western on your tabletop great thing about the game is you're you're really doing what it says you're doing you know if i'm playing as a cowboy and i want to shoot another cowboy then i literally get down to his eye level and i flick a bullet and i try and knock that cowboy over and
i've got cowboys and they're running into buildings and looting buildings um trying to free other cowboys who've been you know hung up on a noose or whatever you've got different weapons that allow you to shoot the discs in different ways you've got horses and you know you're hiding behind cactuses it's it really really um creates this sort of idea of of being in a western essentially it's just one big toy box i absolutely love it the expansions add a lot of um new stuff to it um i believe there's a there's a dead of winter zombie version of the game as well i haven't played that one i'm much more interested in the western theme than the zombie theme um but yeah i i think it's great it's just a lovely production and a wonderful thing to have this this big toy box of western toys really with and there's a there's a decent little game in there loads of scenarios and stories that you can create um you know settings for your battles and your shootouts number 55 won't need much introduction that's the game carcassonnes so carcassonne is a tire laying game you're laying down tiles building up the board as you play that was the thing that blew my mind when i was introduced to carcassonne and this really was the the first of the sort of european style modern games that was introduced to me i remember going into uh rules of play the the game shop in cardiff uh many years ago speaking to the man who worked in there didn't work in there anymore and saying to him i want to get a board game for christmas what should i get and him showing me carcassonne and just you think this is like a jigsaw you put together you're building the board as you go but there's a game that you play it's like a
jigsaw that you can play competitively against somebody else um and that's bizarre to me now that thai laying seemed such a a new thing such a new exciting alien concept but coming from mass market games you know i i'd never even considered such a thing that you might build the board as you play um but carcassonne remains a fantastic game whichever version of it you you get i like the game uh clarkson south seas um i've enjoyed many of the different versions i've enjoyed different expansions over the years but i suppose i tend to just come back to base game carcassonne with ins and cathedrals i tend to have ins and cathedrals always in there and the river um but uh i'd love to put more and more expansions in there really um yeah i mean it's just great isn't it it's a good introduction to the hobby it's not complicated uh the farmers is a little tricky but it's sort of just tricky enough that it's an introduction to the sort of mechanisms and little scoring twists that we get in these games so um and you can play without it as well so uh yeah carcassonne really accessible lovely game number 54 is a game that i played a lot when i was a child probably more a teenager this was my dad's childhood favorite game and i've still got his copy of it uh it's called dover patrol uh it's probably not a game that anyone's particularly familiar with it's not in production now um but essentially this game plays like the game stratego it predates stratego this is from gibson's games from harry gibson he created it
along with uh two other games latak which i think is gibson's do still produce an attack and aviation so we had an army game a navy game and a a playing game and then tri-tactics which includes all all three um as well and uh i've got a copy of each of those games i've managed to pick up in you know sort of off ebay and things like this that they're really really old this guy i think um we're talking from the early early sort of 1900s that these games first started to come out um but i'm not i i do really like the it's a two-player face-to-face bluffing game it's a game where you can set traps and i think that's really nice that's one thing i really enjoy in it is that you can um you know you you can bluff your opponent they think they're going to be attacking something but actually you've snuck something else in there and and so they're attacking something which they think is vulnerable but then when you reveal what tile it is that they're actually attacking what the playing piece is then uh it could be something really quite brutal and i i like that there's not many games that give me that sense of i've set a trap and my opponent has has fallen for it um but dover patrol really gives me that in spades um i've never actually played stratego but i suspect it's probably a streamlined version of dover patrol and it may even be more enjoyable but dover patrol of course is something which i love just because uh it's something which reminds me of my dad you know my dad's still around her you
know i could play dog patrol with him well i can't right now because of lockdown but you know as soon as lockdown's over if i wanted to i could go and play a game don't patrol with my dad but it is special to me because it's a family game uh you know something that's special specific to my family um and uh but but added to that quality game takes a while to play that's that's that's the downside to it can go on a little bit um you know particularly my dad's quite a slow player he likes to think about his turns so it can go on a little bit but it's totally enjoyable and engaging while it lasts number 53 on the list is the game tcal this is from the what's called the mask trilogy with mexico and cusco tikal is um a action point game one of the first games that uses action points you can spend to move your people onto the board to move them around the board to uncover temples and you want to build up these temples but you want to have the majority so you want to have more of your pieces surrounding that temple than anybody else so that when a scoring round comes about then you're going to score lots of points for those temples and for the treasures that you've gained it's from wolfgang kramer and michael keisling which is just a magical duo of designers you know anything they create just just is fantastic um uh and and i love the super meeple production you know i had all i had this entire trilogy uh in the original rio grande version um but i've replaced them all with super meeple versions because i just i just love the the three-dimensional
temples and you know all this stuff the production quality is out of this world with super meeple could not be more impressed with them number 52 on this list is sushi go which was the first game i ever came across from phil walker harding uh and sushigo is very simple uh take a card pass your hand on take a card pass your hand on now i had played seven wonders before i played sushi go and i understand that seven wonders was an inspiration for sushi go i liked seven wonders but i never quite it never connected with me hugely i always found it over complicated uh the iconography was too much constantly having to look up and think what does this card do what does that do um and you know i'm sure if you play it a lot then that all falls to the ways you know by the wayside but but i never got totally to grips with it whereas sushi go was so intuitive and easy portable it just feels right for that style of game you know it's not it doesn't come in a massive box it comes in a tiny little box um i remember taking it off to a friend was getting married and i remember sitting in the pub the night before he got married with all my other friends you know obviously the groom wasn't there but all the rest of us were there and we just played sushi go all evening while having a drink and it was really really fun these weren't gamers you know it's such a casual game and then all of them wanted to go out and buy their own copy of sushi go so it really connected with us um sushi go party of course exists the these are the from the game right editions of the game um sushi go party has far more
different types of cards that score in different ways um personally i i don't tend to opt for sushi go party because sushi go what i enjoy is the fact that i know exactly how to play it i enjoy the familiarity i enjoy how portable it is and actually i like the german version from zok verlag more than i like the game right version in terms of the artwork i've also got the original version that phil walker harding self-published um so yeah i would tend to lean towards that zok verlag german version although i know a lot of people find the artwork ugly i just find it amusing um yeah sushi go fantastic it's a great introduction to games this is a great one for children families anybody anybody can play sushi go and have a good time with it number 51 is talisman so um talisman is another one of those nostalgia things i played talisman yesterday with my wife um it feels like a nice christmassy sort of game to play just because you don't have to think playing talisman you lay it all out and you just play it and you see what happens and you've got these ridiculous stories going on so you know yesterday i was a minstrel that was my role so i was this this traveling musician i was able to charm animals and so i met an ape but i i normally have to fight the eight but because i was the minstrel i don't have to fight the ape i can charm the ape and then the eight becomes my follower and he wanders around with me and we go off and we fight dragons my this menstrualness ape meanwhile my wife is a dwarf and and it's just fluctuating between being a good dwarf and an evil dwarf it's got a unicorn
that is following around with it you know it's total nonsense you're just rolling dice your main decision is do i move left or right rolling dice in order to move can get frustrating if you're trying to get somewhere you can't get there because you can't roll the right numbers but i just love the flavor of it all the the the different cards and the different events that can happen just it's utter nonsense the whole thing um but i played this a lot when i was a kid when i was yeah about 12 talisman was you know about the best board game out there really from games workshop really wish i'd kept that original edition and the expansions that i had but i sold that many years ago um when when ebay was first a big craze you know you could make a bit of money selling off these old board games or should hang on to it but now i've got the fantasy flight version um which is uh you know lavishly illustrated big box um this isn't by by all accounts this is this is not a strategy game okay this is not a game that i would encourage you to go into if you enjoy working out your turns and playing well it's also not a game that i would suggest that you play with somebody unless you really like them okay if you're just turning up to a game night and somebody offers you a game of talisman and they're a bunch of strangers don't play it okay because you've got to like the other people if you're playing that's the only way to enjoy the game is to have fun with the stories that are being told and um you know that there's you can't get any enjoyment from the mechanisms of the game the the strategy no it's got to be played with somebody that you really get on with where you're
happy to sit around for a couple of hours and make up some good stories right so what's that done to our leaderboards well when we're looking at numbers 61 to 100 the publishers in the lead were rio grande and then zok verlag were slightly behind and then matago and then a bunch of others so let's update that looking at 51 to 100 zok verlag has now matched rio grande with five and then we've got matagot and hansen gluck taking up the rear with three games a piece in the bottom fifty of my top hundred looking at designers so previously we had ryan ignitzia phil walker harding bruno catala and andrea cephath all on two games a piece in the 40 games that we talked about now with 50 games phil walker harding and andreas sifath are ahead with randy kanitzia bruno catala klaus jurgen roder which is the designer of carcassonne and downfall of pompeii and then kramer and keisling that we've talked about a fair amount uh coming up behind in uh in with regards to themes so in the 40 games we talked about anthropomorphic animals were ahead then the ancient world then fantasy but now with fantasy has pushed ahead so fantasy is now way out in front that's because of games like talisman and uh and blitz bowl and and these sort of things um but ancient world and anthropomorphic animals coming in in second place we've got historic cities down there and exploration coming onto the list this the first time they've arrived on our charts
next up then uh so game styles so when we were talking about those first 40 area majority network building and games played under time pressure were out ahead but now area majority entire laying are pushing ahead tire laying area majority with network building and time pressure behind and stock holding and dice games behind that so there we are that is the top 50 or the bottom 50 of my top hundred games of all time we're gonna be moving into the the top half the top 50 games of all time in the next video so we'll be looking at games number 50 to 41.