Skip to main content
Loading video...

Is One Play EVER Good Enough?

Transcript 23:12

Recently, I played a beloved Euro game quite a few times in a row, and it made me think about when I first originally got that game, which I got about 8 years ago. I played it once and then kind of created some distance between myself and the game itself. And mainly because I probably didn't have quite a smooth experience the first time I played it. And so I was like, "Oh, I like the game, but maybe not enough to prioritize it uh playing that game over other games in my collection." And so I kind of had that kind of lukewarm memory in my mind for, you know, five or 6 years until I thought, you know what, that game I remember playing like 8 years ago. It's time to get off the shelf. Time to blow off the dust. Time to play it again. And oh my goodness, I loved it. I loved it so much. I was like, oh my goodness, I'm starting to see how this works. and really planted the seed in my mind about whether we do a game justice by only ever playing it once. And is playing a board game once ever enough? And that's where we're going to take it in this topic video. Hi, my name's Danny. I'm an avid modern board gamer from Australia.

Share my passion for this hobby with you, my friends, and my family. Come and join me for this journey. And don't forget to subscribe for more wholesome board game content. Today I'm asking you the question is playing a board game once really enough for you. For me yes on one hand no on the other maybe together I can find a happy medium. I want to introduce this topic by talking about the value of playing things once. playing things once. We all kind of approach a brand new game with a certain type of mentality. One where we're like, "Oo, that's a game I've heard a lot about. I just want to try." Ooh, someone's just described this game to me at a convention or a friend has said, "Hey, you should check this game out. I might give it a go." Or maybe it's a game that I've researched over many months, many years, or it's a kickstart I've waited for and it's finally arrived. I'm like, "You know what? I should play that game that I you know backed you know over a year and a half ago and so the value of one play becomes quite different depending on the contextualized situation in which you play that board game and also how you've acquired that board game. So when we play a game once, we're really essentially testing the game to see if it meets our expectations, exceeds them, or maybe is

underwhelmingly below our expectations. And so this litmus test of the experience that we think we're going to have compared to what we actually going to have is going to create this really interesting tension and internal conflict in what we believe the game is going to be. And so the value of that one play actually has a lot of weight behind it. You know, if it's a game where I've been waiting and anticipating this game for a while and you know, I play the game, I sit down, I set it up, I get the rules ready, and I invest all this time in and I play, I'm like, "Oh, this is not what I thought the game was. It's less thematic than I thought. It's more abstract than I thought. Oh, I thought this was a card game, but actually it's a, you know, dice rolling.

uh you know, take that game. That kind of reality versus perception is very very heavily weighted in that first initial play. And so when I play a game, I kind of try and hold my opinion back just a little bit, just for a little while, because you have to kind of give the game the benefit of the doubt. If you've invested so much time and money in the game, then you're probably going to want to give it a few goes. where if it's a friend's copy, you're probably like, "Oh, I'll just come along for the ride, be a passenger in the passenger seat, watch the scenery as your friend kind of like takes you through the game and go, "Oh, actually, this was kind of good." And so, the testing and the actual experience of playing a game is really a gauge for us to see whether it matches what we thought it was going to be or whether it will surprise us in ways that we didn't expect. And so this level of reality and expectation is something that kind of doesn't really match when we talk about our first play and the value behind that first play. So when you play your first game, we're ultimately gaining an initial impression of the game. We're getting a sense of whether the strategy and the themes really come through, whether the decisions that we make are ultimately going to matter. And so we kind of walk into our first game with a set of criteria. And the criteria might be, "Oh, I hope it's engaging." The criteria is, "I hope there's a lot of interaction." And so when the game doesn't really quite meet that criteria,

our level of value that's kind of added to that game is going to really pull into our emotions of whether we were satisfied with that experience or not. And so that first game is quite pivotal for forming that initial opinion about a game. And so I just really wanted to touch on a game that uh has featured on my channel quite a lot. It's kind of come sporadically here and there. It's actually on my shelf right behind me. And it's a game called uh the Grand Austria Hotel. Now, when I first heard about Grand Austria Hotel, I actually saw it through another Australian YouTuber who sadly doesn't make any more YouTube videos. I was like, "Oh my goodness, this game encapsulates everything that I want to play. I love the idea of opening a hotel, housing guests in rooms, preparing the rooms."

And so, like 8 years ago, I bought this game and I was like, I really want to play this. sat down with my hubby, played the game, and I was like, uh, this is not what I expected it to be. Uh, and if you don't know about Grand Austria Hotel, you basically roll these white dice. Dice number actually matches with different actions that you can take and based on the number of the number of dice that are under each of the actions will determine the magnitude of that action that you decide to take. It might be, you know, how preparing different rooms or, you know, making a particular staff member cheaper to play or gaining money or going up on the emperor track. And so when I played Grand Austria Hotel, I was like, "Oh, I only get two actions per turn in a round. Oh, and these actions are really, really constrained. How do I really get my guests into their rooms and, you know, kind of complete this satisfying puzzle?" And so that first experience for me was very lukewarm. I was like, uh, this is not what I thought it was.

And so this was the sort of game that I played and then I just left it on my shelf, moved it around my collection for about 5 years. And, you know, I had this very distant memory of playing it and not really liking and then my hubby probably smashing me at it cuz he kind of already puzzled it out. And it was only until like a, you know, 2 or 3 years ago when I started playing it again. And even like last couple weeks, I started playing it again to try and complete cuz it's on my 10x10 challenge. I was like, click, click, click. Oh my goodness, the game started to speak to me. All of a sudden, I could see how everything really connected together. All of a sudden, I realized, oh my goodness, the abilities and the bonuses you get on those customer cards are going to synergize with also how the staff actions are going to work and the puzzle of trying to map out your like little hotel and all the different colored rooms and if you complete a particular section, you get like, you know, money or moving up the emperor track or victory points. All of it just kind of fell into place. And this is like playing the game like seven, eight times across eight years. Once, you know, when I first got it and lots more recently. And that's just when the puzzle, the picture just came together.

And I'm like, "Oh my goodness, if I just dismissed this game on its initial play, I may not have enjoyed what I enjoy about it now." And so if it's not your type of game, sometimes a game or first gameplay experience may change your mind and make you think, "Hang on a minute. Actually, I do like this sort of game. Hang on a minute. I never really considered that Tapestry might be a really fun point salad and not just purely a theme about, you know, starting your own civilization." It really changed my opinion about that very first and single play. So, I really want to kind of now evaluate the pros and cons of basing an impression on a single play. I'm going to start with what I think is really beneficial and then head on to the flip side. As you can see, I'm wearing my white shirt, so you can see I'm more the angelic side of uh my brain right now. But so, some of the pros of putting a lot of value on that single play is to test whether the game matches your taste in board gaming. If you don't like dungeon crawling stories and you play a game that's got a lot of narrative text around it, you're going to be bored out of your brain and you probably are not going to want to spend another 3 hours playing that game. Or if you're a g gamer who likes story, but the game is completely devoid of theme or uh cultural immersion, then you're probably not going to want to spend that valuable time that you have on that game. And so that one play will kind of

allow you to decide which way you're going to lean and whether the game will match your taste. And so some people might play a game and immediately decide, you know what, this game is not for me. I don't like trivia games. I don't like dexterity games. This definitely is not going to be in my wheelhouse. And then there are some players who kind of like sitting on the fence and they're like, "Oh, you know what? I'm not really sure if I like this kind of classic Euro. I might give a couple of I might give it a go and go okay at the end of this oh actually I can just see that I may like other games like this. So it can be useful for being a litmus test into other games of the same genre. Also, the pros of just playing once and giving that initial impression is if you've enjoyed other games by the same designer and the same publisher, then that impression is already backgrounded by a lot of contextual experience with that design and publishers other games. So, for example, the Lookout or Zman series of games, I know that I'm really going to like uh already based on the box cover and the weird quirky uh old style art. I just know that those are the games that are going to be in my wheelhouse. And so, by having that experience of a Stefan Fel game or Uve Rosenbo game, I'm going to be probably more positively impressed by a game and understand where the design elements come from. Now, if you play um a brand new designer game for the first time, you're probably not going to have that contextual

information. So, you're probably going to want to try and think about, oh, why did this designer go down this route and include this mechanic in the game? And so, you're probably going to be a little bit more investigative with your approach. Another thing that I uh find that a pro is if you're playing a friend's copy of a game, you're probably going to have a lot less unbiased opinion about that game because you didn't buy it. you didn't invest money in or time into it. You're like, "Oh, here I am. I'm along for the ride. Seat belt me in. Where are we going? Take me on a journey." And then your your experience and your expectations are probably going to be a little bit different on that regard. When you play a game once, you're almost deciding whether that game is going to be worth more time. If you play it once and you think, "Ooh, I really like this aspect, but don't like that aspect," you might decide, "You know what? I'm not going to play this game again because I just see that there are other games in my collection that already do the same thing. Give me the same value. Or you might be like, "Oh, that's a new mechanic. Didn't really see that used anywhere else. I really want to give it another go." And so that first play and that value bar in that first play is going to give you and help you make that decision a little bit more informatively. Also, if you're someone who collects a lot of games, sometimes time is a factor. And so, you know, if you've got a lot of games that are unplayed, you might go, "Oh, I'll just play this game once. I'll get back to it in the next 2 weeks, 3 weeks, 4 years, 5

years, 8 years." And so, sometimes playing a game once is just going to satisfy that initial craving uh whilst giving you that intention to always return to that game whenever you decide to return to it. Now, there are certain games where I will only give it one play and one play and that is it. And there are certain situations where I'm like, you know what? I don't think this game deserves my extra time, extra effort, extra life uh investment and energy into it when I already have so many other games I really could enjoy. And so often if a game on my first play I can see there are a lot of flaws or a lot of uh things that don't really sit right with me, I'm probably not going to waste any more time on a game that feels painful to set up, play, and plow through. And so, you know, my time is important to me just like your time is important to you.

And so if I don't want to give another the game another chance, I feel justified in saying that you know what, this game is a waste of my time. This game is not a good fit. It might be a good game, but it's not a good fit for me. And so I will know pretty much off the bat that that game is not going to uh last in my collection. If a game feels torturous, uh you know, a game may be really good, but the rule book may be scattered all over the place. There may be a lot of reading that you have to do and checking and the ease of access to the information that you need to just get through one round of the game. If that is torturous in itself, I'm sorry. I'm just going to put the game rule book away and say I don't think I can spend time and mental energy on this game.

Like I think you know when a game is published there's a lot of play testing, proofreading that goes into it. And so if I know a game feels hard to get into or is hard to read in terms of the rules, I will probably put it aside. Also, if I can see that there's no more fun value extracted from the game experience, I'm probably done with the game. Now, there's a lot of games out there like the Exit games that I absolutely love, uh, which is basically a oneanddone experience or games like Perspectives where the cases are singular and you play them once and then you just repackage it to pass it on. You know, those games obviously you can only play once. Obviously, they're designed for a single play experience. But if there's a game where in the first game you've explored all the avenues or all the strategies or the choices don't really make an impact on the overall outcome of the game or you can see that they're not going to make an impact, then that's probably a game that I'm only going to play once. Now, there is a game that I really want to try um and I only want to try once. And it's not because it's the designer or the game's design itself. It's because the game is so large. So, the game is Civolution. I love Stefenfeld games. Yet, Civolution is probably one game of his that's probably about three steps too far in terms of weight, length of play, time to get it to the table, time to set up, time to teach. That time factor is

really going to say to me, you know what, I might only have one day in my life to give this game the full energy that it needs in order to play. And then after that I may never play it again. After that I may decide, you know what, I will give it another go. I don't know. But just the thought of playing such a long game that has such a lot of rules is probably going to deter me from considering even a second play. And so whilst the game might be amazing, the fact that I have to get through all those mental hurdles first to just get to the game to get it to the table, to get someone else to play it with me is going to be big enough in itself. And so I do kind of have like a lovehate relationship with some board games like a Gricula. You know, the first time I played, I absolutely did not like it. I really found it overwhelming. I really found there were too many things I had to get my head around. Also, I don't know if I'm keen with like a cartoon version of the designer's face appearing in my rule books. It kind of takes me away from the theme of the game. I get, you know, Uve Rosenberg is a really great designer. He's got a, you know, a huge like catalog of games under his belt. But, I don't know, just something about it just really takes me away from the theme. But apart from that, you know, I just found the game itself really tight, really hard to get through, really hard. It was a bit of a struggle for me and you know I I've put it in the sale pile. I've then not put it in the sale pile. I've moved it back

and forth and now it's back on my shelf because I've felt this you know personal surge to try and play classic games again. You know I might really enjoy it again. Maybe it's like another Grand Austria Hotel. I really found that maybe my mindset was not in the right place before but now it's in a different place where I'm there to really be ready to appreciate these sorts of games. Often when I don't give a game another chance, it sometimes comes out of guilt and regret that, you know, I bought this game, I played this game, maybe, you know, I don't really want to sell yet. So, I just kind of keep it for keepsakes and just so it's there. I've spent money and time buying the game, I might as well just keep it. And so, I look at it every day going to the kitchen. I'm like, "Agricula, I feel a sense of guilt about you. I'll get to you next weekend." Oh, a gricula. Maybe one day I'll change my mind about you. So, there are lots of reasons why we don't give a game another chance. And there are some games that kind of sit on the borderline like a Gria where I'm like, you know what? Everyone says this is a good game.

Everyone says it's a really popular game. Everyone says, you know, it's one of his bests. And yet, I haven't really even decided in my head if I'm going to give it a second play. And so that's the conflict that I go through when I decide which game I'm going to pick off my shelf. You know, maybe I just play another Stephen Feld game. Sorry, Uve. Rosenberg. And then on the flip side, giving a game more than one chance, I think, is actually super important. And you know, repeated plays only really reveals to you the true enjoyment, the true nature, and the true design of a game. Maybe that first play that you played through didn't allow you to see some of the connections that you needed to make early in the earlier stages of the game until the later stages of the game and how it impacts the later stages of the game and your success in the later stages of the game. Maybe that first play, the randomness of the tiles or the combo of the card draw just really didn't play into the game's favor and so that left kind of like a sour taste in your mouth. And so I do think that with certain games, if they're easy to get to the table, they're medium weight for me, I like to play it multiple times, I want to increase my enjoyment of the game, I want to be familiar with the mechanics and appreciate there, especially if there's a learning curve involved. Once I can get over that learning curve, my third, fourth, and fifth player might go, actually, I do like this game. Oh my goodness, I didn't see that this connection goes with this and this strategy kind of influences you to go down this pathway. And so through more

plays, you tend to do get a clearer picture of a game's design. And I guess the analogy I like to use for this is when you read a novel, the first time you read it, you're just decoding the words, you're deciphering the language, you're just trying to guess, figure out what's going on. But it's not until you read the same novel second, third, or fourth time, or you watch that favorite movie, Home Alone, I'm talking about you. If you've watched that movie like a bazillion times, you almost compare it word for word what's going to happen. You can see where the characters make their flaws and their mistakes. And all of a sudden becomes this like infused enjoyment in the game. You just know like the steps of the game, the way the game's going to roll, and you're like, "Oh, I can see what I'm going to have to do here in order to negate this issue.

If I want to get that goal, I need to set this up." So the pieces and the pillars in the game become a lot clearer when you become more familiar with the game. And so the game can really surprise you sometimes on a second or third play when you're like, "Oh, this game is actually making sense now. This game actually is like, oh my goodness, I see how it works. I really like what it's doing." And so there are a lot of games that tend to do that. And a lot of games from initial appearance, you're like, "Why do people, you know, like Brues? Why do people like castles of Burgundy?" But it's not until you play the game and really get into the meat of the game and give the game a chance, some life. It's like planting a seed. You pour water, you nurture it, and then you're like, "Ooh, this plant is actually growing." You're like, "Oh my gosh, this game is actually worthy of a spot in my collection." And so the game can become more fun over time. And so sometimes that first initial value that we place on our initial play can be a barrier into further enjoyment of the game. And so having a better understanding of the game will increase the fun factor and will allow us to engage cognitively with the game and its intention for the experience that it was designed to have for us. So what are your thoughts and opinions on playing a board game once?

Does your opinion change whether you own the game and purchased it with your own money compared to when you play a friend's copy? I'd love to know what your thoughts and opinions are. Please share them in the comment section below. Now, if you found this video super helpful, please consider liking, subscribing to my channel. Also, if you really want to help this channel grow, please make sure you head over to my Patreon page and buy me a coffee a month. I would truly appreciate it. This is basically my hobby, my passion, my love. So, any sort of support would truly be appreciated. Uh, other than that, if you want to check out some more of my amazing YouTube board game content, then please head over to my main page. There are hundreds of other board game videos on there to check out after this one. Otherwise, this is Danny Sunia. I'll see you again for another board game sanctuary video in the near future. Goodbye.

Progress saved