Top 100 Board Games of All Time! (2022 Edition) - 40-31
Transcript
foreign hi everyone I'm Luke Hector and this is the broken meeple a show devoted to board games where I always get my honest opinion even though the rest of the world might not like it so firstly before I continue let me just say I'm sorry I'm sorry please forgive me
I blatantly overworked myself through September I had a ton of pre-esson deadlines to get reviewed about two or three separate launch campaign Kickstarter and game founds to get sorted it was insane fun but insane and so I had to put a back foot on certain things and snowdonia tripped in help with time and everything but I had to say look you know what the top 100 just had to wait a little bit so that's why you've been seeing like a video a day for me lately and it's just not been the top 100 which I know you've been waiting for and I am sorry sorry sorry sorry but oh well as I record this on the Sunday the 25th of September I am now up to date everything I need to get done pre-essing is now recorded and ready to be uploaded if it hasn't already and so I can now finally get back to the top 100.
so my 40 to 31 long overdue yes we are getting into the real creme de La Creme of the games I absolutely adore a few droppers on this section not that many risers actually although we do have two new games and I think you're gonna be a very surprised in fact over one of them in particular although well though it depends how much you've been checking out my content so oh no let's just get on with it finally my number 40 has dropped 11 places mainly because it's now got stiff competition from a lot of other games that use this same Dixit card mechanic now I also play the smaller version of this more than the big version although the big one is still on my shelf in the other room or is it downstairs I forget I forget where I put liberaludes games I think are downstairs but this is still one of my favorite co-ops that there is it's still such good fun to bring out it goes over well with pretty much everybody that is mysterium so mysterium brought in this whole concept of combining clue with the Dixit cards the idea being that you gotta find out the person the location and the weapon for a murder mystery except the person who died is communicating with you in Silence with the Dixit cards and you've got to figure out through those cards which ones belong to you out of all the cards on display it's such a good idea it's unreal I mean this is such a cool unique Innovative idea but it plays really well granted the big version does take a bit more setup and I'm not a fan of those Clairvoyance tokens that's the weak link of the game but you can now
get the tiny little um mysterium Park version which I've done a review on which is basically a two to six player very quick version of mysterium where you only play Two Rounds effectively it's all based around a circus and it's condensed in a nice little box honestly pick one do you want the portable quick version or do you want the big grandiose one with the DM screen and everything honestly it doesn't matter to me but mysterium is still great fun so yes it's dropped 11 places big whoop I still enjoy getting it out I always take Mysterion part to most nights I go to because it is just that portable and as much as I like obscurio and Dixit and a few of the other ones I think I've already mentioned on this top 100 mysterium is still one of the best ones that use this Dixit car mechanic but is it the best my number 39 would have been on last year's list had I played it before I'd actually got it recorded yes this one kind of just missed the cut in terms of timing when I recorded my list and when I got it played it was also a bit of a slow burn for me because at first I thought this is pretty good but it's not going to be my favorite of the Year by a bit but then when I came to do my retrospective 2021 List It shot up quite considerably because this game has just been getting a lot of plays it's going over well with everybody I shove it in front of I like playing it solo two three four player whatever and it's just really good it deserved every bit of the Spiel the Yaris win that they got this year and that is Cascadia Cascadia this lovely Gateway game where you are
building a a Park full of tiles and different terrain types you're trying to get the terrain to match but it's not essential what you're more interested in is the animals you've got five different animals that essentially have their own scoring mechanic and as you take a tile you have to take it with an animal token you gotta place it in your Park you can't just leave it that you can't like put it aside and bring about later and so you're trying to create the setup so that you can score the animals in the best way while also keeping your terrain together in big groups so that you can score points for them ahead of everybody else it is so simple you can teach this in about five minutes the solo mode great little challenge modes that you can do with different restrictions and that you can build it out in less than 30 minutes it's just such a good Gateway game that deserved the award I mean let's face it it was full gun conclusion did anybody think that Cascadia was not going to win against those other two yeah right I mean as soon as they got nominated I bet old Iraq was literally in their like meeting room back at their back at their HQ or somebody literally breaking out the champagne like woohoo this game is brilliant I take it to a lot of conventions I've told it to my parents I've told it to friends hell even gamer friends I have who mostly play Heavy Euros enjoy this game that's saying something it deserves every bit of credit it's got you know and granted it's not one that I would sort of go right I've played it and now I want to play it again and again and again I usually play it one week and then I'll bring it back the next week but it's still really enjoyable it just you know could it use maybe maybe it could be a
little bit faster at four players but honestly I still play it for it's not that big a deal Cascadia has jumped onto the top 100 and is solid and is gonna stay foreign has jumped a whole place one whole place which means it is fantastic and amazing and should be at my number one no although a certain component should be at my number one I really want to get that component out um can I go get them please pretty please no biscuit can I go get the oh come on please can you give me a break fine I'll do it without them yeah my number 38 is Seasons seasons is a fantastic like card game with a little bit of drafting at the start to get your initial set of cards and what you do is that you're effectively doing a three year magic tournament so for each year you get this new set of cards out of the ones you drafted you are gathering manner by Rolling these gorgeous big chunky dice in order to get the manner that you need but as the timer goes it changes weather it changes season as the name so when you go into different seasons different manner is harder to get hold of and easier to get hold of than others and it's just a cool timer mechanic but then you get the fun of playing cards and generating a bit of an engine and doing cool combos while trying to get victory points it's just it's very straightforward to play but trying to get those combos and trying to think of the best way to do those cars particularly in that first draft is Paramount and really cool throw in the two expansions and I honestly don't care
about the mechanical stuff that they throw in the whole thing of like oh starting powers and effects and that Moon die I don't really care just throw in the extra cards though bundle it all together and you've got this massive Deck full of cool stuff that you can grab of magic artifacts and familiar Little Creatures it's great love this game prefer it with less players rather than the most but still I would play on board game arena with four players and I'll play it in person I wish I had a solo mode but frankly you know what I'm fine because I'll bring it out as often as I can Reza karna wishes it could mimic what this one was because rezakane is dull and tedious and boring in comparison to what season is I'm sorry season's the one I prefer not res Arcana and I'm sure that's going to get comments but uh I really want those dies this cake you're mean but you know I go do Lally over those dice big chunky Boulders that you throw on a regular basis one of my probably my favorite dice that existed any game ever they're just that fun and cool to throw but I'm gonna tailor myself I'll go play with them later anyway my 38 seasons foreign has dropped 16 places from 21. yeah this actually used to I think to be in my top 10 probably my number five I'm trying to remember how high it was it was quite high but it has not been getting played a lot outside of the app for quite some time it is a big game it's hard to teach I kind of find myself just wanting to play this with people who know the game and that does hinder progress you know
as much as I really enjoy the game being having that hurdle is a problem now this comes from an era when Jamie stonemar and stonemeyer games used to put out great games okay seriously lately I've not been a fan of the games they brought out but in the past they brought out some of my favorite games of all time and this one Scythe is no exception Scythe is just such a cool big Euro engine builder game you know taking control of a different faction with these cool Little Mix doing resource Gathering and engine building like a typical Europe occasionally getting into a little scrapple fight with the mechs you've got encounter cards to add a little bit of like story narrative every now and again providing you you know get immersed in it the different factions behave very differently it looks gorgeous especially as I've pimped mine out or get out with like prefer pawns and metal coins and stuff it's beautiful when you get it on the table and the cover says it all with the mechs in the background and the farmers in the front the expansions have kind of bloated it a bit which is not helpful I mean honestly I'd rather you know I don't even need the wind gambling you certainly don't need most of fenbris granted some of the stuff that fenbrush throws in is really cool you know some of the variable setup outs but it's out of the regions of anybody who's played the game for the first time and that's the thing I really want to play Scythe with people who know what they're doing and not have to go through the long teach because there is quite a lot you've got to teach people there's no easy way to teach Scythe outside of pay them a Fiverr give them the app and tell them to go play it like in their own
time and then come back at least that would be a lot easier work for root why can't it work for Scythe but still really enjoy the game it's just dropped a bit like I say it's not hitting the table as much and that makes a difference so 36 safe sorry that was my 37 Scythe my 36 has dropped 11 places from 25. this is a euro game which under all normal circumstances I should be hating at this game this is like one of my biggest exceptions to the norm of games I tend to play and tend to put my stock behind like say this is the game you need to play now it's not for everybody people can bounce off this one pretty hard it is bone dry there is pretty much no theme in it whatsoever it is essentially dice placement which we've seen a lot of times and it's a point salad through and through so Luke why do you like this game I think it's just because of the amount of options that you have and how smooth and relatively streamlined it is and that is Pulsar 2849 by check game additions what this one I shouldn't like but I adore this game it I think the options in the streamlining is like I mentioned are the two key points because there's no like oh the die needs to be at least this number so it can go here no no what's pictured a free then it needs a free flat out no problems the turns straight forward you do a little bit of a like selecting of the dice and that manipulates your turn order and how many engineering cubes whatever you get
at the end it's like I say it's dry as a bone but then you just simply use your two dice two actions you might get a third bonus action and you're done and the actions are pretty straightforward in terms of how they operate but you've got so many options I mean do I go fly around the universe and explore planets do I go you know do space walks and get points that way do I go set up the the spinning gyrodynes or whatever they're called you know in order to collect points from poisars do I level up with all the texts in the world do I go get transmitters do I just concentrate on the end three goals that you get oh boy there's a lot of options in this game but they all work you know yes there may be some setups where one is probably going to be better than others but then you'll have more competition but there's usually a good way to win through pretty much most of the strategies in the game and I just love the Technologies you've got all the different setups for Technologies multiple a b c and d boards so it's going to be different every time you play it but then you going oh I could really use that Tech this round that'd be cool but then I need to die for it well let's see that means I need to take a six but if I take a six that means my turn order is gonna suck I'm gonna have to go last oh I don't know but I really need that six so I'll take that six it's like all the decisions feel like juicing the agonizing but in a fun way it's just it's kind of weird I don't know how to explain it that well I just played this game for okay I'm gonna go in with an open mind maybe I'll like it but I didn't have high expectations when I played it and then I played it and it's like can we play again yeah that's a good sign of equality Euro game
I guess I'm just more into Point salads but Point salads I mean yes there's no theme in this really but it is space space Beach Renaissance or Florence or whatever other useless like themes they've done for Point salads and most beige Euro games at least space is a bit more interesting it looks colorful on the table so I suppose it's got that going for it but I guess it's just the fact that it does feel streamlined and it doesn't feel too punishing yes you could get blocked out of a space or someone could take what you need or you have that ah I want to take that die but this is going to hurt but it's self-inflicted punishment in that regard it's not that the game punches you in the face and expects you to just deal with it like some other point salads can this one just feels perfectly balanced for a Midway points at it I love it a bit I don't know why not fully but I love it Pulsar 2849 my35 has dropped nine places so this is a lcg and I like a lot of lcgs in the past I mean it has to be said this one is kind of relatively steady I mean dropping nine places at this point is not a massive deal I think mainly it's just getting a bit too bloated for its own good and yet we've got another set with the X-Men turning up any day now if not already and that is Marvel Champions Marvel Champions is you know my preferred game of Marvel you know in a sense it's an lcg where you take a Marvel hero up to four players you go up
against a main villain it's essentially what another certain Hero game does in a similar way except this time you have to deck builds rather than getting your own deck yeah I don't want to spoil too much but the cool thing with this is that it is Marvel themed so I get to play all my favorite characters and go up against my favorite villains from Marvel I can play with the various Spider-Man people against the Sinister Six you know I I can send Captain America against Kang uh actually I did Captain America and Hawkeye versus Kane that was a really good one two-handed I tend to play true solo I should really get the hang of doing two-handed because it is quite cool having the uh the balance of one fighter one not fighter when you play true solo you gotta try and do everything at once and it's not easy but it's just a really solid lcg as I said probably a little bloated they keep coming out with more stuff a little bit too frequently for its own good and at the moment there's so much content for it I don't think I've even played every single hero that's been released for it yeah there are still some I know like Adam Warlock and Scarlet witch that I know I've not played yet it's just there's a lot of content and only so much time so maybe I need to stop but then I do like the X-Men X-Men would be quite cool you know that it's too much it's that Temptation that always gets me but I really enjoy the game it's got the great system of like do I go into hero mode do I go into Alter Ego mode you gotta flip between the two some more than others depending on your hero if anything sucks it's probably the campaigns dude you're embarrassing me in front of the Wizards I I they've never been particularly good there's not much of a story narrative and they're just too difficult I think so honestly when you get a campaign box just say screw
the campaign check that stuff out split the scenarios into five and just have fun playing against the individual villains I think that's probably what I'm gonna do with X-Men frankly and I'll probably enjoy a lot more for it but yeah Marvel Champions are still going strong it's just dropped a little bit probably because of the blokeness but I still enjoy bringing this one out especially when a new pack comes out so yeah still going strong have you ever tried shawarma my34 has climbed a hole three places whatever it's steady it's still kind of hanging out where it probably should stay around now maybe it'll drop a little bit in the future because it hasn't been played for a while but this is a two-player only game small two-player game from Emperor S4 that I've really sung the Praises about over time it's a great unique two-player game it doesn't feel like any other card game I've ever played and I've shown it to people at dice events and various teachings and most of the time when I've shown it at an event if they had it in stock they'd gone and bought it so where's my royalties but this one uh it's somewhere around here here we go yep honey me Koji and I mean this one specifically geisha's road which came after it is really good game but it's not accessible to Gateway Gamers and certainly not accessible to anybody who's not a gamer actually there's quite a little bit going on but this one whether G shares Academy I don't know pick one do you want to talk about geishers or Scholars that's essentially the only difference but this one looks gorgeous and it's just a really good solid fun card game where you're vying
for influence over the geishers using the cards for the items that they've got but you have four actions each one being kind of like a ice split you choose mechanism or I discard some out of the game or I'd keep one secret and you have to do these four actions each player but when you do them is Paramount if you do it early you got more choice but you got less information about who's winning over which Geisha but then if you do it later you have less choice but you have more information it is a balance which is impossible to get right you will constantly regret the order that you did those four actions in because there's no technical right answer but you know obviously you're right right I need to know this I need to know this I'm going to play this but I'm going to Bluff this one out you make those decisions but yeah you try and find the optimal combination of stuff because you're going to regret it but I really love this game it's just so solid again two-player games are hard to get to the table but I make an effort to teach this one when I go to dice events where we're teaching new players board games because it seems to just go down so well between couples that I've taught it too more so than a lot of other two-player games that I've had but if somebody wants to play this with me as a kind of filler while we're waiting for stuff at a convention and by all means bring out Hannah mckoji because it is that solid I'd say pick your poison Hannah mccojo G sure Academy same game different art different person that you're influencing it's still really solid my 33 has dropped 10 places not a massive drop again doesn't hit the table as much because it's a big Euro and I
think it's just had to make room for some other games because I still really love this game this is my favorite vitaliser game yes spoiler alert there are no more the third games that are going to appear on this top 100 this is the last one this one was constantly fighting the gallerist through Supremacy for a while mainly because it was in the original Stronghold version which had some limitations then Eagle Griffin started their whole line of deluxifying every game in existence and they finally brought out the deluxe version of kanban thus kanban EV and kanban EV has now taken the top spot for my Lucerne games because it retains everything I loved about the original and fixes the problems that the original had which mostly related to art graphic design and ease of play here this one now has a better rule book it has a bigger board deluxify with Inno tools artwork where you can see clearly where stuff is yes it's still a little fiddly in some areas it's very tricky trying to explain how you know tested cars work on your board and how the upgrades work that's still a little fiddly but trying to do the meetings at the end works a lot better and yet it still retains that classic game of taking you know control of your job as a car manufacturer you know you're an employee making cars and you're getting the blueprints you've got to get the parts you got to go assemble the cars and then you've got to go test them get upgrades all the while dodging Sandra Sandra evil Sandra here come the test results you are a horrible person
that's what it says a horrible person we weren't even testing for that oh yeah one of the most annoying characters in board games because she is constantly going through all the Departments marking you down because you have to play her in me mode because playing your nice mode is I think they're a little too nice and also very unrealistic come on we've all had a mean boss or somebody who's marking you down you want me and Sandra so it's like every time you see her coming by it's like or you might want to hit the books and start getting up to the technical level so that she looks at somebody else rather than you it's just oozing with theme this game it is one of the most dramatic the sort of games that I think there is possibly the most thematic laserder game I love it I love I I get immersed in it every time because I like the idea of making cars and being that sort of employee it just that theme just jails with me but it's improved looks it's fantastic components it is heavy it is hard to get to the table which hurts it a little bit because you know I've got to teach a lot of it although it has been played too or three times at my local Portsmouth Club recently I've just been busy doing other things if they bring it out again I'd quite like to jump back into it very soon you know it is one of those great Euro games but yeah used to be neck and neck with the gallerist now it's like sorry kanban takes it that theme just wins me over at kanban Evie it's now back where it belongs my number 32 it's a new game this is the second of the two new games on this list
and I bet you weren't seeing this coming this is a small filler game and yes fillers can be high on my top 100 as well you know it's not just gotta be about big grandiose games small fillers that get played often that give me a lot of pleasure when I play them and tick all the boxes for what a good filler should be deserve to be high on this list and this could even go higher I'm enjoying this more and more every time I play it I don't think I've ever done a formal review of it except maybe I did on my podcast I don't know but this is easily a nine if not a 10 out of 10 game in fact I think it is a 10 out of 10 game for me because the only thing I can vote in it is the solo mode and frankly I don't really care because I tend to bring this out multiplayer anyway this is pencil first games best game in my opinion the riferous I don't think any of this expected him to say that peripherals is the next step up from herbaceous which I also have downstairs on with sunset over water these is a beat like these are in a line of games are just Pleasant Zen like they're kind of ah nice but this one as much as herbaceous is a cool game it's very light like float away light you know I'm teaching it to new people and I'm just like yeah whatever it's mostly luck but fluoriferous is a bit different this is you've got Columns of these beautiful looking flowers I think he's pretty quiet Bud the card art in this is Sublime Instagram is wet dream and so what you're doing is that you're collecting the various flower cards how do you score for them but that's up to you you have Columns of the cards along with a point scoring card at the bottom
your counter is before the column are done in turn order from top to bottom and you pick one of those cards the problem is for the next column after that the turn order is now based on the relative position of all those markers again so if you go for one of the early ones you won't necessarily get a flower you want but you'll get to go first for the next column but I want that scoring card that gives me three points for every B symbol I have on my cards problem is if I do that I'm now last for that column which means I'm not likely to get that poppy flower I really wanted that decision is in your mind every single term and yet the turns are nice and simple this is a 30 minute filler it keeps to the time frame even with the teach 30 minutes and you're done three rounds done screw up but you've got great variety with the different points scoring opportunities you've got the end of round objectives you've got the the grabbing the little stones to get that little tea scone at the end you know that quirky little thing that they like to throw in as extra points it's and even just then you know it it's such a cool lovely little filler Pleasant beautiful quick simple great components it takes every single box for a quality filler which is why it's gotta be high on this list I put it in my bag pretty much every time I go to a game night if it can fit it goes in there as my go-to filler game in fact if I take a look do I have oh it could be one of my favorite fillers if we're talking like group filler I don't know we'll have to see but they're definitely up there as one of my top favorite fillers in fact did I put it on
my top 10 filler games list I don't know we'll have to see but ah really enjoying this uh you know it makes me want to play more of pencil versus stuff I mean there's a couple I've not played like the was it the what if what not cabinet or whatever it's called and uh oh what was the it was another one that came after this uh delicious or debate something beginning with d but you know this one is just such a quality filler these games deserve to be high in the top 100 if they are played often and beloved and this one is forever first and dropping seven places to wrap this one up with my 31 from 24 is one of my favorite deck builders but there is quite a lot of deck builders I like so that's not to say this will be the last but this one was a big Hidden Gem like I did not see this coming I didn't know of its existence until I went to a convention and so I was like man that's interesting that looks quite pretty oh it's a deck builder Queen games okay at some point I'll play it fast forward about a year or two and I actually get around to seeing a copy of it shown to me and I play it and I go why the hell didn't I play this before yes runestones runestones is brilliant it's a great little light deck builder with a unique way of playing it and yet it never got any Buzz because Queen doesn't know how to advertise its games for toffee and I'm the one who has to sing the praises to this game I'm the one doing most of the advertising for Queen and it's but it it's so cool I've pinned up with all the expansions
I've got an insert actually no I checked away the insert it wasn't very good but you know I I have got everything I need for that game it's the idea with it is that you are just basically getting victory points which is nothing special you're collecting different color gems you trade them in for these artifacts which then get you Rune Stones which get your points and you're trying to reach a certain point go that in itself does not sound interesting I admit here's the two quirks the runestones give you a special power that you have for the rest of the game and you can get up to four of these so if you trade in big sets of artifacts you'll get a lot of points but not many Powers but if you trade them in really quickly the first chance you get you're not going to score many points for them but then you'll have four really cool special powers that can Propel you for the rest of the game that in itself is great especially as I've got about 18 different powers that I can pick from and you only get a few of them each round or each game even great variety but I love the way the card system is done I mean firstly nice little Quirk it's double-sided on the card which means that if you're left-handed the right-handed you can still play the game that's a nice little thought and nice addition there Queen but certainly my left-handed friend is appreciative but the cool thing with this is that you play two cards at a time so you can use um they're multi-use in the same so you can use the Mana at the top to recruit more cards or you can play the two cards that you're gonna play resolve both their abilities in any order but then they're numbered the higher number is trashed out of your deck whereas the smaller one is retaining a discard pile so your deck self cleans as you play
cards so it keeps you constantly wanting to get more cards without giving you the bloated Decks that you can run into another deck building games it's such a cool mechanic and it's Unique no other game does this I don't know any other deck builder that does it like correct me if I'm wrong cause I want to try it but as far as I'm aware that's unique to runestones and I love you know me something that is new and Innovative certainly hooks me in a bit more but the game is fun it can go a bit long with four player players I admit especially if people try to AP it too much are some of the Rune Stones a little bit on the imbalanced side maybe but you can always take him out I've got 18 little things do I really care if one or two of them are a bit imbalanced I just get a kick out of it looks beautiful simple to teach simple to play and yet it's just a really cool deck builder a Hidden Gem one that I never saw coming at all until I was finally shown it and I'm glad that I was because as soon as I as soon as it was shown to me cha-ching Shut Up And Take My Money my 31 Rune stones oh there we go happy now yes I got another section of the top 100 done and I'm gonna try and do more of them before I go to Western but at least we're finally back on track looking at my uh what have we got there my 30 through the 21 and even the 10 after that we've got no more new games there are no more new games until I get to the top 10. so these next 20 you've seen before the question is have they risen have they Fallen if they remained
steady and in what order are they now these are games that oh I cannot wait to talk about some of these Beauties the I mean the games on this section of the 10 already got me giddy because they're so good I mean these are 10 out of 10 games for me these are games I love and that's just my 40 to 31 so they're my top 30. oh baby I love these games you know they just get better and better from here but you know I better stop jabbering and get on with the rest of my evening yeah I'm not recording another video tonight I've already done several today as it is but uh like I say thank you for being patient with this thank you for waiting I'm sorry it took so long for me to get another segment of this done but it'll be worth it trust me because you're gonna hear about some Quality quality games so that's all for me I'm Luke Hector and you've been watching the top 100 on the broken meeple so if you like what you see please thumb up the video share it on social media consider subscribing to the channel or even the patreon if you want to help me out with review copies but mostly I'd like to hear your comments down below I have just talked about 10 games I adore and I want to know your thoughts do you like these games do you hate these games either or I want to know your opinions because it's always fun to read them and get into discussions until next time you can check out the rest of my top 100 which I'm sure you've probably watched about 10 times over yeah I Wish by now just because you've waited so long for this one but why don't you check out some of my other content as well like my pre preview I did for the tainted Grail expansion like Standalone campaign that's coming out very shortly so take care and remember as always no matter how late I am to the party it's still
only a game bye for now