Top 5 Board Game Themes
Transcript
hello everyone and welcome back to the board gaming doctor my name is Phil and I'll be your board game doctor today in this video I'm going to talk about a topic that I've been thinking about recently and those are my favorite themes in board games at this moment and here the way that I'm going to approach this is through the board game category section on Board Game Geek you can get to here if you go to browse and you go to categories here now I thought this was the best way to kind of conglomerate a lot of the most common themes into one uh overarching I guess description because there are you know thousands of different themes and uh different settings that board games explore especially if you if you take in account all the games that we have up to date but in this categorization it may or may not be outdated but I feel like they do a pretty good job at once again conglomerating a lot of those different themes into a certain category such as uh by mechanisms such as like bluffing or card games using dice Etc but there are also themes here like you know the American Civil War for example and so I went off of these to choose my top five favorite themes that not only I enjoy in games that I play now but also themes that may catch my eye when I'm looking at new board games to try of course I'm looking at board games from different theme or from different mechanisms rather and how they play and what kind of you know
mechanisms they use for gameplay I think that is important for me for sure but after playing so many board games and you know I I have you know come into this uh this hobby relatively uh more recently than perhaps many of you so it may be even more true for you but for me like I feel like all the games that I'm looking at now whether I play them or whether I view them or demo them a lot of the mechanisms start to blend with each other and the only thing that really separates games aside from a few you know mechanically unique approaches or combinations of mechanisms is really the theme like you can choose a a certain theme or a certain mechanism like work replacement and then have like your definitive uh music game that is involved with worker placement Etc um or vice versa as well and so I I feel like I'm at the point where theme really matters to me if I want to put myself in a setting in a board game and have a relatively good understanding of how to play the game then I think what would Elevate me or elevate my opinion of the game is the theme that it's set in as well as how well those mechanisms integrate with the theme so in any case uh and of course A lot of these themes that are near and dear to me come from a nostalgic background in gaming that I've had outside of board games usually in the video game and PC format and so I'm going to highlight some of those highlight some of my favorite games that
are included in some of these favorite themes and we'll go and start from the top so before I get into my official list I do want to talk about an honorable mention because I did consider this game it's pretty close to my number five and that is the Environmental list or categorization of theme to me this includes games like arcn NOA and life of the Amazonia where you're technically in like life of the Amazonia uh creating a habitat that you are trying to help conserve the uh forestation and animals that are included there in in that environment that you're building on your Tau as well as arcn NOA where it is about cons conservation and uh doing that through uh Zoo management essentially and so environmental games I you know there are other games that I could throw on here such as Cascadia for example that are more nature fed I suppose or involve the like the grandiosity of Nature and it's a really cozy theme I I don't want to say that I particularly you know go for games that include animals or or things like that plants for example but anything that does involve a more naturalistic theme I think is something that I'm you know genuinely interested in but there are so many of those games out there that span the range of complexity as well that it's hard to keep track of and really hone in my interest and the time allotted to me to really discover and look into games to to really kind of grasp what is going on in that particular in this particular
theme so for that reason I am putting this at number six I do really enjoy the theme and games obviously I I love both of these games that I've listed here on the page but there are and and so there are so many other games that I would would love to include on this list as well but I just don't um I I guess there aren there are just so many games in this list that it's hard for me to keep track of and so that's why it's at my number six so my number five theme is going to be medical and the medical or medicine theme is near and dear to me of course because of my profession I am in the medical field as a physician and so it you know of course draws me in or intrigues me if a game does feature a medical component to it I put this as at number five one because there's not a lot of choices to choose from that are you know of my top favorite game I of course include pandemic here most of the top games that are medical related are related to pandemic in one way or the other whether it's a legacy game or an expansion or spin-off Etc and for me pandemic is nostalgic because it is one of the first games quote unquote modern board games that I played as a teenager that really got me thinking about board games and being interested in them at the very least until I you know many years later really dove further into the hobby the pandemic introduced you know new Concepts that modern games have such
as a Cooperative game you know up until then I don't think I I had ever really played a Cooperative game and of course pandemic did a lot to make that genre of gaming really shine you know in the mid 2000s but in addition to that I really uh I never knew that games could have expansions to them and so pandemic introduced that concept to me that you could expand PA games like you would uh DLC with video games you know currently or in the past you know if you had uh you know Hardware to to put into your N64 or something like that you could do that as well but anyway so pandemic is is the flagship game for me when it comes to uh modern board gaming as well as the medical themed board game of course I was not in the medical field at that point in time but it still sticks with me and I think about it when I am at work sometimes and in addition to that you know there are a lot of medical games that are out there some of the ones that stood out to me that I've personally enjoyed uh were healthy heart hospital that I played recently um missina 1347 is categorized as a medical game as well these are some of my favorite games that I uh enjoy to play now but are Medical in in theme but not to not to miss out and I do include games like dice Hospital clinic Etc and I I really spoke a lot about this in my episode and review of healthy heart hospital but a lot of medical related
games offer the point of view of either uh Hospital management or Administration and when you do get down to the treatment level a lot of it is quote unquote order fulfillment or utilizing resources in a way to uh fulfill a patient's needs and I go into more detail about how I feel like that is a a gameplay abstraction of what happens in real life which is appropriate for games but may not reflect wholly what does happen in real life in the medical field at least from the point of view from a physician but in any case I do hope that more games in the medical field continue to come out because there aren't a lot you know there's only about 400 almost 500 games out of the thousands of games that are listed in Board Game Geek that are tagged with the medical categorization and so one you know it be nice to see more games come out in this regard but two uh it'll be really cool to see games approach medicine from a slightly different point of view maybe in a more realistic way uh to capture what it is like to treat patients as a physician for example or to run a certain you know portion of the hospital whether it's the lab or or what have you maybe that will come out at some point in the future but until that happens I my eye is still on the lookout for what the board game Space regarding medicine will look like and that is why it's at my fifth spot so
my fourth favorite theme would be citybuilding and this hearkens back to a time where I would love to play games like Sim City and like railroad Tycoon Etc that featured a lot of these games where you are building out a city planning out where certain tiles or you know certain aspects of the city were and managing things in an economic way and I feel like city building is translated to that in board games in a way that I enjoy where there is often a lot of chances for interaction either with other players or usually building out your own Tableau and having something appear you know and and be the the labor that you have uh like the fruits of your labor at the end of the game basically that you get to see and from researching this topic as well you know I I feel like City building does Branch out to much more than what you would Envision a game like Sim City is where you are building a modern city so games like that I mean I consider tiny towns as a good example of that and like underwater cities is kind of a like a Sci-Fi spin on that citybuilding thought as well Lisboa you have those more historic themes where you where the setting is a certain town or a certain city in the world whether it's modern or ancient and you are doing your things there so I take into account some of the older cities or older games that take place in a a time frame in a city that is older so like Lisboa would fit but in
addition to that games like glass road is considered a city Builder because you are developing a certain area you are placing out tiles onto a board in this case a tableau to uh create not not just like a a city where people are living in but kind of a community and so you could expand potenti the the theme of city building into more community building and that encompasses a lot of different games there are games like or at labora and laav that account for this as well uh according to Board Game Geek and kais is another game that came to mind as well that I really enjoyed but it is a really broad category and I often don't think of city building as including some of these more Community type experiences where you are laying down tiles uh on a board or whether it's shared or in front of you and kind of creating the synerg the synergies that you're hoping to get for abilities and points as well a lot of these games feature mechanisms uh I guess you could call it a mechanism but more of a component uh not requirement but a feature where these games have a lot of individualized tiles or characters or cards or what have you that create a lot of different combinations and synergies that you get through repetitious play and so I really enjoy that aspect that is often found in some of these is more community/ citybuilding games and I think that is why I am usually intrigued when a new citybuilding game is announced next my number three theme is
going to be industry or manufacturing as it is listed in Board Game Geek this is a really broad topic and theme once again because it covers a lot of ground say in history as a time frame as well as the topic at hand I've seen games like terraforming Mars is an industrial game uh I think a lot of these games could be linked towards another categorization which is I think more mechanical in nature which is economy or economical where a lot of the decisions in these games are driven around the resource of money and how you have it's not broken down into finite pieces of like wood or sheep or what have you to pay for certain things in the game it's all conglomerated in the form of money and so it is up to you to divide your money in a way that makes it as most efficient as possible to take your actions turn by turn in the game and so a lot of these games I feel uh as you are not only talking about industry but you're like the head of management of a certain industry usually in this time frame which I really enjoy which is like the Industrial Revolution I think is my preferred era of like industry and so games like brass of course and the whole system of games that comes from that including Birmingham is a great example of just that that gritty nature of you know making ends meet in you know the early portion where technology or portion of
time where technology is starting to boom and you're you're mixing you know the uh the uh old world with with the new age of how things are done in the world right and so it's just that that nature of like exploration is just really fascinating to me and so I really enjoy games like brass I ano 1800 as well is really fun um I mean even games like which aren't listed officially I feel like in industry but like uh Yokohama news fured as well by Rosenberg kind of fit this bill as well barrage of course the list goes on and on because a lot of these top games are set in in this time period I should say a lot of these top Martin Wallace games right are set in this time period and in this setting and theme and so I think as a whole because of the nature of using money as your main resource and uh the way that you take actions with you know and pay for them I think it allows for a lot of thought that comes with you know efficiency and making sure that you have enough money to do everything that you want to do and thus the really tight decisions on how you use your money and grow your income to get more money to do better actions as the game progresses is something that is highly skilled uh or at least skill worthy and able to be more competitive and um you know it's it's not as straightforward as it might seem and so there's a lot of strategy
behind a lot of these games uh particularly in the weight class that I have chosen here to represent this theme and so yeah I really enjoy the the challenge that comes from you know having a lot of different options available to you because of money uh I mean you can throw Arc NOA as another example of this where a lot of the currency is based off of how many credits you have um and and so how you allocate those credits throughout the game is how you gauge how efficient you were and how many points ultimately you score in the game and so yeah lots of skill involved lots of uh opportunity and potential for repetitious play and a high skill ceiling as well make this theme kind of fit in that bill because I I feel like that represents what it was like to be the head of management or running a certain business type in this time you know this time period in our history you had to be very you know shrewd with your money and and Frugal and look for efficiencies here and there and so while that does sound like a headache in real life it's nice to kind of experience that in a more abstracted way in a couple of hours on a table and so that is ultimately why I really enjoy industrial games and look for those when new ones come out so my number two theme is farming so this might be a shock to some of you because um for me you know what I try to promote on this channel is Uber Rosenberg who is the Lyn pin of farming games I I suppose in the board game
sphere but here just hear me out so I'll I'll start with why I enjoy farming I've talked a lot about this in the past episodes of the podcast and the channel uh farming games were something that was just very cozy and very welcoming to me growing up I played a lot of games like Harvest Moon of course Animal Crossing is kind of in that similar vein but uh a lot of people play stardo Valley for example you know in today's day and age but these games are and were something that I love to come back to just something really cozy and uh I guess relaxing uh when it came to this theme as you you know just tend to your farm make improvements here and there Etc right and so it was just a fantastic uh experience that I had growing up and something that I feel like defined what I was looking for in games as I was searching them out uh about 5 years ago and that's when I stumbled upon Agricola I thought hey this looks like a game that reminds me of Harvest Moon of course it was not as easy as a game such as that but a gria really opened my eyes to what board gaming can be like and so the theme of it is I I feel like very thematic and that's part of the reason why I really enjoy farming games and of course Rosenberg games I think he does this very well is the Thematic integration of farming with mechanisms and how you play the game I love the the fact that you can plant crops and gain
extra resources back because that's how it works in real life right you put you know a couple animals together and lo and behold you have more animals than next ring Etc right and so there a lot of different reasons why I there are you know thematic Integrations that I really enjoy in games from Rosenberg such as agrica a feast for Odin is technically a farming game as well uh I believe it is listed as an industrial game too but I think I'll put it as more of a farming game it's kind of its own thing I think more of a Viking game right you also have other games in rosenberg's line that are not pictured here such as fields of ARA and a lot of the other games that I've mentioned before caverna of course being the sequel to CA but you have a lot of non- Rosenberg games that are really good such as viticulture for example that capture the essence of what farming and agriculture represent and so yeah it's just a really cozy thing even though these games may not be cozy they're very time intensive and thinky and require a lot of thought and repetitious play but at the same time if I'm for example playing these games solo and I come down and put on some relaxing farming sounds or farming music right uh it's just a a really good space to be in personally for me it's a good mental space to be in and so I always even though if a game is really competitive and you know I'm having a really I guess you know I'm just sweating it out you know trying to figure out the best moves and be as efficient as possible farming games for me just really uh put me at
least in the back of my mind in a head space that I feel calm and relaxed and that's something that I try to pursue as I'm you know exploring this Hobby and participating in this hobby it's something that I can have fun with and relax and I think that's why uh farming games are really exciting and sought after for me now why is it not my number one theme even though Rosenberg has a lot of these games that I really enjoy outside of Rosenberg I feel like the farming theme can really vary as far as the complexity goes and the rules the rules complexity and strategic weight of games are very varied and so games I feel like in the farming theme are often more light uh to to uh to sum up lighter than what I'm hoping to get out of a good game that I feel like I would return to many times uh more along the lines of say like Bonanza or you know some of those of course there are really complex games that are farming themed but uh I feel like I've at least known about or have played most of those I haven't gotten to them yet all of them yet but for the most part I think the farming theme is usually on the lighter side when it comes to rules complexity than I would prefer and so you know I'm always excited for a more crunchy experience but often times those are going to be another Rosenberg game that offers a farming type of theme so that is why farming is my number two so I believe my favorite theme in all of board gaming is
civilization so this stems back to what I grew up playing the most I think I dedicated the most hours I think to Age of Empires that was Age of Empires 2 particularly that was my game on the PC growing up on that old Windows 95 and what I like about those games is the one the sense of growth that the game provides where you start off say in a you know the ancient times you know the Stone Age or something like that where you have very little and you're taking baby steps to making and progressing up the second thing which I really enjoy is like technology tracks right and really differentiating yourself along a certain way or like with asymmetric cultures or factions to allow for a push in a certain direction to really uh create an identity of what your civilization or culture is and so back to the first point you know you start out small but then by the end of the game you've expanded so far you know in in the land that you're allotted you've created uh a lot of different Technologies you've progressed through time as well and you you are able to do so much on your turns and and the third thing that I love about these games there is a lot of a you know interaction there's an element of interaction whether that is through military or through the competition of culture or what have you through points and you know there are different ways that you can represent this but I love the um
abstraction of of civilization mechanically through a lot of these means where you are uh growing from a small culture to an epic you know civilization but and and two you know there's a lot of interaction but three you know it does tell the story it often tries to to tell the story of our Humanity our history and so I love coming into a board game and learning more and and playing as a certain you know ancient civilization that I learned about in school you know it's it's fun to uh remember some of those times I think one of my favorite subjects in school was history aside from like science and stuff but um I I really enjoyed my history class and learning about um our own history world history as well and so I think that is just something that I love to look at in board games and I I will say that it one you know it as you could see it does uh constitute a lot of the games that I enjoy in general Through the Ages uh age of Civilization by Jeffrey CCH including his new game Epoch Mosaic right A lot of these games that I've talked about on the channel our civilization and themed Clash of cultures that I've done recently as well is another one tapestry you know you throw out all of these really you know fun games that may or may not be as close to thematic integration as you might hope for but do have the backdrop
at the very least of you know a Civ building game and so that's something that I love to be in the head space of for the the reasons mentioned before but even just looking at this year like I'm looking at the games that I'm most interested in in Gen Con I did my video on maybe some of the sleeper hits that I believe J con would provide so I didn't really get to talk about some of the games that I'm most interested in a lot of those games are going to be coming out in Essen so I'll address those then but a lot of these games such as Beyond the Horizon uh I think it's called alte civilation by Stefan Feld a lot of these games and if you recall from from the past couple of years as well as I've done this channel I I just feel like a lot of the games that I've been most interested in have some sort of civilization theme to it uh it does not have to be about our history it could be about any civilization progressing so you think of games like revive and teram mystica even Gaia project with a more SCI type of theme to it also are represented in in this theme and and just in the sense of how games progress thematically and mechanically through the growth of your civilization or culture it's just really fascinating to me and I think it's my number one because of how interested I am in games that I'm previewing and looking at further in the in the Horizon right in the future uh they're most like games
that are civilization themed and so to me that's why it beat out farming uh despite the Rosenberg um you know adoration that I have for his games I feel like when I am thinking about other games outside of that sphere of what I consider my my preferred games most preferred games if I'm just looking out at the general populace of games that are offered I think I am more inclined to look at Civilization games first so so there you go those are my top five favorite themes in board games let me know what your favorite theme in games is and uh or themes are and I'd love to you know continue this chat in in you know the YouTube comments wherever you would like to reach out on Board Game Geek as well thank you for all the positive support and the feedback and uh everything is appreciated and it's just an added bonus to be able to communicate with those who genu genuinely want to listen to what I have to say say so thanks for Consulting with me today and hope you have a great day and I'll catch you on the next one take care