My Top Board Games of 2025! - Sommelier Suggestions with Alex!
Transcript
According to my notes, I had 433 plays of 234 unique board games this year with over 150 of them being games that I played for the first time. There were some duds and there were some bangers, but most importantly, there were a ton of really diverse games for all different kinds of people, which made my job of finding you your perfect board game a breeze. But you're not here to hear about every game. You're here to hear about the best ones. So, if you want to know my top somo suggestions for the best board games of 2025, then might I suggest
Hi, I'm Alex from Mighty Suggested Game, a channel devoted to helping you find your perfect board game. Today, like I mentioned before, we're going to be talking about the best board games of this year and announcing the winners of the incredibly prestigious and highly coveted Suggested Awards. They're saying it's like the Oscars of board games, but uh I'll let you be the judge. Anyways, if you haven't seen one of my top games videos before, I like to do things a little bit differently. Basically, I've got seven different award categories that I use to rank my games every year. First is the top table hoger award, which are the games that I played the most this year. Then it's the top game off the back of the shelf award, which helps me highlight older games that no one's talking about, but that are still so good. Then I've got a new category for this year called the top game junior award, aka the best games to play with kids since, you know, I have kids now. Next is the top underrated gem award, where I talk about more obscure and hard to find games that you should be seeking out. Then is the top second date game award, which is all about games that I played once, I really enjoyed, but that I haven't had a chance to get back to the table again yet. Then after that is the top new game in the collection award, which features games that I like so much that I kept them, which as a board game content creator who gets a lot of games every year, that's really saying something. And lastly, of course, is the one, the only, it's the top overall game of 2025 award. Now that you know the categories, I'd love to hear what you'd be dominating this year. Let me know your picks in the comments. And while you're down there, don't forget to hit subscribe and that little bell button so you can get notified when I post new content. Anyways, let's get into it. Will one of my favorite games of the year be the perfect game for you?
Let's find out, shall we? All right, our first award of the night is the top table hoger award. And this one is all about games that I played a ton this year. And that's kind of saying something because I don't get to play games multiple times very often. So, if it made it on this list, then it must be good. Anyways, here are this year's nominees. The first game is Oath from Leader Games. It's a really fun and immersive game full of history and conquest that tells the story of the rise and fall of empires in that classic Kyle Faren art style. The next one is Clank Legacy 2: Acquisitions Incorporated: Darkest Magic from Direwolf Games. This one's a legacy style campaign game that injects boundless excitement into the already thrilling Clank deck building universe.
Next is Can't Stop, a Sid Saxon dice chucking classic that is so easy yet so compelling that anyone can get it to the table. And lastly is a surprise nomination. It's unpublished prototype. That's right, folks. A lot of my table time this year has been taken up by play testing for a game that was designed by yours truly. And now, for the first time, I can officially reveal that my game is being published by the wonderful folks at Gamehead and will be debuting in the summer of 2026. So, keep an eye out for Yes. And, a cooperative storytelling party game that uses abstract images and the building blocks of improv to tell a one-of-a-kind story that you'll never forget. Stay tuned for more info. But enough about me. Let's see who the winner of the top table hoger award is. And the winner is Clank Legacy 2: Acquisitions Incorporated: Darkest Magic. Now, that's a mouthful. Now, this game was kind of a revelation for me. I'm pretty new to campaign style games, and I've made it a goal of mine to try to complete one each year, and Clank Legacy 2 was the one that me and my game group settled on this year, and I'm so glad that we did.
In Clank Legacy 2, you've got all the trappings of the original Clank. your deck building. You are buying cards for the market. You are trying to grab treasures and get out before the bad guys get you. But it adds some really interesting elements and persistent elements throughout the campaign that just made it so much fun and had me coming back every week hoping that we'll get a chance to play again. One of my favorite things about this game is that some of the sessions are competitive and some of them are cooperative. So, you would go back and forth between vying for points with all the other players to trying to complete a singular objective and all having to work together to do that. I love a good cooperative game, but I also love a good competition every once in a while, so I thought this was the perfect balance of the two, and it got me excited every week to see which one we'd be doing. The story line of this one was fantastic. I never got a chance to play the original, but from what I've heard, it adds even more excitement and intrigue than the first one. And for me, I loved trying to complete all of the little side quests, finding all my little dialogue options, and trying to earn achievements for the back of my playerbook. Overall, Clank Legacy 2 was an amazing experience. I would highly recommend it to anyone who's looking for a campaign game to play with their game group that will take multiple sessions, will build on itself, but will never be too much that it's going to make your brain explode.
So, if you want a game that you can get together with your friends and play over multiple sessions, if you want a game that's going to be exciting, that's going to take one of the best deck building systems out there and add elements to it that are intriguing, that are exciting, that add tension at every turn, or if you're just looking for a fun story to tell and a new way to experience one of the best deck building franchises out there, then might I suggest Clank Legacy 2: Acquisitions Incorporated: Darkest Magic. Boom. Suggested.
Next up is the top game off the back of the shelf award, which is one of my favorites to give out because it gives me an opportunity to give some flowers to some games that haven't been talked about in a while. And it also gives me incentive to brush the dust off and get those things off the back of my shelf in the first place, which is hard enough to do on its own. So having this little kick in the pants is always a good idea. I hope this category inspires you to play some of your older titles in your collection, because let's be honest, you got them for a reason in the first place. So, why not play them? Anyways, I'll get off my soap box. Let's get into the nominees. This year's nominees for the top game off the back of the shelf are Rumble Nation, a 2017 game from Yogi Shinichi that just got an English reprint and is one of the best uses of dice manipulation and area control out there. Next is Crusaders Thy Will Be Done, a 2018 game by Seth Jaffy that's snappy, exciting, and that might have my favorite rondell system of any game ever. Next is Grand Austria Hotel, a 2015 title from Lookout Games that has the perfect balance of moving parts and dice mitigation to really give your brain a good scratch. And lastly is Castles of Burgundy, a 2018 Stefenfeld Classic that pairs long-term strategy with short-term tactics to make a wonderful game that never overstays its welcome. And the winner of the top game off the Back of the Shelf award goes to Grand Austria Hotel. And Grand Austria Hotel, what an amazing game. I'm a little bit nostalgic for this game because this is actually one of the first Euros that I experienced when I was first getting into the hobby and I fell in love with it then and I played
it again this year and it totally holds up. In Grand Austria Hotel, you're going to be running a hotel alla Grand Budapest Hotel and you're going to have to use the dice that are rolled at the beginning of the round to feed the guests that are in your cafe to place them into rooms in your hotel and to make sure that you don't overbook your rooms so that you can get the right combination to score the most points and win the game. Oh, and don't forget the emperor is showing up at your hotel at various intervals throughout the game, and so you need to make sure that you curry enough favor with him so that he doesn't give you a bad Google review. This game has just the right amount of moving parts in my opinion to really benefit people that can think a few turns ahead, but to also reward you for preparing for contrarian plays throughout the game. At the beginning of the round, a bunch of dice are rolled, and that will really determine what actions you can take this round and how well you can take that action. So, you always have to be willing to shift your plans one way or another in order to get what you want. There are some really interesting and almost broken powers that you can get with your house staff that I think are really fun to play around with. And when you can get that perfect combo to get your engine rolling and really feel like you're moving in the game, it just feels so good. The only thing I will say about Grand Austria Hotel is that I think it could do with a little visual refresh, if you know what I mean. The artist uh definitely has a more classic board game style, but I feel like people would really get into this game if it had a more accessible visual appeal. Think about if this game looked like a Wes Anderson film. I'd buy it right away. I mean, I already have it, but I'd buy it for my friends right away. So, anyways, if you haven't played this game, you should definitely try to get it to the table. It is fantastic, even though it
looks kind of funky. So, if you're looking for a wonderful, surprisingly thematic and strategic game about running a hotel, feeding your guests cake and strudel and wine and coffee and all the good stuff, then really just getting this streamlined Eurogame experience without having to move any trains or boats or invade any nations or anything like that, then might I suggest Grand Austria Hotel. Boom. Suggested. All right, the next award is the top game junior award, which is a new one this year. I figured since I started playing games with my kids and they started having opinions about them. I wonder where they got that from, I should include some of their suggestions as well. Now, my youngest Luna just turned two, so she's still opening the games just to play with the pieces. But my son, Samson, who's almost five, has been really enjoying getting into the strategy of games. And I've been really trying to foster the idea that games should always be fun. something that I think is really easy to forget. So, all the nominees in this category are hand selected by him, which I think is pretty cool. Anyways, the nominees for the Top Game Jr. Award are Castle Panic, a cooperative classic from Fireside Games that has everyone sharing cards and thinking ahead to protect their castle from the impending orcs, trolls, and goblins. Next is Micro Macro Kids: Crazy City Park, a new title from Hashet Games that takes the Where's Waldo fun of the original Micro Macro series and makes it specifically familyfriendly. Next is Magical Athlete from CMYK Games. A super simple roll and move that's so crazy and
chaotic and fun that you'll never play Candyland again. And lastly is Stitch the Fix for 626 from Zman Games. A brand new take on Love Letter with an adorable IP that adds in some new mechanics for the whole family to enjoy. And the winner of the Top Game Jr. Award goes to Magical Athlete. Wow, Magical Athlete. Where do I even start? This game has been a hit since day one with my family and especially with my son Samson. If you haven't played Magical Athlete, what are you even doing? I mean, to be fair, it's been pretty hard to find at your local game store. But Magical Athlete is a crazy take on a roll and move game where all you do on your turn is roll your dieice and move your character. But here's the twist. All of the characters in the game have these extremely broken powers that are constantly activating through the game and messing with each other's plans. Some of the characters trip other players. Some of them warp other players to a different spot. Some of them even score points for being in last. Every power in the game is broken, which means that none of them are broken. And it's really the combination of these powers and how they interact during the round that makes each race so unpredictable and so much fun. All you have to do in the game is try to score the most points by finishing races or by picking up points by landing on specific spaces on the board. And the concept of the game is so simple that my son was hooked right away. And he's played it so much at this point that he could probably rattle off every single power for every single racer in the game. And that's a lot of racers. This game technically plays up to six players, but you can also play it in teams if you have a bigger group. It also has this really fun two or three player mode that allows you to have multiple racers that
adds in an entirely different level of strategy, especially when it comes to picking your racers for each round. I love the chaos of this game. It really feels like anyone can win and there's always those moments at the table where people are cheering or jeering depending on what's happening. And any game that can really manufacture those moments of fun, I think is an absolute win in my book. So, if you're looking for a game that's competitive, but doesn't take itself too seriously, that's perfect for a family get together, or even just a quick game night for two, and that has endless combinations that'll make every single time you play it super fun, then might I suggest Magical Athlete. Boom. Suggested. All right, next up is my top underrated gem award. And this category is all about highlighting games that I think more people need to know about. As a board game content creator, I end up getting a chance to play all kinds of different games, whether that's prototypes or early Kickstarter copies or even just games from smaller publishers. And this is my opportunity to talk about games that kind of flew under the radar this year that I think are definitely worth checking out.
Anyways, here are the nominees this year for the top underrated gem award. The first is Up or Down from Capstone Games. A really clever card game where you'll be collecting different floors for your elevators that have to all go in either ascending or descending order. It plays Graded 2. It travels well and it packs a big punch in a small box. Next is The Emerald Flame from Post Curious, an incredibly immersive escape room style puzzle game that's full of mystery, intrigue, and clues that'll have you scratching your head till the very end. Next is Botswana, a Rhiner Canitia classic card game all about strategy, timing, and manipulating the value of different safari animals, which just got a reprint recently. And lastly is Here Lies from DVC Games, a cooperative murder mystery solving game about asking the right questions and revealing the right evidence to uncover the culprits behind the many strange and diverse cases. And the award for the top underrated gem goes to the Emerald Flame. The Emerald Flame was an amazing experience that I was lucky to have this year. Me and my partner just absolutely adored this game. Even from the very start, the Post Curious folks have you opening different envelopes and engaging with clues in a way that I had never seen before in an escape room. All of the pieces of this one, whether it was the really tactile puzzle elements in the game, or even just the backstory of all the things going on and why you're doing the puzzles you're doing, was incredibly well thought out. And it really made you feel like you were participating in this story alongside everything that was going on. This game was chalk full of ciphers and different puzzles that you had to solve, different
things that you had to put together, and it really flexed our puzzle solving muscles in ways that we had never done before. My family and I are huge escape room folks, and this one really feels like you had an escape room in a box. One thing that I really loved about The Emerald Flame was that not all of the puzzles were linear, which means that you didn't have to solve one at a time in order to progress in the story. This was great because my wife and I played this one together. And so, she would be working on a puzzle while I'm working on a different one. And then, you know, if we get stuck, we would swap and just see if we can come up with something new. And I thought it was a wonderful experience for that where you get that element of parallel play while still feeling like you're progressing towards the end. Every time we would open up a new envelope in this game, we would see all kinds of stuff that kind of just blew our minds. And there was so much content in this game that it kept us going for several sessions and really made us feel like we got the bang for our buck. Now, just like many other escape room games, this one technically is a one-time playthrough. But like I said before, there's so much content in the game that you don't even really feel like you need to play it again because man, it was just such an unforgettable experience from start to finish that I was just excited to reset it and give it to another friend so that they can experience it for themselves. All in all, The Emerald Flame was an amazing experience. I can't wait for the next installment of the Puzzle Tale series called Emerald Echo to come out and become available to all of you because I got a little sneak peek at that one and that one is just as good, if not better.
And for all of you mystery solving people, folks that like to be detectives, etc., etc., this one is a no-brainer. So, if you're looking for that cozy mystery night experience where you can snuggle up with a glass of wine and just solve some puzzles and really flex your brain without having to get off the couch, then might I suggest The Emerald Flame. Boom. Suggested. All right. Next up is the top second date game award, which like I mentioned before goes to games that I've played once, really enjoyed, but haven't had a chance to get back to the table. These games made quite the first impression, and I'm definitely taking these games on a second date in 2026. Mark my words. Anyways, the nominees for the top second date game are Kinfire Council from Incredible Dream Studios, a loosely semi-ooperative worker placement game about trying to protect your city and do good by its people while still outsmarting your fellow counselors. Next is Leviathan Wilds from Moon Crowd games. A wonderfully modular cooperative game about working together to tame these giant beasts, each with different strengths, weaknesses, and win conditions that make your experience different every time. Next is Andromeda's Edge from Cardboard Alchemy.
A massive sci-fi space epic with an exciting dose of strategy, a clever combat system, and a production quality to die for. And lastly is Tag Team from Scorpion Masque, a 1v one autobattling card game that takes the classic game of war and bumps it up a notch with clever deck building strategies and endless character synergies that make each game totally different. And the winner of the top second date game award goes to Kinfire Council. Oh man, Kinfire Council is so good. I got a chance to play this game as a prototype before it came to Kickstarter. And I was already really intrigued by the fact that we play as a council that has to work together to protect the city, but also wants to do that better than all the other counselors. And now having played the finished version of the game, I can confidently say this one is getting to the table again. In Kinfire Council, you play as a counselor of this city who is involved in the politics and the democracy of the city, but also has to deal with the threats that are attacking both inside and outside of the city.
There are cultists in your city that are trying to infiltrate your infrastructure, and there are monsters and different calamities outside the city that can cause chaos within your city as well. Now, if you choose to leave those be and not do anything about them, things will get overrun pretty quickly. But if you focus too much on them, then you might be missing out on a lot of different points and resources that are available inside the city, whether that's with politics or fulfilling city needs or other spheres of influence. I love a good worker placement game and this one adds just a little bit of extra customization that allows each of your workers to be trained in different skills so that each character can have a crew that's asymmetric and that works towards their specific objectives. I love this game at a small player count and a bigger player count. It gives you lots of different options to play around with. And when you get to the higher player counts, you really have to discuss with the other players about who's taking care of the different threats, or else things might go haywire pretty quickly. The core mechanics of the game are actually quite simple, but the decisions that you have to make every turn have a lot of tension to them, especially when you have more players and less workers to put on the board. I think this game is great. I can't wait to play it again and to play it with the expansion as well. And I know this one's going to be a hit for me. I just need to play it a little bit more. So, if you're looking for a really clever take on a worker placement game that has wonderful art, amazing production, and that forces you to kind of have to work together, even though you have to take care of your own personal objectives as well, then might I suggest Kinfire Council. Boom.
Suggested. All right, the second to last award is the top new game in the collection award. And this one is a very special category because honestly, at this point in my board gaming journey, I'm really not taking in that many new games every year. Even though I'm pretty good at culling, I still feel like I add less and less games every year because honestly, there are less and less games that strike my fancy and that I feel like are worth having in my collection. At this point, I'm really only adding games that are doing something new or that are filling a void that I don't already have or that do something better than a game that I already own. And so, the list every year gets tighter and tighter. But this year, I had several games that I picked up that I loved and that I think will be staying in my collection for quite some time. So anyways, the nominees for the top new game in the collection award are Number Wang from Odd Candy Games, a wacky trick-Ting game for four players only, where you have to share your hand with everyone at the table before the round starts and make bids that'll earn you points or just cause a bit of chaos.
Next is Magical Athlete, again from CMK Games. You know, that really crazy rolling move that keeps selling out at all my local stores. After that is Trinket Trove from Game Head, an adorable little set collection game that pairs a really clever bidding and auction system with the unbeatable art from Sandra Tang for a top-notch experience all around. And lastly is Pokémon Splendor, an import that I brought home from Korea that takes the Splender system and adds in the evolution mechanic of the Pokémon series to breathe life into a classic, albeit mostly themeless game. And the award for the top new game in the collection goes to Trinket Trove. Trinket Trove is so good for so many reasons. First of all, it's compact. It'll fit in pretty much any bag that you have, and you can take it with you wherever you go. Second of all, it's got amazing artwork, which means that people, both gamers and non-gamers, are going to be really excited to play this one. And third, not only does it look good, but it also plays good as well. The auction and bidding system in this game is so simple, but so smart that it makes you feel like, man, why didn't I come up with that? Basically, the concept of the game is you are these adorable woodland creatures who are collecting these shiny objects. And each round, there's going to be a draft of these different objects. Now, you'll have to take some objects that you already have in your collection and use them to bid to determine the order in which you get to select these new objects. So, if there's something out there that you really want, you're going to have to give up a lot to make sure that you get to go first and select that thing that you need. It's a constant battle of trying to determine the relative value of the different objects in your hand. Some of them will score a bunch of points if you get a large collection of them. Some of
them will score points and then stop scoring points if you get too many of them. Each object scores a little bit differently and if you can use the auction system to your advantage, then you'll come out on top in this one. I also love the natural and intuitive implications of the draft in this game. If you bid the highest and get to draft first in this round, that means that you have to put down your bid first in the next round, which means that you're very likely to get over bid by other players in the following round. So, you always have to be deciding, do I really need those things out there or am I willing to save some of the lower value things in my hand so that I can get a better position in bidding in the next round. The puzzle itself is just so fun. It's really tactical because it really depends on the objects that come out in the draft every round. And it is such a satisfying feeling when you can perfectly predict what other players are going to bid. Anyways, I could go on and on about this game, but I am so thankful to have this one in my collection because I just feel it's going to get to the table a ton. It already has gotten to the table a bunch and I can't wait to play it more in 2026. So, if you're looking for an amazingly clever card game that really packs a punch in such a small box, that has mechanics that'll get gamers excited and artwork that'll get non-gamers excited, then might I suggest Trinket Trove. Boom. Suggested.
All right, it's finally here. The category you've all been waiting for. It's the top overall game of 2025 award. Now, the nominees in this category are actually kind of spread out. There were lighter games that really led to some amazing experiences. There were heavier games that really got my brain thinking, but overall, this category is just about the best of the best. So, let's get into the nominees. The nominees for the top overall game of 2025 award are Hot Streak from CMY Came, a crazy and chaotic betting game where you'll be trying to rig a wild mascot race in your favor, all while yelling things like do a dangle or get him gobbler at the top of your lungs. Next is Clank Legacy 2: Acquisitions Incorporated: Darkest Magic, which as we discussed earlier is a legacy experience that I think everyone should have. Next is Vantage from Stonem Games, a choose your own adventure openw world game that's full of locations to explore, artifacts to collect, and stories to tell, all at your own pace. And lastly is No Loose Ends from Game Head, an extremely clever trick-taking game from Taiki Shinszawa, where you play as master criminals, bidding evidence from your hand, and then trying to win tricks to cover up said evidence and commit the perfect crime. And the winner of the top overall game of 2025 award is Vantage. Now, Vantage might be my most controversial pick for top game yet. And I say that because Vantage is not really a board gamer's game. Let me put it this way. If you are the type of board gamer that loves to win, that needs to have a quest, that needs to have a win condition and all that stuff, then Vantage might not be the game for you,
and that's okay. But for someone like me that loves an open-ended story, that loves to explore a world and to get lost in its lore, who loves to be invested in the stories that are being told around the table, this game is far and away the best game that I played this year. For those of you that haven't gotten your hands on a copy of Vantage, this game is an open world storytelling game where your crew crash lands on a planet and you get separated and you have to walk around the planet and just interact with stuff. You can explore different locations. You can interact with the different sentients that live on the planet. You can go swimming, you can build a house, you can reconstruct your rocket, you can do hundreds and hundreds of different things. And while there technically is an objective that you can complete pretty much at any time, if you're like me, you kind of just get lost in the world and you just want to keep walking around and see what you can discover. Every single time I played this game, I left the table thinking, man, when is the next time I can play that game? It is just so immersive and the storytelling in it is so rich and the universe itself is just so vast. It just blew my mind that someone could create something this big within a box of this size. I mean, it honestly has a video games worth of content in it. And I feel like I could play this a hundred times and see something new every time.
The main concept of the game is really simple. You just have to pick one of the interactions on the location that you're at and then do some sort of dice check with it. It really feels like an RPG light, and there's not really any tension throughout the game on whether or not you're going to complete that objective or not, which I think some people might dislike, but I thought was fine. You know, frankly, not being punished for trying new things and doing stuff that you might not necessarily be good at. I think is actually quite fun and leads to an experience where you're able to do more of the stuff that's fun and less of the stuff that's not. The mechanics are fine and they don't get in the way of the storytelling, which I think is really important in a game like this because the one thing that can get in the way of a storytelling adventure like this is being bogged down by rules and making sure am I doing the mechanics of this game correctly, etc., etc. Every time I play this game, something crazy will happen. Like, someone's battling this giant beast over here. Someone's reconstructing a spaceship over here.
Someone's over here getting into a relationship with a sentient. I don't even know what's going on. But I am so invested in everything that everybody is doing that hours past like minutes when I play this one. Now, I have heard some feedback from a lot of different people that maybe this wasn't their type of game or maybe, you know, they played it with four players and didn't like how long they had to wait in between their turns. And I get that. It's definitely one of those games that you kind of have to wait your turn to do the stuff that you want to do. And if the thing that you're doing on your turn isn't that exciting, like you're just moving to the next space, that can feel kind of bad. But I will say I got a chance to play it at two-player. And I've also heard that the solo mode is really good. But at two-player, we were able to accomplish so much more just because we're going back and forth and interacting with things much more frequently than you would in a four or five player game. Now, when I played it at a higher player count, it definitely felt more like an RPG session because there's not really anything that you can do in between turns. You're listening to what other people are doing, and if that sounds interesting to you, then you're going to like this one. But if you are somebody who wants to have their strategy planned out one thing at a time, and wants to do these things and are going to be disappointed if the thing that you want to do isn't as cool as you thought it was going to be, then you'll have to take this one with a grain of salt. But for me, even when my story wasn't popping off, someone else's story was going crazy. And I thought that was amazing. And I just couldn't wait to see what everybody else was going to do. As someone who plays a ton a ton of games every year, the novelty of a game is something that is really important to me. And Vantage did something that very few games these days do, which is make me want to play again right away. The first session I had of this game, I think lasted five or 6 hours and I think
I looked at my watch one time because I was just so intrigued and I wanted to know what was going to happen next. I love a good story and this game helps you tell that story cooperatively with the rest of your crew and it doesn't let the mechanics get in the way and that is the reason why Vantage is my top board game of 2025. So, if you're looking for an openw world experience that feels like Breath of the Wild, but in board game form and that is going to lead you on endless adventures in all different corners of this wonderful universe that they've created, then might I suggest Vantage. Boom. Suggested. All right. Thanks so much to everyone who stuck around to the end of the 2025 suggested awards. Congratulations to all the nominees and all the winners. This year was a great year for board games and I can't wait to see what 2026 holds for us. Most importantly though, I can't wait to see what you all would have nominated for these categories as well.
I love to see the different suggestions, and your comments always allow me to discover new games that I can then share with other people. Anyways, thanks for everyone who supported this channel so far. Please don't forget to like, comment, and subscribe so I can keep growing this channel and keep helping you find your perfect board game. Once again, this has been a Might I Suggested Game production, and I'm Alex, your board game sing off.