These Games NEED Expansions! Plus Expansions I Need to Play
Transcript
hello everyone and welcome back to the board gaming doctor my name is Phil and I'll be your board game doctor today and in this episode uh in an attempt to try to do some more top 10 videos at least monthly for this month I would like to talk about a few games that I think I either want an expansion for or there is an expansion available but I haven't gotten to it yet when I was making this list it was quite difficult to find games that I really enjoy that have not had some sort of expansion made for it already so I'm incl some games that I haven't gotten the chance to play its expansion or expansions yet often times these really successful games of which I enjoy have promotional material that I released during conventions or otherwise and so I won't include those specifically I am looking for a full expansion in order to count it for my list and of course we're going to talk about a few Rosenberg games that I think would need an expansion I think a lot of his games do have expansions and I've played most of them but there are a few out there especially his big box games that have not had an expansion yet so I would love to see some additional material for that too so let's get into it this is going to be somewhat informal without much of a script but the first game and the first category are games that need an expansion and the first one is lowland I've I'm mentioning this first because I have talked about this game extensively over the past couple of months I think this game is really fun and I'll give a quick overview too so Lan you are it is it is a euro game
where everyone is playing a worker placement Tableau building farming game where not only are you competing with other players to build out your farm using individual tiles but also you're trying to semi- cooperatively build out the Dyke so that way you score the game differently based off of how well that dyke is and how as a team you keep up with the rising Tides which may or may not alter your game for the better or worse now this game has been mentioned by the designers that there is an expansion in the works and so this is kind of like a hybrid game that needs an expansion but already kind of has one in the works at least but has not found a home in a publisher yet and so I'm hoping that it does happen at some point and the reason that I would love an expansion to this game is that I felt like the replayability was somewhat hindered based off of the overall strategy feeling somewhat repetitive I really like the interpersonal connections and tensions that arise from building up the dam but other than that the buildings uh the building supply of tiles feels a little limited and it feels like it's somewhat easy to see all that the game has to offer in just a handful of plays and that this game can only come out every once in a while to make it feel fresh again and so I would love some added variability in the building tiles perhaps some additional modules to add a little bit more complexity to this game as well but even if they don't I would love for additional tiles just to be added to the
stock to make every game a little bit more variable next is Yokohama this is a game where you are moving around a modular board to uh be able to gather resources and fulfill contracts with those resources competing for uh your influence in certain areas on the board to be able to advance your points you are also collecting specialized technology cards as well as different contracts from different countries and hoping to set collect some of those country icons for additional points at the end of the game this is a really fun game I've really enjoyed my plays of it it is a very competitive game as well and it's all based off of how well you can plan out your whole game basically or most of it uh based off of the modular setup at the beginning of the game now I think this game in and of itself is pretty well supported with what is in the base game and so I'm not surprised that there isn't an expansion and I'm not wholly dissatisfied with the game I just have drifted away from it in recent times and I think a little bit of an expansion type of energy could Elevate this and I know a new addition just came out a new publisher and look to the game in I think within the last year has been made and I'm not certain I don't think that there is any additional content or anything that has changed from the base game when it comes to what tiles you can play what cards you can buy Etc but if an expansion were to happen for this game I would love to see
additional tech tiles perhaps another country or two that you can purchase from even if it may not be wholly uh according to theme as the theme is set in the industrial revolution time in Yokohama Japan where a bunch of different Western countries are vined for their influence in the city and so maybe there were some other countries that were playing a part there and you can add additional Technologies and orders and what have you maybe an additional resource or two and ultimately some additional modular boards that you can place down may maybe make the map even bigger or even uh cut a few of those modular tiles from the setup to make every game feel a little different uh perhaps just adding you know a handful of different tiles maybe add one or two of them per game in addition to the modular setup but in any case I think that would be a really cool direction to see if this game were to ever get an expansion next is Brazil Imperial now this game is a game that is designed by a Brazilian team and publisher and myself being part Brazilian I really wanted this game to be something special for me personally a lot of people really enjoyed this game as this game tells the history of Brazil in the colonial times modeling uh the struggles and the historical events that surrounded the founding of Brazil all with mechanisms that are found kind of in a similar Vibe as scythe and and so for that reason this game played very
well for fans who enjoy games like Scythe for me I'm not the biggest fan of Scythe in the gameplay and I really wanted to love Brazil Imperial but I did not get that opportunity to really enjoy the game play and part of the reason is that the otoma uh module for this game is not available in the United States and so I have not really had the chance to try that out and kind of dive a little bit deeper on my own with this game but also there is an issue with the replayability I think for me personally I think the modular map in the scenario based approach is fine but when it comes to the more Euro style mechanisms and how you Garner points uh because all the while you're trying to fulfill some objectives by collecting certain pieces and tokens from the game part of these tokens are like these painting cards or these historical figures and there's only a a certain number of these in the game so the variance seemed pretty low as far as what you were able to see and and work around with in this game when it when it comes to some of those individualized cards and tokens and so I would love to see more of those to add some more complexity and some more depth to this game in what you can see from game to game in addition to you know more scenarios and things like that for me personally that would Elevate Brazil Imperial more and would elevate my opinion of it of a game that I would love to love even more than I do now
next is life of the Amazonia hey everyone this is future Phil I do want to mention that there is a mini expansion to life of the Amazonia this mini expansion was released as a part of the kickstarter in 2023 with eight unique animals as well as eight animal cards sets E and F for the ones that are released in the base game and so while this does count as a mini expansion and you may consider this an expansion uh my thoughts still are the same in regards to Further full content in in the future so thanks this is a recent game that I demoed and tried and really enjoyed I think the this game which kind of tells a story of you as an environmentalist trying to build a habitat and rescue these animals and placing them onto your habitat utilizing animals that are found in the jungle such as parrots and leopards Etc and so theme aside this game mostly for its mechanisms of deck building track advancement and Tableau building really spoke to me and was kind of a good fit for me when I tried it I could go back to this game again and have interest in playing this game a little bit more as it does use a Cascadia style type of approach to the variance and what you can score in each game you have all of the same animals that you are playing with in each game I think there are eight of them not including the unique animals that you can draft at the
beginning of the game that you have personally to play onto your board but among all of these eight different animals that you can play onto your board they each can have a randomized effect of how they score points and how many points they will score you if you fulfill those criteria now I think additional criteria for these animals would be great but I think this game would also be elevated if you included more animals to be able to save with additional content as well you can mix and match some of these animals not using all of them in a certain game to be able to provide that replayability in my opinion the uh the approach would be a little bit different each game you're not seeing everything that the game has to offer and that would Elevate this game a little bit more for me you can include different cards maybe different resources in those uh in the tokens that you are drawing because this game is also a bag building a tile game where you draw your actions from a a back and so I I guess I misspoke when I called it a deck builder it's more of a bag Builder but you could have some additional content in those tokens that you are drawing another type of resource that could be like a wild resource that you can spend anywhere or advance on a certain track that is new as well and yeah so I think there's plenty of room to expand this game and I think this game does deserve it uh it really hit strong for me and I would totally support this game if I could uh and if there was additional content as well next is missina 1347 now this is a sui game from a couple of years ago that I
was really excited for and I was ecstatic when I saw this game be free to play on yucata.de and in this game you are retelling the uh response that the Nobles had in Italy in missina to the black plague uh in the year 1347 and in this game you are moving around a modular board very similar to how you do so in Yokohama but also playing with a personal Tableau collecting these citizens that you are saving whether they be Carpenters or nuns and you if they are sick and you know get the plague you put them to work in a quarantine office until they are better and then they can move around your estate and offer you benefits as you move up tracks and so this game was really fun but I I felt like it tapered off in enjoyment for me after about eight plays or so and this game does include uh asymmetric boards that you can play with altering your strategy and approaching each game so I think if there was ever an expansion for this game additional boards to play with would be interesting to see new citizens with different uh opportunities to work around your uh estate as well as in quarantine buildings and of course different quarantine buildings and perhaps even different uh modular uh buildings that you can put or or tiles that you can put in the middle of the board that you Traverse with your player Pawn would very similar in my suggestions for Yokohama I think would make this game even better I think it it would make it a little bit more complex a little bit more diverse uh and not have you kind of feeling like you're
doing the same things over and over again because I I didn't get that feeling when faced with an a new asymmetric player board I felt like the strategy kind of felt the same and once again I've only played this about 10 times or so and so I can't speak to those who have really mastered this game and have taken that dive into how this game works including all of those asymmetric Powers nevertheless for me as someone who has more casually approach this game but with a lot of enthusiasm I think having additional content with all the above but specifically with these player boards and your estate to really offer some new uh strategies and avenues to pursue this game perhaps not even that actually perhaps if you have different uh boards or you know a different set of tiles that you can buy to add to your collection or something like that something additional to um interest your focus you know maybe to steer you off of your predetermined path to make the game feel a little bit more like you can kind of do something else uh while other players are trying to accomplish something else taking those precious spots on the modular board offering you an alternative strategy to either Focus your energy on holy to get more points or to complement what you are already trying to do and so that might seem like as I say it it seems like it's a theme in what I would love for additional content is is basically adding more of what is already there to give the game more replayability or at least more variability to increase its opportunity for
replayability but in any case I think it's still fun to kind of theorize what could be added to these games and what could Elevate them to make him a better experience as well but those are my thoughts on M 1347 and last for this section for games that don't have an expansion but I would love to see one for is ancient knowledge hey there this is future Phil again so after the recording I found I found out that ancient knowledge does have a new expansion incoming this year ancient knowledge Heritage this game or this expansion includes 16 solo mode cards that allow you to play a campaign uh objective cards that you can place into your artifact slots in your player board thereby denying you the abilities of artifacts but also granting you further abilities throughout the game if you fulfill those objectives and in addition to more cards Builder cards I think there 36 of them and 12 new technology cards shuffling them into the deck and so I was not aware of this before I recorded but hopefully the content is still about the same so there you go this was a game from last year that was released onto board game arena and I was super excited to play this game and after a handful of plays I felt like it was pretty easy to understand what was going on in this game in this game you are playing cards onto a tableau which have the unique feature and of these cards of which you know kind of represent some of the monuments and structures that uh our own you know
world history we the different civilizations have built over time or artifacts things that we have found uh you play them onto your Tableau in certain spots and after each turn they move one space to the left altering the opportunities that you have to place cards next to each other to activate their powers but also setting a timer for those cards to eventually fall off and you're hoping to basic Ally take off the uh these tablet tokens they they're shaped like tablets off of these cards that are moving on your Tableau because if they are not moved in time before you move that card off they count as negative points towards here at the end of the game and so the the puzzle of this game is to play cards into certain spots next to each other to maximize their effects but also to remove all those negative penalties to be able to score as many points as possible so I really like the premise of this game I think the Tableau building is fun the unique aspect of these cards falling off over time and losing their effects and having to rebuild your engine is fun but after a handful of plays I felt like I once again saw everything that this game had to offer the amount of variability from card to card and what kind of effects they have seemed a little limited and so i' would love to see additional cards that perhaps have some more complex abilities I I know there were game there were cards in the game that have end of game abilities if they were found in your discard pile or something like that or in the you know the the pile after they have transversed history and and fallen off but it would
be really cool to see additional cards that offered some more permanent strategy uh effects like okay I instead of just collecting different icons or colors of monuments maybe you can introduce some other types of uh criteria to be able to try to fulfill by the end of the game to offer some more flexibility in what you're trying to accomplish and to I guess change the game in a different way uh and it's really easy to do I think in games that have a lot of individualized cards you just add some more of those tweaking some of those effects to make you look at this game a little bit differently and so I think there's a lot of potential for that to happen with this game obviously I'm no game designer so I think there are plenty of people you know the designers of this game who could think of something better than what I'm you know saying right now but I would love to see additional content for this game nonetheless so those are the main games that I wanted to talk about but I do want to include a handful of other games in different categories first starting with games by U Rosenberg that I think would really benefit from an expansion I'll go through these really quick I won't describe the game as in an overview but just kind of go into why I think these games deserve expansion material the first game is at the gates of L yang this was the third game in the trilogy that followed agria and laav both of which received expansions yet at the gates of L y did not this game does include a lot of helper cards which add a little bit of variability into how you approach the game however a lot of these cards are
duplicate within the deck and within a game or two you've basically seen them all which I think does hurt this game in terms of variability which is very prominent in games like Agricola and laav which have a whole set of different uh building cards that you can uh build from and really alter your strategy from so I would essentially love to to see more uh you know variable cards in the deck that you can draw from in L young or at labora is lwh hanging fruit for all of those who know this game the the biggest reason why this game I think deserves an expansion is that you can play this game in two different modes either in Ireland or France and the resources that you play around with are a little bit different but the buildings which are also different from uh region to region are played and revealed in the same exact Order each game and so that is a red flag I think for those who really enjoy setup replayability and variability in today's modern board gaming world and so I would love to see an expansion which allows you to mix and match some of these buildings or play them in different eras or just introduce a new region to be able to do that with so that you can have a different game play out every time with where these buildings come from or and which order they they come and appear rake Holt is another game I think it struggled a little bit with the fact that despite the replayability offer of having worker placement be a part of the mechanism of how you take actions and the player powers that you can draft or have
different from game to game the goal of this game is to collect different vegetables and to sell them to different customers in a very static way to move across the board and score it's kind of like a mix between a worker placement newsford and the uh Gates of lyang try you know custom customer fulfillment but yeah these customers are basically static throughout the game and so you know exactly what customer and vegetable you have to get at the beginning of the game and from and so on and so forth and so a little bit more variability in what customers you're trying to fulfill on that track around the board would make this game a little bit different every time in addition to more as asymmetry and more player powers that can be different from game to game and in a similar vein AWA is a game that I would love to see an expansion for as well because the base game is just so much fun to play it's it was you know it's a big hit for me and and my group because it was relatively easy to play but offered a lot of depth and and fun but there is a limited variability when it comes to the terrain cards as well as to I always thought that the round to round objectives for what you're trying to breed felt a little static as well you always know that you have to have like a a bat or like two bats and two goats or whatever in round one to be able to gain an additional resource in each of those respectively in the next round and so you would know exactly what to do from round to round I I would be interested
to see how that would change if those breeding requirements were a little bit different each time and so and I do love the solo campaign or different scenarios that you can use to play this game with that really makes this game feel different as you try to approach a different puzzle each time but when it comes to the multiplayer experience I think perhaps it would be interesting to see some breeding uh requirement changes and variability to make this game a little bit different and some additional terrains as well to draw from to add some spice to a game that I really enjoy and then in this last section games that already have an expansion but I have not played yet and would be interested in playing I'll go through this list a little bit quicker but we have deos this game is on board game arena it does have an Egypt expansion that I hadn't heard of until I started making this episode and so I would love to see what additional content that provides clans of calonia had an expansion uh kickstarted recently that I would love to explore as well I think you can try a demo of that on tabletop simulator Concordia has famously had the Venus expansion and additional content such as team play additional cards that you can buy from you know a different way to score the game at the end of the game as well as different Maps you know I've played some of the different maps on the digital amp but I have not tried the additional content that it's offered in Venus nor other expansion material that may or may not add cards to so Concordia is a game system that I would love to explore more war of the ring with the new or I guess the second to latest expansion in
against the shadow which offers a solo mode as well as a Cooperative mode to play against the shadow against the uh forces of Sauron I would love to see how those little changes to the deck make the game feel a little bit different as well as to offer an opportunity to play this game more as it I feel is a game that you would want to have a dedicated group to playing with because it requires a lot of Mastery and knowledge of those cards which are static and you play through you know multiple times during a single game paladins of the West Kingdom has an expansion or I guess a full expansion and a mini expansion which adds some variability to the game additional spots on your board to play with as well as new attributes to manage as well and finally brass uh specifically Birmingham I think that this game you could count brass Birmingham as a standalone expansion or sequel to the original brass or now is known as laner but I would love to see some additional content in this game whether it is in the form of a different map uh different cards or different types of buildings that you can try to build out with different effects I think and I put this at the end because I do believe and have heard that there is an expansion or at least a standalone sequel to Birmingham that is coming coming out soon and so I I don't know exactly where I saw it it was just a a fleeting uh thing that I saw on Board Game Geek so I would look there but I would love some more content for brass as as I recently played it and got
really excited to dive deeper into it uh yeah so additional content for that would be amazing so there you have it those are the three categories in a whole slew of games that I would love to either have an expansion be created for it uh some Rosenberg games that I would think would enjoy an expansion as well and finally some games that do have expansions out there that I have not played yet so let me know if any of these expansions or if there are any games that you think need an expansion as well if you have played some of these expansions that I haven't you can let me know all that down in the comments down below and I would love to interact with you and find out what your experience has been like thank you for Consulting with me and hope that you schedule an appointment with us real soon take care
e
e e
hey everyone this is future Phil I do want to mention that there is a mini expansion to life of the Amazonia this mini expansion was released as a part of the kickstarter in 2023 with eight unique animals as well as eight animal cards sets E and F for the ones that are released in the base game and so while this does count as a mini expansion and you may consider this an expansion uh my thoughts still are the same in regards to further uh full content in in the future so thanks hey there this is future Phil again so after the recording I I found out that ancient knowledge does have a new expansion incoming this year ancient knowledge Heritage this game or this expansion includes 16 solo mode cards that allow you to play a campaign uh objective cards that you can place into your artifact slots in your player board thereby denying you the abilities of artifacts but also granting you further abilities throughout the game if you fulfill those objectives and in addition to more cards Builder cards I think they're 36 of them and 12 new technology cards shuffling them into the deck and so I was not aware of this before I recorded but hopefully the content is still about the same so there you go