Skip to main content
Loading video...

Board Games I Got Rid Of (And Why) - Episode 2

Transcript 14:18

hi everyone and welcome to episode 2 of games i got rid of and why so this is a simple series explaining why games left my collection um you know because they leave for many reasons such as you know being replaced by other games or just not being fun to me anymore or simply just not being a good game so let's get started with bang the dice game so this is a social deduction game with a bit of yahtzee involved as you are playing the roles of either a sheriff the sheriff deputies outlaws or renegades and the idea is depending on which team you're on you want to be the winner by eliminating the opposition um the game has this yachty star where you are have a bunch of dice and you're rolling the dice trying to shoot other players to eliminate them trying to heal yourself up and so on but the deduction comes in because only the sheriff is public knowledge and everybody is trying to kind of bluff to each other what team they're on trying to get on the sheriff's good side because the sheriff's a little bit more powerful um to ultimately at the end reveal themselves as the outlaw and try to murder the sheriff and be the winner really cool concept i love the idea of it but for me after repeated plays because i did play this one quite a lot it stayed in my complexion for many years actually i started to notice that some of the roles weren't quite as balanced as i would like them to be for example i thought the renegade was in a very difficult position in terms of winning and you know i played this game 20 plus times and the renegade never won once and i thought that's just not not good enough really for a game to stay in my collection i want everybody to have a fair shot of winning and um that kind of gave a stigma to this game which meant it never got back to the table after i noticed that

next up i have batman the animator series almost got him this one is a very unknown game tomorrow and it's not popular at all it's another social deduction game as you are playing this game of poker all these super villains are and one person amongst all these players is secretly batman in disguise and then you are basically you know depending on which role you get and which character you get you can collect certain poker hands and activate certain powers to try and wean out who batman is or try to eliminate your you know your opponents it's another cool concept that you know it sounds cool from from the face of it but it was a game that was quite convoluted very hard to explain especially for a game that required a lot of players to enjoy you know the most out of it obviously you you had to naturally involve less experienced players to play those kind of games and it was just too much for them to learn too many rules too many exceptions and it was a bit too regimented as well and additionally on top of all of that the game required a dealer who wasn't actually involved in the game just had to moderate the game which i don't think really people want nowadays i think most of these social deduction games do without that and um and that's for the best to be honest so a game that wasn't quite up to scratch which is a shame because the idea was quite cool next up i have between two castles of mad king ludwig now this was quite a game that came out of nowhere for me and just piqued my interest because i'm a big fan of the castles of making big and i always wanted to play between two cities and this one is a mash-up between those two where you are drafting tiles and trying to build castles um with each of your neighbors so you're drawing two two tiles

and you're discussing and negotiating with your with your i suppose opponents and slash teammates to determine where you're gonna place which tile and where and you're gonna score lots of points in different ways depending on the alignment of rooms and combinations and so on um a cool concept again i like the idea of having to negotiate with your with your um with your opponents but ultimately i thought the scoring was a bit too convoluted in this one there was too many options and ultimately i think you could always end up playing something that was just okay and i wouldn't much differentiate a much interesting choice i also found that the production was a slight issue the tiles were very small and the iconography was very hard to read and so on so those small issues just didn't take or keep it above that threshold to make it a keeper for me it was just it was just okay so next up i have the big score which which actually is a game that i consider a bit of a hidden gem and a game that i speak quite highly of to this day this one is a car drafting game and a pushy luck style game as you are basically taking the role of these bank robbers trying to make this big heist to get as much money as you can the game is divided into two very distinct phases the first one being a car drafting game as you are drafting cards and then blind bidding on these different locations trying to make these like smaller robberies and get points that way and the second half of the game is where you were all diving into this big bank drawing tokens one at a time and trying to get as much loot as you can and not get caught by the cops really cool game works well um probably takes about 45 minutes to play which is

which is quite nice for this one um ultimately for me the only reason why this didn't stay in the collection was because not long after this one i ended up picking up push um by prospero hall and for me that was a much purer pushy like style game that really got to the crux of that pushy like a lot quicker than the big score did not really a fault of the big score but i said it was kind of replaced by a much simpler a much more elegant and a lot i think fundamentally more fun game in push uh next up i have blue lagoon which is a somewhat of a modern classic by uh reina kinicia who is a fantastic designer this one is a spin on one of his older titles called through the desert as you are placing tiles on or tokens onto the board trying to score points in lots of different directions such as collecting sets of different um items um kind of trying to connect all the um islands together trying to get the majorities in the islands an ultra elegant game where all you do is just place a token on your turn um i really like it absolutely cannot fault the design and the the stream back elegance of this game fantastic um for me though after a few plays uh the real abstract nature of it started to shine through and i i have a very limited capacity for my tolerance for abstract games i don't tend to get a lot of a lot of joy out of them and while i did initially with blue lagoon and i still do it just didn't have that fun factor for me to keep going back to it which is a shame really because i can

objectively look at this game and say you know what this is a rock-solid design and i'd recommend this to a lot of people so slightly more a personal taste on this one that that's that prevented it from staying my collection long term next up i have burano burano is an interesting one a relatively heavy and involved euro style game with some pretty neat concepts as you are placing these building blocks onto the board trying to score points in different ways and build different layers it has a real nice table presence and 3d aspect puzzle nature to it but for me the the reason why this one didn't stay in the collection was because the rules overhead was quite involved and most of the games in my collection especially these heavier euro style games don't get played ultra regularly you know i often have to relearn the rules again and again and i thought that this one that rules overhead was just a little bit higher than average and the game wasn't quite strong enough to outweigh that that obstacle of me having to learn the rules again and again each time i played it it was a solid game and one that i think is a little bit underrated to be honest but the the fact that the rules weren't very intuitive and as i said quite involved was just just a bit of a hindrance to me and i just know for a fact it wouldn't have got played very at all maybe once every few years so just just wasn't quite strong enough and just a little bit too convoluted for me next up i have burgle bros now burger bros is another cool concept where you are

working together so it's a purely cooperative game where you are trying to do this big bank heist and by working together navigating through the different floors avoiding the security guards cracking safes and so on and trying to escape through the roof really cool game um it works well it has a nice ai in terms of the way the guards move around the rules that sort of move around the um the floors in like a kind of grid reference style manner i like to really like this one quite thematic um for me though the reason why this one ended up leaving the collection was number one it didn't get played very often number two that the game is extremely hard to beat very difficult and when we eventually did beat the game um it was great great moment the the lustre of it started to wear off quickly and i think a lot of these games are extremely difficult once you do crack that code and do beat the game i think that incentive to go back and do it again is diminished massively and that was the case with burgo boglebrose for me at least next up i have bazans a byzant is a small card game a trading style game as you are trying to bid on these different lots of objects using um the same cards in your hand so you're actually building on objects using objects this game has some pretty unique and innovative ideas where when you had bid for things you would actually put the cars that you bid with in a separate lot at the end of the game ready for taking by the player who got who ended up taking the least goodies in the round so i had this real

kind of um interesting catch-up mechanism where if you didn't do too well in the bidding phase you could end up picking up cards or at least the most valuable stack of cards um you get priority on doing so that was quite cool i had this nice flow to it um for me though while i did enjoy this while i played it i thought again i thought it was quite a bit innovative had some quite cool concepts certainly got some mileage out of this one um i thought that there's a bit there's a few too many um these these style games that are out there that do this slightly better than this one can't really fault it other than that really it just it just didn't quite have that appeal and that hook to keep you going back to it after a while so that was why byzan's i left the collection up next up i have camel up my camel up is very much a mainstay in my collection for many many years and ultimately that's what you know to diminish the value of it to me because the more and more i played it the less unless i wanted to play it again so i played this probably close to 20 times which is quite a lot for me personally um and i think once you've played it you've you've kind of seen everything it needs to do and the the fun factor just wasn't quite there for me at the end of it i'll still play this now you know it's a real fun um betting style game as these cameras are racing and stacking on each other and carrying each other across the race trying to weigh up all the different variables and best on the best camels really cool concept nice nice fun game not a really nice family weight game

that plays pretty quickly but again once you've played things 20 plus times they start to become a bit repetitive and a bit samey and that was the case for camel up so massive props for actually staying on the table that many times but no no desire to go and play it now next up i have captain sonar which is probably one of my most polarizing games not only by the people i've played it with but also by myself because this one is a team versus team game basically a game of battleships as you are both commanding both teams are commanding a submarine one being the captain and captain and you're steering the different directions one person trying to track the other ship one person trying to keep all your systems afloat and one person kind of using the weapons and stuff really really good game really nice well designed at least um in fact genius the way everything comes together the problem with this game to get the most out of it you have to play with at least six or eight players that being three or four aside and the fact that every role in this game is so different meant that when you explained it to new players you had to basically explain four different games and that became a massive burden and it became a bit a bit too much of a chore to teach to people and not only that when the game actually got rolling unless you were playing with people who were really committed to the game really wanted to play the game to the most kind of maximum effect it would very really much fall on its ass far too chaotic because it was a real time game you know every

everybody replaced siblings at the same time shouting over each other very hard to govern and it just ended up breaking down one too many times for me i can see the novelty of it i would i would play this again under the right circumstances but it was never going to get out again in my game group at least um it didn't go down too very well and um i said one of the most hit or missed games i've ever played so when it's when it works it works really well but when it doesn't work it really does fall flat and finally for this episode i'm going to be talking about carcassonne uh cakson a game i cannot speak badly of one of the games that really got me into this hobby a tire placement game as you are you know drawing a tile from a bag and expanding roads or castles or fields trying to get points by building bigger castles bigger roads and connecting all the castles together on those fields classic most people have played this game for me though it got replaced by slightly more involved games um more specifically isle of skye i thought of sky just has a slightly next level of complexity that i enjoy while i can still introduce it to new players yes it's slightly less intuitive and slightly um you know less approachable than carcassonne um but for me that reason i i would never go back to carcassonne the reason that pakistan stayed in my collection for such a long time was because i always played this with my girlfriend it was one of my go-to games but when i got either skye she equally got that one you know she took that one in

quite well and um started to enjoy that one more so as soon as that happened kakasan was void for me and um ended up getting rid of it because while it's nice to have a game to have in your collection to introduce new players um i don't play with a lot of new players all the time so um for that reason it was just taking up space so that's um 11 games for this episode i hope there's um you know some interest here and i'll keep doing this one because the last video seemed to go down quite well um if you have enjoyed the video please hit like and subscribe to my channel so you don't miss any future episodes of this and for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye

Progress saved