Skip to main content
Loading video...

Board Games I Got Rid Of (And Why) - Episode 11

Transcript 15:24

hey everybody and welcome to another episode of games i've got rid of and why so this is a series of videos where i talk about board games that have previously been in my collection but have subsequently left my collection then i'll give a bit of reasoning for that decision so um let's get started with the first game so the first game i'm going to talk about is totemic so totemic is a game that i normally wouldn't go for actually so this was a kickstarter project that didn't have massive massive success but it did catch my interest because of the art style that had a very almost like a tribalistic tattoo style art and this was a dueling style game but a micro game where you'd have two i think it's two cards in your hand at any time then you'd use them either to fight your opponents or to use the ability on that card and i really did like the combat system in this game where you would simply just compare the numbers of cards in your hand but you had this kind of bluffing system where you could really push your luck and try to ramp up the um the consequence of winning or losing a fight by you know by threatening someone and i really like that system when it was a matter of whether you're going to buckle under the pressure or keep going and potentially lose a lot more health and potentially lose the fight it was a good little system a kind of a clever little game but longevity it didn't really have the legs and despite there being a load of different characters etcetera um it really did kind of fall back on that threat system and uh once you've kind of got out your system then it was not really much to be explored so i did like it it was much better than i thought it was would be um that was titanic but yeah certainly

wasn't going to be a mainstay game in my collection particularly it's a two-player game and there's a lot better two-player games out there at the next game is a relatively popular game with suro so suro is probably one of the lightest games i've ever had in my collection so this is a tile placement game where you are placing these tiles onto this um this grid and all these tiles have different kind of pathways on them and the idea is you're trying to place a tile and you follow your player piece along a road on that tile trying to stay on the board as long as possible i really like the simplicity of this game this game you could easily teach in in 30 seconds to anybody which was a massive plus point for this one and it also did scale quite well i think you could play from two up to eight players um which a lot of games don't do that and still kept it in a really short time frame so it only took about five ten minutes to play um and to be honest i always thought this game would be a bigger hit than it actually did in practice or than it was in practice i'd always keep this on my shelf because i thought you know there's always going to be that scenario where i can introduce this to people who've never played board games before and it could really kind of open their eyes of what games can do and it always kind of felt a little bit underwhelming when i got it to the table and the people who i thought would be impressed with it were never really that impressed with it so um yeah unfortunately it didn't it didn't quite um fit that niche that i wanted it to and therefore i couldn't really justify having it in the collection any longer but the next game is a game called tumult royale so this is a i think a relatively unknown cosmos game i believe and this

is a real-time game or at least has an element of real time as you are collecting a bunch of resources at the same time of other players blindly and once the timer runs out whoever's kind of got the most of a certain resource or if they go over a certain kind of threshold then you can actually suffer a bit of a punishment and then you're converting those resources into building statues for area majorities ultra simple i had a real novelty factor i thought this one had um you know the first initial plays of this one were really fun and uh it was pretty unique actually i can't really think of much many games that do um what tomorrow royal does i know this is a very affordable game particularly if you live in the uk you can get this one for less than 10 pounds um and you know it is good for what it is but a bit like uh totemic this one didn't really have the legs and the incentive to keep going back to it once you've got that initial fun out of your system and you've got that novelty out of your system so it was a bit of a short shelf life but i did enjoy my time with it but i couldn't justify having it long term that is tumult royale uh the next game is a game called tyball the builder so this is actually an alexander fister small box card game so in a absolutely my news box this i believe is in the same universe as expedition to new dell and oh my goods so it's one of those kind of resource management style games this one has more of an engine build aspect to it as you can either play these cards these multi-use cards as as kind of an engine builder where you can get discounts on buildings you can use them to build buildings or you can

actually have to discard them to get the building in the first place so it had that kind of tension where you're going to use these cars there's loads of different ways you can score points you know not only by building buildings but also by i'm getting like set collection bonuses etcetera it was it was fine it worked as you'd probably expect an alexander vista game to work um very accessible had a little bit of a story arc to it as well which fister is obviously known for um and it was fine it was it was perfectly fine nothing i can really ultimately criticize it for but it didn't really um it didn't really inspire me i found it a bit generic unfortunately for a fister game and it didn't really um you know hook me in the way i would have wanted it to so mechanically no issues whatsoever a good game a solid game with them some good decisions but ultimately it didn't have that spark for me so i got rid of it the next game is one that was a very near miss to stay in the collection this is an older renegade dawn game called ilvecchio so elvecchio has all the kind of tropes of a of a dry dusty euro you'd expect you know very bland looking very you know beige looking board etc and beijing box cover but the mechanisms in this game were surprisingly good and it did have a little bit of shared dna with his more popular games like istanbul but this one you'd have workers kind of dotted around this map and you'd be collecting these different kind of um these different resources and different kind of patrons which you'd use to cash in at certain locations with money to get victory points but i like the kind of dynamism of the board as

these kind of moving pawns would go around and they would visit your different um different people depending on where you were stood and you could really kind of line up a few moves etc you could invest in these player powers which were all interesting i had a lot going on that i really did like and particularly because it played in i believe an hour or so and it was it was quite a nice game and again one that very nearly didn't make the collection um i suppose the reason why i didn't make the collection and i i didn't keep it long time was because it was it was pretty generic and what it did although it did everything very well very smoothly um i think ultimately i would have leaned towards some more modern really good dawn games you know i think i'd always choose istanbul over this one you can play in the right amount of time frame and the same on the same time but it was just a little bit better for me a little bit more juicy whereas ilveki was so so close but um ultimately um it wouldn't have got pulled off the shelf when i've got all these other games to compete with so um unfortunately elvecchio did leave the collection uh next up i have an immensely popular game uh with the voyages of marco polo so i want to make it clear that i absolutely love this game this game is fantastic this is a work replacement style game but with dice so you're rolling dice some allocating them to different spots to claim resources to fulfill contracts and to travel around the map and visit these different cities one of the best euro games out there and by some of the best designers out there so this one isn't in the collection anymore simply because the sequel came out so marco polo 2 which you can see here on my

shelf um i i think it's better better in every way and that's those slants on the original micropillar because i think that was great as well but i think um marco polo 2 just ironed out a few creases for me it made the game a bit more a bit more well-rounded in terms of wanting to do everything and i just enjoyed it a bit more i think maybe the player powers were a bit more interesting in the first one but the second one is just it just feels right for me and again it just any kind of tiny issue i had with the first one is rectified with the second one and that for me is um just just two thumbs up so two great games but the second one just edged out and that's why i didn't really feel i could justify keeping both in the collection so the next game i want to talk about is actually one of the original kind of games that got me into the hobby actually this one is a game called marvel vs system so this was kind of a reboot of an older marvel dueling system a card game where one person takes a bunch of heroes or villains and you're putting them against an opponent's bunch of heroes or villains and you're using special abilities you have this cool kind of row system where you'd have your front line and the kind of ranged attacks in the back and you could fly over each other and shoot each other very good game actually in terms of dueling touch style games this is probably one of the best ones i've played um and i'd even dare to say better than games like magic the gathering i know that's probably blasphemy for some people but this was more up at my alley um i think as time went by these kind of dueling games just didn't really resonate with me anymore and hence why you know kind of totemic fell in that same bracket i i just don't really like that head-to-head

um kind of smash each other to bits kind of feel of the game anymore and i'd rather have something a bit more nuanced a bit more a bit more cerebral but this was a good one again i know this is obviously marvel was an immensely popular ip and this game did what it did well i'm considering you know the ip etc it was it was very good and um i would recommend it if you like this dueling style games it's a nice game and i believe it's still being supported so that is versus system uh next game is one of the most popular games of all time as well one of the most successful games this is war of the ring so i'm a huge huge lord of the rings fan um and this one is basically lord of the rings in a box where you have this huge map of middle earth one player is the shadow player you know sauron and um sarriman the other person's the fellowship and it's quite an asymmetric game where the um the shadow player was trying to conquer all these different lands or find the uh find the fellowship and corrupt them whereas the fellowship players are trying to basically get the ring to mordor you have this kind of hidden movement style system as you know frodo and sam are flying under the radar you got to try and find them by using the eye of sauron very thematic game in fact one of the most thematic games i've ever played you can kind of tell the whole lord of the rings story in a different kind of twist as you're playing these event cards you're deciding whether you want to use these cards in battle or for the event itself um there there's a lot to like about this game and i did like the kind of the the epicness of it and the scope of it and just the general kind of um the theme but ultimately some of the gameplay systems

i felt a little bit clunky for me it felt a little bit drawn out it was quite a long game you know you're talking three to four hours to play this one and it's it's although it does say it's a uh a two to four player game it is essentially a two player game um but again it had a lot like i like but i also had a lot i didn't like particularly the dice rolling combat i find quite unsatisfying and a bit too random and again it's a bit too long and sometimes it can be a bit tedious in terms of having these big sieges we're just rolling and rolling and rolling um but if you like these style games these are you know these are merry thrashy style games and you love lord of the rings this is probably the go-to game it's it's amazing table presents miniatures everywhere and it's a really solid game but ultimately not the kind of game i enjoy anymore so that is war of the ring at the the next game i want to talk about is a game called wavelength so this is player opposite two war of the ring this is a party style game and another game that is extremely unique i can't think of anything that's even slightly like this game and has one of the most kind of the most innovative devices you'd ever see in terms of in terms of a component so this is a team versus team party style game where someone on a team is going to get given this kind of this card that has two kind of polar opposites on it so it might say hot on one side and cold on the other side and then basically using this contraption to randomize somewhere which is going to show this this wheel and on that wheel is going to show a kind of a marker to say where you need to guide

your point your team to go to by giving a clue so say it's three quarters of the way up you might say um maybe bath water or something so it's not as hot as it could be so it's not as hot as the sun but it's still on the side of hot and not inside a cold so you have to be very kind of clever about how you're giving your clues and it's so so satisfying when you give an ultra specific clue and people get guess it spot on i think that's really cool um so i love the premise and the idea of this game extremely innovative you know what more can you expect from a wolfgang wash game but ultimately i think in practice this didn't work quite as well as i would have liked there were some quite big breakages in terms of the flow of the game as you know people would take ages to guess a clue for example and everyone's just twiddling their thumbs while that happens and then when the other your teammates are guessing the clue then you are basically just sat there and not involved at all if you are the clue giver so it kind of had a a degree of being standoffish in terms of the engagement and it was a shame really because the the idea is so great and so fresh but yeah the flow of the game just didn't quite work as i would have liked to and i would have liked to have been a bit more a bit more exciting and a bit more kind of high energy but still full credibility to um you know for for new innovative designs and the final game i want to talk about is wingspan so wingspan of course one of the most popular games um out there um this is a game where you're collecting birds and you're putting them in your different rows in these different kind

of habitats i suppose and the idea is you're triggering these different birds to do lots of different things such as getting you food or growing eggs or um we kind of do lots of things as you'd expect from an engine building style game and this one is slightly toned back as it's pretty accessible beautiful looking and you know text all the boxes and what a lot of gamers are looking for and i will say i was initially caught up in the bit of the hype in this one i had to get it because the buzz was so was so high and when i got to the table i was i was impressed i thought this was a lovely game extremely smooth very digestible um and i did play some quite a few times before i decided to part with it and because ultimately um you know most people i play games with are slightly more advanced gamers and this one maybe didn't quite have that level of satisfaction that a lot of other energy builders do have but i i don't take that as a negative of the game i think the game is great for the audience it's for but ultimately was i going to lead towards this one when i'm when i've got some really more involved more more satisfying energy buildings on my shelf um and you know what i i it just i wasn't quite as caught up in the magic as a lot of other people were i thought it was good but i didn't think it was great um and i don't really want good games on my chef i want great games on my shelf so unfortunately i had to pass with wingspan despite it being stunning to look at so well yeah that concludes uh this series of um all this this um episode with these are 10 games so hopefully there's something on here will give you a bit of insight about my kind of process of what's going through my head when i call these games um but if you

have enjoyed the video uh please hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other videos too and for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye

Progress saved