Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 17:53

hi i'm adam porter and this is my top 100 board game mechanisms of all time you know what this is all about by now i've done this openings field several times so let's get stuck straight into it with our numbers 70 to 61. number 70 is single use powers one time abilities you see these in the game brew which is an area control game where you're placing dice out to claim territories and things like this but you're also brewing potions hence the name of the game and these potions are single single use you know you use them one time it gives you a special ability and then you discard the potion now this is what we did in compromat as well the game that i designed with my co-designer rob fisher and uh in this game initially we had a bunch of different types of powers some of them were powers that remained in play so you always had you know once you've played a card it remained in effect throughout the games you had to remember that it was there then there were other cards that would get you know mixed into your deck and it just added a degree of complication that didn't quite fit the light feel of the game it's a blackjack type game quite simple um and i felt like we needed something streamlined a streamlined system so every card should work in exactly the same way and the simplest way of doing that is saying that you play the card once you get the benefit and then you discard the card the real benefit of it is i don't have to keep track of loads of information i have to remember loads of different things that i can do on my turn i've just got those cards in front of me i use it i discard it later on it's going to be worth a point but i can forget about it now and focus on what i'm doing

so that's single use powers i think that can be a really effective system in a streamlined game number 69 is capture so this i suppose is classically what you'd think of in chess isn't it your aim of chess is to capture the king um but you're capturing lots of different pieces throughout the game it's also the the goal in a game of hive okay so the the old the goal of the game of hive is to surround the queen capture the queen bee yeah but it also might be in a game like mr jack where we've got to capture the the murderer that's on the run yeah and we don't know quite which playing pc is so we've got to work that out through a series of deductive you know logical reasoning and things like that but once we've located the criminal then we've got to get onto that space and capture him before he escapes off the board so i really like that mechanism i find it stressful i find it intellectually challenging working out the sequence of moves if i do this they're going to do that but could they escape through here well not if i cut them off here so you're reasoning several turns ahead in order to to try and work out how you're going to achieve this i find it a really satisfying mechanism and it's a nice way to end a game it's a good climax i've caught your king i've caught your queen number 68 is trading and of course this is the core of the really popular game that started a lot of this stuff off a lot of these euro games came out after the success of katan

okay and katan is full of trading swapping um different resources for other resources freely with the other players to benefit yourself but also benefit them and a game i really enjoy is bonanza which came out around similar sort of time to catan actually it's been around for quite a long time so this is a card game where you've got a bunch of different beans and you could be planting them in your bean fields there's lots of limitations and restrictions on what you can place and when and so sometimes you've got cards in your hand that you really really don't want and you've got to get rid of them because otherwise you're going to be forced to play them and you don't want them so swapping them with other players that might want them is really really fun it makes the game really interactive and so you've got lots of opportunities to chat with players to to bribe them to have banter with them it makes it into a real social experience i don't have many games with trading in them um i don't know why that is i think sometimes these games can run a little bit long the trading is is quite loose and so you know unless you've got a timer on it or something like that you can you can have quite a long sort of system um i really like the game panic on wall street which is a stock market game which can have many many players up to i think 10 or 11 players can play this game and you're constantly trading stock and you're buying you're buying different stock from each other and the prices are varying and you're taking a punt on high risk stock and things like this and then getting the benefit it's a really really satisfying system but it's all done under huge time pressure so that it doesn't outstay its welcome

number 67 is racing and i'm not talking here about racing to reach an objective or racing to reach a goal i'm talking about literal racing around a track okay i really enjoy that i always think it's a a little strange that uh that this kind of works so well because generally um i mean racing is something that happens fast board games are not something that happens fast board games are something which are quite slow and methodical but something like formula d really really works well we're going around the track we know exactly what we've got to achieve it is a you know it's immediately visually obvious who's winning who's losing how where i have to catch up when i have to push my luck in order to try and cut through ahead of somebody even if that puts me at risk of being knocked out of the race or or damaging my car or whatever you know i find that really satisfying a good race in a game um i can really get on board with that i can buy into the narrative simple narrative i know what we're doing why we're doing it i know what my goal is i know what my purpose is and and there's lots of exciting moments where you you get ahead of somebody you get you get a run ahead or a big catch up and can be really really exciting in a race game so yeah it's it's not a not not the sort of system that i play a lot it's not a mechanism that i play in many games but when i do play a racing game i tend to really enjoy it number 66 is deduction i really enjoy a deduction puzzle i think i find these puzzles more engaging than some other types of

puzzles because they tend to have a narrative to them if this person was in this location at this time with this object then this must have happened and that eliminates this person as a suspect and so on and so on i made my own deduction game zoologans which came out last year it's available now it's a solo puzzle game um with the theme being a bunch of animals in a zoo and they're all getting up to mischief after the zoo has closed and you've got to work out which animal did which thing in which location at what time and throughout the game it gets more and more complicated the unique thing with my deduction game is that there are no words most of these deduction games have have a bunch of words and the clues are written out in text mine is all pictures so in theory it could be played by anybody of any age or um you know it's although it is quite challenging once you get to the later ones even for adults um but it could be played in any country and so on so that's that's the thinking there but deduction games even where they're more of a game you know where we're playing competitively so mr jack which i've mentioned previously this is a deduction game where you've got to work out which of the uh which of the characters is the bad guy and try and stop them from getting off the board so one player is playing as the as the kind of um detective you know trying to stop the other player where the other one is the is the murderer themself but they're they're in disguise as a different a different person it's a really satisfying little puzzle to try and solve a more traditional version of a

deduction game would be something like the key from harbor where we're essentially doing similar to insuliguns we're trying to work out if this thing was true and this thing was true then this person must be the culprit but we're doing it in a race against time with the other player um to try and work it out before they can by grabbing cards with different clues from the table all done in real time and marking things off on our boards it's a really satisfying thing getting your brain going in that way trying to solve mysteries trying to solve puzzles so i do enjoy a good deduction game number 65 is root building so making connections this is what we see in the game ticket to ride which is one of my favorite games so we're laying out trains to join different cities connecting one part of the map to another what do i find so satisfying about that i don't know i guess it sort of appeals to the organizing part of my brain that we all have you know you've got a really good visual picture of what you're achieving you know what you're aiming for you can see it laying out on the map as things get shut off by the other players players cut you off then you've usually got other options to go around them and find your way around a bit like driving your car to some location you hit a dead end and then you think well i better take a detour you know and so this sort of factors into the games that problem solving of getting around that map and then you see this in many many other games as well things like roll and right games like avenue where you've got to connect up those little castles to the various different colored grapes by drawing different shaped lines um i'm not sure why this is so appealing

but it really really works for me it's a really really engaging system number 64 is height and what i mean by that is we've got some sort of three-dimensional element to the board so it might be in climbers where you've got to climb up different colored blocks to get to the top of the the tower before anybody else or it might be a game like cusco where we've got different tiles all laid up and and and by being having your pieces on the higher levels that's going to give you some sort of advantage over the other players so that height advantage is actually has as a gameplay mechanism um you know particularly if you're trying to control the territory being higher is beneficial or in a game like llama where having your llamas at different heights on your stack of tiles might help you to complete certain objectives and so i really like the incorporation of that third dimension in these sort of strategic games number 63 is legacy and campaign games and this is another one of those love it or hate it you know love hate relationships that i have with this particular mechanism i tend to avoid campaign games in general because i very rarely play with the same group over and over and over again and i really really like trying out new games so actually sitting through the same game you know 10 20 times in a row to me that's pretty tedious i'd much rather play 10 or 20 different games one time and then come back to them once i've

sort of cycled through a few other games by which time i've usually forgotten what i was doing in that campaign so it's something which i generally avoid although there have been times that i've enjoyed a campaign i quite enjoyed playing through parts of imperial assault at one point legacy games i've dipped my toe in those waters particularly playing them with my wife and that's much more achievable particularly if they're a fairly light game so playing the same game over and over again with my wife is something that i can kind of manage so i've got through charter stone we've played all the way through we've played all the way through my city which are both quite quite light sort of experiences particularly my city but i've also played all the way through zombie teens evolution which is a legacy game for children and i really really enjoyed that i really liked opening the envelopes seeing what how the rules were going to change for the next game seeing what new pieces the game gave to me so in a legacy game often there's a bunch of different boxes or envelopes in the box so when you've played one game you open up some envelopes it gives you new stuff maybe you tear up the old stuff maybe you write on the board you permanently change what you're doing and there is something really satisfying and unusual about that experience so a legacy game once in a while played with my wife perhaps over a week or or a weekend or whatever we you know going away and playing a few games and i think it's it's really really enjoyable

because of the narrative that it kind of creates and and getting stuck into a game that constantly shifts and evolves as you play it number 62 is a very specific one this is the cat lady draft okay i only i've only seen it in the game cat lady which is why i'm calling it the cat lady draft but i think it's really clever so in cat lady you lay out a three by three grid of different cards and then on your turn you select either an entire row or an entire column and that's pretty much the entire game the next player cannot select exactly what you selected so if you selected the middle row for example the next player is not able to select the middle row they must select a different column or row but aside from that you're just collecting sets of stuff sets of cats so really at its core it's just that mechanism but it's a really really good mechanism and so simple um it's really nice when somebody comes up with something so obvious and yet it hasn't been done before that i'm that i'm aware of then finally at number 61 we've got spelling games so these are word games where i've actually got to make words physically with by putting the letters together to create those words um these aren't popular with lots of players um i have found myself i've designed a spelling game pitched it around to different publishers got a fairly lukewarm response but one publisher took it on was really excited about it it was with that publisher for several years before they finally handed it back to me and said yeah we're not going to produce it we're not getting much enthusiasm from our various

different partners and things like that so so i i've seen firsthand how much of a struggle it is to get spelling games to get people enthusiastic about it but i i really enjoy them i find it a really nice thing what i find with spelling games is it's basically a form of set collection isn't it we're taking a bunch of different tiles or a bunch of different cards and we're grouping them together to create a set it just happens that there are many many different variations of sets which create different words so you've got to have a good vocabulary to to to know what's what sets are available to you this is one of the major downsides of scrabble is that you know if you're going to play it really really competitively you've got to learn the dictionary you've got to know all those two weird two-letter words which nobody ever uses so i do like it when a a spelling game doesn't take itself too seriously plays fairly light something like bananagrams is really good i like clever twists on it like in um letter tycoon where you can take sort of ownership of certain letters and if other people use those letters then they're going to have to pay you and things like that there's other similar things like word domination which which uses an area majority area control type system with spelling and then games like hardback which incorporate as i say set collection um but here we're deck building so we're laying out cards on our term building up our deck buying new letters to put into our deck to make it better creating better and better words as you go on in order to score points um

i think there's loads of scope for loads of design um design choices that you can make when you're making a spelling game the problem is the market it's it's a bit odd who plays these games it's not hardcore gamers it's more mass market but the mass market wants really simple stuff and it's already pretty much tied up and monopolized by scrabble so it's a tough one spelling games but i enjoy them always happy to play a new spelling game so as always this leaves me with telling you one mechanism that i don't enjoy so this is we've already done numbers ten nine and eight on my list of ten mechanisms that i don't enjoy so this is number seven and it is programming i'm not a big fan of programming games i'm racking my brains here thinking is there a programming game that i really enjoy the only one i can think of is dominant species would i really call that a programming game i don't know i suppose it sort of is you select your different actions it's a work replacement game where you select your different actions and then um all of the actions are resolved once everybody's finished selecting all the different actions so people can get in your way and obstruct what you're doing and so on um but when i think of programming games i'm thinking of things like river dragons and lords of zidit and robo rally where you set out your plans and then everybody else ruins it i just find that frustrating i don't find that fun i really don't i find it like

i've made a plan and now i get nothing all the things my carefully thought out stuff i've really thought about what i want to do what i want to gain all ruined by the other players and somebody else gets loads of stuff they've managed to they've managed to pull off their plan just doesn't feel very fair and i don't find it very satisfying so um yeah programming games not really for me although i know a lot of other players really like them so what do i know anyway i hope you enjoyed this video we'll be coming back in the next couple of days to do the next 10 mechanisms on my top 100 if you did enjoy the video please watch some of my others my channel is absolutely full of videos about board game design the industry board game reviews and with a real slant on on looking at them from a good designer's perspective so hopefully you'll find something unique and interesting so go back through have a look at them subscribe to the channel so you can keep up to date with new videos throughout the year and please comment let me know what you enjoyed what you didn't enjoy what you like about the mechanisms that i've talked about today and i'll see you next time all the best

Progress saved