10 ways to get better at board games
Transcript
brought to you by boardgameatlas.com the fastest growing board game community in the world kia ora koutou and welcome to 10 ways to get better at board games one of the wonderful things about having a patreon is people on there tell me to do stuff and i put up some suggestions and ideas for longer format videos and this was the one that the people on patreon suggested i do and do it i shall am i an expert in winning board games well kinda i'm not bad at board games i'm pretty good at board games and there's probably a few lessons from my 35 years of playing them that i can pass on to you now does that make me the super grand expert of every single game ever played absolutely not for every game i feel comfortable saying i'm pretty good at there's about 999 that i don't know very well but there's some general rules and general bits of advice that can go across all manner of board games and the reason for that is it's fundamentally the same process each time learning and discovering a game becoming more familiar with it and then moving on to mastery of it now who is this video for well you see there's this cliche that goes around board gaming circles that seems to put board gamers in one of two camps either you're a member of the oh i play to have fun group or you're a member of the win it all costs group and i think this is a binary that doesn't actually exist i think the vast majority of people fall between these polar points yeah sure there are some win at all costs awful human beings out there who are just absolutely miserable to play against and will cheat lie bully and do whatever it takes to
win but there's not actually that many people who legitimately don't care about playing well and that's where i think most people sit they sit in the middle group where they turn up and they play to their best ability and winning is good winning is a fun part of doing it but losing isn't the end of the world and i think that's who this video is for the people who turn up to a board game and try to win now they don't try to win at all costs but they play to the best of their ability within the constraints of the game and the social group they are involved with and that's what i expect from people when i'm playing against them i expect people to give their best people's best might be different based on their ability levels and their familiarity with the game but i still expect people to try to win or at least try to do their best and that's what this video is about becoming better at board gaming by doing the best that you can so this is going to be a list of 10 almost maxims or ideas or concepts that i'm going to loosely frame together into one kind of video that wasn't particularly descriptive but i hope you catch my meaning there are no hard or fast rules to get better board games it's a bit more broader than that so i'm going to talk in broad categories and the first one i'm going to talk about is being where you can be comfortable winning being comfortable winning that sounds like liberal airy fairy bollocks to me jay what the hell are you on about well here's the thing not everyone is comfortable winning and not everyone is an environment where winning is allowed or permissible a lot of people play in environments where there's either a personality who loses their temper when they lose
or generally is miserable and sullen and horrible if they don't get their own way there are a lot of these people in board gaming and they make other people feel like they can't play to their ability because in doing so they cause this other person to be upset and what i want to say is that that problem is the person who's getting upsets problem if people can't handle playing a game and losing without losing their temper and without lashing out at people you need to get those people out of your lives you need to not be playing games with them so step one to getting better at board gaming is find a group where you're comfortable where you're relaxed where there is permission to win where you feel comfortable winning and you don't feel that there'll be repercussions if you play to your ability and i understand for a lot of people this could be tricky there are a lot of social dynamics in geek circles and gaming circles that make this easier said than done but gaming should be fun and if you can't go to a table and you can't play because someone is going to lash out or be miserable or do something because they aren't winning the game or it's not going their way you need to get out of that space because without that none of the rest will matter because you won't be able to play to the best of your ability point number two is have training games and what this is is it's not sitting down and playing the same game 50 times like you're practicing for the Olympics but it's taking the first game as a
learning experience and it's treating that experience as a learning experience in your first game it really doesn't matter if you want to lose it really really doesn't what matters is that you learn the systems you learn what's happening and you learn as much as you can about the game in that first time and what i really recommend is for gaming groups is to treat first place like learning games if someone stuffs up if someone does something terribly bad let them take the move back unless of course you're one of those people who does abuse that privilege just so they can win the training game and for me a teaching game involves the teacher playing reasonably hard like not pulling a dramatic amount of punches and actually showing how the game naturally works but not running up the score so the other people feel terrible at the end it's one thing to teach a game to a group and win by a margin of 20 or 30 percent it's another to play and teach to a group and win by a margin of 500% so as the learner in the teaching game accept that you're probably not going to win and you're there for the learning experience and as a teacher in a teaching game don't be a colossal toe rag just let people learn and let people discover the fun of the game you don't have to beat the crap out of them in their first game so you feel good Paul
number three is something we've always done as a group and it's something we've done an awful lot more since i started the channel and that is the post post-game debrief now the post-game debrief is where you sit down and you figure out what did i do well what didn't i do well why did i win why did i lose and you talk through that as a group with some games you can go oh that was a really stellar play you managed to get that card when i really needed it and that was the turning point in the game others like engine builders you can sit there at the end of the game and go how the heck have you got 64 000 fish and i've got four how did that happen good teachers will say oh well i figured out how to use this combination this combination in order to produce unlimited fish bad teachers will just pick up the game and walk off but for me that post gang debrief is a fundamental part of what we do at the channel and how we review and evaluate games but it's also part of our group's learning process how we learn a game how we get better at a game and how we get better at games in general when one player cracks a game and they totally get it way before anyone else we talked and go hey what the hell were you doing that was so damn effective and we bounce ideas and stories off each other and that's how we as a group get better at games so yeah next time you play a game and you get absolutely thumped by someone stop and go hey how did you beat me that badly what went through your mind what was your strategy is this something i could adapt from that next time i play
how many times have you heard the phrase i lost because of my dice rolls ah compared to how many times have you heard the phrase oh i won because i'm really lucky at throwing dice stop blaming external factors on whether you win or lose now that's quite a confronting statement and there's bound to be some people going but this game's luck heavy it doesn't matter some games are heavy luck but an awful lot of them are a lot lower luck than many people think the more time you spend going oh if only i rolled that number at that time or if only i picked that dice up you're actually deflecting responsibility for the result of the loss onto the game you're projecting onto an inanimate object now some games are like this like no one has any skill at lcr you just roll the dice and allocate things but i've seen people talk about games like paths of glory where yeah there are dice rolls but there's enough of them and enough other factors going on that it's really not that one dice roll that's not why you lost and one thing you'll note is in war machine tournaments or magic the gathering tournaments the same people win all the time and the reason for that is it really doesn't matter how the deck is shuffled well how the dice rolls go in those finals those players have the skill to overcome that and part of the attitude of getting better at games is accepting that it's not always the game's fault you lost an awful lot of people i see online play what i call wide where they will play a whole bunch of different games and they might play one
or two plays of them and then move on to the next game and they can play through 100-200 games in a year but they'll probably only give one or two or three plays to any of those games and that's what's called giving a wide experience to board gaming you can learn a whole bunch of different systems and mechanics and play styles but the problem with going wide is that it's shallow you always get stuck at the discovery phase in a game now for me a game goes through three different phases the first is the discovery phase which is your learning game and perhaps your second game where you're learning the basics of the game you're learning how the mechanisms work you're learning how to win and how the feel and pacing of the game is from games two to five onwards is exploration where you're testing the systems you're figuring out different paths to victory you're figuring out different styles and how the game works for you and then from that point on you start moving into game mastery where you're really familiar with the game you know the ins and outs you've won or tried to win on multiple different paths if they're allowed and the game comes naturally to you at that point so you can sit down with that game you might not have played it for five years and just go bang i know this game because i've mastered it playing wide leaves you in the discovery phase and there's a lot you can pick up by playing games deep so my recommendation is to balance playing wide with deep pick some games you really like play them 5 10 15 20 times get familiar with them learn
a game and master it learn the ins and outs of your favorite game because there's something quite rewarding about mastering a game about learning its intricate details and its eccentricities that you don't get from playing a bunch of different games that's just a very different experience and i think to really improve at board gaming you need to find some games that you want to dedicate the time to that you want to go i want to learn how to play aeon's end and i'm going to play that with my friend and we're going to play like a whole bunch of it and you learn the game you learn the different combinations you learn how the different nemesis work and you just improve at that and what that does is it doesn't just improve your ability with that one game repeated play and mastery of the game teaches you lessons that you just don't get from shallow plays and that's because the games become more competitive if you play 10 different games with the same group uh you're all in the discovery phase so it's just a bit of fun and you you play the game and it's enjoyable but if you play the same game ten times of that group you start seeing patterns you start seeing different strengths and weaknesses and the other players you start adapting your game against the game of your opponents so if you played risk against the same group a hundred times well you know that bob over there really really likes to secure south america that's their thing and you learn more about your players you learn more about their play styles and you learn about your own play styles and you learn
about game matters and only through system mastery and playing a game repeatedly can you start seeing these little intricacies within a game and within your gaming group and if everyone enjoys the game there's actually nothing better for a group than playing the same thing a fair bit many of my favorite gaming experiences with my groups are playing things like gloomhaven or battlestar galactica where we've played the game multiple times arkham horror these are games that we all know we've all played and there's that familiarity with it that comfortableness that you only get when you've played a game a hell of a lot so i think it's good for your social group and i actually think it's good for becoming better at games just learn to play games more than once oh something else about teaching games that i completely forgot to mention is some games contain traps and these are things that experienced players only learn through repetitive plays and a good example of that is the berlin blockade card and twilight struggle now if you're unfamiliar with twilight struggle there is a card that comes along early in the game that requires you to hold an expensive card in your hand in case your opponent plays it if you don't have an expensive card to discard when your opponent plays it you lose all your influence in west Germany which is a really pivotal place in the game now that's what i call a trap for new players if you don't know that's coming that is monstrously unfair and kind of awful if you know it's coming you can mitigate it so that's part of what happens when you play a game deep is you start learning those tricks and those foibles within a
game that can absolutely derail you and make a miserable time if you don't see them coming my next point is when you are playing a learning game or you are in the discovery phase is to just pick something to do early in the game and go for it so if you're playing a game and it has factions that have special abilities lean into that if you're handed a character that says get plus five trade look at the trade system and go okay how am i going to maximize this in other games there might be four types of resources produced oil gold steel or whatever go right my initial hand has some plus steel cards i guess i'll produce things that do steel pick an early goal and it doesn't really matter if that's a successful goal or whatever just pick a plan and go with it some games will also give you secret objectives like in museum you want to collect different sets of paintings just focus on those focus on your goals focus on what your faction does well and just lean into it hard at least for your first couple of games most designers give variable player powers so people can explore different aspects of the game and one i really like is circadian's first light there are eight different leaders in that game but each of them has an amazing special ability and you really can't go wrong by looking at that special ability and going i'm going to focus on that not to the exclusion of everything else but that is going to be my driving decision maker for my first couple of plays now as you get into system mastery of
the game you can do things like oh i'm going to pick up the plus 5 trading race but i'm not going to trade much with them i'm going to focus on military but that's because you're more familiar with the systems you're more familiar with the ins and outs of the game well when you're starting out you're trying to discover and learn a game pick your specialty look at your goals and pick something and just go for it and if you have to adapt throughout the game so be it remember it's just a learning game the next point i want to cover is focusing on win conditions learn the win conditions of the game and focus on them now some games can be a little deceptive about this i had a friend of mine play rising sun and he came away from the game being particularly pissed off with it and the reason for that is as follow from his point of view it looked like an area control battle game he looked at what he could do on the board and thought oh this is about armies and placing dudes on the board and doing stuff and then he started playing and he focused on that and other players built up these engines that did other things in sacrifice and i don't really know rising sun that well but in the end he came dead last by a mile despite winning all these battles and controlling all this territory and he was just pissed off that no one had really explained to him exactly what the win conditions of the game were another really good example of the game that can trip people up is pret-a-porter now this is a game i'm quite familiar with i've got a copy just over there and what you don't realize when you start playing unless someone explains to you is how important money is at the end of the game now through the game you're collecting these stars and these stars get you bonuses and give you some victory points
and you might end up at the end of the game on 80 points or something and go wow that's amazing and then someone sells their final collection for 300 bucks and quadruples their score now those are examples of games where victory conditions weren't described very well there is a game i have however who does an amazing job of it but it's a hidden away a little bit in the rulebook and that is obsession on the back of the obsession rulebook which i'm going to put up on the model behind us there's this pie chart and it tells you exactly where points come from in the game based on their play tests you can use this at the start of the game to explain to people hey the cards in your deck are going to be worth lots of points the buildings are going to be worth lots of points even your staff are worth points but the secret goals you've got won't necessarily be worth as many points as you initially might think and what knowing the victory conditions of a game does is it just allows you to focus your mind on what's important if you get to a point where you're like oh i can get two gold or two silver and you find out that silver's not worth anything at the end of the game but gold is you might go yeah i'll take the victory point one i don't have any need for silver at the moment and in some games like engine builders it can be way too easy to get caught up in what's going on and not necessarily what's going to get you points at the end of the game next up is understanding game time is and i'll ask you how many times have you played a game will you be sitting there going oh i've got this great combination i'm ready to do when someone goes all right it's the end of the game and you're like ah i've only like next turn i was gonna
do this and then i was gonna do that and i was gonna charge this and then we could but you don't get to do it because the game's over some games like scythe are kind of notorious for this where someone can be on three stars and then go bang bang bang and put three down in one turn ending the game others like race for the galaxy the end game can just kind of come on you faster than you might initially expect other games like seven wonders or it's a wonderful world you know exactly how long the game is going to take but you won't quite realize how important each action is at different stages and how they track all together and this is where playing games over and over really helps because you learn that pacing you learn the natural length of the game you learn to sense when the end game is coming and when you go i've got three actions left tops maybe two because frank over there he's just about to go bam bam bam and play these cards and if it is a learning game don't be afraid to ask hey how much longer do you reckon this game will go turn wise are we about halfway through does the game speed up as we go along learning the pacing of the game especially for engine builders and euros is incredibly important because otherwise you'll end the game with a whole bunch of unspent resources that aren't worth anything a bunch of cards you can't do anything with and a lot of plans that you just didn't get to implement
the next point i want to bring up is shifting utility now what the hell is shifting utility you ask well i'm glad you asked you see in many games cards resources powers and units change effectiveness throughout the game based on the game timer a good example of this is everdell if you can bring down a production building before the first season it's going to produce three times if you bring it down to the end game it's gonna produce once that means that production card is effectively three times more valuable if you play it early so if you understand the timer of the game you can understand the value of cards and abilities throughout a game using terraforming miles as an example if you expect the game to go for 10 turns and you draw a card it gives you two money a turn and it costs you six money to play if you play it on the first turn that's really beneficial if you play it on turn nine you're actually wasting money and i see an awful lot of players doing this they'll play resource generating cards towards the end of an engine builder where there just isn't time for them to pay themselves off in addition to this in the early part of the game things that generate resources that allow you to buy more stuff are generally more useful because it gets your engine going it gets you more stuff and allows you to start steamrolling but towards the end of the game stuff that converts things into victory points is what you want to be focusing on and the idea you need to construct in your head is that things change utility throughout the game and there's a median point where things sort of flick over from do i want to be developing now do i want to stop developing do i want to start pushing for the end game
and you need to learn that through play through repeated plays of games generally i will not build a production building in terraforming mars after turn seven it's not a hard and fast rule but that's a good example of understanding how shifting utility works within board games something that's great early on and great late on and vice versa so the next time you're playing a game especially an engine builder and you're about to play a card that generates resources sit there and think is this thing actually going to pay itself off and if it isn't do something else and the last thing i want to talk about is the attitude you keep when you're playing if you're playing a group game and you don't think you can win then try to do your best don't be that sulky steve who sits there and goes oh i'm out of the game or i don't have any opportunity or i'm gonna spend like six turns doing nothing more because you bring the whole damn group down if it's a two-player game and you legitimately think that you're not going to win offer a resignation there's nothing wrong with saying you've outplayed me this time well done i give you the win shall we set up and try again or shall we play something else but if you are playing a group game and there's a time commitment involved and you sit there for an hour being miserable you're just killing everyone else's fun plus there have been many times where i've been in that position where it seemed almost hopeless the odds are totally and utterly against me and i just do something i try something i try as much as i can to actually win the
game and it might be doing something that has terrible odds like okay i get to flip over three cards if the exact one card out of the 300 and the deck is there that i need i might actually win but it's better to try and to learn and to understand how you lost or how you got in that position and do better next time than it is to sit there being a miserable soul so next time you're getting your ass handed to you and you feel like throwing a tantrum just settle down understand that learning can happen in defeat in fact you'll probably learn more from the defeat if you keep your eyes open and your ears open and start paying attention instead of throwing a sad and who knows you might actually do something that steals a heroic victory it might be one of your best board gaming stories i'll give you an example i was playing someone at war machine i was absolutely in a dominant position there was absolutely no way he could win and he did it required a chain of events mathematically that was about one in seven and a half million and he did it and he won and it's one of his favorite damn stories of all of gaming was a time that he had to roll literally like nine sixes in a row in order to do this chain of events to defeat me and he did it and i couldn't help but just laugh at the ridiculous probability and go yep i gave you this much of a window
and you got through in fact i gave him like a millimeter of a window and he managed to sneak through it and win the game if he'd pack the sand just gone oh i resigned i don't want to do this he wouldn't have that great story he wouldn't be able to tell people about the time at a tournament he managed to do a one in seven million shot and win a great game so yeah next time you're down playing a game look up try something you might do something really fun so that brings us to the end of this video these long format videos are made possible by our supporters on patreon thank you people you're amazing i hope this video has been at least slightly useful i really struggled with the ideas of what to put in here to try and get all of that game experience out onto the screen and hopefully there's at least one or two useful things in here you can pick up and there isn't i don't really care you know you do you if you do have some advice on how people can get better at board games leave it in the comments my point of view is not the only point of view and i really want to hear from you and in order to see more of these long format videos come support us on patreon and if you enjoyed this video subscribe to the channel hit the notification button support us on patreon and go check out the website, take care