Skip to main content
Loading video...

Game Design Trends for 2025 with Jamey Stegmaier

Transcript 45:25

it's essentially 1,700 cards but aive cardboard it's 1300 cards it's literally an entire planet's worth of Art and content and story so tell me just what you learned designing a game that took that long and was that just enormous in scale psychological power like the of of incremental progression in terms of the design itself when I decided that I wanted every location to have all six action options on it move Look engage help take or overpower when I made that decision I had to give myself the grace of saying I can't do this all at once but I can make a little difference every day I can move forward a little bit every day and that's okay and that feels good because you know designing three locations in a day that isn't that much when I have 797 more to go but that's three more than I had the day before something I tell myself all the time is no zero days yeah yeah right what's up my friends welcome to the board game Design Lab today in little episode we're going to be talking about game design right the board game Design Lab I realized I I don't typically do episodes where I I just talk about General things usually we're diving into very specific topics and trying to you know go as as deeply as we can but I wanted to invite my friend jimie star back to the show for this little minseries of episodes and let's just talk about the current state of game design where are things in the industry right now where are things going you know Jimmy really appreciate you being here welcome back to the show I I am reled to be back Gabe I I always

enjoyed it listening to and joining your your original show and so yeah I'm glad that you are returning to it at least for a little few a few part series here yeah yeah and it's something I want to do I've wanted to do for a while last year I was so busy doing a game every single month which is lunacy and I don't recommend it for anyone um it's not a good idea but it has been fun it has been an adventure the downside was my time just got absolutely eaten up by you know the constant campaigns and constant customer service and constant fulfillment and constant production files all the things that a publisher does except times 12 as opposed to you know the the typical like times two to three like how many games did you do last year how many games did I do uh as a designer I I mean for your company yourish how many we published we published um worm span and then rolling Realms Redux and then stamp SW swap so three three games yeah yeah that's that is a healthy number of games a company perspective and just a time and health perspective and um yeah doing 12 is nuts but but I'm starting or really several months ago figuring out the Rhythm figuring out the scheduling and you know everybody on the on the like I'm just a one person publisher but like I've got all these Freelancers that help out and do stuff everybody's kind of getting in the groove it's like okay here's what we do by this date here's what we do by this date and so figuring it out so I wanted to do some episodes and just kind of chat with some people that I love to hang out with you this gives me a great excuse to talk to people I enjoy talking to and hopefully I can do some more of these little miniseries all along but um

yeah let's Dive Right In and just talk about game design you know we last spoke at least a year year and a half I mean it's been a while and the industry has changed in a lot of ways um both you know with shipping and fulfillment and game design in general uh and so I just want to get your thoughts on kind of where we are game design wise right now and also where we're going I know you've got three years worth of games already planned and so you already effectively setting the trend for the next three years because a lot of people look at ston meire games and that kind of sets up you know what's going to come in the industry as a whole right you've you've done an amazing job of just kind of separating yourself out as one of the Publishers that every time you make an announcement people listen they watch they get the email they're they're posting about it you know the number of memes I saw a few weeks ago when you posted about finpan like it was like every single post I saw on Facebook with somebody with a new meme of a new span game and it was a lot of fun all that free advertising that you got but you know give me your just bird's eye view right now where are we as far as game design as far as game designers as far as pitching just give me like a broad Strokes 30,000 view where we at right now I'm I'm really curious to hear your thoughts on this too uh because it is for me it's I I closely pay attention to what other designers and what other Publishers are doing um but there is still a so much variety it's hard for me a little bit to paint truly broad Strokes um uh sum of it one Trend that I've seen continue particularly since

the pandemic is a renewed focus on um games that play solo either solo only or they have a solo mode something that um that you've really leaned into very strongly and successfully and games that include either include or feature two-player play either included or only two-player play I mean I've seen if there's any Trend actually at all that I've seen over the last six months it's been a ton of duet and Duo games announced or released um and I wonder if some of that came from the pandemic games that were worked on after during the pandemic after the pandemic when maybe you were stuck with only one other person or when people saw that those games were being played a lot more than than uh bigger games with higher player Accounts at game nights um and so those are those are two initial observations maybe coming from that time that are continuing till now do you have you seen that as well and and how am I correct that it's been successful you it's appeared to been successful for you to go with the solo aspect yeah it probably one of the best decisions I ever made you know a year and a half ago if you'd asked me I was like I don't know man we're going to see we're going to find out and I was hoping I could get you know 500 to a thousand backers per month right looking at the math looking at the like okay what do I need to pay my bills and be able to create the products and put them out in the world and paper shipping allu it's like okay I need around a thousand backers and I'm getting close to around 2,000 backers every month and so it's like okay this was a good decision and to your point I think a lot of it is from still hold over from the pandemic as far as like games that were being designed because it takes you know several years for these things to come to life but also

the pandemic created a lot of solo Gamers and created a lot of like partnership you know couples that play games together it was just natural and so for all the terrible and evil and awful that the pandemic was it also created certain opportunities which is the case with everything right the financial crisis of several years ago created opportunities like the current tariff situation the shipping fulfillment all is creating certain opportunities and if you super emotional about it and let it ruin you it will but if you see it as a problem to be solved as a oh what are the opportunities here not what are the things that I can you know lose my mind and get depressed about uh people have an opportunity to you know keep saying opportunity people can really make the best of it and so it's been it's been cool to kind of see all that you know in my own company but also so many other companies um another thing I'm seeing right now is a lot of Ip driven games there's been a lot of Lord of the Rings games coming out recently you know from movies and books from a long you know a while back but they're really good and I think that's another thing I'm seeing is game design is now so much better than it was even just a few years ago the bar is so much higher both design and production wise marketing wise artwise like is the cream has risen to the top in a lot of ways and it's it's kind of in a lot of ways getting harder to separate yourself out as an indie publisher as a new designer as well so let's let's chat about that have you noticed is it just me or there more good IP games like you've always had IP but now it's like wow that's a top 10 game of the year with the IP on

it am I seeing that I absolutely agree yeah um you mentioned Lord of the Rings Lord of the Rings trick taking and the Dual for Middle Earth both I I love those games I I I think they're both excellent games and June Imperium has continued to be a hugely successful uh game that leans into that IP and I like the way that you said it there that uh people designers Publishers are looking for ways to stand out and an IP is kind of a built-in way to stand out it's probably going to get uh a certain amount of attention due to the IP specifically so I think that is still a viable path moving forward and I love I really I love I I've been I've L seeing the creativity that's come from that that it isn't just slapping another theme onto the same deck builder that we've seen a dozen times we're getting deck builders like d Imperium we're getting do for Middle Earth uh uh what was the one I played recently I play the Star Trek one that's based on existing system uh as uh no Captain's Captain's ke chair yeah yeah another deck builder really creative deck builder that that really Embraces that theme so yeah I I I don't think you're alone in seeing that I I absolutely agree right and it's honestly it's not even the it's not even just the big IPS like for a long time it was Marvel it was Star Wars it was Lord of the Rings it was you know things everybody knew but now you also have companies like Jay Cormier and his company off the page and they're going to independent comic artists and they're making games based on that comic IP and you you got people I think you actually wrote A Blog about this recently You' got people on Instagram who have a zillion followers they're like wait a minute how can I monetize This and like show some love for my community I what

what if I made a game and providing so many opportunities to cross over where you have someone who has the reach but doesn't have the industry understanding or the game design understanding where they can partner up with a game designer or a game publisher and all of a sudden they can serve Their audience of a million followers on YouTube or Instagram with something fun and enjoyable make money in the process oh and by the way I get to design a game and publish a game that gets to be part of that as well so you know give me just like the brief synopsis of that blog post you I'm referring to and kind of what your thoughts are I'm glad you connected it to this topic I wasn't I didn't think of that but um similar to what you said before there's an opportunity I think that so you and I when when we design or create a game we create it and we hope there's an audience for it there all the there are these Brands um like the the blog post was about a BL a brand called chers i' I've never heard of chers it's a Whimsical kind of cartoonish uh Instagram um Channel Instagram yeah channel that has around 600,000 followers um you know there are these Niche brands on there and Niche I'm using in a in an odd way here 600,000 is a lot of people but I never heard of it Instagram has millions of followers in across the the platform um but the opportunity here is that a publisher or a designer who is hoping to get their workout out there or their name out there could get paid by one of these Brands to do it so they're not they're not waiting for customers to maybe buy their game and maybe make a royalty off

of it these are brands that are willing to pay to have you create a game I think it's a great opportunity and I was actually a little surprised that when I posted that um I I mentioned one publisher that does it that the only one that I knew about and only one other publisher so far has contacted me to say hey I do that too put me on the list that's two like that's a that's not many people who are who are doing this yeah yeah think about a designer came to you and they said hey Jamie I got this idea for a game I hope you like it oh by the way I have a million people on my YouTube channel subscribers like oh all of a sudden that Designer has way more leverage they have way more because even if the game ain't you know necessarily the best I feel like you as Jamie stagmire have enough confidence in your skill as a publisher and a developer to go oh we gonna make this work because that is a huge audience and so yeah as a designer as a publisher thinking about I feel like I find a new channel that has a million followers or subscribers all the I'm like oh I didn't know this existed and there's a million other people that have you know I'm reminded of a channel I found during the pandemic called 3D bot maker which this guy races Hot Wheels cars as if they're real races and the commentary is excellent the narration is excellent the video production is off the chart and it's like a real race and a lot of people watched it during the pandemic because there were no other sports going on and so people looked at this like a you know a real sport well if you go to that guy because he's got somewhere around a million and you say hey I've got this cool race game you know could we partner in some way can and I pay you a percentage to like come on board and like consult and help me out and then we sell this you know to your audience that's an opportunity to you know make some money and and make something cool

in the process so yeah I think more and more people are going to be doing that because again as the market gets harder and harder to stand out I think those strategic Partnerships are one thing you can do to make it a little bit easier to go hey that's an instant audience now are a million people going to buy the game no but let's say you only get 1% that's still a lot of games as you're selling you know far more than the normal Indie publisher print run W of so yeah I think there's some really cool things that could be happening soon if people see that right um you I've talked a lot about this with people that work in different businesses or work in the church I'm like what would it look like to do business or to do ministry like it's the Year we're actually living in because I feel like sometimes people get caught up in the past so you know looking towards the present looking towards the future another thing is is system games I think that's another way to stand out and you've got a buil-in audience you've been doing an excellent I think you you turned wingspan not into you built it into more than just a game not only do you have tons of expansions which is excellent not only do you have like these really cool Deluxe things that people can buy as ADD you add-ons after effect but now you've created The Hyphen span system the line of games you got worm span which is all about dragons now you got fin span that just came out which is all about fish you know the number of possibilities are effectively endless for how many you know animals or creatures or whatever you could put in there so tell me your thoughts on that give me like the backstory what was the original idea to go oh wait what if we did this with a similar system and put it in like a line of games kind of was that your idea originally or did somebody reach out to you tell me about that yeah um I I'll try to dip into my

memory to find out exactly how it happened but what I remember is that basically wingspan came out almost actually six years ago today as we're recording this on March it came out on March 8th 2019 so it's been out for six years and and that was when you ordered like 10,000 copies is that right uh that is that is when we had around 10,000 copies available yes um you only needed about 10 times more than that right yeah yeah um yeah in hindsight I wish I had made 100,000 absolutely um but so yeah that was six years ago and at that time truly I had no thought and even I would say a year or so later even after it was doing very very well I I was just thinking we continue to make wingspan make more copies of it reprint it make expansions for it and then around three and a half years ago we had a conversation internally at still Meer games um and honestly I don't remember who started it it might have been me it might have been somebody else but the conversation topic was is there a way that we can listen to the many fans who have started to who have said over the years can you make a you you know a dragon themed version a dinosaur version an insect version a cat version whatever you know people had a ton of ideas for how we could expand it and fish did come up to and we can we make this in a way that isn't um that isn't just reskinning the game I think that is maybe viable for some Publishers but it's not interesting for me to do that even you with your hunted series you're not reskinning anything you're you're going back to the drawing board it looks like every time to find the right mechanisms Right theme um and so

we we thought okay can we do this and how should we do this and the idea that came up was let's make one game that is slightly more complex than wingspan to cater to audiences who want have been a little bit heavier we decid debated between dinosaurs and dragons we went with dragons and then we thought can we go with something that's slightly less complex than wingspan something more accessible to maybe to kids who can't read yet um or basically an icon heavy version of of wingspan instead of depending on so much text uh we went with fish I don't know if we debated between another theme for that but but fish was the clear winner for that one that and then fin span just took longer to make them worm span and that's why it came out more recently worm span came out last year when did similar for for you how did uh when you were thinking about the hunted series when did you decide to make it a series and what did you map out the whole thing then or did you just a few other ideas so it's funny the original plan was to do mining Colony 415 which is kind of the aliens inspired version and it but it's dexterity based and during play testing and during development I was like man a lot of people just don't like dexterity even if it's good even if the dexterity is fun and engaging and a good you know mechanism there's a lot of people that as soon as they hear the word as soon as you say Dex like you ain't got to finish the word and they're like no I'm out I was like What if I made just a dice driven version as well totally different mechanism same core like every hunted game has the same like core the way the cards come out but then there's totally different other mechanisms going on so it was from the get-go two different games depending on your taste do you like dexterity you're really gonna like this one you don't like dexterity okay this one's over here really fun too you

know similar experience and I could do the you know Die Hard Theme as well that worked out um and so yeah from the beginning but it was more about demographics of like players and what they like from a mechanism standpoint and then later it was like oh I guess I could just kind of keep doing this I could make another game and just change the systems and change the mechanisms but one thing I wanted to do was if you've played one hunted game then you understand 75% of every other hunted game so talk to me about that as far as your your hyph and span games is that similar where you're like all right if you play one of these you're going to be able to jump right into any of the other ones that I that is certainly an asset I see for the games it's also um it's also in some ways potential for confusion for someone who comes into worms span thinking that they already know how to play uh and so in even in the worm rule book there's a section of it that says here's what's different about worms span I I really wanted to highlight it to make that clear I don't think I did the same thing in the fins span rulebook I don't know why but uh it made sense for worm spin at least or there was rule room in the rulebook to do so uh so yeah there there is that com but I think the the pro of having that similar to like what Ryan Lockett does at Red Red Raven games I love that he uses the same icons in so many games because I don't have to relearn a whole icon system even though it's a new game that I'm learning and for you found the same thing yeah oh definitely as far as icons Go 100% less cognitive load because again you already know a certain percentage of the game going in I even use the same icons like four totally different games you know one that saves me some money because it's less assets to have to create and less time and all that going back to Ryan Lockett another thing he really takes advantage of is putting the

games in the same world so he can really continue narratives he can have characters that show up in different games that are almost like Easter eggs for players that you know if you played above and below and near and far like you might be seeing some crossover you might be seeing some things you're like oh wait I remember that guy um so that's kind of a cool thing you can do that that really just kind of leans into your your customers that have bought more than one game right and giving them things that they can recognize and feel feel smart oh I remember that uh let me tell you about it that's kind of a cool moment as far as the as far as game design tell me your thoughts on the opportunity that game designers now have because all right Jamie stagmire has proven that he is making span a line of games me personally you know hunted is a line of games so I actually just I guess about a year and a half year year and a half ago I had a a guy reach out to me and said hey I've got an idea for a hunted game are you open to doing more the answer is yes if we can make money off of it let's do it this is a good and so that's when hunted Transylvania came about and interesting guy named Kyle and he and it's it's a good gamees but it's an opportunity for designers to go oh this publisher is already leaning into this what if I designed a game in that line and then pitch it to him so tell me your thoughts on that because there's definitely some pros and cons as far as time and and you know the opportunity if I pitch if I if somebody makes a hunted game and they pitch it to me and I don't like it it's not like you can take that somewhere else right PR you not take it somewhere else right but give me your thoughts on that are you open to more

hyphen span games from designers that is a good question Gabe I would say for there's almost two categories here one is a new game in the span line um I right now I'm kind of honestly I'm happy with three I know we could continue the series but there's there's a lot of uh effort that goes into a lot of room to grow and effort that goes into the expansions for those games so we have a lot to explore still with Dragons birds and and fish there's a lot of fish in the sea literally and a lot more birds to explore um and so I I wouldn't say right now that I'm looking to expand the the the span Universe um this the secondary part of that though is within the existing universe if someone comes to me and says hey I have an idea for a worm span expansion or I have an idea for a fin span expansion or even better than saying I have an idea for it I've already made 50 cards 50 fish cards um because I love sea turtles and I wanted to make a bunch of sea sea turtles um and generally my initial answer to that is still awesome go share it like we have ways for you to share that and you can get people's opinions on it and because we've done this with games that we publish where someone comes to us they say something like this and I say share it and people end up really loving what they they see and then I end up working with them the one caveat though that I wanted to ask you about as you said that though is for me there is a difference um work because the fan the span series is designed by other people I'm not the designer I'm the developer but not not the designer I

feel a different level of responsibility and kind of write a first refusal for those designers to be the the also the expansion designers opposed to a game that I've worked on like side where a fan came out with a wind gamut expansion or parts of that expansion and I you know I have full ownership of sidee it was easier for me to say yeah I want to work with you on this rather than having to go to someone else do you can you relate that at all with hunted because hunted is your thing it's entirely yours you don't have to go to somebody else oh that definitely makes it easier also from a contractual standpoint like several of the contracts I have with other designers have right of first refusal built in where if there's going to be an expansion or there's going to be a sequel prequel whatever then contractually that Designer gets so if another designer came and said hey I got this idea and I was like oh this is really cool oh let me go talk to Bob over here and see if he wants to be on board with it because it kind of needs to go through him you know and so I'm assuming you went to Elizabeth Hargrave designer of wingspan were like hey we got this idea we get this other designer is that how that kind of panned out yeah the f after we decided it was something that we were hoping to do the very first thing I did was go to Elizabeth to see if I could get her blessing for it and to see even if if she wanted to work on it but it was also an easy way for me to say you're so busy with wingspan and these other games that amazing and games that Elizabeth is making do could we work with someone else and you could be a developer on it yeah yeah and that just makes sense from a like you said time and Publishing standpoint because there's so many things people I just wish they would understand Kickstarter and gamefound backers especially they just don't and I love them they're

amazing they're awesome people I appreciate them back in the games but they don't have perspective they don't have the point of reference to understand everything that goes into something and they don't understand necessarily like a delay delays are weird too because things something happens and it's not like oh this is going to add eight extra hours I don't know maybe who knows you know delay is such a weird thing and um you know I try to with my Sol game of the month series I'm trying to get games to people in four months or less which is crazy it's kind of nuts to do that and unfortunately that means one week of delay all of a sudden feels different right if you're doing a big game it's going to take you a year a onee delay nobody even bats an eyelash but all of a sudden if that four month period turns into four months and two weeks people feel different it's because because March rolled into April like hey wait a minute and so anyway that's a whole another thing is from a publicy standpoint but well can I let me ask you about that I don't want to hearken on the point but because I'm so detached now from crowdfunding I follow what I'm a backer but I haven't created in that platform in a long time you're better for I don't have to deal with delays is it seems to me like my hope would be that we could be at a point now where um backers could see that a delay means that you are that it's either out of your control or that it's because you are trying to make the game the best game it can be and I would think that most backers would want the best version of the game not a rushed version of the game that that happens to arrive at a hypothetical time that you said it was going to be there have you seen that

change over time or are you still getting kind of that vocal minority that maybe you're referring to a little bit here 99% of the people 99.9 probably or what you're talking about they get it they they're like hey give us the best version without misprints without errors in the rule book we want the best possible experience you can have now there's there's still some limits on that like what I've run into with Robo mine it's taken so freaking long to finish and unfortunately I've been finishing it in public and we're going to talk about Vantage and your ability to finish in private because we we've been talking about that game for like eight years nine years maybe um so we'll talk about that in a second but um there's still some some lines that you know once something takes a long long time like robmont has even some of those people get frustrated but in general it's just a handful of people who are very loud online who post all sorts of comments and things but I've had people say in comments and actually you know a couple emails every now then they're like why don't you just finish it why don't you just finish like just finish it and put it out it's like think about that for a minute like would you tell GM or Ford just just throw a car together just put it out there what's the worst thing could happen no it's a terrible idea you know and with a game we can't we can't do automatic updates for games if there's a mistake then there's a mistake in all 5,000 copies 10,000 you know in your case you're printing 100,000 copies if you make a mistake it's multiplied 100,000 times and now you got to fix it or work around maybe you got to send out replacement parts so the advantage is take your time take a step back and that's one thing I've been talking to Publishers new Publishers especially

don't let the handful of people in the comments sway you one way or the other and we've talked about that I mean I think that was the first episode you and I ever did was the whole metal coins thing right where you could have been like you could have listened to backers and like all throw all the stuff in there put the metal coins in and then Stow Mar games probably wouldn't exist so you have to be careful and don't get discouraged um because a lot of people are fighting hard battles and unfortunately some of that hard battle sometimes spills out online and they take things out on other people and also sometimes people speak English as a third language and maybe they just didn't mean to be unkind or rude it's just you know that's the words they knew um and so you know I try to take everything gracefully and also not take comment seriously like if if someone's saying something I'm like oh that's kind of mean I bet they're just joking they're saying it with a laugh um that's been super helpful um but for the most part going back to your original 99% understand they get it they've probably backed more than one campaign and if you back more than one campaign you've backed a campaign that's been delayed you know Rob M's a little different and Advantage let's get into that so I think we first started talking about the game that eventually became Vantage in 2016 you and I were both were just in awe of Zelda breath of the wild we were just flabbergasted that a game could do those things and you and I both had the idea of like well how could you do that as a board game and I was working on an open world Fantasy game that eventually turned into roaman um a lot of those systems from way back then are in robmont you were working on a game that

is now Vantage and both of those games Lord willing are coming out this year right so you know eight nine years of working on something from a design standpoint talk to me about what you found over this long period designing a game truly epic in scale just enormous how many cards are in Advantage there are 1300 cards and 8 or and 400 of those cards are double-sided so there it's essentially 1,700 cards but of cardboard it's 1300 cards it's literally an entire planets worth of Art and content and story because every card is not just like one thing you've got like six options on every card which lead into more options so tell me this what you learned desig a game that took that long and was that just enormous in scale one of the things I think you can relate to that I learned is uh the psychological power like the of of incremental progression in terms of the design itself because when when I'm design when when I was designing this giant world if I made even a small change like when I decided that I wanted every and this actually isn't a small change but when I decided that I wanted every location to have all six action options on it that you can move that six different ways to interact with it move Look engage help take or overpower um when I made that decision because originally it was like two or three specific to that location and then I was like no I want to give players the freedom to interact with every location the way they want to when I made that

decision it was almost like I needed to take a step back because I was committing myself to probably an extra year of work to design all those actions it's impossible in a single day or a single week even for me to go through 800 different locations and add three to four actions to each of them so I really had to kind of give myself you mentioned the word Grace I think earlier I had to give myself the grace of saying I can't do this all at once but I can make a little difference every day I can move forward a little bit every day and that's okay and that feels good and I need to also encourage myself to do that because otherwise it's so daunting that I won't move forward on it I because you know finding three locations in a day that isn't that much when I have 797 more to go but that's three more than I had the day before so among many other design lessons that's something that I I really came to terms with have you can you relate to that at all with with your project something I tell myself all the time is no zero days yeah yeah right if I get one tiny say it's one tiny thing I don't have to do tomorrow you know one is greater than zero by an infinite standard you know so trying to do something you know matter how small just to move forward because it does add up over time and you know something I learned with these giant games something that's fun at the beginning might not be fun at all at the end and so you can't even really get a full perspective of how the game plays does it work is it truly fun until you have that entire you know or at least close to it a huge percentage of the game done and then you can play test that because that's what

ran into over the last couple months as the game is like in the home stretch you know I at that like 90% done 90% % left to go phase and what I realized play testing the bigger experience was like oh that system was really good in hours one through five in hours 20 through 25 not as much it kind of becomes a slog and a grind and how can I go back and fix some things and cut and change and do some things that make the game just as enjoyable to finish as it was to start because I think that's what a lot of games run into right I've talked to people who have finished Gloom Haven and they were like yeah like the ending yeah it's fine you know like the ending is not necessarily worth getting to according to them yeah I don't I don't know I can't speak for I haven't finished GL not my kind of game but and so I was thinking about that with my own game Ro M it's like I want people to finish the game and to go online and not give spoilers but to say You' gotta finish you've got to get to the end you will not believe the ending it is so cool it is so fun that's what I want at our 25 27 whatever it is and you know when you got these big I'm sure the same thing for Vantage like the ending has to live up to the X number of hours that somebody just put into it you know it's kind of like if you read a book or you watch a three-hour movie and then the ending is H like what a because that's what people remember they remember the end I had a great conversation with Jeff englin a while back and people remember like the last 15% of the experience that's why nobody remembers the interception or the fumble

somebody had in the first quarter they remember the two-minute drive at the end to win the game that's why Michael Jordan is revered as the greatest of all time not just because he won championships but how he won them he hit game-winning shots at the end of games it wasn't that he scored 40 That's he scored the right two at the right time and so you know finishing big epic games and even if you're just doing like a 60 Minute 90 minute game I think the same same thing applies it's just scale-wise so tell me about that did you run into any situations like that where you had to kind of go back you know first of all let me ask you this how long does vantage take on average to finish well that this is actually the interesting comparison between our two two games during the design process I heavily debated at different times if Fantage should be a campaign game or not a campaign game and I think maybe originally when I talked to you it probably at some point was a campaign game it didn't end up being one though it ended up I ended up deciding that I wanted it to be a in fact this was the thing that really convinced me to do it I found play testing it that um when you start every game of Vantage you crash land on the planet and you crash land on one of 126 different locations so it's never the same place or could be but odds are against it and I found that that moment in the game similar to starting a Rog like game like slay the Spire that moment of crashing starting from scratch not knowing where you're starting starting from with very little was was way more thrilling than I thought it would be and so whenever I was playing Vantage and play testing it I would get to a point usually maybe an hour or two into the game where I would be happy with the the experience it actually doesn't even always come down

to a thrilling climax Advantage which may hurt it may help it I don't know but it's uh usually about the journey for that that one to two hours um but I found myself getting to the point where I was like oh I'm really happy with where I am I'm really powerful now the game leveled me up pretty fast but I'm kind of looking forward to that next game where I can start over from scratch again and crash landine on this planet and see what happens and so play play testing it helped me realize that it was probably not the best for a campaign game and that I could make it a standalone game and I'm kind of excited to see what people think about it it's a little bit different in that way yeah that's interesting I think it's a good choice one because I think sleeping Gods ran into this where it's hard to end a game like that that has so many options so many variables and so many things and it's hard to design a game that you're not entirely sure when a player is going to reach this card do they get it early middle or late are they overpowered underpowered it's it's I mean it's almost impossible to design and unfortunately like video games can do it because they can just scale right oh you got to this place at this level well the enemies are going to scale up depending on your level you know I think the Witcher does that in some other games and that makes it a little easier from design standpoint well we don't have that advantage and so I think doing it your way where you're like every game is a new narrative that is going to reveal itself through play but let me ask you this what is what is the W and I don't think this a spoilers what's the win condition for each game like how do you know when the game is technically over yeah um you you are going to the planet for a reason so that's you're one of 21 different missions like why are you going here in the first place why did you decide to go that's that's one if

you accomplish that goal um two and you don't have at the beginning of the game but whatever your final destination is like did you decide to escape from the planet did you decide to make a home here and those are things that you discover and unlock during the game um wherever you're going to end up so you can win that way you can win by finding that and doing that or you can win with an epic victory of doing both so accomplish your mission and have a final destination whatever you decide that may be and then even really late in the process I added another one which isn't really a win condition but it's an end condition that just says if you set aside two hours to play Vantage today and you play two hours of Vantage you had a journey you can call it you can call it and that's the game I don't think many mo most people probably won't play that way um and it's not really you know there's no climax there at all youve you've just just said to finish playing but at certain times I think I I want to to give people permission to do that to not feel like they needed to get to that ending in case they were in case they saw another two hours of the game to come and they didn't have time at their game night yeah that makes sense more gamers in general just by nature of it are natural rule followers and so as a designer when you give them a rule that says hey when you hit two hours the game's over oh that's part of the game that's not like me ditching the game it's literally part of the experience that the designer intended I think that makes a lot of sense and I'm glad you put that in there just for for people because sometimes again you are not able to play test every single variable right the game when it comes out will get played more on day one than probably you had number of play tests and so more than likely there's going to be some odd little variables and you

know interesting things that happen maybe there's an infinite Loop you didn't know about because you didn't play test the game 40,000 times and so you know to give your players an out that way and that's one thing I'm so with ran being a campaign of a to B to C to D now there's all sorts of different ways you can get different places and it's got some open world nature to it but it's still one story with the beginning a middle and an end and just being afraid as a designer of like putting the number in the wrong place where somebody gets stuck and they needed a number 12 but accidentally put 17 and it's like I don't know and now can ruin the experience and so that's thing is like take your time make sure the numbers are right U don't rush it you know there's no there's that whole like you get one first impression like when people play the game for the first time it needs to be the best it could be but anyway I'm excited for Vantage man I'm really looking forward to when does it come out uh right now we're looking it's in production now so we're looking at Midsummer right before Gen Con I think is when when we're expecting to have it and I'm also a backer of of your game so I am whenever whenever it's ready I'm I'm ready to play it yeah sitting on G waiting on oh man I had a great U conversation with the artist earlier today about some things that are I mean we're in that home stretch and uh he's excited too he's been working on this for a long time he's like we need to work on something else need to get another game I I know we gota finish this one but um yeah it's getting there well Jamie this been great man any other kind of design related things you've been seeing you've been noticing um anything else that you feel like would be a good like any recent blog post trying to think of other blog post you've had recently you had your your stakeholder one that was always that's always fun to look at and to see how the

numbers are panning out and um from a design standpoint any thoughts on there oh let's um let me ask you this I me to ask you this earlier yeah odd themes stamp swapping an odd theme you know no one's like hey what's the what are the top 10 themes this year nobody's like oh swapping stamps like fish fish are G to be big this year although like I feel like last year mushrooms was big like there's like 14 games about mushrooms so it's kind of an odd three so you know when you get a game either you design or or pitched it's got an odd theme tell me about that because that's not necessarily a slam dunk it's not like zombies or fantasy are like oh there's a huge market for this how do you know to go with swapping stamps well for stamp swap we we considered a bunch of different themes it was designed with the stamp theme and then I kind of just poked at it I was like should we do this like is this is this the theme for this game um and I don't even entirely know if we made the right choice I I like that I like I like the way it worked out but there were certainly other possibilities I think in general as a as a publisher um if someone comes to me I'm not looking for any specific theme if someone comes to me with a theme and they design some really cool mechanisms around that theme and the theme makes sense for the mechanisms and vice versa and especially if that theme might stand out a little bit might be a little different than a lot of other games that maybe have a similar theme uh that's probably going to elevate it for me a little bit more um that's where I am right now on it that might change over time because I think there's a risk whenever I do that

thing might that I'm I'm looking at our list of games right now on my other screen just to see what outlandish themes have worked I mean birds birds was a little bit of a oh yeah unexpected unexpected nobody thought that's why you printed 10,000 right as a bird game like what are the odds of this is going to sell a million zillion copies apparently 100% yeah but yeah I mean sometimes it's just the way it goes and recently I had a game pitched to me that you know doing solo games doing small boox solo games the whole like 2 by3 grid on a card is so normal like there's so many games that just have a grid and you put cards on top of each other like there's a million of those games button shy has made several really good ones and I had a game like that with that core mechanism pitched to me and I was watching the video was like a three minute video overview of the game in the first 30 seconds I was like oh oh another one of those but at like you know the 37 second Mark the designer was like but here's the Twist and I was like oh oo that's different that's new I haven't seen a game do that before and so I think that's another thing is an opportunity for a designer take something that is tried and true but put a really cool spin on it put a new hook on it put a new twist and make it very different in that way where people can go oh I get it oh that's cool that's a whole new way to do that thing that I already like so I think that's that's a really cool way to do things and this mechanical right so it's not just themes necessarily it's like tried and true but like also mechanically you think do that

as well yeah I think it goes both ways I I like the mechanical twist and I like that that it's almost kind of impressive that that person that Designer LED with something that you were familiar with and then threw the twist in there I like that but I think it works for themes too and I even for a theme that has been done many times I still I will never forget a vast I didn't play vast many times I don't know if remember vast it it was before super asymmetrical game right super asymmetrical game where the hook was one person so it's like a dungeon crawling game asymmetric where one player plays as the cave itself that is a great hook that is a great Twist on it so I I think it's possible to take an existing theme and look at it from a different angle and make it stand out yeah I agree dead of winter did a great job with that it's a zombie game but not really the zombies are just part of the setting there's side SI is a great example you know people see side they're like oh this is GNA be a giant war game they like well no that's the setting but there's a lot of other stuff going on and you know like anything else you're going to gain people you're going to lose People based on those things and that's okay um a lot of it just becomes making sure you're marketing to the right people to find the right Gamers for your game so the right people buy it and the right people put it on their table and play it and enjoy it and you know that's Universal well cool man we kind of closing out any any other thoughts any encouragement to designers in this time of again the bar being super high production levels and marketing and all art super high what would you tell designer especially new designers as Jamie STM who's been doing this a while as an encouragement well one thing I'll throw out there to to tie into a topic that we talked about

earlier is we talked about games that play well at one or two players and one thing I would say that I've learned is that you don't have to be good at both of those things I think both of them are important for a game to have but I think it's okay for you to specialize in one of those two things if you want and maybe trust if you work with a publisher that they can maybe bring the other angles in if they want it to so they if you design a solo game and the publisher says oh this is could to be this could be a solo Co-op or this could be a four-player game they can do that with them or if you design a game that plays from to five players but you don't know solo modes all that well that's okay too a publisher can help you out with that so give give yourself I think the permission to focus on the thing that excites you the most and that you were good at and maybe trust a publisher to bring in those other elements that you aren't as good at yeah I agree not not every game needs a solo mode that's true sometimes thing people get a little overthinking about it and it's like hey it's okay if it works great but you don't want to put a solo mode in there and then have a solo gamer buy your game and it be a lackluster experience you know um I think it was Ted ok who I interviewed years ago and he was talking about how so often companies try to throw that extra player in there like your games your games go up to five players but I'm assuming the the gamep playay at five is just as fun as the Gameplay at four and the Gameplay at three well that's not always the case and sometimes Publishers put that extra number in there on the one or the five or the six whatever but the experience is not as enjoyable and the problem with that is at game night if I bring the new shiny game and everybody wants to play

it well we're going to play it at the max player count and if that is not the best experience or at least a really really good experience then everybody's gonna walk away from that game going me it was okay but if they had played it at three they would have been like oh this is the best game of the year but and so I think that's nothing to think about Again Play testing and development or pivotal in that and figuring out like what is the best experience and then Having the courage as a publisher to say hey this is only a two to three player game it you could play it at four but it's not fun I feel I feel like Gamers would have more appreciation and respect for a publisher being like don't play this at four this is a two to three-player game and putting that on the box as opposed to putting four on there for the money sake you know and so it's one thing I love about your games they go up to five but the experience at five is really good you know because you put so much time into it so a lot of people can learn from that but Dy man really appreciate your time dude um excited for Vantage I'm excited for the other stuff you got coming out um I'm looking for Pokemon span is there a Pokemon span coming out anytime soon we we I we reached out to the Pokemon company years ago and they they weren't they weren't interested but we at a different place now so we might we might reach out again sometime well we could do robam mpan if my game takes there you go does well yeah we work together on Rob mpan yeah that'd be fun but anyway jimy I know you gotta go appreciate your time man good luck with vage good luck with all the other cool stuff got coming out everything else you got going on same to you yeah I appreciate it

Progress saved