Board Games I Got Rid Of (And Why) - Episode 30
Transcript
hey everybody and welcome to another episode of board games I got rid of and why so in this series I take a look at a bunch of board games that I used to have in my collection but for one reason or another no longer do and I tried to give some reasoning as to why I came to the decision to part with them and before I get started on these 10 games I want to give a shout out to the show's sponsor keyienda dot Co dot UK who are my go to online retailer and if you use the link in my show notes or the QR code then you can get five percent off your first order the first game I'm talking about today is um now om is a midweight euro game with some pretty cool mechanisms involved particularly the main action selection system as you have this three by three grid of tiles and each round you're drawing a tile blindly from a bag and you're pushing that towel in a direction on that grid and the three tiles you have remaining in that grid on the same row or column that you've just pushed onto are these three actions you get which of course will change the game State for the next player because the tiles are going to be in a different orientation and these actions are going to be pretty simple such as just getting money and they could be moving your boat along this track to kind of um start generating your victory points uh but you could also get these kind of um Guild crests which would give you access to certain actions depending on where you were on that um on that Canal or on that River so I did like the I did like the way that two of these mechanisms
synergize with each other um I thought that this game was quite well polished and well designed but I did have one glaring issue with it and that was when it came to these cards that were involved so um some of these actions were drawing these action cards and basically they would have different conditions on them and there'd be two different conditions you could have like an in-game condition and an end game kind of set collection condition and what I found was that generally speaking the in-game conditions were pretty swingy and quite luck dependent because quite a lot of the time you'll draw the perfect card that just so happened to see what your current condition was and you get a bunch of points for that without doing much work at all where sometimes you'll get nothing at all so it's like it was a bit I don't know it's a bit jarring for me and it could leave a little bit of a sour taste in your mouth just because maybe your opponent got a great card draw and you didn't um other than that though the game was well designed as I said um some good timing exercises going on here some good kind of um engine building abilities as you could invest in these buildings on the board where if people visited them you'd get more points if people took certain actions on that grid you can get some income as well but yeah ultimately that card the card mechanism did not do it for me and it was enough for me to part with this one and not go back to it anymore but I know this game does have its fans it's a bit of um it's a bit of a cult favorite I suppose but it wasn't quite up to well wasn't quite what I was looking for I suppose simply because of that swinginess of the cards next up I
have gun kimono now on paper I should love this game because you couldn't really get more of a kinesian design despite not being designed by Rhonda kanitzia and this is a tile placement game as you're placing these kind of domino shaped tiles onto this communal map you're trying to get areas and put your pagodas down in order to start generating new victory points each round depending on your coverage um on that map you can stack tiles on top of each other meaning that you can start encroaching those other players regions and of course they can sabotage Yours by making your region smaller um if you don't want to add it onto the board itself you could choose to climb these tracks which will start getting your points if you climb up there quicker and even unlocking you more pagodas as you go a very smooth game very definitely um definitely fine-tuned um but I struggle to find where the crunchy decisions came from here it seemed like it would always be quite formulaic somebody would create a big region start getting loads of points people would start sabotaging it the next person would have the biggest region therefore this starts to advertising that one so it was pretty predictable on what you should do I've just increased your own regions and make other people's regions smaller and you know the top placement wasn't particularly taxing because it was just simple dominoes but I did like the purity of the game but I did think it's slightly missed out on that magical spark and that really kept me once wanted me to come back for more for this one because I did play it
quite a few times and I really did feel that there was something here that I should be I should be feeling but I never really got that despite giving it more than enough chances so I'm sadly I couldn't really recommend this one despite me wanting to love it um that is gunkamono next up I have a doppelganger this is a silly little party game where you are drawing the celebrity cards and you're discussing who amongst your friends is most like that celebrity it could be personality wise it could be I mean physical traits um and you are having a voting system to see you know who who vote to the majority uh who's working for somebody on their own they might suffer some negative points um and so on so yeah very simple stuff here it's a one-trick Pony um as a kind of a palette cleanser it does a good job you know we tend to play Euro games and this one being some something completely different um it brought something different to the table and we did enjoy it for that one play but some once you've gone through the cards you've said what you need to say there's pretty much no reason to go back to this one so it's a gimmick um it's maybe a fun one to play a gathering or something like that but um it's certainly not going to stay around for more than one or two plays um maximum so that is doppelganger next up I have Mercado so Mercado is a game that's somewhat flown under the radar it's a really good Dawn design and I believe it came out the same time as games like the quacks of credenberg were really blowing up um because this one does share quite a
few things with quacks as you're drawing these tokens through a bag and in this one instead of doing like a push you like mechanism you are assigning these tokens to these different kind of objects on the table which have requirements on them so it might say if you draw two blue tokens and a white one then you can click this tile and get x amount of points now everybody is fighting over these artifacts at the same time so it does have this kind of a race element to it and it's all about how are you going to divide up the tokens that you draw because you could say you know I'll I'll tribute this one to this tile this one to this tile this one to this tile but there's always that sudden death thing going on and you don't want to spread yourself too thin but at the same time you want to keep your options open and it has a racing mechanism to it as it's going to be the first to get to a certain amount of points and there's even a somewhat of a timing exercise as if you land your points marker on certain locations then you can get little bonuses such as those wild white tokens or even shedding these dud black tokens from your bag which do nothing but clog up your bag um it's a really nice match it's very smooth and it's way better than it actually sounds um but I think maybe I don't know maybe this one got lost in the shuffle um because I think the the gameplay and the visuals don't quite match up because there's a very fat family friendly fun Breezy game but the kind of art Direction it went in was a bit more of a traditional Euro stuffy beige kind of visual aesthetic which was a bit of a mismatch but the game itself I think is
underrated and um if you can find this one cheap which you probably can it's worth a shot but ultimately this one was on my show for a long time and I never really found myself leaning to um to put it off the shelf and I do have the quacks of credenberg which I think is a better game albeit there's a bit more setup Etc um but this one's worth a look but maybe if you have games like this it's not quite it doesn't have quite as much going on as that aforementioned quack sequeline book next up I have what the actual factual now this is actually in the same series of games as the Apple mentioned doppelganger but this one you are going to be um given a very difficult question a very um Niche uh question and then everybody is going to write what the answer could possibly be as a kind of a bluffing tool to try to get the other people to vote for that answer but of course the correct answer is also going to be uh in the mix there's going to be a voting system if you get the answer correctly you're going to get some points if people vote for your false answer then you're going to get some points as well so there's been a lot of games like this um you know tons of them out there but this one was a good example of it some interesting questions some of them were much more difficult than others some of them there's just no chance you'd get them but as little factoids it was quite an interesting deck of cards and you could use them for other games um but you know for me explaining the rules you'd probably understand what this game is like there's tons of them out there they've been around forever but this is a strong example that you
can get quite a few game sessions out of if you regularly get past the games to the table so if that's your jam then this one's definitely worth a look but we played through the deck of cards therefore there was no reason for us to go back to it anymore next up I have first rat now first fret is going to be a difficult game for me to comment on because just reading it on this list um makes me doubt my decision as to why I called this one from the collection and because this is a fantastic game it's a family game but with plenty of decisions to be made as you're moving your team of rats up this track collecting resources treating these resources in for bonuses or points um taking shortcuts building up a bit of an engine to increase your yields getting these special powers racing to get to the spaceship at the top and it's one of those games where you are rewarded for being the fastest at doing something so if somebody is taking this strategy you might want to go this strategy because there's more points to be had there so there really is a sense of sense of urgency um in this game which I love very simple rule sets very fun um and yeah as I said I am probably going to reacquire this one now the reason I got rid of it in the first place was because when I originally um acquired it I played it quite a lot and maybe burnt myself out on it um and it was sat on my shelf for a long time thinking oh I didn't really have the urge to pull it back because I kind of got it out of my system but for me this is the kind of game I want in my collection because it does work out a
fine line of being so accessible but still having some meat on the bones here as well as being wrapped up in a really Charming package so um stay tuned I'll probably end up reacquiring first rats next up I have Golem so Golem um is an interesting one so this is actually from some of my favorite designers from the kind of Italian um group of designers um this is definitely a heavy Euro as you are moving these Golems down these three streets I'm getting bonuses as you go trying to keep your little students up of them or suffer some potential negative um effects um you are building up an engine by increasing the abilities of your Golems your increasing your kind of artifacts your building climbing tracks um has a very interesting drafting mechanism to take your actions based on the um Grand Austria Hotel rule sets where and this one you actually um kind of putting these marbles in these runs and kind of the more marbles in that particular column of marbles will be the stronger action you take but the color of marble is also important because that's going to allow you to move your particular students on these tracks to keep up with the Golems I'm definitely systems within systems here tons of symbology tons of rules and the game is very good you know there's no denying that at all and the reason I called this one was probably more of a um a personal thing in relation to where I am in my kind of um my preferences in gaming now a few years ago I was very much into my
heavier euros now I prefer it more at that medium weight um but still with the depth involved now this one I thought was just a little move the needle a little bit too far for me I'm in terms of the rules overhead and again look quite a lot of fiddiness going on here and it's not the kind of game that I can just put off the shelf and you know internalize the rules and get it played very soon um because again there are so many rules within rules here so despite me thinking it's a very well designed game um it's not really what I was looking for in my collection because I just tend to struggle to get these games to the table because you need the right game group you need quite a large amount of time because it's a two-hour game at least um and it you know you need to be in the right headspace because it's going to be a brain burner and for me I'm trying I'm I'm tending to find those games not as enjoyable as something a bit lighter nowadays so it wasn't quite right for me um and what I'm looking for now hence why it had to go but still objectively a very well designed Euro next up I have which Stone which is a rhino cancer game and it's something quite different to what kinesi has been putting out in terms of recent years because this is definitely a more involved game as compared to his kind of more common kind of card games and filler games um this one is a series of mini games kind of held together through this total placement system as you have your own little cauldron and you're placing these tiles out trying to tie certain symbols
together to get stronger benefits so the more you connect a certain symbol that action is going to become stronger and stronger and stronger but it becomes quite puzzly because you are limited in what you can place at any time you are going around this rondelle when generating your victory points you're building up routes on this communal board with your witches and you are trying to collect these contracts and fulfill them as much as you can I'm climbing up this wand and trying to um tile it up in terms of things you're doing in the rest of the game so definitely um kind of yeah a series of mini games here are held together through that core tile placement system it's a hell of a lot of fun it's very satisfying it's fast and it's pretty damn great now the reason I got rid of it is because a very close friend of mine has a copy I'm always looking for a reason to trim my collection down and if my friend has a copy then um that's a great valid reason for me to call the game from my Personal Collection because I can play it um any time so that's the only reason really if my friend didn't have a copy I'd probably still own this one um and it was definitely one of my favorite games of the year it came out which I think was probably two years ago now um but still yeah a lovely game um again it straddles that line of being very easy to play very satisfying terms um a good forward momentum um and yeah just a lot of fun really so that is which Stone simply called because somebody else has it and I can access it anytime next up I have Murano which is another mid-weight Euro this
one you are trying to aim towards these private objectives um which can be a ton of different things and they generally tie to these buildings that you are kind of erecting on the board You're Building these Pathways and these pedestrians are going to come out um you are very carefully managing your income because if I remember right the the financials in this game were quite tight and it's held together through this rondelle system as you're moving these gondolas around the parameter of the board and depending on where you land is the action you can take but all these different pieces are moved communally so um you have to be quite careful to not give your opponent too many opportunities and the game could become quite congested at times as all the actions would kind of get bunched up down the bottom of the board or in a certain area of the board meaning you had to spend quite a bit of money to kind of um change the orientation of these boats on that run down which I thought was actually a weak point in the game I thought that congestion came into play a bit too often and you can feel a little bit of hamstrung as to the actions you could take I also felt like the luck factor in this game was it didn't quite gel with the rest of it and for example there was this lucky dip system where you could draw these um tokens or these little gems from a bag which would be a quite a strong way of getting income and again that swinginess of the car drawers in this game was very significant for me um it kind of had that I always call it the takaido effect if you're familiar with that game where sorry takanoko
effect where you could have the perfect orientation of what you need draw a car that just so happens to match your board State and you've basically banked a bunch of points here without doing much work at all or you've not really earned those points and that's what this game had in Spades really and it did feel quite unsatisfying and it I didn't really enjoy it for that reason um I did like the way you had to commit your workers to different Islands to correspond to those goals um but because it was a kind of a free-form liquid thing you didn't really have to lock in what you wanted until the very end and just through sheer car drawing you could always keep improving your score by sheer luck really a hard game to explain I'd recommend you check out my video review of this one to maybe get some more insight as to why this game didn't gel with me but um yeah after playing this one I wasn't really um I wasn't really impressed by it to say the least and I thought it would be because I did like the rule set but that card swinginess just did not do it for me and the final game I'm talking about this episode is already set best now this game is basically a horse racing uh simulation where you can either use an app or you can do it manually but essentially tons of dice are going to be rolled and depending on the combination of dice rolled um the certain horses are going to move and in real time you are placing bets on the horses
um but of course if you bet on something um and somebody's already gone there then you're going to be blocked out of spaces therefore there's that risk and reward you know am I going to go early and try that on this one um where of course there are tons of variables that could happen or am I going to wait till later until it's more of a short bet but of course that betting space could be taken um by then there are some extra rules you could add into the game such as these specialist bets which add a bit more advanced and more very kind of particular circumstances on these bets but they will give you bigger Rewards and that's essentially what it is it's a simulated um horse race in real time and definitely a high energy game um and it's great for parties because it scales so well people are going to know what they're doing here because everybody innately knows how horse racing works there's not really any rules you need to explain or anything uh like that it definitely feels like a throwback style of game but with that touch of modernity with the um with the apps Etc now when I initially played this one I was quite impressed with it I thought it did what it did very well um I did like the way the app works the app works um and I found it fun but for me the gimmick and the novelty of it wore off pretty quickly and I did have a few games of this one where I introduced it to different groups and it just went down like a lead balloon nobody really got invested and it just did not it did not do what it was supposed to do um which of course um maybe styled the experience for me
because you want people to enjoy these games and if they're not enjoying it then it makes you doubt getting it to the table again because you have those bad memories assigned um to it and that was kind of what I was left with this one I thought it was fine I could definitely see why people like it but I would rather play games like long shot the dice game and I'd even rather play camel up than this one because they're a bit more board gamey rather than just a simulation so um yeah it's good for a game or two but after that the the novelty did wear off you know pretty rapidly so that is already set bet so there we have it that concludes the video hopefully you have enjoyed it and found it useful if you have please be sure to hit like And subscribe to my channel and check out my other content too but for everybody else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye-bye