Finding Six Hidden Gems on Your Game Shelves - Lost In The Shuffle
Transcript
Board games, we love them. You got them. We're going to look at your shelfies and let as few of them as possible get lost in the shuffle. Happy shelfie day, Grant. I love these episodes. I love just looking at people's board game collections, you know? We all do that. Like we love going into different stores or people's game, you know, rooms or things like that and you just walk around and take it all in, you know? It's fascinating. Yeah, it's always always so interesting to see what games other people have on their shelves and I'm always surprised that there are so many board games that are out there. You can look at another person's collection with hundreds of games. It's surprising how little overlap there can be sometimes. I know so many games. You know so many games and yet I can look at someone's shelf and there's always something I'm like, I've never heard of that. What is that game? Tell me about that game, you know? So that is what we are going to share with you today.
Because few actually months ago at this point, we put out the call to viewers to post their shelfies on our Blue Sky account and we received quite a few. In fact,
Thank you so much.
So today we're going to take one of those shelfies that was submitted and we're going to go through it with you to pick out game we think is an underrated gem, a game we want to play right now and maybe some other little favorites.
Yeah, I want to talk about a game that I've never played that's on your shelf that I really want to try sometime.
Twist. Good twist. So we're going to dive right into a game shelfie that was submitted by viewer Evan Diesel.
Yeah, thanks again for sending it.
Yeah, and Evan actually is a frequent contributor to the comments and has his own YouTube channel. To help him be checked out, I'm going to put the name of his YouTube channel right there on screen and down in this video's description.
Nice.
Yes. So here we go.
All right, so the first thing that I'm seeing, I'm already excited, what a collection of like big beefy fellas. Like there's not a lot of small box games in here. There's a lot of like big beefy games on the shelf. You know, that's always fun to see, too, when you're like, "Okay, okay, I get what Evan's like Evan wants the like the bigger experiences." And that's cool, man.
And also, I see a nice range of years here. I see some games like El Gaucho. That was 2010?
Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. And you know, right next door to that almost, you got Caylus, which there we're talking old school. Wow.
For sure. Yeah. But then you got Wonderland's War.
Yeah, one of my favorite games of all time.
Uh-huh.
But I'll tell you, Wonderland's War would be, you know, we're talking about a game we want to play right now. And Wonderland's War would certainly be up there for me. But I have legitimately been thinking recently that I'm like, "Man, it's been a while since I played Creature Comforts. I need to play Creature Comforts again." I really like the game. I really like the series. There was another game that came out in the same series by Roberta Taylor, the designer and the publisher, Kids Table [clears throat] Board Games, Maple Valley. I really liked that.
Maple Valley, yeah.
Yeah, that one came out and then there was a game called Cafe Barista that I really liked. And now they're getting ready to release River Market, which is like the next game in that series. And it's been a long time since I played Creature Comforts, the original game in that series. And I want to play that again. And for anybody that doesn't know, Creature Comforts does this really fun thing where it's a worker placement game, but you need both a worker and a dice to go to
Mhm.
the spot. Like And so you can assign some workers into safe spaces, if you will, but then you have to roll dice. And so you could put a worker somewhere, but you're like, "I need a five or a six."
Mhm.
If I don't roll a five or a six, that worker is wasted. And I love strategic games that still have that element of surprise, that element of excitement. And I think Creature Comforts did it really well.
I have heard nothing but good things about it. I really like it. It's very cute. The only sort of detriment that I would say is that coming from a game called Kids Table Board Games with pretty cute art, you might think that like, oh, this is like a kids game and you might not play it because of that reason and it really isn't. Like, sure, if you have a kid that plays a lot of games and it is it is an advanced gamer, they could play this game, but like it's not meant for kids. This is an adult game that just happens to be put out by a company named Kids Table Board Games. So, yeah.
So, that was one that you haven't played, but you want to.
No, no, that was the one I want to play right now.
the one you want to play right
That's the one I love. Creature Comforts was in my top 10 of the year it came out and it's probably been a couple years since I've played it. And I have played other games in that series, but as more games in that series come out, I'm like, I should play the original one again. Like, I want to I I have legitimately been thinking like, I need to I need to pull that off my shelf again cuz it's been a few years.
Okay, okay. Oh boy, so many good games to choose from here. Yeah. Okay, well, the game I want to play right now, you know, I have a game that has been on my shelf for probably over a decade at this point, which I have not been able to get to the table just because Yeah, when I got it, it was a little older already, but uh but then that's El Gaucho right there.
Okay. And if anybody doesn't speak Spanish, that's the Gaucho. So.
Thank you.
So, it's an educational program. Now, El Gaucho is one where you have these little like you make these little 3D constructed pens to put your little cattle and stuff in. I believe that they're dice. And you're basically just managing these cattle and such. And it's admittedly, it is a game that I got, read the rules, wanted to play it, but you know that old trap of something newer, shinier came along. People wanted to gravitate towards that. So, it's been so long that if I did play El Gaucho, I would have to go and relearn it by by this point.
Oh, you don't remember these rules from 10 years ago?
I know, yeah. That I read one weekend and got really excited about. But, if if El Gaucho hit the table, I would jump in and play it right now. I don't know why I wouldn't. I don't know why I wouldn't.
I believe I might. How's that for a noncommittal answer? hung on to it though potentially for this long without having played it. You really want to play this game.
Yeah.
Okay. So, if there's a game on this list that I find is kind of a hidden gem or an underrated game, uh it is we can't see the whole box here, but there is a game sort of in the middle bottom of the photo called Feierabend, which is a game that we like at my house a lot. Like that is still one that we'll pull out every once in a while. It's still one that I have on my shelf. It is a worker placement game. And it's a really good sort of more introduction to worker placement game. The theme works really well. It's sort of like, you know, uh the working class standing up to the bosses and being like, "Yeah, I'm going to work some, but I'm also going to take vacation. And I'm also going to I need a good work-life balance." And so, in the game, you are going to work and doing stuff, but you're also like going on trips and balancing your work with your personal life. And like you can go to sort of like protest and it and stuff like that. And I just I think it's a theme that is done really well.
And, you know, I think it's a pretty big box, and I imagine some people thought the game was going to be heavier than it actually was. You know, it's it's maybe medium weight, but on like the low end of like maybe the high lighter weight to lower medium weight sort of place. Like if I if I saw the complexity on BGG, I feel like it would probably something like uh a 2.2. Well, now I got to look that up. Now I got to see what But, I feel like it's probably something around there. It's quirky. A lot of his games are quirky.
quite. Yes.
Uh and so, you know, it definitely does have some like quirk and some charm to it, but that's one of the reasons I like it for sure. So,
Nice.
Yeah, that's uh that's my sort of underrated Jim, how do you spell it? Why am I How do I figure it out find it? Oh, there it is. Fearband. I said 2.2 uh complexity. Oh, they have it at a 2.6. So, they have it higher than I would have expected, but it's also not that hard to jump into.
Well, to me, there is definitely a hidden gem on this shelf. It's actually sitting on the top of the shelf, kind of the center there. And it's this game Dropmix.
Oh, I've never played it.
I played it, and I've never played another game quite like it.
That's the one that has like the technology aspect, right?
This came out around 2017. Um I I I remember I played it when it came out at the very first PAX Unplugged.
Mhm.
Uh the cards have these RFID tags in them.
Yeah, yeah.
And that's used to create sets and mixes and such with the game. And so, yeah, it incorporates technology that way. It's It's one of these games I believe it used an app. I think the app has been discontinued maybe at this point.
Oh, wait. So, can you still play the game without the app?
You know, to be honest, I'm not sure. Um maybe Evan down in the comments can let us know, and maybe I'll pin that comment or something. It might be a case where you can maybe not update the app anymore, but maybe you can find it floating around. Or if you already have the app, you can still use it. I honestly don't know. It would be wonderful if it got resuscitated or something revived because again, it was a game I have not seen another game use the you know, the built-in RFID codes and tags in them.
remember people talking about it and being like, "It's one of the most unique experiences I've ever had in playing board games, and I wish the technology worked flawlessly every time, but it didn't.
I think that's fair. I think there were plans to make additional games using that technology, and yeah, Drop Mix was kind of more than a proof of concept, and more than a prototype, but you know, yeah, that first-generation technology, there's always going to be bugs to work out.
In a world where, you know, 3,000 new games come out a year, it's hard to be memorable and different.
Yes.
I do remember playing it thinking I kind of like this. This is neat. But also thinking it was a pretty light game.
Sure, sure.
But uh still, you know, the potential, I believe, was there.
Yeah. Have you ever played other games um where you're like, "Oh man, this thing was so innovative and cool, and the rest of the game maybe didn't work, but now someone else is going to come along and take that one really awesome aspect and then make a better game out of it?"
There's the game from the early '90s from Richard Garfield, uh Filthy Rich, which uses uh the binder that you put cards uh it's like a a 3x3 card sleeve binder for sports cards or trading cards, and it uses that to create the playing field.
Oh, interesting.
I have never seen another game use that. I've been waiting for someone to take that idea, and it also fits the criteria for what you described because the rest of the game was not quite
Yeah, yeah.
fully baked.
Yeah, sometimes that happens where you're like, "I can't wait for someone to do that thing, that one thing, better, you know?"
Yeah, so I can think of a very specific example now. Okay.
And so, last, I want to talk about a game on your shelf that I have never played that I really want to play, and for me, that is the game Septima. This is a game that looks so I love the artwork and the look of Septima. And I actually, even before it came out, I I it at a convention, I don't GenCon or something like that. And I rarely sit down for demos. You just don't have That was a game I sat down and demoed for like 30 or 45 minutes. Not a full game of it, but like certainly multiple turns and stuff like that. And I was like, "This is really cool." And I love player interaction in games. And so I remember there being that that aspect of Septima where it's like, "Ooh, if I go if I play a card that combos with someone else's card, then we both get an extra benefit." And I love the mind games of that of thinking what someone else is going to play. And and I've never played it. I've never played a game of Septima.
I don't have it. And you know, I've heard some people who love it and I've heard other people they're like, "Yeah, it wasn't exactly what I expected." And and maybe didn't like it as much, but like
way.
Yeah, that's fair. That's fair. But that's one that's always been on my like want to play list that I've never played.
Well, I have played Septima.
Oh, yeah.
After avoiding it actually for a very long time because I thought it was going to be a little too much. I was thinking it was going to be a little bit more in the vein of like Anachrony and other things, but no, it was actually very approachable. It was very intuitive. Everything you're doing thematically made sense. Yeah, and there was you know, there's a track over here. You got the cards you're playing. You got the areas over here that you're going through.
Yeah.
Um it was one of the few games that I would say actually it has an expansion, but I think it's actually the better perhaps without the expansion.
Oh, interesting. Okay.
I would play it again and I would actually happily play it without the expansion.
Okay. Nice. That was the one I also remember being excited about because before Septima, like you were saying, Mindclash, who puts that game out, had only put out big heavy games. And this was more of a medium weight game. I'm just not a heavy gamer. And so when this one came out, I was like, "Ooh, a Mindclash game that I like I've heard so many good things about their other games. I just haven't wanted to play them and this is one I want to play. And then they've since come out with other sort of, you know, medium weight games that I have loved. Like I loved Ember Heart and I loved um Astra and I loved Ironwood and stuff like that all from them, but I still haven't played Septima.
Well, I think it's worth giving it a try. I think that you would enjoy playing it.
All right. I think I would too.
Oh yeah. Well, the game that I haven't played yet, but I want to very much is actually right there the tippy tippy top of the photo and that is the stand-alone expansion to Fromage Fromaggio.
Oh yeah.
Yes. I actually have it. I think still in shrink right over there on that shelf. My wife and I were introduced to Fromage a few months ago. So when I saw Fromaggio become available, it was like, I want to play this with her.
Totally.
And so yeah, so it's like I scooped it right up. That's one of my weak spots. It's like, oh my wife wants to play it, scoop that guy right up.
That is an easy game to get to the table when I have a partner who wants to play it.
Yeah, yeah. So Fromaggio is on my short list. I am ready and prepared to play it because it's right over there.
That's one that I want to play a lot too. Like Fromage was on my top 10 of the year when it came out. It's a game I love. It's a game that, you know, again talking about like uniqueness is is something I value. Like yeah, the work the worker placement aspect of Fromage where you have to plan ahead. Like, do I want an immediate small benefit but I get my worker back or do I want a bigger benefit but then I have to plan for not having that worker for multiple rounds.
And I think it's really neat how they actually have the worker placement area on a turntable so that you have this really intuitive easy to understand mechanism of seeing how long it's going to take before you get that worker back.
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
That was really clever. Really clever.
Well, great collection Evan. You got a lot of great games here and you know, I'm I'm glad you I'm glad you have a bunch of stuff you can play and get to the table, too, and stuff. So.
Absolutely. I mean, and and you know, to be honest, I think we just scratched the surface here at Games that we could talk about. But, that allows us to continue talking about more games next time.
Yeah, yeah. True.
Which we hope that you'll join us for. In the meantime, though, thanks for joining us, and we will talk to you again
Yeah. Look forward to it.