Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 27:23

hey everyone today I'm taking a look at the JY project and I'm going to be talking about the seven abstract strategy games in order from my least favorite up to my most favorite sharing thoughts as I go now if you're not aware with what the JF project is it is a series of abstract strategy board games that come with these lovely uh components all designed by the same designer Chris burm and the time frame in which these games were released was quite wide because they started in the mid90s and the most recent one came out in kind of 2017 I believe so definitely a wide time frame and I believe there are even more to come now before I get started on my thoughts on these seven games I want to give a shout out to the show sponsor Kender co.uk who are my goto online retailer and if you use the link in the show notes or the QR code then you can get 5% off your first order okay so I'm going to start with z which was number three of the series and I should say all of these games are two player only abstract strategy games Zer is certainly a unique game I can't think of anything else it would compare to and it definitely feels weird and unlike any other game that I've played or any other game in the series so this one is a game where you're trying to collect Marbles and these marbles don't come well they're not assigned to a particular player so you have three different types black ones the gray ones and the white ones and they come in different kind of Rarities so the black

ones are much more common than the white ones and what you're trying to do is you are trying to collect I believe six black ones five gray ones or four white ones uh or you can collect three of each and that's your kind of two different winning uh conditions or four different winning conditions if you want to put it that way now the game Flow is pretty simple where you have one of two options the first option which is what you'll be doing most of the time is by placing a marble onto the board which is made up of all these separate little discs you can put that marble Anywhere But as soon as you do you have to remove one of these discs so the board is constantly getting smaller and smaller as it as the game progresses now the second option is a mandatory option as long as that particular scenario is in play which is if you have a situation where a marble is directly next to another marble like here then you have to jump over that existing marble or at least make one of those moves if you can so in this example this white marble can jump over this kind of mled marble and land here when you jump over a marble you'll collect it and put it in your scoring pile but you can take more actions and string more collections together if you do that so for example this one could jump over this one here then this one could jump over the one that just landed there so as you can see you can chain these actions together now the feeling of this game is is so strange because I think initially the strategy is quite

opaque you're not quite sure on how you should be playing and it just seems to work out um but the more I've played this the more I've started to understand the nuances and where the strategy really is and it's all about trying to force or trying to force your opponent to make moves that you're willing to make them or to let them have because there's no way of getting around you know allowing your opponents to have marbles one way or another they are to get them but you're just trying to prevent them from getting the marbles that they exactly want and be making them make moves where you can take marbles that you want so you definitely do have to think maybe two three turns ahead at all times here and it does become a bit of a brain burner as you see the potential moves unravel and you start to see that kind of cascading Chain Reaction thing coming into play so this one I think it has potential to climb um I think it's sitting at the bottom at the moment because again that strategy is a little bit more opaque the first half of the game feels like you are somewhat going through the motions and the game does come alive during that second half or particularly that that last quarter of the game when you know what your opponent wants and moving those particular discs become much more important because you can deny your opponent making certain moves and there's is an slightly different way you can collect the marbles where if you have a kind of a stray piece kind on the extremity of the board and you slide one of these discs out and that piece is kind of stranded on an island you also get that marble so just another thing

you need to be uh wary of now this game although I put it at the bottom I do still like it and it definitely has piqued my interest um maybe even more than some of these other games because I feel like I've got so much more to discover with zerz but as for now because I'm still yet to really sink my teeth into the game and seeing where that gameplay is I put zerz at Seventh Place at number six I have punked which is game number five of the series much like Zer this is kind of the the outlier of the group it feels a bit less of an abstract strategy game than some of the others this one you are trying to connect your pieces so you have a kind of a black player and a white player from one edge of this hex board to the other in a kind of an unbroken chain so you have these kind of weird looking um pieces where have these little triangles these kind of straight ones these slightly crooked ones and if you look carefully each of these pieces has a kind of a highlighted spot on it which is called the the punct of the piece and that is a very very strong part of the game is where you place those punked pieces because you have um I think it's basically two actions or two options you can take number one is if you want to place a new piece onto the board then you can just do that it has to be on ground level though so you're going to have to put it flush with the actual board itself but from that point those pieces can actually move by sliding along these

kind of axes where the where the board sits but you are using that punct piece that particular spot as the pivot point so you can kind of pivot them you can slide them up and down or along these axes and you can even end up putting on top of your own pieces or overlapping your opponent pieces which is a very important part of the game by trying to break those chains and break those patter of your opponent but everything needs to be kind of sitting flush and you need to have that punked piece over one of your own pieces the rest of it can cover over your opponents but that one piece has to go over your exact own piece so you can very carefully plan things out here now a bit like zerts this one I think the first half of the game feels like you are just kind of swimming through Tre you're not really knowing what you're doing I hoping things work out on the long term but as you come closer and closer to you know completing that chain and winning the game that's when you want to start really interacting with your opponent thinking ahead knowing what to place pieces down to act as a kind of a base to put future pieces to block them off and cut things off and so on so um I think the actual tension does start to amp up as the game develops again it does feel a bit nebulous it feels a little bit weird and kind of esoteric but but I do like that very clean winning condition of getting from one side of the board to the other there is normally a moment in the game where that Penny drops where you think you

know what I've made mistakes um I didn't see it coming and I cannot kind of make up ground on my opponent now they're going to win and there's not much I can do about it but the game is kind of quick enough you're only looking at around 20 to 30 minutes to play this one I especi if you've got two really good players who are equally skilled it can go on longer than that um but I do like the quirkiness of it and I like how different it feels um again maybe feels a little bit more clunky as maybe a lot of people would like their abstract strategy games to feel um and I can see people bouncing off this one I think some people are going to really like it um some people are not going to like it at all and they might even see it as not really fitting the rest of the series too well but I personally enjoy it again it's not my favorite it has come in at number six but I can see it's it's Merit so that is punked at number six at number five I have JY which is of course the names sake of the series and therefore number one of the series now for me this one feels like a more traditional abstract strategy game feels like something that's been around for for hundreds of years really um so this one you are simply trying to uh create four of a row in your particular color so you have the black player and the white player gameplay-wise very straightforward you're just placing one of your your pieces on one of these outer spots and then sliding in and everything is going to kind of um Chain Reaction as you push these pieces onto the board and shifting them across creating kind of cross-

hatches and so on so for example if I put one here I would slide it in and therefore this one move here this one will move here and so on and as you can imagine as the board starts to populate with um with game pieces creating four in a row is somewhat inevitable now the winning condition in this game is kind of one of the most interesting things about it because it makes the game feel more like a game of attration because the game will actually end when one player can no longer take a turn so it's not about kind of capturing a certain number of opponents pieces although that is very important uh it's all about kind of yes keeping yourself in the game as long as you can so as soon as you create a kind of four in a row of yours or of course your opponent's pieces that player is going to take all of their pieces back into the supply ready to be deployed again but the twist is that any of the opponent's pieces that are in that particular line will be removed from the game permanently therefore they have fewer pieces to play with of course that means they're going to more likely run out of actions to take so sometimes you have to start playing a bit more cautiously as your opponents or your pieces start to bleed out of the game that's pretty much what the game entails again a lot more straightforward I think this one has a bit more of a a slower feel to it I think it does kind of um drag its heels a little bit more it feels a little bit more plotting than some of the other games but I think a lot of players will actually like that because it does feel

more familiar to those kind of abstract strategy games that we're more familiar with um so I'd like this one I can't really criticize the the gameplay because it works exactly as it should but I can imagine some people making feeling this one's a little bit more boring than some of the others now I don't feel that way but um it's definitely not as exciting or in your face as some of the other ones and that potential to make those big moves doesn't quite come through as much but saying that there are you do have to be kind of hyper alert and not allowing your opponent to make an obvious move that you didn't see um because a particular shift in the um in the tokens Can completely throw the game on its head so again another game you have to be very cautious of what your opponent can do at all times and that kind of like comb comboing and how things shift is is very interesting and how those towels move so again this one I don't really have anything objectively bad to say about it and I do enjoy it but again it just feels a little bit slower than some of the others and maybe doesn't have that something special about it so that is JY my fifth favorite game of the series at number four I have Zar now I think this one could be a little bit of a controversial placement um because I know this one is very highly revered now I have to say that I think the bottom three that I've talked about already and the top four of the series there's quite a gap between

the level of quality between them maybe not quality is not not the right word but maybe um how good and how fun the games are because I think there's quite a big gap between a game like Zar and a game like gy and to be honest these top four you could shift them around because they are excellent excellent uh abstract strategy games so this one is a a bit more in yourf face as a as a sty of game because you are constantly just um taking your opponent's pieces off the board so this one of course you have the black player and the white player you are randomly deploying them on the um on the board here and you can see that each of the players have three different types of pieces so you have the completely plain ones you have the ones with a bullseye and you also have the one with the outer ring as well and those pieces come in three different levels of of scarceness really so the blank ones there's loads of them on the board and the ones with the double Rings there's very few of them um entirely and the game playay gameplay wise you have two actions you can take on your turn the first of which has to be to take an opponent's piece so you can simply just move along an axis and take the next piece there as long as you're not jumping over the other pieces um and so on any piece can take any piece now the objective of of the game is to try and eliminate um all of one type of piece so you can probably imagine starting the game you're probably going to start going after the rarest of the pieces because there's few of them to take but

the kind of twist of the game is that there are ways you can protect those pieces by bolstering them um so I've already mentioned the first thing you have to do which is to take an opponent's piece the second option you can do well this for your second action you can either take another piece piece you can do nothing or you can bolster one of your pieces by placing a piece on top of another one of your own now of course they have to be next to each other or at least trace a line there but as you can imagine when you are taking over another piece that means that's another one of your pieces off the board but that stack is going to be higher meaning that in the future in order to take that now higher than one piece your opponent's piece has to be at least that size so there there is that kind of protection but in order to protect things you're making your other pools weaker and what I really do love about this game which is definitely the probably the coolest feature is that game Arc because as I mentioned you're going to start going through those rarer pieces and then you'll start noticing that your opponent's protecting them and you might start going for Plan B and going for the second most common ones and then again the strategy will change again so although you might think well obviously the decision is to go for the the scarcest ones that's not always the best thing to do and it's cool that the fact that you have to gobble up your own pieces to make the other ones stronger so I love that kind of game Mark the constant Dynamic um you know optimal route to take and so on protecting pieces uh knowing kind of knowing what

your opponent can chain together because as the board starts to become emptier uh the potential to kind skip over or jump across the board becomes a lot more tangible because again you can take two actions on the bounce meaning that you can skip across the board take a piece and then skip from there and take another piece and catch your opponent off guard uh fantastic game again this one could have taken um any of the other places really it's that good and I can certainly see why people would rate this one at number one um for me I just thought the other ones I just prefer personally a little bit more but I can't really criticize this one gameplay-wise it is a brilliant piece of design that is tazar at number four at number three I have link which is the newest one of the series now this is number game number seven of the uh gy project and this one's different different in the sense that you don't actually start with your own player color so you can see here there's actually I think there's five different colors on the board or six in total with these wild pieces and you are trying to create stacks of five pieces and those Stacks have to contain one of of each color of course you can use those wild pieces to substitute a color that's not already in that stack now again you don't start with a particular color but at any point in the game you can claim an unclaimed color as your own meaning that that particular colored piece has some

strengths that the neutral pieces don't yet have and all you're doing is that you are moving these pieces along the axes and gobbling up the other colors um if they are a neutral piece then they have to kind of be the same size but if you've claimed it a color as your own then you can even claim bigger Stacks so you can kind of claim much stronger pieces than what you have yourself uh the unique mechanism in this game is that well not only that you can claim the colors as you go on but also that you can use existing colors of of your own as kind of pivot Points to chain moves together so for example if I can see one from the setup here I'm not sure if I can um let's just say I I was the black player I had the black pieces um of course I could normally just jump here or here and take this um this white piece or this blue piece but if I was the black player I could actually skip over that black piece with this double stack here and then claim a blue piece like so so again you can use those other pieces of your color as a kind of a gateway to link your moves together and of course you probably want to start gobbling up your opponent's claimed pieces because it means they're going to have a few options to take on their tan I do like that pivotal point in the game where you think should I be taking a color now should I leave my options open but the long the longer I leave my options open it means I'm taking weaker moves and I could actually be lining the

pockets of my opponent because they could claim those pieces um that I've put so much work into you know into gobble up other pieces so I actually do really like that again that game Arc of the of the game play here I think the potential to make long cool moves in this game is definitely stronger maybe even stronger in this game than any other game in the series I think it has a wonderful flow the scoring conditions can sometimes lead to a a runaway leader I mean if you fall behind it's quite difficult to catch back up because you're going to get one point for every stack of five that you have using those wall pieces can be very powerful um so I try to always take those if I can and all in all I think this game has a lovely kind of upbeat feel to it um quite Breezy but still quite tense at the same time um very quick as well this is probably one of the quickest games of the series from my um experience and I don't I don't have anything bad to say about it at all um one of my favorites more than I was expecting so actually I think it's a fantastic design and maybe one of the most underrated ones of the series actually because I don't see or hear this one talked about in the same regard as the two yet to come as well as the aforementioned SAR so yeah this one brilliant abstract strategy game that is Link at number three at number two I have Yin which was number six of the gy project uh this one

a lot of people's favorite and I have to be honest it really was a tossup between this one and number one for that number one space um depending on which way the wind blew this one could have been number one uh this one what an elegant design uh this one is so Yin is a game where you are trying to create runs of five of your color uh these little tokens here you can see they come in white and black uh gameplay-wise it's so simple where you have these rings on the board what you're going to do is you're going to place one of your tokens inside that ring and then move a ring along that axis as far as you want really um if you skip over one of these tokens you are going to stop on the other side of it or several and then each token you've passed over is going to flip to the opposite side so you the whites will will become blacks the blacks will become whites and because there are so many different pivot Points here you're not necessarily flipping them all over at each time and it's all about trying to work or use all of your pieces together um to try and flip them over and even block your opponent because you can never actually skip through the um the spaces where you have your rings deployed and you can definitely use that placement to your advantage to block your opponent from taking certain moves that you don't want them to take now uh I think this game is probably has the best catchup mechanism I've ever seen um so elegantly implemented where when you do create a run of five pieces uh one of

your rings is removed from the board and the objective of the game is to collect five or sorry three of your rings so as you can tell as you are doing more five in a rows then you are going to get weaker as the game goes on because you're going to have fewer rings and therefore fewer options on the board and your opponent has a little bit it's quite a subtle Advantage but they can use those extra rings to try and stop you from taking those moves or this really powerful uh moves U it definitely has that um kind of satisfying feeling when you do skip over know five pieces and you flip them all to your own color um it just feels really cool um and yeah what a lovely Breezy sophisticated elegant game great placement you know every decision matters here uh the board quickly populates so it doesn't feel like it's dragging its heels um constantly moving at a fast pace and what a brilliant design honestly I can certainly see why this is a lot of players favorites and you know to be honest talking about it now this could have easily been at number one so can't really talk about this one in enough esteem really it is a brilliantly executed abstract strategy game and I'm one of the best that I've played so that is Yin at number two and of course that means at number one I have Devon so Devon was number four of the uh the JF project and it was the actual first game that I played out of the bunch so I'm

not sure if that played a big part in um why it was number one because it's the one I'm most familiar with but there's still no denying this is a an amazing game so Devon you are going to be playing on this longer board here you still have your white pieces and your your black pieces but you also have these neutral red pieces which are a very fundamental part of the game so this one you are going to start deploying your pieces onto the board before you before you play and that's probably my biggest nitpick of the game is that the the initial setup feels a little bit tedious um and it feels like you're doing it without much Rhyme or Reason now I'm sure if you're some kind of r man you can think that far ahead and personally I just seem to scatter them relatively evenly if I can now gameplay wise you are simply choosing one of your discs that has at least one exposed Edge um and you are going to be moving that piece to try and land on another piece now the height of that disc is important because that's going to show how many spaces you move so if you have one piece you're going to move to one of the Adent adjacent um spots but of course if you have say three pieces like this then it's going to skip over and land on another piece going three spaces and of course what this means is that kind of the bigger the stacks become the less mobile they become and they actually become quite cumbersome and you just can't really do much with them now the scoring condition is the is that you want to be controlling bigger Stacks because if your pieces on the top of the stack then every kind of piece below it whether that's your own or an opponent's piece

will be worth a point to you now um I do like that and it does mean that you are constantly trying to protect the bigger pieces or leave yourself kind of with a single piece that you can go and jump on top if they make a move lot of thinking ahead here lot of um AP if you want to put it that way um because there are so many variables but my favorite thing about this game and kind of the the main twist is these red pieces so these red pieces act as a kind of an anchor uh to keep pieces onto the board because as long as you can trace a route through other pieces to a red piece then you uh can stay on the board but as soon as you become detached from a red piece then all of those pieces that are detached will be removed from the board and of course you want to try and take as many of your opponent's pieces off the board as possible to restrict their moves and to give them fewer options I love that twist it is fascinating and I even like the fact that you can use these red discs in a stack that you control so you can again you can just jump away from your opponent's pieces and just completely wipe them off the board here um loads of strategy big strong bombastic moments in this game you know I've seen several pieces be taken off the board and a certain move that I just didn't see there so I love these shifting variables uh I love the amping up of the tension as the ball gets Tighter and Tighter I'm trying to claim those big Stacks at the last second um it's just a masterpiece

it really is so Devon um yeah again it's very tight between this one and Yin especially link just behind that um but Devon just about squeezed out a win here and I think I've made the right decision there so that is Devon my favorite game of the jip project now I just wanted to talk about my girlfriend's um order as well because I do normally play these with my girlfriend um and I thought her order was quite interesting because her is quite a bit different than mine actually so um her favorite of the series was still Devon so we did agree on that respect her second place was zah which again is a lot of players favorites third place for her interestingly was punked that kind of EDG toed Edge building game so she really enjoyed that one uh after that was yych then link then Gip or gy and then finally Zer so I think the only one we actually aligned on was number one and number seven the zerts and Devon so just an interesting take there but hopefully you have enjoyed the video as much as I've enjoyed playing these fantastic abstract strategy games I highly recommend checking them out all of them out actually if you um if you do uh enjoy abstract strategy games um if you have enjoyed the video please be sure to hit like And subscribe to my channel and check out my other content too and for everybody else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye-bye

Progress saved