Skip to main content
Loading video...

OFPG Voices - Our Favorite Transportation Games! (Maglev Metro, Pan Am, Galaxy Trucker, and MORE!!)

Transcript 34:51

of fpg voices is brought to you by the following sponsor Ford and dice creates games where strategy and family fun Collide some of their latest releases are L granha Deluxe Master set books of time Barcelona and nucleum their Ally program lend support to underrepresented voices in The Hobby hi everybody I'm stara I'm and we are our G voices boom yay yay yes and we are back for another week yes we and we have an awesome show for you yes we do yes we're going to talk about Transportation game that's a whole ton of them a lot of them a lot of them yes and of a lot of good ones yes and of course we've got some great contributors we've got Drew who's going to give us a top five list okay okay and then Marcus Ross is going to come through with some designer tips you know for you game designers go yes and then guess what what Mick and I are going to review some Transportation games I have one yes and Mick has one I have one yes yes but first family let's go to our good hum segment with another guest contributor May Beasley she going to say some good stuff y'all here we go May Beasley from

the Instagram Channel America trash talk I am a mom and a teacher and a gamer and I'm really really excited and humbled that I was asked to post this week's session of good humans I struggled to find what I really wanted to talk about but at the core of my heart I am a teacher I run a board game glove at school and I was thinking about things that I teach my kids to help them be good humans as they're navigating their new lives and they're going into the world so I'm going to teach you three things that I teach my kids on how to be good humans and try to give you an aboard game example of how this could work and help our community be more inclusive and help us get along a little bit better the first thing that I want to talk about is entering from a place of curiosity and not a place of judgment so when we are interacting with other people in the community or we're bringing new people into the community I feel like you would be a better human or You' be a good Human by entering from a place of curiosity but not judgment an example of this could be when a new board gamer or not even new somebody who's transitioning out of more casual games into heavier games into Hobby Games comes up and says something like oh I'd love to get into games and we say

oh that's great what games do you like and they say my favorite game is Monopoly that's what I see oh gosh no not Monopoly there's so many better games than Monopoly that's a place of judgment and when you enter into a conversation from a place of judgment what happens is the other person shuts down they feel like you already haven't accepted them you're pushing them out they don't belong and that's never a good thing to be good ambassadors of the Hobby and to be good humans in general we want to enter that space with questions versus judgments of that person so an example of this whole conversation being different but entering with curiosity and not judgment goes like this I'd really like to get more into board games oh that's great what's your favorite game well my favorite game is Monopoly oh that's wonderful what is it that you like so much about Monopoly what's your favorite part and that person might say something like oh I really really like when I buy a spot and then somebody puts their piece on it and they have to give me money that signal say as Bor Gamers that have been in the hobby for a while that that person really does enjoy the concept of engine building and you have probably hundreds of engine building games in your head and you can say to them oh wow that's amazing I know a lot of games that have something similar to that that same feel would you like to try one and most of the time they're

probably going to say yes and then you've already hooked them in with your curiosity about what they already enjoy versus judging them off the bat and shutting them down so my suggestion for number one of being a good human in our space is to enter from a place of curiosity not judgment the second thing that I teach my kids that I would like to put into this segment is talking about when we speak up like when we say something and I always tell them before you wait just say something we should ask ourselves some questions the first thing is what is my desired result like why am I saying it then is it helpful and is it kind if it's not helpful and it's not kind and it's not going to get you your desired results you probably shouldn't say it and that I feel like still applies in the war game Community particularly to our interactions online because there's so many of us and we all want to talk about different things in the space there's also so many games and games are art so they're subjective what sometimes happens is somebody will post about how much they like a game and they won't ask what other people think of the game but we feel the

need to trash the game to tell them everything we didn't like about it even though they didn't ask and we have to ask ourselves what's the desired result of that I have no idea so you would have to answer that for me if you're somebody who did that um is it kind and is it helpful and if it's not any of those things then do we need to say it in the first place this also applies like at the table so for example somebody might take a turn and they do something inefficiently well I mean it's a turn and it's inefficient instead of like going at that person and being like Oh my gosh I don't know why you did that you should have done what's the desired result is the desired result to like teach them what they should have done is it helpful maybe maybe it is but is it kind is the way you said it is the way you presented it kind kind of goes back to the first one like enter with curiosity not judgment Maybe maybe it's just he why'd you do that and then they might explain it to you but just to like enter in with like they did it wrong that doesn't feel kind of helpful so why would we say it so I just think before we talk to each other in any capacity whether it's board games or anything else we should ask ourselves what's the desired result is it kind is

it helpful and if none of those things ring true then doesn't need to be said third and final thing but it's definitely not the least important comes from actually a PD that I took a couple of years ago and the PD the Norms were to recognize intent but to speak to impact and since that PD I have always taught my kids to do this to recognize intent is to go into something assuming the best that the intent was not malicious um the intent was either normally to be funny or to be informative um but sometimes even when you're trying to do those things it impacts somebody some type of way because of their personal experiences or their upbringing or whatever right but we don't always know those things about each other so recognizing intent is being kind by allowing and giving the person who's seeing whatever they're saying the benefit of the doubt at least the first time and I it's tell the kids say the first time you can just assume that they didn't know and that is from a place of love and and understanding that everybody doesn't know everybody's situation right they don't know you um but speaking to impact allows you to voice why what they said bothered you or impacted you in any type of way because being a good human to

yourself is allowing yourself to take up space and feel like you belong and if you never speak to the impact of a situation or to a comment then that person may not know that it's doing that to you and you're going to continue to feel unsafe um when it's possible I'm not saying it's always going to happen but it's possible that there really was no in ill intent and it will never happen again if you just let them get to know you a little bit better so a lowkey example of this would be something like somebody's table General you so you go to make a move in a co-op game and then somebody tells you like what to do so you might say I know that your intent was to be helpful but the impact of that makes me feel like you don't value my opinion and that you think I don't know what to do it's very simple right the intent you you're in you're telling them you know that their intent was to be helpful but you're you're speaking to how that makes you feel in the space a kind of like larger key example of that would be something like somebody says something like sexist or racist as a joke right and being a female in the space and also being Filipino American that has happened to me in the past so the way I would approach it is just with honesty that I know your

intent was to be funny but that comment affected me in this way it made me feel this type of way because I'm female or because I'm Filipino and it's hurtful and nine times out of 10 when in my experience watching children do this and doing it myself the person never does it again and they cuz they didn't know they didn't know that it was offensive to you they didn't know it would hit you like that they may not even know that you feel that way about it so from a place of love for yourself and being a good human to yourself I think a very powerful thing would be to recognize intent but to speak to impact thank you so much for joining me for this session of good humans and learning three tenants of being a good human that I teach to my kids one is that we should always enter a conversation with curiosity and not judgment the second one asking ourselves before we speak what's the intent is it kind is it helpful and finally being a good human to ourselves by recognizing intent but speaking to the impact I hope you have a wonderful week and happy gaming bye what's happening family it's Andrew here with TBL talk and today I'm breaking down my top five Transportation games starting with number one this game is all about Intergalactic transport it is a like to

medium Real Time game called Galaxy trucker in this game you are assembling a Intergalactic Transportation ship sadly made out of sewer pipes cuz your company's cheap and you are trying to transport as much Goods across the Galaxy as possible while keeping your ship and your crew alive as you are going to be facing meteors and Pirates and space reck and you have Shields and guns and cargo holds and crew members and aliens to help you out but you have to assemble this whole ship in real time and then go through this event card deck and see what ultimately happens trying to bring the most cheddar home by selling the most goods and keeping as much of your ship intact as possible it is chaotic it is fun still strategic you just got to be okay with some of the stuff you build getting destroyed because it inevitably will but everyone else's will as well and this is number one transport game Galaxy trucker number two Transportation game involves ship transport and this this is a game called Jamaica in this game you're trying to race around an island and use your cargo hold to transport as much stuff as you can most efficiently as you're going to be storing treasure hopefully not but sometimes curs treasure food guns and sometimes crew members to ultimately try to get around the island as best as possible as you're going to be firing guns and other ships trying to use the dice and cars as most efficiently as you can throw cursed Treasures on your opponent get as much treasure as you can have enough guns

have enough food to get around the island quick enough to ultimately be the winner in a very very fun light to mediumweight racing game with some Transportation this is Jamaica my number three favorite Transportation game involves Train transport and in this game a train is trying to transport its passengers and goods across the Wild Wild West and hopefully not get robbed too much but you and your opponents are going to be playing those very Bandits trying to rob as much wood as possible gyms briefcases in a lock box with a lot of d as you are firing at each other throwing each other through other train cars punching each other climbing up the roof climbing down trying to avoid the Good Marshall that's trying to stop you guys from stealing in a chaotic fun interactive lightweight programming game called Colt Express if you want a lot of fun that Wild West theme a 3D train that you are running around as Bandits shooting each other and stealing loot look no further than this trans Transportation game Colt express my number four favorite Transportation game is survive escape from Atlantis where Atlantis is slowly sinking in this 3D Island and you are trying to get as many of your survivors transported on boats to safety as possible it be worth variety of different points and your opponents are going to try to feed your survivors to sharks and sea monsters and all kind of other things like whirl pools and volcanoes and you might actually sometimes have to work with those very

opponents trying to destroy you as you might climb in the same boat and argue about how to get best to safety in a very combative but ultimately lightweight family game with a ton of interaction a lot of take that and fun and survive escape from Land my final top five Transportation game is a stone cold classic in the modern board game Hobby and that is Ticket to Ride and Ticket to Ride you're going to be trying to build the best transportation network of trains across different countries and what I love is it has this very very simple rumy style rule set that's really easy to pick up you can introduce to almost anybody and who doesn't love collecting sets of cards and trying to fulfill goals also I love the variety of experiences you can get in the Ticket to Ride Universe you have a legacy style experience with Ticket to Ride Legacy a kids experience in Ticket to Ride first Journeys a USA experience of people in the US the original if people are in Europe there's a Europe version there's maps from all over the world so if you like Tech and technology in your games you can go UK or Japan maps if you like very combative tile maps you can go Africa or India and also if you like teams you can go TI right Asia and if you like two to three players you can go Ticket to Ride Nordic countries there's so much variety and there's a reason this game is so popular and that people love the rumy style playet with these train Transportation networks where you get to throw out your trains and build up as best you can while trying to block

your opponents and ultimately score the most points in my top five Transportation game ticket ride with all that being said I'm going to catch you guys on the flip side all right thanks Drew for that awesome top five thank you like a lot of those games he had on the list yes me too so I'm going to do my own review okay because we just could not agree on which transation game going to do her so he's going to do one I going do mine all right so I'm going to kick it off with pan and okay it's a 2020 game from Funko fun game yes it is fun game family that one point in time PanAm was like one of the largest airlines out there yes it was it was taking over the world with its planes and all the places it traveled to and then here you come along competing with PanAm with your own Airline trying to take some of their territories and destinations and all that and that's the fun of the game I mean this game you're going to deal with some hand management you got some worker placement you're going to do some bidding I mean there's all kinds of things you're going to be dealing with with trying to get your piece of the pie from PanAm yes but it's all about airplanes and travel and I mean this board game um you've got this wonderful board now when you look at the board it could be a little boring cuz it's just blue and you've got all the continents and stuff and kind of a whitish gray color then it's got routes on the board and everything but then you got these cute little planes you know got little yellow planes

and greenes and you know gray and all that so you're going to put these planes on the board and all that so once you finish you know the game at the end it really has presence cuz you see all these planes that have gone to these different destinations but from the onset the the board is just a little to me boring it's not it doesn't have that color doesn't have that punch that I'm looking for but the game play is solid and then you get into the history of pan you get into the history of what they were doing back then you know with with uh transportation and planes you know and and it's a really fun game it's an interesting game it's an interesting looking game and and I really enjoyed it now one time you know we would we talked about this before and you said you didn't like the plastic planes I did not I still don't like the plastic planes cuz they're a little on the light side the che side but I mean you're getting this game at retail you know they you get it anywhere at one time you got it Target yeah Target so they tried to keep it reasonable for every everybody yeah would I like to upgrade the planes and make them better yeah but other than that the game is great game is really fun because you got you know pay gobbling up everything like Pac-Man you got fight you got to fight trying to you know get routes and you know get destinations and airports you know so it's a fun game fun game all right so I picked for my Transportation game magas Metro oo I like that one from uh from beier games 2021 one to four players yes now mag Metro is a really cool pickup and deliver game yes which I love and also

you're building routes and stuff now the one thing you loved about it and it's really cool is the colorful translucent tiles that kind of go over each other because they're not colorful they're clear they're clear the the tiles are clear which I thought was but the routes have color got that one little route and then they connect so well yes and then you put them on top of each other like a r board you know cuz you're going to go to different areas but you might be going to the same area too and it's really a fun it's like a tile Lane game yeah I haven't seen another game do that where you have you know seethrough tiles that you can see all the way through so you can have four players and put those four tiles and you just see all you see is the route but the actual tile itself is clear and I thought that was so unique and you have you know a couple of different Maps where you're trying to replace the old Subway system with this new subway system with this levitating magnetic magnetic lines that's yeah mag Metro come from yeah and so you're trying to get workers and robots around the city and you're trying to make sure you match them up with the right places they need to go to get points so it's a really cool game they have S they did an expansion I think last year that they you know brought it in new maps even one on the moon y'all even one on the moon we did a preview for that one but it was really F it's a really fun kind of you know pickup deliver and and it adds a few more mechanics in there that really make it a fun fun game well I just thought it was fun when we first saw it

we were at Pat yes we're at Pat and we got a chance to play it and I was just floored I was blown away by it and really the tiles and also the game the tiles really got you the tiles got me very pretty very unique and then the gameplay cuz I like pick up and deliver games so I just thought it was great and you know really to me both of these games I don't think they get enough love no uh well unfortunately PanAm will not be around anymore cuz you know Funko and you know Funko got soul and you know we don't know if that game is going to come back or not with the new owner Goliath game so they may come back I hope they do bling it out this time bling it out bling it out you know cuz I I'm really trying to see how could I bling it out with the airplanes and stuff because pan is a fun game it has been forgotten it and it is a they did a really good job on that game they did I feel the same way about mag Metro mag Metro yeah well done fun game and not enough attenion it's not getting attention it has that real nice balance of it's a mediumweight game it is not Gateway and it's not too heavy it's just right in the middle that gives you enough strategy that it keeps you interested and you know you don't find many like that you know nowadays so and it's a really fun game yes so those are our transportation games yes so next we're going to hear from Marcus Ross all right hi I'm Marcus Ross with water games back with another segment for ofg voices this time I'm covering play testing the most important part of your

game design process play testing is where you take your Prototype game present it to other people and have them play it to find the fun and uncover the flaws this can happen at any stage of the game's design from early concept to the final rule set validation play testing is different from just playing the game in key ways the primary goal is generally not entertainment but work every part of design can be up for scrutiny and subject to change trying to find out which parts the game performing well and getting data to refine the rules for your next play test prototype games for testing don't need to look great they just need to be functional enough to test the concepts and be graphically laid out in a way that doesn't hinder usability prototypes do not generally need illustrations just placeholder images to distinguish components from each other at a glance in general if you're still developing the core of your game you your prototype shouldn't be that polished a greatl looking prototype will actually discourage your play testers from giving you full and honest feedback it's obvious when a ton of time and effort has been put into making a prototype and people can be reluctant to tell you if anything's wrong with it because so much effort's been put in if I'm doing a play test and I get the feeling people are feeling that way then I take a sharpie and I write directly on some part of the game and it just lets people know this is a game that's still in development the changes you suggest could be things that make it into the game in the earliest conceptual stage you should be playing your game entirely by yourself the first way you respect your tester's time is to not show them things that are so obviously broken that you could find them on your own when I have something playable I take to my group for Alpha Testing I keep an evolving set of rules in Google Docs but not a super formal layout until I'm quite late in my process in my later design stages I like

to teach the rules verbally and have printed copies of the rules and play AIDS available for players to reference during the game this closely mirrors that people are expecting when they play published games and when I do that I don't answer rules questions afterwards I let them reference the rules so I can test the rules and the game at the same time so decide your goals for your play test is there a certain scenario you want to test or is there a player account you interested in in any case let your players know what their commitment is the type of game it is how long it's going to take to play that way they can decide before you get started if they're going to get involved uh and if it looks like the game's going to run long stop the game and ask people if they'd like to continue or go straight to feedback you don't need to finish a game to get actionable feedback when possible I like to teach the game but then sit out and watch it being played by removing myself from the game I can focus on how the players are receiving it if I were actually playing I would focus on my design strategy but by sitting out I can watch them come up with their own strategies and do things I wouldn't have thought of and I'm also free to look at their cards and ask them questions and things I wouldn't be able to do if I were playing the game myself so while the play test is happening I'm taking a bunch of notes on everything if a player is delighted or disappointed I write it down if they're frustrated or say something odd about their position I write that down if a Player is taking too long and another player pick up their phone to check Instagram I'm writing that down and underlining it my are my reference for determining what needs to be kept or changed between tests otherwise I'm looking for patterns common mistakes points of confusion or misinterpretations of the rules are prime candidates for changes I'm most

interested in discovering if the game is inspiring the feelings I intended or not I need to remember what happened during the test to be able to make those changes later when the game is over invite everyone to tell you absolutely anything they want about the game this is the most exciting most important and often most difficult part of play testing you will have spent a lot of time designing the game and people are going to to tell you things you probably don't want to hear and a lot of designers are be tempted to fight against any negative feedback they get from their testers and I'm urging you not to do that it's vitally important to honor the choice your testers made to play your game instead of doing literally anything else on Earth respect their choice by truly listening to their accounts of the experience they just had the math you did at home the justifications you made the simulations you ran they can't compete with how actual people playing your actual game felt actively listening means recording their feedback and responding to questions you're asked explain but don't defend Your Design choices make sure to give each person a chance to say something the more open you are receiving the feedback the greater chance will be offered if you defensively shut down one person you're going to discourage anyone else from telling you anything that can improve your game sometimes people will make specific suggestions for changes they could be things you've already tried write them down anyway you do not have to commit to doing any of them you're the game designer you get to decide what goes in the game and what doesn't but listen carefully for any underlying issues they're trying to address if multiple people are telling you the same thing and they're trying to fix the same problem then it's something you should consider changing because it's a problem with your game so getting good play tests can be kind of tricky I primarily do mine with my game Design Group that meets at spielbound Board Game Cafe every week but one of the ways I

especially love to get feedback is going to protospiel events these are small weekend long conventions that are held at a hotel and entirely devoted to prototype gaming so no publish games are even allowed on the tables and because of the nature of that event most of the people that are attending are other game designers so you'll be playing with people who understand what you're trying to do this is especially valuable because I get fresh opinions from people who haven't played my game or been exposed to any of the prior versions it's important to keep in mind that most of time you'll be playing other people's games at protospiel so at the last one I went to I played my game three times but I played 22 other prototypes uh playing those other games as a tester makes me a better designer knowing that I'll be called upon to provide feedback makes me more conscious of the choices I'm making and the strategy I'm pursuing when I play thinking about my motivations player agency the reasons I'm taking the actions I am is good practice are figuring out how my own games are working all right I've rambled enough get out there and make some games I'll see you next time everybody all right we want to say thank you so much for joining us today and thank you to our awesome sponsor Bor and dice yes go check them out y'all check them out support them and our wonderful contributors so Drew and his top five yes I love Drew and his top five cuz he's had a lot of games that we have played that are in our collection Ticket to Ride come on we got about ticket the rides up in here and what I love about ticket the ride you know if you don't want to give somebody you know the starting out you know the big the big North American or the you know the Europe or anything else

get on the small City games that only you know only it's real small box it only takes about 15 20 minutes to play so it's so many opportunities to show them about Transportation gamees cuz that's all what they all about now the one that kind of threw me for a loop was survive escape from Atlantis that is it threw me for a loop for Trans but it is transportation cuz you're trying to get a boat a boat trying to get to them different islands and people acting a fool trying to get you all eating up I love it so when you first said that I'm going okay Transportation but yeah you're getting on a boat and you are you are being transported to place get and we have had some great times with survive escape from Atlant there been some great times and they are coming up with a new version pretty soon yes now the two others on this list I have not played and that's galy trucker yes I heard it's a great game and Jamaica I heard that's good too yeah but you know he he explained it so well and they are Transportation games yes they are yes they are so great list Drew yes great list and then Marcus I'm tell you Marcus he be dropping some some some wisdom he dropping wisdom on I totally agree with him about play testing oh my God please please play go to unpub or any of those like you know different things like spill Masons at what they were doing at uh you know spielbound Cafe go to those things they they help you to get better so your game will not act a fool with us when we see it oh no and and don't be afraid of

constructive criticism be AF you want your play testers to give you honest feedback and you need to listen and take that feedback and utilize it and make your game better don't go to your friends and family all the time go to different folk oh they going to say oh it needs to come out tomorrow no I do not no get you some unbiased play testers I think it's great I think that's the one thing that we see a lot as content creators where they we ask have they played this game or us like what's going on with this what is happening to this game so yes please get play testing like crazy yes do thatly and last but not least yes we have to say thank you to May Beasley now she has an Instagram and YouTube channel called a merit trash talk she gave us a great good human segment and she just wanted to share three things that she teaches her kids mhm and it's so cool cuz she is she be teaching boy she's one of my favorite teachers out there and and family check her out on Instagram she be doing her stuff she be working out I mean she's a weightlifter all that stuff maybe getting it on and she be trying to fight her husband in competition like me and star be doing and they actually give an award for who wins I love that I love that with May and a husband do that but may is good people check out and she really you know she said don't judge with that game Monopoly don't judge May I'm trying May I'm trying not to judge so thank you for letting me know thank

you so much yeah I really enjoyed her message and thanks again for being on the channel yes thank you so much mate thank you thank you love you now love you now star what about our merch we don't have it on well if you're looking for a shirt for our family plays gamg voice you can check us out oning and then we also have a new shirt for our family plays games on the B online store so be sure to check that out as well now Family make sure you like this video and all the others that you see that kind of help us and also subscribe and get other folks to subscribe too come on let's let everybody see these lovely voices and and joining this community but now our next episode is April 11th and the topic is going to be uh-oh Cooperative games can she do it family can she do it we'll see we will see now star where can they find RPG and RPG voices out here come on let me know well if you're looking for our family plays game our offg voices you may find us on Facebook Instagram Twitter yep right here on YouTube right here on our website website and Tik Tok Tik Tock TI talk family thank you so much for coming out and checking out these lovely voices make sure you you definitely take a look at our sponsor Bor and dice games support them cuz they keep supporting us so we want to help them out so definitely check them out and family if

you have any questions or comments please put them down below hey and there's one thing one thing we want you to always know family we love you bye bye now

a a

Progress saved