Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top 25 Solo Historical + War Games | 2025 Commentary

Transcript 1:09:32

Hey gamers, this is Liz David from Beyond Solitire, and I'm here with two of my very good friends. I've got Brandt Gillery from the Armchair Draons and Paul Wright, uh, who is my co-designer, uh, for our hopefully upcoming game, Foxes and Lions, uh, and also a heavy gamer extraordinaire. Actually, omniamer extraordinaire. Uh, but we are here to talk about the 2025 top 25 solo historical games list. So Brandt, do you want to kind of run people through what it is we're doing since uh you're my partner in crime on this?

Sure. I we're doing the same thing we did the last two years. Um and done. No. Um so yeah, we uh

for those of you familiar with the social sciences research, this is what we call the methods section of the paper. Um we uh we we just put together a basic Google form and and uh we're asking folks what are their favorite um solo or solitary war and historical uh board games and and the solo and solitire piece. Not that we're going to get too wound up in definition, but we weren't necessarily looking for purpose-designed solitire games. If you enjoy playing a a multiplayer game by yourself, multi-handed or using uh using bots or whatever, like cool, you know, just stuff you enjoy playing on your own. And and so we ask folks to plug in their top five. And we do ask for folks to plug in the BG URLs, so the from Board GameGeek, because that helps us keep the data consistent. And and I'm sure we'll talk later about where some of the pitfalls of that come in, but it it allows us to know for sure what spelling, what version, what specific game you're referring to, especially because there's some things that have very similar titles. Um, it gives us specific titles rather than series of games. So, so there's there's a variety of advantages to that. The disadvantage is it's a pain in the butt to, you know, tab between things and cut and paste, especially if you're doing it on a phone. Uh, we also ask a couple of just optional questions at the end, not necessarily pure demographics, but but along those lines.

How long you've been wargaming? What percentage of your board gaming diet is wargaming? U, we ask some folks sort of, you know, we always ask where did you hear about this because kind of curious where we should be targeting some promotion there. Uh, but those are the kinds of things that we ask folks about. Uh, that that optional piece at the end sort of changes a little bit year to year. We always ask where did you hear about it? How long you've been wargaming, but the other pieces will will change some questions out here and there. We add it all up. Uh first place vote gets five points, second place vote gets four points. Kind of like a, you know, truncated version of the college football rankings and and then we take a look at the high score, right? Who had the most points in the rankings? And then we just stack them up from there. Uh in a few cases, we get some ties on those points. In that case, we then sort by the average. So, the one that got more higher votes. Not sure that's grammatically correct. Go with it. Um, that's the higher average wins ties. And then we we stack them up from there. Uh, Liz ends up putting the geek list on Board Game Geek of the top 25 this year.

I think it's actually the top 26 because it was a tie at the 25th spot. And then we post the entire list all the way down over at the Armshare Dragoon site. And then we'll also post a couple of articles following up where we kind of dig into some of those optional questions. We uh we slice and dice the data set by how long you've been wargaming, what percentage of your your diet is wargaming. Uh so we we'll mix and match some of the data diving as well.

And of course, Brandt does all the real work because I'm a bum.

At this point, I've got a couple of sort of templated pieces for the spreadsheet. So, it's a little easier to It's not pure macros where it's like just push a button and it does all the work for me. But, it's I I might record some macros for this next year now that we've done it enough. Uh, so I think that we actually just go right to the top and talk about the big drama of the list, which is that in the third year, so for the first two years, uh, D-Day Omaha Beach was the number one by a very wide margin to the point where I didn't actually expect a dislodge this year. I just kind of assumed D-Day at Omaha Beach would be the top again, but it wasn't because the number one was Fields of Fire Deluxe. Um, Paul, you're a big Fields of Fire fan. So, how how do you feel about how do you feel about the upset?

I feel I feel happy. I feel vindicated. Uh, much as I love D-Day at Omaha Beach and much as I respect uh John Butterfield, who I think is the most represented designer on the list, certainly up there. Uh, but the reason I I love Fields of Fire, which is also on the list in its non- deluxe version, right? Um, not as high obviously as the newer version. Uh, I love it because I think it's probably the best simulation of company level engagement and command that I've seen certainly in war games. Uh, I will admit though when I got involved with the earlier version, the non- deluxe, the less recent one, uh, I bounced off of it at a certain point because the onboarding and the rules were not, you know, welcoming to a newcomer, even an experienced war gamer.

And that's something the whole community knew. This is not news. Uh, but I think everyone was so impressed with the new release at how good it was in or onboarding you to the game. The number of introductory materials that ease you into the system that help you understand why it is the way it is, plus all the other videos and fan-made materials that have been made for this new version. I think it's not surprising to me actually that the new version leapt up as high as it did. Uh, I think onboarding is the key here and maybe that's a lesson every company and designer should take to heart. I know I am in my own design thinking about how how to onboard players to more complex games.

Yeah.

Well, you keep using the term onboarding, man. I do this to get away from corporate America.

Yeah,

let's in on this

not a corporate guy in anyway, but I guess I stole that lingo. We'll put a pen in this conversation for later. And I'm talking actually um one thing it does give me some hope for. Yeah. Like the ability for heavy games to really get in and be a big part of people's lives. Um you know, a lot of times I really only have time for a shorter game or I'll play a game I already know or you know, like it takes real work to get into like a heavier new system. And it makes me very happy that Fields of Fire Deluxe is like delivering on that level both for itself and yes like as a communitywide indicator people like heavy games. People are hungry for that and if you present it in a way that is going to be accessible enough like they will if you design it they will come.

Um, I think that's I mean it feels of fire has its own kind of legendary status, but I still see it as an encouraging sign for what people are willing to do and learn if it's presented well.

I think what made a difference to me uh this time around after many journeys with the game uh I've had it until recently on my table which is pretty big table. I can have multiple games on it, but it's been on my table for about six months straight.

Uh, and the reason it stays on the table, first of all, I love it. I enjoy it, but I also now have gro the rules enough that returning to it after a bit of a pause isn't the nightmare that it was before. Um, when I played the older version, if I left that game, whether it was on the table or not, if I left it mentally for too long, uh, I felt like I had to start all over again. I do not feel that way anymore.

That's awesome. By the way, for those of you who don't know, Paul's basement is like a wonderland of really. He's got a great game collection. He's got these big tables and if you lift the tops off of them, World in Flames is under there.

It is hiding under there. not on the solo list. I am so shocked.

What? People didn't want to solo World in Flames all year.

Okay, so so here's the real question, and this is a slight digression off of the solo game qu solo game stuff, but Paul, how long has the current game of World Flames been going on that is hiding under the table?

We are now entering, I think, our second year of play with a group of six. Um, we are currently in uh 1941, so we have a ways to go.

So, you're basically playing World War II in real time

kind of. Yeah, we we only meet about once a month in a good cycle, but then life gets in the way. Vacations, work, kids, whatever. And so, it becomes every other month. Uh, but we're getting better. We're getting faster. We're learning the game.

Yeah. So, but each turn in World in Flames is a month, isn't it? or is it

it's a two-month period.

So, it's a two-month period. You get together every two months. You are playing World War II in real time.

Yeah, more or less.

So, we're having like the hardcore games discussion today. And I actually think that's um worth talking about. Uh, so, um, things that we touched on a bit in the podcast, which I'll also link that I did with, uh, Brandt and Mike over at Armchair Draons. You know, we looked at, uh, how many people had been wargaming for a long time, and the majority of contributors to this list had been playing war games for more than 40 years.

Yeah. So the the first year we did this back in 2023

when we asked that question um we did like you know zero to one so so brand new war gamers right rookies uh one to three 3 to 10 I think 10 to 20 10 to 25 and over 25 was the what we asked the first time and that over 25 was like 60 or 65% of the I'm I'm in that block so so the next year we added in over 40 years We went like 25 to 40 and then over 40 years worth of wargaming which you know gets you back to the mid80s. Um again I'm still in that block also but it's uh it's still the major it it's not it's a plurality. It's not a majority but it's still really damn big. And so the the folks that the folks that are responding to this survey and again I I want to be real careful that we are not projecting these numbers to the population of War Gamers as a whole.

These are the respondents to the survey. Um that there's still a huge percentage of them that are um that that are over that that are over 40. So wargaming going back to the mid 80s, which also means that you're probably in your your late 40s at the youngest. Not a lot of war gamers start at age six. I'm not saying there aren't any, but not a lot. And uh

people with good parents.

Yes. So you're you're up there in the the you know you're in the over 50 age bracket at this point and that's still a lot of folks. I do like that we continue to get more and more people in the zero to one and the one to three bracket which as we pointed out on the podcast those are folks that picked up wargaming post pandemic. So that's you know and and not like during the pandemic. If you're in the 0ero to one block or the 1:3 block, you only go back to like 2021, you know, at the earliest. So, those are solidly post-pandemic war gamers, which again, cool. Yay. More more younger war gamers out there, or not younger, but rookie war gamers out there. Bring them on.

Yeah, I'm hoping that we'll get a more more of a demographic mix in the list as we go on. um just because I want better data so we can see like what people are playing in different in different groups. Uh but one thing that was neat about the list is that it's still got

I would say that the game the list definitely skews towards older titles but not entirely like Halls of Hegra is fairly recent that came in at six. Um you know Pavlov's House pretty recent as things go. I mean, it's it's aging now in terms of like our new hotness culture, but it's not really that old a game. Um, you know, uh, both of the second editions from Worly Gig, so Pax and John Company are up in that top 25. Uh, I Napoleon is pretty spanking new.

Even Atlantic Chase is postpandemic.

Yeah.

Yeah.

I mean, that's that one's not even five years old yet,

and it finally cracked the top 10.

Yeah.

Yeah. Which I think it deserves it. It strikes me as a strange one to play solitire, but I get that there aren't a lot of other games on the topic. So, if that's a topic you're interested in, you're sort of forced to adapt.

So, I I that that would be my guess. But

I thought one thing that was interesting about the top 10 this time uh is Comancheria and Navajo Wars. Uh, and all due credit to Joel Toppen. Uh, I fell in love with Navajo Wars when it first came out. Uh, one of my favorite stories about that game is I was in Argentina on business for my university and I was in the hotel. Uh, and I had brought Navajo Wars with me as something to pass away the time due to the jet lag. And I finally managed to, if you want to call it, win that game, uh, by helping the Navajo, the Da survive all three periods, the Spanish, the Mexican, the American periods. Uh, and I was so thrilled because that game is tough that, you know, I was cheering and I'm sure the Argentines in the hotel had no clue what this strange American was cheering about. Uh, and yet they had their own colonial experience in Argentina, of course. Uh, so it would have been nice to be able to tell them why I was so excited with that game. U, but I mention it mainly because um those are unusual titles. You know, they're not your typical war game both in terms of perspective and mechanics and just overall interpretive approach. And the fact that both those titles uh have cracked the top 10, I think is uh speaks in some way to what Brandt was talking about in terms of changing demographics and changing understandings of what a war game can be.

And and I think both of those have been on the in the rankings before, maybe not as high, but but both of them have been there because we have called them out over over the last couple of years um for for being up there. Uh I I do think it's interesting that um it it's not a topic that represents a large percentage of wargaming as a whole, but it does bubble up a bit here. Um I just pulled up the uh the 2023 list. Navajo Wars was at 13. Um I was scanning for Comancheria, but I'm not seeing it like the top 2025. Uh but it it Navajo Wars was up there. Um and then in 2024, uh where'd he go? Sorry, I had the rankings right there in front of me and I clicked on the wrong tab. Um I know Navajo Wars was 13, I'm sorry, 12th in 2024.

Um and then Comancheria was down at 27. So

Oh, that's interesting. So they were places and risen.

Yeah. they're on the rise and they are both of course designed as solo games which may help their ranking.

So I have a I would have to do a data dive for this that I haven't had time to do yet but I'm very curious. So I feel like when you're making a list of games of top games I think a lot of people kind of like are oh I'm going to put my favorite worker placement. I'm going to put my favorite deck builder and they'll try to like get variety among like types of game as well or like maybe you know like for example when I do top 20s I'll be like okay well which of the chip theory games is my favorite chip theory and I might actually not put another even if you could in fact cluster a bunch up at the top. So what I want to see is are people who are putting commandria and Navajo wars are they putting both or are we having subsets of the data who put one and then a different subset who puts the other and I'm also curious about that with regard to 11 and 12 which are packs from John company second edition. So are the people who like those Ricky Royal solo modes putting both of them on their list or are different subsets of people putting them and then they just happen to kind of reach parody on the list?

Yeah, that that's something we can crunch. And then similar to what you were saying about uh you know worker placement versus you know whatever the area controller or narrative one we do ask um why do you choose the games that you do for playing solar solitire? Um artwork or graphics. Uh the completeness in terms of like a series or a designer or publisher trying to complete a set there. conflict, theater, battle, the designer, educational utility, because some folks are interested in these for for learning purposes, the game system, the publisher, whatever. So, uh, we do ask folks, what's the primary reason you do this? And we could certainly filter the responses by that as well and see.

I'm a little leerary of that because even with the uh the games that are are up there on the list um for uh Comancheria, Navajo Wars, like they still are only in the teens for a total number of votes.

Yeah.

So, it's tough to project too much, but but it'd still be interesting to see what's there for those.

Yeah. Also, those of you who are watching this, if you didn't vote and you're curious, do it next year so we can get more delicious data in

end of the summer every year, right? Sometime in in early to mid July, we'll launch it. It'll run for a month. So, we'll leave it up for 30 days and then we'll pull it down and start crunching numbers.

Yeah. But um this year we started a little later just because when we normally launched it overlapped with Gen Con.

Yeah. I actually think next year we should try for a QR code at Origins since you've got that War Game section.

War Game HQ.

Yeah.

Yeah.

We can do that. Although like putting a solo War Game survey at a convention where everybody's sitting down at tables with other people seems a little counterintuitive. But

I go to conventions. Rant. Why are you acting like I'm a troll who lives in a basement?

They only put me in a tiny work closet at work.

And they didn't put you under a bridge at least.

There is a really creepy like electric room down in the basement. I guess they could put me there

with your red stapler on the desk.

Yes. Yes. Exactly. So, but maybe I could get paychecks for years and nobody would know. No kidding.

Yeah. No pop culture reference to obscure for this group.

Um, so the other thing I thought was kind of interesting, uh, was that once again we have a couple of games that are, as far as I know, um, out of print in the top 25. So, one of those is Ambush, a classic,

uh, a classic among classics. Uh, and then kind of right there at the tail end, um, we've got Raid on Saint Aair.

Yep. And so I think it's cool and also um I worry about people trying to get copies of everything on the top when it comes to book games that are out of print. Uh so

by people Liz means her getting copies of

I'm good. No, but uh you know actually uh one of my big purchases this year was a copy of Ranger that I'm looking forward to exploring once all the oath files are submitted. I'm gonna just do re research and research just means I play solo games because how do you be a good solo game designer if you don't play solo games all the time? That's my justification.

Sure.

Um but I'm wondering if in future years we're actually going to see those drop off or you know will they you know hang in there for a long time?

I'm curious about it.

It's interesting you mentioned Ranger because I don't think it's been on the list at all any year. I think somebody mentioned it.

Did somebody previous years? I don't think it's on this year's list.

Somebody uh one person

Yeah. 164

one. Oh, there's there's two people that voted and it ended up getting uh a total of five points. So, somebody was either a fourth and second and fifth place vote or a third and fourth place vote split there.

Yeah. Um but yeah and and Ranger ain't coming back because Bill Gibbs passed away. His wife doesn't want to run Omega games. So it's what's there is there and and that's it.

Can I make one observation uh about a series that I only see represented uh twice in the top 20 if I'm right and that's the coin series. Uh I think we have Fire in the Lake and Cuba Libra there at 20. Mhm.

Um I I don't know what it has been in previous years. I know coin games have always lived somewhere on the list. Um it's a very popular series. I certainly love it. Uh I think what'll be interesting to watch in the next couple of years is how much the turn GMT has made towards a card-based easier to run solo mode for those games, which they're starting to retrofit to some of the older published titles.

Mh. Um, maybe that will help uh overall raise the rankings of some of the coin games. Uh, the games that don't have those card- driven, easytouse systems, and I wouldn't say easy, he's probably a stretch, but easier to use. They have the old flowchart bots that, you know, frankly, aren't as inviting or easy to to use. And I think the longer those stay uh as the defining solo mode for a coin game, uh then the more those games might drop over time. Uh but we'll see if there's a trend in the other direction. You know, Gandhi, I think Fire in the Lake now. I know they're working on one for Cuba Libra. A lot of these now have bot decks. They're definitely easier than the old flowcharts. Yeah,

the um the the coin games have always been on the list a bit. Fire in the Lake always seems to be the top one. So in 2023, Fire in the Lake was tied for 18th and then in 2024 it was up at ninth. Um so Fire in the Lake is always the top of the the coin games in the list. And I don't know if that's a topic thing, if that is a a an availability piece. Uh the designers may have something to do with it because you you've got two rock stars on that one. Um the I know that there are the the solo bots for those uh have always been talked about as being really good compared to some of the other coin games. So that may have something to do with it. For some reason, I'm thinking one of the expansions actually changes the bots a little bit.

It does. There they're actually two expansions, one prequel, one sequel. Uh, and I think part of the appeal. It's it's all the above. I think everything you just said.

Um, but the the epic scale of the game, which I've done, I've soloed all three parts that you can play as an interconnected story of the entire uh leadup to and aftermath of the Vietnam War. Uh, that epic scale is definitely appealing to a solo gamer like me. And if I can run that with cards and even if they change a bit between expansions and main game main game, uh I think that makes it just easier to get to the solo gamers table.

Yeah, I I've I for folks watching the video, I have all of the spreadsheets on my side monitor. That's why I keep looking away. It's not it's not there's a squirrel out the window or anything. Um in 2023, Cuba Libre was the I'm sorry, I take that back. I thought it was Cuba Libre. Falling Sky was the next coin game on the list after Fire and Falling Sky was tied for 25th and Kuba Libre was down tied for 26th. Last year, Pen Dragon was the second one on the list um after Fire in the Lake and it was where was it? It was tied for 18th or so. Um and uh so again, Fire in the Lake is always the top of the coin games that appear, but it's far from the only one. Um and that was something that Mike had also brought up on the on the podcast as well is something it'd probably take a little bit of manual coding to do to go through some of the list there, but to kind of categorize what's there of these are the coin games, right? These are the uh the more narrative kind of choose your own adventure sorts of games. these are the tower defense games, these are the whatever. And to to kind of go through and and look for themes or patterns across the types of games that you have in there. Um the Danver fill-in- thelank leader games, right?

Whether it's Corsair leader or Thunderbolt Apache leader or whatever. And and even the the Sherman leader or Pan, you know, the the different um the ground combat ones, those all use a very similar system. and he's like the only person using that system. So that would be a a series that you would see kind of in there as well. Um it it's something that unfortunately that's not an easy thing to query against the BG database. So that's something that you would have to to go in and manually code.

Interesting.

Yeah. Yeah. So, um, but but yeah, I mean, there's coin games are a consistent presence on the list. They're not always that high. I do find it interesting that Fire in the Lake has been the top one all three years. Uh, but there's always at least two of them in the top 25, 26 or so.

Yeah,

just we sometimes the break point ends up at 26 or 27 because of ties further up in the list. Uh, but that's, you know, we break it in the mid high 20s and there's there's pretty much always at least two coin games on the list, you know, among our respondents. Um, in in that top block, I mean, there's other coin games further down.

Oh, yeah. Well, one thing that's kind of fun, as I mentioned before about this list, is that if you go all the way down, there's so many like oneoff things that get mentioned. Like, there's so many games that are one of someone's favorites that I've just never even heard of or I've only heard of because I've run the this list a couple times. And I think that that's really cool. Like um there's always like a a hidden gem to be discovered if you if you dig down enough. Um that said, there's still some things maybe that wouldn't have gotten mentioned that should have. So Paul, I know you have some ideas on this matter.

I do. Uh before jumping into the ones that that I'm thinking of that aren't on the list at all for various reasons. Um I also was interested in the so-called non-traditional titles on there. And I made note of a few. I'm not pretending they're the only ones. It depends on what your definition of non-traditional is as far as a war game. You know, the oldest argument in the book. Um, I will say I'm an old Grognard. I've been playing forever. I'm in that upper age demographic, but I am not a traditionalist by any stretch. I'm very open to new approaches to war games. I think if we were not, uh, we would never have gotten Mark Herman's innovation with card driven games, right? If we weren't open-minded about that and just stuck to Hex Encounter, it would be a very different gaming world. So, I'm always interested in these titles. The ones that stood out to me are This War of Mine, which of course captures the civilian experience of war, Legion of Honor, which is about the Grognyard experience on the ground, right, during the Napoleonic era. Really great role playing type game with mechanics. It's not pure role playing. Uh, Votes for Women, of course, has been on the list, I think, more than once now. Uh, Molly House and John Company both on there might not be everybody's traditional ideas of war games. Uh, congrats to Cole on that. Uh, also and Ricky. And I also notice Imperium, uh, that series from Osprey Games, which I quite enjoy.

Uh, and I think certainly qualify as conflict simulations, if you prefer that term. Yeah,

Imperium's also been reskinned with a totally amazing reskin uh for Star Trek if you're a Trek fan. Star Trek Captain's Chair is one of the best Star Trek games I've ever played and it's built on that Imperium skeleton. Um so those stood out to me as the non-traditionals and I think we'll probably see more of those over time, you know, as people play more games, as demographics change. as as you were mentioning the uh the Legion of Honor, I I was curious. I just went and looked uh because I saw it on there, but I didn't remember where it landed. Purple Haze, uh which is isn't on the previous two years.

Um it didn't exist in 2020. I mean, it it was in play testing in 2023. Um but Purple Haze was was released this past year. It got two fifth place votes. That's it. Um, it it I don't know if that says more about just who the audience was responding to this or what. I I know it it sold a ton. Uh, because I've I've talked to the publishers. It it sold a ton. It they they shipped a whole lot of them around. There was a lot of online chatter about it. Uh, it showed up in a couple of best of lists here and there that I've seen online. and it it had some crossover appeal to um sites that don't typically cover war games popping up and saying, "Hey, this is a really cool game. You should check it out." It's it's undeniably a war game. It falls Paul into your box of this is not a traditional war game, you know, Pex Encounter, blowing stuff up kind of kind of game.

It It didn't resonate with the people that responded to this survey.

Yeah. could be people like Liz and myself who are haven't played it yet,

you know, but would probably rank it pretty high.

It was for folks that are interested, it was tied for 369th on

But see what's funny is when you say the title of that game, I have a feeling an immediate sense of recognition of, oh that's something I should play. I've been hearing so much good buzz about that and I just haven't got around to it yet. So, that one could be a sleeper or yeah, I think that you know, we just need a different subset of people maybe to pop on because I think um you know, it's it's a game that I think is going to be around a while based on what people say about it. Um

yeah,

it's got everything it needs except the actual votes.

That is true.

So, the uh the two I was thinking of that aren't on the list, and Brandt, you may have yours. Liz, you may have yours. Uh, and maybe I just missed them on the list, but I did do the search. Uh, they're both, I think, clearly war games. Uh, they may not yet have the the recognition yet to kind of make their way onto that list. Um, but the recognition for for one of them certainly is growing. It's a newer title, series. The other is an older game that's now back in print in a second edition. So, there's a story there. Um, the one that's older and now is back in a much better edition, frankly, uh, that's lovely. Great graphic design and just a great game is Unhappy King Charles about the English Civil War. A great card driven game. Uh, I love the original version. I love the new one even more. Uh, and for a long time, you couldn't get your hands on it very easily. It was basically out of print and expensive to buy online. Uh, but now you can. I believe I got the newest edition and it has a solo mode and I quite enjoyed it. I would definitely um want to keep playing that one solo and two-player. Uh and the other one you're probably all familiar with is Sebastian Ba's uh latoral commander. Uh not literal but lural as in shoreline uh marines etc. Uh an account of modern or near future warfare. There's an Indo-Pacific volume.

There's a Baltic volume. more on their way. They all come out of the Deetsz Foundation. Um, a lot of people are playing these games at, you know, Army War College um, you know, gatherings and seminars. So, it's not just at game stores. Uh, and that's a game that actually, uh, lends itself well to a kind of, um, multi-handed solo approach. It doesn't have an official solo mode, but it's very soloable and very enjoyable. So 2023 latoral commander got one second place vote.

Ah so it's been there

nothing since. Unhappy King Charles got a fifth place vote each of the last two years but is not on there this year.

Okay.

Interesting.

Yeah.

For me what I noticed was just

it's probably the same dude replied the first two years and just didn't

he didn't do the survey

and didn't bother to fill out the survey because it have gone down from the first year to the second year to the third year. we have dropped participants a little bit. Um, I'm I'm a little concerned with that. I'd hate to see that trend continue. I think part of it is the promotional side of things. I think part of it, as Liz has said, there there may just be a little bit of fatigue from the audience there. Um, I I would like to see people, even if your top five hasn't changed, I'd love to see people still put that same top five in there this year. um just to continue to represent those games that are your favorites and and let's let's make sure that they are still heard from. So

yeah, uh I will say one thing that made me a little sad was a big drop from 2023 for Europa Universalis, Price of Power. Um it's heavy. It's a big boy. Uh but I think that it's a game that's really worth engaging with. And so seeing it go from having been in the list in 2023 because I can see the thumbnail on uh

yeah,

you know, on our our previous like on my little geek list tab over here. Um I think it's a bummer that it's now like in the 300s or something like that. Um and there's also games that I think I would like to see get a little bit more recognition. So, um, you know, Votes for Women is actually pretty high up, but other games I kind of think of as in that kind of new wave of trying to, I guess, make war or historical games that are about non um kinetic topics. So, Stonewall Uprising appears in the list very low, but I actually think that's a game that's really worth the time. I think it's good. Um, you know, I'm not saying it has to, you know, there's only 25 of the top 25, but I'd like to see more attention and kind of ground swell under some of those games that are maybe not super traditional war games. And I know that Europe Universalis Prize Power is not either. Um, but games that are worth your time sitting there and thinking about and and playing.

So, go ahead.

Well, just a quick question, Liz, on Europa Universalis specifically. So, so it was in the top 26, 27, whatever it was that first year. Yeah.

Uh last year it dropped down to 51st.

Yeah.

And then this year it's way down on the list.

Yeah.

Do you think that one

uh became what we thought Mr. President might become, which was the new hotness that kind of fell off?

I think that's possible, but uh Paul, you've played a lot of pop. Like I think it's a little bit shame. I I have a theory on that. It could be totally wrong. Uh first, I I love the implementation of EU that is in that new board game. It is a great multiplayer experience. My group has adored it. We want to get back to it, in fact, after World Flames is done, whenever that is. Uh and

yeah, it has a great solo mode, a pretty easy to use set of decks. Uh, of course it requires you understanding the game itself first. So I'm not saying it's an easy climb. Uh, but I will admit I have run a game with six bots fighting each other of Europa Universalis. So I put that system through its paces and it's really excellent given the complexity of the base game. I think the theory is that it's such an investment of time to play the base game with people or to play it even solo. uh it's not so much a mechanical uh challenge as a time challenge and a table space challenge.

Uh that that's probably why it's seeing less play now uh than it did when it first came out. Now there's an expansion coming that may resuscitate, you know, the attention to the game on the solo front a bit.

Yeah. But if that's the case, why why a drop for European but not for Mr. President?

Yeah. Ex. That's what I was about to say, too. because table space, you know, I mean, Mr. President, you need a you need an aircraft carrier.

Well, m Mr. President is designed for solo game.

Yeah.

So, I think there there's a kind of readiness to the solo player there that doesn't require the same lift. I mean, it's a huge lift,

but it's not the same as EU. Can

Can I make my mandatory Mr. President joke?

Yes.

That small self-published indie game of Mr. President.

Yeah. Yes, it's in my Steam wish list, though. I think my own plays as a Mr. President are going to go up once it's available as um as a computer game.

It was very smart of them to get it uh implemented online. I think it will see more play that way.

Yeah. Yeah. I just the whole self-published thing, it takes people a second to sort of realize what I'm saying there. But it's um I I do find it interesting that a purpose-designed solo game has the AI built into it and should be among the easiest possible things in the world to adapt for digital play. And yet, how many of these actually have digital modes? I like playing it on the table though. It's not

I don't enjoy the table piece of it all. Like I I I am very much a tactile gamer. The things that I play digitally are things I'm not playing on a tabletop, right? I I have a a long I mean 30 plus year civilization addiction at this point that I continue to feed. So, and I'm not playing that on the tabletop. But the the solo game with the AI built in is the easiest thing in the world to I I'm not saying the actual writing of the code is easy, but there's no design work underneath it. Like you you're literally just transposing stuff into the digital realm.

And those are those those don't make their way into the digital world nearly as often.

I think you're you're on to something, Brandt. Uh, I think it it would be easier than a lot of other things to implement online. And certainly, while I prefer the tactile experience 100%. Uh, when I'm on an airplane, I can't lay out my game, you know, in the middle of the aisle, uh, you know, without being escorted off the plane by the police later. Uh so I think you know we we crave these kinds of games and maybe the tariff situation with all the downsides to that uh and the overall cost of making games will lead more of these titles to have an online implementation uh perhaps even an exclusively online implementation which would make me sad. I mean I want them to be board games.

Uh, but I I think there are a lot of titles, Grant's right, that already and they could be older titles that have the AI going for them already and would not be uh too hard to to transition.

Yeah, makes sense. Um, so something I want to talk about in this uh kind of last stretch of this uh video uh is something that's not in the podcast because Brandt hadn't crunched the data yet, which is we've now got our lovely list of um what uh what publishers are involved in our in our list. So, we've got like a publisher column and a designer column. So, I'm just kind of looking through and GMT published 10 of the top 26 games on my quick count. That is a very nice representation. So, so just to be clear, uh the the publisher and designer as they are returned uh in our list are not necessarily 100% accurate because the query of the BGG database and this is this is a programmatic query that we had somebody run for us because because Min is a lot smarter about the code piece than I am. um it returns the first person associated with the game as the designer or the first publisher if there were multiple publishers. So if if you had if it was originally published in Europe and somebody brought it to the states and did a a localization for the US or vice versa, it's going to show up with first publisher. first designer is a little bit more of a headache because you do have co-designs out there and so like Fire in the Lake was a co-design

but I think Vulkco is the only one credited for it. Um I I have to go double check but it's um it it's not always the right answer. It's it's often an incomplete answer I think is the way to say that. So I just want to caution folks with that when they see the data there.

Sure. All the same, we are gonna ruin all of your scruples and have fun. Brand. Okay,

go for it.

Um, but no, seriously, uh, so GMC definitely has the lion share among publishers in that top stretch of the list, and I just think that's cool. Um, I'm looking through here. I see Decision Games only appears twice in top stretch, but it's two, it's games two and three, so D-Day and RAF. Um, let's see.

Compass second. I thought it was, but

I think so. Yeah. And then there's a three DVG titles in here.

Yeah. For for the actual counts across the entire list, um, GMT led the way, uh, the the list credits with 98 total titles. Compass with 25, Decision with 20, DVG at 19, White Dog at 17, and the bulk of those are probably Ben Madison games with uh with Dave Kershaw right behind. Uh Multimman, Revolution, Lock and Load, Avalon Hill, and then Self-Published with double digit number of games. Um and then it goes on down from there. Uh so self-published and web published are both on there, and those those are essentially the same thing, but BG credits them differently. SPI is only on there with four, but I think there's probably a bunch that were originally done by SPI that have been re-implemented by Decision. And so there's it's a bit of a duality there.

Some of them I think are probably SPI games that Decision hadn't got to yet.

So Brandt, would you say um GMT's representation there, I'm sure part of it is just market share. Yeah,

it would be true of a lot of lists, not just a solo list,

but um would you say that they might have been

uh early adopters as far as um leaning into games that have good solo modes or are solo only. Uh you know, there was a time when I think um game makers avoided solo modes. They they didn't see the point. Uh and maybe GMT uh was wise to that a little little earlier than most. Maybe I I think the other piece of it is that the bulk of the the Mark Herman card driven game uh universe that Pantheon are they're almost all GMT published. And I think Stuka Joe's CDG solo system

probably helps push those up a bit where having a a purpose-built tool to do that solo adaptation for those styles of games probably draws more eyeballs to them. Um, but I think also, you know, GMT does have some purpose-built solo things like I Napoleon and Fields of Fire and so that probably helps as well. So I I think GMT is just so big that they cover a lot of space.

Yeah.

And and so you know like you said market share is for GMT even if it's not pure market share mind share is certainly very high for them

that

well thanks for noting Stuka Joe because that's an example of you know the the enduser community the fan community stepping in and sort of showing the way on on solo mode approaches.

Yeah. which maybe companies need to see, you know, before they start realizing we can do this ourselves.

Yeah. Well, and something else that came up the other day that that I thought was a little interesting. Um, so there's uh Compass Games, as we are recording this, Compass Games has now started shipping their uh holiday cataloges, right? The the giant fold out holiday catalog that that is always a blast to to receive every year. And and and look, we we're all weird in our own ways. One of the weirdo things that I've got, I I I have a giant stack of game company cataloges in a box here that I I hang on to over the years, like I going all the way back to mid70s Avalon Hill cataloges. Like if I get a used game and it's still got the catalog in there, I pull those things out and I throw them in a stack to the point where a bunch of the local gamers here know that I I keep these things. And so they've started bringing me their older cataloges from from older games.

And and going back, the Compass one in particular, I've got them back to 2019 and somebody had asked about, hey, how long has this particular game been in the Compass Games catalog? They asked in our Discord server the other day. And so I was like, I got them back 2019. Let me go look. It's in there in 2019. Coming soon. And like all the way up to this year, it's still coming soon. They just keep changing the date. But I noticed just kind of eyeballing these things the other day when I was I was flipping through looking for that answer for Bill that more and more of the things in the Compass catalog from 2019 to 21 to 22 to 23 I don't know if they published one in 2020 but I don't have it if they did that you start to see more games either designated as uh designed for solo play or you know solo compatible.

the both of those designations go up. So, they were taking in more designs for solo designers as well as highlighting in more places that they were that they had solo adaptations available to them. So, and that's that's one company just because I happen to have the cataloges over several years, I can go and compare between them.

Yeah. Um, but but I do think it's something that you've seen more of. Um, and probably became more, you know, as Liz has noted, it probably became more popular uh during the pandemic and then, you know,

they're not not coming out any faster though.

Yeah. No,

I will say I mean, you know, talking about kind of hobbyists stepping in, I don't think that I would have my job if it weren't a clear like community um message that people want solo modes and they want good, thoughtful solo modes that actually show care for the solo community. Um, so you know, I have a mandate at work to try to like meet those expectations, which like I wake up in a cold sweat occasionally, but um, but you know, I think that, you know, any Kickstarter you look at, any crowdfund, does it solo? Is there going to be a solo mode? People want it. And you know, I think that we also owe a lot to war games like from their inception, from early um I think for those attitudes. And uh one thing I really enjoy about doing this list every year is even if you're a hobby gamer who is not who does not consider themselves a war gamer, I think that the entire solo gaming hobby owes a lot to especially some of these earlier war game titles um because people playing against themselves, people coming up with kind of rudimentary early bots, the rise of like narrative gaming, all those things.

I, as far as I know, emerge from the war game community. And so, you know, even if you don't consider yourself a war gamer, something that you're playing has war game DNA.

Uh, Liz, to to your point there, uh, first amen to everything you said, and obviously one of the reasons we became friends is our similar perspective on solo wargaming. uh you know the the sea change in the whole community uh may be reflected in the fact that there's now inherent pressure I think to create solo modes even when the game might not be appropriate to it.

Yeah.

And I think designers now have to know when to say look this just can't be soloed uh or at least not in the published version. I mean, some person out there will always find a way, and that's fine by me, but as far as forcing that onto a game production circle or cycle, uh, you know, that's not something you want to do in every last case and the pressure may be there to do it because companies see the advantage of having a mode. Um, the other thing we haven't talked about, you know, the the elephant in the room as always is AI and how will AI over time be used um ad hoc by players of these various games and and if that's happening, will that affect our rankings at some point? We've got a local guy here that's already experimenting with that some and then sharing I he's in our Discord also and and talks about it some in the Discord of hey I I plugged in this information into one of the the LLMs and said you know give me this plan and so he he kind of used that as as the broadstrokes opponent of these are the kinds of things we're going to have this thing do and then he he executes from there. Um, you know, going going back to the idea of looking back over time as to where uh or how some of these things developed, I remember when when the solo game universe was Ambush and Patton's Best and like that was that that was it.

Like that, you know, Ambush and its expansions and then Patton's Best and that that was it. But the other thing was at the time if you go back to up through the early and mid 80s basically up until TSR buys SPI the the war game universe up to that point because that that's kind of a a fairly clear break point in the history of tabletop wargaming at least. Um there weren't a lot of particularly, you know, weird cases out there for the games. The the the the block games, what's now the Colombia block games are are the clear exception where there was an unambiguous fog of war, hidden information that clearly could not be penetrated without fundamentally changing the game. there was some fog of war that was sort of two-sided fog of war. In the case of uh the the late 70s, mid late7s, SPI had a series of games um that that I want to say Panzer Group of Gdarian was the first of the the ones to use the untried units. So, they're face down units. You don't know what the combat values are.

You only know what the movement values are until they're in contact. You can solo that. I mean, it's hidden information, but it's hidden from both players. So, it's not like you get an inherent advantage where you have to like, you know, switch off your brain one way or the other. Um, the Mod Quad 2, Invasion America, there were a couple of those games that had that untried unit mechanic. Gives you some fog of war that is soloable with no real change in how you play the game. The block games, obviously, you can't because the information is only facing one player. Uh but but up until you put cards in people's hands, there's not really a whole lot of information that only one player is privy to. And so while something like Patton's Best or Ambush gave you a surprise factor as the player, um you know, you could play Africa Core two-handed. You could play, you know, Mech War II. You could play Napoleon's Last Battles. You play any of those two-handed because there's nothing hidden.

So, it's it's not like you have an an inherent advantage one way or the other up to that point. I think once you start seeing the the Mark Herman CDGs, once you start seeing more block games, once you start seeing information that is only held by one player, um the TCS games with the OP sheets from MMP or or you know the the ASL games with the hidden setup where you can cover your stacks of counters with question marks. Once you get to information that is only available to one player, now suddenly the bots become a little more necessary. So

yeah, I think there's a lot lot of truth in that.

Yeah. Yeah.

I also want to talk really quick just about the number the the designers who are appearing a lot at the top.

Yeah.

Um because John Butterfield is clearly still the man. There's a good variety in this top 25. But

I did go look Fire in the Lake is credited only to Mark Herman, not to Vulco. Um, in the way I So BGG lists both Mark Herman, Vocco Rookie, but the way the query returned to us. Um, it only credits Mark Herman, not both. Um, yeah, which which is is cumbersome, right? A bunch of Ben Madison designs are co-designs with Wes Ernie. bunch of David Thompson designs are co-designs with I mean other than the

Although Pablo's house is just David.

Yeah. The value defense ones I think are all just David. But other than that I think literally everything else David's done has been with somebody else.

Yes. He's got just a whole crew of us that just

Yeah. It's the Cambridge Six, right? Right. I mean, somebody posted the graphic on social media not long ago of, you know, David and Trevor Benjamin and those couple of other folks and and the connections between all of them of who's worked with who. So,

yeah.

Although David will tell you that codeesign is just more fun. So, solo gaming but make it together is I think the advice.

I I think at the at the at the top of the list it's the usual suspects, right? Butterfield, Herman, Dan Buren, Ben Madison, Richard Berg, Greg M. Smith, who's probably designed seven more games in the time it's taken us to record this.

Yeah.

Um,

Richard Clark, Dave Kershaw, Herman Lutman, Vulco, uh, Jim Dunigan, Mike Lambo, Mike Granilla. Like that's

if you Hey, give me your rogue top 10 solo game designers. Like that's,

you know,

there they are.

It It is exactly who you would expect them to be. Um, which I I don't find weird. I mean, that's

No, not at all. All right. So, as we kind of reach the close of the hour, um I guess uh do y'all have some final thoughts and maybe some hopes for the future of this list?

All what do you got?

Uh I I'm just always intrigued uh by the list each year now that I've gotten involved with all of you talking about it. Um, I am interested in some of the things Brandt was mentioning earlier about uh changing demographics among war gamers. And that's not I'm I'm so glad Brandt said it's not just an age thing. It's in fact maybe more so about who's a veteran of these games and who's a rookie to these games regardless of when they're getting started. you are seeing, you know, just as we found a lot of war gamers migrating to try other types of games, be it Euro games or whatever it might be, card um deck builders, etc. Uh it goes the other direction too, right? People who would never have imagined themselves trying a war game per se are now experimenting with them or even designing them. And they're realizing that it's not just Hex Encounter anymore. And even Hex Encounter is being uh appreciated by those uh new gamers who might have been gaming for decades, right? But they are new to that sort of war game sphere. So the data will just get more interesting as we get more people involved in this community. And I agree, we need to get more people doing the survey. I think we will have some interesting uh revelations, you know, the larger our our set gets of respondents.

I will say that one fear I have about our list marketing and maybe this ties into my own hopes for the future of the list is that you know I think that people when they see oh what are your top war games I think a lot of people still tell themselves they're not war gamers even if actually they are even if it's the nontraditional style and I want people to feel comfortable does this only ask for your top five and I want to get to a place where enough people have played five historical games five war games on their own so they feel like they are contributors to the list. And that is my goal. I would like to see more people either new to this or doing it, but like embracing the fact that they're that they're one of us.

And to clarify, Liz, the and Brandt, the list does not, it seems to me at all, exclude uh nonhistorical war games and conflict simulations. So,

um, this root is on there.

I think Root's on the list, though. You can't control what people put in the list,

right?

In years past.

Yeah. So, so in years past, we had um we had things like Space Empires 4X showed up on the list. Um and I think Burning Banners was on there last year. I'd I'd have to go back and look, but we had uh nonrealistic games, let's say it that way, because we we still have you'll still find some Cold War goes hot games on there, even those aren't those aren't strictly historic. Lator Commander is not a historic game. Like, it's near future, but it's still realistic, if you will. One of the things that we did specifically put in the information in in the invite this year, the initial post that said, "Hey, come do this survey was we were looking for war and historical games, not the fantasy sci-fi stuff. So, please don't put the fantasy and sci-fi things on here." Um, so we don't get Space Infantry or Freedom of the Galaxy or Space Empire 4X or whatever. Um so so this year we did put that specific caveat um in the intro to everything that we didn't do in 2023 and 24. I think we'll probably leave it in place going forward.

Yeah.

But that doesn't rule out something like Molly House, which is not a war game, but it is a deeply themed historical game. And I think for for you know when when Liz and I first talked about this uh her vision of kind of that that deep historical theme we were okay going a little further a field and and yeah we'd end up roping in Molly House as as a part of that. But we also put in there we're not defining wargaming for you because for some people Twilight Struggle is a war game. For other folks it's not. For some folks you know

uh John Company is a war game. For others it is not. we're we're not going to try and draw that line for you.

So, I would say I appreciate the caveat and uh personally I gravitate to historical games myself.

Yeah.

Um but as Liz said, people are going to put what they're going to put down on the list. So, I wouldn't get rid of the caveat. I would just say we live in interesting times, right? Yeah. Where the number one war game on board game is War of the Ring,

which is a great game, and I do think it is a war game. Uh, it doesn't have a solo mode, nor do I really think it ought to have one. People have tried I've tried them, but and some some of them are great efforts, but it's just not really designed as that. But in an environment where that is viewed as a war game,

it it should inform our conversation. Let's say that.

But I agree with the caveat in principle. Yeah, that that's something that I in order to better hone our focus, we we put that in there. Uh not that I was afraid of War of the Ring and Burning Banner sort of running away with with the the list or anything.

Um but I think it helps us focus the audience a little bit on on the kinds of things we're looking for. Um

yeah, agreed.

You know, and and people to use Liz's vocabulary, people have understood the assignment. Nobody's putting Ticket to Ride on the list. You know, we're

Look, anything's a war game if you try hard enough. Okay.

Yes. We're not so much worried about those. Um, you know, I I definitely want to see participation go up.

Yeah.

And and I think there are some ways that we can approach

uh encouraging that participation. One of them is simply, hey, if you've done this survey, please go recruit a friend to do it. Also,

um, you know, there's the Ozarks joke of, well, if you're playing solo games because you don't have any friends, yeah, fine. Go find a friend. Um, part of it is the some of the best places to market this are ones that have some inherent restrictions on how much you market to their audiences. like some of the Facebook groups. I mean, there's 15,000 people in the main War Gamers group on Facebook,

but they are fairly restrictive about how often you promote things like this that if you

don't hit them multiple times,

of those 15,000, 14,000 of them never see it because of how often they log in, how many other things show up and push you down the list there. So, so there are some challenges trying to get the word out. I don't live on Reddit, but even the friends that I have that hang out on Reddit have tried to post, "Hey, you should go check this thing out," and it gets flagged as spam on Reddit. It'd be nice to have some way to get it into the appropriate groups there.

Um,

yeah, Reddit's scary, though.

It it can be, but there are some very active wargaming groups on Reddit and and it would be nice to be able to promote this through some of those. Um, I don't have a Reddit account. I there's there's, you know, a place or two here and there where I go read some stuff like my local community just to see, hey, new restaurant's opening up, but I I don't hang out on Reddit, so I don't have an account to try and do that stuff. But but folks who do tried to help and, you know, got flagged as spam, and that was that was kind of annoying. So, it would be nice to be able to more organically grow the marketing. And and Liz, you know, the the QR code at at Origins would probably help that. Um, you guys could probably do it at Gen Con, too, here or there or somewhere.

Um, whatever other summer conventions we might be able to hit.

It's It's tough. It's tough. You're asking for people to voluntarily help you out somehow and not get a whole lot out of it,

but it would be nice to have a

get a sick list of the tough work.

It would be nice to have a bigger data set. And ultimately, I think it comes back to, hey participants, please share this and go get a friend to come do it also.

Yeah. Yeah. So, here's hoping for bigger years. But honestly, I just love doing this list every year because I like to see what people like. I think it's really cool.

Um, and it makes me, I guess, feel like reconnected to everybody to see that, you know, what everybody else is playing. It's like, I don't know. It's like a touch base with a bigger conversation that I like being a part of. Yeah. And and one thing just real quick that I will throw out. So we've got we've got the master list that's already been published. The we've got it excerpted down to just the top 26 27 or so. Again, you know, it expands a little bit because of some ties that Liz has posted as a geek list overGeek. Um but we also do some additional data crunching with some of those other data, some other parts of the data that we have. So, for instance, we separated out the top 25 for the rookies versus the veterans. The top 25 for the folks um that are 75% or more of their board gaming is wargaming versus the 0 to 25%.

So, the high war gamer versus low war gamer count in your in your board gaming diet. We've got some cross tabs of um how much you or why do you play versus what percentage of your game is uh your gaming is is wargaming. uh where do you get your info by what percentage of your gaming is working? So, we've got some additional data diving that we've done that's going to get published over the next few weeks after this video goes out there. Like, if you're listening to this two years later, like it's already published. Go look for it. Um I am happy to let other people crunch numbers also. I don't mind providing a set of deidentified data to folks to say, "Hey, go take a look at this. Um see what you get. Uh, if you find something interesting, crunch away. I am happy to let other folks play with the data.

Also, um, I've made that offer every year. Nobody's taken me up on it yet. So,

well, maybe this is the year.

Rookies versus vets is very interesting. I was just looking at it. That alone. Yeah.

Yeah. And and for those, you know, once we start slicing the data set thinner, you really can't draw a whole lot of conclusions outside of about the top 10 to 15 or so. simply because you don't have enough votes to really aggregate up at that point. One favorite game is going to skew what's left of the voting down below. Uh but that top 10 to 15 or so, you've got enough votes that you can really see some distinctions.

Um yeah,

the other thing I haven't pulled yet that I need to is I want to go back and take a look at um the games that showed up on all three lists,

not necessarily in the top 10 to 15 or so because it's a lot of the usual suspects. Uh, but I'm also curious, what's the population of games that only ever showed up on one list, right? What are the ones that showed up on 2023 and never again or 2024 and never again? So,

yeah. Or do we just have one person who will never give up on their favorite? And I respect that.

Yes. What's the one game that got one first place vote in all three surveys?

Happy to see that guy, right? He's voting for the one he designed. I say he, could be she. I'm happy either way.

Um, so, uh, on this note, since we've been going about an hour, uh, we will conclude. But gentlemen, thank you so much for coming on. This has been such a fun chat. I enjoy doing this every year.

Same here.

Absolutely.

All right, everybody out there, please like, subscribe, ask questions, and most of all, happy gaming. Go play war game.

Progress saved