Top 100 Mechanisms in Board Games: 60-51
Transcript
hi i'm adam porter and this is my top 100 board game mechanisms that i love and 10 that i really don't and over the last few videos we've been counting down from 100 to 61 and today we're looking at numbers 60 to 51 so let's get stuck in number 60 on the list is positional drafting so what this means is where you have a bunch of cards or tiles laid out in a grid and then we select those cards but we we can only sort of access them uh from the edges or by moving a certain piece around the board in order to access them so you've only got access to certain certain cards in that display and in the case of seven wonders dual for example when i take a card it might reveal other cards that then become available but we weren't sure what they were until that card had been revealed so maybe some are face up some are face down it's a really satisfying way of doing a draft of getting cards into people's hands because you've you've got limited choices which is great because it means you're not going to sit there for ages thinking about all these you know many many options that are available to you but you've also got a little bit of foresight you can see what's going to happen uh a few turns ahead so you can kind of plan for right well if i take this card now maybe the other player will take that one which might give me access to this one and of course those plans can change but you're often setting up your opponents when you take cards i mean it doesn't have to be as complicated as something like seven wonders jewel in with that big grid a
positional draft could be something as simple as the system in santa monica where if i take a card from the bottom row then the card from the top row slides down and becomes available for the next round so positional drafting is one really clever way of reducing the number of available choices but still allowing a little bit of forward planning in your card draft number 59 is what i'm calling the fantasy realms mechanism now this is fantasy realms is a game where essentially you have a hand of cards and you're always going to have that same number of cards in your hand but throughout the game you're going to be swapping those cards with cards from the center of the table and cards blind from the top of the deck and once a certain number of cards have been placed into the center of the table into essentially the discard pile then the game ends and we score the cards that you have left in your hand so you're essentially trying to build the best possible selection of cards that are going to combine with each other in all sorts of different ways to give you the best possible scoring potential this mechanism was elaborated on in stonemeyer games red rising uh adding a board and other little levers and tables that you could you could kind of move pieces over to to score points in various different ways but really the core mechanism is from fantasy realms and it's a really simple satisfying one and that mechanism harks back a little further to games like golf where players have a series of cards on the table face down and then throughout the game they're going to be swapping
those cards out to try and get better cards into their display until the game ends we reveal all of our cards in front of us and we see who's got the best stuff this game comes up the golf that traditional public domain game which should play with a regular pack of playing cards it comes up frequently in um published games like that attack cat has a similar mechanism as well as omerta and uh and the silver silver bullet silver coin silver i can't remember what they all are games from bezier games they all use this same system i really like that system because i think it's really streamlined essentially we have a set of stuff it's never getting any bigger all we're doing is swapping stuff out to try and make the best possible selection in front of us and the other players are doing the same number 58 is catch up rewards so there's lots of different catch-up mechanisms in games and i'm sure we'll be touching on a few more of those as we go down the list but this is where the players who are behind get some sort of benefit to help to boost them back up again so for example in isle of skye if you're behind you'll be getting additional income additional money to help you to buy better tiles to help you to catch up with the other players who are ahead in the game quacks of quedlinberg if you're behind you get these little rat tails that you can put into your cauldron that just gives you a slight head start you're further down the track than the other players when they begin so you're more likely to score the better points and get more currency to buy better stuff
some people don't like this mechanism because it feels a little bit artificial essentially you know it's just closing that playing field when actually the the players who are behind are behind because often they haven't played with a great deal of skill um so people feel it's unfair but i i would rather that than people being left out of the game you know who wants to realize you're losing a game in the first or second turn and then find that you've got to sit through the rest of the game knowing you're never going to catch up well these mechanisms give you a chance it's the equivalent of the game mario kart where if you're way out in the front way out in the lead you're going to get hit by that nasty blue shell that's going to slow you down and if you're out in the lead you're going to get the worst power-ups whereas the people who are behind are going to be getting great power-ups whenever they drive through those boxes that give you rewards if you don't play mario kart you won't know what i'm talking about but but that sort of catch-up mechanism is i think it's essential in a in a in any game really i was going to say in a light game where where it doesn't really matter but perhaps it's even more important that there are ways to catch up in a long strategic game where you could be sat there for hours and if you're falling behind then it's only going to get more and more depressing for you and we all want every player to have a good time right number 57 is real time so this is where we don't have turns in a game where essentially we all just play simultaneously usually there's a time element to this so it could be a game like magic maze where we're all playing together and we're trying to find the the different treasures and
then get out of that shopping mall but we're all doing it at the same time rushing to move our pieces around and place the tiles and get to those locations or it could be a game like deja vu which is a memory game where we're where we're trying to spot have we seen that before is this the second time that it's come out of that deck in which case we grab the piece but everybody's doing the same activity all at the same time without any turns now i really enjoy this mechanism when it works and when it's simple when i understand what's going on one of the problems with this mechanism is that you can't really stop and check um have i understood the rules correctly because everybody else is so frantically doing what they're doing that it kind of ruins it if you have to stop and say uh sorry can i just stop and ask this and i've had that experience before i remember playing escaped curse of the temple many years ago for the first time and having a baffling rules explanation then being thrown into this real time thing where i was thinking i don't know what i'm doing i don't know whether i'm cheating i don't know whether i'm playing correctly and there's nobody i can ask because everybody else is so busy so i think that's one of the downsides of real time and i think some people are going to be turned off by the stress that it creates number 56 is roll and write games but specifically those that use number sequences which is a lot of them i recently made a video about how to design a role and write game looking all the different mechanisms used in these games but number sequences is a big part of it so in quicks and quinto and welcome to
for example you have to position numbers and they must go from the smallest number to the highest number as you go sort of along a a particular row and there may be other limitations for example in quinto you can't place the same number in the different levels of a column so in addition to having to place them in numerical order along the row and some of them if you put a number down you can't then put something lower uh once you put it you you're kind of stuck with it in others you can you can put lower numbers as long as they're in the right sequence um and i find this you know it's simple mathematics isn't it it's kind of that that end of mathematics which is accessible and you know feels like problem solving feels more like a puzzle than than work um if you go too far down this down that line the balance tips and it becomes okay well now i'm just doing maths again it becomes a bit of a chore but i do like simple number sequences in games i find it satisfying it fires off some of those those neurons in my brain that maybe i haven't used since school days um and yeah putting things in sequence organizing things is something that that appeals i think to everybody the organization part of your brain number 55 is three or four or five in a row okay essentially it's it's tic-tac-toe really isn't it or or norths and crosses is where we're trying to connect up a series of things but we're blocking each other as we go usually an abstract game but we're trying to to to make a chain
of adjacent things it could be the game connect 4 for example but the versions that i really enjoy is quarto which we'll be coming back to later in this list goblet goblet you're trying to make i think it's four in a row but you're you're able to place pieces over the top of other pieces hiding them and then you can move that piece again later but when you do you may forget that there's a piece hiding underneath it so you might reveal one of your opponent's pieces which might be just what they need in order to complete their set of four in a row so this mechanism i find i guess it's just familiar that's why i enjoy it it harks back to playing you know noughts and crosses or tic-tac-toe you know in the back of a school uh school book a school exercise book when i should have been listening to the teacher you know scribbling away playing with a playing with a friend that's that's my sort of where my fondness and nostalgia for this sort of system comes from but it because it's so familiar it's very accessible to new players you know if if you put a game of quarto or goblet in front of a new player they're not going to be totally lost in fact you can see their eyes light up when they go oh this is like that game that i knew but it's better because it's got this this twist and the twists are not overbearing in those two games the twists are a nice simple things that just liven the game up a little bit and give it a bit of spice number 54 is worker placement now this is quite low on the list isn't it really 54. i know worker placement is sort of a favorite mechanism of many
many people particularly people who like quite large strategy games so worker placement is where each player has one or more workers usually more uh a bunch of different sort of playing pieces tokens and they can place them onto a central board in order to take an action and that action might be to gather resources for example so in agriculture you'd take the action of placing your worker in order to take wood now what happens there is nobody else can now use that action spot while i'm sat there no one else can go there so i've blocked it off i've limited their access to that wood and and they're gonna have to wait till the next round and maybe it's gonna take some time for that wood to replenish because in in agriculture for example we're adding resources each round to those spaces and if you let them build up for a number of turns before anyone takes the action they get a better reward but over the years lots and lots of variations of worker placement have have evolved and in in all sorts of different ways and no longer is it the case that a worker absolutely blocks the space often there's ways around that whether it's the grande worker in viticulture who can kind of break the rules and and sneak in there or the white um the white pawns that you get in in dominant species marine that have their own special worker placement spots where they can access better versions of the actions than anybody else in in dominant species marine you can only place workers further down the chart than your
previous workers so so it functions a little bit like a rondelle really if you want to take one of the actions at the top of that table then you better do that early in the round because if you take a lower action you're not going back up to that top until you've placed all your pawns and retrieved them so worker placement has proven itself to be a really versatile system for large strategic games it's something that confuses a lot of people newcomers into the hobby because it's jargon essentially and people think well if i'm you know in a carcass on if i'm placing a uh one of my little person tokens i mean reasonably you could call that a worker and i'm placing onto a tile well i'm placing a worker therefore as a worker placement game and that's not the case it's one of those um annoying bits of jargon the game is used where we say no no you're wrong you might be placing a worker but it's not worker placement um and i suppose specificity in these mechanisms is is really essential particularly if you're you're a designer um you've got to be thinking about right well you know what is this mechanism that i'm using what other games utilize that so it's useful to have some sort of classifying system but i'm not sure the term is particularly helpful it's actually a subsection of a previous category that i've mentioned already in my top 100 which is action selection perhaps worker placement is just the most famous version of action selection that we have in the hobby right now number 53 is hidden movement and i've not found too many games that i really like with hidden movement the one that i really really enjoy is scotland
yard scotland yard was one of my favorite games probably my favorite game as a child so it's been around for a long time it was as spield as yara's winner all the way back then and amongst all the games of monopoly and cluedo and everything else that i was playing the mass market games um there was scotland yard this german game and i didn't realize at the time that this was something different this was an early version of a sort of euro game really it was it had a different aesthetic it had more strategy and it was just that bit more satisfying but i'm really glad that i could even record without knowing that stuff without knowing that it came from a different sort of ancestry or a different um a different background to the the the mattel and mb and and hasbro games at the time um i still recognize the quality in it so i'm glad that you know looking back and seeing that a child can see through all that stuff and see where there is quality sophisticated design and i don't think scotland yard has ever been bettered you know games like fury of dracula and letters from white chapel i feel they complicate the game i feel they extend the time unnecessarily whereas scotland yard is very simple quick to play and really satisfying you're chasing mr x around a map of london and you can see what modes of transport he's using but you don't know what location he's at but every now and then he reveals himself and you think well okay right he was at that location but since then he's used a taxi and a bus and an underground and so maybe he's
here and the other players will work as a team and try and hone in on mr x so i mentioned in the previous one of my previous 10 for this list i really enjoy teamwork well this is a great example of it working together as a team in order to catch that one player who's functioning as mr x so that's a hidden movement game i'd like to see more of these that don't complicate the game but maybe just you know a clever twist on what happened in scotland yard all those years ago number 52 is take that now take that is often hated by players players don't like take that very much and i understand it and i i i guess i don't in certain circumstances so it's got to be used carefully and skillfully but i really like it in games like abyss and bruges where those are two examples of tableau building games where i can choose to to pick up cards and and use strategies that uh enhance my own powers and work on my own resources gathering resources um you know and just make me better and better at scoring points and things like that or i can choose to use the powers that directly knock back the other players that take their stuff that beat them down and i mean those games i feel get away with it because it's used sparingly and it's not particularly punishing um and it's just those little delicious moments where you feel like you're being a little bit naughty because you're you know all the other players are all
playing quite nicely but haha they didn't know i was going to play this card and there's some fun in that some vindictive fun in that the problem is when it goes too far or when it can overturn a player's entire strategy you know in some games if you play it take that card in the middle of it and okay everything they've been working on for the last half hour or hour has been ruined or maybe it's even lost in the game that's extremely frustrating when those sort of things happen in a super light game then i can really get on board with take that too i can find it really fun to be playing cards back and forth attacking each other as long as the you know if the whole game is built around take that i can buy into it i don't want it to drag on too long and i think that's a problem with some of the the mainstream versions of that like um uh for example flux or munchkins some of these games can drag on and on and on but when it's kept short and simple i think take that can be a really funny fun mechanism it's it's it's fun to be vindictive once in a while um when when with friends who understand and aren't going to be hurt or offended by it number 51 is a variable interface and what i mean by that is essentially it could be a modular board um it could be a different you know a different board different maps for example in power grid you can buy all sorts of different maps for that game that change the way the game plays the way it feels in kingdom builder you build your map by placing together four different boards and you can put them in different orientations you can you know there's lots of different boards to
choose from and so it creates a different layout of terrain that just changes the way you play the game each time in cartographers they release map packs they've just started releasing these expansion map packs same thing happens in welcome 2 and these just change although the core rules haven't changed it just changed the way you play the game slightly and i think this is a great way of keeping games refreshing whether it comes in the main box or whether these are expansions i don't really care i just like the fact that the game can be refreshed without actually changing the core rules just by pervading providing you with a different sort of playing space um to to get stuck into so those are my numbers 60 to 51 and as we've done in previous videos um i'm now going to finish off by telling you one mechanism in a game that i really don't like and that today is going to be pre-game auctions now i've previously talked in one of these videos about how i enjoy auctions and i do i like auctions in games what i don't like is an auction right at the start an auction to kind of determine we're bidding to see who gets to be that player that role uh who gets to use that special ability or play a turn order we're bidding for who gets to go first or second or third um i find that a clunky mechanism an awkward mechanism it's a is a mechanism that alienates new players because how are they to know what they're supposed to bid they've never played the game before so how are they supposed to decide how much they it's worth to be first player
or second player or third player or how much you know it's worth to have that power over another power i just think it's a yeah just a really awkward mechanism that is only there for experienced players which means you're always going to have a really sort of dodgy first second third experience to play in that game by which time you're probably most players have probably done with it with plenty of other games to play they've probably moved on so yeah i'd like to see the end of pre-game auctions not my favorite mechanism at all i hope you enjoyed the video today let me know what you think of the mechanisms that we've talked about i mean what do you think of take that for example i bet a load of you out there hate it and maybe some of you love it love being vindictive let me know in the comments i really like knowing your opinions if you've never commented before please stop by and say hello if you're just visiting the channel for the first time make sure you subscribe because there's going to be more and more videos like this over the coming days weeks months so i've got loads of videos on my channel you can go back and watch as well and i'll see you in a couple of days for the next installment all the best