What's on Your 10x10 Board Game Challenge for 2020?
Transcript
H1! It's Ryan from Nights Around a Table, and i'm doing something new for 2020 at the behest of my lovely wife Cheryl, who is the family's planner and organizer, who's setting all kinds of goals for this year: she wants it to be a complete blowout! She's got fitness goals, she's got food goals, and she's got leisure goals. So she is really on us to do a 10x10 Challenge. "What is a 10x10 Challenge," you ask? Well, that's where you pick ten games from your board game collection, and you play them each ten times, and you've got a year to do it. The challenge to see if you can do it in a year. Neat! Does it have to be a 10x10 Challenge? No! You can do all kinds of mix- ups. You can do a 20x5, you can do a... i'm not good at lowest common denominators!
Some other math-y thing, where you play a number of your board games a certain number of times. How do you track it? Well, you could use a boring old piece of paper, or write on the back of a bill envelope that you're gonna lose by May. You can go to Etsy, or you could make for yourself a fancy tracker sign that you can hang up in your game room. i've got a Pinterest board that you can check out that shows you what a couple of these may look like, and to be honest, i think that that is one of the strongest appeals for Cheryl, because she just really wants to build one of those cool 10x10 tracker boards. Or, you can use this app: BG Stats. i was introduced to this app a few years ago when i went to a local board game conference. Somebody said it's great, because you get to track the board games that you play, and i said "Well, why is that exciting?" and they said all kinds of things.
You can find out how often you've won, and how often you've lost, and who you played with, you can track where you played... and then just stuff like start player position and who played which role, so you can actually suss out whether certain roles are stronger than others - all kinds of stuff in the BG Stats app. Go to BGstatsapp.com to grab this. It's a few bucks, maybe five bucks, and if you pay a few extra bucks, you can grab the add-on content, which gives you the Challenges mode. So here you can see - no spoilers, but i've popped in the 10 games that my family has picked to do our 10x10 Challenge for 2020. Why are we doing this? Well, i can see a few benefits, and a few disadvantages, actually, to doing a 10 x10 Challenge. One of the benefits is that if you've got a big board game collection... we're a really consumerist culture, especially in the board game hobby, and we're just constantly amassing board games and spending money and amassing board games, and then Kickstarter's really bad for it.
They're like "Ah! Buy this board game we'll give you nine more board games on top of that, and board games inside your board games, n' ... mmm board games." So what it does is it lets you slow down. It lets you focus on a few of the games that you have that you can really enjoy, so instead of buying 8 million games and playing them each at once ,you can go through your games and really... really savour them, right? Really taste your food. And as a side effect, you're gonna save money, and you're gonna save shelf space, which i am fast running out of! One of the joys of board games is when you really put a board game through its paces, you really get to discover all its nooks and crannies, and emergent strategies appear, and you get to find out the best routes to victory, and you can't really do that if you only play a game once or twice, or even four times.
If you really sit down and play a game a bunch of times, you can really spelunk it and figure out if it's a great game that's gonna stand the test of time in your collection, and if it's not, yeah maybe nix it? Maybe sell it, and save that shelf space, and maybe fill that with something that deserves to be there a little bit more? i like that, especially when using the BG Stats app - which, by the way, i'm not being paid by the BG Stats app guy to plug it. i just think it's a great app. i use myself all the time. My friends make fun of me for using it, but foo on them... now i know who won that game of Trickerion four years ago. But it lets you figure out who's really good at a game - a particular game - and who really stinks at it.
So maybe you picked 10 games, you put them on your 10x10, and you find out that one member of your family just KILLS at worker placement games, and another member of your family is really strong at trick-taking games, but that worker placement person stinks at them! i dunno - that's kind... that's kind of a fun... fun insight. But perhaps the biggest benefit that i see, and my wife Cheryl sees, in doing a 10x10 is when i put together my Christmas list, whenever i put together a wishlist for board games, really what's nagging at me in the back of my brain is: i don't really want more board games. What i want is more TIME to play board games. i want to enjoy the board games that i have. rather than amassing new ones all the time. And that's what the 10x10 Challenge lets you do.
It gives you an excuse - nay, an IMPERATIVE, because you're on the clock, to sit down with the family and play a board game, and my family likes to put it off a lot. i say "You want to play a board game?" "Nuhhhh - i'm doing something, Dad." "No no no - we're... we're off," you know, and then Cat's in the Cradle by Cat Stevens plays, and a single tear rolls down my cheek. What this does is we can say now, like, we can't put it off. We HAVE to play this board game tonight or we screw up the entire year's challenge! So i don't know if we can get the kids' buy-in on that. As you may know, i have two daughters - Cassandra and Isabel - and they are ages 13 and 11, and i don't have them for a whole lot longer. i'm really conscious of that. So this is an exciting opportunity to sit down at the table, to look into their faces, which we don't do all the time - i admit we eat dinner while watching TV together quite often, and that's just not the quality family togetherness bonding time that i want out of my family experience.
So! 10x10 helps us get all that good stuff in. What are the disadvantages of a 10x10? Well, the first obvious one is that maybe you're gonna get sick of the games that you pick. That's why some people tend to favor a 20x5 or, maybe - you know - reduce the... increase the number of games, or reduce the number of times that you play them. That's fair. Another disadvantage is that y... it doesn't leave a lot of room if, you know, a big exciting game comes along, and you pick it up. You'd really like to play it, but you got that 10x10 Challenge, so all of your free board game time is eaten up trying to get through that challenge. So it doesn't give you a whole lot of wiggle room, depending on how much leisure time you have to spend on board games. And if you use the BG Stats app, there's a hardcore mode on the Challenges add-on that says once you pick your x games and the number of times you're gonna play them, it's locked, and you can't change it for the rest of the year!
So it really, like, holds your feet to the fire. i decided not to opt for that particular setting! So our 10x10 is malleable, but we'll see how it goes. And then the last disadvantage i can see is, like what if you... what if you don't finish your 10x10, and then that's yet another goal that you didn't make, and maybe you're ten pounds heavier and you've been eating chips all year? It's just one more reason for you to feel like an utter failure. But! i thought about that a little bit, and i thought "Well, even if you... you don't get through the entire 10x10, you still have played a bunch of games a bunch of times with your family, and you've realized a bunch of those benefits that i mentioned earlier. So i think it's okay. i think you're fine. So without further ado, you must be wondering "Ryan, what is on your 10x10 Challenge list for 2020?"
Well, let me tell you! In no particular order (except the alphabet), here is what's on my 10x10 board game challenge list for 2020. Number 10: the Alhambra Big Box. This thing's taking up most of the shot. The Alhambra Big Box... a big box is a product where the publisher has come up with a base game, and then an expansion, and another expansion, another expansion... they've taken all the expansions in the base game, and rolled them into one gigantic product, which is what this is. i have never played this with my daughters, so i don't know if they'll like it, but my wife Cheryl and i think they probably will, especially my oldest daughter Cassandra. It's an economic management game with a little bit of city-building, if i remember, but it's been so long.
But the best memory i have of the Alhambra Big Box is when our family rented a cottage
or you may call it a cabin - a couple of hours north of here for the s... a week in the summer, and my friend Jess came up to the cottage, and she's not a big board game fan in the in the least, but she does like logistics, and she does like challenges. So this was a heck of a challenge! So we cracked this open and... and i said "Hey Jess: what if we played all of the expansions together at the same time??" and so she... i mean, it's vacation - whatever. So we popped it all open and read all the rules, and we sat down, and we spent hours, i think, reading the rules and organizing the pieces, and then another few hours playing the game with all the expansions. i don't remember at all how the game went, but i remember very fondly that experience with Jess.
And that's the true testament of a friend, isn't it? Somebody who doesn't like board games, yet will tackle something like that with you. Number9: The Castles of Burgundy. This is the very first modern board game that our family ever finished together, and it was only maybe a year and a half ago that we did it, and our family has a sort of an ADHD trait to us. It's interesting: one daughter is hypersensitive and can't handle distracting noises or movements, and my other daughter is hyperactive, and has to make noises with her mouth and snap and tap. She's a drummer. So you can imagine when we get together at the board game table, that poses a few challenges. So i was amazed and thrilled when we all got through a game of Castles of Burgundy together.
It's a great game. We've only ever played it in once, but i'm excited to play it with them multiple times. Ten times, you could say. Number 8: Cat Lady. This was one that the girls picked. They both really like it. It's fast. Its simple. We actually just played a game of it last night. It went, like, zippy, and they said "What - it's over already?" There is now a deluxe version of this game that comes in a tin. i'm not too sure about the resources, but when i was playing last night, i was like "These cubes don't look like actual tuna. Mweh!" i don't know if they do look like real fish in the deluxe version...? Funny though: when you feed cats, their food does kind of come out in cubes, or in cylinders when you shake it out of the can. Anyway, the other thing that this version is lacking, as we noticed last night, is a score pad, because there are all kinds of cards that you can get, and you can tell you up scores different ways.
So we missed that. It would be nice to have the deluxe version, but i'm not going to cry about it. Cat Lady: the girls like it, we like it, it plays quick, so we're excited to have that on the list. Number 7: Dice Forge, and the expansion, Dice Forge Rebellion. If you've been following along, i was on a vision quest to get a deck builder that doesn't use cards because i don't like shuffling that much, and i happened upon Dice Forge, which has customizable dice faces. This one... one of the common criticisms about it is that it sort of plays a bit longer than it needs to, and overstays its welcome. But i hope that by the time we play this a few times, it'll... i hope this with all the games, actually, on the 10x10 Challenge - it just will get zippier. Nobody has to be reminded of the rules, and we can bounce through a game a lot quicker than when you take a board game off your shelf, dust it off, and crack the rulebook and go "What is this again?"
So that's my hope with Dice Forge. Otherwise, i love the artwork in Dice Forge. i love that, hopefully, when we're all on our A game, it's a quick one to playm and maybe we can even get one done on a school night. Number 6: King of Tokyo. This is monster Yahtzee. If you haven't played it, it's a lot of fun. i never play it without the Power Up expansion, because i think it adds a fun dimension to it, and makes every monster unique. Again, this is another quick, zippy one that i hope we can get through on a school night. One of the drawbacks of it is the player elimination. So somebody can get knocked out of the round really early, and then not play for the rest of the game, but the saving grace is that hopefully - it's not always the case - but hopefully, the game is pretty short. i have seen matches draw on a little bit long.
We'll see how it all goes. Number 5: Last Will. Czech Games Edition sent me this copy of it. i'm surprised that this game doesn't get more love than i feel it should! i really enjoy this game, and to my delight and shock and surprise, when we sat down to play with the girls, they really liked the game too! They asked to play it again the very same day, and then they wanted to play it a THIRD time the next day! That's unheard of for any game, so Last Will very deservedly earned a place on our 10x10 Challenge. Number 4 Lords of Waterdeep, with the Scoundrels of Skullport expansion. Here's another game that i don't think i would ever play without the expansion, Scoundrels of Skullport, because it just adds so much, and makes it so much more interesting a game to play.
i admit that i burned myself out on this game because i grabbed the iOS app, and i was playing it like a fiend, and i really got addicted to being able to just jump right into a game without having to go through a long protracted setup of shuffling tiles and placing things everywhere, so - you know - the prospect of taking the physical thing off the board game shelf and putting it on the table, laboriously placing tokens, was just like ugh! Why would i do that when i can just play in a corner by myself with one light swinging from the concrete ceiling, and get paler and paler as... anyway, there are benefits to digital versions, and there are benefits to physical versions, and i think that it's been a long time since i've played the iOS app, so i think it's out of my system now, and i can stomach putting this game physically back on the table.
Number 3: Oh My Goods! It's a little game. It plays quickly in about an hour, but it's got enough semblance of complexity to keep me entertained. There are a few games that didn't make the cut, and i'll show you those in a second, and so this is kind of a concession to my brain needing things to be complicated. It's not really that complicated a game... somehow my how to play video for it went 22 minutes long. i think that it'll scratch my board game playing itch in a shorter amount of play time than some of the heavier stuff i've got in my collection. Number 2: Welcome To... This is a roll n' write game. It's a little bit like bingo, where you have a card, and you make some choices, and you write down your choices on the card, and everyone's writing choices based on the same data on their own card in a different way - a little bit like Yahtzee - and then at the end, depending on where you've written things - there's a tiny bit of Sudoku, i guess, in this game
depending on where you've written things, you score different points. It's fun, it's fast, it's the game that Cheryl requested for Christmas, so i picked it up for her, and i picked up a couple of extra packs. This one is... i don't know! Easter Egg Hunt, and Doomsday? ... cuz you know how those themes go together... and this one is Outbreak and Ice Cream Truck. Hmm! Next one will be Tooth Fairy and Euthanasia. i don't know what they're going for with these packs, but that's we've never played these. We don't know how they change the game at all, but excited to have them in case this gets super dull after the fifth play. Before we hit the last game on our 10x10 Challenge for 2020, let me show you a couple of the games that i forwarded that immediately got shot down by my kids, all for pretty much the same reason.
Roll for the Galaxy. i put it on the list because it plays quickly and i enjoy it. Kids? They don't like it. Both of my daughter's rejected this one out of hand. Scythe. "No, Dad. Too long. We got stuff to do, and lives to lead." "You're eleven." Trickerion. To my mind, playing Trickerion ten times in a year.... (cortles) it's a ridiculous thought. It thrills me to my core, but at six, seven hours a game with the expansions, it's just not gonna happen. And the last game on my 10x10 Challenge for 2020... Number 1: Wingspan. i don't like.
It... it's it's fine. It's fine. There are other games that i'd rather play, to be honest, but my wife Cheryl and my daughters both really like it, and so Who am i to argue? i want to spend time with them and i want to play board games, so sure. Wingspan's on the list. But enough about me! Tell me about you! Have you ever done a 10x10 or X by X challenge? That would be an XxX challenge... i don't want to know if you've done an XxX challenge! Have you... have you done one of these board game challenges? Naked? No! Tell me in the area below wherever you're watching this video if you've ever done one, and how it went, and whether you'd ever do one again, and what changes you would make, or you suggest that i make to my 10x10 before i get myself too far into the reeds.
Or you could join us on the Discord chat server and tell me all about it in 1337 speak... or emoji talk... i don't know. Whatever you want to do. i want to hear what's on your list, and why you put it on your list, and a couple weeks into the new year, how it's going! Maybe i will come back at you and June or July with an update about how our 10x10 Challenge has gone, or not gone. We'll see! We'll see how it rolls. Happy New Year, everyone! i hope 2020 is great for you, and thank you for watching! Did you just watch that whole thing? Oh - hey! To 100% this video, click the badge to subscribe, and then click the bell to get notifications when i've got new stuff!
[Music - Board Game Boogie by Ryan Henson Creighton]