Skip to main content
Loading video...

Board Game Pitfalls: AVOID the Mistakes I Made

Transcript 10:27

In today's episode, we're going to be going through pitfalls and board game booby traps to avoid so you can end up being more like Indiana Jones and less like BoardWithSteve. What the are all these board games doing down here? One of the biggest pitfalls I've fallen into, and it's a mistake that I catch myself doing all of the time, is buying a game that I already own. And I don't mean a literal same game over and over again. I mean a copy or a clone or a game that basically does the exact same thing, whether it's worker placement, engine building, area control, or whatever the genre of the game really. Unfortunately, we live in a world where so many games are just so similar to one another, especially when a game or a style of genre gets super popular. The most obvious example of this is trick-taking games. If we look at the amount of trick-takers released over the last 5 years, we can see that they have tripled. Let's also take a look at one of my favorite genres, puzzle games.

Games like Harmonies, Shallow Sea, Cascadia, Azul, the list goes on and on. I don't need to own all of these games and neither do you. Cuz what's going to happen is you're going to end up buying them all, you'll play the same two or three over and over again, and the other games are just going to become dead paperweights. So, do yourself a favor and find the ones that you really, really like and just stick with those and avoid the others. You don't need to own everything. There's just no need. Another pitfall and a mistake that I've made dozens of times, it's buying a game that's already available within my friend group. If you're anything like me and your friend group is the people that you spend the majority of your time playing games with, why are you buying a game that you can play for free because one of your friends already owns it? You can use that money to buy a game that your group don't have access to instead.

I know some games are amazing, but do you really need to own another copy of it? If you're playing with other groups and you play with family or whatever, then that makes more sense, but there's just no need. Use that money smarter and wiser. You don't need to just own things for the sake of owning them, especially if you can play them for free. Free is way better than paying money. And while we're talking about playing with a gaming group, another mistake which I found myself making over and over again, especially when I first got into the hobby, was just buying games for myself, even though I knew people in the group wouldn't like it. And why would you force people who you love to sit through a bad time? I can tell you exactly what's going to happen because it's happened to me before. You're going to get really, really excited. You're going to explain the game to everybody. People are going to hate it. They're going to be miserable, and then it's going to make you miserable, and then everybody's just going to have a miserable time.

It's just a mistake that's really easy to make. Whether the game's too mean, it's too long, it's too short, it's not heavy enough, it's too heavy, you have to find the right balance for your group. For a lot of people, board gaming is a community of experience, and it's all about just getting together and having a nice time. And if you're just bringing something for you, then you're just being selfish, especially if you're hosting. You want to make sure that everybody's having a good time. And unfortunately, this is something which I learned the hard way, so please don't be like me. And the next mistake that I found myself constantly making, especially when I first got into the hobby, was the Kickstarter all-in trap. Look, Game Found and Kickstarter are cool. Bling is cool, and board games are cool. But let me ask you one thing. Do you really need 44 expansions with 834 miniatures that have been painted with moonshine iridescent sun drop that cost you $500, then all you've end up with is a 75-ft pile of board games that you've played once, that you're too scared to come back to because you go to read the rule book and you discover that it's like buying one of those mega LEGO box sets and opening them up every single package, putting it in the middle, and then setting the instructions on fire because that's how difficult it is to set up and learn how to play when you've got so much stuff to add in. If you're going to back this style of game and you're really into it

and it's going to be the one game that you're truly going to sit and play and do every single bit and play every single campaign and complete every single mission, then heck yeah, go for the game. But, if you're anything like me and you're not all in on the game, you're going to end up wasting money on something that you didn't need when you could have just bought the base box and a few extra things and then got your worth from the game and moved on to the next one. One thing that I was totally against was the deluxeified versions of these like smaller Euro games, things like Puerto Rico for example. But, last year my wife bought me Castles of Burgundy special edition for my birthday and I completely take how I feel back about that. I think owning an amazing, beautiful edition of something that you're going to see and play a lot of is a wonderful thing to own. I think it's a really, really nice thing to have. Me and my wife probably play Castles of Burgundy 10 times a year. We see it a lot and it's fantastic. It's got so much replayability and the pieces are beautiful and it's honestly one of my favorite board games that I own now.

But, going for a deluxeified, all in on a game that you've never really heard of before, that there's little gameplay of and that just looks nice, I would say I would hold against stuff doing. It's not a proven entity and you don't even know if you're going to like it. So, maybe hold off on spending all of that money on something that's unproven and just try and wait. I know one of the worst things in the hobby that we have is FOMO, the fear of missing out, and I hate that companies, like especially Kickstarter, use it against you where it's like one-time printing, all in deluxe-ified copy, get it now, it's only this much money. If you don't do it now, you're going to miss out, it's never going to come back. But, trust me when I say this, if companies can make money from a board game, they're going to reprint the game. So, if the game is worth having around, they're going to make more copies of it because companies like to make money because that's how capitalism works.

Try and hold off on something until it's proven, until you know that you love it and like it, and then go for the deluxe-ified version of it. FOMO makes me really, really sad, and it's something which I find I have to catch myself not trying to fall into all of the time when I'm looking on to buy a board game or whatever, and I see there's only one left, and then it's like, am I buying the game because I want the game, or am I buying it because there's only one left and I'm scared that I'm never going to get to try and play it. One of the next things I used to do when I was really bad for it was I'd just listen to every single YouTube reviewer of a review I would watch. Whatever they said, I would just believe them. So, I would see a game that I had like no interest in, but they were like, this game's amazing, you need to own this game. So, I would go out and buy it, and then I'd be like, well, this game's crap, I don't like it. Even though I knew when I was watching the review, the game wasn't for me, I still sat there and bought it anyway because this person said that it was good. So, one of the things that I would really suggest that you do is if you're interested in a game and it's getting good reviews, watch some playthroughs of it or a how to play so you can get an idea of actually how the game works and if it's going to be something for you.

Don't listen to somebody because they like the game. There's nothing wrong with them liking the game. It's just because that person likes the game, it doesn't mean that you're going to like the game. At the end of the day, it doesn't matter what somebody on YouTube is telling you. If you like the game and they don't like the game, or they like the game and you don't like the game.

What?

There's plenty of games that I love that reviewers have bombed and have got bad scores on BoardGameGeek. And there's plenty of games that people love. Ark Nova, like I just don't get that game at all. I don't know why people love it. I think it's okay. It's fine at best, but I'm not going to poopoo on other people for liking that game. It's just not for me. I spent ages getting it. I spent over the MSRP, and then I I was just like, "Oh, uh." It's fine. Sold it. Played it like four times, didn't like it, moved on. And yeah, it's just a another another tip. Pretty good one. You should listen to me. I'm smart. I'm not. I'm dumb. Don't listen to me. I'm an idiot. I really am. Okay. So, for my last bit of unsolicited advice that I can give you is just take your time. Whether you're new or old to the hobby, just sit on the thing that you think that you want before you go out and purchase it. The one of my biggest issues is impulsiveness, and I'm I'm quick just to want something and I'll just go and buy it and not even think about it. But, if you learn to like sit on it for like 10 minutes, a lot of the time you'll stop yourself from doing that impulsive purchase that you don't need to do. And just just take a second, have a good time, smell the roses, and just look at the collection that you already have if you're not new to the hobby. And if you are new to the hobby, it's really exciting, and I know it's hard not to fall into the trap of finding all of these cool mechanisms and all of the new language that you get to learn. It's so fun when you find a new

hobby and you get into it and you just become obsessed. It's one of the best feelings and I know a lot of people are know what I'm talking about here when you find something and you get really into it and you just spend hours doing all of the research. It's It's all part of the fun and it's something which I would never want to take away from anybody. So, definitely do that side of it. But, hey, actually, as long as if you've got the funds and you're not spending all the budget and you're not putting yourself in debt, just do what the hell that you want and have a good time. Anyhow, with that, I just got into Magic the Gathering last week and I've been playing a lot of Commander and I've got 45 decks to build. So, I'm going to go and do that to add to my collection that I've just spent lots of money on in a short amount of time. So, with that, take what you will and I will see you on the next one. Please remember to like and subscribe and yeah, thanks for watching the episode. Bye.

Progress saved