Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top 10 Mystery-Solving Board Games

Transcript 16:22

everyone likes solving puzzles after all who doesn't want all the smartypants glory of putting together the final pieces of a murder being a private eye but without the alcohol dependency or a visit from the goon squad but also with the alcohol dependency over the pandemic puzzle games escape room style games and or mystery games have been some of the very best kind of games to play not only because we've all been trapped inside the escape rooms of our own homes whoops i've made myself sad again thank goodness for that alcohol dependency but also all the games on this list can be played in couples or even all by yourself so let's look back at the best of the best in fact we love puzzle solving games nrb so much that our very own john gracie co-runs a company that makes its own little escape rooms in a box they're called mini mysteries cool puzzles with cool artwork that can be shipped all over the world and while john being on the channel means it's not really kosher to feature them on the list itself check the link we put in the description to find out more about mini mysteries they're really great john is great it's all great i'm adam from no rolls bard and here are our top 10 mystery solving board games and while you're here you too can solve the mystery of how to subscribe you've put the clues together and it turns out you just need to click that button you've cracked the case also review copies for some of these games have been provided by publishers number 10 escape room the board game as your uncle derek who's just bought that new car proves you're never too old to play with toys and i'll be gosh darned if escape room the board game doesn't come with one of the niftiest toys in all of gaming this little beauty

is the chrono decoder and you'll use it as a countdown you'll input solutions to puzzles in the form of these keys which are slot into the top of it it comes with helpful code cracking cheat sheets on the side and it'll even play atmospheric sounds as you're sifting through the game materials to find the right combo of keys although intense moments those atmospheric sounds can tempt you to drop kick the thing off your balcony each scenario comes in three parts each part comes with maps cards bits of paper little hint cards that you need a special lens to look at all to lead you to a four key combination maybe the right sequence of keys is to do with the shapes at the top the numbers printed on them maybe the letters it's all very swish and solving a puzzle and typing into your phone is one thing but slotting keys into a thing that looks like a bomb and hearing it congratulate you with a victory flourish that is next level batteries for the great big toy not included number nine detective season one so as you'll work out like the hard-nosed little gum shoes that you are most of the games on this list are basically a collection of puzzles plus a gimmick that ties it all together and this list exists so you can basically figure out which gimmick you like the best detective season one and its predecessor also called detectives so technically season one is the second detective game thanks guys very helpful both games have a killer gimmick you're tasked with solving a case using a very strict amount of resources changing locations cost you time following a lead costs you time diving deeper into certain leads cost you the skill token so far a stressful little action

economy fellow but what ties it all together is the antaris database on your laptop or tablet you can log into the game's official website and it takes you to this glorious early 2000s movie approximation of what databases look like complete with scrolling matrix text why not bypass the main subroutine crack the trojan boom i'm in using this database you can access profiles of suspects transcripts of police interviews you can even watch videos of cctv footage or pre-recorded skype interviews it's a knockout presentation that makes a fairly standard murder solver into something properly atmospheric and properly engaging number eight time stories and speaking of mystery franchises time stories is a monster you need to buy a base game which gives you the board you need to play and then a series of standalone modules each adding to a story so convoluted and expansive that the continuity has already kind of rebooted itself after five years like marvel and dc comics you are time agents sent to various times and places a doctor who style to fix paradoxes solve puzzles and even fight monsters each module is presented as a deck of cards most of which are used to build these beautiful tableaus of a location with each card representing a different part of that place like a locked cupboard to be opened a suspicious character to be questioned or a very important plunger as a team players split up to investigate different areas collecting tokens to gain access to other cards rolling dice solving riddles and essentially choosing your own adventure the only catch is that most things you do will cost you time units

run out a time unit and your run ends which means you need to zip back in time start from the beginning and take a different approach like the movie source code or a much more threatening groundhog day most modules add an extra mechanism or twist to the game formula that keeps each box fresh and while restarting a run can be frustrating the time investment the dangers the group of comrades dynamic it makes a time story's victory punch the air satisfying number seven chronicles of crime 1900. we've covered chronicles of crime a lot on no rolls bar in our list of great co-ops we've given the base game as well as its spin-off chronicles of crime 1400 its own review and now we're returning to the series again looking at the second part of the chronicles millennium trilogy set in 1900 why well because annoyingly 1900 is the best single chronicles of crime box released so far so our hands are tied it is very good for the uninitiated chronicles is a mystery game fueled by an app and qr code go to a crime scene use your tablet to look around in 360 degrees which is very cool scan clues that you find to add them to your crime board scan locations to travel to them scan suspects to talk to them suspects which do unhelpfully all look the same for some reason grilling them about the clues you found it's all very fun but what makes 1900 so much better are these puzzle cards that you can discover which are mini escape room style puzzles dotted throughout the game codes to crack riddles puzzles using cards laid on top of each other they're so great genuinely elevating this chronicles game

from wandering around paris smashing clues against very similar looking suspects until the case breaks into something a lot more substantial number six detective city of angels oh man this game is a lavish son of a we've talked about it before in our 10 best solo games list but while it's a quiet intense little choose your own adventure game played solo it is a riot when played with friends it's also a fascinating little puzzle see unlike every other game on this list there's a mystery to be solved but one player which the game calls the chisel but is basically an evil dm is working to make sure that no one cracks the case for real the chisel is going to be role-playing as all the suspects in the case all the other players racing around the map playing la noir era flatfoots on the beat of a dirty town with a dirty bottom and you're at the bottom of a bottle and from the dregs damned if everything don't look like the stars that didn't mean anything but gosh this game is cool though like elenoir the chisel can make the suspects lie to the players when questioned which forces the players to either accept what they're being told and maybe not get all the information or gamble challenging the suspect to spill the beans before you start seeing more stars than growlman's chinese theater and if they were lying you'll get a token you can cash in to cut through the lies later but if they weren't if they were telling you the truth that'll hamper you later in the game and give the chisel a token they can use to block your questioning all as time runs out before you need to present your findings to the chief it is

beautifully written beautifully produced and a whole lot of fun to play detectives with your pals number five escape tales most games with escape in the title require you to solve some puzzles in a box within a short amount of time mostly an hour with a teeny amount of story on top the escape tales trilogy of games say screw that presenting you with a series of sprawling adventures that require most of a day if you want to finish them in a single sitting and what i love capital letters love about these games is how ambitious they are with their narrative elements at their core they're escape room games a series of locations with puzzles in them you move around locations by playing finite movement tokens which makes you choose your spots carefully you collect cards put the clues together input codes into your device move on but it's more than that each game comes with storybooks depending on the answers you find in the places you go you'll turn to a section of the book and read the next chapter with your characters constantly being presented with choices that branch the story out in different directions taking you to different locations and resulting in dozens of different endings the awakening the first game is about a father moving through a nightmare dreamscape of his own past to rescue his daughter from a comet proper lynchian low memory sees you control three different characters in three different games presented in a garish techno future and children of wormwoods the best one by the way boasts over 60 different endings to a tale of a man unfortunately called gilbert heading into the wild and eerie woods the puzzles are great

if you're looking for an escape room game that'll last well beyond the usual hour something with a beating and often bloody heart escape tales are some of the best in the business number four sherlock holmes consulting detective baker street irregulars oh yes the most famous storytelling detective of all time an infamous ripoff of basil the great mouse detective sherlock holmes we've covered the consulting detective games in a past video but the baker street irregulars box is the newest and it's also the best in the series each consulting detective's game comes with 10 cases each case is a booklet the introduction of each case in that booklet gives you starting leads some suspects a crime scene places that the victim has visited you know crime stuff love a bit of crime stuff the secret ingredient is crime the game also comes with a map of the best and also worst city in the world london a phone directory and a newspaper say the victim was found at a theatre find the name of the theatre in the directory that gives you a code go to that code in the booklet read what you find and that'll lead you to more clues it's that simple but what's so wonderful about these games is the way the scope of each case slowly expands until you're finding references to random side characters in the newspapers you're able to trace the victims movements on the map itself and use that to find new codes cases start to connect together with no time limit no devices with countdowns just paper and pen you can sit back and enjoy an old-fashioned style puzzle game with a modern coat of paint the bakery box is a beautiful production with gorgeous art 10 cases written by dave neal an actual professional

sherlock holmes writer and a new system of collecting clues that force you to go to locations in a certain order so you don't accidentally give yourself confusing information by just picking places at random it is the best game in a series of great games number three exit games i love the exit game so much little boxes of fiendishly cryptic joy exit games are hard they are tougher than a two dollar stake as a cherish wrestling commentator would say what sets them apart from their competitors is how they create uniquely physical puzzles lots of games have you looking at cars and entering numbers on a device exit games have you destroying the box slicing up the instruction manuals folding bits on top of each other peering at cards from odd angles there's proper genius at play here in all the different ways they can turn standard game materials into puzzle pieces including a new line of games they've just launched which contain actual jigsaw puzzles you assemble these puzzles which gives you clues to find codes which you enter on this series of interlocking wheels and just like exit games push the boundaries of what you can do with bits of paper these games manage that but for puzzle pieces i don't want to spoil anything but you'll be ripping bits off puzzles attacking puzzles with pencils the shapes of individual puzzle pieces can contain clues to crack the case exit games may be disposable one play and you're done games which you can't resell because they'll literally end up in bits but hot damn did the designers keep managing to surprise us number two the initiative talk about a fun surprise the initiative is a treasure trove of weird little secrets

it really sounds like it shouldn't work but it does it does it does it's a co-op move around the map action economy style game like pandemic where you're collecting these little case file tokens each game you're tasked with solving a specific puzzle maybe what's the secret phrase what's the combination to a safe where did mr x go and the answers hidden on this card held in this little plastic shield however find a token that matches a symbol on the card and you can reveal it via a little window and start to piece together the phrase you play cards and move around the board costing you more and more time you don't have see if you run out of cards you shuffle the discards and keep playing but from then on the game could end at any moment by drawing these little time symbols at the end of your ghost so do you push your luck and keep exploring to try and find more matching symbols as attention mounts or do you make a hail mary play and try and solve the puzzle and instantly win or lose the game right there is a cool concept for a game but the initiative has so much more under the hood including a full campaign of games linked together by this lovely little comic you read throughout a bunch of secrets to give you bonus escape room style puzzles to solve between games codes to crack an actual introduction to various forms of encryption and even legacy game style secrets hidden in the box and no spoilers but some of these hidden secrets made me full on yell with joy when we found them there are 14 games in the campaign but the box comes with loads of standalone missions

after you've done so oh boy do you get your money's worth with this one and number one micro macro crime city this game is so weird and different and it's been nominated for this year's spilled ajaras which is the best picture oscar for games because micro macro crime city is so weird and different the game is set in crime city presented on this colossal map which feels more like a ship sail than a game board gonna need a bigger table in this city are thousands and thousands of little cartoon characters going about their lives but more often going about their deaths in most of the game 16 cases first you need to find the person who died so you study the map with this little magnifying glass find the cutesy little corpse then the game says right retrace that poor soul steps let's find out how they died and why prompting you to look on the map trying to find traces of the character while they were still alive traveling back through time as you find tiny fragments of their day littered around this huge overwhelming wall of tordry data it's where's wally or where's waldo for our american friends except wally fell on hard times moved to gotham and got shipped in a alleyway seriously these cutesy characters are poisoning drowning and shooting each other it's a dark little game but the process of it of gathering together with a partner or even just by yourself literally using a magnifying glass to pour over the map find clues that take you to completely different parts of the city slowly building this morbid disney presents true detective

timeline it's mind-bendingly wonderful stuff god mystery games are the best it was i who sabotaged your friend's time machine and it is i will foil the ministry of time once again

and that's our list what's your favorite puzzle solving board game let us know in the comments don't forget to like and share this video around if you enjoyed and make sure make sure you subscribe to no rolls bard for more silly board game content get on board

Progress saved