Top Ten Spiel des Jahres Runners Up (Board Games)
Transcript
Hi, I'm Adam Wales. Um, and this video is the third in a series of videos looking at the history of the Spieles Yares Award. Um, the Spielares Award is the most prestigious award in board gaming in the world. It's it's based in Germany. It's given out every year. The the the 2016 award winner will be announced uh in July. And it's between Emoteep over here, which is my favorite of the three, but I also like very much the other two games, Code Names, and um Karuba. Uh both both also excellent games. Now, when the Spielers Yares award is announced, clearly there's a couple of games that were nominated but don't win. The runners up and that's what we're looking at today. Games that were nominated for the Spielers Yares award, but didn't win it. Okay, so let's make a start.
Way back in 2002, Stefan Dora designed a game called Bucket King, which is similar to a trick- takingaking game. Um, but players will have a a sort of two-dimensional pyramid of of of uh of of little sort of buckets, and they're laid out, they're essentially tiles laid out on the table. The the newer version which came out uh a year or two ago is Bucket King 3D which uses plastic cups that stack on top of each other to give it a real three-dimensional view. And also this crazy Japanese art style from Jolly Thinkers which ties it into the pick a pig, pick a dog, pick a polar bear, pick a seal line of games. I really like that art style and I really like those little party games I just mentioned, the pick a pig series. Um so Bucket King was an easy sort of buy for me. It was an obvious one to pick up and yet it's not very wellnown. Now, this is not a great game, but it is a funny one.
It's a lot of fun. When I say tricktaking, this is not sort of that sort of uh dry trick taking player card, little bit of strategy in there. This is much sillier than that. Uh it's much more attacky than that. The the the flow of play keeps going back and forth between players as it changes direction going around the table. And when you attack a player, you get to actually knock a plastic pyram plastic cup out of their pyramid. So, it's got that great tactile thing. Lot players are going to come and say, "What what are you playing?" Because no one's going to have seen anything that looks quite like this game. Um, so Bucket King 3D and Oddity never should have won the Spielfield, and it didn't. But definitely a game that I can recommend. I can get behind. It's It's a lot of fun.
If I said Freedom and Priest to you and you're a board gamer, you're going to know who I mean. It's the guy with the green hair. It's the guy who made Power Grid and a whole series of games that begin with F. Now, Power Grid, we mentioned in the previous list, it was recommended for the Spielers, not nominated. So, it's not it's not Power Grid that we're talking about today. It's one of Freedman F's lesserk known games. What we're talking about is Fisher Flippen Fadelan. I said he likes Fs. His name being Freedom and Free and he likes the color green. Now Fisher Flippenfadelan was nominated in 2003. Freedom and Free outside of Power Grid. What he's known for is innovation. He comes up with weird little mechanisms and things that don't always necessarily quite work, but they're always interesting. They're always worth a look. He's he's an experimentter. He likes to try out different things and I have a lot of respect for him for that.
Fisher flip and fricadelan is perhaps his most audacious project of all because in order to play Fisher flip and fricadelan, you don't really just need this. You also need this. And ideally, you need this as well. Yeah. If you have three copies of the game, then you see it at its Sorry, I got to put them down. then you see it at its absolute best because this is essentially a pick up and deliver game. You you you gather goods, you take them to other locations, but you can play it on three different tables with five people playing on each table. So 15 players perhaps in different rooms and when you reach a certain point in the game, you can swap tables and continue playing. So the goods on one table might be worth a certain amount, but when you move to the other room, they might be worth even more or they might be worth less. There's so there's all this stuff about moving in between rooms and all that sort of stuff. It's not a great game and it's uh it's it's not something you're going to want to play all the time, but is it interesting? Is it innovative? Absolutely. It's it's an event when you can get a game of Fisher Flip and Frickellan going.
Unfortunately, it's not something that I can get going very often because it's not often that I have 15 players, all who want to play the same game, all who are happy to play something quite so odd. Um and and so um it's a bit of a hard sell. I'm not surprised at all it didn't win the Spielers Yares, but worthy of a nomination just because it's so
interesting. Number eight on my list, I don't actually have a copy of this game, but this is Splendor. And the reason I don't have a copy is because it's everywhere. Everyone's playing Splendor the last couple of years. It received a recommendation in 20ou, sorry, a nomination in 2014. and it became a bit of a staple as a gateway game, which surprises me a little bit because the artwork is so boring. Um, it I mean it's a lovely game, don't get me wrong. It's simple. It's accessible. It's it's strategic but simple strategy. Anybody can dive in and pick up and play with this game. Ideal for the Spiel. I'm surprised that it didn't win. But the artwork is this sort of generic. I don't know. Is it medieval? is it it's it's it's good artwork, but it's very very dry. And yet the other components are lovely. Um I can't see any reason why this game didn't get a a lavish production with, you know, Xavier Klette or Pierro or or even Clemens France or one of these one of the the artists that that makes these iconic looking board games um in the modern sort of era and yet it's it's got this dry sort of look to it. Um, I shouldn't go on about that too much because the game itself is fantastic. It's a game of uh gathering these tiles. You have to um you have to use gems and on your turn all you're doing is either taking gems or buying tiles. And yet there's so much more strategy than that because when you're taking the gems, you're depriving other players of them. When you're taking the
tiles, it may be just the tile that someone else was working towards. It's a it's a fairly short game. It scales well between different player counts. I mean, lovely, lovely game. Worthy winner of the Spielers. It didn't win. I don't know why not. Number seven on my list of Spielers nominees is bingo. It's not actually bingo. It's Rise of Augustus. It's Julius Caesar bingo essentially is what's going on here. We're in the Roman times. Uh we're we're g gathering senators. We're gathering chariots. We're we're you know we're shouting a Caesar. It's it's essentially bingo. We're drawing things out of a bag. We're gathering these things to try and build sets and then we're claiming tiles that give us special abilities and allow us to move stuff around. When I say it's bingo, I don't mean to do it a disservice because it's actually quite fun. you know, bingo in itself. Yeah, it's random, but if you can get a little bit of strategy in there, if you can add in a few decisions, it becomes quite a fun mechanism. And Rise of Augustus demonstrates that. The fact that it is bingo is the one thing that makes it so accessible. Um, the game's by Paulo Mory. Paulo my also did Libertalia, which was on the recommendations list. A fantastic game. um added with the be that that designer added with the beautiful artwork of Vincent D trait um really makes for a a pretty stunning
sort of game. Machioro I said previously with Splendor that this was a game that you see everywhere. A game that probably should have won. It was a bit of a surprise when it didn't win. Machioro I feel the same way. 2015. This one got a nomination and yet it was beaten by Cult Express. Um, that's an odd choice. I think Machiora was the obvious winner there to me. Um, this is a accessible, simple game. It's got a beautiful look to it. People can really buy into that idea of building a city. I've got the deluxe edition here in this nice tin. Um, but there's other versions that that are available. I can't see any reason not to buy this. This has both expansions in it and it's at a cheaper price point than buying it in the individual editions. Um, lovely game, Machioro. Surprised that this one didn't win. Number five. And now we're on to games that I love all the way through.
Now, these are games that I absolutely love. First one here is Concept. Now, Concept is a party game. It's um a little bit like something like Sherads or Pictionary but with this fantastic twist. Um it in in using these little icons and the iconography is is is so beautifully done. It's such a nice graphic design. Uh the idea really draws people in. You can play it as a big party game. You can do it as a simple um exercise. I think a lot of people abandon the rules altogether and just try try it out. Try doing it as a bit of an exercise. But I I when I play, I must admit, I don't use the rules as written in the box. I tend to use rules that are that are from a variant that somebody posted on board gamegeeek. Um, which works very well for me and I think it works well as a structured game with scoring, although I can see the appeal of just trying it out as an exercise too. Um, concept would have been a worthy winner. Um, but it missed out in 2014, losing out to Camelup. Also a good game.
If any game on this list is one that has been completely sort of overlooked and forgotten about now, but really really deserves to be heralded alongside a lot of the the greatest games that have been made over the last 15 years or so. Um that game is Arcadia by Rudiger Dawn. Rudiger Dawn being um one of the the the best game designers in the industry um currently. Now, Debbalmeister von Arcadia harks back to that old sort of style of it reminds me of Wolf Gang Kramer and Michael Keyasling games. Um we're placing out pieces on the board. We've got a subtle element of speculation and stockholding. Um it was it was nominated in 2007. I don't think it would be nominated these days. This is more of a Kennespiel level. So, we're looking at something a little bit more complex than the standard Spielers Yares Award. Um, this production, even the the box size and the coloring and the imagery on it, um, from Ravensburgger suggests an earlier outdated sort of design, but the game itself, nothing outdated about it at all. It's it's it's lovely. It's a fantastic game. It looks amazing when you play it, lay it out on the on the table and and you actually start to play it. Um, I think it it's worthy of awards. Spielers Yarz perhaps a little bit too complex. Although back in 2007 when it was nominated, I think it it would have been a great title to
win. Number three on the list has had quite a lot of fanfare. It's Las Vegas. This is Las Vegas Boulevard, which is the expansion box, and that's what I keep the game in. The expansion, I must say, is one of the best expansions that I've seen for any game. It adds so many options. Um, and yet everything is so simple and integrates so well with the basic game. Now, I say it's had a lot of fanfare and yet this is a very sort of, you know, unassuming sort of game. It doesn't look fancy. It looks like you're just rolling a bunch of dice, you know, standard dice, just loads of them, but there's nothing very fancy looking about it. And yet, the game play is really, really good. This is Rudiger Dawn as well along with Arcadia. Um, and perhaps I think this this this may be his best game. Um, it's it's just one of those games where it's everything just works so well, so simply and and you just think, why didn't I think of that? It's it's that sort of a game. Just such an obvious, brilliant game design. Um, so I I can't recommend Las Vegas highly enough. Wonderful game, wonderful expansion. Um, and I would just buy both straight away. It gives you more players. It gives you more options. It gives you more dice. It's not expensive.
And I promise you, you'll get a lot of fun out of this game. 2009 and Freedom and Free is back on the list. Uh, nominated once again for the Spielers Yarz. This time with his game Fauna. Now, I keep Fauna in the same box as terror, so I can't show you the Fauna box. Um, but it's essentially the same game as terror, except that Fauna focuses specifically on animals, whereas Terror focuses more on general knowledge and particularly geography. Now, what these games are is general knowledge games, but they're general knowledge games where you don't have to know everything, where you can kind of leech off the knowledge of other players, where you can sort of gamble a little bit and try and get a bit close and follow what other players are doing and you don't have to give away the fact that actually you don't know very much.
There's a slight strategic sort of euro sort of element to it. Um, almost a party game, but not quite. Um, it essentially I would think of it in terms of if people want to play Trivial Pursuit, don't bother. Play Fauna, play Terror instead. They're quicker, they're more accessible because you don't have to know everything. But if you do know everything, it gives you a real advantage. Um, lovely production. I I think I think Terror and and Fauna are both masterpieces. I think they're stunning, stunning games. Um, again, I can't rave enough about these two games. Um either one of them would have been a worthy winner for the Spielers Yarz. Um I believe there's another example coming out or or has recently come out which is about US um sort of general knowledge.
Uh perhaps that one's not for me because I'm not going to know much about it, but for people in the US, another I'm sure another great entry into the into the genre of general knowledge games. Um Freriedman Freeze is not a one-trick pony. That is one thing he is not. He he creates diverse games with diverse um mechanisms. Um everything's always different. Um and this is one of his big successes. Fantastic game for uh 2009 and later Terror. Uh excellent games by Friedman
Freeze. And number one on my list comes from 2004 and that was St. Petersburg, which was nominated for the Spielers Yaris Award. This is a classic Euro style game. It has the pacing of a deck builder. Essentially, we're buying cards, we're placing them in front of us, and then they're going to activate over and over again. At first, generating us money, which we're going to use to buy better cards that will generate us more money. And then at some point, and it's up to us when, we're going to switch to buying cards that are going to generate us victory points instead of money. So, very similar pacing to something like Dominion, but this game predates those deck builders. And it's really it's a tableau building game. The cards are laid out in the table in front of you. It's very much a card game, although it has a central board in which you place the cards.
That's not really necessary. Um, it's it's just wonderful. It's a simple uh design. It's it's not quite simple enough to win the Spielers Yarez these days. Uh, I keep saying that. What I mean is in 2011 the Spielers was split into a main award that was for family style games and a second award that was the Kennespiel which is for complex games, gamers games, the connoisseurs choice it's so called. Um I think this game would be in that category now and I think it would be a worthy winner of the Kennespiel but currently the way that the Spirit Zarus is now it's a little bit heavier. It's not something you're necessarily going to pick up and play with your family. This is the newer edition that came out fairly recently. I was really looking forward to this and I got rid of my old copy of the original edition. Um, waiting for this one to come out. This one has some expansions mixed in, a lot of different variants and this new sort of art style. I found myself missing the old version. The old version had such a unique sort of look about it. Um, and I found I didn't want to play the variants and the expansions because the game is so good as it is.
So, I went out and I sort out the original copy and its original expansion at great expense, I might add, because this old copy has now become quite valuable because people want it. Some people hated this art style. It really was divisive. People either loved it or hated it. Personally, I think it gives the game a lot of character and it it it it's a game that it doesn't leap out at you because it's kind of themeless. Um, and so I think it needs that unique look just to make it sort of stand out as something a bit different to other games. Um, so I think the new version looking fairly generic is probably not helping it very much. Um, but I hope this game sticks around forever. It's a fantastic Euro game. It belongs alongside all the classics of the genre. It it it it's definitely a worthy award winner. And so that brings me to the end of my top 10 games that were runners up in the Spielers Yarz competition. um games that didn't win, but were they good enough to win? I'd say the top half of this list are some of the best games I have in my collection. The bottom half of the list, oddities, you know, nice games, definitely worth trying. I would recommend every one of them, but the top half, oh, those are stellar games. Um, so thank you very much for watching. I'm Adam in Wales. If you want to uh watch more of my videos, please subscribe to my YouTube channel. If you want to follow me on Twitter, I'm Boardame Wales. And on Board Gamegegeek, I'm Adam 78. So, thanks very much for watching.
All the best.