Skip to main content
Loading video...

Games That Left Our Collections | July-December 2025

Transcript 51:32

Hey, I'm Ryan. This is my brother Daniel. And this is Rolls in the Family. And today we are going to be talking about the games that have left our collection. You're not going to see it on that shelf.

Never again behind Daniel. That's right.

These are games that are

outgoing in the last 6 months. So, it's like July to December of last year. Uh this is a pretty normal cycle of things in our our uh gaming collection. New games come in, games go out. Sometimes it's new games that just didn't land and so they they have a pretty short stay in the collection and and end up going out. Sometimes it's longtime even favorites of the collection that for one reason or another uh

I was wondering Ryan, this is coming right off at Christmas. Do we have any uh immediate exits from Christmas for you in this video?

I don't think any I think I already know some that might.

Oh, but none that

they're likely to be in the next video. They'll likely be in the January future content as well.

I I didn't call them in the 6 day window after Christmas.

Wow.

Uh we will include links to all these games in the description below. Just because they weren't games that we kept around doesn't mean they wouldn't be the right game for you. And some of them looking here are ones I think we still would say we recommend. Um, and we'll maybe get more into the nuances of that as we discuss them. Uh, if you want to drop in the comments below games that have maybe left your collection recently and why did they leave your collection?

What are what are the games people hate these days? That's what,

you know, it's a good healthy thing to be doing, I think, especially if you're someone who tries a lot of new games and has limited gaming time. I mean, something's got to give eventually. You can't can't keep everything and expect everything to get played,

right? Uh, so we are going to be providing our ratings for these games. We're going to be going from lowest rating to highest rating. No, no complete duds in this set. We've we've had some much lower ratings in other other videos.

Um, but we'll work our way up to the highest rated. And that is going to start here with me

with the game. This is a party game. We try a lot of party games, Daniel. It's especially around Christmas.

Um, you know, and it's

it's with party games. It feels like let's do lots of shots on gold. They're easy to get to the table. It's easy to try it and get a feel for like, okay, this landed, this didn't.

It does feel like every Christmas is like Ryan just getting an influx of party games. And

well, and the other thing is if I put party games on my list,

the people that buy gifts for me are way more likely to pick the party.

We're not buying you this $120 game that none of us are going to play. Let's buy the party game.

Yeah. That we can all all enjoy together. Uh this one is one that we tried with our family. You got to try this one. It was a while back that we we tried it. Um yeah, and this one I I had pretty actually high hopes about it. It had gotten a lot of buzz. This is Itto. Um I'm gonna give Iido a 6 out of 10. And the idea here was very similar to a game I have wavelength where and actually there's quite a few party games that do this now of like have a spectrum and you're trying to get someone to guess like it's a spectrum between hot and cold and in wavelength it might be like okay I need to come up with a clue that's a little more to the hot side than the cold side or whatever. Edo kind of takes that and says, "Well, what if it's a cooperative game and we're basically giving clues with the category for your specific number that only you know, and then the team were trying to put those numbers in order in like a number line, but only using the clues to be able to put them in order."

And so that sounded really nice. We've had huge success with cooperative party games like this, like just one and so Clover. Um, and it was like, "Okay, maybe this could be another one." I actually went into this thinking, man, there's a good chance Wavelength gets cold because of this entering the collection. But Wavelength won this battle actually as my preferred preferred game.

Um, and I think when we played this, and we played it a few times with our family.

Yeah.

There was just some weirdness that kept it from like just working the way

I wanted it to work. Um, and it really boiled down to this whole thing that we're all working cooperatively. I know my number and the clue I did of my number. Like, what am I allowed to say as we are talking about where to put these things? Cuz what would happen is like you do a clue and everybody would be like, "Oh, I think that's down here under this." And you're going, "Oh, no, it's not. I meant for that clue to mean like much higher."

Right? And so then you're like, well, I mean, maybe this way a little bit. And you know, it really was meant more like a 65 level of, you know, it just it fell into this weird like how and then there was also this rule that you could change your what you said,

which I see why they did it cuz you you could easily have it that the clue you gave like it quickly becomes evident that it's throwing the group way off.

That's on you. But yeah, I mean it almost feels like it would work better if you couldn't change it because once you can change it now it's in this really wishy-washy of how can you keep changing it to like slowly nudge people to be talking about it the way that you

cuz you're comparing it to other things that you don't know. So you don't know that the other card is a 30 or whatever,

but you can hear how people are talking about it. Like you can hear they're treating this as though it's a higher than 50. And I don't know, it kind of just ended up falling a little flat with our family. Um, and I kind of was trying to think of, you know, how could I maybe introduce or teach it differently or tweak a house rule or something to kind of make it work. And I wasn't really seeing a good way to solve the issue, at least that our group had. It seems like a lot of groups don't have this issue with this game. And I'd actually be like curious to be a fly on the wall that this really works to see kind of like what they aren't falling into.

But in the end it uh you know the other part of getting lots of party games is it ends up being kind of a competitive niche. Like only the ones I really like do I end up keeping and this one just didn't didn't quite land. So

well I do wonder that. I mean maybe we play more party games than maybe the average person. I don't know. That's a complete guess. But I think we have a high standard of what a party game delivers.

I can guarantee that Tom Bassel and some of the Dice Tower crew have played more party games than us.

I said average Ryan.

Yeah. Yeah. No, but I'm saying they love this game. Like

like across the board like all of them like really really rate this highly as like a top top party game. Um

but yeah, for us didn't didn't quite work.

We'll have to we'll have to revisit our top party games of all time list sometime. That that's a good evergreen uh video. Um

so you can hear some of the ones that are some of our favorites. But

uh onward to another game

that left my collection.

Quick.

We'll see if Daniel gets to talk this video.

Daniel's got some on here. You can always count on Daniel to call the highest rated game on the list.

I think I have consistently

Daniel's signature move right there.

Um yeah. So this second one is one that when I saw reviews for this, it did not catch my attention. It was like it looked fine, but over time I kept hearing about it and kept hearing about it and kept people were writing it so highly and talking about it as I mean it just really felt like it was getting this momentum into being this modern classic in the maybe modern classic is a strong word, but a a strong strong new entry in the filler

card game uh niche that finally I ended up putting this on my list. Um, I think I got it as a gift strictly on that. Like, it wasn't so much that I looked at it and was like, "This is a game that I really think I'll like as much as like I feel like I have to try this."

That's 100% how I get board games.

And maybe it's one that I just need to u, you know, experience to kind of see the magic that's there.

So, this is Sea, Salt, and Paper. Um, and I am giving Sea Salt and Paper a 6 out of 10.

Uh, now in its defense, I only played it once. Oh,

but I will say these days

in our limited gaming time, I am much less willing to give games many, many tries.

Your play was with me.

If I Yeah, my play was with you. And I'm interested kind of what your feelings were on it. I can't even.

Um Yeah. Yeah. And it actually is going to be taking my little memory exactly how this works, but it basically like has this card game that you're getting cards and it's got kind of this set collection thing and then you discard I think there were two discard piles and you could like take from one of the discard piles. Um, and you're trying to assemble a hand that scores well and there's kind of different cards that score in different ways. Um, but there's this interesting dynamic that you can call the end of the round and say like, you know, I think my hand is the best hand.

Um, and you can either call it immediately or you can like basically raise the stakes and say, I think I not only have the best hand, but I think even if you all get another turn, I'm still going to have the best hand. Which I think is an interesting uh mechanism. Um, it had some stuff with like kind of some set collection. It had the mermaids that were like kind of a shoot the moon thing where if you got all the mermaids, you could like win the whole game.

Um, and so there's some some interesting ideas here. When we played this, it kind of felt I mean I guess it fell flat would be like the short answer, but it felt like we were trying to see where the magic moments were in this.

Yeah. Yeah,

but we were kind of playing it out and it kind of was just going, you know, I I remember there was a time I called the end of the round and everybody else was just kind of like,

oh,

oh. And then like tried to get, you know, it just like I don't know. And maybe if you played it a lot and everybody knew it, those moments become a little more exciting. Maybe we just got some hands that like really

leaned in favor of somebody. Mhm.

But I guess I I didn't see anything in it. And I even afterwards like really thought about this game and kind of like cuz with a game that's this simple like it's it's another thing to have a really complex big game and be like I need to give that one another try. This I can almost trial it in my head like I can like picture the interactions that'll be happening here and I just wasn't seeing something that was going to like make it me feel super different about it on a second or a third play. And so then it puts it in this weird purgatory where it's like, well, am I going to try to get it to the table,

knowing like instead of other games, knowing that it's a game that I am leaning towards getting rid of, I'm kind of just like seeing

and it's like, man, I just don't get to play that many games these days. I would rather play a game I know I love in that in that niche.

Um,

so interested to hear if any of our viewers are are big fans of this game. But for me, 6 out of 10. It was a good fine card game.

That's what I I mean the limited uh memory I have of it is it was like oh yeah that's that's fine. But I feel like those that space the game's got to have some kind of, you know, thing that jumps out that's like, ooh, that's I like in this quick game, that's a really just interesting thing. And and this thing does this game does have that, but I think I don't know if our play was just off or

Yeah. I will say a a game I have in this niche that I also have a very hard time getting to the table, but I hold on to because I love how comp interesting and compelling I find it is Biblios, which has been a long time probably since, but I would say that's in a similar that's in a similar lane as this as far as kind of a car collection. I find Biblios a lot more compelling than this game.

I really like Biblios. So, if you're looking for an alternative or like you know what I maybe would recommend in a similar space, that's one that I I do really enjoy.

Very nice, Ryan. Well, it's my turn to jump in. Uh, this is a game that I have owned for a long time. Uh, I've had this one uh, you know, this was back kind of shortly after my wife and I actually met. So, we're, you know, talking, you know, close to a decade ago that you kind of introduced me to this as a a fun just kind of simple head-to-head, although I think you can play um,

there are ways to play with more than two players, but we always just played with two players.

Um, head-to-head game. Uh, and this goes to Star Realms, which I'm going to be giving a 6.5 out of 10, which is actually maybe lower than I would have thought. And and part of that's like I held on to this game for a long time. And my wife and I honestly we played it quite a bit. Um, I think we what we liked about it was one, it's just it's a quick like it was really quick to just kind of shuffle a little setup, boom, start going and you're getting into just this quick little deck building uh deck building game. Um, as I played this game more, I don't know. I just felt like I wasn't making that many interesting decisions,

you know, like on your turn, you play your entire hand. So, you kind of just like draw your hand, you play it, and then you decide what you want to buy.

Um, there were certain routes like color. There's like the four different colors. There were some that like again I'm not the expert at this game but felt just better than other routes.

Yeah. I remember I only played this once with you I think but I remember feeling like once you committed to a color

you just buy every incentivized

well because colors have the bonuses that if you've already played one of that color then with the every future one you play you get also the bonus of it. So you are very incentivized to buy the same color.

Yeah, it's a little more on rails than I would like a deck building game to be that really lets me creatively come up with some hybrid strategy.

So your hand is just played. You're incentivized kind of just to lean into one color of whatever you commit to. Again, you can do some, you know,

Yeah. We're going to get the people in the the comments like, "You guys are bad at stuff."

Yeah. No, I I will willingly I recognize I'm probably not good at this game. Um but I don't know. I think it just and then with that one of us would usually, you know, it's an engine building game as you're getting more and more cards

that you're directly attacking.

They were directly attacking and so it became kind of very clear who was ahead in this kind of engine building and it felt like often times the person who would just kind of get ahead and then roll away to the win. And so I don't know. It I I think just kind of the more I played it, I was like, man, there's just not a lot of moments in this game that I go, "Oh man, that was a that was really cool. That was really interesting." Um, and so this one kind of just slowly start. I mean, I would have probably, if you ask me, a few years ago, this could have been as high as a 7.5, you know, maybe even squeaking to an eight. Um, but, uh, it it's kind of just been dropping a little lower and lower. uh for me and so settles at a 6.5 um and leaves the collection after many years.

You know what honestly like with the good Yeah. Like you play a game for 10 years and you have a good time with it and then you know you get you got new games that that you want to play more. So I don't regret it at all. Um I think there's a lot of people that would really enjoy this game. Um, it's a, you know, if you're again looking for that kind of simple, uh, deck building,

and I know it's been there's like Hero Realms is like a spin-off of it, and there's I know there's like expansion concept.

So, I I approve of the game, but just kind of

kind of fell out for me.

Fell out of favor.

Fell out of favor.

Speaking of games that fell out of favor,

every game on this list, uh,

I thought you were making like a pun with the word fall, you know, that kind of connects with this game. Yes. Yes. Things do fall in this game. In fact, yes, this is a really, really unique game and one that I have had a lot of fun experience. I've had a lot of fun fun experiences with it.

Uh, this is my version was called Rampage, later renamed to Terror in Mele City. That's the version you can get it after I think they ran into some copyright issues with the name Rampage. This is a video game and

Okay.

Um,

but this is a really unique one. I ultimately am going to land on a 6.5 for this one. And this is one even in my highest enjoyment of it, it probably was somewhere around a seven, but it was so unique and it brought such a unique fun thing to the table that that's what kept it in my collection. I mean, I've had this for probably 10

years. I have many times considered getting this game.

Yeah. And it's it hurt me a little bit to to let go of it. So So in this game, very unique. It's a dexterity game. You build up these towers. There's this city where like the buildings are the seawing tiles supported by little meuples.

Oh, great.

Um, and so there's these towers. There's like a football stadium in the middle. And then everybody's got their dragon monster thing that has a disc for its feet and then the big blocky like dragon piece.

And so you have two different options on your turn. You can move and moving is literally flicking your disc to move around and then you set your thing on it again. And all the buildings are like raised up on like a tile so you bounce off of them. Um, and so that's how you move around to be if you get close enough to a building that you're overlapping the sidewalk. Now you can try to destroy the building by literally dropping your piece, your big chunky piece on the building and seeing how it breaks. You're literally destroying

the city. But then there's game rules around it. So, there's this thing that they can eat a certain amount in your area of the meeples that landed there and you're trying to collect all the different colors and you're limited by how many teeth you have. And so, if you start getting hit by other monsters, you lose teeth and then you can't eat as many in a single round. Um, and then on top of that, there's uh special powers that you get in each game and like a super secret power. So, you have a little a symmetry. Um, and yeah, you keep going until you all destroy the city and then you count up your points based on like how many tiles you ate and the sets and your like special scoring.

Um, and it's a good fun time and like with a group that's in the right mindset can have a really good time with this. I think I think me getting rid of it is kind of two two factors. One is I played it a decent amount. I think I logged like 15 plays over those years. I mean, this isn't a game that you're like itching to get. It's like you got to be in the mood for it.

But enough plays that I will say the novelty

wore off a little bit for me. It was like, okay,

in those first five plays, it's so novel like what's happening and the abilities and stuff that once that, you know, goes away a little bit and you're just dealing with like

the gameplay,

it it turned more into it was fun to introduce to people, right? somebody. It's fun to have somebody that hasn't seen it at all experience it for the first time.

But I think what really ended up being the nail in the coffin for this one is I introduced it to my son Toby because I was like, "Oh, he'll probably love this game." And we had a good time of it, but I had this sinking feeling as we're playing it or as we're pulling it out again that like I like didn't feel like playing it anymore. and like this feeling that like we're g he's gonna want to pull it out. Um, you know,

so you got rid of it because you didn't want him to choose it.

He he wasn't like in love with it. I mean, it wasn't like he was picking it all the time.

Yeah. Yeah. Sorry, son.

It was his favorite game.

No, but we have lots of games we play together. And it just was this realization that like I wasn't really wanting to get it to the table um if I was being honest. And that's a hard trait to have in a game you're going to keep in your collection,

you know, with the intention that you're gonna play it.

Um, so we when I when I got rid of it, like we hadn't I hadn't played it with Toby in like probably eight months or something. So I don't think he was like,

"Where's Rampage Dad? Can we play it today?" Like I don't think he even remembers will like notice that it's gone.

Yeah.

Um, but yeah, it's a really fun novel game. you know, if you're looking for just a really unique game in your collection, I think this is still one I could recommend to the right person that wants to laugh. We even had some fun eightplayer games where people teamed up and because every turn you get two actions and so it was kind of like, well, each person gets an action on the turn and it actually worked really well and the group energy is really nice when you have that many people.

Um,

so really good times with this one. also was just a big honking box on the shelf and as I looked to free up some shelf space, it was like, well, that could be nice to reclaim.

Yeah. Well, that was a that was a plot twist, Ryan. I was expecting you to say Toby was the one that didn't like it, but turns out he loved it and you didn't like it. Um, and so I

calls the shots around here.

It's funny in my

in my mind when I think about this game, I get super excited,

but I think it's because you haven't played it.

I haven't played it as much. So, I honestly still have some of that novelty factor. But I actually remember I think maybe the I mean I haven't played this game in years, but I think I remember the last time playing it was like as we were playing

I kind of then realized the actual game play was fine, you know, it like but

but a lot of the draw to it, like you said, is the novelty of it. Um, so, uh, I think I I can understand why

why it fell into that place for you, but

it was time.

But man, when you got this one that it kind of blew our minds of,

yeah,

what a game could do

for sure. Uh, so that's an example of a game that I played quite a bit. This next one is not an example of a game I played quite a bit. I played it once. So,

jeez, Ryan, you take everything I say with a grain of salt.

Come on.

This is one I'll just say what it is first. This is The Fox in the Forest and I'm giving it a seven out of 10.

Um, and this is a really It's actually the first. So, rewind right now.

No, literally rewind your YouTube video right now.

Rewind. No, we're rewinding to the present day. Rewind is the wrong word.

We'll go back to the past. This is getting confusing.

Uh, right now we are in a just tricktaking explosion. It's exactly what happened with like roll and flipping rights is now happening with trick taking. It's like okay how many trick- taking games

do we need? It's cool to see all the innovation on that front. This is back way 10 plus years ago that the fox in the forest came out and it was the first cooperative trick taking game or sorry not cooperative two-player trick t there there's a uh there's a cooperative version of this game

um but a two-player trick-taking game which is kind of a novel concept of how do you make

trickt taking work with only two players and this is one that I'd always kind of been aware of but wasn't like super interested in the only reason I ended up trying this and having this is cuz I found it in a thrift store for like $3 like fully. It was

Isn't that the greatest feeling ever when you go to a thrift store and you actually see a good game?

Yeah. And it was one of these moments of like even buying it, I knew there was probably a good chance it wasn't going to stick around cuz it hadn't been one I was super interested in. But for $3, I was happy to give it a try. Uh, and get, you know, I'd always been pay $3 to have a terrible time. That's that's worth it.

No, I I recommend not doing that. remember time is the bit bigger constraint right now for gaming than anything. Uh but had the chance to try this game uh with someone else who enjoys trick-T games and we had a really fun game of it. Um it's got this I'm going to struggle to remember a lot of the details here but there's something with um your you know it's kind of normal trick taking as far as how you're leading and following. Actually, I haven't played this game.

Um, but the Well, I'm saying it's like normal trick taking, so like that can kind of anchor your your mind. But there's this thing in each round where you either want to get very few tricks.

U, so there there's kind of like you'll score if you get the let's see, I have some notes here. The humble victory, which is zero to three tricks. You can try to kind of go for very few.

You can win if you get the seven to nine tricks. It's like a victorious. But if you're greedy and get 10 to 13 tricks, then you get zero.

So what ends up being interesting in every round is you don't know what your opponent's going for.

And as you go, you might be thinking, I'm going to go for victorious, so I want to try to win some tricks. But as it goes on, you're like, I sure am winning a lot of tricks. And you realize they're going for humble. They're trying to not get any. which means that they're also trying to get you to go over because if you take too many

and so there's this really weird kind of chicken game of like are you trying to should I

let you should I lose some tricks intentionally on purpose now

you know so that I don't overshoot. So, there's some interesting things there, but then a bunch of the cards also have special abilities that let you do different things. And I'm going to remember none of them, but they were different things with, you know, cards in your hand or um changing things around. They gave a little bit of tactical interest into how the round went.

Um, and so I think it was a really solid good system. And I think if someone loves trick- taking games and likes the idea of playing with one other person, I think this is a great option. Though I think this is now not the only option. And I don't know others off the top of my head, but there's a freaking trick taking game for everything now. Like I mean like The Crew was kind of the first cooperative trick taking game. Now there's several coop.

You don't like this? Go get arcs, you know.

Yeah. I don't know if I would quite That's the trick taking in Jason.

Yes. The the natural progression from Fox in the Forest to Arcs. Um so at the end of the day, it was it was good. It was fine. Um, but I don't usually keep fine games around in the collection is and with two-player games especially like

you want to have ones you really

only two players.

Yeah, but it's two-player only. Maybe there's like a variant for three or something, but it's primarily a two-player game.

That makes sense.

Cool.

So, yeah, very clever design, fun, good time, but not one that wowed me enough to be like, this is going to be a staple in my two-player

part of my collection. Speaking of a game, Ryan, that has been on our collection for a long time. I mean, this is this is in the uh the the box shows some wear. Uh we've had this one for a very long time. Uh had it together when we were both living at home. Uh I inherited it as uh um in the tragic uh board game split that had to happen. Um and then I believe you have now taken it off of my hands. Is that accurate?

I do currently have this,

which means it is technically cold from my collection. Uh, this is going to go to King of Tokyo, which I'm giving a seven out of 10. And honestly, I I really enjoy a game of King of Tokyo. You know, a game where you're uh you're kind of battling. It's kind of a King of the Hill style game. You're battling to get to the center of Tokyo, and you do it by rolling these dice and then deciding, you know, through the course of three rolls dice you want to keep. And kind of the tension is around you're trying to you know you can win either by getting to I believe 20 victory points. And so on the dice if you keep three of the same number you get that many victory points. So three threes would get you three points. Um or you can keep claws which attack either the person who's in Tokyo or if you're in Tokyo it attacks the person outside of Tokyo.

Um you can keep hearts to heal up although you can only do that if you're outside of Tokyo which is one of the tensions. But being in Tokyo is good because every round you gets back to your turn, you're in Tokyo, you get two points, I believe. Um, so honestly, it's a really fun system. Uh, it's one that, uh, I think, uh, this game has become gotten more and more popular. Um,

yeah, this one's gotten pretty mainstream as far as its availability.

Um, and and one that we've enjoyed, I think, why did it leave my collection? Um,

yeah, why did it

one just played it a lot? So there's, you know, it's just sometimes when you're in those situations, there's other games you you lean towards. Um,

uh, another another thing that I I didn't love about it was the player elimination aspect of just the fact that like you could, you know, if some, especially if someone's not careful, um, they could get eliminated very early.

Yeah. and miss like you know it's not a super long game but it's kind of a bummer if you're playing a 30 minute game and you just got eliminated like

standard in modern board games is that there isn't player elimination so if you're going to bring out a game where that's a possibility like you have to feel like you have a pretty

like you really want this experience specifically that you're willing to bring that on

right

so I but honestly like the cards are cool you know the kind of upgrades you can buy are cool um I find the tension of like like balancing do I like how long do I stay do I stay in Tokyo longer or do I uh do I leave because every time you get hit you have the option to leave.

Um

but man, if you can stay in Tokyo, not only are you getting points, but your attacks hit everyone outside of Tokyo. So, uh honestly, I I think this is a it's a really solid game. Uh I just I really don't like player elimination. Um, and and I've just played it a lot. So, it wasn't even really a get rid of it. I mean, it was it was giving it passing it over to you because I think your kids were a little older and it felt like this would be could be a good one to Have you introduced it to them?

Yeah. So, Toby and I have played it. Um, and had some good games with it, though admittedly it's probably not the best

two-player game. It's fine, but not as good two-player. It'll be interesting to see with this one because it was it this happens sometimes with games that you haven't played in a long time that were like you played a lot in the past that you're like super excited to play it again cuz it's like oh yeah Kika Tokyo it's been a long time right

but then playing it a little bit you're kind of reminded a little bit about like maybe why it

fell out a little bit over time.

So it'll be interesting to see I could see this one not sticking around long term. Um, basically for the same reasons you're selling.

I give it to you.

The combination of Yeah, you give it to me and I'll sell it behind your back and for probably like $3 cuz you can find at a thrift store.

I found King of Tokyo in thrift stores.

Yeah, that is one you can find there.

Yeah. And so I I we'll see. But I think there's a good chance um the combination of the I've played it a lot and that player elimination and the you know it's a little bit more

in yourrface game that like

if I have a bigger group a lot of times it's not going to be the right game for that group.

Well I was going to say what situation are you are you saying King of Tokyo is the game I'm picking?

Yeah. And like I I basically was confronted with I don't think I had one. And that's not to say it's not a good game. Just in every situation I like if you could think about the prime situation of King of Tokyo, which is

you'd still be gravitating.

I still think there's some other games I have that I would lean towards. So that's, you know, that's the nail in the

Yeah. And I feel the same way. So stay tuned for in six months.

It sounds like Ryan's calling it, too. Just the list, Ryan. Add it.

Yes. We'll see. Uh not not locked in stone yet, but it certainly feels like it's trending in that direction.

Uh my next game is one that Danielle's going to be happy to hear that I'm calling.

Oh, yeah. Oh, good. I am. Yeah.

Uh this is one that gets a lot of praise as a modern classic from one of the most prolific designers, RER Canitia, and got a really nice new reprint. Um had the opportunity to pick this up. It was actually we had uh unloaded a bunch of books at uh Second and Charles is a place you can go like sell used books and then yeah get store credit. So we had some store credit there and they had board games there and so I actually picked it up there. Uh but this is through the desert. Uh really nice new production for this.

Mhm. And this is kind of a abstract game that almost is reminiscent of something like go with or or like some of these things where you're like making like paths or things on it. But everybody's got their different camel caravans that they're making paths on and you have your color of camels, but then you have what five different camels that have different colored people on them.

Excuse me so much.

Yeah, it's a little it can be a little hard to read the board honestly in this game at times. Um, but basically the game is so simple that you're just every turn adding camels and you always have to add camels onto your existing caravans and you can do any of the caravans, but other people are doing this too. So, it's kind of these lines going out and they start cutting each other off and you're trying to race kind of to get to the different oases or scoring tokens. And it's got an interesting thing that if you can kind of circle off a section, which we in the one game I played with you, we let our brother do that way too effectively. like closed off to the

It's like, oh, um, you get to collect everything that's in there because basically nobody else can reach it now. Um,

and so it's a really clever, elegant design, and it was one that had never really really piqued my interest, but I I kept hearing good things about it, especially with the reprint. And there was something to be said for how simple the rules were. Like, this is a game you could teach to anybody really quickly, could play with almost anybody. And I was like, maybe it'll kind of fit this this niche. Um, and I enjoyed it. I certainly enjoyed it more than you did.

That was correct.

Yeah. Which isn't saying much, but I didn't enjoy it like that much. Like it was kind of like, okay. And the people I played with it overall,

it did not like it wasn't like a big big winner. Like it was like everybody was kind of fine on it. Mhm.

Um and so that's kind of where it landed for me and it was like okay if I whereas compared to another game from RAW is a game that I definitely like raw more in in my personal enjoyment. I have also had specific games of RAW where win over really really well with the group

and I just wasn't seeing that me or that feeling that way about Through the Desert. Um,

well, can you remind me because I I played it once.

Once it's I mean, is it It's all open information. There's no This is It's It's a

Yeah. And

which, you know, you kind of get the element that you get with other abstracts where if everybody's like not a master of the game, it kind of works out cuz you're all just trying things, what other people are doing kind of shakes it up for you. And so I think it could still be a lighter feeling game even though there's no luck,

right?

Um, but there wasn't a lot.

There's not much here that's like jumping out to excite players, right? So all of the like enjoyment of the game really has to come from finding that core interaction on the map really really compelling.

Yeah.

And I think for us, for me, it was like kind of compelling. It was like kind of interesting. It was like a nice little experiment that was fun to play,

right?

But I wasn't like really feeling like, man, I want to play through the desert some more.

Um, so I know others completely feel differently about that and are like, this is a game I could play hundreds of times and it never gets stale because of how differently things goes out. So, uh, you know, it's a little bit just realizing our own tastes in games um, with some of these. Uh,

I'm glad I tried it because it's it is like really

a bigname classic in the hobby. Yeah.

Um, but for me wasn't one that was going to

Yeah.

stick around. I think Dang, did I say seven out of 10 for this? I think dang it would be several based on

It's hard to remember all the like what

you actually did you play it once or twice?

I think I just played it. Maybe we played it twice. I Yeah, maybe we did play it twice.

Did we do it at your house and maybe the other game?

You know, you know what's hard about games that are all hope and information? Again, this is partially because I'm oftenimes not good at that stuff is when there's no either like when it's all open information, man. When the just when things are going wrong, you just feel so like h like what am I do? I don't know.

I was dumb. Everybody watched me be dumb.

Or like we're as we're watching our brother like cut off the map, we're just like, oh my gosh. And then you can't even do like we like realized it what was happening. It's too late and we're like okay dang it.

Yeah. And some of that would get better with with repeated plays that you just get a little better at avoiding like big pitfalls. It is interesting that there's something to be said that games that where it isn't all open information can like kind of hide people's suboptimal play.

Oh yeah. Cuz like nobody knows on that.

Yeah. Nobody Nobody knows that you made decisions cuz they didn't know everything that you knew about your decision.

Exactly. I just said these cards are terrible. You have no idea.

Don't know what it's like.

Yeah. So clever game.

Danielle's not not running out to purchase it.

No, I honestly I forgot about it and now that I see it again, I am thrilled to see it leaving your collection.

Thrilled. My next one actually of everything on this list is the one that I

saddens me saddest to see leave. I don't know why.

This is a long time

longtime staple in kind of the party game segment of my collection. This is Camel Up,

which I rate a seven out of 10.

I've played Camel Up a lot. I think I'm like over 30 plays of Camel Up and I have had some absolute banger games of Camel Up. Um because like if you get a group together, you're betting on this camel race, which I love like just being able to introduce that as a concept. Like we could here's our options. We could play this this party game or we could gamble on camel racing and people always like come again.

Uh but it's got a really interesting thing with how the camels stack and how they move. And if one moves on the bottom, it carries the other camels. And you know, every camel is going to move once during the round. So you can kind of start to picture all the things that could happen. Okay, if orange moves first, he's going to carry everybody before they move.

But if orange moves last, people are going to get off of him and then he could go on top of the stack and that could change. And people can put out their like oasis or their desert tile that'll like modify things and then you're picking bets of who do you think's going to be ahead at the end of this leg and who's going to be ahead at the end of the race.

Really, really good betting on a race game. And I think the DNA

works really well of providing enough variance and interest to make that betting interesting

and like there's amazing moments that can happen in this game uh when something very unexpected happens. And so I think the number one factor that's pushing this out of my collection. I'm going to I'm going to give it three factors. Here's my three factors.

Wow.

The first one is I've played it a lot. And this is a game that again you lose a little bit of the novelty factor. you, you know, you sometimes just get a little you're not as eager to play it as you once were after so many plays.

Um, another big one, honestly, is it's a little longer than I want it to be.

I was wondering how long does this one usually?

It definitely varies. Now, granted, some of that self-inflicted cuz we choose to play with the extension board and the extra dice cuz I feel like it makes the game better. Um, but even without it, like it's a little unpredictable, but it was often pushing 45 minutes to an hour, which for a party game is a long party game.

Yeah. You kind of want 45 minutes to be the cap.

Yeah. And I I just definitely had a lot of games of this where it went longer than I wanted it to go. Um, so that was another factor. Another factor is just new games that have come into my collection. Um, and so there's games like Ready Set Bat, which is very different than this, but is a somewhat similar lane of gambling games. While something's happening, I uh Hot Streak is actually a big one

that

it loses a little bit from Camel Up in, I'd say, the interest of feeling clever with your betting as the race is going on and calculating things and some of the just things that can happen. But it trades it for like close to half the playing time.

I was gonna say it's much quicker

more consistently funny moments like it gets the the table laughing more and just like at this race that's happening.

Um and so I I definitely after getting hot streak felt like a lot of times if that's the type of party experience I'm going to bring, I feel like I'm going to lean towards it because of the length and just the higher probability of the group laughing and having a fun time. because Camelop can provide that, but it doesn't always depending on how the dice go and everything. Um, and so this is one that sometimes a game after a long stay in the collection, it's just it's time for it to go on. Uh, highly recommend this one still though cuz again, like I played it like let me look. Daniel, how many times do you think I've played Camel Up?

Um, I'm guessing you played Camel Up uh

34 times. 28.

Oh wow.

I was going to guess close to 40, but 28, like when you think about it, that's all physical plays. All physical plays. Um that's a lot a lot of a lot of plays for a game like this.

Um and so it was time. I think somebody that comes new into this and has a group that hasn't played it before.

You're going to get all that enjoyment that I got for the first however many games of this, which I would highly recommend. It was a great experience.

Yeah. I mean, I'll be honest, I'd probably rate this 7.5. I I uh I enjoy Camelot quite a bit and like I said have considered owning it. Um I don't have a game currently in that. Uh

well I guess I have ready set bat but that feels very different but

although I did play hot streak um so and that was very fun as well. So

there's a new addition of Camelop and I played magical athlete that's you know I got a also a little bit of a feel of of that which that was also very fun. Yeah.

Um, okay, Ryan, I'm bringing this home here.

Yep. Last one.

Do my honorary big jump in rating here.

Big jump in rating. Honorary calling of a good game. You know, as much hate as I get from Ryan on this channel, um, I always have good reason why I

most of the time this one's a good reason.

Um, but my uh uh top rated game that I called goes to Dwellings of Elder, which I'm giving an 8.5 out of 10. And this left my collection uh primarily because of a uh new version. Well, it's a different game, but clearly a uh

80% the same,

you know, iteration uh upon it of Andromeda's Edge, but I got Dwellings of Elder and um got to play it a few uh I think I play ended up playing it maybe four times. I know I played it with you at least once. Um and it was a pretty bad play. Um but uh for at least for Ryan. Um

but anyways, I really liked a like a lot of what's going on here. Um I I mean that whole again I' I've I've always just kind of wanted to find a game that lived in that kind of hybrid space of being, you know, like it started, you know, I used to own Scythe and and really enjoyed a lot of it. had a few few things that that I didn't love, but then but something that lives in that like workers resources, but also there's kind of like some combat and and this game does it just in a really interesting way where you're playing your uh little, you know, mele people out onto um these tiles out on the map which you're, you know, getting taking actions of the tiles, collecting resources. is you can also if you enter into a place with another person or one of the big you know I don't know what they're called but big boss monsters you can fight one of them which then can get you rewards but then once you've placed all your workers then there's a recall um you know action which you can take them all back and then there's you're building your own kind of personal uh action board that your workers can come back and take actions there as well and so it's kind of this whole cycle happening and it it is a system that I really really like.

And so playing playing it in dwellings of Eldervil um was super fun and I had every intention that like I think I you know I I had some mixed plays but I think it was more I taught the rules not well and stuff like I felt like this one was going to be like okay I think I maybe found one that could consistently um be in there. But then, you know, you see a video of uh Andromeda's Edge and people start talking about like a lot of similarities between these games. Um some people think it's an improvement, some people like Dwellings better. So, I wanted to just like after having played Dwellings, look into it and kind of see what what were the things that they've changed because I think that's helpful is you can when you've played Dwellings already. I know we got a comment about this on like one of our other videos or maybe it was a question in our Q&A video, but uh being able to have played dwellings and then look at what they did in Andromeda's Edge and see if you like the changes that have been made. And for me, I felt like the changes that they made, almost every single one I looked at and was like, "That's a nice tweak or oh that like they did a lot of stuff around combat that felt like it helped prevent like crazy swingy uh upsets uh to happen around like I think it's called like targeting. Um they it felt like what you were building in front of you like the actions that you were coming back and building was even more

interesting uh in like kind of yeah what you were what you were doing um back there. And so there was a lot of interest you know there there as well. I mean it's a lot of it's the same game. So like it's not like if you don't like you know Dwellings you're going to suddenly love Andromeda's Edge. Um, and I think there's people that Dwellings of Eldervil might be the, you know, uh, the better choice. Personally, honestly, I actually like the theme of Dwellings a little bit better. I kind of liked that fantasy, uh, theme versus, um, I don't know, space is fine, but it didn't feel like it was as uh, just grab me quite as much. Um, I liked one thing, a couple of things I liked about Androme's Edge more. I liked having a board for everything to like be on. and it just felt like it contained it.

I really was thinking that as we were playing Andromeda's Edge that uh it just felt like it was easier for me to parse what was happening and like understand it cuz it was all on the same board, right?

I also was having a bad time strategically during Dwellings of Elder, so it's hard for me to like knock it too much. Um

yeah, so it uh so I enjoyed, you know, enjoyed that and we had a good play of Andromeda's Edge. It was actually it was really fun.

Um, another just like side thing that you know we talked about you mentioned with Rampage like space on your shelf.

So I have just the standard edition of Andromeda's Edge. It's like it's like a half if not even you know maybe less than half the size of Dwellings of Elder Dwellings. Man, Androme's Edge might win the award in my collection of like most just like best use for like how big of a game

for how big of a game it is. Um, and I don't have the I don't have the deluxe edition. I'm happy I don't because it fits really really well on this on the shelf. And I think in the standard edition, it looks beautiful. I

It's one of those things if you didn't know there was a deluxe edition that existed, you wouldn't think anything about the production.

Yeah, I thought the artwork and everything, they did a they did a great job. So, both great games, but I don't know when there's a game that you love and then you see, oh, there's another, you know, we want we want the best version of the, you know, the game, right? And this is the same

which admittedly I don't like love the trend of like the 1.25 versions of things,

you know, I'm going to push back on you for one moment, Mr. uh Terrammystica Gaia project.

I and I I agree. times where and there's times we've come out on the other end being like, I'm so glad this happened. But I don't love the dynamic of like loving a game and then feeling like now you're in this situation where you have to be like, well, but I like this game, but do I need to do I need to go try Dune Imperium Uprising? I already love Dune Imperium. I don't need to.

Um

Well, and the answer if you have Dwellings of Eldervil and you love it, the answer is no.

Well, but that's the situation you were in, right? Well, I think I think I I don't think I like it was an 8.5 for me, so I really liked it, but it wasn't it wasn't this wasn't quite in the

Yeah.

And I think you were technically willing to cuz I think you waited to sell dwellings until you tried Andromeda.

I still haven't sold it, but

you still haven't sold it. You want a copy of dwellings. Um, but I think you would have been willing to if Andromeda's Edge fell more flat for whatever reason, be like, "Oh, actually I do like Dwellings more and sold Andromeda's Edge." So, you definitely have that option.

Yeah. No, for sure. Um, so yeah, I I think um both great games, but Andromeda's Edge for me has kind of uh just felt like it it took it took that step that again I've only played it once, so I got to play it more, but it feels like it might take that step that pushes a game from an 8.5, which is really really good, to you get into the nines, and you're talking about some of our some of our all-time favorites. Um, so we will see where it lands. Yeah, I would say that uh Dwellings of Alderville for you uh walked so that Andromeda's Edge could run. Hey, thanks for watching what is one of our only like negative leaning videos of the entire year. Almost all the content we put out is talking about games that we really love and enjoy. Um but it's good for you to get a window into maybe the ones that didn't stick around for us. Uh, we've got some other content here you can check out if you want to watch and hear more about board games.

Progress saved