Skip to main content
Loading video...

Introducing People to Stonemaier Games - The Mill

Transcript 12:39

hello and welcome to the mill my name is dusty crane and today I thought we would talk about introducing people the stone mire games we're fans what is a good entry point for new people into the Hobby or introduce people that are maybe already in the Hobby to the stone mire games that we enjoy I post this question to the Facebook groups the varying Facebook groups to the my little scythe group to the euphoria group to the viticulture group and kinda pitched it like hey our game in this forum is the best one to start people in right and by and large the agreement was yeah in our favorite game that we're talking about right now that is the best one but there were a few people ahead different opinions I thought we could just talk about it we have great games right we have side we have my little side euphoria viticulture Tuscany we have between two cities now we have between two castles I was looking at each one of these titles I was asking myself which one is the best one to be your first stone layer game I figured I just kind of talk around how my thought process went there I started with euphoria and I got to thinking euphoria is I mean it's worker placement but it's dice placement and there's a lot of tracks there's a lot of different resources

there's artifacts and there's different places you can put your workers and different places you have to unlock to put your workers I think it's probably straightforward for people who are already familiar with Hobby gaming but it might be intimidating for a new person to the Hobby or to the table or to that game so I thought maybe not euphoria the second game I thought about was viticulture I think if you talk to anybody that's a fan of viticulture they'll tell you viticulture is great Tuscany is where it's at like Tuscany makes viticulture what viticulture was meant to be I thought that was pretty cool that viticulture obviously anytime you have an expansion like Tuscany and you're adding all kinds of new stuff it is a situation where it makes it more complicated but it's almost like viticulture it's a great game by itself but there's people they have you know concerns about the gameplay they don't like just having the two seasons they want the four seasons that Tuscany provides it's kind of neat how if you want to introduce somebody to viticulture then you have the very base viticulture game and then once they have it you take them and you lead them into Tuscany and so it's almost like viticulture is a great gateway to Tuscany if you want to play Tuscany starting with viticulture so then I

started thinking about scythe and scythe is a terrific game sign is my favorite stone layer game and it can seem pretty overwhelming especially if you take it to a new game day or you take it to somebody's house and you have the legendary box and it's just packed with airships and mechs and workers and extended boards and all these different cool things these resources these these coins it can seem like a lot and so almost just the presentation is intimidating if they're not familiar with the Hobby board games bring in my little sighs my little scythe it's cutesy it looks like a kids game but there's so much more to it I mean you probably already know that you've probably played it and if you haven't check it out it's really good it's a great introduction to scythe well being a great game all on its own you have you know you're still placing workers or you're doing action placement so you're you know choosing what you're gonna do and moving over that that player mat and you still have quests and you still have it's not combat power but it's pie he's you know because you're in do pie fights instead of combat and you have friendship instead of popularity but the core tenets of saya they're there right you're still moving around these hexes you got in this case you're making a delivery to the center of the board but the center of the board is a destination just like it is inside and so my little side is a

great gateway for people that want to get other people in decide and then we also have between two cities which is probably the best game to introduce people to stone Meier games in my opinion because you as the person familiar with the game can work with the people to your left and your right if you're introducing two new people then yes they're gonna work with themselves but you can kind of guide and you can do this any way no matter what your player count is but you're working together with potentially this new person to the to the gamer to the hobby you're working together with them on your left and you're working together with the person on the right and you're building the city together so they know that their interests are being served or that you're not just trying to pull one over on them hopefully you're not the kind of gamer that will go ahead and take advantage of the newbies but I mean there's something that are out there so between two cities is a great game on its own I've had a chance to play capitals yet but I played between two cities with my girls and they picked it up right away they're ten and after the first game they were ready for another game of it so that's that's great I mean that's kind of a new person to the Hobby example right there from there we can move on to between two castles which is the new release from Stone wire and between two castles in Mad King Ludwig and it has a lot of the same things in

common with between two cities but there's a bit more to it there's a bit more meat but the same core tenants exist right you're still working with the person on your left and your right so in that regard maybe that's a good intro point to but there's still other things going on in the scoring I haven't played the game yet the scoring looks a little intimidating but maybe it's not there are a lot of good games in the stone buyer library that build either onto themselves or serve as a good introduction to the hobby based on how you want to go about introducing people to it I haven't mentioned charter stone yet but charter stone is unique in that it's a legacy game you kind of have to get people on board for more than one game unless you're playing your completed board what's kind of cool is it starts like a basic worker placement game and as you get more familiar with it and you complete game after game after game you add more pieces to it you add more complication to it and it's almost like it is its own gateway to itself because the end game is different than how it starts and I just think it's really cool that it's almost like an introduced introduction to itself you just need to have somebody committed to the length of that campaign my opinions are what they are the opinions that were in the Facebook group they are what they are they everyone had great points everyone knew exactly why they were introducing people what their reasons were how they

go about doing it and it's worked well for them I decided to ask Jamie what his opinion was I asked them in your opinion what is if you had to choose one title that represented stone wire games is a good introduction to what your brand stands for and what your idea of a stone layer game is what would that game be what do you think his answer was I'll just go ahead and read from his email so I don't misrepresent what he said but he said I think I might actually say my little scythe it has more meat to it but it isn't complicated to play or learn it has a great table presence and it's representative of many of the things that define stone layer games nice flow from turn-to-turn through the end of the game mostly subtle form or mostly subtle forms of player interaction plays from 1 to 6 etc yeah I mean that's kind of what stone wire does right you have a high player count or I guess what you would consider what's been called an event presence or big table presence it is not a filler game or a small game like that not that it and I'm gonna say gateway game or filler and I don't mean any of that derogatory but in terms of a good gateway game Jamie mentioned that maybe between two cities because it's got a pretty straightforward rule set it still got you know great interaction with the other players at the table so I can see the case being made for that too like I said my own personal opinion kind of

differs depending on what game you ultimately want to get them to play I think if you want to get people playing scythe start with my little scythe you want to get people playing viticulture and Tuscany start with viticulture charter stone if you can pin them down for a whole campaign it's a great introduction into and of itself for euphoria that one's a little bit harder that one I think might be a little heavier on the on the scale that one's a harder one to I guess necessarily get people to grok because there's so much going on but yeah I mean for me I think my go-to game for an adduct introducing people to stone mire games is probably my little scythe unless they have a theme that they really strongly enjoy so if I have a friend who's really into dystopian stuff maybe I am gonna go ahead and break out euphoria if I have if I'm gonna introduce a game to my wife I'm gonna start with viticulture because that would be more along the theme of something that she would enjoy versus if I brought out my little side that she's probably look at me cross-eyed and the say no thanks so that plays a part in what you introduce to people as well I'm telling you stuff you already know you're gamers you know this already but I mean I thought it was an interesting discussion because everyone had a different answer some people are like no hi like sighs my friends are gamers or

even the ones that aren't they'll get it in a game or two it's gonna be fine my introduction to stone Meyer with scythe so their introduction to stone layer will be scythe and I think that's fine too what about you guys do you have a game that is your go-to stone Meyer game to introduce people to stone layer games or is there another game that segues well or leads into a stone Meyer game I don't have an idea here for what game would lead to another one but maybe you're like you know what you know is a great introduction to to between two cities no reason why I just said that doesn't make any sense at all but for an example so let me know what you think before I close I just want to tell you guys that I really have appreciated the comments and the likes and subscribes and the support that you have shown to the mill to me in particular I wanted to say thank you to all of you that have watched these videos I also want to thank Jamie because his promoting the channel his helping the channel grow has been invaluable people that like watching numbers and are interested in that kind of thing there is a very noticeable spike when I post the video on my own versus when Jamie says hey check out this video that dusty made go check out the latest issue or the latest video of the mill so I appreciate his help in

this endeavor yeah I just wanted to say thanks thanks for watching this video if you have any ideas for future videos make sure to drop it in the comments leave me a like and subscribe if you haven't already let me know what you want to see let me know what you'd like to see different I am open to the conversation so just wanted to say again thank you for watching and you know have a good one bye

Progress saved