10 Board Games Ranked - Episode 32
Transcript
hey everybody and welcome to another chairman of the board ranking video so if you're not familiar with this series it's where I take a look at the last 10 new to me games that I've played no matter what they are and I rank them from my least favorite up to my most favorite now these videos normally I'm put out quite an Eclectic bunch of games and this episode is certainly no exception I'm not sure about some of the interest that you guys will have in some of these games but hey that's what makes it so fun for me uh before I get started on the game I want to give a shout out to the show sponsor Kender who are my go-to online retailer and if you use the link in my show notes or the QR code then you can get 5% off your first order at number 10 I have fart now fart is basically an UNO variance where you're shedding cards from your hand trying to match the number or the color of the suit The Twist on this game is that when you play the card you have to make a fart sound correspond ing to the type of fart that is on the card yes that is what this game entails um it's very silly um you know no strategy no decision space um and it's funny for about 30 seconds and after that it kind of drags on too long um lots of take that cards stuff like that and um you know from the explanation you can probably tell that I did not like this game at all and I'm pretty sure that none of you guys will either so let's move swiftly on at number nine I have ground Breakers which was kindly provided to me by by the
publisher and designer of the game now this is quite a misleading game that left me a little bit confused because from the look of it you might think it's a kind of civilization Style game um that's car driven or maybe some kind of innovation variant but in actuality it's a more kind of a mass Market feeling game that's almost a variant on um exploding kittens where again you're trying to shed cards from your hand as quickly as you can because by the rounds end once somebody's dumped all the cards from the hand if you you have cards remaining in your hand they're going to be worth negative points which is a bad thing of course and the cards are pretty simple stuff try to play things in sets and shed them together um you could do reaction cards do block people's moves or force them to pick up cards so there's a bit of take that here as well and it drags on too long the game also encourages you to play over several rounds which again is is not really a starter for me not my style of game but I know that these games are somewhat popular but I'm not sure if the kind of mechanical side of the game mixed with the Aesthetics um is a good combination to really showcase what this game is about and to get it into the hands of the right people so um I can't really recommend this one it's not for me and if I'm going to play a shedding game um I'm going to play something like Linko Scout or a um or even games like mask men which are much more enjoyable more mechanically sound and um you know it is my tastes a bit better at number eight I have green team wins now this is an
ultra simple party game where you are given a question as a group and you going to secretly write the answer on these dry erase boards you're going to reveal them and what you're trying to do is you're trying to be in the majority um of everybody and if you are in the majority you'll go to the Green Team or if you're in the Green Team you will start generating points and basically if you're wrong you go to the orange team and if you're right you go to the Green Team and again staying in the green team is much more lo ctive in terms of generating points um I was surprisingly good at this game for some reason so I must have a good idea about what people like um and it was enjoyable you know very simple stuff these kind of games are so inoffensive and you just play them anytime anywhere and it was a nice game to end a game's night on now the only issue I had with it was that the questions were quite Americanized and they didn't really land with a kind of a pure British group um so it would have been nice to see some of those more American questions tailored to more of a British audience but other than that game was perfectly enjoyable and I would play it again at number seven I have three ring circus which is probably going to be the game that you want to hear most about so this is a brand new Euro strategy game by Fabio Lano published by Dev games um I'm generally a fan of Lano and a fan of of DEA I think they make good products um this one I've had a bit of a roller coaster with so when I first played it I wasn't quite sure what to make of it um I thought this is good there's a lot of things here that I like I like this card
play as you're building up this Tableau of characters um I like this timing puzzle with these area majorities getting triggered on the main board um and this kind of thread of strategy that you're building towards these huge performances the more I play this one sadly the less I'm enjoying it um I think the luck of the ticket card draw is too significant because to put these big performances on you need very specific characters and if you not drawing those characters then you are pretty much screwed and I also felt the game feels somewhat unsatisfying because you're not managing physical resources and it seems like generating points is too easy um in lower play accounts I think you can get too much done um I think my review should be uploaded by the time this video comes out so check out that video for a more detailed rules over kind of overview and more detailed thoughts my detailed thoughts on the game but sadly yeah I think this one is is not quite up to par of what I want in my collection I think it's slightly above average but um I don't think it's going to be in people's or in the Forefront of people's minds for too long I liked how simple the rule set was you only taking one of two actions playing a card or doing a performance but um I don't this I don't think this game has legs and it just left me feeling a little bit L little bit numb sadly despite how beautiful the game looks so um that's it at number seven I have three ring circus at number six I have sea salt and paper now this card game by
brunic cathala seems to be getting a little bit of Buzz and a bit of a a bit of a cult following at the moment um because it does have some cool little twists here um I like the fact that your score is not only the cards you've played but also the cards you have remaining in your hand i t to I tend to like that mechanism and it adds a bit more murkiness into who you think is doing well but essentially what you're doing here is you're drawing cards either from um a face down deck or from two discard piles and you're collecting these different cards you can play matching cards together two of them um and they'll give you a special power but that will of course reveal more information about the cards you've been collecting and how many points you might have and there's also a bunch of set collection cards in the deck as well and I also like this twist that there are these mermaid cards which has this kind of shoot the moon mechanism and if you collect all four of them you'll automatically win the game now the game was a little bit clunky when it came to the end of round trigger because it was player driven and you actually had to declare the end of the round and by either saying look I think I'm going to win here I'm going to wager on myself and if I'm right then I'm going to H everybody scoring or you can just say let's end the round now and I think we'll just score what we already have and um let's keep it balanced that way now I thought because of that scoring mechanism the game could go on a bit too long and I felt like you were just going through the motions not really knowing when to call it um and that and that scoring mechanism where you're wagering on yourself was a little bit confusing
because um it's a little bit of a wonky um you know scoring mechanism there it's been done before in games like Cabo which I think is done perfectly but in this one I don't think it works quite as well um don't get me wrong it's a decent game but I think there are other card games in my collection that flow a bit nicer and are a bit more succinct U than sea salt and paper is because because you know even playing one round of this is quite long and the game encourages to play over several rounds until you've reached a certain amount of points so um would I call it a near Miss maybe um but I don't think I'm going to miss this one when I end up passing with it at number five I have perfect Alibi now this is a deduction game by Christen aosi who's made some fantastic games um definitely a different style of game for him and it's I think it's one of his more original games going back to 20 15 actually so this is like a um you know a pure logical deduction game think of games like sleuth this is very similar to that a bit more simple than that in terms of the brain burning burner nature of it but the unique selling point of this game is at any time during the game each player has a special power which will kind of break fundamental rules like for example um normally you can only ask questions depending on these tows that come out but if you have a certain character you can ask anybody any question or normally if there's an answer you're given and there's more than two of those cards you have to show your opponent a card well there's a card
that prevents you from doing so or there's a card that let you do a lucky dip from people's hands or lets you um kind of know answers when it's not even your turn these kind of things that are you know very minor but in a logical deduction game can be quite significant and definitely be the Difference Maker in the winner or the loser and that was actually what ended up costing me um the uh the game that I played of this um recently because um somebody had a card and um that prevented them from sharing that information from me and if I knew that bit of information I would have probably won the game so that was quite cool that you can chop and change your characters as um the game state is changing so if you want an introductory um D deduction game then I definitely recommend this one um it's pretty affordable very cheap at least when I bought it but for my own collection I do have other games that I prefer um such as awkward guests um sleuth as I already mentioned um even games like um like crypted I think are a bit better than um perfect Alibi not like there's anything wrong with it at all I just don't need that many deduction games in my collection at number four I have delicious so delicious is one of the pencil first series of kind of filler games small box games and that I've been talking about quite a bit on the channel um recently and there are more to come on this um video um this is a bit different to other games because this is more of a flip and right Style game and you're revealing two cards one of which applies to the top row of your player
sheets one applies to the bottom row and these cars have different vegetables on them and what you're doing is you're trying to fill up these Planters of either different types of veg and the same types of veg or even pairs of veg as well the more you fill the more points you get and but of course the more you play the more restrictive that sheet becomes um because you have actually very selective options on what to pick like for example you can either take one card where it is or you can take one card but in the opposite location you can take two cards where they are or you can take two cards anywhere and you only have limited options to do that throughout the game um so you know you are going to be at the mercy of luck here because sometimes the car is going to fall with the way you've planned your sheet and sometimes they're just not but there are a few mitigation tools to overcome and even some little combo things you can do as you place these little tools and stuff on your player sheet um to broaden your options I suppose um it's a nice game um it's again it can be frustrating at times because you simply can't place things at times but it's enjoyable and you know for a 20 to 30 minute fill a game it's it's perfectly good so that is delicious at number four at number three I have the next of the pencil first games which is the what not cabinet now this is a tall placement puzzly kind of spatial awareness game as you have this kind of a CAC shelf I suppose and you are drafting these towels and then placing them on your little shelf to try and build rows and Columns of either the same color the same artifacts these kind
of things um to get more or or fewer points but you're essentially trying to build patterns and there are public objectives as well that you're trying to be the first to achieve but I really do like this drafting mechanism here as you can kind of go quicker in player order and hopefully get the ti that you really need that's on display but you have a little less control or you can go really further you lower down in the priority of turn order you know obviously you're going last in priority but you might have a little bit more control to get the exact tile um that you want so the pencil first game seem to do a really good job of mixing um you know initiative turn order into their game to makes that make that a pivotal part of it and play in around 20 minutes so Ultra Snappy and it's one of these games it feels quite satisfying when you manag to pull off the chains that you um that you intended because some sometimes it feels like you're not going to do it um but you end up just pulling it off um regardless so I like this one I'm not sure if it's going to hold up long term but it is on my shelf at the moment and I'm going to play it some more um you know a perfectly Pleasant filler kind of a puzzly game that is the whatnot cabinet I've heard this game has a good solo mode actually so I might have to check um that one out so that is the whatnot cabinet at number three at number two I have the biggest game on this list this is Moon rakers so I was actually taught this game at a local games group and I'm really glad that I um I put my name forward into playing uh this one because I enjoyed it quite a
lot actually so this is um there's a lot going on in this game and I did play with a lot of the expansion material which I didn't think it was too overwhelming actually but it's a hybrid negotiation and deck builder game as essentially on your turn you are putting forward a mission to go on which will require a certain amount of cards um to be played amongst all the players um going on that mission so you might say well I really need these extra bits of damage therefore would you come with me help me do that damage and then I'll give you this share of the rewards so I really do like the fact that you can strike up some cool deals you might think you know what I'll give you a point if you do this damage but I want two points and I'll do the rest of it that kind of thing and you're always kind of um going back and forth haggling about what you want um I thought the deck building was really fun actually Different Different Twist on the deck building because you could actually only play one card at a time unless you had a specific C type of card in your hand which will allow you to play more cards or let you to chain more cards off from each other so I did like the fact that it wasn't as simple as you know draw five cards and you can play five cards each round you really did have to think a little bit more about how you were playing these cards and which cards do keep filtering through your hand I it worked really well I think the it's it's not a kind of game I'd have my own personal collection because I think it's a little bit too rules intensive a little bit too um situation dependent because you want Higher Play accounts here as with most negotiation games um a
massive table hog um but for an an event game something I'd play probably once or maybe even twice a year and I would recommend it quite a lot actually so I definitely ended up enjoying this one way more than I was anticipating and it's actually a really well put together and well constructed game um you know if you like negotiation and you regularly have higher player counts then I would not look over this one it's actually really quite quite impressive so that is moonrakers at number two and finally at number one it is the third of the pencil first games this is sunset over water so Sunset over water is another set collection game but this one's more of a of a contract fulfillment game as you are moving your player piece around this big I think it's a 5x5 grid of cards collecting cards then cashing in the symbols on these cards to um to gain points essentially um The Twist on this game is that you have a personal deck of cards you're drawing three of them you're playing one of them each round which will give you a bunch of different information so the first thing it will show is time now the earlier the time it means you get priority in turn order which can be hugely important in this game because you need to go first to get the card you want the second bit of information is the direction that you can move your porn in and the third bit of information is how many cards you can pick up and as you can probably assume um generally the slower the cards are the more cards you can pick up the faster you move um the fewer cards you can pick up but of course you you jump priority um it flows very nicely um
gorgeous artwork um and it's just a really nice filler game now I've not given it quite a commendation yet because I've played this know three or four times I think and I just want to play it a few more times to see that is it really going to hold up and am I am I going to play it um that many times more I think I will I think this is going to lean towards a commendation eventually but I'm just being a little bit more reserved into giving that um award out I suppose so really enjoy this one um probably one of the best fill games I've played in some time actually um and I've been playing a lot so out of all the pencil first games this one is right up there for a lovely set collection game good again good spatial puzzle good use of um of initiative and a good kind of conflicting mechanism of thinking well that simultaneous flip ping of cards it's quite exciting when you go really early somebody else has just pipped you going a little bit earlier and they snatched the card you want which can of course be a good type of frustration and what that player interaction is all about so that is sunset over water don't really hear too much about this one and I think it should be more out there more talked about and discussed because it's a very solid and well put together game so that is sunset over water at number one so there we go that concludes the video hopefully you have enjoyed it and discovered something um new here definitely an Eclectic bunch of games um this episode now if you have enjoyed the video please be sure to hit like And subscribe to the channel and check out my other content too but for everybody else I'll see you next time on chairman
of the board bye-bye