17 Board Games Ranked - Episode 6
Transcript
hey everybody and welcome to another month in review so this is a series of videos where i talk about all the new to me games i've played during the month of course this month being october 2021 and i rank those games from my least favorite to my most favorite giving brief descriptions of the games along the way um sometimes i've already provided reviews of these ones but more often than not there will be a review dropping sooner or later so keep an eye out for those so i've played 17 new games this month from all different years and i've also played two additional expansions so let's get started with those expansions both of which i've got a positive perception of so first off i played seven wonders duel pantheon so this one adds god powers to obviously seven wonders duel and i like the way you acquire these god powers because in the first phase of the game depending on which cars you reveal along the way you can choose to basically take um skim from these decks and allocate these cars to a different spot on this additional section to the board and basically depending on where you allocate those god cards it's going to be cheap for you or more expensive for your opponent and of course your opponent's doing the same thing so you can kind of tinker where you want to put these cards and make you know depending on what strategy you want to go for and i like the fact that going forward when these god powers come into play then you can actually choose to almost pass on the main action or where you'd normally acquire a card in favor of using a god power additionally i really like the change in the third phase where rather than using the guild card you have these kind of really special cards that you can build to get a lot of points so i liked it not too much foodiness and not too much overhead to
add to the base game so i'd probably more often than not play with this expansion the second expansion i played was thing velia which is the uh first and only expansion so far for nidovillia that one's of being a really cool kind of bidding game as you're acquiring cards to score points in a ton of different ways depending on the suits of cards that you get this one has a new thing to go for as you can collect these artifacts all of which are really interesting and i also like these special character cards you can get just adding more variety different paths to victory and again next to no overhead in compared to you know the base game so not too much fitness and another expansion i'd probably play with every single time so two very nice expansions there that i would recommend picking up if you're a fan of the base games but let's get started with the actual main bulk of um of actual main core games so first off at number 17 i have hit the silk which is actually a 2021 release so brand new kickstarter game this one has a cool theme to it whereas you are trying to um i suppose you've just especially in a group of burglars or bank robbers doing a big heist and you're basically on this plane that's about to crash and you've got to get your share of the money but there are only so many parachutes on the plane um for i think it's like one or two fewer players than actual is in the game so you're going to have to leave some players high and dry and make sure that you're in a position to not only have money but also have a parachute to escape safely so you've got a little bit of negotiation there but fundamentally this game has a lot of take that's in it it's one of
those games that i think that it tries to really sell itself on the theme and the idea of it where the actual mechanisms and gameplay are pretty lackluster it feels dated and it does feel pretty nasty at times just just for the sake of it um the scoring in-game scoring is a bit a bit of a mess and to be honest the whole game in general is a bit of a mess it doesn't feel good it doesn't feel like a satisfying game and have any really interesting decisions on it um i just kind of sat back and just kept a hold of my parachute get hold of some money and ultimately did okay just doing that so not very exciting and a bit of a bit of a botch of a game to be honest so i highly highly recommend you give that one a miss that one is hit the silk at number 16 i have happiness grand bazaar now this one goes back to 2017 and is a pretty simple set collection game on the on the surface of it as you're collecting cards of different different suits i'm trying to trade them in in different areas depending on the sets you have so you know do you want to send um sell a bunch of the same cards you want to sell um one of each different color or something something like that and whatever you do depending on the difficulty um depends on how many points you get for doing so but this all that set collection stuff is under the veil of a negotiation game so in this game you are bidding for these different locations um to either acquire cards or to i mean to sell things but also there is one spot on the board that is kind of the chief negotiator so there's a whole section in this game where you can choose to trade cards with one another of course trying to aim towards those sets but if somebody has that chief
negotiator position then every deal has to go through that player and they have to kind of sign off on that deal to be made maybe taking a cut of the um you know cut of the trade or getting some kind of bonus for doing so and i really thought that idea was quite cool you know where you had this this authority figure who did pay for that privilege to do so but ultimately that was kind of the downfall of this game because every deal ended up being a bit of a a bit tedious and a bit too much work in order to strike a deal you know you just want to make a simple negotiation just trade one card for one but of course the negotiator will stick their nose in and say you know you're not doing that which kind of just draws the game to a halt if it was a bit more clunky than it needs to be and despite sounding cool on paper it just does not work in practice so the rest of the game is okay pretty standard stuff it feels a bit too routine and a bit too predictable and what people are going to go for each round so ultimately i can't recommend it and it wasn't a great game despite having some signs of promise at number 15 i have unmatched cobble and fog so if you're a fan of my channel you probably know this isn't my kind of game that i'd normally like so this is a um a skirmish style game dating back to or this particular edition goes to 2020 with these characters and out of all the different characters and sets you can get this one is probably the most appealing to me because it has more it has the invisible man it has i think it has jacqueline hyde so has some quite interesting characters from you know from old books and folklore um and you are basically trying to
collide with each other and smash you know smash the hell out of each other and and knock the other person out but the characters are massively asymmetric you know if you think for example the invisible man can teleport towards these uh amongst these clouds so you don't really know where he's going to go where he's going to be and things like that you've got like um sherlock holmes as well which uses watson to his advantage and things and you've got like dracula who has these like harpies that can help him so i do like how asymmetrical it is the characters do feel very different but ultimately these style games just don't normally do it for me i was expecting a bit more gaming so this one where in fact you are basically just playing attack cards and using defense cards to counter those so pretty simple quite formulaic about the way it plays but i think in the right mindset if you just want a game of a bit of chaos then it's not a bad one and out of all these dueling games this one's pretty good nice production great artwork and the miniatures and stuff look really good on the table but yeah ultimately the gameplay is not something i tend to enjoy at number 14 i have ishtar the gardens of babylon this one dates back to 2019 and i believe is a bruno cathala game and i'm normally not the biggest fan of cathar games but this one was okay this is a tar placement game as you are collecting these tiles on this rondelle system you're trying to control these pagodas by having these biggest gardens surrounding them and you're placing tiles you can potentially overlap those tiles to build these chains um you can also try to fulfill these contracts by collecting gems on the board this one was perfectly fine it played relatively quickly quite smooth in the way it plays
i think sometimes it can be a bit lucky in terms of the the way that rondelle looks and just you know just when falling on your turn and you just have to have a really good tile that's been revealed and you're obviously going to draft that one so it was quite paint by numbers but the rest of the game was perfectly fine what you'd probably expect from a cathar game it just works well but ultimately doesn't excite me um tremendously but a fine game i'm at number 13 i have kanagawa which is another bruno cathartic game another pretty game as well so i can't deny um you know brutal cathar games normally do have a very high level of production this one no exception now this one goes back to 2016 and is a i suppose it's one of these games where you are collecting cards i'm almost in a coloretto style fashion as you're laying them out on these rows and columns and then you can kind of choose to cut your you know cut your turn off and draft one of those columns of cards and in order to contribute towards this um panoramic painting and you're scoring points in lots of different ways such as the characters you're collecting um the different seasons on those cars but i like the fact you can use these cars as dual layers so you are either using to contribute towards your painting for your scoring or you can use them as the bottom part of the game to add towards your art studio which will allow you to basically paint more paintings in your top part of the game so this just has some quite nice synergy between what you're going to use these cards for um lots of different ways you can score points and it has this kind of chicken mechanism to it where do you want to cut your losses now while you've got a certain criteria fulfilled or do you
want to push further for more points knowing that you can never go back on yourself to score those earlier points do so it did have quite some cool scoring mechanisms in it very nice production as i said gorgeous artwork but it was pretty standard fare in its gameplay nothing bad with it at all perfectly fine and a game i'd play any time but nothing i'd lean to take off the shelf and play despite it looking so pretty because the gameplay was pretty generic at number 12 another game from 2016. this is mr cabbage heads garden so this is pretty much a solo experience although you can play it um two player this one is a puzzly style game if you're acquiring all these different fruit and veg um in order to build your garden and you are trying to either paint the um put these pictures um sort of put these cards down which have different fruit and veg on them in certain patterns in order to score points at the end of the game um and you're also trying to bear in mind that every so often one of these neighbors which are these really interesting characters come in and kind of mess with your puzzle and make you kind of um you know mitigate them to try and get around them and the way you acquire these cards is quite interesting as you have three cards handed out to you at first you can either choose to pay b's to take from one side of the um row you can kind of take the one from for free or you can actually um take b's to take the other card so it has this kind of cash flow thing where if you you have to balance these bees so you have some in your kitty to spend in future rounds but bear in mind that if
you if you don't have any then you're not going to take certain cars if you have too many then you can't take certain cars either so it has this yeah this balancing thing but it works perfectly fine it only takes 10-15 minutes to play and for a solo experience i will every so often maybe take this off the shape and give it a go because it's quite satisfying it's very cute and it's a bit bit weird as well because the artwork is really out there and i'm a bit a bit head trippy so it's okay if you like your solo games and very simple ones this is probably one to look at at number 11 i have a stefan feld games with arena roma 2 and this one dates back to 2009 is actually actually a sequel to i think steffenfeld's first game just called roma this one is a strictly two-player dueling game as you have this board and you're allocating these cards to different spots on the board all relating to a different dice pit value so you've got your one two three four five and six you have additional spots as well which gives you money additional spots that lets you draw cards and you're basically allocating these cards and you're using them depending on the dice you've rolled and allocated to certain spots which will either hurt your opponents or let you score points in different ways um you know you've got to be careful about having money in your hand because cards you know you have to pay money to get cards down there and i like the way that the winning conditions of this game worked out because you could either win by having the most points when the points pull runs out or by making your opponent bleed all their points out of the game and that's really cool because when you attack their cut
of their your opponent's cards if there's ever a gap on those six spots or i think maybe even eight spots at the start of their turn then they are actually going to lose points for each of those empty slots so you want to be making sure that you're hurting your opponent but despite this one being relatively in your face and confrontational it didn't feel um that way to a point where it was you know it rubbed you the wrong way it was quite eurofied in the way that this was a dueling game so you don't normally get that and you and if there ever was a an example of what would stefan bell do if it was a head-to-head confrontational game then this is probably it my problem with this game was that it has the potential to go on too long sometimes games would be really rapid and quick and sometimes games would just outstand their welcome and drag on and it became a bit more of a wall of attrition which for a game this simple i didn't really want to drag on over half an hour at number 10 i have another game from 2021 this is streets and this one is almost a spiritual successor or a sister game to villagers and by sinister fish this one you are trying to build these streets made up of these tiles you've got these different shops and houses and they all score points in different ways depending on the other shops all the kind of pedestrians in that street and you can choose to kind of finish these streets by building um almost cars like opposite those roads so you're kind of building roads and streets that you know are kind of starting and ending and when they end you score all the points in those in those streets um they might say
score you know score x amount of points for each of um each hipster in your street or score x amount of points for each kind of commercial shop in that street so very simple probably what we'd expect with a a light tile placement game but it did have a slightly different mechanism to it where certain buildings would spawn pedestrians and then you can kind of move them around the board at certain points in the game to amp up your scoring um very quick you know very rapid game only takes about 20-25 minutes to play um so i thought it was fine i don't think it was great but what it does it does quite well and for an intro level title placement game this one is something a bit different i think maybe that pedestrian mechanism of you know moving those people around it was maybe reaching a bit too far trying to find something unique rather than finding something that really was was fun but the actual tarpon itself was was pretty good and what it did so not a bad game not a great game but it works quite well that is streets at number nine another game from 2016.
this is archaeology the new expedition by phil walker harding this is a simple set collection card game as you're trying to collect all these different artifacts and cache them at certain points um depending on the size of that set to get more and more points but the thing about this game is it has a real thread of pushy luck in it we're at certain points in the game where you draw this card and there'll be a sandstorm which means you have to lose half the cards that you've collected um which is obviously a really bad thing so you know do you want to get quick grabs and trade them in while they're worth the points or do you want to really gamble to get the bigger sets and maybe risk losing them in a sandstorm so for a simple game it did work quite well it wasn't too frustrating when there was a stand for sandstorm because you know it's in there and it really is a kind of a key part of the game is that pushy luck stuff um i had a slight issue with some of the setups in this game where um sometimes you'd have these bonuses where you could collect a bunch of cars which felt a little bit too powerful for me because ultimately all you're doing on your turn in this game is to draw a card on the top of your deck and maybe choose to submit uh submit a set so ultimately you're only acquiring one card per turn where sometimes you get these bonuses which would sometimes let you draw maybe eight cards into your hand straight away which felt a bit too strong so um some setups are way better than others and i want to try more of them before i can give my final opinion but the you know the key gameplay is very smooth it's fun and for a simple set collection game this one does work really well
at number eight i have cabo so cabo is a game that goes back to 2010 and on paper this game was something that i really would not like the look of i read the rule book i was very skeptical very apprehensive about how this was going to play in practice i thought oh this has a really strong element of memory to it which normally is a red kind of red flag for me i don't like memory games but in practice this game is remarkably fun and way better than i thought it would be so this one you have a bunch of cards in front of you of different values and the idea is that by the time someone triggers the scoring you want to have the lowest score so it's a kind of a golf style game where you want to score as few points as possible and the game will end once somebody reaches 100 points and all you're doing on your turn is you're drawing a card of this deck you're either using the power on it if it does have a power which could be maybe to look at your cards to look at our opponent's card or to swap them over or you are choosing to swap one of your cards with with an existing one to maybe try and get your numbers down or anything like that so a very simple game but i did like some of the twists on this one where if you triggered the end of the game by calling cabo everyone gets one more round and obviously you're doing that if you think you've got the lowest amount because if you've got the lowest amount and you do call cabo then you score no points but if you don't have the lowest amount and you call cabo you get all the points of your cards plus an additional 10. and then on top of that there are some really cool twists as well where you can kind of shoot for the moon and if you have the two zero cards and 213 cards
then all your opponents got 50 points and you scored nothing so there is that kind of outlying chance that you could get one of these really cool and scoring mechanisms and the game works way way better than i thought then i thought it would really fun and i'm really looking forward to trying this one at different player counts um maybe with some more inexperienced gamers because i think if it lands well then this one could really be a mainstay of my collection and to cater for that very lightweight gaming group now at number seven i have elements another game going back to 2010. this one is a micro card game where you are acquiring points and it almost has a strictly two player and it has almost a blackjack feel to it but rather than always going for the 21 you have like a moving target as you are have cards in your hand you can literally have cards in front of you which is going to be your score um or your or your points value that you're going to have for the round and you the idea is you ought to be having the value as close as you can to a value of cards in the middle because one of your abilities is to get rid of cards from your hand and to play them into the middle of the table which is the tucker you're aiming for but you could actually choose to take cards from the center and add them to your kind of tableau in front of you so you always want to be keeping this balancing act between the cards i have and the cards in the middle um a bit like cabo you could also trigger the scoring by calling it yourself and if you do have that you know if you are closer to that target than your opponent is then you're going to score the two points and it's a race to get to six points but additionally if you think you're going to lose you can actually say you know i'm retreating from this round and i'm only going to suffer a one
point defeat so a really small game i think it only has 18 cards in the game um and for what it does it does really well has some pretty interesting decisions here some quite um some quite agonizing decisions at times i don't think it's got the weight and the complexity and depth that a lot of other games do but what it does it works really well only takes again 15 20 minutes to play and gorgeous production this one has these massive tarot cards for some of the best card quality i've ever seen and it was good it was good i liked it and i think um it's interesting and it's different and i always like games that are different and elements certainly is that so number seven elements i'm at number six i have robert knights by rudiger dawn um so this one goes back to 2005. so it was actually one of his original games this one is an abstract tile placement game as you are placing tiles onto the board and at certain points when you play a castle onto the board you place a stack of these discs very much like istanbul and you can choose to divide those discs out by moving orthogonally out on that board dropping them off trying to control these different buildings and things to get points at the end of the game but certain terrains require you to drop more discs than others and you can even cover certain players discs up and once it gets to kind of four discs high then you can't actually touch that disc any up that tile anymore and it's locked in for final scoring pretty tactical and some good depth here i like the restrictions on the games you have to abide by this strict grid grid
restriction and it works pretty well you have to pace yourself not to spend all your discs too early and leave yourself some room at the end depending on when those castles are going to come out um really liked it works really well and i think objectively it's a really solid design um and i actually played this game several years ago in a different form called expedition luxor and i think i must have played it maybe in the wrong mindset and or maybe not in the best of moods um but this was way way better than i thought it was and i remember it to be um so yeah i'm actually looking forward to trying this on all the different player accounts um work seems to scale really well and um i like it really really solid game that's um massively underrated that is robert knights or alternatively expedition luxor at number five i have acro tiri i go back to 2014. this one a really weird game and another nice looking game as you are building this map of all these different islands i'm a really nice table presence by the end of the game this one has a stronger element of pickup and deliver as when you place these new tiles um you're spoiling these cubes on them which affects this market so it has a supply and demand thing where the more cubes on the board or certain color means that the value or demand for those is gonna ramp up and you're gonna get more coins if you pick up those cubes and deliver them back to the center tile and coins are really important because you need those coins to build these temples on islands um and which is basically one of the main ways you get points so it's a kind of a contract fulfillment game where you are
trying to abide by these or complete these cards which might say in order to complete this card you need one of these symbols to the north of your boat you need one of these symbols to the to the south maybe two of these symbols to the east and one of these symbols to the west and if you find the perfect island for that position then you can build these temples as long as you can afford it and then potentially get more actions as you go and place more things get more endgame scoring cards a really interesting game that works well another strictly two-player one so it does have a bit of a restriction or of course a very tight restriction who you can play this game with which might hinder it hitting the table but mechanically it works well um the game the decisions are good the scarcity in these islands are good i like the travel mechanism of this game as you have to build these routes to connect these islands together and go from port to port but sometimes you have to travel through other islands in order to access other ones so i do like the kind of network in this game and the way that the game does develop um my only app or the only kind of thing keeping it from getting my shield of quality is i think it does have the tendency to go a bit long at times and also sometimes or especially as the game goes on the map's getting bigger and bigger sometimes these contracts will just be automatically fulfilled they'll have the criteria there without having to do too much work or having to build towards it so sometimes the draw of the card is lucky than others but that's a very minor issue um i liked it and i think maybe with more plays it could even creep up to a shield of quality so i'm
stand by on that and i'll get my review out what i've solidified those thoughts so let's get into the top four games all of which have my shield of quality so at number four the first game of my shield of quality is rajs of the ganges the dice charmers so this one goes back to 2020. only in last year's game and of course this one is the roll and right version of raja's other ganges which is a very popular worker placement game which uses dice to do everything this one of course all takes place on a piece of paper um you are trying to build these roads to connect these buildings together and pass through them to get points and you're connecting roads to these bonus things you are traveling down the river um to get other bonuses as well so this one really did have the feel of the ball game almost the entire experience of the board game condensed down to a roll and right games but i actually like this one more than the board game because of that potential to get these really cool synergies these cool like domino effect combos you do this to get this to get this to get this to get this and you can have these really amazing turns where you get loads and loads done um additionally this one kept the scoring system in the original um range of the ganges where you want to connect your victory points to your coins and what they connect is going to trigger the end of the game and the winner is going to be the first person to do that i absolutely love that mechanism it should be used more and that was really the usp for the original version of the ganges and this one kept it so really happy with that probably maybe even my favorite role and
write game i've ever played so absolutely adore it i think it's great now check out my review if you like your role and rights and uh you know i'm skeptical on this one maybe you didn't even like the original game i think you might even still like the dice charmers very solid number four i'm at number three i have mermes and this one goes back to 2012 and is an older estari game about building and maintaining an ant colony so a really interesting theme as a worker placement game as all the worker placement really does take place on your individual player board um as you are acquiring new ants to send out onto the main board to maybe um kill insects to get points and food and you would be laying these pheromone tiles down which is kind of your income of resources um and you can build these routes in order to travel around faster as you kind of can skim through a whole bunch of these tiles as a single movement point um it has a quite nice scarcity in terms of grabbing the best land to get the best resources you want to be upgrading your colony so that you get you can place bigger pheromone tiles you'll be making sure you have enough food in your supply because at the end of every year you have to feed your workers or suffer negative points and of course you are trying to go for public objectives as well so despite really being multiplayer solitaire in what you're doing this one did have a very tight feel to it very little room for error in this one i'm not very much turns you get and manage managing each turn efficiently is a big part and doing well in this one and as i said not much room for error and if you do start
making errors you're going to find yourself falling behind if your opponent isn't doing so at first i can feel like you're not going gonna achieve anything but by the end of the game you normally do um a real nice tight game of spending a lot of plates but staying focused on the goals you're trying to achieve and a real nice throwback euro game that's really hard to do well at so love this one love the theme really solid gameplay and um yeah really enjoyed it so that is mermes at number three at number two i have another istari game this one is just yes um not the easiest game to pronounce but this one goes back to 2004 so quite an old game now and probably one of the um one of the most fun eurostar games i've played at least in terms of um you know wider appeal to it as you're trying to use these cylinders with all different numbers on them and you're using them to claim different spots on the board you're placing one of these cylinders face up and one face down each in each of your turns so you've got this element of bluffing as well where you can you might be using your zero cylinders to claim a region and your opponent might think it's one of your strong ones or vice versa and on top of all of that you are trying to manipulate this market so that all the gems you've collected by controlling these regions are going to be worth the most points and all the other people are doing this at the same time so you are going to use these cylinders to control these quarters of the board are you going to use them to manipulate the market and even those quarters of the board are divided up into three other sections where you can
get additional bonuses as well there's so many things you can go for here really interesting player cards that you can collect and give you powers um just a really smooth fun experience that i would highly highly recommend massively underrated criminally so and a real hidden gem so that is at number two and the best game i've played this month is a classic go back to 1997. this one is tigress and euphrates by reina knuczia so this one you might think why haven't i played so sooner simply because i had yellow and yanksy yellow and yangtze was the modern version of thai christian um with some very minor differences and i actually prefer tiger's new freighties um noticeably more than yellow galaxy you know not not loads more it was a tough decision to decide which one to keep i've decided to keep tigers and euphrates um because i think it's a little bit more intuitive so this one is a really strange game it's quite hard to wrap your head around at first but ultimately it is simple but again it's a bit different and the idea is you're trying to collect all these different points by placing tiles on the board and trying to control different cities and you have four different types of points all represented by different color and at the end of the game your lowest of those four different types is your final score so you want to be making sure that you're not neglecting anything and you want to make sure that all your points are balanced so that you score the maximum amount of points you can and this is quite a conflict-heavy game
you know very confrontational as you are um you know maybe potentially connecting these cities and having these big walls where you're contributing tiles to kind of stay in control of those cities and for each tunnel that you eliminate for your opponent you're going to get that matching colours points so very swingy at times very dynamic game as the borders state is constantly changing the tiles are popping up everywhere um really really great game an absolute classic one that i'll play for years and years to come updated so so well and um if it does appeal to you you don't mind a bit of confrontation in your games check out my review i was on the fence with it because normally i don't like too much too much conflict in my games but this one just works beautifully such a great game um probably one of the best quincy games i've ever played and that's saying something because i really like him as a as a designer and i know this one is regarded as one of his best and i can't disagree with that so yeah that's topically freight he's my best game that i've played in the month of october in 2021 so that's um 17 games plus two expansions there for you so if there's something interesting here as i said go check out those videos um if you have enjoyed the video uh please hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other content too i apologize if i feel a bit i sound a bit weird today i'm full of cold and i'm not very well um but hey c levy um so forever i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye now