My Top 10 Sandbox Board Games
Transcript
I don't like sand it's coarse and rough and irritating and it gets
everywhere hello everyone I'm Luke Hector and this is the broken me the show devoted to boarding card games where I do reviews top 10 and basically tell you not to buy any board games this is a top 10 list and it's been a while since I've done one actually because mainly I've just had to get a few reviews out a few podcasts and I've been kind of busy but uh you know I get the patreons to vote on top 10 list ideas so they can submit their own ideas and I put a few up I put them on a poll and then tend to do the choice say two free Maxs out of them you know based in the order that they vote for well I'm going slightly out of order this time sorry patreons uh the one that they voted for will be a collaboration with Mark monk from Ninja games that's what I'm hoping for so that will come soon as a live stream so I thought I'd go for the second most popular out of the list to do myself which is sandbox Euro games now sandbox is going to be a bit of a weird definition to go with but essentially we're talking things like open world do whatever you like tons of options play the game how you like I mean I like these games when they're on PC you know on those sort of games just being able to go right here I am how should I go about doing this you know things like valheim and that you know you know you can do what you like and yes you have to build up to a point but am I going to go do lots of hunting am I going to build my base here or over there I'm going to go hunting there I'm going to go into this Crypt you know you can decide what you want to do and they're always good and entertaining well for board games even though most of these aren't in the higher areas of my top 100 I still enjoy these games and I suppose the problem with sandbox games
is that they tend to be harder to get right because you've got to have all the options you've got to have all the variety but then you've got to make it a robust game as well and not make it too overly complicated and not make it too overly long and a lot of games in the sandbox genre tend to falter on one of those aspects and certainly a few of the i' say honorable mentions but a few of the mentions at the end of the video are certainly going to fit into that category but I generally do like these I like having a lot of options in games like here I am uh do I do this this this this this or this I don't know I could pick one but you know what I'm just going to try a mixture of the lot or I'm just going to do this so that that element of choice the element of choose your own path to Victory is always something that I really enjoy if the game's too linear and too constrained then that that irks me a little bit you know I like to have a little bit of freedom of choice before I get on with it just a quick word from the sponsor as a fellow gamer you'll understand this is unacceptable the solution head down to my new sponsor kendra. co.uk Kender stocks many of the hot new releases as well as some old hidden gems free delivery on orders over £30 further discounts on bulk purchases and even 5% of your spending refunded back to you as points to be used for further discounts down the line if you use the referral Link in the description below and sign up for a new account you'll get 5% discount on your first order over £60 so let's make gaps in your collection a ft of the past get down to Kender and start saving today thank you for listening and enjoy the rest of the video get on with
it number 10 is a game that I do enjoy Joy but I have not played it in a long time I've got it downstairs it's in a big box it's got the expansions so I can play it solo it's all complete it's got an inser it's as good as complete as can be and it is enjoyable the problem is it's a lot of rules to absorb a bit of a hog to get to the table and I just haven't done so in ages but when it comes to space games this is probably the daddy of the sandbox genre and that is zire Legends of a drift system this one basically just drops you into the middle of this Galaxy with a ship and you go do what you like you know are you going to be hunting down Pirates you're going to be the pirate yourself you're going to do lots of trade you're going to go explore lots of asteroid fields or mine ice comets or go do missions for various people you're going to be a good guy a bad guy you name it you have a lot of options here and you basically choose the path you want to follow in order to score I think I forget how the solo mode even works I believe you're trying to race to a certain amount of points before an AI effectively does it for you this is typically a game most people only play with two two players because of just how long it is when you play it in multiplayer and I don't get two-player games to the table so this is a solo only experience for me but yeah it definitely does give you that Spacey theme and if it was a little easier to get to the table and a bit easier to get the rules down then this would actually be higher on my list despite the fact that it has a high level of Randomness and yeah you expect that when you played this you're not playing this kind of super seriously really you're telling your space story and seeing how things
go and you're trying to mitigate a bit that luck but you know the randomness goes to come and kill you in certain Annoying Ways now and again don't try to fly through planetary Shields put it that way so yeah I'd like to play it more it just hasn't really hit the table but I certainly don't feel like culling it cuz I hope that one day I will get it back to the table and I'll probably enjoy it then but it squeezes on at number
10 but number nine is a fairly recent review I did it's an open box card game sandbox card game where you are exploring effectively kind of like an alternate history fantasy well actually not alternate history a future setting Nature Reserve you know it's all about national parks and conserving the environment after it's all gone to pot this is earthborn Rangers which I believe is literally behind my back right there I haven't managed to continue with it as much as I would like since I reviewed it but you know I've gone back to it every now and again but this one is a card game you have your deck of cards with your character you customize your character deck slightly depending on which kind of path you want to follow and then you have a starter selection of cards but then as you go through all your encounters you'll tweak your deck with different cards and upgrade and experience and all that but where you go is pretty much up to you really I mean there is a main plot but how you go about the main plot is still open to some kind of flexibility and even then it's still pretty you know liberal as to how you want to approach it but the side quests that come up and all the stuff you find could have you going off into all sorts of different directions cuz once you're done at the initial location you have a big map in order to decide right do I want to go north south east or west and you basically just decide which way you want to go you know what I just FY going this way this time and see what happens there and every time we go into a location the deck of like the kind of the location deck is tweaked to be based on that the terrain type of the location and maybe
any landmarks maybe people and you'll explore through them you know you'll have the different hazards for terrain and animals come across but then there'll be people of interest that you come across only in that particular location it's definitely a approach how you like it game I haven't had a chance to get out to the table much lately and it certainly could have maybe had a better rule book the rule book was definitely not the best with this one compared to a lot of other games on this list but it is a very good formatic solo Venture I don't think I would see much Point playing this in a group I mean I have I have played it in a group and it is fine but I've played it it fine solo I suppose you could play it two-handed or play it two player that would be fine three and four player seems a little bit of excess but it's a good little sandbox one if you want to if you want to play something that's more environmentally friendly I guess is the phrase but it's just pretty solid all around just haven't again got it to the table much okay that's a start that's very Earth
friendly my number eight is a theme that I don't even tend to go mad for really it's not that I watch movies for apart from maybe two and even then that's mainly because they have other elements to them I don't really play PC games based on this theme I haven't really played any other games based on this theme bar one that I can think of so you know Western are not typically my thing Clint East would never wor anything like this Western Legends on the other hand though is a very good Sandbox game I've got way too much content for it though which has probably hindered my ability to actually get it played more often because it's allow the rules to absorb when you start thrown in all the expansions and I need to find a way to store it better I have yet to find a way to do so uh but uh hopefully I'll be able to figure something out because the last thing I want to do is buy that stupid big box the one that's ridiculously expensive and has a crappy insert in it yeah I don't want to do it that way I've got to find some way to store it in the original box you know in a in a way that's easy and quick to set up but yeah you want a western Sandbox game this is basically your bread and butter I mean what do you want to do prospecting for gold you want to go hunt band Bandits you want to be a bandit do you want to be a law enforcer or not do you want to go rob a train do you want to go play poker high stakes low stakes you know go to a different city maybe train to another area rustle up cows um you know do various missions there's so much you can do in this game it's unreal particularly with the expansion that opens up the extra map and you do whatever you want to get the legendary points that you need what items do you want do you want to get a really good
horse a really good shotgun really good revolver you is are you trying to be the best law enforcer or the most renowned Infamous Bandit or are you trying to be the best Gambler in the in the cas I love being The Gambler I love going down that route because I like poker I love Tex and Holden poker played it a lot when I was younger and I love doing the poker in this game because it's just fun just doing it it really just get you in that mood but again ease of play is what hurts it and brings it back down this list and you're noticing this is a theme with a lot of these sandbox games they have so many rules that it's quite hard to get them to the table often unless you do it frequently and these aren't games that typically tend to come out frequently but Western Legends makes for a good good a very good convention experience where somebody like people are already prepared for what's to come and you get a reasonable size group although I don't recommend going about four I think anything above four players is a complete uh waste of time and even then four requires you to know the game well and maybe play it with less of a cap on the victory condition fre is a pretty good number though and yeah it's just a really good valid game you know if you want a western game that sandbox this is the one you go
for number seven is probably the most recent review I've done or is it no actually I think I did this one before from Rangers but not by far this is you know there was a game that came out in January called well a Kickstarter it was fulfilling around then called myth wind check out my review video for more details as to why I don't believe that's a game you should go for uh yeah didn't give it the highest rating ever but I compared it to another game which I think did a similar thing but much better and that is Lands of gaer this is from snowdale design uh and this one uses their cool like really cutesy animals with the lovely artwork in that but this is an open World sandbox Story game and we're talking super light Story game I mean there is not a lot of rules in here your character has free slots for items and you keep chopping and changing these as you go through the game there is an app that assists you with the story elements of which you typically get a choice like do you have this keyword if you do you can do this if not try this choice or this choice and you've got these little it's cool little skill tree thing where throughout the game you can constantly keep sort of tweaking what skills you've got like are you really good in survival are you really good at fighting you really good at negotiation that sort thing and you just basically pick a route go that way do some light side quests and tell your own story that's pretty much it there's no overall game Ark you just play essentially the equivalent of like like a week in game time and you see whether you've got enough reputation to you know win or at least do well at the end of it but other than than that you just carry
on and on and on you know mith win tried to do something similar but that one basically got you to do boring Euro mechanics over and over and over again with no end this one at least is getting you to you know do lots of cool little short stories that are nice and straightforward you know and don't there's very little setup in this game the save features really good so you can whip this one out Fair really quickly I mean so far I've done three games that are a nightmare to get set up and played Lanza Galer is not a quick sorry not a difficult one to get set up and played if I want to bring it out now I could I could bring it out and learn it in pretty much like 10 minutes just to recap the rules and then I'm of and get going again and then I could rinse and repeat as many weeks as I like if you're looking for light storytelling this is definitely I think the one to go for it's just such a smooth elegant design with enough variety to keep you finding something just a little bit new each time whether it's changing locations on the board or just equipping yourself with different items and you can kind of cherry pick how you want to do I mean at the moment I think I'm pretty good at survival and negotiation I think that's the two I've focused on and sort of ranged attacks but you know you could be a melee brawler you could be you really good at I don't know is science one of them I forget well oh no I'm a very observant uh range specialist yeah that's what I am observant and ranged so you could be a melee survival expert you know you could be focused on other as on other SK skills and it just gives you a lot of freedom and a lot of choice which is what you want from a Sandbox game and yet this one doesn't burden you with a 100 rules to work out how you do
it right we are done for the moment with story games and to be honest uh I must admit there's not many of those left on the list you know most of these are Euro games in the sense and yes you can have a Sandbox Euro game because it can be a Euro game where it gives you so many options it's ridiculous this is again kind of a Euro hybrid you are technically telling your own story and you can tell the story how you like but at the end of the day you are pushing cubes around a lot and essentially choosing which card you want to get so it's not necessarily a story based roleplay game although you could roleplay it to an extent this is Vindication Vindication from Orange nebula is basically the sandbox Euro that a lot of people are aware of uh you basically have these attributes free primary free second your cubes are in these which dictate your own character's attributes and you're trying to not be a scumbag anymore you landed on this island and you're a scum bag and you got to try and vindicate yourself how you do it entirely up to you you have all these different color cards different categories purple Relic items orange monsters to go kill green personality traits to develop uh and then you've got the companions for blue yellow and red you know melee fighters versus you know spiritual survivalists and maybe versus scientific and intellectuals and you can do what you want you know do you want to be do you want to have a really fast mount in r mofra in which case go ahead and do that do you want to beef yourself up as a melee brother with a bunch of like Melee characters and by all means go do that do you are you happy with slow speed fast speed up to you do you
want to get loads of Relic items that you know that you can power up and you know give you really cool abilities or do you want to just get a bunch of personality traits that give you like more scoring opportunities or some other cool Powers maybe I'll go kill some monsters I mean I've got a bit of Courage I could go kill that moner that would give me a nice scoring thing that I'm going for there's so much Freedom here you do what you want to do based on the attributes that you've got and the whole Euro side of the game is micromanaging those attributes in such a way that it's efficient it's a really solid game with a variable game end you've got different end game triggers and different ones will come out as the game progresses until eventually one is met so the game could take 40 minutes it could take a couple of hours which H is not always the best thing I admit with some games but here I actually don't mind it so much you know you know it's coming so it doesn't necessarily creep up on you unexpectedly you know with the exception of when a new one gets revealed and somebody's already done it although the likelihood of that the likelihood of that is pretty much nil never really happens but yeah it's got a few too many expansions to it I have not even tried Chronicles or whatever the new one is that adds more story aspects cuz frankly I need to relearn all the rules again and it's a little bit of a bloated mess at the moment so it does have some problems this is another one of those occasions where bloat actually hurts the game a bit but Bas set Vindication is still really good fun you just need to find your your set of mini expansions where you vary the locations that you're happy with stick to those and then stop varying the game but there's certainly a
bit of content that have come from the kickstarters like hamlets and things like that where I could not care less if I use them or not and they're just basically sat there going to waste but at some point really must get this out with the Chronicles expansion and see what it's like but if you played with that expansion I'd like to know your thoughts in the comments and tell me what it's like is it as good as it could be or is it a waste of time let me know your
thoughts my number five I would have been castrated if I hadn't put this on the list yes a lot of people would certainly have expected this because it's on my shelf it's one that I've really enjoyed and certainly with the expansion unfinished business it got a lot lot better you of course I needed to have some kind of sandbox star Wars game on my list and of course alter Rim is the choice to go with you do want to get it with unfinished business though it's definitely lacking in a few areas if you play just the base set not just on the variety front but also with a couple of quality of life improvements that the expansion brings but with the expansion you can now travel around the sectors a lot easier you have more variety with the cards you have ambition paths that you can go through which give you kind of like a a personal story arc and a little bit of guidance for how to play but it's still effectively a sandbox Star Wars game I mean you are a bounty hunter I'm the disintegration machine want to gu disintegrated getting me integrated that's dengar's Mel you're going to hunt people for bounties you're going to side with the rebels or the Imperials a bit more maybe uh do some deals with the Huts you're going to grab yourself a load of cool gadgets and items and weapons you're going to upgrade your ship and if so what's your fancy you want Boba Fett Slave one do you want the Millennium Falcon do you want ig88 you know killer Raptor Droid ship I forget what it's called you know you you can kind of decide exactly what kind of bounty hunter you want to be you're just carrying on until you get to a certain amount of Fame points and whoever gets there first is the winner so yeah not a game I recommend playing with a lot of players I mean I've played it with two and it's been good fun three would probably be the absolute Max I
recommend but I've played this more as a solo game particularly with the expansion included and the solo mode is actually a pretty solid Affair you know the AI will go around and will be slowly leveling up its Fame so you do have somebody to race against effectively but you get to play the game and tell what kind of Star Wars story you want it's I really do recommend you get unfinished business though if you if you try it with just the Bas set I worry that you might not like it as much as you could and you missing out on some good quality of life improvements but if somebody is able at a convention to show you outter rim with the expansion included and teach you the game not something I'm going to be able to do at the games Expo I'm afraid but uh certainly if somebody else can do it then by all means try and jump in on one of those because I can't think of a better Star Wars Sandbox game this is the way
number four we're back to a Euro big pure Euro with a ton of options this is the direct killer of its predecessor which a lot of people still really enjoy and I respect but Juju it's restrictiveness it's a Reliance on having to go get children more workers and stuff it it puts me off wanting to play that particular game kerer killed agria I'll give you a pie of yeah that's already caused a bit of a Ruckus you controversial hav we pass this but yeah CER is a pure Sandbox game which is sitting right there with forgotten folk do not get the second one the fish was it forgotten fiends or whatever it's called I forget but yeah the second expansion to cero with the Orcs do not get it check out my review video to find out why but trust me you do not want that expansion forgotten fol though pretty good way to add some cool asymmetric powers that can kind of guide new players will just give you some more variety but even just basic Cera I mean you have got all those buildings that you can like choose from you've got the different like uh roots to take you know and it's all open and uncapped which is the better thing because Agricola caps you on all your stuff you need to get a bit of everything which means you're not truly differentiated and if you end up with too many vegetables for example it caps you on how many points you get Cerna doesn't do I want to do nothing but Farm wheat and have all the wheat ever well good go do that you won't have a cap on points do you want all the cows
do you want all the donkeys do you want just a sheep farm you know okay fine do you want to do a bit of variety then great do you want to go outside or stay in your cave that's entirely up to you I had a really weird one where I managed to get all six of my workers out as an albino dwarf uh like faction so I got all my workers and never ventured outside that was a weird game I was playing but again I can choose to do that and see what happens you know I was doing a lot of donkey mining so i' got a lot of Mines up and running a few donkeys use gems to get me pass some stooks but yeah I was doing quite a lot of that with a bit of adventuring on the side you can choose what you want to do with this and with the Forgotten folk you then have the asymmetric factions that give you some restrictions and some other benefits and they make you play in lots of different styles as well it just truly is one of those games that you can do whatever you feel like although a surprise to hear in terms of how many options you have it's still pales comparison to some other
Euros right but number three you might think that this is not a Sandbox game but I had a deep think about this and I think it is so ha now this is a euro Game Y through and through it definitely has a theme and certainly an interesting setting a very unique setting compared to others but I believe this is a Sandbox game because you have so many options as to what you want to do and how you choose to live your life life is entirely up to you oh yes I consider Pursuit of Happiness there to be a Sandbox game and I mean it's it's got to be surely because you have all the options in the world yes you are trying to get the most long-term happiness points but you can decide where you're going to get a bunch of projects and do tons of those are you going to hoard items are you going to go on lots of activities you going to get a job you don't have to you can get a job if you want do you want a little job do you want to own your own little store do you want to be like president of the United States you know really demanding job do you want a girlfriend or a boyfriend up to you you can have two partners if you really want although good luck with that it's pretty hard to maintain it it's time SN SN can't we just kle but you can you know decide I'm not going to have a partner at all you know I don't need a partner or a job I'm just going to do paper rounds the rest of my life and you know have a nice simple life where I just do lots of little projects like grow a bonsai tree or become an activist or the leader of a biker gang and the ninja you know all these weird things I can be a health freak I'm just going to do swimming I'm going to do running I'm going to do yoga and I'm just going to be the healthiest man alive by the time I die you can do whatever you like to
get those long-term happiness points and of course there's an efficiency to it you know youve got the free resources interactivity influence and book knowledge and you have to micromanage these resources in order to find an efficient path to getting lots of points but there are lots of paths available and you can just do what your fancy and that's just a Bas set throw in the expansions as well particularly Community which I really like and you've got like the you know doing stuff for your local neighborhood as well again more choices more options and sometimes you'll do it because it's efficient sometimes you'll do it because it's just thematically amusing this is such a great Euro game one of my favorites one of the most unique themes out there for a Euro effectively The Game of Life as a Euro game as I call it but it's just one of my favorite Euros that I love to play particularly in its big box form where I've got so many cards they're spilling out and those jumbo resources so everything looks like you know massive hourglass and stuff it's oh it's never going to leave the collection I love it too much and this is if I play it multiplayer or solo though granted four player is a bit long three player I think is a good cap two-player works great but even solo Pursuit of Happiness is pretty good you know you have to reach a certain point target and achieve some goals so it's not just beat your own score but then you have all the options available as to how you want to do it it's a Sandbox if you dispute so then please let me know why it's not a Sandbox but I feel I shouldn't be getting a lot of blowback with this one oh God you're killing me my number two and my number three
could have probably switched around you know it was kind of either orw at this point this is another space game and you're probably thinking ah finally we can have the space game that I like Mr Twilight imp no it's not Twilight Imperium all right we'll talk about that later this is my go-to space game and it's definitely a Sandbox I mean you can approach it how you like there's a lot of different options it's been sitting there for ages is you know it's there it's empires of the Void 2 of course I mean I loved the original empires of the Void second version even better but yes you're trying to get the most victory points but how are you going to do it I have a colony ship right here's a bunch of alien planets do I go conquer them their resources or do I do negotiate with them have a peace treaty and we have now allies to use and combat all for their abilities uh do I upgrade all my texts there's a lot of text on my board I've got three different types of buildings I can build do I spam a ton ofies or do get a little bit of everything you know each has their pros and cons do I go spread out all over the place and just occupy a load of little planets do I do a bunch of missions there's a bunch of delivery escort missions or I could just do these other missions there's all sorts that you can do and I feel like it's kind of right for an expansion actually to add even more options I don't need like necessarily more complications but I think an expansion to empires of the Void 2 would be due you know add more cards just add more cards for variety you could add maybe a different couple extra planets with new factions that could work and maybe just one or two other ways for you to score points I
would be totally down for some extra content for it but even with the box as it is I mean it's not a small box you can see it right there it's got a lot in there and this one just gives me that feeling of exploring space and meeting new alien factions a lot of space games don't do this I mean zire does that to a point although you're not really negotiating with other factions or speak species you're more just flying around the Galaxy here you actually see the faces of the thing of the creatures that you're either conquering or negotiating with hello my baby hello my honey it just creates kind of like more of a a Galaxy full of life you know I would certainly love to play this as a kind of app version I think there actually was an app version for this but I hear it wasn't very good um yeah a way to play the board game on Steam and yeah the last I heard about it was that the app wasn't very good so it be interested to know if anybody's got any feedback on that one but it's not something been desperate to you know look up because of mainly time but yeah sorry Twilight fans you're not on the list empires of the Void 2 is just accept
it and my number one of course most of you have called this it's the ultimate Euro sandbox there is no sandbox Euro that I think that I can think of that is got more stuff in here than this I mean if you know of any then by all means let me know cuz I would certainly want to try it but I already mentioned the effective predecessor to this one or at least from my perspective of playing it this is normally restricted to two players but it can be expanded to three this has more options in a euro game than anything I have ever encountered and you might be thinking Feast of Odin but no not on my list although it could qualify as a Sandbox Euro I of course mean fields of all fields of all is just a fun Euro I love playing this most mostly is a solo game because I don't tend to get two players to the table although playing this with free player is still good fun if you can find a table big enough to host everything but it's just the swarm of options it's beat your own score when you play it solo yeah I know that's a bit of a pain you know rankings this it's not my favorite way to have like a I would have liked there to have been some kind of an AI I mean I think there is one I think there's like a restriction on where you can go work a placement wise that's about it but wow what do you want to do okay let's see I want to uh Peete off my land and you know cook bread okay fine maybe I'll grow some animals and slaughter them for food maybe I'll Slaughter some cows and make leather jackets out of them maybe I'll extend my diyes all the way so I can reach the shoreline I could grow some wheat grow
some flax uh maybe grow some uh forests you know so I've got a good wood supply you know what my tools aren't particularly good I could level up a few of those tools the local villagers could do with some food and some supplies you know what I'll make some Woolen coats go trade it with the Villagers down there that'll give me some points uh could uh build some Les I could do with another cart you know maybe a few wagons that would allow me to get to the villagers easier um I could maybe let's see I mean cooking bread is nice and so slaughtering animals but maybe I should just grow lots of Wheat and just have that as my food source that is doable uh there buildings over there well I could construct a castle or to maybe a couple of barns you know a couple of things like that wow this game has just got so much in it and that's before you even add the te and trade expansion now now I can deal with tea now I can export to different you know a few different countries now I can build fishing boats now I can build ditches around my dikes you name it this game has it you are so bere of choice it is somewhat overwhelming for new players but it's got a brilliant system where you can pick pretty much any route you like and there's a good chance it will score you a decent amount of points I've had very tight finishes with this now granted you obviously are trying to play more efficiently than the opponent but you don't have to think I suppose I should go with the animal and slaughtering strategy CU that is way better than the uh growing wheat and baking bread strategy not necessarily everything scores you points it is a point salad all the way everything is points even
half points and so you can pick whichever route you want to do we won't know who's doing best until the very end and then it's a tight finish for those scores it's got so much options though oh man I mean does any Euro game have more options than this I need to know cuz if so I need to play it because I would certainly like to see about that you know a lot of people would be thinking Feast of Odin Feast of Odin's fine it would be in my teens I guess it's got a lot of different work of placement spots and you can certainly decide how you want to go and approach it it just would never make my top 10 Fields ofal though whole it doesn't need an expansion it's got an insert certainly needs one of them uh but it's just all the options I love it I love it I love it and this is one that even though I don't get to the table as often often as I would like to the desire to get it out is always there I'm always noticing it and going when can I play fields of all again that would be really solid but maybe I should get it out as a free player one time and have a you know cool setup with that CU I feel like I want to show more people this game it's just one of those that is such a good amount of fun to have all those choices so my number one easily fields of okay just a few mentions I mean some of these are kind of honorable mentions although on this occasion I think it's more that these are games that I either like or don't particularly like and I just need to explain My reasonings I haven't got that long on the camera battery uh but let's see sleeping Gods I'm kind of done with Campaign games as I mentioned in my recent podcast I like
it it's a pure sandbox through and through and it is an enjoyable game I just don't know if I'm desperate to commit myself to another run through after you you know when you've got to control nine characters as a solo player distance guys I feel might have done a better job of it but I just don't know if I want to commit to again another campaign game I'm just like can we just have scenario games now so I do like the game and I do recommend it but it's just not one that I'm going to play again Feast for Odin I've already mentioned gives you all the action spaces like 40 to 60 odd action spaces it's kind of ridiculous but you know the theme is kind of lost when you're basically playing Tetris with all these this loot that you've got and like taking up islands and stuff so it's a very abstract mechanical game which stops me wanting to to play it on a regular basis particularly as it goes way too long when you've got three to four players this is really the one that you just want to play solo frankly because there's not really much incentive for other players there yeah the worker placement might block some spots but the solo mode already has a very good way of simulating that so the need to want to play this with lot players just isn't really there um some people suggested Scythe I'm not sure if Scythe is a Sandbox game I mean I suppose you do have some options but you're mainly going down one of four routes you know you're going to go full buildings you're going to go full um you know sort of combat power you're going to go uh full e um economy um or are you going to do uh what's the other one um that's pretty good oh yeah or get the uh the things that allow you to do stuff with your neighbors you know those ones I forget what they're called the uses food but
you there's not a huge amount of variety in that one for path so I'm curious as to whether that counts so I wasn't prepared to stick it on this but even then it wouldn't make my top 10 uh feudum feudum definitely a Sandbox game you have got a lot of options as to what you want to do in feudum and really love the guild mechanis uh The Guild mechanics in this I think they're brilliant but the rule book is a mess there's a lot of rules to learn the graphic design is not particularly good I hear they're doing another addition of this I don't think it will be enough to bring me back because I just think that they're going to just have it still bloated with too much in it I mean the mini expansions are enough to tell you that they really need a second edition where they can keep that cool Guild system but streamline it down cut out the fact and make the rule book solid and you would have a banger that I would want to have in my collection as it is this is a game that I certainly enjoyed playing but would never want to own uh Mage Knight uh do I need to say much more about Mage Knight I hated it when I played it years and years ago I might like it a little bit more now if I tried it again but I have no incentive to I don't want to play it so there you cut me deep shrick you cut me real deep just now merchants and Marauders I played it once or twice I think ages ago it's a Sandbox Pirate game definitely fits the scenario but I don't remember liking it that much or at least not not enough that I would want to own it I thought this is fine this seems a little bit unbalanced like I feel like doing like fighty stuff is more better than doing the other stuff I couldn't remember which way around it was um the rules were a little bit clunky you know it needed a bit of streamlining in places
but it still was a fairly okay game but just not one that I was desperate to own um or you know try and get to the table I mean it's quite a long game definitely wouldn't want to play this with a lot of players so I don't know if I've really got the incentive to buy it and relearn it I just remember playing a mates copy uh Twilight Imperium look Twilight Imperium has some good stuff for it but there is no game that can justify an 8 hour time limit to play this game it's just ridiculous you know the game is a bit of a luck Fest in some respects it's pretty much a case off right everybody go cluster in the middle on mechor Rex and some people get left out and the others just duke it out in the Middle with combats that take forever and and until until somebody sneaks to 10 points but the game is fine and I like the variety in it I just would rather play inscription if I want that theme you know just for a cool rolling right but no game deserves to take like 6 to eight hours there's no game at all I mean hegemony takes me a good 4 hours to play that one justifies its length but even then if it went any longer I think I would go a bit mad and it's already quite long as it is but 6 to 8 hours I mean when I see people from my Portsmouth cup my Portmouth club play this they play these events and they start at like 10:00 in the morning and they're not finished until like the early evening and I'm just like no game justifies this I would be bored out of my head I wouldn't be invested and if I was losing which you can do I mean you can have a bad start with those really dumb expiration tokens that basically go
oh something kills one of my ships oh great there's not much I could do about that that sucks oh you got extra resources well you've got a leg up and much like Stellaris lots of little things you get early then compound into the late game but yeah if you're losing Twilight impan you've got no chance of winning you're stuck there for a long time just going through the motions pseudo knockout is not enjoyable in Long games people so no I would never put this on my top 10 and then finally Firefly I respect Firefly I love the TV show I like the movie but Firefly the board game is a very long and very random luck Fest it's it's got the fee and it's got the coolness of oh what do I want to do I want to get these jobs upgrade my ship get these people you know can I get Kaye on my ship that' be fantastic you don't I want to work with these people but it's too long I mean this game goes on for hours and hours and hours particularly when you've got expansions thrown in and it is mostly a luck Fest you know your game is not won because of skill it's or like making meaningful choices it's usually won just by whether you're lucky enough to get through a lot of these missions particularly the ones that are based on essentially a die roll it's you know if if it was a bit more deterministic and a bit more controllable I would probably really like this game but as such I respect it for doing Justice to its theme certainly is doing Justice on that respect and it's got a lot of fans and I can see why they would like it but just doesn't suit me really you're going to burn in a very special level of hell so yeah there's a list of sandbox games if there are any other sandbox games by all
means get them in the comments I'll be interested to know I've heard about Lost Valley never played it never even seen a copy there's a game I would really like to try that showed up in some sandbox charts called bios uh Manu no bios Mega for Mega forer or something it's something like that I don't know it's a bios game I've not heard of this uh particular type of game but it's meant to be this really heavy big one that's kind of got like a dominant species vibe to it where you you started off as like vertebrates or primordial or whatever and then you spread out and you I don't know bios up I'm not entirely sure I forget what its name is it's some weird name beginning with m but I would like to try that game if somebody show shows me at a convention the theming of it sounds right up my street and if it is a true Sandbox game like it claims to be it definitely would get my vote on that respect so yeah definitely one on my try list but yeah will I ever see it I have no idea because I certainly don't know if you can buy it pretty sure it's not available anywhere but by all means somebody tell me if it is I might even look into it but uh there any other sandbox ones I can think of there weren't that many and I can't think of many off the top of my head but I'm sure you lot have got some suggestions so by all means get them in the comments so that's it for me on this episode of the broken me if you like what you see then please thumb it up on YouTube and let me know your comments as I described check out the video reviews I have done for some of the stuff I mentioned uh let's see which games have I done um I have definitely done Star Wars outter Rim unfinished business you definitely want to check that out I reviewed earthborn Rangers I reviewed lands of gaer I've uh I think I reviewed zire Legends of a drift system but I'm not entirely sure
you might have to look that one up I've definitely done videos on the pursuit of happiness like complete comprehensive guides to the expansions and that's a biom means check out those uh but yeah there's quite a lot I've done so by all means if you want to find out more details on some of those games look them up and see if I've done a video for them until next time regardless of whether you want to play in the sand pit for a long time or not it's still only a game so bye for now