The Optimal Board Game for Every Social Situation (HOLIDAY 2024 EDITION)
Transcript
you don't watch marriage story on a first date do you you aren't going to Christmas dinner and putting on terrifier 3 as the holiday flick for your grandma just cuz it's a guy in a stic costume and what I mean by that is a claimed media doesn't necessarily translate into a good time in every social situation so why are you planning on bringing Mage night or on Mars on your family's Thanksgiving game night it's not hard to understand when you go on BGG and look at those top 100 games these are the games that are ranked by well Geeks these are the ones that people who are Enthusiast pick for a game night with other enthusiasts who want to play games these aren't the games you play when it's an engagement party for your cousin's fourth marriage and everyone just wants to survive the night peacefully all social situations have certain expectations and a goal in mind and I've been thinking a lot about what games fit what social situation best and with the holidays coming around there's a lot of potential awkwardness that comes if you just bring your highest rated game and think it's going to be a slam dunk every time and I'm sorry dude but your semi- literate Doom scrolling brain rot skibbidy cousin doesn't want to play a 14-point game of ti4 for 12 hours so for this holiday season I'm talking about the best game for every kind of social situation and let's get into it friends Miss characteristics High familiarity between
people it's a gathering that reinforces long-term relationships really to reconnect and reminisce together there's lots of in jokes Nostalgia conversations about life ah friends miss the non-denominational winter holiday of Millennials for this I think wavelength is the best possible board game to play wavelength has a lot of good things going for it right away the box is aesthetic and fits right in with perusing the shelf of a Nordstrom Rack it looks like belongs at a party and it's reminiscent more of a friendly trendy dating app than a board game it immediately shrugs off any preconceived notions of what a board game is from people who might have only had negative experiences of being yelled at by their parents and Monopoly the setup is almost instantaneous and it plays a flexible player count while allowing people to drop in and out with minimal pain all of this put together is perfectly suitable for a flaky group of friends who want to lying and dying their lomin debt away for a night wavelength is a team-based game that has one player acting as the psychic who knows where the bullseye is they pick between two potential prompts they spin a dial behind a hidden screen take a look at where the bullseye is close a dial and then they give a clue to their team on what they think best represents where that Bullseye is then it's up to the rest of the team to move this red little marker hit that sweet sweet fourpoint mark for for example if the prompt is casual versus formal and
the clue the psychic gives is sweatpants the rest of the team has to determine how the psychic view sweatpants from a casual to formal lens the thing is it's based off the team's interpretation of the psychic's take on the clue so if that particular psychic wore sweatpants at his graduation it might read that sweatpants might be a little bit on the formal side teams have to dive deep into the psyche of the psychic and digging into their own interpretation of that person likewise there's a lot of logic jockeying and bartering teams will try to logic things out like by saying sweatpants are more formal than pajamas but less formal than jeans right then when the dial is finally revealed and it reveals a full-on Miss there's laughter and the psychic will desperately explain how sweatpants have never been formal and he's just a really casual dude it's a lot of fun trying to decipher what a psychic means when they provide a certain clue and the subjective nature of the game makes people think about each other as individuals which is why it's great for friend groups wavelength at its core is a mechanism to get to know one another through in jokes playing off pre-established relationships and understandings and thinking about new facets of people it isn't unusual for the psychic to say something like my older brother or high school English and people who have shared the same experience can pinpoint exactly what the psychic means by that
on the other hand new information about people can be shared in a positive environment much like a communal therapy session with friends in other words wavelength reinforces common understandings of shared experiences it encourages an understanding of one another in a fun light-art way which is why I think it's perfect for close friends at a holiday party next up we have family therapy over a turkey dinner car characteristics of this are a very high familiarity between people siblings children parents grandparents everyone knows each other very well but there's also a high range of age groups between people there's also a high potential for unintended arguments the goal is really just get through the evening with everyone liking each other there's really nothing quite like going home for the holidays there's always tons of food familiar faces and plenty of unsettled childhood resentment and sometimes finding the right game to play with your family can feel like navigating a Minefield and I find that poetry for neander talls somehow manages to thread the needle and provides the perfect medium for General pleasantness poetry for neander tals is a team based game that's all about using one syllable words while trying to get your team to guess the correct word for example if you have the word hat you can give the hint wear on head and then if your team guessed correctly you get a point if you're feeling frisky you can go for the
three-pointer which in this case would be top hat and say something like tall wear on head and if you mess up and say a word with unnecessary syllables or Rhymes or gestures then you get bonked by an inflatable Club it's perfect for bonking your rival sibling for the time they took your SpongeBob Gogurt but that said the magic of poetry for neander hols is that it elegantly makes aan seem smart and stupid at the same time the innate playfulness of using one syllable words really helps with creating an immediately light-hearted easy to laugh atmosphere there really isn't anything to get too mad about and any frustration is quickly alleviated with a bonk the reality is that this inflatable Mallet is the stress relief valve that moves the game from competitive team-based nightmare into a more comedic familyfriendly game I mean just look at this thing it's not meant to be taken seriously and then you add on stringing together one syllable words desperately trying to lead people to an answer it's just all innately funny and light-hearted it can be especially hard to make a game that works across Generations but word games tend to be the most successful since most people have some experience with word-based games like taboo Scrabble wle or even crosswords it isn't hard to teach something like poetry for neander tals also since poetry for neander simplifies what words can be used it does try to create an even playing field across
Generations younger kids and adults can match against each other without feeling unfair for either side this simple concept and the de evolution of language makes for a crowd-pleaser that works perfectly for a family dinner all of a sudden your grumpy parents are smiling and siblings can finally Bop each other with an inflatable Mallet and there's no fear of meltdowns or retaliation so yeah this simple premise this simple game works perfectly for families that might be a little bit of a dicey situation when it comes to game night next up we have office parties the characteristics are you want to maintain some semblance of professionalism the game should be quick to teach in general you want something that's a little bit of a team building exercise to keep upper management happy great here we go again the office party it's often another excuse for some strange and surreal team building exercise from some sea Suite executive who just came back from his off-brand Bohemian Grove retreat at the very least the big league designer of Vlada chav decided to give us Mercy from his Heavy Hitters and provided us a game that's easy to teach engageing and overall a rather palatable experience and it's the perfect office game for people who want nothing more than to leave their daily prison Coden names is an ultra popular board game about giving secret Clues to to your teammates to pick certain words and find all their secret agents before the enemy team while actively trying to avoid civilians
enemy secret agents and the Assassin to play one player the Spy Master will say a word and a number for example Taco 3 it is then up to the rest of the team to find the three words that the Spy Master thinks relates to Taco like it might be a food or a vegetable or a meat or Mexico or any various combination that the team might be going for once a word is guessed from the 25 possible choices it is then revealed as a correct or incorrect guess if it's correct it reveals one of the team spies and once all the team spies are contacted that team wins there's a lot of jockeying for what words can connect and a lot of fun comes from Making Connections that may not seem obvious at first but somehow all relate together now office culture can always get a little dicey but unlike getting a pizza party for your contribution into your boss's new Lambo Coden names is fairly digestible and is an inoffensive way to spend time with people who go into the office fridge and also steal your SpongeBob Gogurt it's engaging enough to have people who don't play games become enticed in its word play similar to poetry for neand halls w-based games work very well for people who have never played board games Beyond Monopoly and Jenga Cod names has that same Mass Appeal as games like connections does and can capture a pass in interest in a large swath of people just by the innate cleverness of the game when you're playing with people who aren't really Gamers it's very common for people to disengage sometimes with
some games but Coden names is clever in that it naturally tries to get multiple perspectives from different team members so it really does feel like you are working together as a communal team and everything just clicks when you get the right guess code name's premise and gameplay work together for a very easy to explain and somewhat captivating competition that works in whatever office culture you might be in it is pretty common for people just to be rather invested into their team's Victory and there's brief moments of jubilance that can be even found in a bleak office through playing this and look this might not sound like a resounded endorsement but you really don't need to be challenging your co-workers with the new hotness when code names just work so well for what a normal corporate office World expects it's a little bit generic it's a little bit safe but it clicks quickly and it's still a good game and look I'm not going to say it's the greatest party game of all time but it might be the greatest office game out there right now next up we have a party with people you don't like for this kind of social situation the characteristics are it's antagonistic nobody really gets along the frustration is a definite and you really want to funnel that high potential for conflict into something potentially enjoyable there Comes A Time in your life where you'll be stuck in a room with people you don't like whether that be your in-laws or an old buddy who's way too into mlms and you need something to do instead of arguing over any various source of conflict instead of those senseless pointless fights
direct all that anger and bickering towards a potentially enjoyable experience such as the wonderfully crafted zuus zuus has quickly become one of my favorite hot mess board games not because the game is bad no on the other hand zuus is very good it's just very good at making people mad at its core zuus is a negotiation game where up to seven people are trying to make their animal faction the star attraction in a zoo in order to do so you need to move your wonderful little animal meeples and go through all of the Lesser exhibits the thing is you need to have enough votes in order to move up to that star exhibit and what that means is other players will need to help you move up with help comes deals and with deals comes betrayal the voting can get really nasty and since the mechanism to vote requires a majority relative to the whole capacity of the current exhibit it's a tense braw all the way up to the top getting votes will often require bribes or promises both of which can get extremely messy like eating soup with your fingers plus each of these wonderfully designed factions has its own aesthetic and power for example the armadillos let you use these Nifty tunnels or the ipsis can allow for an extra animal to join the exhibit each animal power feels useful and is welld designed but the trick is that these Powers can't be used on yourself but instead are used to barter and sell to other players and it's all part of the
deal making mechanisms of course the game also involves collecting these Nifty Laurel tokens and since these Laurels are both the currency and point system it's a brutal back and forth when you're trying to get into that star exhibit because the cost can be so extreme that even though you get to that exhibit you might be at a loss either way at times it can feel like you're in a lose lose scenario and there's nothing you can do except just Justify Your Existence in zuus you can also ruin people's Days by just moving these peacocks or the Zookeeper and the smart thing is that all of these individual game mechanics are meant to create deals and points of conflict because zuus eliminates players who don't make it to that star exhibit there can be a lot of natural selection and trying to wheel and deal your way through there will be moments where you are making two conflicting promises to two different players and you're bound to make at least one of them mad it's like everyone is making their own Ponzi scheme and somehow you need to end the game without ever needing to pay back all those people you've swindled zuus has an easy to explain premise a wonderful aesthetic and it's a mean tense game that allows for betrayal and bickerin to really bother people you would have otherwise get into nasty arguments with it's the perfect game to play with people you're going to fight with anyways next up we got drinking with the boys characteristics of this it has to be easy to set up and teach the game should be fast-paced to keep everyone's attention and it has to give opportunities to snack and drink and enjoy those appies when you're hanging
out with your boys and you got some Crispies you're going to want to play a game that's easy to grasp fast-paced and has enough Shifty eyes to keep them interested and skull is an elegant game that really is just bluffing distilled into its purest form the game involves placing little coaster esque tiles down and eventually challenging the Bluffs once a player challenges there's a little bid where everyone is placing their bet on how many roses they can reveal before hitting a skull the trick is you have to reveal all of your tiles first so by challenging you're trying to Bluff that all of your tiles are safe but since you're a handsome devil you're really setting up a bait to sucker in other players or not maybe your tiles are all safe but nobody needs to know that since skull is all about s up Bluffs being innocent and inconspicuous is key kind of like how the British named their nuclear program tube Alloys nobody would ever think much about tube Alloys and in the same way nobody should think much about you when you're playing skull you want to be devilish and clever and small and really make those big Bluffs that make other people question their existence skull comes in a small box and it's a super quick teach and keeps the attention on one another throughout the game since it's so focused on each other's little Tails everyone is keeping Shifty eyes on one another between sips which makes it a super engaging night in other words a lot of the game is over nonverbal communication it's easy to have a few sips or nibbles in between each person's
turn it's a game that gets progressively more fun as a night goes on and since people get eliminated it's a good chance to order more food Use the washroom and just laugh at other people's misplays the game is easy to drop in and out of between rounds and you can easily play play 6 seven eight rounds in a night plus these tiles are practically coasters but advise keeping them untarnished to not give away what tille you just put down anyways skull is supposedly an old rediscovered game from a bunch of biker gangs and I don't know how seriously I take this Preamble at the start of the instruction manual but it does have that Vibe of sitting around a Dusty table while everyone's eyeing each other aggressively which makes it a really perfect game when you're having big chugs with your sip gang next up we have a flock of Gamers all in a single room characteristics for this is that these people are familiar with games they have knowledge they have understanding of mechanics and it's a large group let's say 9 to 20 people those normal Euro games those top 100 Board Game Geek games they won't play that many people most often and these people want a challenging experience it's also important that everyone should be involved and not simply Spectators and and I've talked about blood on the clock tower extensively before but over the years it has proven time and time again as the premier party game for those who want a meaty game with a lot of people who all love to play games blood on the clock tower is an evolution
of the classic Mafia and werewolf formula that just takes the core idea and expands on it in brilliant ways the core difference is that blood in the clock tower uses a curated selection of roles that are put together and form a script because the script is a recipe for each match it creates a new flavor dependent on what roles are in each game the game encourages an understanding of how each script and how each role interconnects in order to solve this mystery and it's almost unlimited in terms of variety since each script is its own puzzle and each offers a new way to look at Social deduction and when blood in the cloter clicks together there really isn't any experience that can beat it there are so many memorable moments from a lunatic finally realizing that they've been crazy the whole time to the drunk cluing in on their own ineptness and somehow solving the whole puzzle in a single moment to all the unique individual reads like someone's Apple watch note in a high heart rate or people trying to decipher Brea in or talking patterns and all those individual behaviors that can compile it to make a fascinating social game it takes everything good about Mafia and werewolf and removes the junk like player elimination boring roles being a boring admin and all those endlessly long games and makes a tight clever brilliant experience and the thing is when you're talking about nine or more people it's very hard to find a mey game that can satisfy a group of Gamers sure you can play code names
or charades or I spy with a big group but if they want something mey there's not that many options at that player count I find that a lot of Gamers want something that has interlocking mechanics a deeper puzzle and a game that rewards strategy and thinking Blood on the clock tower satisfies all of this while also creating a social atmosphere that encourages a lot of discussion it's as Hefty as a party game should get and game Enthusiast will devour Advanced grips like a famished food critic so yeah if you got 9 to 20 people who are really into board games there really isn't a better option blood in the clock tower is perfect for a large gamer group next up we got being stuck in a room with complete strangers for this the characteristics are you have zero familiarity between people nobody knows each other it's very likely going to be awkward and you have no knowledge of people's behaviors or how they interact with each other or what they even like and okay let's say you're going to some place where you don't know a soul what do you bring what's the most crowd pleaser of all crowd Pleasers is it Uno is it musical chairs is it diplomacy no it's camel up camel up is super easy to teach easy to love game about racing camels you aren't playing as the camels but instead gamblers who are trying to place smart bets in order to make the most money by the end of the race you are not the camel you are a gambler of the camels and simply put you can bet on
a leg you can bet on the winner or loser of the whole race you can roll a dice and see where the camels go you can cheer or boo in a particular space and in games of six or more you can make a bed agreement it's all easy and each action can be resolved in under 10 seconds the reason why this game works so well for complete strangers is that it's hyper likable the idea of a race especially a race where individual player skill doesn't matter is immediately appealing to almost anyone there isn't any stress to perform intelligently since you aren't making strategic decisions or drifting your camels around corners like a game of heat making poor decisions is often just taking the underdog bet which is also exciting for Avon watchin even if you're completely off with your bets the race itself is enthralling it's a joy to see camels stack on top of each other and there's true sadness when your favorite camel gets carried back by one of the crazy camels not to mention there is enough RNG that even if someone who has no idea how the mechanics tie together they still have a pretty good chance of somehow just getting lucky and taking over the whole game it is a game where there is a winner but the innate Joy of watching a race while adding minimal Stakes it's just an easy combination to fall in love with plus these chunky camel meeples stack it on top each other it's pure Bliss there's a satisfying click of the pyramid and because the game is not teamb based you won't ever feel like you let someone else down the
race itself is the centerpiece and the gambling adds a personal investment into that race you'll still get to know one another and you'll discover fellow players through their shared celebrations the hype the disappointment their risk aversion camel up cuts through all of that extra nonsense though and just creates an easy to love gameplay Loop that's easy to play and fun to watch which is why it's the greatest crowd pleaser of them all and the best game for perfect strangers so yeah there we go what I think is the best game for a bunch of different types of social Gatherings I've definitely missed a ton of situations like date night birthdays Retreats bread bacon nights Disco Night Lord of the Ring marathons etc etc but you know let me know what you think what do you think would be good for a social situation let me know what I got wrong what you'd recommend for future and thank you as always for watching bye