Top 10 Set Collection Board Games - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
Hey everybody, today I'm counting down my top 10 set collection board games. Now, set collection is a pretty simple mechanism to understand where you're trying to acquire more and more cards or tokens or you know, tiles of a certain type to amplify your scoring. So, normally every time you get an additional card or whatever of that set, you're going to get more and more and more points and score for them at the end of the game. Now, I think set collection is a mechanism that kind of transcends complexity. very simple games that use set collection well up to very complex and you know, involved games that use the set collection mechanism. So, my list here is a quite a range of very light introductory games to more involved heavier games. So, I hope there's something on here that picks your interest and I'll get started at number 10. So, at number 10 is an extremely light game with Age of War.
Now, Age of War is a Yahtzee-style dice rolling game by Reiner Knizia where you have a bunch of seven dice and you're rolling them in each of your turns trying to claim a castle or a castle in the center of the table and all the players are going to be trying to fight after over these castles. But, not only do the castles themselves score you score you victory points, but for but collecting different sets of those cards, you're going to score more victory points and when you do collect the whole set, you are going to flip them face down and they can no longer be claimed by other players because not only in this game are you trying to roll to claim the cards in the middle of the table. Once players have already claimed them, you can actually try and win them off those players by rolling an additional symbol. So, I said it's a Yahtzee-style game where you're going to roll the dice, you're going to try and match these different battle lines and if every time you can't match one, you remove a dice.
So, the tension ramps and ramps up and you're just trying to get lucky with your dice rolls, but it's a lot of fun, very light and a great introductory game that uses set collection well. So, at number nine, I have a relatively unknown game with Mammoth. Now, Mammoth is I I believe it was Queen Games who published this one. But, it didn't get a lot of fanfare at all. I think it's fairly low ranked, but the game actually works really well. So, it has a very unique feel to it as well where you get a bunch of these different tiles and tokens in the middle of the table. And on a player's turn, they are going to literally take as many of those kind of tokens as they want. And all those tokens are going to score in different ways and you know, different kind of having sets of them or just having pure points for each one. At the end of the game, you're trying to collect sets of these animals as well which score you points at the end.
But, when you take one of these bunch of tokens in front of you, other players can either take from the center like you have or they can take your pile in front of them and but remove one of those tokens and put them into the center. And that's going to continue until every person is happy with their kind of their hoard of different tokens they've taken. But, just the way the different sets collect together or synergize is very interesting. You know, you're trying to get those end game points, you're trying to score the points for now, you're trying to get the sets of cards so you don't have to suffer negative points, you're trying to get the set so that you can move further than the other players around the kind of the track so that you score more points that way. So, yeah, there's a lot of different things going on, but again, it's very unique and has a nice family weight to it as well and it's a lot of fun and it's a pretty quick and engaging. So, that is Mammoth at number nine. At number eight, I have Abyss. Now, Abyss is not only an absolutely stunning looking game. I think it's Bruno Cathala who who designed this one.
It's a pretty interesting game that uses push your luck and set collection. So, throughout the game you're trying to collect all these different cards and then you're going to trade those cards into collect these different noble noble kind of cards that give you they give you set collection bonuses or give so they give you powers and then eventually when you get certain cards of different types, you're going to get these kind of location tiles and they're going to give you points based on set collection. And there's lots of different things they can score you on cuz all the different kind of nobles have different suits. You're going to score points for lots of different things. So, you can kind of use these locations to amplify your scoring. You can really focus on just getting getting the the nobles, but I just love the way that everything comes together. It flows nicely.
Artwork is out of this world. Production is really good. It has a nice flow to it and there's kind of lots of different things to explore in terms of that end game set collection scoring. So, that is Abyss at number eight. At number seven, I have Bumuntu. Now, Bumuntu is an abstract game. I think it only came out last year. It's in 2019. And WizKids produced this one or published this one. So, in this one you have a token and a grid of I believe it's 8 by 8 tiles of all these different animals. And you are trying to collect these different animals in sets to score victory points based on majorities. But, the cool thing about it is when you collect certain types of tiles, you can move the different value or the value of those sets or the different animals up or down on the score track which is going to either increase or decrease the points they're going to reward you at the end of the game. So, that's a really interesting concept. It's very interactive as you were trying to amplify your sets higher and push your opponents down. You're not quite sure on what they have because everyone everyone's got a screen.
You can't see what they've got. You're also trying to get different symbols as well because if you score the most of a certain type, you score more points or a very simple kind of set collection mechanism where you if you have the most kind of these mask symbols, you score more and more points. And but it's got a very nice flow to it. All the different tiles act in different ways. So, they kind of dictate how you can navigate your your pawn around that that that 8 by 8 grid and pick up different tiles that way. But yeah, a really fun game. It's quick. Again, another family weight style game, but the set collection is really strong and I think what gives it the X factor is that is the way that the scoring board can be manipulated. So, number seven is Bumuntu. At number six, I have a very popular small card game with Coloretto. Now, Coloretto is a push your luck style game where you are trying to collect sets of these different chameleons. And at the end of the game, you're going to score points for three of your most numerous types of chameleons. But, the trick to this is that every set you collect or every color lizards you collect above those or in addition to those three that you're scoring for is going to score you negative points in the same fashion.
So, you're going to be very careful about when you're going to take a certain column of lizards because not only do you want to kind of get what get as much as you can, you're going to try and reduce the amount of cards you're taking in addition to your three because as I said, they're going to score you negative points. Turns are very simple. You're just going to play choose either choose to play a card to a column or you're going to choose to take a column of cards. And the the pressure luck is interesting that because sometimes you got a kind of a you know, an easy kind of set to just add to one of your additional ones, but do you want to press for more? But, every time you do, you're kind of handing it over to your opponent to you know, you could be helping them. And again, they could either be trying to shaft you or helping you at the same time. And it's just a great back and forth and it's a lot of fun, but very light and one that I'd highly recommend to anybody. That is Coloretto.
At number five, possibly the heaviest game, in fact definitely the heaviest game on this list is Lancaster. Now, Lancaster is a pretty involved Eurogame that uses worker placement. But, not you know, normally with worker placement games you're trying to kind of place them down and collect resources to build buildings and stuff. But, this one you are actually trying to either boost your kind of knights up which are your workers. But, one of my favorite things about this game is the set collection where when you kind of claim a worker space, you can take a noble tile from those from that kind of region and add it to your player board. And what you expect obviously for every noble you have, you're going to score higher and higher multipliers for end game scoring. But, in addition to that scoring, the the usefulness of those nobles is extremely powerful during the game because they're going to give you influence cubes which let you manipulate the basically the rules of the game and the scoring of the game as the game develops. So, I love that kind of dual mechanism of the set collection. You know, are you going to collect you know, you're trying to collect them all obviously unique ones to get more points, but also to get the influence to give you more kind of pulling power or more stroke in the in the voting phase. So, I absolutely love that. It's really really good fun.
It's a different type of approach for working place worker placement as well because you know, when you place things down, you haven't necessarily got that spot. You can be kicked off by stronger knights and people can boost them with their squires. But yeah, in terms of you know, I'll keep this in relation to the set collection. The set collection is very strong. There's a huge tension of getting the nobles you want. Not everybody can get the same ones because say in a three player game, there will only be two of each noble out there. So, you're going to have to be pretty cutthroat to get the nobles that you want. So, I love the tension of the of the set collection here. It's it's brilliant and just a fantastic game in general. That is Lancaster. At number four, I have my second game by Reiner Knizia with Ra. Now, Ra is a another push your luck game, but this one has auction an auction mechanism to it as well.
It's set in ancient Egypt and basically a player's turn is going to consist of drawing tiles from a bag and placing them on the board. And those tiles are going to score in loads of different set collection mechanism ways. Such as um, you know, having unique types or um, you collecting all these different monuments for an end of the game. You're trying to set cat set so that you don't have the least of a certain type, which will score you um, negative points. Um, and all these different kind of tried and tested set collection mechanisms, um, which give you points in loads of different ways. Um, the game is a lot of fun. It's extremely engaging. Um, you uh, uh, the game is a very nuanced because these auctions or the way you acquire these tiles, um, are based on a kind of a one or a single bid auction where um, everybody can place one of their bid tokens each round and um, basically the person who triggers the um, the auction is going to get the last bid, which can either kind of, you know, choose to trump the the person who's already bid or basically let them have it. So, it's a game of very kind of, you know, it's a very nuanced game. Um, you're going to be very careful about when and where you're going to use your um, your bid tokens because you got to be careful with them, um, because if you don't get all your bids in, you're going to potentially leave with nothing, but if you waste them all on kind of lots that aren't as aren't as good as they could be, then you're going to lose that way as well. So, um, a very clever game and um, the set collection is a huge element to it. That is Ra by Reiner Knizia.
Um, at number three, I have a small box game by Dr. Steve Finn. This is Biblios. Uh, Biblios is a very clever game. Um, again, I suppose it has a an auction style feel to it. The game is bit um, divided into two two phases, um, but the premise of the game is that you're trying to collect sets of cards. Um, and each set has a value assigned to them, um, based on um, on dice. So, basically the dice will start with a value of three and throughout the game those values are kind of being manipulated through different cards, you know, being raised up or or reduced. Um, and whoever's got the most of a certain uh, suit of cards at the end of the game is going to score points based on the on the value of that dice at the end of the game. But the way you acquire the cards is extremely clever because you are basically drawing a card either to keep for yourself, to give your to your opponents, or to put on a face down pile, which will be auctioned for later.
So, you've got to be very careful about um, you know, how you're going to um, collect these different sets because you if you really focus on a certain um, suit of cards and say you've got, I don't know, an eight value in them and you could you could basically over-invest in things because um, it doesn't matter if you win the win the set by eight, you know, an eight difference or just by one difference. Um, you know, ultimately if you if you lose that suit, you're going to get nothing. So, you've got to be wary about what your opponent's taking because you don't want to be shafted about, you know, you know, as I said, investing too much in it and getting nothing in return. Um, sometimes at the end of the game you're surprised because you have the most of a certain type of suit and you had no idea that you did and you spent the whole game reducing the value of it. So, it's a very brilliantly intricately designed filler game, um, where the set set collection is um, paramount. So, everything just synergizes extremely well, the push your luck, the auctioning and the set collection.
And this is a filler game that is pretty much um, head and shoulders above most and I definitely recommend checking this one out. And I pretty much I think this is a uh, an essential in most players um, board game collection. So, that is Biblios by Steve Finn. Uh, at number two, I have Colosseum by Reiner Knizia. Uh, not Reiner Knizia, sorry, with uh, with Wolfgang Kramer. Um, Colosseum is um, another auction style game where you are collecting these different tiles, um, basically to make sets of tiles to match these different performance tiles that you can do. And you're trying to acquire all these unique um, different tokens um, to put on these huge shows to score points. Um, but the way you acquire these sets as interesting because you are um, not only are you trying to bid for them and you bid for them in sets of three, there's also a trading and negotiation round as well where you can either trade your tokens for other tokens or um, trade it for money and stuff like that.
But it's all about basically you've got a a tile which kind of has a kind of a criteria of all these different kind of things or props they need to put on those shows, such as gladiators or horses or um, lions or chariots. And you are trying to collect all these different sets of tokens to put that show on and you know, if you're a few short, then you're going to score negative po- or a few um, you know, fewer points than if you'd have the whole set. You can also score um, based on having the most type of a certain animal or stuff, you get bonus points. And it's just a really nice um, introductory weight Eurogame. Um, the negotiation is great fun. The way you acquire the sets is is great. You're always trying to buy new kind of performances to put on to amplify your points and um, you're going to be careful about which ones you're getting rid of as well. But yeah, it's all about um, you know, accumulating all those different tokens and um, trying to get a pathway to strategize and um, basically get the biggest performance you can possible to score as many points as possible. But yeah, it's a fantastic set collection game and that is Colosseum.
And finally, at number one, I have Museum. Uh, Museum is um, it is quintessentially the the ultimate set collection game. It is what this game is all about as you're acquiring all these different artifacts from around the world and um, placing them or exhibiting them in your museum. And you've got all these different um, well, you've basically got four different parts of the world, but in all these different parts of the world are broken down into different kind of cultures. So, you know, in Europe for example, you've got like the Roman Empire, you've got um, I'm forgetting. I can't think what other ones go in there now. Um, but yeah, you've got like all the different kind of, you know, Metropolitan, you got the Incas, you've got the Aztecs. And you're basically trying to line up all these different artifacts in in your museum to score more and more and more points. Um, you've got kind of criteria that you need to meet as a secret objective at the beginning of the game. You've got all these different domains which all these different artifacts stretch over.
So, you've got like your military artifacts, you've got your um, like astronomical artifacts, you've got like um, you know, your nautical and stuff like that. And you are trying to synergize all these different sets to get together to make these huge displays and um, you know, basically squeeze every point you can out of this game by making these different sets. Um, you're also going to get additional points for filling um, different portions of your museum. So, it's all about acquiring cards and there's also that spatial puzzle as well about how you're going to line them up to get as many points as possible. Um, it's a pretty simple game um, as you are as I said, as you're acquiring cards and you are choosing to um, exhibit them by paying with other cards. So, you're going to be careful about what you're discarding because when you discard cards as well, your opponents have access to um, to buy them off you. So, um, there's that very um, you know, there's that give and take. You got to be careful about what you're discarding.
Um, you you want to be careful about how much you're spending at all times as well because when you do um, exhibit stuff, you're going to get that many points and when you get to a certain point on the track, um, the game is going to basically going to be or the game end is going to be triggered. So, you're going to be careful about not spending too much on too many expensive items because you want to get the sets by putting lots of different cheaper items together as well. Um, there's a lot of kind of um, variability you can have with the expansions as well. There's a lot of different modules and stuff you can plug in to to up the complexity. But the the set collection really does shine through. The theme works very well for the different artifacts from all the different cultures. The art on this game is out of this world good. Uh, it is just absolutely um, yeah, it's a gorgeous production and just the set collection, the theme, the mechanisms, the the spatial puzzle just come together beautifully. Um, it's a family weight game, so it's not overly complex.
Anybody can play it, but there's still enough going on to satisfy, you know, more experienced gamers. So, um, a brilliant a brilliant game. And so, yeah, that concludes my uh, my top 10 uh, set collection games. Set collection always something I enjoy in board games, whether it's the main focus or just kind of a you know, a side mechanism, but yeah, always something I enjoy. So, I hope you've enjoyed the list and I hope there's something here that you maybe uh, I piqued your interest. So, um, I hope you enjoyed the review. If you have, please hit like and subscribe and check check out my other videos, too. For now, I'll see you next time on Chairman of the Board. Bye.