Skip to main content
Loading video...

District 9 & IP Games - 3 mic'd up boardgamers podcast - ep1

Transcript 1:33:30

terracotta terracotta tena koutou katoa and welcome to three miked up board gamers the new podcast from three-minute board games the premier board game podcast emanating from Airtel in the South Pacific I'm your host Jason Freeman of board games I am joined today by my co-host Conan mikeg howdy and our special guest Frazer Pete hello now the regular format for the show will be Conan and I as your regular recurring recurrent co-hosts of the show and we will have a different person each time on the show a different third a third well if you would the reason for this is that I want different voices how do what makes women aboard games what it is is that behind the scenes are a lot of contributors to the show they give their ideas give their feedback give their thoughts to me that I form and shape into the three-minute reviews they're not just my ideas and they're not just my opinions and I want those voices to come through on this channel I also want to do this podcast inside my own house so that means I'm not going to be interviewing people from all over the world unless you can fly to Wellington New Zealand and you want to sit on the podcast that'll be absolutely great but it's going to be a otehr are strong here you are representing you can hear New Zealand voices on gaming and New Zealand manners so most of you will know me Jane Freeman at board games I'm now going to introduce my co-host who is going to be a recurring villain on this series and their moms can and the gig a man who really swipes white on a board game but just as really lets them go to second base he is the creative mind behind - naked gay guys

comedy series on YouTube and when he's not reviewing games he's reviewing queer films on his channel the king of Kickstarter the Baron of backers gamer advocate filmmaker and philosopher the Magnificent mercurial Conan mikeg hi I'm a villain writing I'm feeling like I'm gonna put on more of a dark deep villainous voice that's what you took from that well the rest of it was true and we'll introduce our guest at this time as well our first guest is a longtime friend and contributed to the channel we're not playing games he contributes to the dice Sarah tops live D&D show we can also catch on Podcast oh that and he also heals the sick legend says are not one infant and the neonatal intensive care board has beaten them at a board game a man who can speedily decide on a life-saving treatment for a child it takes ten minutes to decide what card to play the doctor of dice the physician of filibustering my friend dr. Fraser Pete welcome to the show actually I mean I'm really proud of the line the position of filibustering betters yeah if I can respond it would be that you know bull games decisions I mean these are key decisions to the future of our lives gonna make the right one alright so

there's a recurring name and our wider community which is whose turn is it then you pause and say Fraser because invariably its phrases turn he's making a call so welcome whose turn is it Fraser thanks that's great I almost feel like there is to be a section on the podcast did listen I'd like it known there as far as I'm aware this podcast just could be called roasts Fraser you will get an introduction like this no I love it anyway we're going to jump straight into our first recurring and regular segment and that is the hot seat where we grow our guests 10 questions and a very short timeframe

recipe your time starts now what do you need classes you'll go to wizard bitte game space Corp or leaving Earth leaving earth what TV show a medical mistake annoys you the most Oh CPR is terrible just people who do CPR in the show should absolutely go on to like a basic life support course run by a paramedic and get taught how to actually do CPR because I honestly I think it's dangerous how bad it is because people think that they know how to do CPR or at least have some idea of what they're supposed to be doing and it's terrible amen to that yeah how about like oh he's dead already and it's like that's the point yeah on a scale of 1 to 10 how smug did you feel when you found out you were the first human per beat me at Twilight Struggle wait I was the first yeah well right now I knew that I beat you on my first guy there was what I always went about it with I didn't realize was the first to beat you overall yeah scalar wants to add 10 I'm feeling really smug right now I mean I do worry you're going Slightly easy on me because it's my first game though little based on what ballgame theme immediately makes you think I really want to get and play that game our space stuff it's probably my go to yeah so is it just any space stuff so well I mean so I fight in general I love but specifically like realistic space stuff always sings to me

that's the space cool leaving Earth's yeah I suspected my bring your own yeah but yeah you you picked well break from top to bottom your favorite analog gaming types from the following list lap collectible card games board games miniature games and role-playing probably laugh then role-playing games Dean board games then miniatures games was it and then guide collectible card games so that's from top to bottom yeah the top three is tough though yeah but definitely miniatures and little card games would be able go if someone was coming to visit earth here are what's a nice spot they should absolutely visit I mean Wellington is actually a really great place to visit in my opinion is lots to do here but if I'm going to go slightly out of where I live um oh that's a tough one one sport and out here though I don't want to leave DDA it's not like you're playing a card bunny just just June it's also kind of hard because like anywhere from our Tilda is pretty much a away from me we're out from El Toro and all right I'm gonna give an answer that's an honest answer with the caveat being it's already knowing to be quite nice and is full of tourists but there's probably the abel tasmen national park the the coastline walk there is is stunning and

it's full of tourists for a reason because it's really nice it's the only [ __ ] I've ever done where you can walk over a rise go oh I'm hot I'll go for a swim at this beautiful beach go for a swim put your gear back on walk over and low rise ah it's kind of hot I'll go for a swim it this other beautiful beach and rinse and repeat all day it's amazing it's fantastic in defenders of summer if I was to attack you with mycoplasma what would you defend with is it through my son it's a very common cause of a typical mo pneumonia mr. clean a school-aged children and final question sing the next line of the song at first I was afraid I was petrified and then through all right your time on the hot seat is over I'm so embarrassed it's the element the element BMF addendum room the next segment coming up is the elephant in the room where we discuss big-ticket items of the day important news and other things that confound and annoy us this week's elephant in the room is district 9 now the team and I had the privilege the responsibility to test this game and consider reviewing it to put it up on the channel and I'll hand over to Fraser

what did you think of district 9 well okay people who know me know that I don't like to speak ill of things or people very much and district 9 is again where someone worked hard on it or at least someone worked on it someone was involved because it's not very clear much work was put into it and as I said I like to be polite and it's really bad Coenen Oh so I'd say a lot of work went into it that demo set the babe oh it was amazing beautiful my juice so I I don't think I've seen many like pre-release products like that better come out so beautiful but so the product the components the board's the cards everything looked yeah but yeah it just fell it was so obvious that more attention went into the design aspect of like the art design aspect of it then it felt went into the actual game design like the game design felt like they had the committee of people who all loved the district 9 franchise and were all throwing out ideas about what a district 9 board game could be and nobody was editing yeah

and that's that's exactly the point I want to head on is that game design is a process you start off with a core idea and then you throw a bunch of crap at the wall just throw ideas up on the wall and then you trim them down you trim them down what makes a great game is what didn't go into it not necessarily what went into it and I've talked up him like Shem Phillips about this and he's all about this iterative process where you be streamline you refine you refine your apply a new test refine and you just make the game better none of that appears to have happened with district 9 every original idea that was thrown up on the board is in the box well that's like Ryan Lockhart like one of the really fascinating things about the deluxe version of Empires of the void - there's his developers diary that comes with it as kind of an art book and he actually shows you the iterations that he went through while designing the game and that game went through quite a few versions before he kind of hit upon the core idea that he was like this is what I want the game to be about if I recall it's like version 15 or something yes something like that yeah yeah I remember hearing about this haven't had a chance to check it out myself it does sound quite interesting and I guess I mean I probably should qualify my statements about district 9 a little bit because obviously it's pretty harsh just say it's bad but I mean I described the game as Calvinball that's true when we have like a good point I did say I feel like we're playing cabin ball but that's actually kind of where I'm going with this is

that I mean if I'm gonna make a really big leap here um I feel like Kevin bull would be fun I feel like district 9 has elements of games that could be fun it is probably about five games that could be fun and if they pick one and develop that you could have a really cool game but as it stands I could feel my enthusiasm to watch the film again dying I have to say when you're designing like your key information board that's gonna be used to remind people of rules if the font of your rules is going below eleven font size you probably have a problem with your game you have too many rules on the board yeah but for me was the busy work of right everyone draws a bunch of blackest cards then we decide one to pick and then we put them in a pouch and then we draw to our resolve them it's like why why just why not just lit to the players active turn over to cards yeah like that whole process that just doesn't need to exist it just it's superfluous yeah but that whole tree yeah the choosing of the cards and then passing the cards all around and then shuffling the cards and then revealing some of the cards putting them in the bloody path thanks not forget the fact that once you've done that you have you don't have to witness is the rules it's optional but you put

the cards inside a cat food pouch and that actually reminds me of Kitchen rush because kitchen rush has a pouch yes a game that you put some elements of the other game in spices yeah and that's a deliberate design choice because it drags things out nice they recognize that taking the pouch and opening it is time-consuming and in kitchen rush time is critical because you have literally for real-time minutes oh no I think it's three real-time minutes actually number one yeah to do it and and so that whole action is actually a deliberate system to make you not just always grab the pouch like you've got to actually think about what are you doing and when you're doing it yeah so that's the only reason you would have a mechanic like that is if there is a time element to it and there isn't the district right yeah so aside from the mechanics which we found confusing bloated and generally we might find out what the core game was of what you were supposed to be doing is actually quite obtuse there are things like the right mechanic which slowed the game down to a crawl and was just no fun but there's another criticism of the game and that is that it's a game about an apartheid analog mmm and what are you playing you're playing the guys roaming around evicting of the prawns from their home and stealing their stuff and I don't know when looking at the district 9 sitting that's not what speaks to me

about what the game should be no I mean I was playing as a gang of of the pawns that didn't feel better because it's still doing the same thing yeah what what were you doing that was different to what I was doing that nothing there's no real mechanical difference was just very subtle flavor difference now that makes me think like imagine a world where there was a block by block style district 9 game yeah no that is how they showed done it right yeah yeah arguably yeah yeah I think one of the things that that was a big mistake that they made in the in the design is they were trying to replay the narrative of the film which the whole act structure yeah so rigid yeah my kiss is all about because it was all about seeing his actions from the movie from a different perspective and that to me is not how you do an IP game at all and I mean you look at something like Battlestar Galactica which is one of the better IP games out there right and that doesn't really try to mimic the narrative of the show and said it tries to set up a game where you will have an emergent storyline that will feel like the show absolutely and we're gonna be talking more about other IP games yeah later and that I'm absolutely gonna echo what you just see it kind of because all of my favorite IP games via common

element is that emergent narrative where you can tell a story that is inspired by the source material but not slavish to it but you still feel like you could if you really wanted to recreate that original story you just don't have to yeah yeah and that's I think the sweet spot we will get into that in more detail later on so to close off on district 9 I'd like to to say that I think the team we're to have done a stellar job assembling the game or producing it and I I've talked to John Oh who's the guy running this and he is an excellent guy and I've really hated giving him the bad news that we thought the game was beyond bad so what I'm saying is if district 9 comes out as it is it will be a terrible mistake for winner and a B terrible mistake for anyone who backs it but there's potential there wonderful figures have got the color for a great game they just need to get someone and to make that great game it's editing I think editing is one of the key things and probably also having a rethink about who are who are the players playing yeah yeah yeah who are the heroes of the story yeah who the heroes of your story because if the heroes are the guys driving around in a truck kicking over poor people and stealing their crap that's a bad game ugly yeah for district 9 yeah yeah by the way it's still beneath the table kind of making the elephant of the room can see it a little bit too real good I'm still gonna see the back

all right so the next segment we got an interview Fraser on the dice Sara tops live DD show tell us a few things about that who's involved so die Sarah talks presents is a thing that might make Mugen Davey and his seat up I think what you two both know Morgan yes and for those who don't Morgan is a bit of a role-playing legend around Wellington he's like a good-looking version of lurch from The Addams Family that's actually so accurate um anyway so here he's put together died Sarah talks presents we do the indie live shows with comedians he it's his baby but I'm helping him out um I provide character voices and that sort of thing and give him feedback on their stories that he's putting together but he's the DM and I help and we have rotating cast of comedians who play the characters so how many shows have you done today so we've done three live shows so far and the de Cerio types of cuisines podcast has two episodes on it so far which is encompassing one of those shows because it got broken up into two halves and I'm a campaign or is it standalone adventures they're standalone adventures but each comedian has their own recurring character and there is an ongoing I guess continuity things are happening one stayed true in another people who never went to the first show I probably be very confused way out low-level dwarf either has a portable hold that has scorpions in it

but that's still a thing you know for example so you can check it out if you go probably the easiest thing to do is either the Google dice Serie tops in zine or dicey row tops D&D live and you can find the link which should tell you how to get the podcast and but I'll probably ask Jared if you let me put a link in the podcast description maybe yeah absolutely although you're not touching my site I'll put the link in the description keep your hands off mustache Thank You Fraser if you're and dandy podcasts and like the New Zealand style of comedy which is represented by such things as flight of the conchords in Thor Ragnarok checkout die sir tops DnB odd cap a next segment is Conan's Kickstarter comma steer I did not pick that name feel free to pick another name like I don't know I'm not sure I could come up with something quite so clever so the purpose of the segment is Conan is quite vested in Kickstarter he looks up a lot of Kickstarter games and he's usually how I found out about Kickstarter games he normally goes wow check out this thing I'm backing or check out this game I think it's up your alley so cut in what have you been scoping out on Kickstarter over the last wee while okay well I've been scoping out a credit fuse I've got I've got a list here yeah that I'm going to try and get through as quickly as possible but still actually

tell you why I'm interesting some of these tell us a story I thought I'm surprised okay so the reality is is that yes I have a bit of a Kickstarter addiction and I probably first thing I do when I wake up in the morning because the ball everything gets late at night kick-started games to go is there anything I want to look at least like go I'm gonna come back to this game yeah so on that note there's a few games out there they're sounding really interesting there was merchants Cove initially but after our discussions and having a good look at it I'm just not sure how again a submit to an asymmetrical game that goes so asymmetrical that you basically got four or five players around the table or playing a different game it's the root problem yeah so roots a great game but teaching everyone that first game there's so much overhead and you can't look at someone else to figure out what the hell they're doing but I think in roots defense they do a really good job of having everything tied to a core mechanic and then each different faction kind of spans out from that core so you can teach players how to read their own rules and if you're playing against someone else you know that you just have to look at the victory track you have a general idea of how well they're doing yeah whereas merchants Cove doesn't seem to

have that um the next ones go not back not back Inc know there's match breaker which I'm still really intrigued by it's kind of it sounds like it's kind of a one of those party games like cards against humanity' and so on except good except I've got a little bit more to it there's you put prospective lures out on the table and then everyone secretly assigns good or bad traits to each of them and then you find out if they're a match and you're trying you're trying to get a match but you're trying to make sure that all the other players aren't so one of those games where you'd win by voting who's the best from what I can understand yet there's like a you reveal all the cards and if you got it wrong and then everyone takes about I'm intrigued and checking it out frigate factory looks really interesting so it's kind of basically dice forged meets digit cubes yeah so basically you're playing people on a I think it's a space station or a spaceship and they're trying to repair things and to do that they use fidget cubes don't don't try to examine that too much I think I might have to bring up a picture of that one and so like basically you've got little trolls who are carrying segments of fidgets cube and then you have like a cube that you build and you design the faces of your future cube for

it listening really interesting what am I one of the things that kind of had me raise an eyebrow and consider it is there's Cthulhu is one of the creatures and it says you can only communicate an alien gibberish straight down to madness yeah yeah I've got I saw one it's not really me because I'm on you know I'm more of a worker placement drafting kind of guy I like games that have really intriguing mechanics but I thought I should be a bit fair to people who like games other than mine yep so I had a good look and there's a strategic game called Saigon 75 which is set in Saigon yeah during their era and that looks like there will be quite a really interesting not quite war game it looks like it's more of a grand strategy game okay so it's worth having a look I think that it's a game yeah all right I thought that's J yeah there's a really interesting role-playing game out by group who recently did a Rocklin game could never go never go home or is no never coming home yeah which is sick which was a horror role-playing game set in World War one and so now they've done another game could to knee to knee brie a remnant of Rome where you're basically a group of people living in a Roman

colony just after the fall of Rome and basically trying to keep civilization alive as it's kind of crumbling so some Dark Ages are on our own coming in they're coming yeah and and so it doesn't look like it's got a lot of a fantasy element in it which is what really interested me like they're kind of presented barbarian clans and these kind of almost supernatural threats in the eyes of the populace yeah but the game itself is all about building up your community and surviving and keeping it all together so I really recommend that one okay well that's a that's a pretty awesome list old stuff so thank you can cut it and this will be a regular segment so stay tuned for all these kind of things all right moving on to our next segment we have what's new to you now this is segment where everyone talks about the games they've played most recently so we ready gonna cover one or two games that people have played most recently and it's just a quick a quick fire round table about that so we'll start with Conan hey well funnily enough what's new to me is also talking about later so the newest thing that I've been playing is horrified which is the universal monsters board game and this kind of

just came out of nowhere to me on Facebook I just started seeing loads of people posting about horrified and posting pictures of it I was like Oh Universal Monsters that's my jam yeah so it's not available in New Zealand yet typical yeah apparently it's also quite limited over in the state so you can only buy it from Target apparent wow it's a target exclusive right yep so eventually it'll probably get released to a wider audience the target will have like so it's gonna be kind of like niggle and basically in front of lover I think was like that as well know if I got loved went the other way they kick-started and then they went retail and then they got a exclusive deal with Walmart I think okay yeah I remember I can't remember who they I know one of the big chains and yeah and that's why they did the new covers for the right so yeah so I I tracked it down on eBay and it only arrived yesterday so I've only played the solo game of it and it's a really interesting mix of pandemic style mechanics with I don't really have to think of another game because each of the monsters has their own kind of mini game about how you defeat them so there's a really interesting it's a pandemic thing but there's multiple ways to solve it instead of just having to cure X number of diseases you got a difference in tech boxes you have to go through based on the combination

and do you have more than one in the game yeah if you start off basic as to stand in as three and challenging as four monsters and they have six different types of monsters because Frankenstein and Bride of Frankenstein are considered one monster yeah this sounds expandable oh yes definitely expendable and it's got so much going on in it I think solo play wasn't so great just because it felt a little easy yeah but it's also a little challenging at the same time but I think with multiple players the challenge will ramp up quite quickly as is always the case with pandemic style games really as the less players you have the easier the gamers and a guarantee the first expansion will be challenged wrong yeah yeah but again so you've got a lot of things going on and you're chasing after villages and so on tracer so a couple of games of and new to me but actually most of those are ones that are played with you lot so probably the only game I've played recently that's new to me this wasn't with you too well with you and others is guns June Cleaver was rolling right and this my very first time I've ever played a role in right and I just played it the other day actually with Conan split meeting this year and I had a great time I had not never been exposed to these role and rights before but it was clever it was it was easy to pick up there was some interesting kind of mechanics there

was stuff to dig into with which my kind of slight puzzle puzzle solving kind of oozy Azzam kind of came through with and you said that's what let's see that the synergies and the ways that you could so do this to do that to do this yeah I had a great time I I really enjoyed additionally I also want to point out that during that game phrase I managed to make decisions quite promptly oh nice yeah Halloween whose turn is it Fraser and I've got a little bita this is sturdy and has a stroke and is he not always me anymore thank you very much it was major enough to look at this for sure Oh yeah crippled by the game that froze froze up da Fraser go back 15 years was way worse way WAY worse I think that's true of any person just like to go on the record I was fantastic 15 yeah you Paragon the fiction so for me the new new to me game there's two of them on a cover off and the first one is detective City of Angels and it is a crime solving noir game in the style of LA noire and LA Confidential how it subverts a normal detective trope is that you're not just working for a book one player is playing their chisel and the chisels goal is to misdirect the players so when they ask questions of a witness they've got multiple options so

the chisel can actually choose different responses and seeing people off on different tangents the investigators can choose to challenge that response and if their guess correctly that it's a misdirect they'll get the right information but if they guess wrong the chisel will have stuff that they can use to slow down and delay them later on and for me a lot of the problem with detective games as they rely on clever writing and clever writing usually means crimes don't pan out the way they should how they wouldn't the real world it's usually some wacky clue that gives you the the answer in this because there's their ambiguity in an investigation it's an extra layer I think that detective games have needed for damn long time and I'm really kind of regret that it's a Kickstarter only game because it's one I think that if more people played it and it got out in the stores it could really shake up the genre we we actually I had that getting because I kick-started it and of course you and I loved it because you know me I love detective games and definitely I think addresses a lot of the issues that you brought up especially because like games like chronicles of crime which is another one I really love yeah that does have kind of a little bit of variability based on the quality of the taste that your work yeah right whereas detective City of Angels has such a beautiful presentation and so the problem was that the regular game is that I played it with haters really yeah

they they were like I don't see the point of the chisel fascinating I know right and I was like the bets kind of the whole point of this they say it's a lot more interactive and but I think the thing was again it's kind of like we were having a talk before before the podcast about people who are very statistical strategic thinkers as opposed to people who are kind of narrative thinkers in both games so this is the caller call to adventure yeah and if you play called revenger just for the numbers you know it's a pretty image yeah yeah there's not a lot of game there there it's fine but it's nothing more but you're not playing yeah if you're playing it for the story aspects then you real then you understand what the game is and these the the main complaint that got given to me was if the chisel can lie then we can't guess the clue right and so we're not gonna solve the case and I'm like that's the point fantastic I love it when you hear about a game that you had a really positive experience about that means someone else is like that for the record this is three of the four people who play through a full campaign of gen7 again the doc panned by so many people and we're really good time and and I'm in the middle of playing it with a completely different group of players some of them who are these statistical

thinker types and we're having an absolute blast with it again and I think it's because for them there is that like having to think about or one of my odds if I do this or do that and so on and because of the way that it's all structured it draws you into thinking and the narrative even when you're not really intending to and I that's something I really love about it alright so my last game is going to be head lobs house so Pavlov's house is a game set in Stalingrad during the Battle of Stalingrad okay and it's a solo game although I think you can't play it co-op where it zooms into a complete tactical level of a house that you're defending the operational level of where troops are suffocating and pandemic style and in the strategic level we are building artillery of resources try to ship supplies across the Volga and building in offenses so you've got to play across this three layers so you start by planning a strategy and how you're going to play on the big board and that might bring more ammunition or more resources into the house then the vormax will attack along the different channels like they wouldn't a pandemic game and if you've deployed machine guns you might stop them from advancing and all that kind of stuff and then finally you take your actions inside the house we're actually moving individual soldiers around to the individual positions and one of the things I absolutely adore about this is that the guy who wrote the game did as research there's this great companion book that details the entire

Battle of Stalingrad right down to the individual records for all of the soldiers who were in Pavlov's house and add their facts and a lot of them that died in the battle is if you don't know the Battle of Stalingrad is the most horrific battle in human history it's absolutely ghastly and Pavlov's house was the sort of anchoring defensive point in the line that they hit they held the fall for the war and yeah wonderful solo game if you like solo or war games or especially solo war games if you hadn't played it definitely check this one out pretty cool yeah yeah well shot to you guys after with the next segment is stacking the shelves where I quickly go through what's arrived for three minute board games over the last week or so and we've got two new games both from the same publisher and that is anomaly which is a hidden movement game with the quick that all players are hidden from each other so there's a monster trying to track down these students on a space station the monsters hidden from the students the students are hidden from each other you can't reveal who's where and you have to guess when you're in the same area of someone else if you want to attack them and do stuff so if you're the student you might go I think the monsters are gonna Biff a grenade and try to do damage but that will give away possibly your position and we you are so yeah I really wanna see how this one works to get it on the table looks like

it's going to be a good one for three players especially with two students and one monster and the other one is the collector's edition of infidel and the pill book expansion which Conan will no doubt be able to tell me a lot more about cuz these plays a lot more than I have well not expansion the expansion infidel itself infidel ever dealt I secretly give myself credit for getting half of Wellington into the city because my flatmate Nasir who is a much bigger board game phonetic than I am she's I think she's got it counted over 220 house she of course mingles with quite a few different ball game and groups across the city and so often we get invited to go along to various gaming groups and because she loved David l when I got the original Kickstarter of it she took it around everywhere and even Dells a tabloid building game where you're drafting cards to build a tableau of your city you only have 15 spaces you can build in so you've got to be really selective and it's engine builder and that the buildings and inhabitants that you select will then decide help decide what further cards and resources and goods and points

you get at the end so it's a really good game for that and it had a really nice replayability because because of all the various random factors that you could add and to keep each game playing with different rules and so pillbox just basically added more of that flexibility to the game to ensure that this is a game that you can always pull out at any time and just sit down and have a game and have a really good time and I think that's that's is real strength it's one of those complex but not too common tasks einde of games with really simple knees with the one game of that I've played and I do intend to play it a lot more before it goes on the channel it felt like the game there cos you know I didn't really like wingspan actually thought Monopoly wingspan was a bit shallow but a bit wasn't engaging enough or thinking enough for me to really dig into I think even L is the kind of game that could have been a bigger wingspan like it's I think there's more decision space in the game and it's equally pretty and good-looking yeah it's just you know the quirks of fate one becomes a if it are still pretty popular game pretty successful I don't think it's it's done well on the kickstart front yeah it's definitely not a nada everyone and their dog is running out to play medellín there is a shame because it is a beautiful game and when you've got that three-dimensional tree set up it's just it's a game that demands your attention oh yeah you put it down on the table on the convention hall and if people haven't seen it they walk past a girl what the hell is that

and the latest Kickstarter had a wooden tree ah both Missy has gone and bought her own singer so we now have two sets of evidence and it's like normally when we end up with two sets i end up selling man because the sea is the bigger board game fan so I'm like I'm not as addicted and so to say by the way we we would like you to come on the show she listen she's interested oh it's good excellent she's she is a font of knowledge about a lot yeah the seer annoyed we go way back when we played board games on and off together for at least 10-15 years maybe two thousand four or five something like that yeah yeah love to get on the show so yeah so to wrap it up yeah the wooden tree is really gorgeous and I think there was a really clever decision on styling games part to produce it because one of the biggest concerns about ever Dell was that the tree made out of cardboard was going to have a very short lifespan yeah and so they they address that and I think that's always been one of the reason that they are a really impressive team for being able to produce such awesome products and they come out really quickly like no they're really good at sitting we're gonna have this ready December 2020 right yeah then it comes out September twenty twenty because they always account for that which is interesting cuz like my experience with Starlin and to a lesser extent with victory point games which they also there's always been really

positive but there's apparently a lot of people out online who in a previous incarnation or in some other form they've got a lot of bad blood with them so yeah never I've never personally had from them but I know a lot of people that will hear the name bad come BR and those people are perfectly entitled to their opinions you know I'm not diminishing their it's just yes it is it shows you that that whole thing about how consumer confidence in your brand is so fickle then you've got to get it right every time because it it just takes one bad experience to put people off yeah and then those people will go are we gonna back this you shouldn't back this don't buy that game those guys screwed me over a few years back yeah it's just that kind of legacy that hangs around well they just have a saying in retail I think it was for every bad experience that a customer has eight more people are going to get told about it but for every good experience someone has maybe four will get told yeah yep this is very interesting all right let's move on to the final round table which is on IP based games so what we're going to do is we're going to whip around and we're going to count down six different games and I'll tell you what the categories are when we come to them and then we're gonna have a discussion back and forth while we're doing this on the nature of IP games what makes them work what makes them

suck and some of the pitfalls they fall into so what we can do is we'll start off with bracer and his third favorite IP game oh you're gonna make me them favorite all right um Ben Saget ticket so the 2008 I went to ball game gig knives as I was gonna present them in ranking board during its HD the lowest ranked on board game geek of my top three and it got seven points in four words with which i think is probably a little bit loges it's quite good yeah anyway um love but BellSouth let's go great okay so we got a spoiler here cuz I've also got battle star on my list and because we're not ranking them I'm just gonna mention it now now a psychrometric is also on my list and the reason that is is every time we plan it's just a fantastic experience so you merging narrative ideas and it different things happen there's suspicion at the table there's name-calling this card counting and for a particular group of mine this is our signature game this is the game on all five of us together this is the one we'll be most likely to play if we really want to have a good time and I think we played like 15 20 odd games of it like a lot of Battlestar over the years and it just I can't imagine working with another IP I just can't imagine all of those mechanics working for something else you can tree theme it as is if you if you did that it would just come across as feeling like this

kind of feels a bit like and I'm surprised I didn't bring up so I um Jared has coined a term from Battlestar Galactica there I actually quote in conversations in context there may not even reference bill cycle etiquette until I bring up this conceived which and critten if I'm pronouncing it wrong but goes something online along the lines of in copy trees in computer H is the word which I believe you did you coin it before or after you blog but knows during a journey up it was during a game with Thomas and yeah I did post it on the Vaughn Creek blog back in about 2012 and it's the idea that someone is so incompetent at a traitor board game that you immediately assume that their what they're doing is traitorous and it's not because there's a Cylon is because they're just clueless but and I've got a friend of ours Thomas who he just tells us to mess with people he not because he's a Cylon he just likes doing I'm gonna do that because it looks fun and that's his thought process I'm gonna jump in a fighter and go and do stuff as like well this no fighters I think yeah looked fun and you just assume he's guilty and it's a real problem when he is okay but yeah although I can kind of see there that Thomas was also doing it's an applicable concept to a lot of ball games particularly ones the heavy traders we just like I just can't tell

if you aren't getting this game and you're playing us that's what I see we always come back towards the idea that board games there tell stories and the fact that we immediately reference stories like this with again my battle cycle antic it means it's doing its job really well very true so you or one of your free or one of my three top favorites no well one of them I was going to name I pretty sure it's going to end up on phrases or so I'm actually going to go for one that I'm pretty confident neither of you have played because you know I'm like that yeah yeah it's kind of true I'm always the one who shows up to games it's like here's my new board game that none of you have I'd layer but I'm not like okay so we had one person in one of our gaming groups who always does that but he has not opened the box I hate that guy yeah and so he opens the box are these popping stuff out and while everyone's like going are you sure we should be playing this game right now it's I mean the Sears kind of got the thing where it's like she has to read the rules yeah [ __ ] play game so she's keen to bring a new game in but she has to have read the rules so she can explain the rules because she refuses to play a game with people who don't know how to fear rule to head I'm the same pretty much it so my game is Crusader Kings ah which I know Jay and Steph I came to play at some point I have read

the rules but we are near two of us in there was a three player minimum so we could get rid of fire so it's a game talking about building stories their game is all about emergent stories because you're playing three generations of a dynasty basically and it catches the the feel of the videogame quite well in a smaller sort of frame of kind because that is one sprawling ass but yeah it's huge and so being able to capture even like a like a sense of that is really good so I think having that three dynasties allows you to sort of have a bit of the sprawl without having the game feel like it's being dragged down by the sprawl and because like the way that you run them rolling dice the way that you're randomly resolving issues as you're pulling character traits out of a bag and all the character traits are basically you rule those character traits or sometimes two character traits of their kids and so like when you pull it out like lustful and may not just go Oh God's sake it was that god-awful son of mine ago and try and hit six with the enemy's daughter you know that kind of that kind of narrative thing of it and I thought that was that was just mom yeah yes yes yes all right Fraser onto you for one of you games that you thought were not their flesh Oh them to go the bad ones right well I have some slightly um unusual choices for this well the business

probably not super unusual because it's just bad which is that BEC in 2012 there were a couple of games that came out to tie into The Hobbit an unexpected journey yeah this actually quite a few so the Hobbit and unexpected journey 2012 which has a rating of but it's not the one that has 6.3 which is actually designed by Reina connects here of all people which is mean to be quite a reasonable game well it's got six point three which is more than mine god it's also not the 2012 adventure game which got three point two five which is more than mine oh Christ the one that I played actually wasn't a see it in the couple of other people as well I should point out that Fraser contacted no he asked Nasir when he was over for board games the other day because I was trying to work out which it was yeah and and I contacted the various people I play with him the theme of the responses I got was along lines of oh God and oh I block there from my memory anyway The Hobbit an unexpected journey from 2012 has a rating of 2.8 on BoardGameGeek it's pretty much one of the worst gaming experiences of my life I don't think we finished the game we had to get drunk which is actually quite unusual for me because I'm not a big drinker and lost drunk on this train ride home we came up with a better game yet even when we sobered up in the morning we were like yeah I'm giving a

cake I mean I know I better come across a session I mean person from honestly do try to be you know fine dude compassionate people but it was so bad something some things don't deserve your kindness no oh man like I'm gonna feel really pathetic following this up because my sick and bad game isn't actually that bad and it's legendary x-files and the reason I'm putting it on the bad list is first of all I don't like legendary as a course of a legendary Marvel I think is a very forgettable game that does absolutely nothing for me legendary encounters aliens I find actually quite find it the mix of mechanics and the systems just gel perfectly and then x-files they try to recapture the magic they tried to use 90% of the same system with the aliens game and we're aliens you'll have like a ticking car moving down the ventilation shaft towards you but you have to kill before they get to you in the x-files it's like monsters of the week and there's hidden cards and a set of lights try solve objectives you're trying to piece together this conspiracy but it just feels too scary gamma so we're each aliens game is focused on one film and the three-act structure of one film the x-files is three seasons that you play at once so it's just like Oh remember this character remember this thing remember this disconnected idea it's just bland none of the tension none of the

excitement none of the real feeling that you've got an aliens and also the graphic designs choices of making it all look like 80s bureaucratic clipart was creepy bad so it's yeah it's gonna get kicked out right Karen one of your disappointing okay I kind of the two disappointing IP again so I chose work both by the same crowd and they're both kind of disappointing for the same reasons but the one day I mentioned is labyrinth the board game so that's okay to clarify that's the not the labyrinth where you've got the Dino thing it's not labyrinth by volcko the war on terror game no it's the one that Jim Hanson that it's the Jim Henson branded board game that comes with the very nicely sculpted miniatures of the key characters from labyrinth yeah beautiful our beautiful presentation I've heard there's nothing basic Illya roll and move pizza roller move game yeah it's like it's got potential of being like a game where you're on quests before you you faced off against jerath but really it's it no different from one of those old classics of place your piece on star and roll dice until you get to the piece to the end yeah so like the old GI Joe 80 years and what's really disappointing

because I was kind of hoping for something that was because you know to me like IP games they've got to catch of the kept you know feel I mean as you know my favorite style of any kind of board game is that it presents a theme and then I feel their thing when I play the game like kitchen rush one of my top five games feels like what I remember working in a restaurant and a restaurant felt like which is your thing a lot of you chef and and I love the fact that it captured that that feeling of stress without actually being stressful that that's a real that's really clever design and never games I can capture any of that well I guess it captured the feeling of a dream because you kept falling asleep I've just loved a new tagline for the game that got this podcast and explicit racing to another one of your favorites okay so I'm gonna go with Star Wars rebellion is my second favorite seeing as you asked me to bring them forth so just to jump in rebellion is also one more rebellion is also a milos I got it I knew it was gonna die Ellis this is a terribly on an

unsurprising list it is space stuff but it's not realistic space though yeah I mean it's really stars rebellion I mean you know IP games they come out you go will this be good will this be occasion you kind of don't know and then something blew me away I honestly I didn't know what to expect and I played it and I was like there is two great games here yeah and they mesh perfectly yeah and I feel like I could tell the story of the original trilogy or not and I could have fun both ways and there's just these great stories that come out of it and we've kind of been harping on this point about you know what's the emotion Aaron what's the stories next something but it's such a great example but even more I feel them better circulate to cut off just getting that theme of this is a sequence of events and oh no Mon Mothma is now working for the dark side planets to the Empire what are we gonna do we're getting shafted you know I'm like oh she's such a great imperial agent I know it turns out um but yet great just amazing game but it's gonna echo everything Fraser said about souls rebellion is just an amazing game and the asymmetry is just mind-blowing ly well done and I think we've played about six or six or seven times right yeah and every single game has been a butt

clenching nail-biter it's a great kind I seem to recall whether two times when you absolutely schooled me about as many times okay make sure you keep track but yeah just a wonderful game can't say enough good things about it yeah I I think the thing that really strikes me about rebellion is it's a classic fantasy flight lots of systems kind of game but then never feels like there's just mechanics for the sake of mechanics yeah everything feels like it's been carefully thought about how its pushing forward that that feeling of you're playing through a galactic rebellion and it was friend Luke's stories about all the crazy outcomes of the games that he was playing that sold me on it no actually and I think that's yeah it's just it's such an impressive game I think you played over Luke before you play with me I think so I think yeah Luke was the person who got me into as well when Luke also got me into my other it looks another person what am I getting almost great and it is such a Star Wars fan yeah if he's like saying the Star Wars game is good then it's like oh I'm paying attention yeah yeah yeah and there's another game where the expansion was really good expansion because it editing a few quite few new ideas but it also kind of improved slashed overhauled probably the only

system that I would have any criticism sort of which was the combats yesterday open played the expansion yet oh really it's the combat system and just an extra layer to it yeah yeah so yeah if the original valiant had one weakness was the combat system was okay yeah it was always more about the kind of moving around and and the the political side of the game was really its appeal yeah yeah being up to make combat a bit more and I think the secret weapon and rebellion is that it's character driven mmm and that's that's where the cat thinks come through your voice any harm to do something you're not sending just smoke yeah no just evening - yes - Troy is commanded by an opiate yeah yeah all right so we went a full rotation so I'm going to go back to freezer and right we're gonna go with your other bad game my other bad game your other bad game well so there is a game there's several games from this IP and it's the one that I'm beating is probably gonna surprise my well to cut my hosts the most and that's the flintstones from was published in 1971 oh my lord because and the reason why I bring it up I mean it's pretty classic for that kind of era it's a it's we kind of touched upon the earlier you start the start you roll some dice well actually in this case you spin a dial which tells you the

number of spaces that you move basically same as rolling the dice you move them in these spaces if you get sometimes you draw a card that says go forward some spaces go back some spaces with some vaguely themed thing from the TV show yabba-dabba to go forward - I but it's that kind of thing and it's really dull and I played it ever Ellis of the young age I must mean like eight ish and I think it was just I found it at my grandmother's place and it was old Dean and I was just like oh I like the foot starts I'll play this ball game and I bring it up because it's literally the very first time I ever remember a ball game or really any kind of game not being fun and it was kind of like an an interesting thing for me in that regard because I kind of had this world open to me that just because it's a game doesn't mean it's good you can have badly designed games you can they badly designed anything really yeah and if it's badly designed it's terrible so I'm gonna pop your innocence died that day Wow taste that phrases shouting yeah yeah let's go with that no but seriously like yeah I mean it was it's it's really bad and sometimes you learn a bit about

my game also starts with if so there's our segue and this game was for a franchise and I was very fond of and this is gonna take games on PC and I have played all four versions of the numbered versions as well as new vegas and that is fallout of the board game from Fantasy Flight Games I wanted so much from this game the idea of a FFG based narrative driven fallout games like oh my god I won a few games I ever is over I really demand to get something as soon as it comes out because it's usually a hassle to get shipped on them this is a game I actually got straight away important as soon as I could possibly get it to the country and this is before I started the channel and it arrives logic we played stiff and I play through a two-player game we were like what what what why why is this game a thing and the killer was the victory conditions this nonsense idea that you like trying to infection points and push affection one direction and you competing against each other but if one of you gets a clue the other one can action it so we had this thing where like stiff bound something a clue to a location and that was a story she was investigating I instantly knew where that was on the other side of the board because I was right by the square I can move in and

finish the quest and that makes no damn narrative sense I just on top of that the mechanics were just near forgettable mediocre junk and the stories weren't that great it was just a big pile of bland and my opinion of it only went down the more I played it we really gave it a good go we we were like this kids gotta be good it's gotta be good do you listen I'd like you know they say she would care it sounds like in real life your voice they put song yeah yeah this moment so I didn't really have a second game like I would I was kind of like going oh well Dark Crystal which is done by the same God that did labyrinth pretty much all decisions trash one of our favorite games but I do I do think honor on an IP case I've got two mentions the original collector's Star Wars monopoly what we had that right yeah we had a copy of that yeah because while being able to trade an imperial credits was loads of fun and there was a certain comical nature of Chewbacca buying the stick really it done kind of emphasized how a monopoly he it's not a

game you can just slap in the IPO but they do it there's like a base much to say in free y'know Polly IP game because monopoly is a slight there that's a game that's got a very particular ideology behind its design yeah and there's a there's a kind of perverse humor that by slapping any IP on it you're only reinforcing all the negative points about monopolies ideology teaches you that monopolies are bad yeah and that exploitive land ownership is bad because one person ends up with all the money if everyone else ends up Brock what's losing monopoly how many of course is that monopoly thinks it's saying becoming riches awesome yeah but what it's really teaching you is that one person becoming rich makes everyone else hate them also it gave me a very unrealistic expectation of what movies involved so I think there's a general consensus that pretty much every version of monopoly can just go in the sea yeah yeah yeah no the only reason I used to play my favorite game of Monopoly when I was a kid was to take all the monopoly money out of it yet my mother's that my grandmother's coffee stand which had these like multi-layered stands so they put stuff on the bottom

on the top and then I put all these toys on the bottom one pretend it was the window in a shop and then get my brother and my cousins to play shop alright and the last round we're going to do is on games we thought were intriguing or interesting not necessarily great games but they might have been great games for once it surprised us that we win and not necessarily expecting them to be fantastic so this one is both unexpected because I enjoyed it and I was hoping to enjoy the fact that I'd enjoy it was still somewhat surprising because I don't know if I would it was also surprising because I thought it was surprisingly easy to learn given the kind of crunch I had expected and I felt that the way it was structured made there particularly helpful but the reason mostly including it is that it was surprising because I didn't realize it was based on an IP and that's space Corp that we're playing recently with u2 which is based on a book called space Corp by einar full Sun who is a NASA engineer who wrote a book in 2014 with space called the first book of the galactican series which I believe has another book either about to come out or heads just coming out and yeah it's an ip-based game oh my god like that's mind-blowing just like hard science and they checked on some alien stuff you

know for just shits and giggles well yeah that's kind of the thing that's that's what it's it's like no offense to the game because I really enjoyed it it's kind of a generic idea you know it seems like this junior at concept of we're gonna be a corporation it's exploring space sure oh it's based on the hard science I don't know if it's alive your libertarian ideology I don't know maybe I know well maybe it's just a realistic kind of a look at what space exploration the future might involve well maybe that's a dire example of what happens with a NASA space engineer tries to write in look I couldn't find much information about him like these are good reads article like page about it there's not a Wikipedia page about either of them yeah that's fascinating yeah so it's clearly like John Butterfield the designer of it just read the book I thought that'd be a great idea for a thing because you but nothing not necessarily because of commercial pressure to go we need to make a game yeah that's good that's intriguing yeah don't ever happens very often no I can think of one case like that and that's Bethel Woods Oh Philips game and the reason he made it is he just loves that guy's music and the stories that are around biffle woods so Shin was like I want to make a game based on this contact the guy said yes fascinating right yeah yeah I mean

we should mention the mechanics given that as the other thing I saw was saying which is that because it's structured over three eras of space exploration I did quite like the fit that the first era introduces the basic concepts and in iteratively introduces more advanced concepts which is just a great way to do a long game because it is a long game yeah and if you're gonna do a long game doing like that is actually a pretty genius idea yeah yeah but we all agreed that that was differently again we wanted to oh yeah again yeah I think it's it's a weekend game not necessarily evening game because I think for players easily hit the four hour mark yeah yeah though in fairness to the game you could just play one of those ears and it does have rules but I mean it would be really satisfying but don't just play an era in an evening or over a sequence of evenings yeah and I think we've you get to the end of an era there's actually a much data you need to say no yeah it's pretty much what you've got on your board and your score it's that it yeah we're just not a lot no take a photo yeah be done all right so onto my interesting game my intriguing game and this was a surprise because it's a very hammy TV show like it's a ridiculously heavy TV show full of nudity swearing and murder and that is Spartacus a game of blunt said I'd like to play that I love this game who's never played spot is never played spot is everybody has told me oh yeah so

there are several things I love about the Spartacus game and a lot of it's very similar to what happens in a game on Battlestar Galactica it's the finger pointing the accusations and stuff because there's a lot of plain duty tricks on each other so there and there's also peeling influence of other players and there's just that whole interaction and then there's the mini fights that you do inside the arena which people bet on it's just a heck of a lot of fun and it's also got a hell of a lot of Kiwis in it mmm because the show was produced here and yeah Crixus the goal mari most of the most of the other characters pretty Maori there's a lot of Polynesian boys as Thracians and ghouls and then there shows so a lot of very familiar faces in there and of course the unofficial queen of New Zealand Lucy Lawless oh yeah yeah yeah well that's kind of the Cliff Curtis syndrome isn't it yeah it's like like Murray actors tend to just be any non-american nationality you want I think cliff has played pretty much every nationality nod that's what I was quite good seeing them all fear the walking dead as as a moment yeah yeah yeah any talk about that was actually a part of this character it was really cool to see but it's always good when it's like we see a little bit more be representational yeah yeah pretending to be Arabs yep frequently get cast as essential Americans yeah yeah all right

also you're interesting so my interesting game was one that we tried out some time ago and that was Doctor Who time of the Dalek yeah I was really I was expecting that to be kind of trashy yes yeah yes I was really pleased with it so that was one I found in a books game store up in Auckland I had some time to kill while I was working up there and I went in there and they had no good copy and I was like didn't I was not expecting much other yeah open up yeah solid solid game dude like I mean it's it's not going to be one that I sing its praises from the rooftops oh yeah I think but it's it's a game where it's like this to me captured Doctor Who like it it understood the show and understood what fans liked about the show you know you have all your favorite monsters showing up you had cool planets you have the companions and the fun thing of playing different incarnations of the doctor or competing for the same companions is just I love it yeah yeah and and there's also that whole again emergent narrative thing going on in it which I thought was really good no I also really enjoyed playing that game and it's more they says you say as a Doctor Who fan if you got a peg ball game with Doctor Who fans it's kind of one of those things where there's not a lot to choose from and so when one comes out you imagine it's probably going to be bad because the not a lot to choose from and so you can I have to make do with biggest coming choices yeah yeah um and no it's actually really fun and yeah I probably would I knew you want to play it with

people who really Doctor Who fans I think it might not be super engaging for people who are old it's it's definitely more of a game that kind of requires you to have a bit of knowledge about the season I'm not sure cuz mechanically it's quite similar to say elder side I don't know if you need to read them as long as you get the ideal it mechanically yeah but I think phonetically also the enjoyment won't come from in the english-speaking world who hasn't least culturally picked up knowledge of some knowledge of doctor the US has yeah yeah anyway the BBC what did you mean the real West and that's the story of how this podcast got cancelled yeah young your sister bring up three games we like you know IP games I really do want to talk about the ones we like so start with yours alright well I did say it for my number one spot and it's War of the Ring from 2004 which of course we'll say he's a second edition I love bordering it's a game that I've loved playing every time I played that

I'll play it multiple times mostly with Jared it's great to play again it's asymmetric a lot of the things I loved about Star Wars rebellion I love about War of the Ring I feel a little bit silly that I've got two games that in some ways there's so many things about them there's similar that I love but they are different and I just I remember playing it and I think was probably the first asymmetric like proper asymmetric game I'd ever really play certainly long-form strategy game and I just it blew my mind when I first that you could have completely different goals for each side and even more than Star Wars rebellion those two goals there's two ways to win for each side but one's a lot easier for one side one's a lot easier for the other side and it's kind of this weird race to like which captures the feeling of the theme so well of you trying to story the ring before the shadow can overrun middle-earth or you can use the ring to fight the shadow like Boromir wanted and it can actually be quite effective if you play your cards right yeah literally yeah but ya know just great game that did some really cool things and also just evokes its theme so well yeah now that one's gonna be on my list as well but I absolutely I kind of knew you were gonna do rebellion as well I figured figure those two would be echoing exactly same thoughts yeah wonderful

game rebellion a war will ring out two of my top ten games of all time yeah just every time it's an experience it's a charm and they're great stories and my favorite one is still the game I played against you with the harem linking up bypassing Gondor which are activated and pushing through a row hard and ending up in the Grey Havens yes yes such a great game well played I think Jarrod's kept a record of every game we play there so the score at the moment I think is eleven nine to me yeah that makes me after twenty games that is a very close series yeah yeah yeah but no I'm looking forward to a nice romantic yeah all right and then I've got my top one and have you been paying attention to the channel over the last year you've probably heard me mention this game more than once it was my game of the year for last year and that is Matlock ox thunder the mers I don't know what it is about this game but I absolutely goddamn loved it I wasn't actually that big a Thunderbirds fan as a kid I mean I watched the show but it wasn't like I was about forward to Star Wars and Star Trek then I was into Thunder business even even by the time I was growing up in the 80s Thunderbirds was a bit kitsch and a bit dated the marionettes were still a bit stiff and stuff but holy hell does summer birds not only captures the the narrative and the theme and all the ideas that make up the Thunderbirds show it's also a really clever mix of

the pandemic style idea we've pick up and deliver and there's something so satisfying about okay well we're gonna move thunder bit to here and pick up thunder bit for and move it over there Angela and thinking like three turns ahead of where you need to deploy things and having them in the right place at the right time that's just [ __ ] scarce it's like such a satisfying game and I've played with people who don't really know the IP and I've played with absolute casual gamers who had not really played any games at all and it's worked with every group really interesting again how I read or - based on your recommendations because I'm a big fan of I was a big fan of embeds in this year and I both sort of agreed that we do really enjoy playing that game I put one of our other regular players was like a year it's an OK game and I was like what do you mean so it's very interesting when you like for him I think he just found I don't think it's really into cooperative games as much you gotta be him yeah and I and I think he was one of those rare people who kind of has like this predisposed prejudice against I still believe that well the reasons hasn't performed as well as the IPS even probably even more obscure than Doctor Who across me you know yeah and I imagine if it was rebranded as team of

America world police it could have a second life on the American market it's a very good point actually yeah I I've only played at the once on the paper with Jared in him I'm had a great time and one things I don't think I mention about actually is that um it's been so long since I've seen any of the source material that I kind of forgotten a large part of what it involved like to the point where as even the bits of it was a rescue show that really to me was like wait they go to other planets what crazy chick you know like ships that could carry like like airplanes they had like this dropship kind of like central core but you know I'd like that doesn't seem too far future tech but then it was like oh no it's near future well near future sci-fi and I was like Lady Penelope and Parker yeah like nearly every Commonwealth day guys like and go to people and because we were kissing district 9 earlier and putting a bit of shade on Twitter I'm gonna throw them some love love now and the Thunderbirds reboot TV show mmm Thunderbirds I go which is done with widow models and CG really fantastic reimagining of the show like it is a really good kid show I've

watched the first series and yeah absolutely top-notch um probably I'd also love to see potentially are3 skin for that hmm but again the commercial success of Thunderbirds I don't think we'll ever see anything like that which is a bit of a tragedy right so my last one was monolith games conan and batman games because they both basically the same yeah and I'm gonna be a bit of a shocker because a lot of people seem to feel that Conan was the better of the two games yes whereas I actually felt Batman Gotham Chronicles with better so I felt it had something more to it like genuinely like the Batman Gotham Chronicles game it's one I got rid of to me to you not because I just liked the game but just because these shelves are crumbling and it's it's a game that like you have to kind of really get a bit of a commitment to sit down and play it yeah and I think just pull it off the shelf I think gotta love the IP as well yeah yeah see because like a couple of my friends oh really big DC Comics fans and so the whole peel of being able to step into the shoes of your favorite DC Batman character and it does such a good job of making the skirmish feel like something out of the DC comic and you really you never feel like Batman's underpowered or anything you feel like everything's just at the right level bit it is really

nicely balanced I agree with that and I think the insurance system and the one spin thing works really really well there's a lot of exceptions in a Stephanie game that needed a hell of lot more reference cards and yeah that's a pieces to help no I had to print out a thing of the what each of the symbols mean yeah because while once you know what all of them mean you never have to look at those references again from a teaching people have a fire you can't spend the whole time sitting there going through and then this ability those blah blah blah you want to put something down from the player and just go look just read there yeah that tells you what you need to do and that's what your character does yeah so a little disclaimer before I make any comments cause actually which is the HTM played Batman cause but my understanding is that you're basically playing the heroes of the bit members versus the villains of the Batman voice right and usually one well two major villains and a whole mooks war sure but the point I was gonna make is that if you're going to have a game themed around the you know that sort of idea with superheroes then Batman is absolutely the right choice because as has been previously discussed too many conversations around the world I'm sure that been by far has the best cast of villains and so long and everyone kind of knows them to some extent and if you even if you don't that you kind of get it from the visual design alone yeah and so long as you've got the mechanics that jive with the theme of that particular villain I'm sure you'll have a really interesting adventure against that yeah two core boxes have a really beautiful display it's a striking

yet striking cover to a box because the hero's box has like all the classic Batman heroes and then they're mirrored on the other box with all the classic Batman villains and yeah it's exactly that it's like it's the spot your favorite yeah kind of image and I think that's also really great example of art for an IP game of being able to just with your cover alone evoke a feeling of I want to open this box and play this game and if there's one thing you cannot argue about Batman Gotham chronicles is if you put those boxes then a room of gamers inevitably someone opens it up and just wants to pass it around inside it oh my god I want to see what's in this in this box an invite I mean my friend Simon was just he couldn't keep his hands off it this is my opportunity to do my usual joke to Simon which is Simon couldn't keep his hands off my box say look I've got I'm gonna have at least won't want to show anyone still listening

all right so closing thoughts for us on IP games so I think the things that have come through hooking into that idea that the game is not necessarily retailing the story that it's on Rails but that it allows you to recreate your own take on that story so it's not playing history it's retelling history it's not playing the story to examine story yeah and it's taking the world that's available and giving you access to it rather than just running you through whatever thoughts of you guys got the clothes off on that um well I'll jump in with um every intellectual property every story has a theme and if your mechanics when you're building a board game for their IP don't evoke that theme which is kind of what you're saying but slightly different um then actively why even bother ya know like these are the you know these are things that we tell ourselves as a society to reflect on the human condition and yeah you need to evoke that otherwise you need to choose you from that thing yeah so why would you make judge Street the accounting game yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah Bango even arguably why would you make just read the literally nothing more than Street Kombat game yeah which you could see someone making oh they're probably go but why bother

yeah you know that's not that's not the theme of their IP no yeah and that's the the thing I I've been saying most of this podcast probably is people don't want to play the show or the book or the white of the eye piece off right they don't want to play what they'd seen read they want to play and yeah what they seen already and so your games got to make them the game has got to be this feels like this show this feels like this story but it's not it's doing something different but you still feel like this could have been how that story could have gone and I think that's often what people prefer there oh my lord we've basically describes IP games as they should be interactive fan fiction generators yes people I these two secrets lightly there's a lot of criticism that fan fiction gets from certain corners of the of the internet for one to be a tomb and it's interesting because I mean I don't read fanfiction a country to fanfiction but I can respect the idea which is that it's a creative form of fandom yeah you love something and you want to create something with it and I can't I can't vote that in a lot of ways what's making a role-playing game you've read the world of exalted you've read the world of Star Wars yeah if you're running a role-playing game inside and establish seating you're writing fanfiction oh yeah absolutely and this is a bad thing

no no no but this is also a problem that a lot of IP role-playing games run into is like if you're if you pick an IP that is so fixated that is so reliant on the narrative that it tells yeah then it's really hard to make a solid role-playing game out of it because people are like what are we doing and the to I want to jump in straightaway and point out for that middle-earth role-playing mmm and the Babylon 5 role-playing game the narratives and those two stories are so strong what are we going to be yeah we can be ranges and both of them yeah you can be ranges faffing about somewhere while the important stuff happens else off screen where Star Wars has got the city guys we have this big galaxy you you you can tell other stories in that setting and that's what game video games have shown is that there's so many of the stories in the Star Wars universe and Star Trek is the same it is like there is nothing about any of the Star Trek shows that means that nobody else can be going out and having adventures in this universe and I think that's a thing that a lot of IP at people looking to get an IP for a game needs to consider that is what's what's the hook what's what's gonna draw people in it if it's only repeating a story that's already being told then why are you doing this and war of the ring is a great example of going ok let's not just

repeat the story that's told let's give players the freedom to break loose of that story that's why for all my love of war of the Ring I have not gotten the new Fantasy Flight Games middle of the pitch again oh really yeah cuz I'm like oh cool will be Rangers and stuff passing around the edges of the story more of the Rings and epic yeah this allows me to retell the epic mm-hmm your Hobbit game you mentioned earlier that does not let you retell the epic yeah I can only barely remember it it was something to do with like you have four troll minis and I don't know why and you had to keep circling them until you did something right and you can move into the next circle we could do and I just don't know why leeches are quite good actions and it's apparently what they get useful because the people who owned it still owned it it's in they've got the Box still in their cupboard somewhere but they've stripped it over the minis because their daughters just love playing with the miniatures well I guess some joy came from it I always loved a heavy so that brings us to the end of the show I'd like to thank my co-host gautama kick yeah yeah I'd like to thank our special guests for today Proserpine thank phrase for coming on board

I hope the experience was all that you feared it would be thank you very much for having me I was expecting us a subtle one that's not true I was expecting in addition of roast Fraser slightly I got what I expected below us a really good time yeah I have to ask do we ever really do saw fool's errand no not really no no these podcasts are going to be infrequent and irregular so I'm not going to tell you when the next one's gonna be up because I have no idea can it has no idea no one has any idea we don't know who's going to be the next guest and we don't know what the next topics going to be so that's probably going to be discussed with my people on patreon thank you all for listening this will be available as a podcast somewhere else at a later date I will post that below in the comments and you enjoyed this podcast like it subscribe to the channel and support us on patreon

Progress saved