Gloomhaven: Buttons & Bugs Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Gloomhaven: Buttons & Bugs
Reviewers agree that Buttons & Bugs is a small-footprint spin-off of the Gloomhaven series, but they split on whether that reduced scale is a strength. Colin of Meet Me at the Table is the most enthusiastic voice in the sample. Across a solo campaign playthrough and a Pub Crawlers expansion session, Colin treats the game as a tense, well-built tactical puzzle that suits solo play. 3 Minute Board Games takes a middle position, calling the game legitimately deep for a small-box release while noting that it contains less content than the larger entries in the series.
Board Games Unlocked is the clear dissenter. Its reviewers ranked the game among the worst releases of 2024, argued that the design feels watered down for a solo travel product, and questioned why it was made at all. Your Board Game News offered a more tentative endorsement, with Matthew expressing interest in picking up a copy. The overall picture is a game that rewards players who want a compact Gloomhaven-style fight and disappoints those who expected the full series depth in a smaller box.
Core Mechanics That Define Gloomhaven: Buttons & Bugs
Fixed Attack Modifier Die
Enemy attacks are resolved by rolling a modifier die whose faces are fixed, rather than flipping through a shuffled modifier deck. Colin highlights this as a practical advantage. Because the outcomes are known in advance, Colin can plan around them, something that is harder when a deck of 20 or 30 cards might produce any result. Board Games Unlocked sees the same design as static, arguing that a fixed range of outcomes removes the tension that makes combat memorable.
Element-Driven Card Play
Cards carry elemental icons, such as Earth, that can be spent to strengthen attacks or unlock secondary effects. Many cards are dual-sided, so a card used for one effect is flipped to its other side for the next, which means each turn involves choosing which half of a card to use. Colin notes that the element rules are a little confusing at first, though Colin works through them during play. The system rewards careful sequencing, since spending an element early can leave a stronger option unavailable later in the round.
The Gloomhaven: Buttons & Bugs Experience
Tight Tactical Pressure
Colin's solo sessions feel close and punishing. Mice and other small enemies swarm the board, retaliation punishes melee attacks made from adjacent hexes, and health totals fall quickly. In one fight Colin drops to three health while still trying to finish the last enemy, and the tension comes from weighing each attack against what it costs to stay alive. Reviewers who enjoy this kind of positional pressure describe the rounds as absorbing, with obstacles, wounds, and muddle markers all demanding attention at once.
Small-Box Restraint
The game is built to fit a compact footprint, and that restraint shapes how it feels at the table. Board Games Unlocked praises the minimal rule set but argues that the lean design leaves little room for variety, so each session can feel like a repeat of the last. 3 Minute Board Games reads the same restraint as the source of its depth, treating the limited components as a deliberate choice rather than a shortfall. Which reaction a player has depends largely on whether they expected a scaled-down Gloomhaven or a standalone tactical game.
What Makes Gloomhaven: Buttons & Bugs Stand Out
Credible Solo Play
Colin's recordings make solo play the game's most convincing feature. Colin works through multiple scenarios, including the Pub Crawlers expansion, and presents the solo format as a natural fit rather than a compromise. For players who want a Gloomhaven-style campaign without arranging a group, that focus on one-player play is the main reason reviewers recommend the game.
Portable Scale
The game's small box makes it easy to carry, and 3 Minute Board Games groups it with other small-box releases that repay a second look. Board Games Unlocked, despite its negative verdict, describes it as a travel-sized game, which confirms that its portability is clear even to critics. Players who value a tactical game they can take to a cafe or a trip get a format the larger series cannot match.
Potential Drawbacks
A Watered-Down Feel
The most pointed criticism comes from Board Games Unlocked, which argues that the game feels thinned out compared with the core series. Its reviewers say the design lacks the weight of Gloomhaven, that the spin-off was not needed, and that the money might have been better spent elsewhere. Their objections center on scale and ambition rather than on any single rule, so players who accept the reduced scope may find this criticism less relevant.
Component Quality and Repetition
Board Games Unlocked, in a separate review, calls the card quality poor and says the game felt repetitive across sessions. Reviewers who value production quality in a tabletop product flag this as a real concern, particularly given the price relative to the content. The repetition complaint links back to the fixed modifier and the lean rules, which some players find satisfying and others find static.
If You Enjoy Gloomhaven: Buttons & Bugs
Players who enjoy the tactical positioning and element management of Buttons & Bugs will find the fuller experience in the original Gloomhaven, where the same core systems are developed across a much larger campaign. 3 Minute Board Games points to Jaws of the Lion as a closer comparison, since it keeps much of the series feel while reducing scope. Readers who like the compact, solo-friendly format should compare both options before deciding how much scale they want from a Gloomhaven-style game.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"I really like this system for the attack modifier. I find it very different from flipping the cards and I actually kind of like it because I know what my chances are of each thing."
— Colin, Meet Me at the Table
"Some of these games are legitimately deep like I kind of banged on about it but buttons and bugs is legitimately deep."
— 3 Minute Board Games
"This just did not need to exist in my opinion like I don't know who was screaming for small Gloom Haven."
— Board Games Unlocked