The Best $100 Board Game Collection — Who did it better?
Transcript
I give Iron Man a 4.75 out of five. What? What do you give it? 4.75. That's nearly a five. That's almost a perfect score. I love it. What would you give it? What did I give Captain America to start? Four. Well, yeah. I changed to a four, right? Okay. I think I like Iron Iron Man a little bit more. I give it a 4.2. Oo, high scores. Hello everyone. Welcome back to Foster the Mele, a channel all about games and board game. Exactly. Today we are doing part one of a two-part series and that is building a game collection. Today's video is building a collection for $100.
Not easy. Not easy. Second video will be for $1,000. Almost too easy. Too easy. We probably should have compromised somewhere in the middle. But we wanted to just like 500. Yeah. We we could we we wanted to show you kind of like this is what $100 can get you in our opinion. What we believe is like a decent in Canadian dollars without tax. In Canadian dollars, no tax, no shipping. Hey, it's a great sale. No tax, no shipping. Uh and we use Board Game Bliss. And if it was on sale on Board Game Bliss, that's the number. That's the number. So, you better get on it. Uh, and then the next video is going to be our thousand collection. Um, so few things to note. The first is I don't know if you knew this, but we're actually Board Game Bliss affiliates. We are. So, there's a link in the description where you can buy from Board Game Bliss. You'll get a little bit of money off and then we get a small percentage of commission. We get a little bit of a kickback. Uh, which is fun. So, if you're interested, that link is below. $100 collection. I don't know what your approach was. Was your approach just as many games as possible?
No. Mine wasn't either. That was my initial approach. And I was like, you could buy this expansion for later. For later. But it's really freaking hard. Yeah. To find games for a cheap price point that aren't card games. Yes. So, anyways, let's get into it. I think mine ended up coming in at like 9950 or something like that. 9576. There you go. And also, I want to like I know people are going to be like, "Throw in a deck of cards." And it's like, okay. Yeah, we get it. You can throw in a deck of cards and play a 100 different card games. I just didn't do it. I didn't do it either. I did have a deck of cards on literally not the point. It's just for fun, people. This isn't actually happening. Sometimes, Cho, when you are a man, you wear sweats. You wear sweats. Are these good? It's just for fun. Yeah, they taste like fruit leather. Um, I think the best way to do this is one person gives their full list and then the second person gives their full list. And in the comments, we would like for you to decide who you think Oh, that'll just has the better list.
There's too many biased people. People love you, Jeff. There's too many biased people for me to ever have a shot at any of these, even if I objectively have the better list. Be objective, just like we are when we make top 10 videos. Yes. Easy, easy does it. Would you like to go first? Sure. Okay. First and foremost, I needed to pick a game that I thought like you can't buy a board game that's not a card game for less than like 30 bucks. I got one. Okay, sure. But for the most part, like most board games in like in the traditional sense of like it has meeples and a board and whatever is going to cost you like 30 bucks minimum. Yeah, 30 realistically 40. So, I was I was realistically trying to find the cheapest board game that would give me that substance. Sure. That's not just a card game, whatever. Uh, so I decided for $32.95 from Pandasaurus Games to buy Brew. Brew Baby. Brew is a And why I picked Brew specifically is because it's a very mean game. Uh, and we really like mean games.
That was my version of like a chunkier experience. Y and Brew is beautiful. It's got beautiful components and was at a decent price point. But again, that still chews up like almost uh it is basically a third of the entire budget. Yeah. For that one game. From there, uh I was like, okay, well, I I did it in terms of like I want some variety in terms of types of games. So, Brew is like my traditional like board game experience with a little bit more thinkiness to it. The next three are kind of like partyish games, but not really. I did end up grabbing Flip Seven. Okay. Uh, and that that probably came in a bit higher than I needed it to. 20.95. Yeah. I mean, it's the greatest card game on earth. It is great. Um, and right out of the box, I did bulk at the price tag a little. Not that I don't think the game is valuable. No, but when you're building when you're building $100 list, like that's expensive for a card game. But that has so it has so many applications that I had to include it. Like I could play that with our families. I could bring it to a con.
Like we could play it with friends. It's always going to be a good time regardless of who you play that game with in my opinion. So you got two games in your two games and I'm I'm over half of my budget. Games are One of them is this big. Games are pricey, man. In Canada for for sure. Yeah. Facts. Um, and I just I also want to state though like Board Game Bliss has great prices in comparison to most other stores. So like these are considered like these are good prices, but it's like Yeah, I wouldn't you wouldn't be able to get these prices at a normal brick and mortar. No, it do be luxury hobby. It do be luxury. Yeah. Uh, next up is another small box card game that I think I've played a so much of that the the I always look at things in terms of ROI, which I should, but uh, Sea Salt and Paper is another one that I was like, I have to include this. I almost put on a list. It came in at $15.95, which is a much better deal in my opinion than Flip 7, but is a different game. Um, and we've played Seaw on paper at 2, three, and four. It plays great at all. Um, this doesn't include the expansion, but you could build on your on your collection later. You could build on your collection later. But Cesaw on paper is a really really enjoyable like set collection uh race to points game that uh there was just for the price tag, you get so much return on that game. It's so good and you can play it so many times. Every game's going to feel different. And it's 15 bucks. Had to almost put on my list, but it got cut. I only have two more. Yeah. Which is wild. So, I only got five games for $100, which is crazy. This one was just
like at that lower price point that we've played and have had a ton of fun with. I wanted something with with like dice. Sure. Uh, Brew has dice, but you're not like rolling dice to the same degree. Has dice and you're going to like play brew now that you're talking about. Yeah, I know. Me, too. Uh, but I wanted something with dice because I think it's like it just dice have a great feel. They're really fun to roll. People get it. Yeah. You can make your own other games with this. Yeah. And so I grabbed Sausage Sizzle probably on your list, too. I saw the little like there all of these games are around 10 bucks. There's like zombie dice and all of these other things. So, I'm sure Jamie grabbed something in that realm. This one came in at $11.95. Sausage Sizzle is steal is a push your luck sausage themed game. It's chaotic fun, but I wanted something that's just silly uh and has some dice and you can just chuck dice and have some fun. Last one up for me. Uh, I needed to have a trick taker and I knew that you could pro like most of the trick takers I enjoy are hard to get unfortunately. Um, but I wanted something that I knew I could enjoy with you particularly because in this world it's probably going to be the two of us. So, I gamed I grabbed Claim.
Uh, Claim came in at $13.95, which I think is a phenomenal deal. And again, it's the base uh traditional version of Claim. M um and but I I just could not get through this list without having some form of trick taker. And a lot of them are pretty pricey. Like I think skullking was was there as well and it was close to 20 bucks. And I was having a little bit of a hard time justifying that one when I was like well I can get claim for almost half of that. Yeah. Um but that's it. I mean that those five games come in at 9576. And I wasn't going to bother trying to I mean it's realistically what is that? $4. You're not getting $4.24. Yeah. I went through the site and I was like, what comes in under five and it's not nothing. So, that's my list. So, we have uh Brew, Flip Seven, Sea Salt and Paper, Sausage, Sizzle, and Claim. Yeah.
Which again little lineup. Yeah. It's I didn't not if you had asked me before I did this like what I thought my list was going to be. It wouldn't have been that. No. I honestly don't think I've realized how much I know how much board game costs, but sometimes we we like we don't buy a ton anymore. And when we do, we buy a bulk of games that I think I lose concept at the individual. Convention as an example. Yeah. We're like, "Oh, we just dropped $300 on board games." And like we don't quantify it the same way. when you only have like a limited like budget and how much you have to make that stretch out. It would actually be a really interesting challenge to like go to a convention with $100 $100 bill and see how far you can get to the pandering do the the bartering like Dwight does.
Yeah. Be like, "Okay, well, what can I do for this?" Take this paper clip and walk out of here with the best item that would be and he walks out with Jim's magical beans or whatever. Okay, so that is Chef's List. How did you do it? Did you like mark down a bunch and then start cutting some? No, I legitimately like I was doing the math in my head as I went. So, I actually um I started with the first two or three uh smaller games. Mhm. And then I I got to the point where I was like, so basically what I did, I I got three of the smaller card games. I was like, "Okay, what's that put me at?" And I was like, "Well, I need I need a bigger box game with a little bit of chunk to it." So, I went in like the $30 range. Yeah. and grabbed brew. And I was like, "Okay, what do I have left?" Yeah. And then after that, I was like, "Okay, what can I get for that?" And then I looked in that price tag and grabbed uh another one. I had a bit of a different method. So, we'll go into mine now. I went on Board Game Bliss and I just put lowest to highest. I did that as well.
And so, I just started going through and anytime that I saw a game that like, yeah, I would consider putting this on, I write it down and put the whatever. So, I can kind of tell you what got cut from my list as well. Anyways, let's start. Um, the problem with doing that though, I'm curious. When you did lowest to high, I was like, "Oh my god." It was like five pages of expansions. It was like so much hostage negotiator. I was like, "Oh my god, hostage negotiator." Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So, okay. I am going to go I'll go low to high. You went high to low. I'll go low to high. So, the first game that is going to be in my $100 collection is a party game and it is a smaller version of a game that we love. We do own this game and that is Tapple 10. Oh, yeah. Yeah. Okay. Tapple 10 is a version of Tapple that doesn't come with the toy factor cards. $9.95.
So, I think actually that is a that's a really good steal because Tappo is a super fun party game and I believe Tapple 10 you could play solo even which I think is great. So, that was my first one. My second one is going to be Sausage Shashage. Sausage. I figured that was going to I knew it was that one or the zombie the Walking Dead one. Yeah. So, Sausage Sizzle is $1.95. This is It's a great deal. It's a great It's a great deal. Like, if you don't already own that game, like that is a game that I'd be like, "Yeah, it's super fun. It's like a push your luck game. It's cute. Anybody can play it. You could play it. It plays just as fun at two players as it does at more players. And so, it's really versatile and an excellent price. Then I wanted to get another game that is kind of like a card game. Um, because it is a card game and it's a bit of a unique game. I want to get a game that's kind of like a card game, but it is a card game. It is a card game and it's a classic and that's Hannabi. I almost included Hannabi. So Hannabi is $11.95. You see, you're pandering now. Why? You're pandering to the Cuz people love Hannabi. Sure. It's so unique. Now you have a unique game in your collection. You're pandering to the get. I'm going for a versatile collection. Jamie's not going for the best. She's going for like the votes.
She's not going for speaking to Wait till you see what I was like. Yeah. Okay. But Hannabi is a great game. Basically, you play your cards opposite and people are you're trying to like put out cards in the right order and kind of like the mindesque, but I find this one better. Yeah. Honestly, this one is just fun. Sorry. Terrible. Um, then we're going to start bumping up in price. I have three more games on my list. So, I have a total of six. Okay. The next one I came across and I was like, "Oh, this is like almost a miniature board game." And it's a game that we freaking love. And that is bottom of the ninth. So, uh, I saw I saw the expansion to that. Uhhuh. And almost included it. Yeah. And I didn't because I felt like Sausage Sizzle took that realm of rolling dice.
And no, but the I'm just pissed because I didn't pick it realistically. So, Bottom of the Ninth comes in at $17.95. Such a great deal. And this is a it is a solo and two-player game where one player plays as the home team, one is the away, one is the pitcher, one is the hitter, and there's a cards that you're going to be playing out and dice that you're going to be rolling and doing all these things to try and score runs or to knock people out. That's a great pick. It is. So, and it has a real time element like when you're doing like home runs and stuff. It is just such a I'm just pissed that I didn't pick it. I should have and is genuinely a game that we both really enjoy. Okay. Yeah, I should have picked I could have picked that instead of Seesaw on paper and been fine. Yeah. Dumb. Uh, next up on my list, now this is a solo only game, but I do believe you could play it co-op.
Oh, you lost me then. This is Gloom Haven Buttons and Bugs. You want that big campaign experience in a tiny little box and it only takes 20 minutes to play up. Gloom Haven Buttons and Bugs comes in at $21.95 for people who want the Gloom Haven experience but don't want the master. You were up here with Bottom of the Ninth. I listen, I've not played Buttons and Bugs, but I'm just saying 20 bucks for that little pack. But you're getting a Gloom Haven experience. You get Battle Crest or something for from Buttonshy? Nah. Last but not least. Yeah. What's your chunky boy? Last but not least, we have what I deem to be a classic. We we own. Now, this is buildable. Let's just keep that in mind. This is buildable experience. Unmatched Houdini versus Genie and it's coming in at $25.95 and you have an unmatched set.
And then you play this and you're like, "Oo, this is fun." And then later when you get another $100, $100, then you could go and get more unmatched. You cater to a very heavy two-player experience or two players. Tapple 10, Sausage, Sizzle, Hannabi, all your chunky game. You picked unmatched. Yeah, that's wild. Find find another friend with unmatched and then you could play with more than two players. No, that's a loophole. No, it's just science. But that is my collection. And the math on that uh I did have, but now I do not. 9.95. People should drop your vote at unmatched. Unmatched is incredible. I just think in this in this environment as a bad pick, but this is like I like this collection. I would be happy with my little collection here. That's all that matters. Exactly. Doesn't matter what the vote voters think, but they should. But listen listen to this.
$99.70. I got six games. This guy didn't even spend the last was $5. He's pocketing it away from you. Smart. Keeping Keep that in mind. He only got five games. That's smart. That's like the lemon. That's like the lemonade stand. $20 on flip seven. You could have had bottom of the ninth for 175. Um, oh, and I was gonna tell everybody the games that I was considering but dropped off for one of my $20 games I was considering Cgraphers was 23.95. Full Throttle I had a really hard time cutting, but I ended up cutting it. It was $180. Uh, the I also had four sales. Full Throttle is only 18 bucks. Yeah, 1881. Uh, for sale travel edition I had was 16.95. I did have sea salt and paper, but I kind I almost did welcome too. I had any kind of ugly uh any kind of buttonshy game, but I picked ugly Griffin in for $15.95. And then I did for a while had Disney villains the card game. I had that for a bit, too. That's a great little game. Yeah. Oh, I already had 9970 written down. Freaking idiot.
It's right there, dummy. Anyways, those are our $100 collections. It is. We should do a $10,000 collection. I'm just kidding. That would be insane. What do you like? You would just like all you would do is take your top 50 games and be like, "Okay, how many of these can seriously tell me when serious?" I'm going to start again. Anyways, those are our $100 collections. I would love to know in the comments below, who do you think made the better collection? Who helped you make your money go further? You screwed up with Unmatched. I screwed up with Flip 7. But I'm also wondering if Flip 7 was $20 cuz it was the promotional one, which is harder to find. This should be cheaper though cuz it's smaller. Doesn't matter. You let us know who had the better collection. I'm pissed about bottom of the ninth. Let us know why it was me. See, if I had picked bottom of the ninth instead of flip seven. Yeah, I don't regret picking fix flip seven. Sure. I want to be clear, but I feel like I would have annihilated you. I think I've I made it close. That is everything that we have for you all today. I do want to give a shout out to our April sponsors, only then Studios.
They have a new game coming out next month called Dark Leaf Gambit. You're going to have some coverage coming on it soon and I'm going to have the all of the information listed in the description below, including you can try it out yourself on Tabletop Simulator if you are so interested. You follow the campaign, do all of that fun stuff. You may recognize the name because they had a game called Wicked Cribage, which could go on this list, but they didn't have it on board game list. That's But you need a crib board. Everybody has one. Oh, everybody everybody has one. You get them at the dollar store. Do you know what's interesting? What? Um, so when we were in Washington, Yeah. Americans don't ever call it crib. I shouldn't say Americans, but like I'm generalizing, but every American we've been around when we say crib, they're like, "What are you talking about?" Oh, they just call it cribage. Cribage. Because Rodney and I were talking about crib. And uh Sam and uh Charlie had no idea what we were talking about. Really? And we were like, "Cribage." And I'm like, "Oh, yeah." And and then Rodney and I were like, "People don't call crib. That's weird." And I've never heard they've never heard it called crib. And Rodney both agreed like no. Nobody calls it cribage. Yeah. If I went home and was like, "Hey dad, you want to play cribage?" You'd be like, "Me crib?"
Yeah. Crib. If you're interested in buying board games with your Crisp 100, your Canadian 100, which by the way is plastic and basically indestructible. Can't even goes through the wash. Can't go through the wash and everything. It's crazy. You should first start by checking your friendly local gaming store. And for us, that is the Boardroom Game Cafe. Oh, heck yeah, it is. And if you like what you see, please subscribe. We hope to see you again soon. And now we say goodbye. Goodbye. Later days. Uh, okay. Ready? No. Right on. Forgot my list. Hop along, Bunny. Money. I love that you changed thinking that was a strategic thing. No. No. No. Do you want to know why I did? Cuz I'm cold and I would rather be wearing my sweater. It was making my hair janky in a way that was driving me nuts cuz my hair was like doing this. Got it. And I didn't like it. I just want one for the coffee. To get the coffee taste out of my mouth. I want one. Ew. Did Ben bring these? Yeah, it's fruit leather. Ben brought these.
Well, he got them at the grocery store. This is such a Ben thing. Oh, yeah. They're actually pretty good. M. I understand the Well, here's a fruit leathery. Here's a fun fact. Jeff went to Tims. We got some coffees from Timmy's. Proudly Canadian. Um and uh they didn't have any freaking Timbits. Yep. It was so much better when I was a kid when it was just coffee and donuts. I agree 100%. Mhm. The the the cash the Yeah. They didn't have debit forever. The downhill trajectory of Tim Hortons was fast. Directly correlated to Burger King buying them. Yep. Correct. Do you think this is still good? Ew. No, Jeff. That's old. Yuck.
Still got caffeine in it. Cribage. C R I BB A G E. Okay, I spelled it right. Anyways, okay. So, those are a cribage board. Those things are so expensive. That would blow your budget right there. Anyways,