Jack's Top 10 Greatest Combative Area Control Games
Transcript
Hey folks, it's Jack from the Cardboard Herald and today we are doing a top 10 list. This is a good day for a top 10 list. Well, really whenever you're running a channel, every day is pretty much a good day for a top 10 list and maybe we don't do them as much as we should. For me personally, it's just a good way of kind of thinking about my history and relationship to specific sets of games, use case scenarios for different types of games, genres of games, and recently I have been thinking a lot about combative area control. Some people call it dudes on a map, some people call it conflict games, some people call it war games, which is really kind of another thing, but I've been thinking about it because we're about to be covering Blood Rage: Valhalla on this channel and we don't have that yet, so that's not going to be on this list, but it's got the wheels spinning nonetheless. But first, hey, we got a couple rules and a couple honorable mentions.
First off, no repeat entries by the same designer. You know those designers who specialize in this type of game and I could have an entire list dominated by one or two designers, which we'll get a bit into as we go on. And second, I'm defining combative area control in a way that I'm kind of taking away some of the area control that's more Euro in nature. Like this is the stompy, rough, battling it out on a map type of area control, not necessarily military control, but it is your units going into places, you're gaining control of area, you're getting a foothold, you're somehow rewarded for that, and there's going to be some sort of attrition between both sides.
Now, for honorable mentions, we got a couple things here. Recently I covered Pond on this channel. I love it. I think it is a great [snorts] new take on this whole concept where you are putting out permanent infrastructure and rather than destroying what people have, you are gaining points for batting on their primary units. They're their big structural units, so they're long frogs in that case. But, I think it's a really clever game. I think it does a lot of cool stuff to blend this genre with deck building, but it's also so new that I can't really rank it on this list. If I were doing this again in a couple years, it might be on there. Then we have Reiner Knizia's iconic Tigris and Euphrates or Yellow and Yangtze or Huang Long. There's there's a lot of ways that we could talk about this game, but because it's currently not in print, it's about to be in print. It recently had crowdfunding, but it doesn't cleanly fit into my concept for what this genre is, but it undoubtedly would be one that I'd try to leverage into this list if it were currently available, but it's not.
So, it's not currently on this list. And then third, Undaunted in all its iterations is incredible, but I view that more solidly in the war game camp. There's definitely an argument to be made that there's a lot of overlap and DNA here, which is why I'm putting it on an honorable mention. And if you like these types of games, there's a really good chance that you're going to like Undaunted or its kind of cousin War Chest by the same designers, but nonetheless, it didn't fit really into the core concept here. So, Undaunted honorable mention, you should check it out. Okay, number 10 on here is one of the most recent games on this list, which is Roth. Uh insanely colored psychedelic trip of a brawly stompy area control game that can be distilled into about 45 minutes or less. It is bright, it is flashy, and it takes out all the in-between setup stagnation and getting you straight into conflict. It's not particularly nuanced in how the combat itself resolves, but it's one of those games that the more that you play, the more you glean just how much you can leverage against your opponent's and force their hands in their specific moves. I really like the action drafting system, but of course the incredibly impressive Exodus action where you can sacrifice two of your
precious actions to just spread all about the board. And speaking of which, a board that is so deceptively connected is really interesting here. The asymmetric powers of the different factions are cool and fun to play with in ways that makes it seem a little bit hard [snorts] to guess balance, but because of the game plays in such a short amount of time, that's never proved to be much of a problem for me. It's easy to table, and it's easy to teach, but it brings me a lot of the best feelings of kind of the back half of a great area control combative game. So, it makes a place on this list. Number nine is Small Samurai Empires, which is a great blend of area control as well as programming. It has a lot of DNA with a later game on this list, but the sequential resolution of that programming is really interesting in a game that is overall pretty rules light.
When you're resolving the individual actions, whether it's move, produce units, combat, it's very straightforward and easy to understand, but the ability to pivot what you are utilizing that for, especially based off of how you were planning it early on, and then the hidden plans within plans as you kind of set up the different actions that are going to be resolved in that south to north and north to south resolution in Japan is just really [clears throat] fascinating. I find the game is better than its small moniker seems to put it as. I feel like that's kind of like this weird cash in that it could fit in with the Tiny Epic series. I don't really find anything particularly small about it, and I think it's a game that deserves a lot more attention than it actually gets.
Number eight is a historical war game, combat of game, area control game, and that's Votes for Women, my favorite game that Fort Circle has put out to date. This is a two-player, one-to-two player game in which you are either playing as the suffragist movement or the anti-suffragist politically battling it out in the American 1800s following the Civil War, following very exact moments in history in interesting ways that each player can unfold to hopefully lead to the either passing or the suppression of the ability for women to vote if you're playing on the anti-suffragist side, but that's just the breaks in these types of games. It's incredibly well researched. It's very fun to play. It has an interesting and completely unique theme compared to so many of the games on this list, and it's completely engaging throughout. And I love that there's this very real-world balancing act that's happening between the financial operations and keeping momentum going for your movement, as well as the moments of intersectionality that are coming along with other civil rights that is going to play into the ultimate final vote. It's a very cool game. It's a very clever game and very worthwhile being on this list.
Number seven is a little bit less heavy, and that's Ahoy, a game of piracy, asymmetric powers, and just trying to get points on the high seas. A lot of people think of it as kind of the poppier version of Root, but I think the reasoning for that is more to do with the publisher, as well as Kyle Ferrin's artwork, than it is the actual gameplay itself. Yes, you got asymmetric powers. Yes, you have those cosmetic relationships, but here this game is so focused on just getting you involved in the combat and the control of each individual tile, and that is the primary thrust and drive of everything that you're doing. Yeah, there are the smugglers who are kind of doing another thing, but only within the operations of the combat and conflict that sets up the core pillars of what's going on. It's even better with the expansions that have come out. I think it's beautiful, immersive, and just looks great as it sprawls out on the table and develops as the players are adding tiles. Very cool game.
Number six, well, let's go from something that's a little bit more focused to the ultimate chunker, and that is Eclipse Second Edition. I have been a long-time stan for Eclipse since I very first played it when it first came out absolutely ages ago. Eclipse is just one of those base that I'm going to hold on to, and Eclipse Second Edition is, no doubt, one of the best 4X space conflict-heavy games that you're going to get, period. It is so interesting and nuanced, and the adaptive technology that you are trying to structure around both the MPC opponents as well as what your real-world opponents, the the other players are doing is unparalleled in anything else that I've played. How much you hone and shape and adapt and counter-adapt each of your technologies, whether it's your movement, your shields, your your you know, like capacity for missiles, your cannons, and then the alien technologies that are introduced and then adding to that the sprawling board that's developing out in front of you. It's not a quick game.
It's not an easy to learn game, but it is one of the richest and most satisfying game experiences that I've ever had.
Number five is Ironwood, another more recent game, which I think was kind of an interesting inclusion on this list. I went back and forth on whether or not I wanted to put it within the scope, but ultimately I kept coming back to because yes, you are playing two divergent games. One side, the Ironclad, are really trying to focus on just honing in and making their towers. There's resource management, you're kind of shifting things around. The other side, they are just hopping through the woods, occupying different spaces, and playing kind of peekaboo, capture the flag type of game. But success in all of those things is directly related to being able to hold on to specific areas, to navigate specific areas, and doing a lot of conflict. And though the two sides never occupy the same spaces, their own spaces are directly related completely to the management of the others. It's really heady, it's interesting, and what it's one of those games that rewards a lot of replay.
Helps that it's also completely beautiful with some iconic components within. Huge fan of Ironwood.
Number four is one that you're just never going to break my nostalgia for, and that's Game of Thrones second edition. This is peak fantasy Flight Games old-school just big stompy gaming. And when I was talking about Small Samurai Empires having some DNA, well, I think that it's really that it distills some of the concepts of Game of Thrones second edition into a much smaller game. Well, we're going back to the OG here, which I completely love. And some of that is influenced by the fact that I am a huge fan of George R.R. Martin's works. So, thematically, it really speaks to me, but even still, there's nothing quite like a six-player game upon Westeros where you're having to manage with the the political relationships, making sure supply lines are addressed, making sure that you're able to manage your troops, and then having the sort of fog of war as you're programming out your different combative capabilities. Some of the best, most surprising moments I've ever had at a table. Some of the biggest upheavals, some of the most memorable times I've had with my friends have been sitting playing Game of Thrones second edition.
And the not recent, but most recent expansion, uh Mother Dragons, I think, really adds some new elements to the game that if you haven't visited since that, I think it really makes it a little bit more modern. Not truly modern, but a little bit more in line with what current gaming tastes are. Number three is Kemet: Blood on the Sand. Hey folks, editor Jack here coming in to say first off, yeah, I flubbed it. It should be Kemet: Blood and Sand. And second, I don't know what happened to my Kemet: Blood and Sand folder for my B-roll. I keep a library of B-roll at my original Kemet folder for B-roll, and I've covered Kemet: Blood and Sand on this channel, but I don't know. I also don't own the game because one of my best gaming buddies is like all in on Kemet, and I didn't find it necessary to be redundant on it. So, enjoy some B-roll from the original Kemet, and yeah, back to the vid. And I think of this as just one of the greatest examples of taking a game that was already fantastic and taking the the iteration that has happened through expansions and new concepts, as well as other games in its vein, and just re-honing it into the best possible killing machine it can be.
Kemet is so interesting and so bloodthirsty, and the power escalation as you acquire the different upgrades is the closest thing on this list to the adaptive power upgrades that I was talking about with Eclipse. It's nowhere near as nuanced, but it's certainly much more accessible. And Kemet is just one of the all-time greatest brawlers. Maintaining your pyramids, how those pyramids relate to points, how it relates to powers, maintaining your power escalation, how everything is so close together, and to achieve anything, you have to put yourself into vulnerable positions. Kemet is undoubtedly just one of those designs that is always going to withstand the test of time. It's iconic, it's interesting, and Blood on the Sand just helps it feel incredibly fresh.
Number two, if I was talking about this game being inspired by Blood Rage Valhalla coming on the horizon, well, it's because I really love Blood Rage. Uh it's a game that has had an interesting trajectory in our own household. It's one that to get it to the table more often got reskinned as Spicy Vikings, which has its own lineage and maybe I can talk about that more on the Blood Rage video, but this is one where it's a game that I think epitomized the transition that was happening in the mid-2010s from the classic Ameritrash versus Euro arguments into Wait a second. Why why do we got to have these barriers? But nonetheless, I think Blood Rage is the one that still holds up the most over time. I love the drafting mechanism, the immediacy of everything, and the kind of inversion that you don't necessarily always want to control or win in a battle. It gives you so many different interesting ways of pursuing point accumulation, and it's one of those games that feels fast, feels meaty, and it feels like you just want to play it again as soon as you're done. And it's worth pointing out that Eric Lang is one of the reasons that I have a limit of only one design per designer on this list because we could be talking about
Chaos in the Old World. We could be talking about Ankh. We could be talking about uh Rising Sun. But for our purposes here, I really think that Blood Rage is Eric Lang's crowning achievement, and certainly his best combative area control game. And speaking of designers, where we have to limit it to only one entry on this list, we have to talk about my number one game, which is Cole Wehrle's Arcs. Yes, I know a lot of people know me as someone who is a huge fan of Root. And you also know that Pax Pamir second edition is one of my favorite games of all time. And there's a good argument to be made for having Oath on this list or other Cole Wehrle games, but if I were trying to distill this into games where it is heavy interaction, heavy conflict, and everything filters into that relationship of spaces on the board and combat to take advantage of them, take advantage of your opponents within them, and to kind of force your opponents to do things that are going to leave them in vulnerable positions, I think his crowning achievement is Arcs. Now, I will say, while I'm a huge fan of Arcs, I'm kind of lukewarm on the Blighted Reach. I like the ambition within, but I don't necessarily think that it makes it a stronger game, a more
interesting game, a game that's a lot more like Oath, but I don't necessarily think that it makes it as potent of a game, especially when it comes to something like this list. Now, I could go on and on. I love the trick-taking inspired action system. I I love the declarations of your intentions and giving your opponents time to resolve within that. I love the look of the game on the table. I love the brawling combat system, the the different ways that you can approach combat in that. And I love the asymmetric powers, as well. There's so many smart things that are happening in this game, where every piece feels like it is filtering into the greater whole. As far as combat heavy conflict games, area control, I can't think of something that I'd be more excited to play if someone was like, "Yo, dog. You want to play a game?" Arc's is my number one. And that's my list, but it's not your list. Go ahead and put your list, or if you want to take apart my methodology or terminology when it comes to combative area control games, put it in the comments below. And as always, thanks for watching, thanks for supporting, thanks for doing all the things that help us grow, your likes, comments, subscribes, checking out our Patreon, and of course, sharing these videos does a huge amount to help us thrive. But above all else, thanks for being such a great community. You know that I've been Jack for The Cardboard Herald.