10 Board Games Ranked - Episode 29
Transcript
hey everybody and welcome to another ranking video so in this series I take a look at the last 10 new to me board games that I've played and I rank them for my least favorite up to my most favorite now generally speaking there's nothing bad on this list at this time a generally solid bunch of games but of course I like some way more than others now before I get started on the list I want to give a shout out to the show sponsor keyienda dot Co dot UK who are my go to online retailer and if you use the link in my show notes or the QR code then you can get five percent off your first order at number 10 I have Dinosaur Island which is a mid-weight euro worker placement game about trying to run your own Jurassic Park I suppose and this one you are drafting these DNA dice you are then using them to create dinosaurs and put them in enclosures and exhibit them to the public for for money and profit and points the uh most of the work placement stuff is fairly standard but I did like this idea of you know the more dangerous dinosaurs that you breed and exhibit your security risk goes up which is another track you need to manage otherwise you can end up losing lots of points as the you know the dinosaurs eat your customers essentially so it does have that kind of risk and reward game more dangerous animals means um you know better points but more risk of them breaking out and so that was quite nice how it worked you know always having to increase your enclosure sizes to fit more dinosaurs in there Etc
it's a very logical progression in this game now I did feel like this game was fairly stagnant because it seemed like the more dangerous dinosaurs you'd get it just meant that you would just have to increase your level and so on so it kind of kept on kind of leveling itself out as you go up and it didn't really it didn't really escalate in terms of its excitement it just kind of stayed level because if you raise one thing you just automatically raise another thing and you keep going on so it kind of feels like it's almost like an artificial escalation rather than actually feeling exciting so I can see why people would like this one I'm not quite sure the hooligan mechanism worked for me I thought it was a little bit lucky for a Euro game but it was absolutely fine I'm not against it at all and um yeah it was pretty standard stuff so that is Dinosaur Island at number 10. out of a nine I have peanuts club now this is a pretty wacky auction Style game and randomly you are dished out this bunch of cards at the start of the game and they come in three different currencies I think it's camels peanuts and money and basically you have this hierarchy of what these different currencies are worth so you might have a ton of money but because see the peanut outranks the money a single peanut is worth more than all the money but I do like the fact that this is a closed economy and you never get any change and you have tons of these tools to mess with the rules basically such as though changing that priority order or blocking a certain currency being used Etc and I like the way that you only get
those tokens refreshed once in the entire game so knowing when to use them is quite important otherwise you can be left high and dry without much control of your fate um you're using these currencies to buy these cards these cards come with different symbols and the more pairs of symbols you collect the more points you get basically um I thought this the scoring itself was um very underwhelming I think this game could have done a lot more to make the scoring as wacky as the actual auction mechanism and I think this game would have benefited much more if they did that they didn't have to do a whole lot they could have just used some tried and tested set collection mechanisms but the fact that all the cards essentially scored the same way just felt a bit lacking for me and I felt like it missed out on its potential but I did like it you know I'm generally a fan of auction games I do have a ton of them this one isn't quite as good as most of them I have but I would play it again because of some of that quirkiness and it has some very nice artwork as well so I think you know it is it is unpredictable it's wild it's chaotic but I did somewhat enjoy it because of that so that is Peanut Club at number nine at number eight I have Bombay now Bombay is a pickup and deliver game as you're moving these elephants around the map are collecting silk and then depositing that Silk at these different kind of locations um Based On A supplier demand mechanism where you know the longer a certain type of soap has been neglected the more it's going to be worth and the player with
the most money at the end of the game is the winner essentially and there were some different strategies you can go down as you could erect these palaces in your name essentially and if other players would use your roots then a pass to go passes then you'd get some passive income there which I did like and the game is fairly quick um and it's pretty again a pretty standard stuff if you're looking at a pick up and deliver genre as a whole you know just moving around picking stuff up I'm trying to not waste any movement and strike when the iron is hot in terms of the demand that's pretty much where the game sits um you can you can plan ahead quite a few turns and because you only get three actions per turn sometimes the game can move slower than you want it to um but it's definitely a nice introductory family way pick up and deliver game that's not really got anything wrong with it at all it's just not entirely exciting and it feels somewhat pedestrian because there are so many games that do this and I think there are better pick up and deliver games out there even you know even quick ones so I liked it it's fairly standard stuff but um but yeah I couldn't really recommend it at number seven I have a living Forest now I wasn't quite sure what to expect with this one because I went in completely blind to this one you know a friend taught it to me um and this is one of those games that are quite um synonymous with the time this was released because this is you know a few years old now and this was when a game called the quacks of credenberg was red hot and the pushy-like mechanism in general was was
quite hot and this game has a lot of shared DNA with a game like the cracks clevenberg however this one is more card driven as you are building up a deck of cards playing them out in front of you trying not to go bust by revealing a certain type of symbol um but I like the way that you could string these cards along and build up different currencies to do different things you're collecting better cards you're fighting off these kind of flame threats you're building up a little Tableau of um things in front of you and I like the way that you could have a ton of different ways to win the game like even by revealing a certain amount of symbols on the cars you're playing is a way you could automatically win so I did like the way that you have to kind of dive into different ways to you know optimize your deck and try to um you know try to win as quickly as you can essentially it was pretty Punchy it was quite exciting at times and all in all I thought it was a very nice well-rounded game albeit nothing terribly original in fact I can't think of a single thing that's original but it does what it does quite well and I'm considering this did quite obviously or was directly inspired by other games I think this one did hold its own so that is living Forest at number seven at number six I have Elysium uh this is a card game with variable Decks that you're using game from game and what you're doing is you're essentially drafting cards from this communal pool I'm building up a bit of an engine as you collect them because all these cars have different abilities but their instant abilities ongoing abilities once per game abilities once
per round abilities and it's all about trying to string these things together to get as many points as you can now the Twist on this one is in fact there's a couple of twists number one is when you draft the cards in the first place you need to have the matching colors pillars in front of you on your player board but whenever you draft a um a card you have to give up one of those pillars so your options are becoming squeezed as the round progresses but the main scoring mechanism in this game is interesting because you have to use this um kind of mechanism to shift it from your engine to your scoring pool um I think it's got a transfer action and basically you're trying to collect sets of the different colors or sets of the same color in the different values um but as soon as you make them eligible for scoring you no longer get the power of the card so it really is that trade-off about how much do I want to exploit this card before I secure it for end game points and I tend to like it when games do that I have seen games such as Coco Pele games such as Valley of the Kings you use that before or even tie them to the underdark it's a nice visceral kind of conflicting mechanism that works well in board games so I definitely think this one did it well um I feel like a lot of the cars were quite minuscule in what they did and there were different setups you could use to get a different feel of the game whether you want a more confrontational game or a more kind of a comorific game but they did feel fairly standard and personally I found that whenever I played this one I was kind of neglecting what the powers could do because generally though it'll work anyway just
to collect the exact cards I wanted for the end game scoring and that kind of took a bit out of the decision making for me but it's a good game it's definitely solid got some good design pedigree here amazing artwork some good variability if you want the different you know use the different decks together and see how they combine and you know all in all it's a bit of a near Miss for me really I don't really see myself coming back to this one anymore but I am glad I've played it so that is Elysium at number six at number five I have splitto so splitto is a set collection game where you are working with your neighbors so if you're familiar with games such as between two cities then you might understand what I mean where each player is working with their neighbor and are sharing a pool of points between you and in this game you are using this pass and draft system collecting either these colored and numbered cards or collecting these scorecards which you know kind of work hand in hand with those colored cards so some might say well if this particular pool of points has the most fours then you'll get x amount of points or you want the majority of these cards or you know a set of these cards and so on and because you are working with your neighbors you are trying to keep each pool as balanced as possible because at the end of the game both your pools are multiplied with each other for your final score so having one great parallel is not going to be a great idea if your other pilot is really weak and because your multiplayer is going to be that much lower and I did like the fact that when you
draft these cards you are doing them simultaneously and sometimes you and your you know opponents slash teammates um might have conflicting ideas about what you want to score for and you might kind of tarnish and sabotage each other's scoring even though you're somewhat working together because you can't openly communicate what you want to do here it's a very fast game it's a very smooth and tons of different scoring cards and I think it does what it does really well so um again that scales well no matter who you play this with or how many people you play this with and I think it goes up to like six or seven players which is quite nice um the game is still going to take around the same length so it does have that seven wonders uh pacing to it where you know no matter how many people you're playing with you're still going to play in the same time frame which is always a huge Plus for me so again pretty standard stuff again Cherry Picked different things from different games but it does it very well in a 15 to 20 minute game and I don't really have much negative to say about splitter so that is at number five at number four I have Val Bara so this is a simultaneous selection Gamers each player has an identical deck of cards but you only have access to five of those cards at a time and each of these cards not only has a unique number on them from one to twelve but they also have a power Associated to it and what you're doing is that you're simultaneously choosing these cards revealing them and then depending on who's got the lowest number is going to get a first chance to grab these scoring
cards which will score you points based on a ton of different set collection methods and then all the cards will also come with that power which will trigger in order so some things might say well if you are the first car to play in um amongst the players then you'll get some bonus points or still some points from the person you played in front of you or double the points from your scoring card this round it's all about trying to almost get into the head of your opponents to know what they're going to play Maybe use a bit of deduction because you have open knowledge about what they've played previously if you try and maximum well to try and squeeze as many points as you can out of every single card play I tend to like games like this this one is very minimalist um you know very pure in the way it works and I like it a lot most of these games I tend to like the idea of but they often become a little bit chaotic and a little bit nasty at times this one I think stood away from that kept it a bit more player friendly and um and even if a card wouldn't pull off to its maximum degree you could probably still get something good from it by you know getting the best card scoring card Etc so I did like the way that works so all in all and this is a very solid game plays in around 25 minutes one of the simplest but best versions of a game like this that I've played and I'm quite a fan of it and it's getting better and better for me so um yeah definitely increasing my enjoyment over time of valbara so that is volbara at number four okay so we have three commendations at
this episode the first one is a little bit on the fence with giving and I'll try to explain why so at number three I have spicy so spicy is a very simple game it's a bluffing game as you are trying to shed cards from your hand and these cards come in three different suits you've got like Peppers you've got like salt and you have I like chili I think and they're also numbered from one to ten and all you do on your turn is you either pass and draw a card or you can play a card face down onto a stack and claim or declare what that card is now when you play a card every other player has the chance to call your bluff and Challenge on what you've played because you can blatantly lie and say you know you've played something that you didn't play but they can only ever Challenge on either the type of card that you played as in the suit or the exact number so I like the way that you have two different categories of bluffing here because you could be honest about the suit but lying about the number which means that if you're challenged on the suit even though you lied technically by The Game's rules you didn't like because you didn't like about the suit and that means that one of us anybody falsely accuses you you get to pick up the stack and take it as points at the end of the game and also if you shed all the cards from your hand you get like 10 bonus points which is quite significant so I do like the way that the attention of this game ramps up as the game goes on as a stack of cards get stronger and stronger or bigger and
bigger um and um and obviously that's a ton of points there but I I do like the way that the game almost forces you to allow some cars to step through and it always feels exciting when you're getting away with murder shedding these cards that you've never had in the first place um and it has that real fun jovial feel to it and um no early experience of this one have been Top Notch for me so gameplay it is what it is there's very simple stuff but this one managed to pull something out of me that a lot of other games like this didn't do you know I've played games such as um cockroach poker before and I found that very uninteresting because nobody won uh there's only one loser of the game whereas this one when you pull off these big Buffs and you get a ton of points it feels much more exciting than just not losing so that's why I like this one so much more but is it the best game ever absolutely not I mean but pure fun Factor you know scalability and just the novelty of it um I don't have anything else like it I think this is probably the strongest game of that type that I've played so that's why I have put spicy at number three at number two I have the number now what a strange game this is it's certainly going to be a polarizing game as you're either Gonna Love it or you are probably not gonna get much from this one at all um because and I understand this I think a lot of people are going to question the amount of gamers in the Box here but in this one you are writing a three digit number down
and then basically from highest lowest you're going to put them in order and then starting from the top you're going to have a look if anybody has anybody below you has written any duplicate digits and if they have you are going to be eliminated from scoring until somebody who's eligible basically and whoever's written the highest number with no duplicate digits in it is going to get some bonus points and you're also going to score a number of points equal to the first digit that you've written so higher numbers are great because they're worth way more points but people are probably going to know you're going to go for the high numbers and try to sabotage you and that's essentially the game you're going to play through round after round of that but each time you write a successful number down and score it as points you are going to eliminate those digits to be played again for the rounds so as the round progresses more information becomes available to your opponents meaning that they're going to have a better idea about what you're going to write down which means that they might know that well you've got to use your nine therefore I can go for my nine put it right at the top of this and get chunk of points or I might go lower than you knowing that I'm going to eliminate you and prevent you from scoring that's pretty much the gist of the game it's very interesting it's a game that you don't really need the physical components to play because you could play with pen and paper but um it's cheap it's affordable it's nice to have the uh the dry erase stuff with it and this is the kind of game that I love to have in my collection I can pull this out anytime and almost guarantee myself a good time and I can really foresee myself racking up the place of this one hitting that 50 to 100 play counts
um because it just it just strikes all the chords that I want for this type of filler and you know where we've played so many games you want something that is distinct and unique and the number has that written all over it so that is why I write the number at number two and finally at number one I have a chin by Reina kanitzia now this is pretty much a pure abstract tall placement game as you're trying to shed these pagodas as quickly as possible because if you do you instantly win the game now all you do in this game is you take one of three towels in your hand and you play it on the board and just touching another tile essentially and these tiles have one or two of three different terrain Types on them and you're essentially trying to create an area of different of the same matching train type I mean if you do you put one of your pagodas on there but as soon as you become a five in size you have to put a double Pagoda down on there which is obviously a good thing and because not only do you get to shed more pagodas but you become protected from having that region stolen by other players because if you ever end up having a bigger region than somebody else of the same type and you encroach on them you can kick their Pagoda off and claim it for yourself there's additional mechanisms as well as you venture and attach yourself to these different cities and towns on the board you can shed more pagodas on them if you have the most figures touching them and it really is a game about seizing opportunities blocking people and stuff like that and I'm Jerry not a huge fan
of abstract games but this one for me is just the almost like the perfect abstract it's so clean literally just draw a towel place a towel I love the little tricks you can pull off which you probably have to play the game to realize how they work and it just it takes so many boxes for me it's plays in around 30 minutes and the the depth here for a 30 minute game is outstanding um and I found myself playing this one again and again and again it plays very differently at say two players where it's a bit more cerebral a bit more head-to-head than it does at three players and I probably like both play cards equally I've not played it at four players yet um but the third player you know it makes it a bit more chaotic but almost in a good way because more opportunities become apparent and in this game I I think it's amazing I think it is truly a great uh kanitzia maybe even my top three four connected games that I've ever played we're just saying something because I tend to love these games anyway but yeah this one the cutest place in my collection probably forever um because it is that good um and yeah I'm all over it so that is chin at number one so there we have it that's another 10 games here again a very strong Bunch um and I've really had a good good time playing these ones because you know it's always good to play solid games so if you have enjoyed the video please be sure to hit like And subscribe to my channel and check out my other content too but for everybody else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye-bye