Ranking ALL of the Star Trek Games
Transcript
Hey everybody, I'm Tom Vassal.
I'm Joey Evans.
And we all know that a lot of people out there like Star Trek.
You mispronounced love.
Well, well, no. I don't mean it in any negative way. A lot of people love. There's a lot of people like it, too.
Nah.
Okay. So, there's a lot of people out there who hate Star Trek.
That is true.
Anyhow, Star Trek has definitely had an influence on popular culture. We name our one of our space shuttles after it. Um it is there's a huge franchise, one of the biggest, maybe the biggest science fiction uh franchise that's out there.
Yeah.
So, today we're talking about Star Trek board games, which unfortunately there is not a ton of.
Which is sad. You know, we are compared to the other there's other Star franchise that tends to have more. But this one has some good ones.
It does have some good ones. So, we're not covering every game that's ever come out from Star Trek. We're going to mention it. We're going to start off by talking about a few that neither of us have played. And then we're going to go from our least favorite to favorite, sort of, with a a mixed between
them together. Did you just do ours or do you add a BGG in there, too?
I did not. This is us. We don't care what everyone else does.
Yeah. That's what I was saying.
So, we're going to start here. This one is the the one of two games on the list that does not have the word Star Trek in the title.
Star Trek
Right. It says And this isn't even really Star Trek, but this is so iconically associated with Star Trek, the 3D chess board. Um
Which everyone has seen. If you've seen Star Trek, this has stood out to you like, all right, this is the way to play.
weird. I did not realize that this came out in 1851.
I did not either until this moment right now.
had three dimensions back then.
I don't think they were all black and white, that's for sure.
I would love to see like the original version of this. Anyway, I've I've messed with this a bit, but I don't know that I've ever really played it.
Same here.
Okay.
had to see where you move.
Next we have Starfleet Battles. Now, this is the granddaddy. I know enough about this. I've read the Well, part of the rulebook. Have you seen the rulebook for this?
No.
It is a monster.
Really?
40 pages of tiny print. This is a huge game. The people who love it definitely love it. It is almost as old as I am and is definitely as old as you are.
And you you're probably tell when you play it.
Yeah, well, it's like all It's basically a war game. Look at the counters and again, I I wish I could show you the rulebook for this because it is just so
That's
immense. And when you look at that, you think Star Trek. But, it would be weird not to talk about this. It was re-implemented by Star Trek Battles Commander's Edition in 1983 and then the Designer Edition No, that was 1979. You know what? It is what it is. I'm never going to play this. I'll admit that now, but it's worth talking about. It's in the Dice Tower library. Then we have Star Trek Expeditions. This is a weird one that I feel like I should have played. It came out 15 years ago.
I remember seeing it and thinking it was just a movie push. I don't know why the movie didn't come out.
it definitely was a movie push, but Reiner Knizia did this design this and I remember people when it this came out, I remember at a convention people were like, "Yeah, it's it's fine. It's ranked 4,189, which is not particularly low."
No.
Um and Reiner Knizia is not a bad designer, but he's also not known for designing Star Trek games.
Right. Right. So.
And then the fourth game neither of us has played is Star Trek the game. Well, no, wait. Never mind. I did play this one.
Wow. You gave it a great score.
No, listen to the description. Players must navigate their way to each of the four planets by correctly answering questions from each of the five categories, obtaining five citations and then returning to Starfleet Command completely intact and fully It's half trivia, half this.
Ho ho! Wow.
Also, don't know that I'm particularly good at Star Trek trivia. I don't even know if I can name you all the captains. I can name a lot of stuff.
You can name all the captains.
Okay, let's go to the real rankings. Here we go. First, we have Star Trek Conflict in the neutral zone. I've not played this one, you have. This was Joey's number Wait, 15? Pretty low. You didn't like it?
It's It's fine. It's a flicking game where you have your ships, you flick around, you get little powers and stuff. It's cute, it's forgettable. I think I played it cuz it was a flicking game and it was different. There's better space flicking games.
Oh, WizKids. This is in there in the weird years in 2019.
Yeah.
Mike Elliott does has designed some good stuff. One of the worst names in the world, though.
Conflict.
Conflict.
Yeah, that would get It get gets auto-corrected pretty bad.
Then we have Star Trek Deck Building Game. This is one you have not played. I played this and it's abominable.
Really?
It's from Bandai. They're not known for making really good games. There's also a a Next Generation version of this, but it was just grab cards, put them together, read these stats. I Did Spock turn into Khan in that picture? That's confusing.
I don't like goatee Spock.
Yeah, but he's cool.
He's very cool.
He's the only good person in the mirror universe.
Wow, you guys are good pulls.
I didn't
All right.
I'm not as bad of a Star Trek as you think.
Okay.
Then we have Star Trek Five-Year Mission.
Uh
Joey gave this one a 13 and I gave it a Uh this was your 13th and this was my 16th, I believe.
Yeah, this is just very dice or I'm if I I remember the right one. Is Should we do it?
Yes, this is take control, roll dice, and survive. Yes, Captain, I will roll a two. Oh, I rolled a two. Khan!
This is You know what? Here's what's weird. I ranked these cuz I want a a Trek theme when I get in there. This you didn't feel it much.
Yeah, at all. At all. Don't recommend this. We'll get to some that we recommend. There is more bad than good. Uh Star Trek Flux. I've not played this one, but you ranked this as 12. Number 12.
what? I have a soft spot for Flux. Now, I play the TNG one a lot. I put this all I'm not ranking them all. But, um they're Flux for what they are. And there's more than one Star Trek Flux.
Oh, there is. Yeah, there is I think there's Voyager. I think all of the Star Treks have Flux. So, TNG we kept just because but it's more nostalgia. If I'm going to play a Flux game, I'm going to play one of an IP I like. And that's a big if, by the way.
Next is one I thought you might rank higher, but you ranked it at 11. And Oh, no, never mind. I'm jumping. We're at Star Trek Missions. Star Trek Missions, you ranked this one at 14 and I ranked it at uh 12. And that's only because I ranked the deck-building game I just ranked a bunch worse. I I really don't like this.
This is horrible. The icons, all the tags on it. This overcomplicates Fantasy Realms so badly.
And I wanted to like Fantasy Realms because adding an IP to Star Trek doesn't bother me at all. I thought that'd be fun.
I think it's great.
And they did IP this with Marvel and it worked It was great. And that's not cuz I like Marvel better than Star Trek.
No.
It was just a much simpler game. This, they were like, "Hey, you're going to have two decks of cards." Why, teacher? To make things complicated.
Mhm.
How many icons should we put in? A thousand.
All of them.
Yeah.
It's insane how many there are. I wanted to like this so much. I played it a lot because I'm like, "I got to be missing something." And I'm not. It's just not great. All right, this is the one I was talking about that you have ranked number 11. And I was surprised. Now, I've not played this one uh because I feel like I did play it. If this is basically Castle Panic, but in a Star Trek way. So, you have your ship that's spinning around and stuff's coming in and you have to fight it off cooperatively.
I can see this go I enjoy this. I played this a lot. I even got a little 3D printed Enterprise for the middle. It's it's panic. I just haven't played the panic games a lot.
It's almost the same thing as Castle Panic. I know they changed some things cuz you're warping or whatever.
Right.
But yeah, and you and you also have a facing.
Yes. Yes. You turn depending on where your shields are up and all that. I liked it, but I don't go back to the panic games much. I think it's a good one though.
All right, let's go back to the '90s with Star Trek CCG.
Customizable card game?
number 10.
Is that what the C stands for in CCG?
Well, it used to be CCG, then they start turning they said trading card games and somewhere along the line they changed it, but they used to all be called CCGs.
Really?
Collectible card games.
But this is customizable.
Well, no, that's a different thing.
Anyway, this is made by Decipher. It paled in reception to their Star Wars game, the the Star Wars CCG, but the Star Trek CCG was the Star Wars one was better. And not because again Star Wars versus Star Trek, but because Star Trek is not conflict heavy. Star Wars was I fight you. Bum bum bum. Star Trek is like, I'm going to go on missions. I'm going to do this and I might fight you. And that you can do a game like that. In fact, we will show you a few of them.
Mhm.
But not really in a CCG setting. You can do it with all cards, but that's coming. And Decipher did not do it.
No.
All right. Next we have Star Trek Star Realms.
That's low. Why is that so low? I had a higher mine. Didn't I?
I haven't played it.
Oh, got it. All right.
Uh yeah, you gave us five. You're right. I don't know. I was cross-referencing it with my not ranked at all.
So, that's just how this worked out. But yes, this is five for you, so pretty high up there.
This is great. This is Star Realms. I mean, you love Star Realms. We played the campaign. I love Star Realms. You All right, so he likes. But this one I think I like Well, I know I like more than Star Realms cuz it feels all the IP, all the theme comes through. Even with that Borg expansion, the way you have the modulating shields and the way everything works, this is a great, great game. I love that system. This is one example of that system being implemented perfectly. I would pick this over Star Realms and most of them.
Yeah, that's true.
I would enjoy it playing it. I just haven't.
like it. Then we have Yeah, I can't believe that we ranked this one above that. Sorry, it just the way it worked because I played this one. This is Star Trek: Away Missions. You ranked this as nine. Nine. I ranked it as 11, which means I ranked it higher than Missions, but still.
You would like some of this.
I like the concept of this.
That's where I think it stood cuz you get to go So rarely you get to actually do these miniature things inside of the ship. So you're in the You walk in and you shoot.
It does.
I'm running around. I'm shooting at you. I'm going to do this panel. Okay, let's go.
Right.
I'm turning the pan If you ever want to play a game in slow motion, here you go.
[sighs]
Yeah, but it's just I still love being able to run around on the ship. Nothing else does that. I like the concept of it.
There really isn't any. I should mention at this point in time that we are not doing Star Trek adjacent games, where people say, "Oh, Battle Stations like Star Trek. There's a game called Redshirts like Star Trek." Yeah, but they're not Star Trek, so we're trying to focus on that in particular.
Starfleet Captains. No, no. That's Star Trek. It's where the little track goes through. I don't know. We'll get there. Anyway.
Here's one you haven't played, but I ranked this as number three.
Is this just an economic game with Quark on the front?
Yes.
Okay.
However, the game is so mean that it fits the Ferengi really well.
Yeah.
Cuz I don't know that they Star Trek does not really display the Ferengi two three-dimensional.
I know they They to do it more as the series went by, but they were usually conniving. Man, I hated Quark so much. So, in this game, you're selling things and we both sell something, but if I sell for lower, you get nothing and people buy mine. But, if we can come to agreement that we'll both sell for higher price, we both make more money as opposed everyone else at the table. And I'm like, we should do that and then I lie to you.
Which is what he would do.
That 100%.
So, I thought it fit well in this Star Trek thing. It's a funny little game. So.
There you have it.
Well, we're going to get the games that we both played at some point. Oh, Star Trek Catan. This sounded stupid.
Right.
But this makes sense when you start the stuff you get to trade feels good in that Star Trek universe. I don't know why.
I'm not 100% sure I'm sold on the theming of this. You're building things. But, what this game did is it actually made Catan better because it had these special ability cards. You would pick a a character that you would then use and these characters switch back and forth between you and I really like that. Now, they've actually added that in in other games. But, I also like the pieces of this one. Yes, I know it's instead of roads, you have, you know, ships connecting. But, yeah, why not?
I like this. This is one I still own. I keep thinking I'll get rid of it. No, I want to keep
number seven. This is your number 10.
Yeah.
But, if you think that's not very Star Treky, our next one is pinball. Star Trek super skill pinball. And if you've never played any of the super skill pinball games, Jeff Engelstein designed these and they are essentially you can play with multiple players, but they are essentially solo games.
tribble one. This right, okay. This the problems with this are only because of the problems with the pinball I have. Like, as far as the marble erasing things and all that. These boards are solid. That tribbles is great.
Oh, no, no, no. And I like this game a lot. This is our both our number eight for us. Um, which made it easy to average. But, it's not the most Star Trek themed, but it's it's like a I'm I'm playing a Star Trek game in a game. But, the Super Skill Pinball, and then they did theme these pretty well, I thought.
They did. Everything feels good in those. This is probably one of my favorite in the series, that and the holiday ones with Christmas stuff.
All right, the next is my number four and Joey's number seven, and that is Star Trek Attack Wing. It's kind of phenomenal to me in my mind or just a really strange thing that this game came out before Star Wars Attack Wing, which X-Wing, right? X-Wing, which decimated this game.
That's the thing. I would rather play this over X-Wing, but I played X-Wing more because people own it all.
X-Wing came out first.
Did it?
Well, you You know what? Now, I'm I'm I know that the Wings of War came out before both of them. No, this one This one came out, and I remember they said that they used the Star Wars system. They used that system. Cuz I remember asking how that worked, and they said, "Do not ask." And I don't know if that matters. But, anyway, so the thing of the matter is I like this game. It's fun.
I like it.
But, Star Trek is not this kind of fighting normally. Every once in a while there's the What the Picard maneuver where he jumps I forget what that was. He like goes back in hyperspace one or I don't remember. He There's They They show it, but if you ever watch the movies, basically, the ships are sitting like this.
Right. Right. And they're like,
"Shoot! We're down to 40%." Now, they've gotten more exciting, and they show when they fought the Borg, and it got more grandiose as time went by. But, this is like that. You know, flying around trying to get behind every person. So, I think it fits Star Wars way better.
I agree.
And yet, still fun. Still get to fly my Romulans against your, you know, the the Klingons, and that's a fun time.
You you know, yeah, I like it. Next we have Star Trek Fleet Captains. This was my number five and your number six. This is, until recently, if you wanted to play Star Trek in a box.
This was it.
It really was.
Mhm.
What's the biggest problem with this game? The component quality, man. The tiles were paper thin. But you had all these different ships and apparently I'm just showing you a bunch of ships. Let me see if I can show you an actual Here's the game board, but it really had a sense of discovery. You go out, you flip a tile.
I love that.
Um and you didn't even fight. You could fight and in fact some factions like the Klingons were encouraged to fight while the Federation, you could beam people down to a planet and they could do something. It was the most Star Trek themed game for years.
And that's what I want to see games like this lean into is that theme of cuz again, it's not Star Wars. Star Wars is very battle heavy. This is like you got to play into the factions. The use of the use of the word of of what you're playing, you know, and this does.
That's great.
That was our number five. Number four, Star Trek Ascendancy. Now this is Joey's number two and it is my number nine.
It's so good, man.
This is a game
that gets you?
Yeah, well, there's a few things that get me on this. Look, I think it's a I think the game it This is one of those personal preference. I think this game is well for what it does.
Yeah.
It It's an exceedingly Star Trek. It's really different in the factions again. The Enterprise, they supported it really well. I think there's like six different factions.
The original game was for three players only. My original rating of this, I remember, was a 5.99999999 because I was like, I just can't say I like it.
Right.
It just missed the mark for me because it's really long and I was also a little put off by the fluidity of the the the thing building, although I know for some people that's a positive.
Yeah.
So, go ahead and say why it's good.
This one I like because it has a TI4 feel. It's a very big epic. It's It's hard to get to the table cuz it's long. Also, sprawling. You're going to see that in your exploration again. It really hits on this and the fact that like TI4, when you have to play into your faction, this you really have to play into what you're doing. You know, if you're Ferengi, you trade. If you're And then you've got the Borg, they can just do crazy things. Klingon battle. All of this and you feel that huge sprawling map. This gives me all the feels of that big 4X style game with a Star Trek theme. You know, we have other ones I think I play the theme just as well, but this one gives me that wide feel. It just feels good. I love it.
Yeah, and I can't really argue against any of that. I mean, it's That's why it's that high on the list.
Yeah.
But, three more are better. Number three, Star Trek Frontiers. This was
My number six and your number three, so you like Ascendancy better than this.
A little bit, yeah.
But, this is essentially Mage Knight redone in a Star Wars thing.
But, it works.
It does.
It does a lot.
Because in Mage Knight, you'd be like, "I'm going to explore this dungeon." Here, you're like, "I'm sending an away team down to this planet." It's the same type of thing. It is a slow burn. It is a complex game comparatively.
Um but, it also is Star Wars. It's a little more customizable than others. And I would imagine if we did a poll that more people would rate Ascendancy higher. I think so.
Probably, but this I think But, this also has a wide of how long it can be. You know, this is It can go up to like several hours. But, it is fun. Again, theme is strong with this. I never played Mage Knight, but I have played this and I like it a lot.
All right, number two was also my number two and Joey's number four, which averaged it out to the top. And this is Star Trek Space Hunt. Two, three, and four could be all interchangeable. This one I honestly could be easily my number two. This is a fantastic game. Which it did not get the splash I think it deserves. This is great. This answers so many problems I've had with well, Captain Sonar and things like that. Right, so this is based on Captain Sonar. It is a two V two game and it's real time. But you are It's basically real time battleship. One person's moving the ship, saying the directions that they're moving at that. The other person on one team is trying to figure out, "Okay, they said they're going here, here, here." But this also lets you jump to warp.
Oh, when you go to warp
and then jump back out of warp.
Oh, great.
It's such a fascinating way that this game plays. I just It's It's really fun.
I do like
It does a better job of the ship combat than Star Trek Attack Wing does, I think. Because again, it's more of the thinkingness of combat more than dog fighting.
Right. But there's some dog fighting, too. There's some anxiety. You know what? But this is That's my two. It just has that It hits the table easily, too, because you can play with two. I think four is where this is the best.
newest game in the list, by the way, too.
It is. Number one though was number one for both of us.
Game is great.
And I think for maybe many of you watching it would be the same thing. And that's Star Trek Captain's Chair. Now, Star Trek Captain's Chair was a re-implementation of a game called Imperium or or something Imperium. It doesn't even say here that it's a re-implementation of that. Um but this is a one to two player game in which you are taking one of these Star Trek captains and then they add a ton. They just released another set and an expansion. So all your favorite captains are in here. You pick that captain, you get a deck of cards with them and you are doing a little bit of deck building. You're doing a little bit of everything. You can fight the other player a little bit, not too much. But you're trying to You also are deck building. You can add more cards from your deck.
Mhm.
But there's also neutral cards that any player can get. So you might come across Quark and throw him in your deck.
And the the idea of it again the theme is so strong that when you hire someone outside of your show onto your ship it just makes me happy. And then you can promote somebody else to you know executive officer number one or whatever and I'm like I shouldn't promote them but I am. It's there's so many good little factions with this or like or like different mechanics. I I like this a lot. This this is fantastic.
It's really good. It plays it good at solo but I my favorite way to play it was with two.
It's a game that's deeply deeply strategic. I will probably never be good at this game but I just had so much fun doing things.
Yes.
I'm like oh we're messing with the prime directive today. Oh we've come across what's that line that was in the movie?
Neutral zone?
No that that Kirk got caught up in for years and
Oh yeah yeah yeah.
Yeah. Sorry. I know the stuff I doesn't know the names of all of it but you you can run across anything and everything in this game and the more stuff you add the more that might be in there but you're you're also doing what you need to do.
Mhm.
Go find what's it what's it the the five year mission to go seek new planets and you know what Star Trek fans are mad at me now.
They're so mad. They're going to be like turn it off. This is great.
There you go. You brought it home. You can do it.
long and prosper.
No this is great for you to have it. It's a big box. It's a fairly heavy teach but not as bad as the original Imperium one people say. This I think is more streamlined. Everyone who has played both has said they
enjoy this far more.
And it also is the kind of game where you can kind of just play. There's some games I do that and this one I'm like hmm what's the best strategy? I don't know but I really want to put this person in a ship and send them over here and I really want that new weapon on this and I'm doing that and it just it's it's a very intriguing game. You're very you're not bored at all while you're playing cuz you're thinking about what you're going to do.
And your ships you can get you can get and all of a sudden your away teams the way you have to have staff them. Oh it's so good.
And another thing I really enjoy about this game is that a lot of games we talk about you know like Firefly. I'm not a huge fan of Firefly. One of the reasons I'm not is because I'd be like I would like to see some of the characters in Firefly on my ship. And they may or may not show up. But if I pick Picard's deck I'm going to get Data. I'm going to get Riker. I'm going to get all the people in that. If I pick Kirk's deck, I'm going to get the folks I'm going to get Spock. And And I'm like I just want to play Romulans. I can.
Right.
And so you can kind of get the stuff you want. But also see cameos from other people throughout the series.
So great.
But it's not just that it's thematic. It's also a really good game.
It is solid.
So there you go. That is my number one and your number one.
Mhm.
Let us know what your favorite ones are.
And any of them we missed that you loved.
That's true. I will say I'm pretty sure any game we missed is fairly low rated on board. But you never know it might be a treasure for you. I'm out there. And like I said there's a lot of adjacent stuff too that you're like well this is essentially Star Trek.
I I like that too because in my mind I could put that theme in.
Best Star Trek movie?
I just saw Star Trek motion picture recently. It's pretty good.
Galaxy Quest.
Oh, I agree. It's so good though.
Alrighty folks. Until next time. I'm Tom.
I'm Joey.
Live long and prosper.
V'ger.
Hey folks. Thanks for joining us for that video. If you haven't yet like the video, subscribe to the channel. And hey, make sure you check out what's happening where I'll cover an app on an iOS or switch device and you can check it out along with me. Thanks very much. You've been watching the Dice Tower.