Board Game Rating Changes - Episode 2
Transcript
hey everybody and welcome to the second installment of board game rating changes so this is a series of videos where i take a look at games that i've rated previously and see how those ratings have changed sometimes for better sometimes for worse and before i get into the 10 games i'm going to talk about i want to give a shout out to kianda dot co uk who are my go-to online retailer in the uk got some great games at some great prices but let's get started um i'm going to go through these lists through this list from from least favorite to my most favorite at least as a starting point so the old rating is going to be where i'm going to start with um so the first game i'm going to talk about is a game called sub terror so this is a cooperative game but yeah of course working together you're supposed to be uh this this i suppose a dive team that have been tracked down a mine shaft you're trying to navigate through this mine shaft by placing tiles you can peek in you can charge them blindly try to overcome all these hazards um and it uses that pandemic system you know where you have a certain amount of actions and you can spend them accordingly how you like um has a kind of a ticking clock where you want to be pushing your luck a bit or pushing as fast as you can because the longer you take and the longer you kind of dawdle it will potentially catch up with you and kill you all basically this one i used to rate it for um i didn't enjoy it i'd never been a big fan of the game but i thought a lot of that one might be because you know it's it's not a bad game it's not a terrible game it's just not my tastes i would already get a lot of fun from it i think it maybe goes on a bit too long and because you know that the end tile is in that kind of bottom few tiles then you're kind of really
going through the motions for a lot of the game just biding your time to get to the end and doesn't really feel like there's any kind of peaks of excitement it very much plateaus for me and unfortunately this game has actually gone down from a four to a three i think i actively dislike this game i don't like it at all i don't get any fun from it um again it takes too long um and it's kind of one of those games i'm not really interested in playing it's just it's just not that well put together and i think there's a lot better copter games out there and despite me not being a massive cooperative game fan so can't recommend this one i think it's it's it's just not fun it takes too long um potential for player elimination anticlimactic moments and um yeah just not not a good game that is subterra but the next game um is a love letter so love letter a game that i've had a really good kind of uh relationship with it over the years this is kind of one of the first small card games i ever played kind of in the modern um board game hobby when i got into the hobby uh this one is a micro gamers you're basically trying to basically eliminate players with some take that cards you want to be the last man standing and by holding a certain card when it comes to the deck being depleted you can peek into players hands i mean and as these kind of games go this is probably one of my favorite ones you know a lot of these games i don't tend to like but this one again is a decent one so it's a true fill of me it's a relatively quick game very low rules overhead and has some pretty fun moments um i think the only reason why this one's stepped down is because i've played this one to exhaustion you know this is probably one of my most played games um ever and i think those kind of returns have really diminished over time and it has
become a bit of a game again going through the motions now um and i don't really get too invested in it because i'm just kind of playing by ear just again just playing things on autopilot um but the game is fine um it's gone from a six down to a five um so again not bad game it's just not something i'm really gonna advocate to get back to the table because i feel like i've just i've just done everything you could possibly do with this game um but hey i do have some nostalgic some nostalgia and some sentimental connection with it um because i've had so many great games of the over the years so that is love letter but the next game is actually going to be a positive game going from a six to a six and a half you're still just shy of a shield of quality but who knows that is subject to change this is q birds so q birds i played for the first time a couple of months ago on the back of a viewers recommend recommendation a very simple set collection card game where you have a market of cards which are these birds and then you're basically playing cards from your hand and if you play like a duplicate set of birds you can kind of trap the ones in the middle and take those into your hand and then try and play them as sets and sometimes you can play these bigger sets to get two cards played in front of you or just play the smaller ones and get a single card in front of you and you're basically trying to get one of each of the birds or trying to get i think it's two pairs two or two sets of three i think it is um i could be wrong on that i think this game really does remind me of a game called jai paul which is a strictly two player game i'm a very good kind of uh back and forth market style game where things are constantly changing but this one actually caters i think two to four
players pretty well i think it scales very well um and i think i prefer it at three players because there's a bit more the game or the market becomes a bit more alive yes it's a bit more chaotic but not in a bad way and i think there's some pretty good layers here in terms of leaving opportunities to your opponent be careful when you play things because when you play cards from your hand you have to play all the cards of a certain type and you can't just pick and choose which ones you want and keep something back and that actually adds up quite a lot of decision because again you can leave opportunities for your opponent to capture those birds because because even though you might have them they might not have them and um yeah really recommend checking this one out and hopefully i'll get a review of this one up soon um but yeah this one is going up and up so yeah some six and a half two sorry six to a six and a half which it might sound minor but it's not mine in my head that is that's quite a jump so uh that is cu buds uh the next game is a a decline so this is a game called allegory which is actually a 2021 game uh this one was gone from a six and a half so again just shy of a recommendation down to a five so a bit of a bit of a rapid decline for this one um i think one of the big reasons for this one is that i'm quite enamored with the concept of it so this is a bidding style game you're trying to collect these cards um in front of you and you're cutting three different or several different types depending on the play account and only your lowest type or only your lowest color is going to be your final score so think of something like tigris new freight is the way the way that scores however i do like the system or the
concept of the system when you buy something when you win a bid you place your winning bid and divide them amongst the existing cards there meaning that the future cards can come with kind of a token bonus to pay for future bids that's a really cool idea a really cool concept that i'm surprised hasn't been used before but i think unfortunately in practice it doesn't work quite as well as i would like and on top of that the scoring system is just it's too it's way too tight there's way too many negative cards in the game and sometimes you know your final score is so low and additionally i think there's quite a viable strategy in the game just to buy as much as you can and to rush that finish of the game and catch all the other players off guard yeah it's completely viable but for some reason it just doesn't quite sit well with me it doesn't quite feel right so i feel like this has you know it's 80 of the way there it's so close to being good um but unfortunately for this reason that is it is declining for me because i have so many bidding and auction star games in my collection this one just isn't quite up to the standard of some of the others so yeah unfortunately that's a bit of a decline for allegory the next game i'm talking about is a game called garum and this is a positive change and quite a big positive change actually considering it's gone from a six and a half to a seven which is enough to achieve my shield of quality so this is a relatively unknown game a puzzly style game you're trying to place these tiles onto this grid and on these tiles you've got not only your color so everyone's assigned the color but also the other players colors as well you're trying to build lines and columns of
your color and then potentially claim them with meeples in order to score kind of set collection bonuses or sliding scale scoring so the more symbols you have of your color in a row or column you're going to get bigger and bigger points however you can really mess with your opponents by manipulating these tiles when you place them to try and again knock down their points so they can't get as much potential to get those higher scoring points works so well i've played this a few times now and it's gone down quite you know quite a big hit every single time i love the interaction the game you have to consider each thing without without thinking too much it's not too overwhelming um and you can pretty logically you know play something down with minimal effort but still have a little bit of decision space there and it just works well for a 30 minute game um you know some area control some stuff like that a joy to play a really nice concise medium-like game that can cater to a lot of different people so yeah happy to give this one a shield of quality that is garum next up i know that negative game go from a seven and a half to a six and a half actually lost my accommodation this one is res arcana and i'm quite sad to say this actually because this one when it's good it's brilliant it can be fantastic um however the most recent games i've had of this one um all the cars that i've ended up kind of drafting into the game just didn't really synergize with each other there was it really did kind of stall it felt like a real chugging um kind of pace and again nothing gelled and i think once i lose confidence in the game i think you know
it's a bit of a toss of a coin you know are these cars gonna work together are they not that is a real kind of a a red alarm for me you know a bigger warning symbol say you know do not play this game anymore because it could be good it could be very um you know very very underwhelming and unfortunately that's why this game has left me now um you know time is too precious for me i can't risk playing a game that's not going to be a hit um particularly when it takes you know 30 30 minutes to 60 minutes to play um and yeah unfortunately this one is not going to kind of earn my trust back so still when it's good it's pretty it can be fantastic when you get the right cards together and they synergize with each other but again that slight nagging feeling in the back of my head saying this this could go wrong it could go astray um it's just again it's not going to be enough to stay in my collection because of that so probably a very unpopular decision because it's an extremely popular and um well-received game but not quite right for me at this point so that is res arcana and next up i have fiom so fiam is a um very strange game by freedom and freeze one that came out last year to get a little fanfare no nobody's really talking about this one this one is a real unique game i have nothing like this in my collection um potentially because of the scoring and the wide variety of cards you have in this game um as you're trying to build a hand of cards and play through these cards in a specific order and i'll touch him why that's important later in order to basically build up uh or kind of yeah build up a city really or build up a
whole civilization you're building roads you're building uh settlements and towns and farms and things managing resources converting those resources into points in different ways um however the some of the mechanisms in this game are absolutely fantastic so you've got some again the hand management is great as you're drafting from the aurora cards that uses that kind of power grid system so all the cards have numbers on them and just because the lower numbers are in the deck it doesn't mean they're going to come out first and i find that quite fascinating so the pacing of the game changes from game to game um but this hand management system is great as you're playing these cards using them but once you take a certain action to pick all these cards back up so you use them again um cards get wiped and you actually can only take three cards back and end up paying money for each additional card you want to take back into your hand and that creates some amazing decision space and um again really does uh kind of keep you on your toes and keep your brain ticking along from start to finish and i will say this game is a perfect example of the more you play it the better it becomes because you start to see how the cards start to synergize with each other and the way the potential to get points work um i will say the end game is a bit swingy at times in this one but the more you play it the more that becomes kind of digestible i'm absolute i'm really fascinated by this game i thought it was it was really enjoyable i did enjoy my first play of course i always had my shield of quality it still hurts my shoulder quality but going from a seven and a half to an eight just don't shows my confidence in the game um after repeated plays so yeah that is fire uh
the next game has is gone from well actually just at my elite shield so this is like the biggest um acclaim i can give to a game this is hanza two tonica gone from an eight to an eight and a half um this game is just an absolute amazing game the way it's put together is fantastic um almost abstract in its approach as you're trying to build these routes placing these tokens onto the board establishing them as your own um you can either establish a trade post which can potentially get you points or even try to get upgraded abilities to place more cubes onto the board or i'd be faster to take stuff from your kind of general supply into your personal supply getting more points for building these routes um what an absolute masterpiece this game is um andrea steading's best game no doubt and i think this one scales very well i mean you know you want to be playing at least three players but three four or five players it works great lots of different maps to play if you have the big box version um and it just is such a low rules overhead very elegant in its approach no fat on this game whatsoever very simple to digest but the depth and complexity nuance uh sophistication of the game is just off off the charts so brilliant game and a right you know well deserved of an elite shield and i do not hesitate to give it that for a second so yeah very happy to finally upgrade hands to tonic to the best of the best and talking of games with elite shield so the next game i'll talk about is uh glenn moore 2 chronicles so this one's been sat at around an eight and a half
for a long time now and i've finally upgraded it to a nine i'm so really up there with the best of the best so this one is a kind of a rondelle or kind of time track game but mixed with tile placement so you're building up this more um placing tiles i'm getting resources converting these resources into points i'm collecting upgrade tokens i'm getting unique benefits and powers that nobody else has moving scotsman and meeples around your board to score points in different ways um and you increase your potential to build and expand uh the best target placing game i've ever played no question i actually played a vel really basic game of this no none of the additional modules or the chronicles that come with the game just the pure fundamental um gaming experience and i had an absolute blast and really sometimes you know when i play so many new games um i don't get to go back and visit old games so much but when i get an old game back to the table sometimes it's just like you know this is how it's done and this is why this one is in my collection and glenmore 2 chronicles is the perfect example of that um you know sometimes you forget how good games are but when you get them back to the table you think this really is one of the best games ever made and um that's why i've given it a nine so that is glenmor2 chronicles and the final game i'm going to talk about on this installment is capital lux two generations so this one is kind of the hot thing in my collection at the moment this has gone from an eight and a half um so i had my elite shield but i've given it a nine and it's very rare that i give a game of this um scope or this weighting um a nine so this is
actually a relatively light game this is only like a a medium-like game um very easy to understand as you're trying to um play cards not only in front of you to score points but to the capital as well because if you go higher than the card value in your personal cards then the capital then you can go bust and end up losing a lot of points however you've got to be very careful when you go to the capitol because you get a power for doing so and sometimes it's good sometimes it's bad the dynamism of this game is off the charts the interaction is great the the tenseness and oh it's just an absolute perfect card game uh it's modular you can try lots of different setups and you know even the base core game alone is is this good you know i'd recommend this one to anybody um you know even the sci-fi theme which is something kind of generally turns me off um didn't hinder this one at all because the game is that good so a bit of a cheat ready because i've only recently rated this one at an eight and a half but soon after i upgraded it to a nine i like it that much and it is that strong of a recommendation from me so loving capital lux to uh two and a right you know a well deserved of a nine so i hopefully uh you've enjoyed this video if you have please hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other videos too additionally be sure to check out kianda.com uk if you do live in the uk i do think it's a really good idea to or a nice a nice kind of premise to look back at games and see how things have changed over time because again we're always looking onto that new thing always playing new stuff giving new opinions and sometimes
the older stuff kind of goes to the wayside so good to give these a bit of spotlight and hopefully see how things have changed over time so again thanks for joining me and i'll see you all next time on chairman of the board bye