Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top Ten "Big Box" Board Games w/ Hilmar

Transcript 2:30:16

yeah

hi everybody hopefully that wasn't too loud for you because that sounded loud through my headphones but uh the problem is the volume where I listen where everyone else listens is entirely different but uh yeah cheers for joining us whoever can I realize this is mid December and most people have geared up for Christmas or going elsewhere or don't have much else to do but uh we do have a few people in the chat so thank you but it was high time I got back to some of these top 10 because it's been so long since I've done a top 10 period let alone a you the collaboration one apart from like the old Essen thing but now that all the Essen reviews are done pretty much my last one I recorded this morning and then I got the top 10 of the year to do that's it that's it for this year so when I get back in January I can start doing nothing but top 100 you know top 10's the OB stuff like that and well while it's quiet but Co blind me S and takes that out of me but yeah so today I had to find somebody willing to join me in mid December and uh if anybody recognizes Hilmar from a couple of my Essen live streams I did before we basically did some like random Vlogs while we're at Essen and the two of us can happily banter and go nuts and insult each other and that to our hearts content so uh we we said that we were going to do a top 10 it just took me a while to actually get round to sorting it out so this was kind of a last minute job so cheers if you do turn up butth before we get into what on Earth this list is about if you haven't met Hilmar now's the chance for him to

explain hello everybody yes my name is Hilmar I have a web page called bill.is which is a a web page about the uh board games and playing board games in Icelandic we you know people don't realize that even even with a small nation like Iceland where we have only 360,000 people in the whole island we still we have our own language and we need to have content made in our own language we do have one podcast in Islan made by few of my friends but we also have uh I also wanted to have some written content and I'm also uh creating some videos about uh about bames as well although as you can see on the page right now it's mostly just Asen uh content right now but I just got a a very good camera and I'm starting to film my 2023 top 10 list and 2022 retrospective and and some more yeah apart that you know I'm a we designed by by trade I make some pretty content Rich website one you might have seen before from a

rival uh YouTuber called Dice Tower small a small you know content creator from the US yeah that's me oh that you were coming through a little bit muffled there for a second but I've been Ching around with your volume settings cuz they said you were a bit soft probably because I turned you down for my perspective and then haven't necessarily uh sorted out forther so can I get that definitely in writing that my voice is soft because almost nobody tells me that my voice is soft and I'm need to speak up that is never never my problem n i' say I've turned you back up to what it normally recommends anyway um I think it's I think it's because my headset volume was so high that everything was just deing me or something so yeah much better now that's good so yeah note to self don't interfere with the volume settings that works for us so yeah top 10 big box games now this is very specific and God and first of all whose idea was it to do big box games I it came up in Essen I'm not sure if it was you or I or if it came up in the chat it might have come up in the chat and we we jumped on that idea oh that well shame on whoever it was for coming up with the idea because God blind it I've had some Johnny about it Johnny let's blame Johnny yeah we'll

blame our friend that but oh God of all the lists I have done there have been some doozies to do this one was hard um because we just it was hard to do this list because it wasn't even just the case of ranking it ranking the games was hard enough I I think you may have to sort of take it as just 10 favorite games at this point although I have tried to rank them but when we were talking about big gax games the definition of what is a big box is so subjective and so hard to do because boxes are coming in all sorts of different sizes now that it was just impossible to even find a starting point and for we did we did at the end meaning that it had to be published as a a bigger than ticket to write box and not that at some point it came as a a storage solution and and then I mean I have I have quite a few boxes like I have the wingspan nesting box but wingspan is definitely not on my list because that was that was well for for many reasons not only because it didn't fit the criteria right yeah yeah whatever well I'm just saying that that that's a particular the right size the Box in that but we're not talking about big box like like Sentry spice Road big box out of Sky big box ququ number Big B we're not talking about the ones that come out and include all the tons of expansions which is why that's not on the list because that is just the storage soltion ution with a ton of expansions in it we're talking about base game possibly base game and Miniatures if they all fit in the box

but it's a bigger box than usual but the hard part was just trying to find a starting definition cuz for for me I've gone with essentially if you look over there at the Fantasy Flight stuff over there that Star Wars rebellion is essentially twice the size of a um uh what you call it um yeah double double the ticket the right size box that's my minimum threshold if it's as big as that some of it also going and do is it just a faf to carry to a game night uh can I put two can I put more than two of them on a shelf like for example those two that are there that's the two that's on that shelf I couldn't fit three of that size on a shelf therefore that's big enough for some people they think like the likes of Gloom Haven is like the minimum size for like an oversized thing it's just that is a crate if that's the smallest one you can come from that's going to adate a lot of the stuff yes I would not have been able to go with top 10 by then well that's so I mean so I went yeah I went with the Fantasy Flight size box double size box is my minimum F have you got a minimum uh yeah it was there is one maybe a little bit of stretch in here um but uh most most of them are yes they had to be you know taller almost you know the the Star Wars rebellion box or or equivalent to that there there's one one maybe a little bit of stretch because the the uh well we will come to that soon yeah there's

going to be an element of that and I'm sure people are going to disagree somewhat on the sizes particularly if the box is rectangular but there are some games that people might expect me to put on that I haven't because as much as they are large it's call the like you feel like the box would fit into a ticket to rise size box if it just simply squished it back down again you know there were some rectangular games that do feel a bit like that cuz most rectangular boxes are long and thin if you squished it down into an actual square box you probably would get a similar size that's kind of how we're thinking anyway well there is there there is one cheat then definitely yeah well I say there's one or two that I are not on my reason but we'll have to see but as always with these things you know it's subjective obviously you chck you know we'll give you the chance at the very end to suggest out your ones why we didn't mention them whether you agree or disagree with certain choices and as always with any time I do a top 10 banter is well encouraged not to mention any hatred for a game is welcomed to be said without holding back because it always well you're not you're definitely not going to love every game on my list for sure well there was a couple that were being suggested like by I went on to uh Paul grogan's like patreon slack Channel and all sort of asked a question a bit and there was some interesting thoughts back from there you know once I get past all the abuse but I don't get abused on there it's just a laugh but certainly you know the definition I think is going to be somewhat subjective but you know that's that's just the way it is so the best way you can do it is just to make a

start go for it take it away himma yep so my number 10 is Glenmore 2 Chronicles oh straight in uh yeah yeah yeah yeah why not and you can actually see it it's right up there so it definitely falls into the category of rectangular box uh in the shape of eal Griffin type of games in glenore I Chronicles you have well it is a game with like 10 or yeah I think remember correctly 10 mini expansions in it but the just I I love the Ty and Ratchet kind of um game mechanism in it uh it's I there are there are so many just different things that uh makes my my head hurt um in in in the decisions to be made I I like how the intermittent scoring is done I like how the game can just end prematurely if just the correct tile comes up there are just so many amazing things about this game that makes it uh pop up not just here but uh also on my top 100 yeah like it very much I've I've tried it once because i' I think when it came out in its second version I gave it

a shot to see what the fuss was about and it certainly did look good I need to try it some more that the first the first go I remember enjoying it enough except for there was I think there was a path of victory that I was doing or something that involve this board a lot I know where is it there we go this this board in the back where I was doing quite a lot of collecting stuff on there and it didn't seem to be as lucrative as all the the rest but I also probably would want to check try this with a few like extra expansion modules thrown in because we did do the Bare Bones game and I feel like I I want it with a few extra bits of meat in there um but yeah it's one I would try again I I always throw in at least one if not two mini expansions just because they're very easy to incorporate into the game even teach with it so yeah it's mean do you throw to teach H do you throw any stuff in the teach I mean I suppose the only thing with this though is that I wonder how much of the box is taken up with the base game alone then or are the modules small enough that they don't really contribute to the big size of it yeah yeah yeah yeah the the uh one of it I think it's called The Bridge or something that is just connecting to two tiles and uh sometimes it's just uh you know in the box there are few cards and and and two or three tiles so there's nothing major to be added on although you know some of the big bigger parts are of course yes there you go that hill over

there but there's little green bit the grassy null yes yes yes yes interesting little piece what why why is the less monster in this is that a module yes yes it's a module of course it's Scottish H true I guess although suddenly going into the VH on that on that one I I didn't see this one talked about a lot though cuz I remember it getting a decent amount of buzz when it first appeared and then it sort of disappeared off the radar a little bit it it did it was uh part of when I almost backed every other Kickstarter there was uh until I realized that I had to also pay shipping and I live in Iceland so shipping is bad for you in general oh yeah so bad so bad fair enough all right on mine mine is definitely a big box certainly when it came in regardless of whether you get expansions or not because it just came in a sight big one although this one does require you to play with a variant if you don't play with the variant this game is lacking a bit it does and the variant is official it's not entirely a cheat but um the basic version of endless winter um doesn't quite fully work if you play it in its normal form it it it works fine and I still enjoyed it but the the problem this one has is that you get free workers in order to do a lot of your actions while doing the little mini

deck building with the with the sort of TR the clan cards and all sorts of other bits like that but by the time you get to the end of the game despite the fact that there's a lot of past to victory in this you find that you can pretty much do everything by the time you get to the third fourth round and it just means that the whole concept of differentiation is kind of lost really but what you do in the official variant that they've released is you remove one of the workers so you don't have three you have two I don't know if it's for the whole game or it's for the half a game I forget but the idea is is that by doing so you restrict how much you can get done and therefore you avoid that problem a little bit but you can see the boxes there on the right you know this is quite a sizable table but this is a decent size you know rectangular box that does take up most of the cic square in there and this is including a lot of these pieces all these different boards all the cards that will sit on there you know the the tiles that you need for the abstract puzzle bit in the middle the monolifts or whatever they were called and and then you've got the tiles for the like the map around the outside and even I mean this is that was an expansion so you can ignore that even but it all fits in the Box anyway but you've got the trays as well so this even if you just ordered the retail version it will still come in that giant Siz box so it is a little bit of a mission but this one has disappeared I mean yeah U as M mentions um basically it was like hyped up for ages and I suppose this is just the way of the

industry now it it was hyped up for ages it came out got a decent amount of Buzz and then you know some people even put it on their like top 10 of the year I think I might have done as well and nobody mentions it anymore at all well not quite true um the on the retrospectives that the dice tower is doing um it popped up at least twice Mike delicio still loves this game and uh and I think there was at least one more that did mention it I have this one of my shelf of opportunities I bought this uh yeah I I I bought it used from somebody here in Iceland but I've not uh I've not been able to to get it to the table yet it's been a while since I've brought it out I must have been I haven't seen those um retrospective ones yet I might have to like give them a look although I tend to prefer the ones where they're in a group but um yeah it's good that because Mike was one of the ones who like biged up quite a bit and possibly Z I can't remember but somebody else did um yeah I think I remember it was on on both of their lists yeah probably sense but they just I just don't see like anybody s of mention it locally and that I mean I need to kind of get um I need to get this like out again or something whether it's Solo or group because I do kind of miss it it was it is a good fun game even if it's Bas for I say the variant does help a lot it just makes it a lot tighter you know it was starting

to wne from my likeness because I found that yeah I was getting a bit bored of the fact that you could just chat combo changed so much um before and it just got a little bit annoying but eventually it decided to sort itself out cheers enjoyed G project in hegemony yes did you play aony with him then actually no no I played I played the Gia project no I sorry yeah I think I did eony but then I also I think I remember playing um a different game with naron which I don't want to spoil but certainly um I know or perhaps he was talking about Mar night not sure but oh right well we started off on the biggest front D they again any

bigger well my box yes um for the people who know me um I tend to like certain type of games that have the bir Legacy in so my number nine is definely a legacy one

y sorry I had to collect something in yep so my my number nine is Clank Legacy Acquisitions Incorporated is a pretty big box that is that it is and I actually I do have two copies of it I have played it once all the way through and I'm about halfway through another uh complete game I like this game very much um I think the story is very rich there is definitely a lot of story in the game uh too much for some people uh Chris L I am talking about you uh but the uh the thing is that uh well when we when we did it the first time we had a h a really great narrator my friend was able to read with his very deep was and it was just very you know almost as much fun listening to him read the story as it was playing the game h of course I'm not going to spoil anything but you know it's just it changed up quite a bit uh how Legacy games were played and um I like Clank so Clank Legacy was definitely something that just came naturally and yes I am backing Clank Legacy 2 but there's a second one yes and I bought two copies

from the Geto oh great do I have to come to wson order to play it because I still haven't actually tried this one I'm not I'm not the biggest I don't go mad for Clank so I didn't I didn't jump onto the Legacy game when it came out but it seems to be one of the the few that everybody kind of holds in high regard compared to a lot of the other legacies where there's definitely a mixed opinion right but I you normally Clank Legacy is in the top proper rankings of a legacy game for sure so for for most people who who like Legacy games and if you like I mean you have to like Clank I mean there's no way can you can like this game and not like Clank I mean this is Clank you know you know to the extreme yeah but that works for all Legacy games I mean I mean apart from the ones who try to do their own system but those ones tend to fail by the fact that they try their own systems cuz they it's not if you want a decent Legacy game you've got to base it on something that already works right oh for sure but I don't I don't know if I'll get a chance to even try this one I me I'm certainly not going to Fork out for it and force my mates to sort of binge through it like there because I mean how long does it how long does it take to get through the whole campaign how many games is it uh officially 10 and uh no sper alert spoiler alert there's a hidden 11th game in it um but yeah no it's it's not that long I mean it takes a little while to play because you know there is there is a lot

of reading I mean sometimes there there is even you know there is more than one page of text material to read so actually what I would love to see is to have something like forer uh notar it for me or yeah you know yeah the reading games do take a while just to get through it yeah yeah they are a bit mad I suppose dep I mean Clank games vary a lot in terms of their length as well so it does get a little bit mad at that respect and certain I mean a lot of the other Legacy games have taken a while just because it's trying to get the same group to the same location to play the same game I mean I've you know we've I mean we've already finished like we had to binge through to get to ride Legacy you know hence the video on that one and other mates of mine are at least getting to near the end of pandemic Legacy season zero but we are certainly it's a case of how often can we meet up in order to play that one but now I've seen FL teller yeah sleeping Gods is one um as mentioned but I swear I've heard it in a couple of other games and it does do a good job like I like it when it's there cuz I mean if I'm playing solo I'm just reading it in silence but you know what if I want to get immersed in it I do like to have some somebody narrate it to me yeah with sound defects and stuff I mean they they do quite good sound effect effects as well so you know it's it's I know for gloom Heaven you know you could hear when they were uh you know fighting and and sword fighting and clanking and and all that kind of

stuff so that was that was really really well we right okay cool right we're going on the M I say with all these uh things that we've done we've tried ideally to stay away from doing too many from the same publisher and designer so I can think of three games that are on my shelf that are from pretty much I don't know if it's the same publish I think it might be but it's certainly the same designer and this one isn't even my favorite of the three but it is the largest of the boxes hence it gets the slight leg up anything if oui Rosenberg well before OU Rosenberg started having a fetish for polyomino Tetris tiles you know it was all about big chunky wooden resources it was all about big giant boxes full of sandbox Euros which to be fair I love sandbox Euros you know give me a Cerna or a fields of all any day and I will have the whale of a time this one in particular though is not is probably my third favorite out of these three but it is the biggest box a feast of Odin this is a pretty sizable box I had to look at it I I had to look at it on the shelf and is that picture showing there we go um but yeah if you look at the boxes Cerna is you know a decent size um you know field ofal is a little bit bigger but there's I don't let me get the close up there so yeah that is is the Feast of Odin Buck yes it's it's bigger it's bigger than Cerna and bigger than Feast of fields of all you know this one definitely is the larger of the boxes but still an enjoyable game if uh

you know if on the basis of just how much is in this wretched box I me I crying out loud that's the contents of it it's just like you know a million t a board with a million actions on it a million different tiles I mean this is kind of like the first time I saw like a game give you like trays in order to hold all the different pieces in it and then all the other bits of resources then all your player pieces then all the ships then all the boards it's like oh my God this thing needs to be a crate and even when it's this big it's still a little bit of a mission to get everything back in there especially unless you've got an insert but it's there it it's still a solid game but I I have not got this out for a while because of just how big it is you know I preferred to play it solo R than multiplayer player cuz it's for the most part a multiplayer solitire game apart from just you took my space but you know as a solo puzzle it's got a pretty good mode in there it's just how many rules am I going to have to relearn and how much of this stuff do I want to get out on the table in order to play it although is this on board game arena I have no idea I don't I don't play much on board game Arina I think to remember it might be because if it is that might be an excuse for me to actually go back can try it a bit more when I can just play it on there but uh CU it takes a while to get EV and not to mention you need the largest table in the world you know to hold everything about this person here is clearly just playing a solo game and look how much room it's taken up on there it's uh a little bit insane but it's worker

placement de got and Resource Management feed your people Tetris pieces on all the minus Point spots so that you don't lose a load of points it's just the smallest Board of actions you have this board with about 40 different actions on it that's kind of ridiculous and you know trying to remember what they all do it's like uh it's 65 I like say I lose track it's it's more than I would need in a typical game but the wealth of options is one reason I do like it however and like as yeah as cbed yes I thought I saw it on board game arena I've got premium so yeah I definitely have seen it on there I might have to go back on it at some point but but with it there is one thing you definitely need and as much as I hate to say it because a couple of uh content creators can get all their egos enlarged for this but yes Norwegians is an expansion you need to have for this game because the base set is fine but Norwegians actually rebalances a couple of sort of Fairly major issues with it yeah that one so cuz you know it it adds a bit more Choice it cleans up a couple of things but mainly it balances out animals which do not work in the base set alone you have to get the Norwegian expansion otherwise animal tiles are not even worth the cardboard that they're printed on um you not a Flawless game I do wish that the occupations were a bit more interesting CU they feel like such a little side thing that's like bolted on at the last minute they don't I don't find they tend to work very well but given that there's 60 different action

spaces I can just ignore them right Y no I I like Feast foren a lot and uh I I do do agree that you know it has to be played with a Norwegian expansion it's just you know it fixes a lot and it adds like five or six more action spaces because the 65 weren't enough but uh but and revises a bunch of the old ones right no I think I I think the uh U you know those those games are some of the masterpieces U has um so yeah I I definitely agree with fair enough right ah I don't want that let's get back to I mean do M get any bigger than that it varies this is definitely I think one of the larger ones on my list but not the largest that one's going to come up a little bit later oh I got one large I've got one's larger than that just one well well I suppose it's relative actually I suppose yeah there's more larger than that I know it's it's it's it's rectangles and squares and stuff it's hard to sort of Gage but don't worry we we'll get I'll let you know when we get to the biggest one that I have and yeah definitely it's a bit of a

crate so yeah it was a little bit hard for me to give you too much of a Hackle for Fishin because my number eight is CNA fair enough I mean converter is a game I prefer it's I went for the box size no yeah I I I went both both box sizes but I also went which one do I want to play more and caverna is just a game even though I like fist foren a lot caverna is just it it I feel it has you know a great deal of options although I have played the game with people who have played it like 300 times and that is not a lot of M because they know by heart you know every single tile in that game and how every single room works and the benefits and the points and everything and I'm just like yeah I have to remember if there are goats or sheep in this game you know or both I mean it's no I played it like 20 times but still you know there is sometimes inet and uh I do like it more with uh with the expansion with the first expansion yes ignore the second one like the plague but the first one is great I do have it I mean it's it's interesting and and actually H A

friend of mine who hates U games really really much Cera or gria quick far question yeah yeah yeah right great AGA yeah yeah I think I think so although I do love Agricola as well but yeah I mean the yeah what I was saying with the second expansion that a man who dislikes caverna a lot started to like caverna in after the second expansion and I thought that was a very interesting perspective but uh he's very much into step you in the back destroying everything you know you're doing sounds like they liked a gri as well in in the first place maybe because a lot of people no no not not not by uh you know he wouldn't test that with a stick oh fair enough cuz some people like who preferred agria like caverna when they threw in the second expansion but for someone like me who likes caverna for the reasons it's not like a griol it's like no you've you've made it like super weird and tight and fiddly now and it's just like you've changed it completely but the first expansion with the the asymmetry boards in that I mean that's a given you can almost teach the game with it because it kind of guide you in a particular sort of path to Victory route asymmetric asymmetric kind of play which is something that I like very much so if you play it with a with a a gamer that has played asymmetrical before it's really easy to teach them to

play the game because it like you said no that just talk there for a second yes one two one two okay am I fading out now was there was occasional times when ah I'm hearing it in the back of yours sorry I turned off Echo cancellation for a second uh but that was not a good idea okay cool there be good but yeah cernis cernus a solid game at some I don't know I think we played it at some point this year but it was just a case of like getting it I mean that that's one problem with these big box games it's like we say like oh we haven't played them for a while well they're giant big box games it's hard to get big box games the table so you know cut as a little bit of slack you know this this is why I like things that come in a small box every now and again but pack a lot of game into it you know it's a lot easier to get a Garfield game out to the table than you know cver or Feast of Odin for multiple reasons yes one's heavier than the other but you know some are just easier sometimes I mean my fiance now has gotten more funter of of bigger games if they do have theme they have to have theme they have to have theme I brought out arnova the other day and she loved that she loves F of AR uh her favorite game is Grand Austria Hotel so I mean you know it's just yep how's that that's got no theme in it that has a theme yes you're building up your hotel

you just need a just a tad of imagination a tad of imagination to get P the dice and the fact that when people eat at said restaurant they then stay the night I mean it's yeah well you know you have you have been to griton haven't you you have to eat there before you get to sleep I have to but then if I go to I mean I'm going to a restaurant to tomorrow I went yeah I went to a restaurant on Thursday for Works Christmas do I didn't then have to sleep over as a result of eating their food wor that yeah I I yeah yeah but but still it's you know having having a little bit of theme and being able to to get into it is definitely a uh yeah and most of my games I really the the games that I don't like are abstract games anyway so I I like abstract games when they're quick or when I know they're it depends on the mechanics to say if they haven't got a theme they've got to work harder to impress me but then I perfectly like a pure abstract I've got a couple of ones you know like you know Cado and Yin and stuff like that I used to play chess when I was a teenager a lot so you know those sort of abstracts I do like but it's more with hey you I mean I had to do look I wasn't into football all right I had to find something else to do but right all right next game so this is my mine Clash pick for the list and this is not the big box that came out for it cuz frankly the original box for anacron was big enough so it was a pretty sizable

container this thing you know even in its original like kickstarted version that you got I don't think it even mattered if you got the Miniatures I mean they could fit but you know this one is still just mammoth in size and I know the essentials boxes yeah there we go that that thing in the distance there with the giant sleeve which I think my old one had I've now got the infinity box but you know it's got to hold all this it was big right it had a lot but this one you know one of my more I think probably one of my titles from David tury that I prefer out of all of them partially because not just the fact that this is a good fun mey worker bement game but just the the theme of this one as we were just talking about resonates a lot this whole idea that you know you've got to prepare everything for this cataclysm which does happen at a later stage and when it does it kind of changes how the game goes at that point but it also takes time travel and basically makes it what debt is in real life you know debt is turned into a time travel mechanic of I need to borrow some resources now I need to get you know I need to get this stuff to me how do I do it well I borrow it from the future on the basis that at some point point in the future turet I go and pay it back it's literally debt which basically means every time you go to your bank and get a mortgage or anything like that these days you're borrowing it from yourself it's it banks no time travel and they haven't um you know told us all about it um you know and certainly I have mentioned that this is my mine

Clash pick yes I know void Falls technically came in a bigger box but you might want to check out my video on that one um but actually I don't mind vo I like vo fall fine it's just that's too much faf this one is already quite a faf to get to the table void falls on a whole another level um as much as the game is still enjoyable but yeah just all these pieces all those tiles all these Miniatures the board takes up a lot of space but it's still a big favorite with me and quite a few others you know we do try to get this out every now and again at a convention yeah I like uny a lot we actually were planning on playing it at griton with most of the expansion the big expansions at least toy himself told us please do not play with everything the game just doesn't work that way and and I I totally agree this boggles my mind actually with this stuff because I mean I agree the infinity box I almost kind of half regret it because I do like the fractures expansion but it's it's a lot on top of a lot I don't like using any of the mini expansions cuz they're just too much and you and it's sort like he say he's saying himself don't play with everything including cuz that's too much then why did you make them in the first place why didy variety and I can understand that that you would like to play the base game with one or two of the mini mini expansions for sure but uh well just that fractures is good enough I mean you know the mini ones I don't find is that fun anyway I haven't tried them I've

only tried fractures once and anacron I like anacron it's not on my list uh but that is mostly because I haven't played it enough in order for me to be able to put it on the list I think I've only played it three times so any three well to be fair I mean with these ones playing any of these M Clash titles three times is usually pretty impressive in itself you know given how much of a mammoth they are but uh yeah we do try to get this one out it's because a group of mates and M who I play these like heavy Euros with fairly often we do like these mind class titles and ma is a good favorite although we do end up taking treron out a little bit more on the basis that it's um the girl in our groups it's her favorite like one of her favorite games period let alone of mine Clash so and given that I don't tend to get my collector's edition out because again big box faf and all that it's like oh you want to play it good that's one less hurdle that I have to jump over it's you know you get it and you set it up and it's all good I don't have to do anything apart from think during the game and it works for me but no um I think an Arron still my cheran has gone up a little bit in the recent times we play but now I think anacon still my favorite of the mine Clash a

lot so I did mention that theme is something that I really want to have in my games and my nextx although um just repeat yourself there occasionally your mic muffles out a little bit but I don't know if it's Icelandic internet or or something with the microphone but if you talk again now I bet it's working fine okay uh yeah what I was what I was just saying is that you know I just mentioned that uh I like theme in my games and my next game is definitely a full box of theme it's literally aliens the board game Nemesis get oh that oh I was CU say now I get what you mean yeah yeah Nemesis Nemesis is great I I've played Nemesis quite a few times and I I like to play it either uh as a five player semi co-op with uh all the hustle that comes in with semi Co-op especially when you don't know the players enough and you're both trying to figure out what the hell they're doing and also just you know yeah are are are they are they lying to me or are they just you know really bad players I I've I've had some really interesting uh game plays of of Nemesis but I also like to play it two-player fully Co-op um okay yeah it's when you when

you do that it's I like you know like I said I I like to play with my fiance and we like to play then more Co-op than than semic Co-op yeah and uh it's it's just it's very immersive it's awesome to play when when you have like a half lit room and some some really good Sci-Fi music playing in the background and just you know there there's just tension in every single corner it's a luck Fest I know that but you know come on sometimes you know you have to just be in the right mindset to to play uh whatever game you're playing you're not going to play Nemesis expecting uh a Truro for trying out now though say just mentioned it have you seen the the Allin pledge for everything that's I think everything that they've released for Nemesis lockdown and whatever their new spin-off is retaliation or something like that $900 the entire lot you've got to be thinking to yourself I'm spending nearly a grand you know including like the shipping and vat for a board game or two and it's like what mindset do you have to be in to S consider that that's actually a good idea you mean you have to really love the game well I have I have Nemesis lock down all the kickstarter things yeah but did it cost you 900 bucks I mean I remember getting

you all in I think it was for about 300 or 260 y for yeah for that was before retaliation was a thing but I've since sold it cuz nemesis one of those games where you know I mean certainly we've one person here is not a fan of it but um I don't find them as boring but the problem is is that it's definitely got the theme and I love the Aden movies and that so it's definitely like resonates me over there the game is incredibly fragile though I have had some games which have ended with some hilarious stories or something crazy happening but then I've also had games that have felt either very dry or somebody's dead within the first two turns like it took longer to explain the game to them than they actually played it um you yeah but come on when you're play when you're okay so I heard this a lot and I call BS on that if that no no no no no if that happens and you know it's a three threeh hour game or three four hour game and somebody dies in the first two rounds just resurrect them and continue it's a co-op game even though it's semi Coop well it's semi Co-op that's the thing we weren't playing Co-op yeah but still I mean just resurrect them and continue well I mean how resurrect them how I mean just it didn't happen the queen did we didn't draw the queen you know on the second cple Warriors yeah yeah okay you know it's just like yeah this you know it's like Choose Your Own Adventure and uh when you when you get in oh I'm sorry

you died you just say nope that didn't happen let's backtrack and continue because we don't want to restart and that's what I just do I just you know I guess where you draw the line now on that one yeah it has happened once with my gaming group and we just did that and that was absolutely no uh no problem to do that and we continued and and they lost anyway but they were still in the game yeah I don't know it's it's kind of old in that sense I say some games I have had the most hilarious of endings but I just and it was a nightmare to get to the table again cuz the rule book's not very good in it so trying to relearn all the rules was a little bit on the tricky side but it with the music and with the right theme I know a couple of people I mean Nemesis is definitely one that I need to know who I'm playing with like I'm not playing this with randoms I'm playing this with people I know who love the game and can just Breeze through it or something but at that point I don't need to own it so you know I since had to sort of get rid of it which is kind of annoying given it was I mean I got my money back for it but it was just like I spent the time getting it un boxing it shoving folded space inserts into it and then suddenly to get rid of it it's like cuz cuz the thing is that I think I tried to use lockdown as a means of getting back into it because I thought ah maybe they fixed some of the problems in the first one made it a bit more stream like that and then I found out that it was 99% the same it's like oh right okay so still good but again still fragile I just needed

although that one playing with the Doom music was quite cool because Nemesis lockdown kind of feels a bit like Aden cross with doom but but then again I mean you know maybe I'm a little bit more forgiving you know one of my all-time favorites is betrayal at house on the hill and talking talk talking about God stick with Nemesis least you can get some fun out of that game I I have both I have both H I can play I'll happily play Nemesis with you if you promise never to play Betrayal on House of the hill with me so that's that's definitely a given right now as much as the last what like four or five games I think from this publisher I've not been massive fan a fan of which has certainly angered a lot of the fans out there but oh well deal with it but you know back in the day this publisher was putting out some pretty quality games three of which are in my top 100 and still on my shelves this one in particular I think was probably the second one I played from this publisher cuz previously I played his wine based game um which I really highly enjoyed and then this one which Then followed after was of course safe no Charter Stone do we need to rewind back to the thing we had about Legacy games and which ones don't work um but uh come is fine charterstone is

teach yourself a Euro a boring Euro in 10 games it's like with no story I don't know but but Scythe yeah even if you forget about legendary boxes and stuff like that Scythe big chunky box it's still if you bought it in retail form it's still big it's still got a lot of stuff and you ain't fitting a lot much else on your cic Square so this one definitely is taking up all the space but I still really enjoy this one I mean even if I haven't got the expansions in it to you know show off a lot you know to like use like the the expansions ofel the airships and that I'm happy enough just literally playing this game with the base set and possibly with the uh you got those extra what you call it the encounter cards you know that added some more interesting stuff in there they're certainly not particularly balanced there are some uh good and bad ones in that pack but exactly yeah Stone Mar is not known for balance even in the good gam so so I just take that one on the chin but you know I still like this little efficiency puzzle that doesn't take that long it's a good race has a little bit of interaction on the board but not too much but you're still kind of doing your own thing and it's it used to be I think in my top 10 games it's since probably dropped a decent amount now um but you know when somebody wants to get it out you know I tried the fenis campaign that was not the best of campaigns but it did unlock some cool stuff for the game but it's when you use that stuff you're not

really playing it with any and that's I think one of the things that hurts this one is that you know if you want to do like top 10 games that you don't want to play with Noobs this is definitely one of them because when somebody says I'm going to get five six seven of us together and we're going to have a game of Scythe the first thing I'm asking is has everybody played it because it only takes one person who doesn't know what they're doing to either unbalance things or just to drag the game out to an excessive length I've had a seven-player game of this where all of us knew what we were doing we were friends and we knew the game we played it in 90 minutes seven of us you know it is doable but that was with us taking fairly quick turns that can double as soon as you throw in one two people who have never seen the game before because they are going to be they're going to not be thinking about their turn before it gets round or they're not going to know what they're doing so this one doesn't hit the table as much because I am more of a case of look has everybody played it cool then we're going to have a cool fun game of scy you don't seem to agree on that I'm guessing no no I you know I really disagree on on how fast you have to get the game off the table again uh I I had I played once a five player game where four were new one was totally lost most of the game we finished in just under three hours but it was still a very no it was still a very enjoyable time that I had with my friends and that is what I take out of some of the games I have then played with them again and

uh they've got we're now getting those games under two hours but sometimes it takes a little while to teach people who are not super fast with playing and I find it fine problem is that if you make if they're at like a club or something you're not necessarily going to be playing a lot of games the same game with that person all the time in order to get them up to that speed and I know what you mean like you know you're there with your friends and that but that's that is inherent no matter what game I'm playing I could be playing Scout or Monopoly with you know or you or barrage or Concordia or whatever with friends and still enjoy the fact that I'm with friends that does that doesn't make the game fun you play Concordia no I'm I'm listing four games I hate but but I'm saying that I can play a game I hate with friends I mean like I played Imperial steam a friend of mine taught me that one at my request funny enough I actually decided you know what I want to see what this game's like I detest that game with a passion but I was still enjoying the fact that I was with them I just detested the game it you can't forgive a game for dragging out too long just because you're with good people I mean certainly that improves the fact that it's dragging a bit but even if I'm playing with friends I mean you know first time we played void fall with the four of us that was taking forever to finish yeah we're enjoying the fact we're with each other but we still acknowledge this game is dragging like crazy you know it's it I can't yeah I experience that with void but I was taught by tury so you know we were pretty fast well yeah I'm pretty sure yeah Dy just does it at lightning speed

with him but yeah yeah no I I totally agree with you with Scythe I like Scythe a lot it's uh my actually last year it was my number three of yes yes top three of all time didn't make still didn't make it on this list it yeah it used to be in my top 10 I think it used it got up as high as five but then it's falling out of that top 10 and by the time I do my top 100 next month I suspect it's going to be a bit further down the charts but like I said say if you're in my top 100 you're still a game that I rate at bare minimum an eight out of 10 if not a nine or a 10 so uh you know you're going to be have you played for the r fenis yes I've got all that and I the campaign itself was a bit lacking but I like the stuff that I I would have probably prefer to just rip everything apart and just use the modules because the story is fine still it it's fine like I said it's adequate but I mean once it was all said and done I'm like yeah I would have happily just torn it apart and just used the modules cuz some of the stuff in there if everybody does know the game and it's my copy I want to get some of those modules out but again you play with someone new the last thing you do is get all that stuff out because it's just a bit of a mission at that point uh but all right that's sevens on to

sixes so my number six we are still uh spending some time in space a lot of big games do tend to be space related I mean that is they they do and the funny funny thing is that this game uh a lot of people say that this is one of the uh most heaviest game they've ever played uh you said yourself that every time you track uh put this on the table you have to relearn all the rules and for me for for me when I I played it for the first time I thought it was one of the most intuitive games that lerta had ever made of course I'm talking of course I'm talking about on Mars oh that oh sorry yeah the S are not mine Clash I on a minute but yeah yeah right there's so many games that there's so many games I'm thinking of of giant space games that you could have been picking until you mention the designer it's like ah okay now it's working right yeah no on Mars it's it's a pretty heavy game it's and I'm not saying game I'm not I'm not saying that the game is easy I just said when when for for me it just worked everything was very intuitive and it just clicked in my brain and you know I I have no other explanations on it I you know I am autistic so maybe that has something to do with it but the the fact is that you

know you're either on the surface or you're in in orbit and then you just look at to the left or to the right of the table what you're doing and and yeah I love this game a lot there's a lot of things to do um it's very heavy but amazing game in every single aspect of it I did enjoy it I mean I do not think it's bad you know this is a game I did enjoy when I played it but intuitive is not the word I'd use to describe it this one I mean I broke the brain of a friend of mine who normally is the one who beats Us in most heavy Euro we play I was like like he's the one who can find the broken combo by just staring at a game piece and that and this one broke him you know which is yeah we we we did that my first game there were three of us and my friend B he he just I he was halfway in and he was still trying to figure out how the how the basic functions work and after afterwards he was like can you can you you know cut me to my car you know I can't even walk it's I mean I like this concept of like I've got to be in space for a bit and I've got to be on but it's just it's just too much of a rules brain Bender like it's you know kind of insane you try to retach this word if you walk away from it from longer in a couple of days or so it becomes an absolute pain because there just so much to consider it's like if it was just a bit more streamlined I'd be playing it a lot because I did still enjoy it but I

couldn't keep it for the basis that it was just never going to hit the table yeah it's it's not hitting at the table very much for me me but I still love a game of it and I would definitely R teach you the game if if if you would come over and and i' I'd happily play it again it was just a massive thing although I mean it's not harder than hermany I just agree gin's got a lot of rules in it but then that's the rules are per player you know the players have their own individual bits to learn if if we're just talking like I'm sat down I need to know the basics and this thing it's a rules curve for sure but I would argue Gem's a lot more intuitive rules-wise particularly mainly because the theme is stronger in that one you know the stuff that you're doing with all the other players Works theme wise to the ah yeah that kind of makes sense because you would do this you would do this and they would obviously you know if I do this it's going to tick off the capitalist and it's going to you know be great for these or that this one's definitely more mechanical than formatic but it was still enjoyable and I do like this whole I need to be in space or on land cuz something else recent like evacuation yeah only said it was an average game but I do like the fact that you had to transfer stuff from old planet to new and you had two separate like areas that you had to be aware of same kind of deal with this you know and that was definitely probably my most fun bit of it but trying to figure out what on Earth I was doing was you know a different story but nah it it's it's solid but uh will I have a lerta later well we'll have to see I know what lert

that you have on your list so you know um right well this one we're going to Fantasy flight now so I did mention that the double siiz box is you know on my sort of minimum scale of this is a big box game I've got three of them over there that are this big and you know tried to pick a favorite wasn't the easiest one although I had to sort of think well hang on which one have I played more often recently and even then overall which one do I enjoy more and for that one I do like me a little bit of uh culu tentacle love every now and again so for for Mansions of Madness um you know the big double box there you get two of them on the shelf and that's it but you know especially when you start throwing in extra bits and Bobs on top it's it's going to take up the space but this is definitely one of my favorite kind of it's not my current favorite because you know we'll see later on in the list you know some things have come out to kind of eclipse it but it's one of those story based narrative formatic games which you don't play in a campaign you um yeah and I like the I mean the thing I like is the fact it's not a campaign it's scenarios managers the madness is get your investigators here's your mission use the app I like the app integration get over it people who don't like apps but you know it's a quicker game to set up because yes it's a big box but all you've got to do is just get your starting investigators and items which the app tells you what they are

and then a couple of map tiles and then you go the rest of it you set up as you go along now these Miniatures suck they suck absolute balls you know to the point where literally I think I've got them all I've got like a suitcase storage thing for Mansions of Madness because I've got like all the expansions and stuff all the Miniatures are now stuffed into a bag you know they're they're stuffed into a couple of bags based on type in a separate box and I never open that box again I only use the tiles now when I play this game because these Miniatures a don't look very good but they are the most fiddly thing ever and the whole idea of sliding the tile which has good artwork on it and important stats into this stupid black plastic thing it's just like a dumb idea that that was a horrible version of it but I just used the tile you know do I want this little gray miniature or do I want the artwork with the stats on it I'm going to use that like hands down so with that blemish aside oh God weird paint work there yeah this the culu one is is very strange this this one is much better yeah the it kind of varies but I mean oh you want like a fmatic story you you want like cool the app telling you things like you know it's not just attack enemy for six damage no it's like what type of attack do you want it magic bladed blunt unarmed and then it gives you a little Narrative of you know you slide under the cultist legs sweep up sweep the legs and stuff that so it's adding to the story and there are some

great scenarios with this you anything from you know house traveling in time to an Airship with a who done it mystery you know uh some that are heavy combat some that heavy theme start off captured you got to get out of this area it's like I I do really get a kick out of this one it's and it's and say the fact that it's an eia one to bring out is one thing because most Campaign games are so like ridiculously hard to get played you know you know there are some Campaign games I have played enjoyed and sold before I can finish finish them because they just can't get finished but when it's a scenario I don't know why it's so hard for scenarios these days I don't need a 20 Mission campaign just give me 20 scenarios you and then add more as you go along I just think that's a a better one I got to admit if they did make a Marvel version of this I would buy it within seconds like that would not be a difficult purchasing choice I don't I I don't know uh actually IP's really don't work with me I so the I've never have any connection with marvel at all I well I like my Marvels I got me well Marvel Champions there for a kickoff but even um even Marvel dagger is still on my shelf from before because I've enjoyed that one so yeah if it's Marvel chances are I'm going to like it you know they may be slacking a little bit on their movies lately but they the the general comic La that is still uh popular with me but yeah if I want to I need a scenario based game one of them

that I'm going to pick these days is going to be Mansions of Madness all right right was that sixes fives so we're still in space I for cry out loud changed the record you're as bad as Roy cada oh thank you uh I'm not as colorful as him but you know I I appreciate the uh so this is actually a game that is not talked about a lot it is heavily themed it's based on one of the biggest IPS in the world and uh the funny thing is that I haven't seen a single episode of that IP still I love the game to Pieces I'm trying to think which ones are based on IP but there's one I can think of that wasn't a big box the uh the the base box had three factions in it now it has seven I think and you can play with all of them and it's a big Mega game with uh you know it takes a long time to play but I can tell you with the right crowd I love Star Trek ascendency okay I've I've not played this one yeah this one I think actually you would like uh if being being taught

by people that and then you know we when everybody knows the game except for you so it's you know it's easier teach um it what I like very much about this game is it is so highly asymmetrical I mean every single faction of this game is different and you know the Federation is probably the most boring one that you play figes yeah but uh uh there you have the Romans and the the cleance those are the ones in in the base game but then you have the frankis and you have you know you even have pork ass simulation that will work as a so it's it be becomes a co-op at that point is it well it's a semi Coop because you know you just want you you want to fight the Bor but I just want to push them to you also and you know so and get you killed but not me so have you not have you not heard a thing that Q is said don't provoke the Borg like I said I have absolutely no connection to the IP uh the it's just yeah I I I sometimes I cannot uh fully explain why I like IPS that uh that I don't like the IP and but you know like Trek no I I have no I have no connection to

Star Trek at all I haven't seen you know I might have seen like five or six episodes in whole and but just you know the how the mechanics are in this game how this game functions where you are building your space lanes and there is a a random length you roll a die to see how long the the lane between the uh the uh planets are and then all of a sudden you can connect to another uh system and and start screwing other people's uh things up and it's just it's amazing game I'm surprised you went near this not like in Star Trek though it was you know I have a friend who he can bring out he he actually has done this more than once because uh not on my list but another another IP that I've haven't seen a single episode of is Firefly and I love Firefly the game okay okay you have got I mean I'm not going to expect you to like catch up on a a ton of Star Trek CU that's a little bit much but you have got to catch up on Firefly I do I do have Firefly the Blu-ray in my other room I I might start watching it at some point that's an easy one to get through 14 episodes in the movie and you're done I know I know this one this is one I actually do want to play though because I more of a connection to Star Trek you know certain series more than others I mean you know

I love generation I love Voyager I don't particularly care much for the original t or the um uh Deep Space 9 you know it's just and I quite like Discovery after it finally got a bit better and strange new words I'm really loving so it's like I say there are some series I like some I don't but generally Star Trek is a theme I do enjoy so this game is definitely one I want to try but not me purchase the game and try and learn and teach it there are a couple of people I know with this game I want them to teach me it right well just come just come to my retreat in in iseland in February and you know I will teach it to you you should said I'm Dum but it's uh I'm looking at it so there's only so much holiday left if anybody likes Star Trek even a little bit and like Space games I mean this is a Forex game you know in all its beauty um there is another Forex uh star game that is not on my list although I love it uh two pieces as well so this this is the one that I go for more than the uh than than filot Imperium there is yeah definitely I mean I say spoiler alert that's not on my list it's it's a fine enough game it's just way too long um righty five for me okay I debated to put this on the list cuz I had to really look at the box and go is this bigger than others I wasn't entirely sure it

wasn't as big as I thought it was but it is still big I mean it's comparable to a Fantasy Flight size I think it's like marginally bigger or around that size so it still counts I think but you know as much as I've said most Campaign games I'm not as big on anymore because I just know that they're never going to get played there is one campaign game particularly that I give leeway to and that is mainly because even though the mechanics are you know hit and miss in some places I have had to house rule a couple of things to make it a bit more less grindy but the theme of Tainted Grail is unmatched with any other campaign game I have played I abs are you trying to find your copy to look at the size yeah yeah it's no I I I actually shipped it away to to my secondary storage but why do you why do you say that is uh marginable it's like a a box and a half of ticket to right it well I mean it was whether it matched a a double siiz Ticket to Ride Like You Know was it comparable to some of the other choices I had to debate about it but it's on the list now um but this one I I tot I totally agree yeah this one though from a campaign perspective just cannot be beat I've had to house rule a couple of things to make it less grindy but the 2.0 version Kings of Ruin does fix a lot of that stuff so that is going to be a I'm waiting for that yeah although I don't know if awaken Realms remember they owe me a copy for doing the preview I'll bet after all this time they've forgotten

but uh I'll have to try and um remind them of this fact because I do want the game but oh God blam me the theme of this playing this with some Arian sort of Style music in the background and going through this story with this phenomenally gritty artwork the great setting it's not all love and rainbows and everything like that it's like no this is a horrible world you're in everything's gone to pot you've just got to basically survive I've just and and I've played through like most campaigns I don't ever finish this is one where I have finished almost all of the content for the first edition so I've done the base campaign I've done the frost age of legend or whatever it was called the the last night I think it was called and I've done the age of Legends prequel one so I've done all three of them I just haven't done the extra hard red uh one or whatever it was called I forget exactly that one the game's hard enough as it is I don't feel like I need an extra difficulty curve but oh I mean I've not played the Steam app like version of this you know to see whether it's uh like anywhere near the same or something different but I hav the the narration the story and the writing with this setting is just so good you know whoever writes the stories in this I I hope they write novels elsewhere or something because it sounds like they should be be especially for gritty fantasy settings I like this card combat I know some people weren't as fans of it

but I thought it was quite a clever little puzzle trying to you know get the best combo to survive against ridiculously tough enemies I mean that was one problem with the game the difficulty curve was a little bit extreme but you know I like I like the the combat system very much I dislike the uh the social uh part that you know those diplomacy diplomacy yeah that that that just I I tried and tried and tried and I never fully understood that how it worked it was a weird system but the main thing was that diplomacy wasn't as good as combat like you really wanted to be good at combat diplomacy was a side thing so far Kings of Ruin I think balances it a little bit better but I still think combat's probably a bit more important still anyway but depy is no longer like a waste thing but okay yeah it's there's not many campaigns that I will sit through I mean I have I don't want to say the in case you've got them on your list but there are several that I've played where I've gone this is an enjoyable game but I'm never going to finish this it's either too much or maybe the mechanics aren't as good or the story isn't that but a lot of the times it would just be a case of I can only have so many Campaign games I'm willing to get out and play a lot and tainted Grail always ends up being better like I I I play this one I play a few missions of it and I go this is fun I prefer TG boom you know this was fun I prefer TG and you know when kings of Ruin comes out you know whether I'll keep the first edition I don't know because I know there is like a update pack that will come out for it to bring it up to 2.0 rules that might make me

want to sort of maybe repeat play it at some point but I think TimeWise more likely I'll just have it in storage and play the second one but yeah I'm looking forward to it you know this one is easily probably the most immersive campaign thing I've ever played I can't think I can't think it one better I can well we'll see if it comes up

later well we're back from space have we actually landed on planet Earth now or at least a planet yes we landed on a planet just not earth now all right so we still technically well yes Tech I I think technically we are still on Earth uh my my number four is so this designer has become a huge favorite of mine if not both because uh he tends to create games that I love uh very much but also because that man is just one huge huge machine and if I tilt my head just a little bit to the right you will see a full sh he of his games yes that one yeah I debated it yes so yeah and I have this disguise as well but uh that one still is waiting to hit the table but for sure sleeping Gods is my number four um first of all this game is gorgeous uh very often I like to play games with other people but sleeping Gods is actually one of the rare occasions where I actually just like to play it

solo um or I think I've already played it solo I at least with not more than two people and that is just because uh when you when you split up to more and especially in sleeping Gods where you have what eight or nine characteres uh it's it's just it's too hard to get the Synergy between the characters because you yeah all of a sudden all of a sudden even though everybody is in the same boat uh because I'm doing the fighting you cannot really help me out or I mean that that part is a little bit wonky and but this story and just the huge world and what you can do in this game is just I've I've I played three times through and I still have South and Southeast to explore in the in the on the on the island and and I and I also have the expansion with the with the Dungeons and and and and all that so it's just it's ridiculous amount of content it it's definely so much in there I mean I've played it I've only played through it fully once and I do love it I this I think this was probably like my 11 or 12 like I did I think it just missed it because I haven't wanted to get it out since I finished it one way through but yeah I could just head out in like one or two different directions and just have a completely different experience I think it was just the idea that controlling nine characters was a bit

much yeah yeah I know the second one distant guys I think fixed that a bit I I think there are five so it's it's much easier and and I think it fixes a lot of problems that the the original had but I mean you know for for a game this big I forgive just a little bit of oopsies that can be a you know especially if you can easily hous rule them or if you do what I do and just play them play them solo uh I I there is there is this game is almost to a Perfection this one yeah there's there's a couple of little bits like particularly with the combat that sort of get a little bit much at times but I did I I did really enjoyed I say it is still there cuz I hope one day I will get it out and just play another run through at some stage maybe with the dungeon stuff added on for a bit of extra thing I only played it solo I can't think why I would want to play this as a group the the the fact that all the characters are split and Synergy wise it would just go a little bit all over the shop would just I think that would just get a little bit too much you know playing it solo yes nine characters is a pain to keep track of but then you get to go and just enjoy this immersive World by yourself and you know the guy is a machine I don't know how he's creating this much story content like he does nothing else dayto day apart from Just Right Stuff you it's the only way I can think of you would expect some of these games to just fall apart at the seams because there's too much in it and

yet they're still cohesive yeah I mean I mean to think of it that for the for the past three years he've done uh this one this disguise the the the the the uh print and play version of sleeping Gods the the Peril of whatever and yeah and then now and now and never and which is a fine game as well so I mean just how does he do that no it's literally gotta be all he does I can't imagine that he does anything else in his life from e but but then again I I mean his wife writes a lot with him and she writes the music so I mean it's defin it's definitely you know they they they can definitely work together that is that is definitely a merit made for the two of them yeah it does work there um interesting then that James mentions my my games are stored as a mix of horizontal than vertical because some of the I mean they're vertical they're horizontal it it just depends on the game you know some games will store fine vertically and some won't so I tend to just mix and match for a bit of variety I think you pretty much by the looks of it store only vertically but I know some games where the components will just fall out everywhere if they're not well yeah obviously you're not going to store those giant things vertical but but I mean some of these I mean I technically could do these vertical I

don't see why not they were just there I guess but yeah it's just on and off my my second storage actually has uh I store them vertically there and I am thinking about changing but it's going to take a while you know when I redo my my room here I will most likely store some of them at least vertically fair enough right you said earlier that you know exactly all right is you said ear on that you know exactly which game from this designer would be on my shell which is not surprising considering how much we discussed this ahead of time and it's probably not no it's not that it's just I know you and we played this game together and we had a blast when we did because we also played it with lorta himself yes we did do that and not to mention you know thanks to thanks to Shir shirt and merch studios I've now got the T-shirt to effec go with it yeah I I I debated about whether a long rectangular box was good for the list but as soon as we agreed yes Eagle Griffin was there it's like fine which is my favorite it's kban you know without a shadow of a doubt you know this one I just love you the theme of this one is so strong and I liked it in its first iteration but the it was fiddly stronghold games was not the best one at doing the busy board with a very fiddly rule book and as much as I always Lov to play the game it was just fiddly then when Eagle Griffin started doing their Deluxe forms this one was pretty much Shut Up And Take My

Money the second it was there I knew it was expensive I knew it was uh you know ridiculously priced and stuff but I was like I just did not care because you know making cars from blueprint to get the parts to assemble them to test them all formatic dodging sandre your boss we've all had bosses we don't like it work this is a that istic and it's interactive as well because I there's so few spes to go timing is very important you must know where your opponents are going to jump on and jump off spacewise at any given moment and then you're fending for all of these bits in The Boardroom where you're kind of just like the pictured here you know Sandra staring at you and you're basically all on this table going miss look I've done this and there so and so's copying my work you know don't give me anything this there just lot of cool things on this but the eagle Griffin version made the components a lot better the board is a lot easier to read the rule book is a lot better you know the solo mode is a bit of a faf to Pilot but it works you know it does work as a solo mode it's just quite a lot of rules to get around but honestly this isn't a game I tend to want to play solo this is one where I'm like I've played it two player and I enjoy it a lot there but if I can get three or four for this this is just my lerta game of choice and as much as it's closely followed by gallerist um they were offending for Supremacy for a bit I think it's like nah it's kban you know I love gallerist but this one just Pips it yeah I totally agree I you know it

it's it's just how sort does theme there is a hit and miss I mean you know we machine is probably you know but even with weather machine I actually have uh read quite a immersive uh detailed listings on how weather machine is thematic and after that I was like okay uh I I get you but when I need to read a 10 page listing explanation that is a little bit too much but I get you when I talked about weather machine at some length saying why I thought it was you know above average like I like it but I don't love it when I started to mention that I didn't think it was a phatic game oh my God you got to be careful the people come out of the woodwork to slag you off of that because these people will go oh no this is exactly how it works in the field of science with making Publications and stuff and it's like okay maybe but isn't the game predominantly about a machine that mucks around with the weather and you're doing all this stuff it's like why is the bit of theme I should be focusing on just making Publications I don't know it's a the theme does not jump out of from weather machine as much that but after B yeah I think lur is starting to slip a little bit in terms of theme though cuz late originally there was what like a well for me it was kban gallerist and vgos right all three of them are wonderfully fmatic games lbo is historically accurate and I guess fmatic in a way but that one takes a bit

longer yeah well let me come off this screen yeah yeah lb's got a strong theme but it's mainly if you've had the history lesson to go with it but then wether machine's theme is a little bit more disjointed I would actually argue I don't think inventions has any theme I think that is bone dry that one um the newer one it is but I loved it ah it was a good game yeah I like it okay it was fine but it was just like you know I just didn't get much theme from it escape plan that technically does have a strongish theme but I just hated the mechanics with that one that was just a dud for me I I typically at least like to play any Lura even if like say inventions I only find them average Escape plan's the one I won't play again but yeah it's just like the earlier ones I just think like their themes were just so strong and lately those themes just aren't coming out as much I don't know but or maybe there's just the settings aren't as interesting you know certainly you know a car factory of making cars is just like gold dust for me or something because I like cars and that sort of thing will work but then you like cars cars are cool okay have you seen your car my car is awesome shut up my susuki Twi sport is amazing so um you know I've like religiously watched like you know the old top gears and grand Tours and stuff with that so I still I still like the the concept of making a car with the factory and dodging Sandra and that just works from that aspect um I've not played a board

um sorry what was it called bot Factory I've not played that one I don't know if that's any good or not but uh is that on your sh yep that good unplayed yet oh unplayed yeah so yeah I want a little bit I want I want to return to a really solid theme or something you know cuz I was shocked at you know I was shocked how little theme inventions had I think that was kind of like the biggest problem I had cuz inventions just sounds like it's tailor made to have a really cool Rich theme but it doesn't sort of follow through with that which was a little bit concerning and weather machine I suppose technically does have the theme with the Publications but the whole weather machine thing is just a madeup setting as opposed to anything else I mean you've you've got the four different different R&D things for like here's rain here's cloud and all that but none of them have any differentiation or meaning so it doesn't necessarily work in that sense I have not tried the new one that he was using at gridon Speak Easy uh because no me neither I didn't jump into it could it be worth I don't know that setting I'm not sure if I'm the biggest fan of that theme but if it's thematic I'll still give it a shot so I mean I I'll certainly try any Lera game you shove in front of me that's the thing it's he's got enough of a reputation and enough likeness the four games that are on my shelf you know the chosen four which is Vineyard I don't know why that's um I think cuz I took it off to measure the size of something I put it back wrong but uh I'll correct that when this video is done for now you're just going to have to accept that it looks weird and see if anybody with OCD has a problem with

that so I just noticed that we're at number threes and we still have not had any but I am no we haven't no I mean we've crossed over on i' say the publisher and the designers but we've not necessarily picked the same favorite no but I am guessing that we actually do have a crossover now uh no you know that you will cross over with this one that is uh so I I've said that I love asymmetrical games a lot so what really uh good big box game is fully asymmetrical um with some high tension there's a lot of those I think yeah we actually mentioned it earlier in the show it's head Jam money of course well um okay slight thing about that one um we'll get on to that a bit later but carry on yeah yeah I yeah I mean it's bigger come on it's bigger than it's not that much bigger than the Ticket to Ride box it it fell short of the size requirement that's the reason it's not on my list otherwise yes it would be probably my number one right yeah no I hemony is just it's when I when I saw it on Kickstarter uh

it was like okay here we have a game that is either going to be one of the best games ever made or it's going to flop like crazy because it was it was being made by people who are very much into Political Science so normally what what can well not normally but what can happen is that they take the theme over the uh mechanics and they don't mix and match but they really really did that in this game um I've I've played it uh I still have to play the um the capitalists but I played the yeah the three three other factions and it was just it's so tense it's so much fun there is so strange that you know if the first time I played I was the uh the the government and uh who and your first game was yeah well there were four of us playing all for the first time so you know State and when they play the when the capitalists played like yeah I need some sponsorship you have to pay me like you know gazillion amount of money and you know and all that kind of thing it's highly thematic and it was just there's a lot of uh Ro rope pulling and just you know General tension in this game so um yeah I I said that it's a bigger than

ticket to right box there for it fit my my criteria of a a bigger box yeah that was cuz I looked at it downstairs and S measure it and I realized I could fit three of these games on a shelf if I like had them next to each other or something and it just fell slightly shy cannot argue that it's unexpectedly become one of my favorite games like it's like how the hell this theme managed to resonate with me I don't know cuz when they first got told yeah cuz the designer recognizes like the stuff I did for pursue your happiness so like you know they said oh you know we can give you a hegemony game we'll send it off you know I think Paul Groen and I got it about the sameish time I was really like tentative about it cuz I thought this could be amazing by what I'm hearing or like you say it could just be something I hate I don't know and c and I don't think I've put so much investment into a review as this one is because this one obviously required you to play it with all four different asymmetrical factions multiple times I ideally and solo I have played it with solo Al on the mode and really get to grips with it and then do the detail review this you know this one took a lot of time to CH through because I really wanted to give it the beans so glad I did though this one is just such a sh I can't even imagine this theme ever being one that I would s go oh a social politics game right exactly exactly yeah but it just works it does did you see

that they have another game in the pipeline at ESS yeah New World Order or something like that um world order yeah World Order um I've pretty much given up doing previews on the show except for ones I cherry pick and I did say to them I'll do one for world order so yes I I suspect I will uh end up with some prototype for that one I will literally fly over to Britain and take the train to Portland if you get that so that you know Port yeah the only thing is I mean it isn't I mean I'm worried a little bit about it because it is mainly a sort of like an area control theme but it's going to have the international politics thing so the theme could still be sell it me I I don't think from what I'm being described to it I'm going to like it as much as hegemony but I'm hoping I still really like it so you but just like as much as there's a rules learning curve here the stuff just makes sense everything flows and some games with asymmetrical factions like really asymmetrical stuff tend to be very separate like I have no in playing something like Merchant's Cove um for the sake that every faction is they well they I mean it's a dry Euro anyway but it's just every faction is completely different but you're kind of doing your own thing in the sense you know this one you're completely in each other's face like throughout like everything you do has a massive impact on what someone else is doing uh root I give root respect I mean I don't love it but I mean I like it for what it is and but you know some factions work for me some

don't um here I'm happy to play any of the four classes I mean granted I feel like I've played middle class too much being the one teaching the game but I love playing the state you know when I teach the game because at the end of the day you want somebody ideal who knows what they're doing and can gauge how well everybody else is doing so I love playing that character who can go you know uh you know what working class will bump you up a little bit like capitalist go stay you got too much I'm holding you back for a bit and just being able to kind of which allegiances like that throughout does make the state very enjoyable for me if anything yeah I don't think I've played capitalist as much as the other three classes uh because somebody else always likes to play it just for theme wise but uh you know I do want to play that class a little bit more lately because I seem to be one of the only few people with a lot of us who play it at kenat who has won with capitalist so it's like some people keep saying oh it's a and this makes me laugh the fact that there's always somebody who says this class is overpowered this class is overpowered in most age of metrical stuff the designers made a big deal on Board Game Geek to post a screenshot from it where they said hegemony wins the award for being the only asymmetrical game where there is a Fred complaining that every faction is overpowered so so there is literally on BGG Freds for every faction saying it's overpowered no other game has done that so it's like that that's got to tell you it's reasonably balanced when all four of them are getting shown as overpowered it takes

I agree it takes it very but yeah I mean if it if it passed the size test it probably would have been my number one I suspect I would not have doubted it all right my free now this is definitely the largest game this is the crate size box for me and it's not going to be on your list it probably wouldn't be on many others list cuz most people have not even heard of the game let alone got it off Kickstarter which was the only way you could get this game um you know especially for because AEG don't seem to like to make their stuff easily available on retail um from John declair Yeah Yeah Yeah Yeah Yeah from John Edge of Darkness yeah yeah this one John declair does a hit and miss affair with the games I'll admit you know some I like some I don't but I love this card like crafty system I like Mystic Veil i i i bounced a tiny bit of dead wrecking or whatever it was the pirate one but I like it fine I like it fine I need to it some more um it was quite lucky swingy for my liking but I still want to try it again um but yeah all anything with that card system of like I get to create a card from scratch and do what I want with it this is the heaviest thing that he's put out heavier than dead reckoning for sure where this one is where it uses that system it comes in a giant ridiculous crate I don't know if the crate will show up on any of these pictures but if it uh well all there we go yeah so if anything I think that's smaller version than the one I've got

that that one looks small in comparison but the the game itself I mean yeah there's your box there's the big tower that's in it all those trays this massive board all these cards all this stuff this thing is jam packed with stuff and I'm not going to get it off the shelf cuz it's down there cuz I probably will break my hip trying to reach down and carry it but this one having the mix of not only the card crafting but the worker placement as well where you've got those 10 location and you're putting your agents there in order to get some cool engine going you know there's a lot of different paths to victory in any game of Darkness regardless of what locations are brought out the solo mode that voiceless Guild or whatever is actually not that hard to Pilot and good fun I find it's a pretty size pretty solid game yeah I think it uses these scheme cards but I love the fact that these cards you craft are available to everybody this is where the interaction comes in because the cards you create end up going across this middle row and each turn when you draw cards you spend the influence tokens to like draw specific ones but they could be neutral ones that have got nothing on them you always get an advancement every turn to slide in so you're constantly updating cards every turn you don't have to go out of your way to do it you can just maybe go out your way to make it more faster I guess but just because you've created an awesome card doesn't mean you're going to get it you know it will come out out of the deck and somebody might go well that is a fantastic card you know what I'll have it get some reward for it you know when

you do use it but I might have wanted the C give it to me you know s off that and it just makes for a very good interactive s mey experience but yeah it's a lot to get to the table in a pretty meaty Affair not too many rules actually you know compared to a lot of these big Behemoth games but yeah it's a behemoth especially with all the expansions that add more scenarios in it I mean I have made the mistake of being a completionist with this thing when I really shouldn't have because there's just too much content in the box for me to ever play in my life but we do like it it's the same person I mentioned who likes to carry on eario we both like this one quite a bit and you know some of the components vary you know in terms of quality it I feel like for the cost it's still built to a reasonable budget but yeah definitely one that I just fell in love with yeah I I played it once I liked it uh when a uh started the Kickstarter for uh the expansion to it um AAG did a huge Fu uh and and they they said that sorry we do not ship to Iceland and oh that was specific yeah yeah no they they just said no we do not ship to Iceland I did meet them at um at Essen this year and I said just what the fge is going on with you guys I mean we are L we are literally part of Europe it's not like

you're sending to uh to to a uh you know like a developing country where all the packages are stolen you'd think that the UK would be harder now so yeah and sometimes it is but uh but but still I mean why there there is for that matter I've never understood uh if a uh handling company or fulfillment company in Germany uh crafty shops I'm talking to about you for example that it's harder to print out a shipping label saying Luke Hector por UK than Hilmar ravic Iceland I mean for a crying out it's a shipping label you're putting on a box that's not I must about AEG with their kickstarters is not uh you know particularly great from history and certainly they do overpricing some like crazy in the shipping costom M because they're US based and that so this was anytime they bring out stuff at the edge of darkart that is like oh God this is going to be a lot of money but it's a it's a game I really like but it's why I haven't bought a lot of all the other stuff you know the the various ones like the Thunderstone quest one like I've always I've been tempted to grab that one but it's just like lots of money how often will I play it that's a ton of money that's always a lot of money it's like it's the the point repeats itself no matter what other problems I might have so yeah but yeah most people have not even heard of Edge of Darkness so it is a bit of a niche game but uh just one

that came out of nowhere and play it so finally we have a crossover oh God finally which to be fair I mean I mean my two you might Crossover with but you haven't mentioned it yet so unless it's your number one probably not uh there is absolutely no chance on Earth that my number one is going to be on your list uh but my number two is on your list just a little bit further down and you can see it uh by the right shoulder of you it's Mansions of Madness that I didn't expect of all the ones that you were going to cross over with I didn't expect that to be it really no you you have you you have heard me talk in you know quite a detail of how I love the cthulu Mythos of Fantasy Flight I have everything for Arkham Horror the card game that's the thing you mentioned more about the card game in Arkham Horror than you do Manion the madness specifically but well AR Man Of Madness is just Arkham Horror in in house I mean it's just so I I like all the games I have second to Third Edition of of the board game I have ELD horror I even have alter sign uh but man of Madness is definitely definitely one of you know my Staples on

uh the top 10 of all time nice uh yeah I totally agree I mean you know even the even the 4H hour uh scenario they had in the base game it's a long one but we had so much fun playing that scenario and the the you know people who say that the you know app is making it the computer game just you know yeah leave just go eat I mean it's just that's not the thing and and just how uh the variety of how just the layout of the house changes every single time and also when you have who done it scenario is never the same person who done it yeah it still changes things up I mean I can't remember how the 4H hour scenario went it was so long ago if I played it now it would just be like a brand new game at this point oh definitely definitely well that happens with the game that I played yesterday but you know but but yeah no uh Manchester Madness is just a genius of a game I love how the Synergy between how I know all the characters from all the other games but they are still have powers um in this game that they don't have in other games for example I mean Lucy is one of my favorite characters in this game she's the only character that I

just deny giving her weapons because she is just so much better fighting uh you know barehanded because you know of her martial arts I was going to say I think I know you mean yeah I know you mean yeah yeah yeah I mean I must admit is it Lucy I'm not sure Lucy Leu I think yeah that's the actress isn't it Lucy L oh no Leu oh maybe maybe I'm maybe I'm yeah I I have a book I know exactly which one you're on about yeah you're on about the yeah the martial artist she's quite a fun one in the card game but she actually on the picture she's literally on the picture in the front what on the front of the Box you mean or no no no no no on on on your screen in the front front detail isn't that her maybe it's not no maybe I'm Lily Lily Chen CH thank you yes I thought I thought I did begin with L I just can't remember but uh right yeah I've SE a pie on this swans I won't belabor but I mean I must admit I'm I've got the arhamar second edition stuff in this massive wooden crate up here I'm either going to Chuck it or find somebody mad enough to take it off my hands without posting it cuz I'm just never going to get it played second edition yeah I've got the third one down there in a couple of expansions but it's like I haven't even brought that one out to the table in so long I still enjoy it and I would probably play that sooner than second edition just purely because it's easier to get played but the problem is I'm at this point where I'm like okay I've got

Mansion of Madness Arkham second and Arkham third and if I'm going to pick out of those three I'm going to pick Mansions so why do I have the others it's it's and I've got the card game as well so again arhamar Third Edition lcg I'd probably still do the lcg so I've certainly got make a bit of a decis on those at some point but yeah I I love it too all right my number two well clearly it's not your number one I'm not sure if you've played it yet but I've made a big deal lately about video game licenses being brought to Big Bucks game well like board games I haven't played it and you know I like video games I love in general but I think they are perfect means to bring to board games because if they relate if if the theme is done strong and it's faithful that's already going to elevate The Experience obviously the mechanics are still got to be good to match but if you do get some half decent mechanics then you know you're in luck it's all going to be great and for me late you know at start of the year when I finally got a copy of it and could play it mostly solo but I have enjoyed my two free player games of this as well man did they do a good job with frost punk I was so worried that this one was going to like bomb or have horrible mechanics or something like that and granted they did need to fix the difficulty rating on this game cuz it was a little it was a little bit obscene I will play with the easy cards not the uh I mean you could possibly make me play a medium one but frankly I

think the easy ones are still challenging they are not easy they are just easier than hell difficulty and nightmarish hell difficulty layer seven that the hard ones are I mean I can't imagine why you would play the hard versions but God this game is so F matically rich and like so yeah I know just Johnny's uh finally turned up took your time Hello Johnny um but uh we said nothing about you at the start don't worry uh but Frost Punk oh man they took the theme and just made I mean not even just visually the fact you've got this giant Tower and all the surrounding buildings that I mean I've got these Miniatures and stuff it looks beautiful on the board put the frost Punk soundtrack on when you play this or this war of mine soundtrack both of them work fine and it just oozes the theme is's a lot of rules it's a lot to keep track of and certainly it's not going to be a short game even if you're playing it solo I mean if I played it now I'd probably have to relearn half the game so I'm like oh great how all that work it's a learning curve but as learning curves go this is one that I am happy enough to just go for it because it is just that much fun you i' you know playing it solo is great you know I do like to um you know play it solo I think for the most part but I have played it as we played it with Paul Grogan as a four player and that did take a long time but it was still a good laugh I've played it with a couple of friends of mine who I've convinced to buy the game and we play it as a free player and that worked

really well you know just having somebody that you can discuss the what you're going to do with with these laws and which ones you're going to pass and what buildings what routes to go down I mean this is a full Co-op experience um and certainly a little intimidating I can imagine cuz uh it's definitely got a lot in it and you I mean you don't have asymmetrical roles but you do if you are playing it as multiplayer you do technically have an aspect of the game you're responsible for and if you play it solo you need to know how all of those aspects work it is a little bit insane but I mean look at this thing you wouldn't even believe that all of I mean the mat is an add-on so ignore the mat but all of this other stuff you see here the cards the boards the pieces and everything like that fits in the base box you know and the Box isn't even that huge I mean it's big it's big enough for this list but you'd think it would be the size of like Edge of Darkness or something and it isn't forget that stupid Iceberg box that was a waste of time um the ridiculous oversized coffin that that thing came in as soon as folded space Frost bunk had something called an iceberg box which they did on the kickstarter it was this it was this huge long rectangular box that could hold it in the expansions but it was wiy it didn't look good had no artwork on it and it just wasn't very well designed but I used it because it fit everything then folded space brought out an insert for frost Punk which could get everything in the bass box so now I've switched back in fact I switched back

because I had to Nick the boxes off Paul Grogan to do it because I'd since chucked mine away so I was like ah whoops um but yeah theme mechanics story you know scenario base and no campaign let's face it the game takes long enough you do not need this to be a campaign the Miniatures look fantastic uh you know I've not I don't think I've even played all the scenarios in it yet because I find myself playing the first one a lot when I'm teaching it or just because it's easy enough rules but I will certainly accept more scenarios down the line some more LW cards and stuff you know if they ever want to expand on this like particularly with frost Punk 2 coming out soon on the PC that will be a a thing but yeah this one was such a please don't eff it up please get this right and thankfully they did they did uh i' the reason it's not on my list is because I've only played it once yeah so so that that was you know one of my criterias I have to be able to play it more than once if I wanted to have it on the list but I I definitely can see um why this game is on your list it's absolutely amazing I actually yeah but I realized yeah you're number uh yeah I I I was thinking about another game for your number two but of course that's number one uh I know you're number one and you fair enough I I'll just assume you I'll just assume your number one's bad I don't

know actually to be fair I just say looking at your ones I don't think any of them have been ones of disliked uh I mean Glen you're 10 I've only played the once nine have not played eight I like seven hit and miss six I like it was just too much five I want to try four I like three I love two I love yeah so I mean you know most of yours are generally like like that you haven't you haven't mentioned a game yet where I've like well you me well when you mention Betrayal on House of the hill I hate that one but thankfully that's not eligible for the list so I don't have to suffer through that one the Legacy game does yeah but that well to be fair does any body like the Legacy game of that I've not heard anybody talk about it I I I've played it twice why why would you want to I mean does it break as often as a normal game or do they fix them no of course it doesn't it it breaks but you know still I like it all right I don't know all right okay right number ones then I mean yeah mine should be obvious to most people by now but I'm curious what yours is

again it's a game it's also highly thematic it's also very much campaign driven it comes in a coffin and it has Frost in it no I was afraid we were G to I thought we were going to go through the whole list without mentioning one of them but uh sadly not no no no no no no no no my number one is of course Frost Heaven I mean you you just don't know what a good game is if if you don't like frost Heaven it's my number two game of all time uh it's a beast but it has a great story yeah yeah yeah whatever um the there is a huge difference between Gloom heaven and frost heaven in the fact that you know that you go into color scheme wise certainly yes of course it's white not I'll be good I'll be there are there are there are there are so many uh you know just how the story evolves in Frost Heaven they definitely thought more about that the changes between uh summer and winter where uh the winter is more harsh um when you when you go to frost heaven in the winter you are you're dealing with other things than you do in the summertime um we I my my uh gaming

team that played it has dissolved because uh the couple I was playing with moved to Norway those bastards uh but yeah but but still I mean I'm I am going to play this solo from now on just because I want to see how the story evolves it's it's just it's far too on as a group I think it's better for solo these games um I I actually think that for for if you can play it as a group if your group is either two people or some kind of mixture of couples so that there are two households they cannot be more than two households uh doing this game because uh if you try with more then everything thing goes down the you know the drain very easily and when you when you do it with a couple then then break up like I happened with Bloom Heaven that was yeah that was that was really really sad oh that I mean if I if I ever wanted to try these Havens again maybe the digital one because it would take a lot of the admin faf out of the game and I hear good things about the digital app I mean I I I've tried the digital app and yeah the my focus I cannot keep track of the focus you know just that you know the hit points go off and and my cards go away and I don't have the

physical components it's just not the same for me so I can't do the the app unfortunately but but you know try try and and see just how much time they they spent with the with the story um who said that uh Johnny Johnny doesn't like it Johnny no yeah Johnny doesn't like good games either uh hey Paul loves it yep of course Mike Mike likes the digital more than the physical though interesting okay yeah I mean for me for me it's the the digital one is just that I have a harder time keeping track of what's happening in the game because everything goes just like this right right and all the calculations and everything is done for you and you but then there is that a good thing cuz there's a lot to sort of calculate and make up while you're playing the physical game but but you don't get have so I can't keep track of what happened so why am I why why are my hit points at four all of a sudden and I don't see it because they just vanished because somebody attacked me you know that that's the thing so for that reason I like the like the physical one yeah I like give the digital one a try at some point but I mean I I tried to give Gloom Haven a chance several times not just Paul grogan's teach but you know the a few more times after that and I I think I remember playing in somebody's

campaign it was drop in Dropout so somebody could take over but after a few scenarios I was just getting bored it just wasn't working for me and I'm not a fan of the I mean some of it I found a little pretentious with the whole vsi we got this really cool system for doing your roles in that in combat it's like it's just a dice all you've done is replace the dice with a card deck it's still the same thing it's you know bits like that and and I think it was just one of those this is too big like I'm not going to finish this campaign if I ever try it you know if I bought the game I don't think I would ever finish it and you know I get that some people have it's taken them a long time I have certain friends who have uh taken most of their lives to finish the original Gloom Haven maybe Geor of the LI would suit me more I don't know being a smaller scale thing but uh and and so because the map is on on you know in a book yeah yeah but then but then that gets the thing of like right you've already got Gloom Haven and now you've got a separate rating separate ranking for Jaws now a separate one for Frost and it's like they're still predominantly the same game you know they got tweaks and that but not I'm justo they're just as bad but yeah or brass and Brass Burmingham but yeah ah no no we can I I'm I'm on the wagon that brass berming is just an expansion oh yeah that's it pretty much is but um you know everybody else tries to tell me otherwise all right well that's fair I

mean I thought we were actually going to be like oh my God he hasn't mentioned it yet and it's like oh it's going to be as one isn't it you know so I thought we would get through the whole lot without mentioning the most obvious pick for a big box game but someone had to do it I guess if the chat wasn't going to my number one new it would have probably actually been Frost Punk had this one not finally got the beans got played and got reviewed somewhat recently uh yeah right you played you actually played that game next to me at gridon yes yes it got played twice at gridon because teaching this is a breeze you know yes there's a bit of an FAQ and rule book is not perfect but the rules are so simple that a lot of it I can just teach as I play and if you've played even remotely heard of the video game a lot of it will make sense intuitively but this one is just working for me yes it's a big box it's got the Miniatures in it yes but it does have all the stuff in it you know it's not like it's a separate add-on it's not out on retail yet either so it's not like you can buy suddenly the small box version but like I said with video game licenses if you can get solid mechanics obviously yes that's going to help but if you respect your license and do justice to it it's going to like it's going to sing for everything and I cannot I would struggle I don't know Frost Punk's really damn good they are on par with how well they respect their licenses this is the video game straight ported you know everything from the artwork to how the characters work to

what all the monsters do how they look in like miniature wise the missions you've got the weapons you can have which you can chop and change your hearts content this thing is just basically Deep Rock Galactic and I mean I was playing the game earlier I still keep playing the computer game um you know every down again because I could literally just go well I got 20 minutes spare you know what I'm just going to play a quick uh you know 20 minute game of Deep Rock Galactic and have some fun with that but uh even I mean I play it solo I can play it with BOS Bosco you know the little robot that you have um which still makes for a good fun game I played it the other week doing the solo thing so I wanted to play it a couple of times before the review but I played it twice at gridon with four of us and you know a mixture of people who have heard of the game or not I wish these photos were a bit better but um the it just works it as again scenario based there's no ridiculous amount of you know campaign stuff you got to do ah yeah this is a good picture I like this one um but it it just you know you can tailor the difficulty it's a bit too easy on the first couple of levels you want to sort of crank up the difficulty a bit 14 missions you can create your own the map layouts can be different the monsters obviously what event cards come out will chop and change things but it's one of those co-ops that everybody gets there something I described similar to flasho fire rescue where you've got a lot of options and they're all generally quite good so as much as we can all discuss

with each other what a good plan is you can still do something and not feel like you're scuppering the team you know it's a bit different from something like say pandemic where you can kind of solve the next turn to say this is clearly the best thing you should do and this is subpar with this it's not that that subar I mean you want to kill this enemy well it could be a threat you want to go grab the you know par of Bloom that we need to do well it is the objective you know that is still the thing and so it just it makes for good stories and if you do play this with people who know the video game as well as I do then yeah the quotes are just going to be the references are just going to keep coming out with loads so I was again with frost Punk all these video game license games I am scared when they come out cuz I want them to be amazing but there have been some major Duds with video game license games you know don't get me started on Skyrim and Fallout for example but you yeah you wrong about Fallout but but the uh have you have you tried Fallout with the expansion no no okay so that fixes Fallout so I mean again I I I I can I can understand why you don't like Fallout if you haven't tried the expansion I'd give it a try with the expansion to see if it does actually fix it I'd give it a shot um but yeah Skyrim that was horrible um but the with this one yeah I just get an absolute kick it's like 99.9% faithful to the game I've already backed the expansions this is a very overpriced game certainly uh the kickstarters are very expensive particularly for the

expansions but I want more content please you know I want uh I want overclocks for the guns I want the biomes I want the sort of space rig things there the mini expansions from the new things are going to be great like having a bulk Detonator run around the giant thing that explodes it's like that's going to be what the miniature for that's going to be like is insane so yeah it only recently whoop only recently been able to give this one as many much of the beans as I could but I love it yeah yeah I you know I haven't played it so is it in anyway no it can't be you know the one game that you know I thought that might be similar to this one is Project Elite no it's not a project Delite is timed so you know everything comes on and you're going ah Chuck everything on no no this is a typical like take it and turn Skirmish creatures activate you know I mean the game play is literally you do free actions from a list of all these actions draw an event and then that event will do stuff and then next player next player next player so that is simple enough it's just what those events are and when the Swarms trigger is when the creatures activate and do their thing so it's a it's like I say a typical scenario based Skirmish game but it's probably despite the fact that it does have slight FAQ and rule book issues which they are going to fix for the upcoming Kickstarter a 2.0 book which I definitely will be getting but I've

puted out some summaries and I know the game well off anyway you know it is definitely one of the easiest ones to just get out and play doesn't take a lot of setup and doesn't have a lot of teach time so it's doing it for me right oh yeah one crossover so question is what I like James comment yeah next top 10 we need big games in boxes that are too small yes anything I mean the whole list would just be devia games all of their games are in boxes that are too small and the original Garfield game lineup yeah yeah yeah exactly I mean you know of things uh for example yeah no that that is that is true I just realized when you were talking about the FAQ and and stuff that I actually forgot a game that should have been on my top 10 and the reason it's I forgot about it is that I played it twice uh it's coming on Kickstarter but I don't have it in my collection and that's probably why got it which is Batman Gotham City Chronicles I mean love Batman and stuff but I mean until they until they learn how to write a freaking rule book yeah no no no no so so a a good friend of ours wrote the new rule book and I was I play tested it twice so therefore I know the rule book is good finally finally in in the third printing I mean just but but yeah that

would definitely have been on my list if I had just remembered it I'll play it again with a proper robot but my God it was a massive slug for there so right people in the comments come on get your big gck games in there I want to see which ones we missed I mean yeah I mean certainly sleeping gods were like like 11 or 12 I did consider a few things like Rising Sun and that but then I've sold Rising Sun so that's not quite one of my favorites these days obviously I mean over there with the Fantasy Flight stuff I decided not to do Rebellion or forbidden Stars which is next to it I don't think you can see it on camera so um you know those two certainly were on the agenda but I play manss of Madness more than I do the other two so that one took priority for Fantasy Flight um we've already mentioned Nemesis I know Johnny's got here a bit late um Arc NOA failed the size thing it's it is a long rectangle yes but I would imagine that if you squish that down into a square box you would get Ark noova in a typical box maybe not necessarily Ticket to Ride size maybe slightly large but I don't think you would need like a Fantasy Flight double siiz box to fit Arc NOA if it was a square um because the majority of it is cards and cards are easy enough to condense down the tiles would probably be the biggest thing and maybe like the board because I mean the main reason it's even a rectangle boxes because the board is predominantly a long rectangle so I did

debate Arc NOA a lot because a bit like um hegemony it would have just easily shut up to like one or two or something had it being on the list but I figured that if I was going to allow Arc NOA I'd have to allow stuff like loss Runes of arnac and AR and arak's not that big a box even though it's a long rectangle so I had to draw the line somewhere uh AR NOA AR NOA Man Of Madness well we've mentioned it twice um on our list and yes it is massive with all expansions but we're talking base game alone it was already a big enough box there um that a good one not played it but Max yeah Max versus minions is a huge box that's another one that I haven't played enough to to get on this list I say not even some people have had it and I've never joined in the game with them I mean programming games I don't dislike them but they're not as high up on my genres I like as others that is just so funny that's to say it's light yeah it's it's very light and I like it but you know just haven't played it enough I had void fall in number 11 I had fields of Arley on the list War of the Rings second edition eclip second dawn of the Galaxy I did I did contemplate War the ring um but I don't like the game enough on that I was actually afraid you were when you kept saying we're in space we're in space we're in space I was waking like he's going to say eclipse at some point and I'm going to give him hell but yeah he didn't no he didn't um which is good

yeah eclipse is fine but it was on number 17 on my list seventh continent I thought about to but that is also a card game that you know is in a bigger box like uh I I feel like it doesn't need to be in a bigger box I mean and even then is it that bigger box if you just buy the base set of it B the base set of it is like Feast of feast for I mean it's it's three CS of of of cards it's a huge C thing so that yeah um no pursuit to happiness no because yes that is that but we said said at the start we're not doing big box storage solutions that is a storage solution you can buy Pursuit of Happiness in a typical even slightly smaller even than the Ticket to Ride size bux you know that's only a big bux because it holds everything for pursuit to happiness in it and it's stuff like the wingspan nesting box and stuff like that we know we're not including just a storage box because they're always going to be big and also that's only big because of expansions the base gameer Pursuit is not that big uh ah Matt this is one that I was waiting for on your list what happened to Mosaic I know the retail version is not big maybe that's the reason but that other one you made us play in Iceland um that's big yeah it was it was on my list it's number 27 I mean there were just 2 that L right yes well I made I made up to 63 so well I know you had a longer short list than I did but yeah I don't I mean once I get past 1520 I stop you know right no no no

it was just I it was an interesting thing to do and I I like to try it I mean you know one game that is uh here that fits but just didn't make the cut is actually just right here tapestry uh I suppose it is big books yeah yeah it's not yes it is uh broken yeah whatever I mean what do you mean whatever that's an important part of a game is it broken I mean you you just read the FAQ version 17.4 and uh and and then they might have fixed it at least tap tapestry is the board game equivalent of a video game live service it's like is tapestry is cyber punk in board game form it's like we'll fix it eventually with updates and patches the the one thing that actually surprised me the most because uh I'm not sure why it happened but Marakesh is on number 24 and I was surprised with that well what do you mean you were surprised you know I you know I'm not a failed fan no I'm I'm I'm surprised that it didn't go higher on my list all right I mean yeah mares is definitely big backs yeah because that one's bigger than the other ones in that lineup oh def definitely with all the with all the pieces there um endless endless winter

mentioned earlier so that one's already done journey in Middle Earth I sold it recently I do really like it um I just exhausted all the content for it yeah I mean that that probably would be in MA tees somewhere I mean that I mean comparable box wise it's the same as a f i mean that's the thing it's the same as a fantasy Fox Fox Fantasy Flight box size for Journeys to Middle Earth yes when you get all the expansions it's a lot bigger but the base set is about as big as those and I probably after tossing and turning yeah M of Madness would still get the uh list on there ank I mean I've not played ank I wasn't the biggest fan of blood rage Rising Sun I do like but I have sold it because unfortunately Rising Sun suffers from the problem that once you realize that the cards are better than any other strategy in the game the game is kind of solved so it's it's started to get a little bit problematic at that point the the the uh the hu the biggest insult that I've heard about ank I I so I backed ank I have ank with everything and uh I I played it with a A friend of mine once brought it down at the store we played it uh you know I opened up both the boxes I have everything in just two boxes and I took the content out that we were playing with and so 85% of the content is still in the box when when you do that and he said after words that

well technically you can fit that into a uh a box like uh well like a small well it's oversized isn't it yeah yes like a bonfire box because you know you so why is it in a big box it's because it's all plastic I mean if you if you replace all the plastic with with you know standies you could fit it in a much much smaller box there is that I mean deep rock galac is similar because I they haven't released a retail box of it but they will maybe that's a much smaller game but the Miniatures are in the box that I get it's not like cuz Frost Punk is big enough with just its box yes there is a Miniatures add-on in a separate box but even the just the normal box is Big so that kind of works on there uh I mean I've not played D because I think by that point I just got sick and tired of Eric Lang in this game so it's like yeah I'm not like playing any more of them and yeah the merging mechanic just sounded bad on paper so I can't imagine it's going to work too well in the game I I find that as a weird Rule and when I've seen it on playthroughs it's like oh yeah I can see that's a little problematic uh Lords of Watty H it's it's it's not necessarily a big backs game it's just horrible shape it's like yeah I'm pretty sure you could fit lots of V easily in a ticket to right box yeah if you did there now obviously I would not care about Mage Knight um but

people did suggest that as a big box one although that's the ultimate edition doesn't that include a bunch of expansions within it yes yeah exactly so I mean that's got an expansion it so isn't that technically a cheat but you know so that's why it's not on my list but then I guess the base set wasn't exactly small so you know I guess it it could pay be work ISS Vanguard I did consider I sold it because I was never going to finish it it is a bit of a faf to relearn all the rules because as much as it does have a fun tutorial in it it still takes forever to play the tutorial and there's still a lot of rules you need to learn on top of that but yeah ISS Vanguard is no small slouch you know that is definitely a uh big bucks one for sure I just would rather Play Tainted Grail um lots of people will naturally mention Nemesis try to think what um other ones were on my short list I can load up my Google Drive and actually find out my special Google Drive uh nope that's my top 10 of 23 I don't want to spoil that really nope forbidden star Star Wars rebellion fine Frost Bank Nations um I wasn't certain if that box was big enough and Nations wouldn't be a top 10 but you know potential fields of ir and like I mentioned I had to choose one UI Rosenberg and I chose the biggest buck even though I think Fields ofar would have been the alternative if I was literally just going for my ultimate favorite but for some reason just gave the edge to the box size on that one uh path for civilization yeah behind me I

did contemplate that it wouldn't be enough for a top 10 but um yeah this sort of thing near but it is definitely a big box it takes up nearly half the cic Shelf which it probably again doesn't need to in fact I am kind of curious why it's in the box that big because it could have been condensed down uh T cerebria I chose an acony as a mine Clash game Vindication was tempting but I was trying to find out if it was that I mean I have to admit Vindication probably wouldn't be top 10 but I think indication definitely fits in the Box you know the box size definitely goes it's a rectangular it's in the eagle it's a giant one yeah yeah yeah I I did I think that would probably be alongside sleeping Gods is kind of like the 11 or 12 um CU that was definitely in there uh and the only other one of the ones I played was Z cuz Z comes in a big enough box that it actually juts out of the the cic Shelf it doesn't fit in it enough um but Z have not played in a long time it's I'd only ever play it solo it's got a lot of rules ton of setup even with the insert but I do like it it's just like I say I just not brought out ages that wouldn't be a top 10 yeah nations in there um funny enough Adam if you scroll back a bit a little bit further in the list about Midway you might hear something about Star Trek um right smack in the middle was my for five pretty much yep the only other one I had on my list was I don't know why I wrote it I thought like uh do I even consider it in

that but i' not played it I I it's one that I was thinking do I play it quickly in ch time was massive Darkness 2 I have it downstairs on the Shelf of Shame and it's just a big game it's like I got to get this out and learn it and stuff but I want to play it because it sounds cool from how it is but there not not enough time so uh was not going to get it to that point but no I mean we covered quite a few big walks ones your short list was a lot bigger certainly cuz cuz I must admit when I was debating the size it got to a point where it's like well if I don't go as small as the Fantasy Flight one I'm not going to have an easy time picking 10 games period you know particularly if we'd gone with the suggestion where somebody said oh it's got to be like coffin size like Gloom Haven or something and it's like well if that's your bare minimum I won't be able to find 10 games well you know not if we cannot then choose Storage Solutions you know as a part of it yeah or even just 10 games I like at that size because because something I noticed when making this list is as much as I do have some games I like that come in giant boxes I got to admit I don't tend to stick with a lot of games that come in big boxes some of it is down to the faf you know when you get a big box it's normally going to be a lot to store get you know put out on the table but also a lot of them tend to be the big Campaign games where I don't have the time or patience to sit through four or five different 60 hour plus Campaign games you know there's just too much content in them

you know and I hate it when they do on Kickstarter you know eer Fields had a big deal with this is like we've got hundreds of hours of content in this game it's like I'm not going to play a 100 hours of content in this game you know I've yes I have 500 hours logged on Steam for Deep Rock Galactic that's over a couple of you know so many years and that's multiple sessions of anywhere from 15 minutes to 3 hours straight I mean yes fair enough I've played it a lot but that game's been out for a while you know and grounded a slight addiction but it's a lot easier to load up a video game than it is to get a board game out yeah one thing actually while we're on the subject no one's mentioned it in the comments and it got mentioned on the second act no one mentioned o swarm yeah I mean I liked it fine I like it fine I sold it again campaign too long too much faf but yeah I mean I like that one fine and it came in a massive box regardless of what addition you bought of it so uh I I you know I had to make a choice and I chose Frost Heaven as my campaign game instead of oldone that's all yeah is that 40ish 40ish hours is my cat for a campaign game I mean it's it's hard to say cuz I don't like to for game or or for total Play Time Well total play time as in for a campaign but um I me 40 hours I don't know Gloom Haven came close but the with 40 I mean

I don't like to base it on hours anyway because the the thing is cuz it's all right saying oh it's got this much hours of content but is it hours of content that you're playing the game or is it set up and take down and also how much of it is padding you know CU even tainted Grail has you know a bit of you know some grindy aspects to it so it's like oh yeah you'll be playing this for over 100 hours yeah but if 20 hours of that is grinding that's a that's 80 and B that's still an annoying part of the game if you've got the grindy aspect hence like I say even I've house ruled a couple of things in Ted gril to get rid of it but eff Fields had the same problem I the theme of it was fantastic like I loved that theme the dream thing I thought I was going to love it and then as soon as I got stuck in I I thought first couple of missions I thought good good you're on the right track liking it fiddly rule book and certainly not the most intuitive game in the world but I'll run with it it's a stick at this time and then it got onto those Slumbers and the game fell apart like I am I am playing Rena Rena roses with this stupid little map getting Keys which I have to get in a certain way and then you've got the Slumbers all in between and those punishing events and it's just like you've turned this into a grind Fest and it just fell apart you know I don't care if you've got 200 hours in ffls I'm pretty certain 150 of that is Slumbers you know I mean hell they re-released it with a mode that took away the Slumbers if that's not enough of a clue that it was not the best of designs I don't know what is you know and that was a giant patch

in itself as opposed to that oh this is a good one yeah foundations of Rome it's a fine game you know it does the job it's a Gateway level game it's it looks similar to a choir with the buildings on the grid map that you buy in plots but you know it's got simple mechanics with it I just think it's ridiculously overproduced that be understatment a game that simple and that like does not need to be a game that big it's it's kind of ridiculous um I did think of Suburbia but Suburbia is only big because of the collector's edition and I did try to actually exclude I didn't mention this at the start but I did try to exclude collector's boxes yep I so collector's boxes tend to be a bit like this to be honest you know they tend to be a storage solution as well because the collector Suburbia has I think two or three expansions in the Box as well as all the other stuff so you could maybe it'll be a big box at the end if you just took all those out but can't exactly do that than goodness any others you can think of oh Amo mag magnet I only played it once oh that magnet yeah yes few what what other the magnet did you think the oh no no no no no that doesn't fit well I know it doesn't fit any it shouldn't be on anybody's shelf but just as soon as you say the word magnate PTSD start

setting in um yeah no no no no I mean James Naylor's magnet yeah that is a big box yeah that one's there Mero funny enough this was the one I mean I suppose excluding caelli because because kapelli doesn't feel like a failed game and even then I've sold that one since Amero is probably the one fail game I remember saying I like this and kept it on my shelf for a while this was quite early in my board gaming life so at that point I hadn't played all the other Fels and gone there but um yeah something about that Cube Tower mechanic with what actions you did was just fun for me on that game so Amero is like the one fail that you could convince me to sort of actually play if it was on the table so so you are not backing the rest of the 29 games of the city collection the city collection is a stupid idea even you've got even the fans of failed have got to accept that that's a stupid I was like I I I did the first four and then I did the SEC the next two with hesitation and when I saw the component quality there and I saw the list that they are now up to 29 or 34 or something no never again yeah it's just it's just asking so much money for unne so like oh yeah look at all these metal coins and stuff like that it's a dry Euro it doesn't need these sort of components and even then the components aren't that amazing I mean the the the the metal coins are fine and all but the storage solution is to have a slot for

each individual coin it's it's like I'm sorry that is stupid I they they actually released uh this yeah box just for coins just just for coins and you want to see how efficient they are that's a that's pathetic that's pathetic sorry I I I I really cannot tilt it more but it was like I I opened it up and I was just like are you kidding me and oh no because Queen games are just I don't know they are just doing such a waste yeah I used my clay chips anyway I was going to say yeah I've got a box of those clay chips I mean that's the best thing that came out of brass was those poker chips I use them in most games I can Arc NOA and hegemony religiously use those clay chips so they're just better on them I mean yeah you comes with cup holders I mean you couldn't even use that coin box as cup holders it wouldn't fit those but those are just terrible no that's a waste of space right anyways two and a half hours is a good time to wrap that up otherwise we'll end up being one of the longest streams I've done but uh cheers for those watching now cheers for those who watch after the fact because obviously I'm sure a lot of people will tune in later when it's not December or Christmas time but now it'll be good to get these collaborations to carry on and certainly I will get them back up and running in the new year you know Essen is over so we can look at next year yeah

but that's nine months where I can sit back and go right there's not as many games being released now I can do the odd review and get back to some of the expansion stuff and I mean Jan AR and feb's got to be top 100 focused so you know that's going to take up a fair bit of time but um I said it on one podcast recently that I think people are just going to have to accept my show as seasonal so when it's ESS in time it's reviews and not much else because there's just too many games and then as soon as ESS finishes by Christmas effectively see go back to other stuff um but that's okay yep see you Johnny later on but now we'll get more of us together I'm sure hmmer is not going to say to more of these in the future preferably with an eia list preferably with an eia list yeah yeah this one this one was still fun and yes it it was still fun but it was a difficult compared to any of the others I've done but yeah we'll have to find something not there we'll have to F I mean I need to ask the patreons for topic ideas because it's about time for those so yep we'll get more of these in the future so have a good Christmas everybody if and I hope hopefully I will see you guys soon we'll do yeah we're all doing that and B beans like I say check out board well tune in to the start of the show where we were talking about what Hillmar does board spill wise all right so check out those particularly the the website and that I have I have three videos three hey we all had we all had to start somewhere including me so uh now cheers everyone in the chat cheers everybody

byebye for now Merry Christmas all Merry Christmas

Progress saved