The BEST Board Games of the Year! Top 10 of 2023.
Transcript
I received review copies for several games on this list so thanks to the Publishers and Distributors it's top 10 of the Year time and once again before we get into my favorite 10 games of 2023 I'm going to give you a quick rundown of my 10 favorite games of the previous 5 years 2018 to 2022 hopefully it will give you a feel for my tastes and preferences and set the tone for my 2023 picks so at number 10 we have 2018s welcome to I've dabbled with some the sequels and variants but it's the original we're talking about here your perfect home welcome to does everything right it has a clever drafting system tiny bit of player interaction variable scoring from game to game and a lovely setting with fabulous graphic design number nine is 2021 zombie teens Evolution this is my favorite Legacy experience so far it's a Cooperative game with a cute little emerging story about a team of teens and their dog fighting off zombies they're an incred incredible number of new rules and modes of play to discover over the series of games and it's endlessly replayable thereafter the product design is immaculate with great presentation and it's an Exemplar of diversity and inclusion to boot at number eight we have pitch out an awesome little two-player flicking game also from 2021 and a really simple and accessible head-to-head with loads of special powers a hugely underrated gem it was distressing to see huge piles of pitch out at Essence Spiel in 2023 being sold
off for5 a piece with punters Walking On by unaware of what they were missing a reminder that a fantastic game does not always equal a great commercial product number seven is 2019s undaunted Normandy I don't play many war games but this one really connected with me I love the art style from Osprey and the clever combination of deck building with tactical movement and attacks it's just perfectly realized number six was my top game of 2021 a sequel to one of my favorite games dominant species the Marine Edition has a new Twist on worker placement which totally changes the flow of the game while retaining the Cutthroat strategic totally engaging gameplay of the brilliant original number five is libertalia Winds of gaale Crest a 2022 remake of the Roll selection Pirate game by stonem Games The Buzz for the game was somewhat dampened by a lot of squabbling over the altered art style But ultimately the new addition looks fine the gam playay is better than ever with new card effects variable scoring and an improved system for breaking ties number four is the modern classic from 2018 quacks of quedlinburg this bag building push your luck game is full of variety and it's a quick little burst of fun with loads of exciting moments 2019s cartographers takes the number three spot a perfect combination of polyomino placement and flip and right gameplay to my mind this is the best of the rle and right genre with Incredible variety a touch of
interaction and the opportunity to really personalize your player sheets to create beautiful Maps number two is 2019s Isle of cats a card drafting polyomino game where you pack cats together in a ship-shaped grid it's a perfect package and one that my wife Iris and I come back to again and again and my favorite game of The Last 5 Years is still 2018s everel the super cute worker placement t building game set in a Woodland Community but we're really here to talk about 2023 so in this video I'm going to tell you about my 10 favorite games of the year I'm Adam Porter I design games and I review them on this channel usually with a heavy focus on product design so if you like what I do please share the video comment and subscribe and of course the greatest game of 2023 was the cute little trick-taking game for young children Zing aam from brain games but sadly that one's disqualified due to my own bias as the game's designer I promise you it is objectively the best game of the year but alas it doesn't make the list the usual ground rules apply to my top 10 of the Year firstly I tend towards short simple experiences so there's not many heavy High fantasy epics on here secondly I don't worry too much about release dates if the game became available to me in 2022 or 2023 because it was released at Essence Spiel or distributed in the UK for the first time or remade from an older title then it's eligible and finally and most importantly I didn't play all that many
new games in 2023 so there are inevitably many many wonderful games missing from this list this top 10 is simply 10 games which I can wholeheartedly recommend in silver and gold pyramids each player fills out two grids on Pyramid cards by Crossing out the boxes in an effort to move from the entrance to the golden tomb each turn an expedition card is revealed with a polyomino shape showing on it all players must cross off boxes in that pattern on one of their cards covering icons along the way gives players various rewards Crossing off bonus spaces scoring points for red or green gems losing points for skulls cancelling skulls with potions and trying to gather one torch per round when a pyramid card is completed you select a new one from the display and after four times through the Expedition deck players score points for completed cards with bonuses for matching colored Pairs and points from red and green gems are added to make a final score the highest scorer wins silver and gold was an unassuming little title which appeared in nsvs catalog back in 2019 from prolific designer Phil Walker Harding now Phil's approach to design closely mirrors my own accessibility is his absolute focus and he achieves it more effectively than anyone else in the business silver and Gold's Innovation was the use of dry wipe cards this was a novel Twist on roll and right or flip and right game games of the time of course later games like rolling Realms have adopted a similar approach but I still remember
silver and gold very fondly so I was delighted to hear of a sequel the pyramids Edition avoids the Trap of added complexity if anything this Edition is simpler than the earlier game fewer rules more intuitive and just as fun in savenac Forest players each form a grid of cards trying to create paths which connect Woodland creatures to their preferred food on your turn you simply select one of the cards from the table but you also gain a bonus depending on the card's location in the display if the card is taken from the first slot you'll be starting player next round if it comes from the second slot you take a water token which increases the points value of one food source for one of your animals if it comes from the third slot you'll also gain a lair token which increases the storage capacity of one of your other cards and the cards in the fourth slot are all animals to add to your display the game ends when everyone completes their 4x4 grid then each animal scores points for the various Foods in the same path the highest scorer wins the real savac Forest is located just 20 mi from wage the small Market town where I grew up and I can assure you there aren't many armadillos or beavers pottering about this one is unlikely to Garner much attention it's a really cute setting and a clever drafting system but nothing really stands out about the game it's just a solid little product it would be nice to see it nominated for an Ward or two to raise its profile I think families are likely to get a lot out of savenac forest in Beaver Creek players
take turns to roll two dice which determine which pieces they need to place on the dam and how they should place them one of the dice determines how many logs you place and how many beavers the other Dy might require you to only use your pinky fingers or to use your fingers like scissors or to use your non-dominant hand or to place the log and beaver together in a single move and if pieces collapse on your turn all of other players discard One log bringing them closer to a win but the game continues on the increasingly unsteady construction and when one player runs out of logs they're declared the winner of the game with savenac forest and now this 2023 is clearly the year of the Beaver Beaver Creek is a very familiar concept stack planks and supporting pieces while trying not to let the structure fall we've seen this in Rhino hero Tokyo Highway junk art Men at Work animal upon animal and many others the dice roll offers you some sort of constraint on how you can place the pieces but the limitations are not too challenging and again it all feels familiar the most notable feature of the game is its box size and price point Beaver Creek offers up an experience to rival those other titles with a much smaller footprint it's very cute too and always hilarious in the fox experiment players are Russian scientists breeding foxes in an effort to creating increasingly domesticated creatures over successive Generations the real life experiment took place in the 1950s and increases
our understanding of melian genetics each round starts with players taking three actions selecting a female fox a male Fox and some supplies which also determines turn order for the next round your chosen foxes each have potential traits represented by colored dice during the breeding phase players all roll their Dice and line them up to create traits which they mark off on blank cards to create pups green Dice and tokens are wild you then score your pups for friendliness based on the number of traits that they have and optionally you can name your pup although this has no impact on gameplay players now compare their pups to study cards in front of them and these have certain objectives that you need to achieve essentially creating pups with specific traits Waggy Tails floppy ears spotty fur and barking like a pet dog completed objectives earn points at the end of the game and they each feature three levels so you can score the same objective several times but it becomes more challenging and rewarding each time each pup that you created generates trait tokens and these are used to upgrade your player board giving you special abilities and allowing you to break the rules in various ways all new pups created in around are then placed into the central display for players to select from as parents in the next round and players gain awards for adding the friendliest Fox to the genan pool after five rounds points are added up at the highest scorer wins now I found this game fascinating perhaps more
fascinating than fun but I do like games which Buck the trend and carve their own path designer of wingspan Elizabeth Hargrave has partnered with co-designer Jeff Fraser to bring us this exploration of an apparently famous Russian experiment which I previously knew nothing about and that I think is where the Game's real value lies I was intrigued by the premise played the game and immediately started reading articles about the real experiment the online response to the subject matter has been mixed perhaps inevitably some find it distasteful and feel it shouldn't have been made but I found it thought-provoking and informative highlighting a moment in history that I was totally unaware of and simulating the process cleverly with all the abstractions that the board game medium inevitably brings the mix of dice drafting set collection and contracts makes for a pretty solid little game though they requirement for a third automated opponent in the two-player game was disappointing Davos is a light to medium complexity economic game for one to five players from firsttime board game designer Jason lent players attempt to earn the most favor the currency of the game on your turn you place a tile often strengthening one of the factions indicated on the board by these little plastic markers no one owns these factions but on your turn you can use favor to purchase cards corresponding to each of them alternatively you can return return a card to the supply gaining favor according to the current position of the faction marker on the track and using the faction's power there are all manner of chaotic effects
on offer here so move a tile to a new position reveal cards from another player's hand and claim Rewards or Draw and place an extra tile connecting a territory to a purple Rift tile Awards a player with a single use ability that they can utilize on a later turn placing a tile such that two territories are joined up brings about a conflict and all players simultaneously reveal cards from their hands to bolster their chosen faction strengths and the losing faction is kicked off the board reducing the value of all corresponding cards in players hands cards used in the conflict earn the players spoils additional favor tokens equal to their current position on the track so the various territories expand across the map as the game progresses with players aiming to purchase cards when they're cheap and discard them for their effects when they're at the height of their power at the end of the game all cards remaining in hand are awarded favor equal to the corresponding faction strength and the player with the most favor wins there are 10 factions in the Box each with a different power and only five are used in each game giving a good amount of variety between sessions so on paper D ofos is right up my street a fairly light stock market game I love harbon gut or the rich and the good as it's known now Black Friday Airlines Europe and Arcadia Tha playing with conflicts inspired by tigress and Euphrates that's one of my favorite games and a Fantastical theme would have led me normally to ignore this game dismissing it as just another tolken esque battler
were it not for the publisher bringing the game to my attention it's a very unusual game and I love it for that even if I struggle to identify an obvious audience for it dawn of ulos Clips along at a fair Pace turns a short and full of drama this is not a game which you're going to play to show off your economic Wilds it's a game to play for the experience the interaction laughing at your Misfortune and that of your opponents at the start of a round of my little idel players rolled ice to generate available resources every player then activates all the green production cards in front of them and then everyone takes turns to place a worker on one of the few locations on the board to perform the associated action or on an action space from a red card which is already in your display after placing a worker you may select a card from below the board and add it to your display but you must have the resources to pay for it blue cards give lasting effects Brown cards activate once when you play them and purple cards provide endgame scoring objectives the point scoring parade tiles are collected as soon as a player achieves the listed requirements and they decrease in value as players collect them so you want to get there first after four rounds the game ends and the highest scorer wins I probably should have anticipated that this game would exist at some point the original idel is too cute not to receive a junior addition to capitalize on the kid-friendly Aesthetics my L idel sits in the same category as my little scythe and a griol family Edition a junior
Edition which is still too complicated for kids to play unless their parents are also at the table but my intention for the game was not to play with kids what I really was looking for was idel Express something simple to set up and play without all the faf even more essential since I invested in the big box collection which is so intimidating in its scale it makes it hard to get it to the table my little idel delivers the express experience that I was looking for even for a group of adults the gamepl is engaging and rewarding though in my view a few minor house rules are needed to deepen The Experience just a touch I predicted sequels to everel other games set in the same universe and we've had two in the last year this one and farshaw which I haven't played yet I'm surprised by how closely Starling G games has stuck to the worker placement formula I was expecting them to Branch off into other genres while retaining the setting this series definitely still has more to offer in a round of medieval Academy players each have a hand of five cards you select one to keep and pass the rest to your neighbor then repeat until each player has drafted a hand of five cards you then take turns playing cards from your hand until each player has played four times and the fifth card is discarded each time you play a card you move your token up one of the seven tracks which all have their own benefits mostly revolving around scoring points the Orange Kitchen track is the exception at the end of a round before scoring the other tracks the player furthest ahead in the kitchen track
advances three spaces on any other track the second highest player advances two spaces and the third highest advances one when you play a yellow card you can advance on the jous track or on the tournament track your choice and both award variable points depending on your position on the the track relative to other players at the end of each round the purple studies track dishes out negative points if you haven't kept up with the other players at the end of each round and the green King track is only scored in rounds three and six you simply have to reach one of the Milestones to gain six or 12 points but the track resets after round three so there's a bit of time pressure to get moving and the blue Town track is only scored at the end of the game again dishing out negative points to those who have progressed them relas scores are recorded on cardboard dials and after six rounds the highest scorer wins the reverse of the board has a different layout with slightly more complex scoring for the various tracks for advanced players now I purchased the original medieval Academy back in 2014 at a time when there weren't all that many pick and pass drafting games seven wonders was a huge hit at the time and fairy tale A minor hit before that but the mechanism hadn't been fully exploited Sushi go and medieval Academy arrived on the market a few months apart both offering up a massively simplified interpretation of the mechanism medieval Academy bungled The Landing somewhat the core gameplay was arguably simpler than
Sushi go play cards to climb tracks with various scoring objectives but the first edition came with a multitude of different game modes and variable board configurations it had great replayability but the rule book and components were intimidating of course Sushi go garnered massive praise and attention becoming a bestselling Evergreen title and medieval Academy was forgotten so I was delighted to see it return in 2023 this was my most anticipated release at Essen Spiel and this time they've done everything right the rules are super simple and clear the artwork was always of a high standard but this Fresh coat of paint is much more modern and appealing and crucially we're limited to two modes of play Simple and Advanced revisiting the game I was reminded just how slight the rule set is reading the rules the game sounds terribly mechanical and procedural but it comes alive when you play it's Cutthroat tight and very interactive it will be much easier to get this new addition to the table especially because it has a very simple and engaging new two-player mode which works really well gigamon is a card flipping memory game for families on your turn you flip two tiles face up and if they're different you flip them back face down and if they're the same you take the tiles and put them in front of you then use the tiles power the effects are a mix of take that and more positive abilities so when you match two floramon you can collect a tile from the stack when you match to pyrons you can destroy another
player's tile when you match to hydrons everybody else at the table closes their eyes and you can Peak at four of the face down tiles in play and when you match two aramon you can swap one of your tiles with with one belonging to another player when you have three identical tiles you gain the corresponding gigamon when the draw pile is empty the player with the most gigamon wins the game you also win instantly if you ever have three gigamon this is an example of me playing fast and loose with release dates gigamon was released first in 2014 by blue orange but I'm allowing it on the list for three reasons firstly it was nominated for the Kinder spielers yarz in 2023 was presumably because it only recently had a German release and secondly it only came to my attention late in 2022 and thirdly it was one of my most played games of the year gigamon is the best little memory game that I've played I know memory mechanisms are an anathema for most strategic Gamers but I really enjoy them particularly when playing with kids and the added level here of the chaotic tile abilities is right up my street I love the immediate feedback of picking a tile and generating a power or reward stealing a tile from another player or peeking at the face down tiles while my opponents Look Away the game is fast funny and gorgeous to look at I highly recommend gigamon for young families but frankly I get a kick out of it with any group in animals of Baker Street a group of players take control of a group of animals a curious Mouse
who's great at finding stuff a swift agile blue tit a persuasive Charming frog and a slightly Psychopathic tarantula who reportedly arrived in Baker Street in a crate of bananas the group selects their mission though generally these are played through in order then reads the introductory passage from the case book there are no real turns in the game the group simply decides which location to visit and reads the corresponding card they can then choose to utilize characters items and information in that location by combining cards and looking to see how the icons line up to determine whether new information is revealed however players need to take care because unsuccessful actions frequently cost the group time there's only so many clock tokens to discard before the mission ends in Failure animals of Baker Street provided some of the most calm relaxed and Charming gaming moments of the last year I played through the scenarios with my wife Iris and there was enough content to keep us involved for a good period of time the writing really hooked me with characters that leap off the page they're distinct and quirky and very funny this is one of very few games that I've played which genuinely made me laugh out loud and not once but frequently the tarantula's dark view of the world in particular is always entertaining but the other player characters are equally endearing and there are a host of non-player characters with their own memorable personalities too the mechanisms in the game are very slight there's really not much to it but the systems that we do
have are very clever and intuitive in Disney Lana players construct their own personal decks before the game begins using cards they've purchased in randomized booster packs deck construction is extremely simple you must have at least 60 cards and it can only contain two of the six colors from the game on your turn you draw a card then take as many actions as you can afford you can add one card from your hand to your ink well and ink is like energy which you will use to play other cards you play cards by exerting cards in your Inkwell equal to the cost of the card and sometimes the inell is also used to activate abilities on cards that you've already played characters can be placed in front of you but not used on the same turn and in future turns they can be exerted either to gain LW points or to attack an opponent's character when they've taken enough damage they're removed from play and when one player has 20 LW points they instantly win the game of course cards have a wide variety of special abilities which break the rules in all sorts of creative ways now Disney Lana had the traditional bumpy introduction to the world I'm a total novice when it comes to collectible card games but it seems to me that they always hit massive problems with distribution ramping up the demand for the game while also stoking frustration loana also had a very high-profile lawsuit to contend with as Publishers locked horns over whether this was an original design or a stolen one I was informed enough to act quickly and snap
up a decent little collection of cards in the brief window that they were available and started exploring the game with Iris Iris enjoys playing games but prefers to stick to a small number of her favorite titles she's not a fan of learning new rules and I've never known her to purchase a game for her own enjoyment so introducing her to a ccg was a big ask I knew the Disney theme would be a draw for her there are six different colors or suits of cards in the game and each player forms a deck by combining two of the colors so Iris and I took ownership of three colors each giving us options for varying Our Deck construction between games so this made opening boost booster packs exciting as we divided the cards between us as they were revealed Iris was very immersed and entertained by the card collecting aspect of the game but initially less so by the game play the thing is Lana is mean it is a game of direct attacks you win by destroying your opponent and this is completely contrary to iris's Preferred mode of Play It took several games before Iris was happy to accept that her favorite Disney characters were going to be destroyed by attacks sometimes just moments off she'd place them on the table nonetheless she's stuck with it and once we got into the groove we found the game to be strategic fast playing with simple rules and some nice opportunities to pull off combos it's really satisfying when a plan comes together and I guess that's what pregame deck construction is all about so as much as I've enjoyed Lana for me it
hasn't yet reached the heights of Star Wars Destiny my one other significant dip into the world of collectible card games I think that's because Destiny had more of a sense of narrative though loose with characters sticking around for longer and a more coherent logic to the game assigning items to characters and facing off in a straightup battle of good versus evil and I do have a lingering feeling that I might have been better off investing in Disney villainous expansions a game which provides much of the fun of head-to-head battle without the in yourface conflict of a ccg and a more predictable distribution model but despite my reservations la was a very enjoyable game that we returned to frequently in the second half of 2023 and I'm Keen to explore future sets for now I'm hooked now I made a similar observation last year but 2023 did not present me with all that many exciting new gaming experiences there were some lovely games released but I do wonder if we're still seeing the after effects of the covid-19 lockdowns game publication generally takes a few years from pitching to release so many of these title will have been signed by the Publishers shortly before the pandemic and then delayed or during 2020 or 2021 when everyone was being very cautious Treading Water trying to keep their businesses afloat nonetheless if you're looking for something new to try you couldn't go wrong with any of the titles described in this list so thank you as always for supporting the channel throughout the year I'd love to hear your thoughts on
my picks and your own favorite games of 2023 in the comments until next time all the best