The games I got rid of in 2023
Transcript
this video is brought to you by the 3-minute board game patrons keep us Independent by supporting us on patreon Kyoto and welcome to this year's the games I got rid of video now these videos are a little bit different to what I normally do normally I'm quite evenhanded with my reviews or at least I try to be the games I got rid of can get a little spicy at times especially when a game has wronged me somehow and I'm just going to blast through these games very very quickly and the reason for that is I've reviewed most of these games before if you want to see more detailed information on each game I got rid of there's probably a review available on the channel and for the ones that there are I'll try to put a link in the description to each of those games and for the games that there aren't reviews of I'll just link to the BGG page for each game but yes the main reason for these videos is a bit of a cathartic exercise on my part it's to go these games left my collection and I'm fine with that and in some cases I'm I'm really happy that they've left the collection because the thing is there are games coming in just about every week and I need to get rid of a bunch of games I believe this is every game I got rid of this year but I'm not 100% certain it's certainly the vast majority of them and we have games coming in and going out all the time just because of the nature of working on a channel like this now I try to view one to two games a week so logically there's about 80 games come in every year and game's going out this year I think is in the 40s so there might be some that I've missed but I definitely mark down the
big important and interesting titles I do have a nice pile of about 20 games down there that I'm looking to get rid of in the new year as well but I haven't selected those cuz they still haven't left the house anyway this is the list of games that I got rid of this year the first game up is Frost Haven now this is a game I did not get rid of because I had played it to death far from it my old group got quite a way through Gloom Haven I think we did around 40 scenarios before eventually tiring of the game and that was mostly due to the fatigue of organizing a group to get together to play it I've played it a lot more since once the PC game came out because I felt like I could enjoy Gloom Haven without having to organize a whole bunch of people to play it with me and yeah I could have kept playing it solo but it's so much set up and that's something the PC game saved me from doing and frost Haven it is Gloom Haven on steroids it is heavy Gloom Haven the chances of one of my regular groups wanting to play it all the way through was around about zero and for the review I played it solo two-handed and that was really just to see if they'd fundamentally changed the basics of the game which they hadn't I mean they tidied up some things but it was an iterative improvement not a dramatic Leap Forward and the thing with frost Haven is I'll probably really enjoy it as a PC game as well because there won't be the setup time they won't be trying to get a group together it's just it's such a big commitment of the game and when you're a reviewer like me and you're trying to cover off one or two new games a week and then do the video content around them committing to a game game it's going to take you know 40 plus sessions uh to get through it's
a serious commitment and it's a serious commitment from my players as well so yeah Frost Haven gotten rid of just because I know I'm not going to play it through the second game on the list is almost as big as Frost Haven and that's youthia torment of Resurrection youthia torment of Resurrection is kind of like an old PC game called Heroes of Might and Magic and even if you aren't familiar with that game you'll be familiar with it tropes each player plays a hero from a unique class with unique power-ups and you travel around the board going to different points of interest completing Quest battling monsters and generally getting powerups in order to face an end game scenario this is just another big game and I'm talking about play time I'm talking about setup time and I'm talking about shelf space it's a fun enough game but it didn't capture me enough that I want to go through the rig morall of setting it up and playing it that many times uh the groups of mine that played it they enjoyed it enough and found it to be a reasonably good game but again the same thing came back it's giant it's a huge mess it's an experience more than a game ultimately youth is just not the kind of game that I'm interested in playing right now and I'm really just not vibing on the whole fantasy leveling up battling monsters thing anymore next up is wild space a game that has a really tight action selection system so you've only got uh five ships and each of those ships gets to take two actions so a total of 10 actions per game which sounds like the thing I'd be really into a very tight action selection game we trying to collect sets
and maximize points sounds really good to me the problem is it was a bit of an arbitrary game like a lot of these drafting games you could only see a certain number of cards at any time in this case there were only three cards available and If You're were fishing for certain Combos and they just didn't come up well too bad and I found that ultimately after a couple of plays a little bit arbitrary if you got on a roll with what popped up and it went your way and you got got the sets you just wanted to be after well congrats you win a big game but if they didn't come up or if someone else was also accidentally going for the same thing as you well you're screwed and that made for a kind of flat experience and that's why wild space got jettison into space over the last few years Games Workshop have sent me a bunch of truly average games and the Battle of balance's tomb was another one of them this board game Zooms in on the fight scene on The Fellowship of the Ring where they fight the cave troll inside Balin to that's it that's the game it's a two-play game where you the fellowship versus the Orcs And honestly the should have been a solo game because the orc players experience is absolutely rubbish uh the fellowship player feels like they've got some decisions to make but the orc players just biffing models at people and rolling Dice and if they get lucky they win this is a nothing burger game uh it's probably only worth buying if you want some reasonable quality Fellowship models and it might be worthwhile if you're an absolute Lord of the Rings Fanboy this year I said goodbye to my
ancient copy of settlers of Katan not Katan of course that's the game I reviewed recently I'm talking about its older iteration the settlers of Katan now this feels like a little bit of a cheat because I still own katam but it's also a bit of a milestone because settlers was the first Euro game I got and that copy I think was 22 years old when I sold it as I picked it up in 2001 and the only only reason I got the new one is I thought it would be a little weird doing the review of kitan uh with a version that's that old but it brings up a wonderful part of board gaming my copy of sat lless of Katan was over 20 years old someone out there is still enjoying my 20 plus year old copy of the game and that's a wonderful thing about board games if you look after them and I looked after my copy of settlers it's still absolutely playable 20 years later and it wasn't even sleeved and it got about 100 plays all righty we're going to do a double headit an hour because the next two games are legendary Marvel and legendary James Bond and I got rid of them for exactly the same reason that reason is I don't really like the legendary games that much well I don't like the legendary games proper that much I like legendary encounters uh I think the legendary encounters games are much better and a much better fit for me and I have currently on my shelf legendary encounters aliens and legendary counters The Matrix I've kept those two I didn't need four legendary games uh on my shelf
at any given time so Marvel and James Bond they're perfectly fine for their IPs they're perfectly fine examples of legendary as a system but as I say I prefer legendary encounters and I prefer the IPS of um The Matrix and Aliens as well well I do like James Bond but I did count against it that it was legendary not legendary encounters anyway pass those on because I'm pretty pretty damn sure I don't need four iterations of the same game in fact I'm probably going to get rid of the Matrix some point next year once I've played it through a few more times because I don't think I need two versions of basically the same
game the next game up is umbrea a game I can't really say much about I received a review copy of this years ago and it was back when I was doing more polls on what games to cover on the channel next and it just kept it kept coming dead last every time it was involved in a poll uh basically no one voted for it so it was a game that just kept getting pushed back and back and back and back in the schedule until basically it fell off the end uh there was no interest in the game there was no one clamoring at me going hey Jared where's that umia review uh it seems to be a game it came out made very little impact and it's just sort of gone away again um so someone else is enjoying that copy it's a game I honestly didn't really look at that much and sometimes that happens like I try to review every game I get sent but there's the odd one that comes in and it just sits there and I I glance over it and I keep glancing over it and then eventually it goes away and I try not to take too many games more than I plan to review I I do review ultimately about 95% of games that I'm sent um but yeah sometimes a game just doesn't fit or it doesn't click or no one wants to play and that was the case of umia got a couple of disappointing titles coming up and the first of those is North guard I expected a lot more from North guard I'd read good things about it online and it looked like it was a very slickly produced game and it was going to be a sort of fast-paced fun
experience but one of the big issues here is that I got a retail version of a game that had a bunch of Kickstarter content in it and from what I gather a lot of the fun parts of the game and a lot of the actual depth of the game were Kickstarter exclusives uh some of the clan powers and a few other bits and pieces that make the game a little bit more interesting and dynamic uh they just weren't in the retail version so we played a couple of games and it was flat experience it just it was nothing inspiring nothing interesting um there was some fundamentally cool ideas about how to you know create regions and territories in this game I think it was the second game uh where I just got a whole bunch of extra action powers and the way the game structured if you have the last action and you've got extra action cards you can just keep going so it's a case of action chicken the last person to act if they've got multiple actions up their sleeve can just go attack attack attack score win and it was really every game we play was decided by the person who hoarded the most actions and that's that's bollocks to me that makes for a a really rubbish game with this one clear path that you're like okay going last and in going three more times where people can't react that is how you win the game of North guard or at least the version of the game I played and yeah that that doesn't interest me and I was pretty glad in the end to be rid of it no one else in my
group wanted to Play It Again the second disappointing game in this grouping is Hamlet another Kickstarter game but this time I got given the kickstarter version and maybe maybe I shouldn't have because this game is so busy there's so much happening on the board there's so many little bits of things you have to move around it's just comes from you have to play it with a bloody magnifying glass I wanted to like this game cuz I like the core premise of it I like the idea of it but physically it was like no one had played a physical copy of this before they publish the game like it was tested entirely online and then they pred out the boards and they PR about 60% of the size they should have been and put all these tiny tiny scratchy little pieces on the board and they said you know go play with them and I look these sausage hands of mine and these tiny little pieces it was really frustrating play experience uh we got through a couple of games of this before I was like I never want to see this damn thing again it also had this like busted ass uh church building in the middle that refused to stick together and again I think this is one of those games where the designer and Publisher's ambition to make a flashy product got in the way of making a functional board game because there's some good ideas in Hamlet as far as gameplay and mechanics go but actually playing it is a absolute chore the next game is one I actually
kind of regret now and that's the original agents of Smur you see I signed up for the everything epic version of uh agents of Smur the new revised version and I got rid of my old version because the new hot version was coming along and it was going to be you know hotter and better and it just isn't it's it's just they fixed some things in the game but then they absolutely totally and utterly screwed the end of the game for me um you see there was a module I didn't own for the original called epic showdowns and what that did was Chang the end game from the sort of set collection thing set collection push your luck kind of thing we trying to get evidence and if you get the right amount of evidence um you you solve the case into this like big story finale and they went and changed it so every time you play you playing epic showdown mode and these epic showdowns are big and I mean big chunks of reading like 20 pages of reading materials for each one and playing it with a group it's a lot of reading aloud like you you're passing the bookr and reading passages and going through uh doing these showdowns and they take an age and there there's like two paths through them basically and um so yeah if you force yourself to you can play the game 10 times and see all those showdowns and then you you've kind of done them you're just going going through them again and that's not what I
played agents of Smur for I played agents of smch because it's a silly spy Austin poers James Bond r events generator if you're familiar with tales of the Arabian Knights it is very similar game to that where wacky stuff happens wacky spy stuff you play it for the wacky spy stuff and it used to be that you'd play two hours of wacky spy stuff and then you might or you might not win big deal in the new version you play like an hour's wacky spy stuff and then read an hour's fiction and it just it screwed the game balance for me they are planning an expansion where they are planning on fixing this and I and giving it alternative way of playing the game and that might resurrect it for me uh but yeah I am now kind of regreting getting rid of my original agents's smch and keeping the new version and if the new expansion doesn't fix um I'm probably going to get rid of my new version and try and track down an old copy silly me next up I have four different Games push that's not hat pinata blast and Disney villains not to be confused with Disney villainous I'm not sure what to say about these these were four kids games that were sent to me by Ravensburger along with a bunch of other games they were not asked for I did not request review copies they just sent them to me and they're not really the sort of games I cover on the channel so I didn't really know what to do with them they kind of sat on the shelf for a
good year uh then I live right by a park uh so just over over there there is a park and inside that Park are two Community halls and one of those Community Halls is an after school group so I just gave the people running that group those four games because I popped in there for an unrelated thing and saw that the kids were playing a bunch of board games and I was just like hey I've got some board games I'm not using uh do you want them and just here you go have these four games so I honestly can't say much about them aside from their kid-friendly games but my we girl she's only two uh she's not going to be able to play these for a good six years and none of my other groups were particularly interested in playing them so while I didn't end up reviewing them at least they went on to a reasonable place next we have eternal Palace from alicat games uh alicat games are one of those funny companies that I get a lot of games from them and I play a lot of their games and I like just about all their games but none of them have ever really got their hooks into me as games I absolutely adore and that is again the story with eternal Palace it's a solid enough game uh it's got some dice placement stuff it's quite clever in it uh it's a set collection things it's got some nice props and stuff in it it's a cute game it's perfectly acceptable it's just a little it's okay I have no malice against Eternal Palace or against alicat games it's just they they seem to be keep pitching these games just at that level where I'm like oh that's a good game and then I kind of forget about it
once I played it a couple of times I am really holding out hope that they say me a Bonafide hit that goes straight to my heart one of these days because they have been a really Pleasant company to get games from and they're always happy to see my reviews uh even when I'm less than flattering about their games regusa is next and regusa is a very solid Euro game it was just one of those games that was just below the sort of cut off point for me to want to keep it um it's one of those games again I'd be super happy to play this at someone else's house they brought it out and be like Yay cool yeah I'm happy to play regusa I don't think I want to teach it again and there is some part of especially in the sort of mid game we have all these chaining actions that are right annoyance to keep track of um so yeah it's a good enough game I'm not sure it's a great game uh and it certainly just I knew it was one of those games that no one in my group is going to go oh yeah let's play that rusa game again it just it didn't really connect with anyone people were like yeah that's that's fine I like that that was okay um but there wasn't really clamor to play it again so again getting back to that idea of a perfectly good game but good isn't good enough to keep anymore so in case you don't know I am actually friends with Sam McDonald and shim Phillips from Garfield games and uh I review a lot of their games because they are friends um Sam lives over the hill for me and Sham lives up the coast a little uh we're about 15 to 30 minutes
drive away from each other and um so it's we've great pains that I say I got rid of my copy of VI counts of the West Kingdom because Vic counts is a game I do not get it is a game that has never clicked with me I love architects of the West Kingdom and I really love paladins of the West Kingdom those are two games I really really dig and I kept VI counts as the third part of that trilogy hoping someday that that game would click with me and it doesn't there's just something fundamentally in that game that my brain goes nope I want no part of this I don't know whether it's the um moving around the board with the man man manala movement or whether it's building the things that go into the deck or whether it's the messy thing happening in the middle of the table the game is like oil oil and water with my brain it VI counts come in it goes out I have come last in every single game of Vic counts of the West Kingdom I have ever played and not not by a small amount I have come last by a mile there are very few games that I am that rubbish atat and VI counts is one of them so I finally got rid of it because it just doesn't work for me it's just not a game that clicks with me and that's fine people going to enjoy V VI counts as much as they want just don't play it near me and speaking of New Zealand companies there's gale force 99 and galeforce 9 had sent me a bunch of games over the years and one of them was Tusk and tusk was
unplayable this isn't a game where it didn't click with me this is a game that wasn't play tested or wasn't developed or something this seems to be a unworked prototype that's been put in a box because it is broken out of the box you go to the board game geek page and you look up what people say about this game just about every comment is this game doesn't work it's busted it's broken and I opened my copy up I had to look at it read the rules set it up and was like this is this is mted this game does not function and it's very rare to see a product hit the market that just doesn't really work does not work as a game uh I have no idea how this came into being it's really stunning from Gale force9 because they have made some really good games over the years T of the underd dark Spartacus Star Trek ascendency for starters those are they've done the June reprints and all the June stuff as well really good games games I've loved and in Tusk is this giant steaming turd I think it's rated like a 3.3 average on Board Game Geek I don't know Board Game Geek is not the be on end all of everything but it's very rare that you see a game with that low rating um yeah utter rubbish I think I gave this one uh to someone as a freebie when they purchase another game and in apologized for doing so and speaking of G Force 9 the next game up is Doctor Who Nemesis which
isn't actually that bad a game it's a very similar idea to Disney villainous if you're familiar with that game you are playing the baddies in the Doctor Who Universe um this one works a lot better than Tusk it's a functional game I think the problem is that playing the baddies and Doctor Who is not necessarily something anyone wanted and I found that the game really hinged on who was best at tracking the board state so there's a whole bunch of random effects out on the board and if you can keep track of what's going where and do a bunch of card counting and and figure out what popping up where you can you can win you need a lot of knowledge of the game to do that though so it's it's one of those games where if you know the game inside and out it's really easy to to trunch all over the people but it's not fun in that regard because you're really just trying to do the same thing you're trying to get a specific goal in a certain sequence each time you play one of the baddies and that just feels a bit rot so it feels like a lot of root learning game for what was supposed to be a very interactive game and that to me is a bit of a hollow experience I loved the look of Starship captains I was really Keen to get a copy of this uh in fact this is one of those games that uh I actually was very cheeky on Board Game Geek the publisher had said we've sent out copies to a whole lot of respected reviewers and then I posted this GIF um below that uh indicating that you yes you have but you haven't sent one to me and they ended up sending one to me and cuz I was really Keen to get this cuz it just looked
exactly like my jam uh if you know I love the captain is dead and this has a lot in common with that by look and feel uh but the problem I found with it is it's just this weird SPAC game where it's halfway between being a familyfriendly game and being a complex Euro and it's jammed in there but not in the good way like there are some games that you know have that simple to learn uh hard to master thing whereas I just think Starship captains was a reasonably shallow game that was just a bit hard to grock and that uh all that really got under my skin in the end and that's kind of why the game sort of fell a bit flat for me cuz I was expecting a little bit more I'd hyp myself up too much perhaps and I got this game and it's pretty okay move around do some things the uh staff function thing that the top uh where you're putting down different colored officers to do stuff ended up being a lot less interesting in mechanic than I thought it was going to be I thought was going to be something really neat that was basically just um a way of cycling out people where you know you didn't get to pick a couple at the last two you didn't get back that next turn I was like oh okay I thought there was going to be way more Shenanigans around that and there just wasn't and it was also one of those games that supposed to have a sort of funny or humorous element but it was basically just this very lowlevel reference gags like h i remember that uh that that's a thing from the TV show oh they're making a comment about about
that episode that time and that to me is not really comedy that's that's just a reference um so I didn't find it particularly funny the game play was pretty ordinary and again it was just too complex to be a familyfriendly game and not rewarding enough to really hook me so ultimately I found Starship captains a bit of a failure and got rid of it now it's elette game second game they sent me this year autoban and autoban is actually a very good game uh I enjoyed playing autoban quite a lot there's a lot of things in Auto I thought was super clever and I I just genuinely it is a game I really liked playing the problem is I hated teaching it and I hated managing it because every time you put down a road you have to change like these values and that did my hidden when I was playing it because I was always the one cuz it's my table of okay you've upgraded that road you you Chang that value that value that value that value and all through the game you're making these little fiddly changes and it's that sort of mental burden when you you're the one running the game or it's your table where you've got to do like the little a little bit of calculations and stuff and that's what got me is I think I would like this uh as an app I think I would like to play it on tabletop simulator or somewhere where those calculations were
done uh for me or I would play it at someone else's house and they can damn well do it um because I just found that a little draining so it was a very good game a a enjoyable game to play but an awful game to teach for some reason it just probably needed to be def fided a little somehow um so yeah if you do like fiddly games um and you do like games where and that sort of mental load doesn't bother you um when you're playing you'll probably have a very good time with autoban uh but for me it was just just a little just a little niggles in the game and that was enough um next up is stroganov uh game I got played once and then got rid of and that's for the very simple reason that it's a game about Russian expansionism and when I got the game Russia wasn't at war with Ukraine and now they are and it just seemed like uh not going to review this uh anytime soon because it's a little on the nose to do a game about Russia expanding uh when they're trying to expand into another country right now and I just thought yeah I I'll just pass this one on there's there's no need to cover this one on the channel right
now Intrepid was a game that I was a backer for I backed this one a Kickstarter this is not a review copy that I got I got the fancy special version on Kickstarter and I was really excited for it because it seemed like this Cooperative uh game whole bunch of dice manipulation that sounded like a lot of fun to me I'm a big fan of Ro for the Galaxy and I'm a big fan of Cooperative board games and yeah and treer just it just didn't do it for me at all uh it was like everyone getting together to do their math homework uh we get together everyone had their own little puzzles on their board they'd do their own damn thing uh we'd have a couple of talks about if someone needed an extra point or two here or there or if they wanted to upgrade something but for the most part you are sitting down doing your little dice formulas on your own sheet and you don't give a crap what's happening out there and this is what I kind of think of as the Rolland ride effect or the tabletop simulator effect where there are a bunch of games that have come out the last few years where each player has their own little sphere and they're sort of just locked in a bubble like this and that they don't really care what else else is happening out there and that's fine for a lot of people a lot of people love that game experience because they get you know their own little secure space where they can play with their bits and pieces and no one takes anything from them and they get a sense of accomplishment uh but for me it it just feels dry and dull and if I wanted to stare at my phone uh in a room of
other friends staring at their phones I'd probably just do that uh rather than sit down and play a board game which basically replicates that experience um so entrep very disappointing game for me um I wanted this to be a lot more than it was very lit down by how uninteractive it felt and how much of the game was really you just in your own head doing your own math it's very similar experience I had to with Merchants Cove um but at least Merchants Cove felt like it was being really ambitious even though ultimately I felt those self-contained games uh took away from the overall experience at least it was a cool idea andreid it's just it's just doing yaty things by yourself and then you go I got 10 and then everyone else reports what they got and that's the game I didn't really want to get rid of treron tryon's a neat game I enjoy playing treron but it has some of the things I talked about when I talked about autoban but even more so because traron is incred L complex it is a ginormous pain in the butt to teach as well it is just an utterly nightmarish game to try to tell people how to play uh it is something I never want to do again is teach people how to play treron uh so it's one of those games that I would if I went to someone's house and they had a copy there I'd be like yes let us play this game you know the rules
don't you and if they say yes I know the rules quite well I'll be like absolutely glad to play if there's new players I I don't think I'd want to um I don't think I'd want to spend that time with a game like Tryon and new players again uh it's it's one of those games that you get a lot out of it the more you play it but it's very rare that you get the opportunity to play it so sadly I got rid of it because I I needed to get rid of space I wasn't playing it I didn't want to teach anyone to play it and I already had an acony which is from the same company and I I much prefer that one um treron very good game but just it's a chore to teach and when you're teaching around 100 games a year like I am you you get over it uh flourish is a very weird case study it is a game that was on Kickstarter and it was sent to me um just after Kickstarter finished so I got a copy of it I looked up and the kickstarter closed like two days earlier and I was like what do you want me to do with this cuz there's no point reviewing this um now cuz the campaign's closed um I only just got it afterwards and they're like oh don't worry about it I was like okay I I might review it when the game comes out and then the game came out and no one really cared about it it didn't do particularly well there's another game a bit like um that just came out didn't really cause a splash so yeah it just sat up on the Shelf collecting dust uh no one had any
interest in playing it no one asked to play it for a number of years it's one of those games that people just lost over So eventually I just let it go subatomic is a neat little basic deck building game and that's about the gist of it like it's one of those games from genius games that uh is a science themed game the science here is pretty basic it's building molecules and you do that using deck building components it's it's fine but the game play is very average it's very run-of-the-mill deck builder by numbers and I've got Dominion I've got Arctic scavengers I've got other deck building games so so this is just a case of do I need another deck builder no I don't next up is another gale force 9 game it's Pirates of Sky do and this one fail to me for one big reason and that big reason is the D20 now d20s work in role playing games because dungeon Masters and game Masters can do things to change your odds they can give you Advantage where you get multiple dice you can do dramatic stunts you can do things where you don't need to roll dice in a board game a D20 is just too big a variable the difference between having a plus one on a character and a plus three on a character is bugger all it's just too swingy of value and that ruined this game for me I think there was a good idea for a game here I think there's some cool sort of Concepts about sneaking around the ship and trying to gain Fame and Fortune but everything hinged on D20 rolls and I just life is
too short to play board games based on D20 roles next up is Dream Home a game I was reasonably high on many years ago because it was so simple it was such a simple inoffensive game you can sit down and play around with practically anyone you can play it with your grandmother the problem is it's ultimately too simple it's a game that there really isn't much in the way of decisions to be made like there's some drafting going on but there's almost always the best course of action so while I can use this game to introduce board gaming to people who haven't played many games before ultimately I am not having fun doing it that way uh so I like the game a lot more five or six years ago um where I think I thought less of non- Gamers which is a a strange thing to say so I was high on dream home because I thought non- Gamers were a bit dumber than I do now uh which hopefully means I've grown as a person next up we have two utterly forgettable games work shop games Crypt hunters and combat Arena Ena these games are junk almost IR redeemable junk I did a video a while back on a lot of the board games that gameswork shop had sent me and I'm not sure what else to say these are excuses to get a couple of models in front of people at Target or somewhere like that the games themselves are pretty much rubbish there's very little reason to pick up the games and play them as games there are way to get Games Workshop figures in front of
people so they go ooh this might be fun to paint I wish Games Workshop would put more effort into actually designing these games so that they're they're a bit more fun and a bit more uh playable um cuz they're certainly presentable like they're reasonably good-looking games for what they are and the models that come with them are gorgeous but games for the most part are rubbish next we have Brazil Imperial the board game box most frequently mistaken for our Channel mascot Brazil Imperial was a very busy game a very ambitious game and a little bit of a messy game I was very interested to see what a game about Brazil designed by Brazilians would be like and it's fascinating that that opened up a complete can of worbs because there are two very distinct camps it seems around this game one who seemed to think it's an amazing homage to Brazil's Heritage the others who say it's Colonial apologist propaganda and honestly I don't know enough about Brazil in their history to make an informed decision on this uh the game play was fine but I already have scythe and I already have ruric and I felt like this was trying to be those two games or it had a lot in common with those two games enough that I just it didn't feel like it had its own space within my game collection so I actually didn't get rid of this because of its theme or its Topic at all I got rid of it just because it's a bit of a busy mess of a game one of these days when my we girl is a little bit older and I have a bit more time I might read up quite a bit more on Brazilian history a lot of people have said that
Marvel dagger is nothing more than and a reskin of Aldrich horor and I think that is a terrible insult to Aldrich horor and I don't like Aldrich horor I'm famously on the record for enjoy Arkham Horror second edition a hell of a lot more than Aldrich horror and finding Aldrich horror the shallow weaker version of Arkham Horror and Marvel dagger it's the worst version of Aldrich horror I found Marvel dagger to be an incredibly joyless experience I felt like a overly long game that you would just playing on Route you're playing whacka all with the bad EAS as they turned up and you were doing whatever your character was specialized in and you just kept repeating that action the game felt on Rails there's all this teamwork stuff in it that's in it but very rarely did that make me feel like I was doing anything clever it was very much a case of you have to move here and spend eight actions doing this okay I've got three actions move action action next turn action action action next turn action action action yay we did the eight actions riveting Marvel dagger is a photocopy of a photocopy of Arkham Horror second edition next up we have Legacy of you from Garfield games the solo and game based in China I played this one a reasonable way through the campaign and it's just it's not a game for me it's a very solid solo experience and I can see why it has big solo fans but it just wasn't a gameplay Loop that really grabbed me I was fine at it I I played through enough of it to get the experience but yeah I mean if I'm going to play one of their games solo like that it's probably going to be paladins or circadian first light
or wall uh I've got three good options from the same publisher before I get onto Legacy auu so it's just a case of Garfield games put out a whole bunch of games with good solo modes uh I don't need a dedicated solo game from them at least not that one next up is Great Western Trail the core game and I pretty much got rid of this because I had such a terrible experience playing Great Western Trail in New Zealand uh that I now just had bad vibes for the original game and I just didn't need bad vibes in my collection so I passed that one on next up is a game called patuna and I'm not sure if I'm pronouncing that correctly um the long and the short of this one is it came with a whole bunch of stickering that needed to be done uh for the game and I opened it up one day and I just looked at it and I went I don't have the brain to do this today and I put it back on the shelf and then I forgot about it and I forgot about it for a year and by the time I remembered about it the next time the window for reviewing it had passed so I pushed that one on I don't really know anything about the game I did get past punching it out um entirely because the punching out experience became work and at that point of time uh no doubt I was looking after a toddler at the time so I was probably very tired uh and I just went I don't have the energy for this today and I shelved it and then forgot about it cuz I'm only human next is a very classic game twah
and TW is a game that I will play anywhere and everywhere I like twah TWR is a good solid game no one else in my group likes it no one else I play with likes it no one else ever wants to play it again with me uh so it was just one of those games that I played I was like Hey anyone want to play this terribly dry looking Euro game and it's got dice manipulation and just it really just turned everyone off um so that's a game I passed on to someone else who might actually get to play out more uh it's a game that if I see at a convention and people people go hey you want to play this you want to play 12 of us I'll be like yes absolutely I'll do that because it's a very good game it's just not a very good game for the people I play games with the second to last game is books of time and I have to admire books of time for its ambition it's a really clever idea here these are different books uh and you turn the pages and the mechanics are involving turning pages and then flipping them back and there's three different books and how they set up and there's a lot of clever stuff here there's some clever ideas it's just the game's a bit rubbish the game is just a nothing burger game it has this really cool concept and I want to see what someone else does with this concept uh of using the books and the the flicking pages and having different actions on those pages uh I would like to see like maybe a magic spellcasting game based on this uh cuz I think that would be really fun but as a history game it it did not work at all playing it no one felt like
they were building the story book of their history now we were flicking pages and taking actions and collecting resources that would turn into things the theming was just non-existent or felt very non-existent we were collecting sets that's that's about it but the idea of books and the idea of how you manipulate them very cool and very interested to see what they do with this next if someone else decides to utilize this mechanic again but with books of time it it didn't work um so that's why I got rid of that one cool concept cool idea so again it's like that thing I see with Merchants Cove I love the ambition I love what they were trying to do just because it didn't work for me and I don't think it was executed well doesn't mean it's a bad idea and the final game of the list is moon now moon really bothered me and it bothered me possibly more than any other game on this list because I really like Sinister fish's earlier games I love villagers and I thought streets was pretty damn need and moon I was expecting so much of and it's a drafting game so one of the things with drafting games is you kind of have to do two things you either all have to draft one card at a time and then Reveal Your one card and do that action or you draft all your cards at once and keep them secret and then reveal and play so we're talk sort of talking uh Sushi Go versus Seven
Wonders or sorry uh it's a wonderful world and what moon does is it has actions between each draft step so someone gets a card and then they can do actions as well and it just kills the momentum of a drafting game like it just feels like a cardinal sin of a drafting game as as you want it to go fast and moon feels three times longer than it needs to be um and it's just I can see they were trying to do something but it was literally the absolute wrong thing to do uh with a drafting game is to put in these interrupt mechanics that slow the game down so at the same sort of time I played ship rights the new ship rights of the North Sea which is just much better drafting game but on the evening I first played Moon I immediately had to play a game of It's a Wonderful World as a palet cleanser cuz I had to go wait this isn't how draft games feel and in Play It's a Wonderful World which half the time and was 10 times as much fun it just felt like moon at every conceivable point where there was a good decision to be made by the designers they went let's go the other way let's let's do the let's do the different thing sometimes doing the boring thing is the best thing because at least it works Moon I think as a game breaks down it's slow it's grindy it it's just not a fun experience and I was hoping for so much more from them because I've had a really good time with their games before and um here's hoping
the next one uh does a lot better so that's the list and it did get a little spicy at times but the vast majority of games are good uh that's that's a problem that's been happening to me a lot is there's plenty of games that are good but you know there's only finite space there's only finite time you can't just keep every game that's got some redeeming qualities and there are plenty games that I'd love to play again uh but I just realistically don't see myself playing with my groups or the worst of all I just don't want to teach them again um so yeah plenty of reasonable games that I got rid of for various different reasons and a couple of absolute stinkers so anyway in the comments below let me know the games you got rid of this year and why and if you enjoyed this video please support us on patreon we do not do paid content from Publishers we don't do paid Kickstarter previews we do none of that stuff our two revenue streams are patreon and YouTube ads and we do that in order to keep our voice as independent as possible so if you like what you see and want to see more please support us on patreon and until next time take care
all