Skip to main content
Loading video...

Best Games of 2018 - Top 10 from JonGetsGames

Transcript 1:15:08

welcome to junk it's games today I have finally decided that it's time for me to cover my top ten list for the games that I played that came out in 2018 then when I did the research for this it looks like that was a hundred and five different games and I've now spent the last couple weeks calling that list down and swapping some things around and at this point I'm feeling pretty happy with it now you can feel free to skip ahead to the slot that you are most interested in obviously I've decided to keep things a bit of a mystery by not putting the names over here but if you would like to see the full list you can check it out in the description down below now before we jump into this list I would like to ask that if you enjoyed this video you please consider clicking the like button down below as well as the subscribe button for the channel also if you would like to directly support the channel and the creation of future videos just like this one then please go to John gets Gamescom slash support to see a variety of ways with which you could do that including voting on a couple of the videos that I film each month alright without further ado let's jump into the list let's go ahead and start with game number ten and this one is Pandora now this one came out at essence field last year and I was lucky enough to attend and I pre-ordered a copy of this game and picked it up there now what's going on in this game is each player starts off with a asymmetric race and many of them are kind of standard fantasy tropes you have elves halflings and dwarves and that kind of thing but the way these different races play is somewhat significant and then when it comes to the actual way that you play this game there's some pretty strange stuff that I really enjoyed in the two plays of this game that I've had so far now the basic structure of this game is every turn you're gonna place down a tile onto a public board and that tile is essentially two hexagons stuck

together with two different types of terrain now after you put that tile down you will then have the option of putting one of your workers down on top of that tile and then this really interesting thing happens where if you look out to the board if you by putting that tile down you have now completely enclosed a contiguous area of a terrain type then that terrain type will score at the end of the round and before that even happens you kick off all of the workers from that enclosed terrain type now when the scoring happens every person is going to get one of that resource for each one of their workers that is adjacent to the score region and for every resource that is within that score region so if there are three coins in that region and you have two workers next to it then that would be three times two or you would get six coins now everyone is score it even though it's your turn you put the towel down you might put yourself into a situation where multiple people will get stuff and there are effectively three resources in this game you have gems that you can use to cast spells you have money that lets you buy cards and you have wood that lets you build buildings now these cards can be used as either a spell or as a building and the spells are effectively one-shot actions that let you do a variety of cool things and the buildings instead you could just slide under your tableau and they give you an ongoing effect that might bend the rules for you now that is the general structure of the game but the reason that I've been really I found the game quite compelling has to do with the way that players are working against each other but also with each other to try and kind of build out these areas while you're trying to squeak out advantages for yourself and also the way you score points in this game is it just feels a little bit different than what

you would normally expect from a game like this you get almost all of your points while you are playing and when you get resources you track them on a player board in front of yourself and you can't store more than 10 of each resource at any point in time now the thing is for every three additional of a resource that you generate with one of these scoring actions you get a point and there are buildings that you can build that will change that modifier for you it might become a two to one or a three to two or something like that so this game but really turns into this interesting affair where you're trying to generate the resources that you need to cast the spells and buy cards and pl buildings but you are trying to build up to a couple times of the game having a humungous scoring now there are buildings that let you add effectively resources to these scoring modifiers and you are trying to get yourself in a situation where you might get 40 wood with one scoring now obviously you cannot store 40 wood so maybe you store like five or six of it and then the rest of it you run through your multiplier which hopefully if you've been building towards getting 40 wood you also have a building that makes you maybe a two-to-one and then you two-to-one on the you know 34 remaining resources and right there you get 17 victory points and you score that on the board now this is a big way that you get points in the game trying to work towards these combos but of course everybody is trying to do that and you're trying to mitigate one of the combos that your opponent's can do and also you're trying to work it so that your workers could score multiple times but of course when an area gets enclosed with a worker on it those workers get removed from bored so you are just trying to be as efficient as possible in this expanding communal tiling space that scores in a

really peculiar way and all of these reasons are the reason why this game is on this list sure it's number 10 but you know just being on this list means it's within the top 10 percent of the games that I played in or that came out in 2018 and I really feel like the decisions that you make and just the way that you talk to your opponents are you trying to get into their minds about what they're gonna do is really fascinating and then I also love the fact that you just draw a tile at the end of your turn and then you must play it down at the beginning of your next turn so you don't have a huge hand of cards or tiles anyway to place down you have that one thing and you have to decide how best to use it now you do have a hand of cards in this game and it's also wonderful deciding do I want to play this card as a spell to do that one-shot effect that might do some really awesome things for me right now or do I want to slide it in as a building to give me an ongoing beneficial effect that maybe is more situational so there's just all of these really cool things to think about and then to circle back to what I said in the very beginning you have these asymmetries which are really wonderful they can definitely affect how you'll play from one game to the next and I will admit that when I picked this one up at SN it came with some promos I'm not sure I didn't do my research I guess to see exactly how many came with the base box and how many came as promos that you can probably get later on but I do know that I have more of the different races in the box that I have then many of the retool retail versions of this game will have but I will also say that the variety of the effects and that happened in here are really cool the last time I played this one I did play one of those promo characters and they're asymmetric effect was that when

I actually remove people from the board by enclosing regions I took them prisoner and I actually took people's workers prisoner and put them on my player board and then they had to essentially pay me off to pull these off and when they take their people back then I got resources that I needed and at the end of the game if I had any people in my area then I got extra points for them and that really affected how this entire game played I'd played it before where there was no wacky prisoner mechanism and what that meant was you know people had this diminishing diminishing worker pool as I collected more and more people until they finally decided it was worth it to actually pay me off I just really enjoyed how that one particular character played but I've also enjoyed saying how the rest of the different asymmetric abilities played so I think that's gonna wrap up my thoughts for the moment on pandorean I think it's got some really great decisions that has a really cool turn structure it's got a very interesting way of having the players play off of each other trying to build up really big combos and I am certainly looking forward to playing this one more next up we have game number 9 and this one is menara now this game came out about the middle way through of 2018 and this is a fully cooperative stacking dexterity style game now the way the game works is when it is your turn you have to decide to flip over a easy medium or hard a challenge for that turn you flip it over and then it will tell you what you have to do now usually this involves taking these long skinny cylinders from your personal supply and putting them up standing end up somewhere in the middle of the player area now sometimes there are some funky challenges that might actually have you moving these cylinders around but the way the game works is as

soon as any of these really strange and interesting lis shaped pieces of cardboard on the table are full up where they have the matching color cylinders on top of their colored spots on the cardboard that is the moment you have to bring in a new piece of cardboard and stack it up somewhere on your tower that you are constructing now you're gonna keep playing this game until well the tower falls over or until some we run out of the cylinders or until you run out of the missions that you are actually trying to play through I think you also finish the game if you get all of the floor tiles out into your Tower and so the way it works is you just need to be in a winning situation the moment the endgame happens now you are in a winning situation if you have it the correct number of floors or higher based off of the current difficulty of at the moment that you are really in and start of the game you choose a difficulty and that will tell you how many floors you need as a base but as you're playing the game if you ever draw one of those challenges that you cannot satisfy then you actually put it face down into the difficulty area and that's one more row one more floor up that you need to have constructed when the game actually ends in order to win now also you can build out at the base to put more don't you know kind of wider but every time you build out a new piece on to the table you add one again to the difficulty now what this means is as you are playing this dexterity game you are having pretty intense and wonderful discussions with your teammates around the table because you might talk about which one of the difficulties you should do and then you'll flip it over and then

well you have to just figure it out like we should put this here and there that'll unlock this ability and maybe I don't know maybe we should do that because this isn't a really good position for this at our board maybe we should do this other thing there's just quite a bit of discussion that happens but then once you know a decision is made as to how that turn is gonna happen then it's that person's turn to do the plant they have to execute it it's a dexterity game and that means that this is certainly not a cooperative game where you could have an alpha player where somebody just you know essentially plays the entire game for themselves because in this case every single person has to do these things and sometimes it's quite challenging like I said there are many that cause you to have to pull these Silver's out from the bottom and put them up on the top so you have this amazing moments where you're just like telling everybody to get away from the table and you're trying to extract this cylinder and everything kind of wobbling is you're trying to put this thing together and it's just it's just wonderful when you actually pull those moments off especially considering it's cooperative so everybody is so elated when you do a really complicated move to get it done now I I do want to mention that when the game when the tower falls over that effectively instigates the end of the game and according to the rules if you at that moment have or matching the difficulty level then you can actually win with the tower falling over but I have instituted when we've plated a house rule to say that if anything falls over then then you just lose because without that house rule you could kind of game it and knock parts of it over while other parts are staying tall enough to actually match up with the victory condition and that just kind

of feels like it's not in the spirit of the game overall so yeah I have played this game a few times now and I've really enjoyed it every single time it's definitely an I pull er like people wandering around like if you're playing in a public space they always come over on the like what is going on here because it's just such a picturesque awesome tower that you are building I found this interesting trouble with the game where every time I play it I want to take the wonderful layout that I built and then I look at the photo on my phone and it just it just doesn't do it justice and I think that's because you're not looking at it in 3d to really see the depth of this thing that you are creating now on top of all that I found that there's kind of a cool meta game that has emerged for me when building this well meta game might not be the right word but if echt of lis like deeper construction strategies I found that the first couple times we played we just made a big tower and got spindle ear and spindle ear until you know potentially fell over and we lost but then we started to realize after we played this a few times that this game is really all about strategically building up maybe couple towers and then putting a big big piece of cardboard across them to kind of stabilize them and they'd be doing that again and then crossing over again and the amount of crossing over with these floors that you could do is definitely going to increase your ability to win the game and at this point I don't remember exactly how many times I've won or lost but I can say that I've really enjoyed this game every single time I played it which is why it is here on the list at location number nine because I think that it very much deserves to get more attention I think that there aren't that many cooperative dexterity games that I can think of and even if there are I I do think that this one is probably one of the best I

certainly have really enjoyed playing it let's now move on to game number eight and this one is Neil now this one came out to end Essen I believe last year so several months ago I didn't actually get my copy of this game until January or so and it's now been played a few times but it is a 2018 release and this game has significantly surprised me honestly when the publisher first reached out and asked me if I wanted a copy I looked at some photos online and I said well okay sure it looks like you were doing some city building with some square tiles I've certainly done that before I've done that with hexagonal tiles with suburbia a bunch I looked into it a little bit and found out that it is a handed drafting style game where you actually have the tiles in your hand and you hold one and then pass the rest to the person on your left and I was like okay those both sound fine I enjoy hand drafting and I like building out cities let's give the game a shot and I won actually got the game I got to play it pretty quickly and on that very first play everyone just really liked it like it just it went over very well with everyone at the table so I played it again and everybody really liked it again and I played it a third time and it's just done so well every single time I plated honestly it like I said before I've been quite surprised I figured it would be okay but instead it's now here at number eight on this list now let's talk about the reasons why I mean obviously I've talked about the base mechanics here it's not really doing anything innovative when it comes to the hand of drafting again you just take one and pass the rest of the person on your left as you're playing and then everybody simultaneously uses that tile to put it down somewhere into their board area but um the things that

you are doing you obviously score a wide variety of things this is a city building style game and some of these will seem kind of familiar you had you can build out residences and you can score some pretty big combo multipliers when you have your residences that are adjacent to each other but another thing that this game does is when it comes to resources I really like what they do so you can build out tiles in your area that give you access to infinite amounts of specific resources and there are a wide variety of these resources you have kind of raw materials you have processed materials and then you have luxury materials that you gain access to near the very end of the game and as soon as you make at least one of the things you make as much as you need but then if you want to build a tile that costs resources that you don't have then you look out to your opponents and you try to find somebody who makes that and then you can pay them a cost and money to gain access to some of their infinite supply of that resource now the farther they are away from you around the table the slightly increased the overall cost will be and you can get some discounts for playing your tiles out in specific ways in front of you but what it means is you are one thing that you can do with this game is try to make a lot of resources in particular the resources that other people don't do so that people have to pay you to gain access to that resource now there's no real way to corner the market here and in fact you as a player you don't get any benefit for putting down two tiles of the same resource besides I guess stopping somebody else from putting that tile down so that it forces them to pay you so I haven't really found that to be a thing but what I have seen is as you're playing this game certain people will go

really hard on resources and certain people might barely put any resources down and instead those people might focus on something else like putting a bunch of the blue tiles down which are I guess kind of business district tiles and they're all about getting new lots of money they might get you money income that will give you stuff between the rounds and they might give you lots of one-shot money or condition money or a variety of ways to get money and then they can just spend that money giving it to the players who are making the resources so to a certain extent everybody's building out these cities in front of themselves but it doesn't feel like isolated little cities like it almost feels like an ecosystem as we are paying each other back and forth to gain access to the resources that everybody has around the table now there are some complexities that exist in this game and in fact the biggest issue that I have with this game is right there at the very beginning because before you even start playing you're going to do a draft to get these cornerstone tiles and these effectively let you dictate your overall strategy for the game these are somewhat complicated tiles and they can give you endgame victory point multipliers for doing a variety of different things and the issue here is that these cornerstone tiles are like four times more complicated than the average tile in the rest of the game so in particular that very first time we played it started off pretty rough like because nobody had any idea what these tiles did they all have iconography on them and the icons are pretty good but many of these tiles do a lot of different things and so we were just passing around and the rulebook like crazy trying to read the specifics of what each one of our tiles did honestly my impression of the game we're starting to get pretty low right from the very beginning I was like oh my gosh

this is like a lot of downtime is the whole game gonna be like this but then once we had finished down that draft and we actually started playing the game and looked and all of the other tiles we realized that that process of trying to figure out how all of our corresponds worked we now kind of understood how the rest of the icons worked and we were able to blitz through and understand what all of essentially all of the other tiles did with very little hiccups trying to go back to the rulebook so for first time players it's a bit intimidating having to do a draft before you even start playing with these tiles that do a variety of things but it is really important to do this draft because as you're playing the game you want to be working towards us in the first game that I played I think two out of the three tiles I grabbed gave me a lot of points for residences so I went really hard on residences in that game and I came in second I came in with a pretty strong second there so I think that the ability to play towards a strategy that you have with these quarter stone tiles is really important it just can be a little bit overwhelming at first now I'm not going to go into the specifics of how all of the rest of the mechanics work but when it comes to the overall impressions that I've had there are some pretty big selling points for this game the first selling point is the simultaneous play nature of the game means that we are all doing interesting things at the same time so there is a bit of downtime sometimes if one person is really struggling with a draft but for the most part people are making decisions all at the same time and then you pass the tiles and you're making decisions all at the same time again and that means that you can have a somewhat nice a medium-weight euro we kind of experience you know it's usually about an hour 15 to an hour and a half long

but it's pretty dense experience like you're spending most of that time making interesting decisions now the next thing to mention it has to do with the actual Tai Lang itself and you know your board is a five by five grid if I'm remembering that correctly and you obviously have squares so tiling is relatively straightforward and you do have some restrictions because you're not allowed to spin your tiles and your tiles have these roads you have to connect them all up back to your city centre and as you're playing so I enjoy the fact that you have some restrictions there but I also like the fact that they went with square tiles so they didn't have to go with hexagons or something like that like even with the square tiles there are a lot of great decisions as you're trying to build this stuff out you actually get penalties if you have residences next to your yellow factories so you're trying to you end up having like these districts in your area and also and you can say this about a lot of town building games you kind of form a narrative as you're playing the game based off of the towels that you make like at a certain point you might look down and be like oh my gosh you're like I think what one person just kind of had like a prison town like they had all these slums they had prisons they had police and it was just like oh like they didn't really realize that they were building that town out and one time that I played all I did I just dedicated myself towards making resources so that people would pay me and it's worth noting you can get a lot of endgame points for the resources that you make and I looked down and I had just barely enough residences to essentially populate all of these different factories and then like the only food I had was like a corner store and it was just like oh man this is just this is just a grizzly town just for making resources to send out to everyone else and then I look over the person next to

me and they have like this ideal ik town just full of like shopping malls and supermarkets and you know a wonderful massive skyscrapers all over the place with very little resources and they've just paying me to make that happen it's just a cool ecosystem so I think at this point I've maybe talked about this one a little bit longer than I should have but I was I've been very impressed with neon and everyone that I have introduced introduced this to has enjoyed it I think more than I think everyone has been pleasantly surprised think they look at it like this looks fine and then everyone is watching away from saying actually that game was great and I'm looking forward to playing it again at this point we've reached a game number seven and this one is railroad ink now technically you could say this is actually a games isn't number seven because when railroad ink came out last year it came out with a deep blue version and a blazing red version and the base rules for each one of these boxes are identical but in each box there are two different expansions with the red version you have meteors and lava and with the blue version you have lakes and you have rivers now every time you play railroading you can select one of these expansions to play with or you could just play the base version of the game and I have at this point played all four of the expansions and the base game many times in fact my overall play count is eight for railroad Inc at this point and that alone is one of the reasons why it is over here on the list at game number seven but also at this point I feel like this is the best role and right game that I have played now might I say that with quotes because this is kind of a new genre of game that is gaining a lot of popularity and the base idea here and with many of this type of game is that some dice are rolled in the

middle of the table and then everybody will simultaneously use the results of those dice and they will write those down onto their pad in front of themselves and from the area now when it comes to railroad ink you actually have these dry erase boards with these drivers pens and what you are doing is you are drawing rail lines and Road lines on your area in front of yourself and you are gonna score a multiplier based off of how many connected exits you have with the different rail lines going into roads and you get some bonus points for how long your roads are and how long your rail lines are there are some lots of little ways to score points in this game but the main idea is trying to make a big networks of these different types of lines in your player board and I think the reason why this game is my favorite role and write game at the moment is because every single turn feels like a big puzzle now there are lots of roll and write games out there where you might flip or roll some dice and it might be a number or two and you kind of write those down onto your pad but in railroad ink you always roll four dice in the base game and if you're playing with an expansion you roll six dice actually and when it comes to those even those four dice they will have a variety of different roads and rail lines that you have to put down and you have to put all four of those down into your area so every single turn is like this tasty puzzle of like how am I gonna interconnect all four of these things in to the greater a network that I am building and how am I going to build myself out so that I have lots of availability to expand out and get lots of points in the future turns as well so

I just I like the fact that you have so much to think about every single turn it seems like every turn is pretty meaty and then you do seven terms and the game is over and you score everything up now that alone honestly I think would get this game onto my top ten list but then the fact that you have these expansions available really adds a bunch of wonderful flavor to the game as well now each version of this game I think it costs around 20 ish dollars and each version has enough materials to play with six people so if you want to have all four expansions you have to pay essentially forty dollars but at that point you also have enough materials to play this game with up to 12 people which would actually I think play fine because this is a multiplayer solitaire game nothing that you do impacts your opponents you're just trying to do the best that you can with the die rolls and try to do it better than all of your opponents try to out to puzzle them when it comes to these die rolls so from my perspective I think that having both of these in the collection makes tons of sense because each one of these expansions adds its own little variety the river expansion is really simple it just adds a river that you can put down to get some extra points I like that extra flex extra flexibility there and the lake expansion is just like a brain exploder because you have ferries to connect all of these different things so it's like the deep blue version has the easiest and most complicated of the iterations of railroad inks that are out right now and then when it comes to the red version you have the volcano one where you actually have to deal with these pools of lava that might expand out and actually destroy some of your roads but you can actually get a decent amount of points for those pools of lava and you

can make new volcanoes which it might be in your best interest but for making volcanoes that does mean good things for your overall network and then the other of the red expansions is the meteor which is maybe one of the more interesting from mechanical perspective because you roll is too nice and it causes a meteor to crash on a specific spot on your board and it destroys anything that was there already but you get a decent amount of bonus points for every connection that are pointed into a meteor because there's all these valuable materials that you can harvest from those meteors so it's not that big of a deal to have a meat-eor crash into a spot that you've already drawn on because now you just try to focus all of your attention to trying to connect up those meteors and I think that all four of these expansions add a wonderful amount of variety to the game I think that every time I play this game all eight times I have really enjoyed every single turn even if I'm like you know pulling my hair out like oh my gosh how can we never roll a straight railroad line like that's all I need and it's been like four turns but at the same time I enjoy that kind of mental strength when it comes to doing these things because everybody's dealing with it and it's the kind of thing where if you find yourself backed into a corner while you did that to yourself and you have only yourself to blame and also this game usually lasts about half an hour like it doesn't take a very long time so you can play with six or even twelve people if you buy both copies in about half an hour everyone who's playing in is having an engaged thinkI wonderful time in a small amount of time so overall I think this one is just a big winner like it's gonna see a lot more play I think I really enjoy the act of playing with it in

addition to the fact that it is so flexible to actually get played with other people so I'm happy to have it in my collection and I think it really deserves a spot on the list alright we've now reached game number six and this one is passing through Petra now this one came out to in the second half of 2018 and I've played it several times at this point and it is a strange and intriguing puzzle East aisle game now my initial impression of this game just looking at photos that I saw online I didn't really expect all that much from it if the board is a little bland if I'm being honest you know it's it's got a lot of kind of yellow it's set in the desert and then you have this row of tiles in the middle with these plastic walls kind of canyon walls that the tiles are gonna be shepherded through and those look pretty cool but I think overall I was maybe maybe just not really all that enthralled by the overall artistic aesthetic of the game but I I heard enough about it to want to try it at BoardGameGeek on last year and I played a four-player game of this and it blew all four of us away we all liked it so much in fact I just got my wife it's one of her favorite games right now we decided to go out and purchase a copy of this game and we have played it many times since then so let me talk a little bit more about how this game plays then I'll talk about why it's on this list now every single turn you are going to make a decision you're going to go take an action by moving a pawn that it's in this three by three matrix now the direction that you move the pawn is going to dictate and the action that you get to take but once you are against a wall where an action is you can't take that action anymore so right from the beginning this is a wonderful action selection mechanism because it means if

you want to say take some tiles from the general market area you could do that a couple times but then you run against a wall and you can't do that action anymore until you do the opposite action to kind of walk your pawn away from it which involves caching these tiles in now this obviously works in the four different dimensions so you have to puzzle this out and make sure that you are setting yourself up to do a variety of things you can't just keep doing a thing over and over again because you'll find yourself in a corner and then you must do a different action which maybe you haven't set yourself up well well for and then it doesn't actually go that well for you now what you actually do with these actions in general is you are going to pick up these tiles for the middle of the board either from the end of the row or from the middle of the row and you're gonna put them down into your own player board area I guess the idea here is these are merchants and entering Petra and then you can kind of you know school them away over to your area and then you have your own little line there as well so this game is all about lines of different colored tiles so you shove it that person into the line down in front of you when you add them in and then and if any people will fall out the other end which I think they always will then you take that person and you move them to the top of your board which is essentially the encampment area so that's now not emergent that's a person who can actually trade with different people and this probably isn't making a lot of sense but effectively what happens is you are setting yourself up to make a big combo turn when you do a specific action where you will looks your board and it will say something along the lines of count up the number of teal merchants that are in the line down below and apply that by the number of maybe purple merchants that are up above in at that

encampment you multiply those things together you get your value maybe it's you know something like a nine and then you look out to the main board where there are these wheels and you move your disk around that wheel that number of steps I believe there are seven steps as you go around here and this is kind of the main engine of the game because as you are going around you're gonna gain these extra abilities that might give you wild merchants they can trade with anybody you might be able to expand out your merchants row you might get other benefits like permanent encampments and whatnot but then also you get to drop off cubes after you hit certain spots on these wheels and this is a game with no victory points right for the get-go if you just looked at it if you walk by saw some people playing it you would probably assume that you would count up your victory points for a variety of different things at the end and whoever had the most points wins but this is actually a race each player has a number of these cubes in front of themselves and it's just a race to be the first person to get rid of all of your cubes and then that person wins you know if there's a tie I think then there's maybe a slight tie breaker or something like that but this game is really about getting rid of your cubes in a couple of different ways and spinning around those wheels is one of the main ways that you are gonna do it now I don't again want to go into too many of the specifics here but this should set an expectation up in your mind of the broad scope of how you play this game because what it means is you are trying to pull the tiles in to put into your row that are gonna match up well with the encampments that you have above but every person that you put down into your row is going to end up going up into an encampment as you get more people and it scoots those people out of your row so you're constantly thinking about well

what's my next big scoring multiplier going to be but what's the one gonna be after that because okay maybe I'm trying to get much steel people down here to score off with those purple people and then I do that and I get a bunch of things and I drop a couple cubes off but now time goes on and now those teal people are falling out and they're kind of stacking up here well what is the teal actually multiplied against oh that that one goes against the orange baby and so now you are trying to get orange as well and every time you actually cash out these big combo turns knitting kind of locks you out from that and it liquidates all of the encampment there so you're not set up to do that one over and over again so this game is essentially it kind of feels like a big slow wheel is turning strategic logic where you're trying to get specific colors now but then at the right moment you're like and now I need to get the next set of colors to work well with the previous wave and now I need to get the next set of colors to work with the previous wave but as you were playing the game you're not always gonna have the ability to do that because everybody is going after all of these different tiles now each player board is different so you one person might have teal multiplying it's purple another person might have teal multiply against the red so that kind of varies things up but overall the way this mechanism works is just wonderfully satisfying the first time we played this game and we were halfway through it and everyone was just like this game is so weird this game is so cool and that that feeling has persisted as I have played this game many more times now another big selling point for this game is the fact that it is not very long the probably average play time for a four player game of this is like 50 minutes to maybe an hour so you are just

giving these wonderful thinking moments as you're trying to set things up set things up and then have these explosive big combo turns which are very satisfying as you build out all of your different benefits and as you get all these cubes out and you also have this kind of breathless race kind of thing in the back of your head as you're looking down you're like okay I'm ahead I'm like maybe even two cubes ahead you're planning this big thing up a couple turns go by and you look over you're like holy cow that person got like three down and that one turn with this massive move now I'm suddenly behind and it's just overall every single time I've played this game I've really enjoyed it I have to admit then from a variable variability perspective you don't really bring new things in versus um from one game to the next there are these cards that you can acquire when you do specific action that can let you come with different things and each time you play you're gonna probably see a different set of those cards which vary things up a little bit but I don't think variability is really the selling point for this game the selling point is that it is so different and that even after playing this game I think four or five times at this point I am still looking forward to playing it more because just every time I think back to every moment when I'm sitting there in the middle of the game thinking about stuff I've just been enjoying myself I just really have liked how all of these decisions come into play I like how fresh the overall feeling is a for it and that is why it is that number six on the list it's now time to move on to the next game and this one is Scorpius trader at number five now I got to play this one for the first time at BoardGameGeek Con last year and despite a somewhat rough first game because I had trouble with the rules because I'd read them a couple days

earlier I went away from that play feeling like I really wanted to try it again and AEG is the publisher and they actually sent me a copy of it and at this point I've now played it I think five times because it really latched on and I really started to love in this game now from a mechanical perspective there are some really neat things going on here the first thing that you'll probably notice if you look at a table with people playing it is there are three circles in the middle of the main board and these are communal rondelle's now if you're not familiar with the term rondell it's a make mechanism in games where effectively you move around it and the the spaces in front of yourself on the rondell usually dictate the actions that you can take and usually you can only go a certain number of spaces forward now in this game you actually have these three rondelle's with a communal marker on it and when it is your turn you have to use some of your crew in order to move that rondell one or two spaces forward and then wherever it lands you can activate the ability that is associated there based off of the strength power of your unactivated crew that is on your ship now when it comes to your crew the game has these seven pre-made sets of four crew that you can play and they're kind of obviously oriented towards different strategies as you're playing and it does an interesting thing where you just start the game with all of your crew and you don't have to actually like you never get new crew and where the crew is on your ship doesn't specifically matter but every single crew member has a special ability you can gain access to if you upgrade them through one of the actions in the main area and you can kind of see those as you're playing trying to build up some combos but the

real kicker for this game the real reason why I have kind of fallen in love with it has to do with that flow of the three rondelle's in the middle now you have the first rondell which is all about gaining these tiles to put onto your ship that you have it in front of yourself now this is kind of a personal tile landing puzzle because the pieces that you put down there are either going to be storage tiles that you can store different types of resources on because you're effectively Smuggler's trying to do illicit deeds without the Galactic Empire saying what you're doing so you're putting the storage units down to your area but then you're also putting these pieces of equipment down into your area and where you put them down it really matters if you put like colored stores next to light color storage then you will likely be able to get more of that material when you end up getting some stuff and the pieces of equipment can do a variety of things so the first Rundell is just about putting tiles down onto your board the second rondelle is all about using those tiles on your board to get stuff on that one you might be able to gain resources with most if not all of your storage containers just getting the various different color resources to put down into those areas based off of how adjacent they are two different things but then you can also activate your equipment which can do a wide variety of really cool things that sometimes has to do with the adjacency of where that equipment is on your player area to activating different things to even doing some special bonus e actions so you can have some really good combo stuff going on there now there is a third rondell on the board and that one is all about using the resources that you have made and in order to get points you can either do that through side deals which are effectively very small

set collection goals way just getting rid of a couple resources here there for points or you can use that rondell to complete contracts which are more complicated set collection tasks as you're trying to get different combos of the different types of resources and then when you complete them you get a lot of points but then you also will get extra one-shot abilities to kind of launch you into trying to do more stuff so you are going to be playing this game moving these different to communal rondelle's around and obviously as you do actions that's going to change the different action set of options for the next player but you always have all three of these rondelle's worth of stuff to pay attention to as you're playing and this game just has this wonderful Evan flow of like in the early game you're just constantly just building out your ship a bunch and then you're using your ship a bunch and then you starting to cache things out and then you're the end of the game everybody's kind of stopped building out the ship their ship is fine and they're just constantly using the middle rondell to get more stuff and then the last one to try and use all of our stuff and I think as an engine it works really really well but then on top of that this game has a significant amount of variability that adds to the replayability of this game because not only are there seven of these pre constructed decks of crews that you can play but there is a variance in the back where instead of using one of these you just do a full-on draught you shuffle all of these different crew together and then you draft six of them and then you choose four of those six and that will be your crew for the entire game and I have played with this variant and it is really neat because some of these crew will get you points at the end of the game some of them will give you various conditional benefits as you're playing the game and when you play with the

pre-constructed decks they're fine they're very like you might get want to be like okay so I'm the people who make lots of money and I'm gonna use money to do stuff cool that's very straightforward or he might be like oh I'm the people who make lots of storage and well I guess I'll make a lot of storage this game but when you draft these things around we when we played this way one player drafted like three of the endgame victory point cards to try and really boost up the score at the end I can't even remember specifically what I did by pieced together some pretty cool combos with the crew based off of that draft and then on top of that there are also these variable cockpits that you can play with that you put down onto your board and they will make every single person right for the very beginning different with the pieces of equipment they have that they have and in fact at this moment I do want to say that if you play Scorpius Raider it is my personal opinion that you should always play with the variable asymmetric cockpits instead of using the cockpit and is pre-printed on the board I played with the pre-printed one many times and I feel like it skews the game a little bit too much towards equipment and people kind of ignored it doing storage facilities but when I played with the different cockpits that wasn't the case and everything balanced out really wonderfully and honestly the game just leveled up when I start when I decided to play this game with that variant and also with the drafting variant although you should probably play a couple games before you actually do the draft variant so overall I've just been really impressed with the flow of this game of all of the decisions that you have as you are trying to build out effectively a spatial engine in front of yourself and then run that engine to try and get the resources you need to squeeze as many points as you can before the game

ends the game ends as soon as any one of those three communal rondelle's spins around a certain number of times and so you know people really go crazy on one bond out that might actually cause the game to end someone early but in all of my plays this it's usually been never more than 90 minutes with within a given place so I've just been super impressed with Scorpio spreader I think mechanically a solid I think variability wise there is a lot to play like every time you sit down to play this game you we're going to build out a different type of engine one gaming might go crazy and side deals in another game you might go crazy on contracts there's just so many different things that you could do here and I've just been really impressed with it at this point we are starting to get to the lower numbers we are now at number four and this game is lowlands now this game came out to an I think June ish or so of 2018 and right for the get-go when you take a look at lowlands it looks like a very generic euro style game you each player has their own player board they start the game with some sheep and some little fence posts on your area you have lots of green with the art to overall and you have a hand of cards with you know stone and clay and wood these all seem like very tropi standard things but when I started learning about this game and then particular when I started playing it I realized that this is a very interesting game like it is not your average euro game in the slightest now the central mechanic of this game or the central the central conceit of this game is that there is water coming in you are I guess in the Scandinavia area I don't remember exactly which specific country but there

is water the ocean is coming in and you have to build it dikes collectively as a community everyone around the table is communally spending actions to build dikes and you spend resource cards that you have in your hand to build out these dikes now every time you you help out with the construction of the tanks you will move yourself up on that track and this is effectively like everybody being like hey look that blue player over there they're really trying to help the community out by really focusing on getting that dike built out but the thing is that by spending actions to work on that you are not doing other things like breeding tons of sheep and a sheep are a big way that you can get a lot of points in this game but at certain points as you were playing the game you will effectively have a high tide and at that moment you check to see if there is more water than there are dike pieces to actually hold it back now as you're playing throughout the round the water you will learn more and more about how more how much water there will be when you have that high tide moment and when that happens if the dike is big enough then that's awesome like congratulations everybody can high-five because they held the water back everything is fine and then what happens is the person who contributed the most towards the dykes essentially the person who is for the stole on the track he's going to get the most amount of points in the second best person will get the second most points because they will get points based off of their position compared to the person who contributed the least so one person did just nothing with the Dyke track and somebody went crazy with it and then they actually held the water back then that person went crazy with it is gonna get a lot of points but here is an interesting thing and that is that there is this sliding

multiplier for endgame scoring where the more times you hold the Dyke back the less points you actually get at the end of the game for having contributed to the dike I guess people just kind of collectively ignore the threat of the sea the like they're like hey look at me I did all this stuff with the dike in people like yeah whatever like nope no sheep died at the end of this game like you know quick Tooting your own horn and in that case if the dike gets held back if the dike is big enough through every single round of the game then the Sheep will be both me worth just tons of points because it's kind of an inverse multiplier the less points the dike track is worth the more points cheaper worth and the inverse is the more often that the dike is not built up big enough and the water spills over the dike and starts killing people sheep well the more victory points you get at the end of the game for being a person who could tribute into the night because at the end of the game you could be like look at all this work I did look how you know awful things got like all these sheep died but I did my best and so that person will get a lot of points in that respect so what this means is you have this wonderful Cecil in the game where you are trying to do what you're trying to breed sheep and you're trying to repair the dike as you're playing but you don't want to over commit to one of these and allow other players to just go crazy like if you start the game and you're just like all I'm gonna do this game is build out of the dike that's gonna be my plan and that's what we're gonna do then everybody else is gonna be like cool thanks for building out the dike build and you spend all of their actions instead of building the dike just breeding tons of sheep that are worth tons of points so then you have this interesting thing where if you start the game maybe you're like in the early stages you're like I'm gonna build a lot of the night come gonna push push push

and then you're like oh people are going crazy on sheep well then maybe what you should do is actually stop building the dike so that the water goes a little bit over and it starts overflowing and washing the Sheep away and suddenly those sheep are actually worth less because the slider moves over and now your dike points are worth so you if you as a person who invest a lot of actions into getting naik points actually want the dye kit to break so you have this wonderful social dynamic of people talking back and forth about who is gonna get it to whichever points and is it worth it to them to do this or that and the other thing so it's just a wonderful push and pull mechanism now there are some other really good things going on in lowlands in particular the action selection mechanism is quite simple but very effective every person has three workers and one of them does two actions one does three actions and one does four actions now as you're playing the game and when it's returned you do use one of your workers and you activate one of the four main actions you can do in the game but it's not really worker placement because you activate it on your own personal board you never interact with your opponents in this way but that means every single round you need to decide what action you're gonna do for to what's gonna be three and what's gonna be four and you were gonna change your priority as the game goes on you might be like okay I'm gonna set my four over here to the dike building action because I have a lot of cards for it and oh my gosh the deck is about to break and I have all these sheep and I want to do what I can to actually save these sheep even though you know if we save the dikes then it means the sheep are worth slightly less but you still actually want to have them I've not seen anyone win this game and do not actually have sheep I've seen people win with a lot less sheep than other players but either way it's

definitely something to consider so the action selection mechanism is simple it just works and then you have this wonderful push-pull of the environment of this dike being built and the storm coming in and the water coming in and everybody's kind of stressing out about how it's all gonna play out it just makes a wonderful social dynamic and I don't want to make this sound like a social game you're not really negotiating but it also makes a wonderful mechanical environment as you're trying to figure out what the result what the the results of your your decisions actually are like what are the consequences of my decision to do this versus that and on top of all that I didn't even mention that when you're building out the dike you actually have to ask an opponent if they want to help you out with that dike building the process and if they do help then you get an extra little bump but they also get to help with their trap their marker up on the track so you have that element of trying to figure out who you actually want to ask if you want them to help you out or not as you're trying to figure out where everybody is of the game I haven't even talked about the fact that there are a bunch of different buildings that you're gonna build out into your area as you expand your pasture out and the more fence posts you put down the more resources you get when you take income but I don't need to go into all those details long story short there is a decent amount of variety here because you do see different sets of those buildings each play you can't build many of them and they are going to give you combos that will make you better at one thing in one game and better at another thing in another game but every time I play this game I think in the push and pull intention of the dike and the water level has just felt really fun like I've just enjoyed the the stress and then that puts on the overall table and it also just feels new like this is that

not at all the play that generic euro game that it looks when you first walk by it it actually has some really fresh cool ideas in it at this point we've reached a game number three and this one is underwater cities now this is the newest game from the designer Vladimir tsuchi and in fact this is the first published game from delicious games which is a publishing house that I believe has actually run by Vladimir SUCI and his wife katka now I reached out to them before Essen spiel about getting a press copy and I was able to actually secure that with a discount because their new company they couldn't really give away a ton of different copies of this so I was able to pick it up at Essen last year and I was quite interested in trying it although I wasn't necessarily expecting it to become one of my favorite games of the year now mechanically what's going on in this game from the outset is it seems like it's just a worker placement game every single time you have a turn you have three workers and you take a worker and you put it out onto a spot on the central fire board you can't go somewhere as somebody else has already been and then you evaluate the spot that's there and then you can move on now in general I think worker placement is fine but I am much more interested in interesting action selection mechanisms and the reason that really this game really caught my eye is because in addition to that worker placement there is a card playing aspect to the game that goes along with it so every single turn you're gonna draw card up into your hand and you have a hand limit if I think three and they can go higher as you're playing the game getting different combooo things but every single time you play out a worker you must play a card from your hand now the

thing is if that card does not match the color of the region you play to then you literally just discard the card you don't get to do anything with it however if the region you put your worker on it matches the color of the card your hand not only do you they do the action of where you put your worker but you do all of the actions that are listed on the card that you just played along with it now some of these cards are just one-shot actions you just immediately get resources or many of them have conditional things like if you have an upgraded desalination plant then you get to do this kind of thing so that card might be really good for one player because they have an upgraded desalination plant and for another player that might they might just discard it like then not even worry about it because it's not really going to work towards what they're doing now many of these cards can actually be played out in front of you into a growing tableau and some of them at Kant are action cards and when you do specific actions on the main area in the board it will allow you to do extra actions that are the cards we have in front of yourself so they're kind of like combo bonus the actions but there are also lots of cards that are conditional benefits you put them in front of yourself they got a little infinity symbol on them essentially and every time a certain thing happens then this card activates and you get a certain reward now a big pleasure of this game is trying to put together combos of these cards with these these effects trying to have synergies with them maybe get a card that gives you benefits when you go to specific spots on the political track and then get another card that gives you notices when you that make it easier to actually go up that political track or you know that kind of combo or perhaps get lots of cards that give you bonuses for building

tunnels and then try to get an action card out unless you build tunnels more efficiently and that kind of thing now obviously I've just been talking about the action selection mechanism at this point but the game is called underwater cities and what you're doing is each player has a player map in front of themselves and they are building out tunnels on this player mat and these underwater cities that are domed into cities and in each one of these cities you are also going to be building out laboratories desalination plants as well as kelp farms and at three points throughout the game you are going to run your engine and that means everything that is on your player mat in front of yourself is going to give you what it makes some things just make points some things make food some things make science and mental tokens that kind of stuff and this game is really all about building out that engine while you are doing work emplacement actions and trying to do those actions to sync up with the random cards that you have in your hand now you get these cards there couple ways to draw extra cards but in general you just draw card at the end of your turn so you're constantly looking at a handle cards some of which you want to save until later but you have a hand limit of three so it's really hard to do that if you have a bunch of cards you want to use in the future but you don't want to use them right now and you also are conflicted with the action place there might be an action spot you really want to go to but it doesn't match any the colors of the cards in your hand so is it worth it to go there do the action you really need to do and discard a card without getting that benefit or do you do a different action that's slightly less good for you but now you get to do the action of the card and the action spot there and is that worth it to you so all these things work together really well and I have really enjoyed the

process of building out this underwater city in front of me when you actually get to the point where you run your engine it's wonderful just getting all of these different resources and you're like I'm never gonna spend all these and the three turns later you're like I am out of resources and then you do another production phase and you have even more this time because you have built out your engine and even bigger and that is just a very fun aspect to the game now at this point I do want to mention that this game was at one point my best my favorite game of 2018 I think then after playing this game a couple times I told many people and I said I think no underwater cities this is the best game that came out last year I've just absolutely fallen in love with it but obviously I'm not talking about it here at game number 3 now part of that is because the game is number two and one are also really excellent games but a big reason that underwater cities fell down a couple steps for me has to do with player count now this game plays two three and four players and there are two maps on one side of the board you have just two players you flip it over and then that time the board is four three and four four players now this game is brilliant and two players and this game is brilliant at three players the problem is that if you play a four player game you play on that same three player map and the only thing that changes is you add a single tile onto the board that lets you clone an action spot that somebody else else went on to already and that's the only balance for the player camped now when you're playing this game you are going to be taking ten you're going to go through ten to overall rounds in each round you're gonna take three actions so that means every single player is going to take thirty actions which is on the high

side for worker placement games in general and when you add a fourth player in there it's gonna take 30 action so that's just a big chunk of extra time that's gonna get added on to the game but on top of that you have the fact that the board you only added one extra spot with when you're adding an entire another person with our three orchid placement actions so that that means is there's a lot more conflict for the worker placement spaces so you might be building this plan up and then somebody goes down they go on the spot that you needed that means you have to do something else and that's kind of the main crux of worker placement and that's fine but in a four player game your plans are gonna get disrupted way more often because it's just a lot more contention for those different spaces and on top of the fact that you have an extra player in those extra 30 actions the experience that I have seen is that three player games usually take about two hours maybe like two and a half on the long side a two-player game that I played we finished in like an hour and 45 minutes but I have not personally played any four player games but I've heard and I've known people who have that have played like four and a half to five hour games for players and that's just too long I think for this game when you consider the amount of downtime that must have been happening between your turns with these people in fact I've played this game I mean I've talked to people who played this game the first time had four players and they just they're like oh I don't want to Cities that game was horrible it took us five hours I'm like well I can't really say that they're wrong I think that this is one of the best games that came out last year arguably the best the game came out that the game that came out last year but the fact that the four player account just seems so detrimental to the

fundus of this game means I did have to slide it back a little bit at this point unless a really good barring it comes out maybe even designed her approved variant for playing this game at four I don't think I'm ever gonna play it at four like I've had situations where three people really wanted to play it and along with me and I just said I could either teach this to you and I'll do something else or let's just play another four player game that plays really good at four players because underwater cities doesn't at least from my perspective and the people that I play with so I am actively looking forward to playing this game a lot more in the future at three players I think the two players is also amazing and has his own side of the board so it's obviously very well tuned for the two player overall experience and I'm just the process of figuring out all these tactical decisions every single turn of what work a placement to go hard to choose along with that in addition to the overall strategy of the game as you're building out this engine on top of the fact that there are these endgame modifier cards that give you conditional points for doing various different things that you were also trying to keep in mind in addition to the fact that you are working out on your player board that can connect you up to different metropolis is there's just so many wonderful things to think about that this game is just it's just amazing I love it and if there was a good way to play this game at 4:00 then I think it would have easily been the number one game of the year for me but as it stands it's number three which is still really high up there and I'm looking forward to lots more plays at the two and three player account at this point we were getting pretty darn close to the end we now have game number two and this one is key flow now this one came out at Essen last year and it is effectively a new modified version of

key flower and key flower came out many years ago now key flower is a beloved euro game that has a really funky and interesting and very stressful auction mechanic it also has tile laying and work placement and all that kind of stuff going on as you are acquiring different resources in different seasons and trying to turn those resources and the things that are going to give you points now in key flow you have pretty much all of that same key flower stuff except instead of having the auction and instead of having the worker placement and the hidden workers and all that you now have hand drafting kind of like seven wonders so in this case you deal out all the cards for a given season you choose one and then you pass it to the left or the right depending on the season and then everybody simultaneously uses that card to build out their tableau area now it's very blatant that key flow is supposed to be a kind of streamlined and drafting version of key flower it's even in the name I guess you know things flow there's a river that you're kind of building out in front of yourself but it's also key flow is just key flower without an ER at the end of it now as you're actually playing this game let's talk about the mechanics of it a little bit more what you're doing is building out a town in front of yourself and you are gonna move to the right - and to the left or left and right with a camera and you're gonna be building these buildings out as well as a waterfront and what you were trying to do in addition to build out your town in front of yourself is you're gonna play these cards that have workers on them either on your own area to activate your buildings or onto the areas of the opponents your right or your left now if you do

that then you are essentially donating that card with the worker on it to them and at the end of this game once you go through four full seasons you get points for so many different things as you are playing through these seasons there's kind of different vibes like the first season is just about kind of building out your town and maybe getting a couple of different animals that kind of stuff for endgame points the second season thing is ramped up as you get access to boats which gave you conditional which give you ongoing rule-breaking tweaking type things and then when you finally make it over to winter which is the final season there are just tons of cards that you can draft and put into your town that will give you points for doing stuff like extra points for gold gold is normally north one point but maybe you'll have a jeweler now it's worth two points you might put a thing down there that will give you points for a combo of things like for every pig and a tool that you dedicate towards that when you do endgame scoring you get four points there are also lots of cards that will give you points for the different workers that you have accumulated throughout the game and you accumulate the workers that activate in your town again you can send your workers to your opponents but that means you might be giving them cards that will conditionally score off of the winter cards that they end up having over there so what this means is as you were playing this game you are drafting these cards and you're really trying to figure out what the right card is for you in this moment but you also need to look out to your opponents and see am i passing them really good stuff maybe if this is too good for them maybe it's okay for me so I can play that and stop them from taking that but you also need to pay attention to your opponents to your right and your left because you can activate their buildings and maybe they've been upgrading their buildings they can do a whole bunch of cool stuff with them and it's worth it to you to

send a worker over there to activate that and get to the benefits of that really cool building that they've been building out and you're okay with getting rid of that worker because maybe based off of the conditions that you have you're not even going to get points for that anyway so you know you don't have to really worry about it so the tension of this game is really just every single round every single turn trying to figure out what is the right card to play in that right moment are you gonna be able to make up um are you gonna be able to get the cards that will give you the points based off of the conditions that you have in front of you and the very beginning of the game everybody has some of those winter cards that they and one of them they get to auto-draft at the very beginning of winter so you already have an idea of what is gonna be out there and you can have dibs essentially on one of those and game scoring conditions so right from the very big the game you could be working towards that so all these things are really wonderful I think I may be talking about the mechanics of it a little bit too much because well when it comes to the reason why this game is on this list and why it is so high up this list that has to do with the the wonderful decisions that you're making but it also has to do with how incredibly versatile this game is when it comes to play groups now I've played this game four times at this point and it plays up to six players and I think three of those four games have been at six players now it's very rare to find a euro-style game of resource acquisition of engine building of playing off of your opponents that also plays well at five and six players and key flow is so good at these player counts in fact I would argue that it is best at six players because it makes the setup at the start of the game much

simpler if you play with five four three or two if you play with less players than six you have to pull certain cards out and certain other cards so the setup can be a little bit annoying it's not too bad you just really have to pay attention to the setup instructions in the rulebook but playing this game six players man you just deal out all these cards and you just jump right into it and the cards just make sense and every single time I play this game it's never gone over an hour and I felt like it's just been such a wonderfully dense hour of great decisions of you know if I do this and then that it like do I give this to my opponents and just all these wonderful thoughts and I guess when I consider it compared to key flower that game I've only played it once I played a three-player game of that and it took over two hours and we were all new to the game and I understand that's probably why there's so much analysis paralysis and downtime in that play but that game also has auctions where you are bidding with hidden workers behind your screens so you were contemplating what is my worker have what have I seen my worker have in though my opponents have what I see them taking the past and how's that going to apply to my strategy whereas here and key flow you just have the cards in front of yourself and you're trying to figure out which ones to use some of them might come back around to you based off of the player count and I think the fact that you can play it with so many different player counts the fact that it plays in an hour makes it almost a super filler like it's not not really but like there are oftentimes moments in game nights where you'll have like five people or something like that and everyone's like I could play or maybe not then this is like a perfect game for that because it's only gonna be an hour the teach is not very long

either I found you don't have to go through quite a few examples but I found I can teach this game at about 15 minutes which isn't too bad and that just means that it can just get to launch it into so many different moments and that means that this game is likely gonna get to played a lot like this is likely gonna be the end up being the most gay a played game for me of 2018 if I look back on this in a few years that would not surprise me at all in particular of the kind of medium-weight style games you know there are lots of very lightweight games that I could play a lot of like railroad Inc but I do think that key flow is gonna keep hitting the table because it is so versatile it's so fun as well I just really enjoy the process of putting the stuff together and I'm not even very good at this game the last time I played was a 5 player game and I came dead last and I enjoyed every second of it I was putting a thing together and I did a good job of it just my opponents did a better job of putting their things together than I did and so even though I came dead last I really enjoyed it I have yet to win this game I think I came in second once and I'm looking forward to trying this more and trying different strategies based off the cards that come out each time and based off of the different winter cards I see in the very beginning of each round I just think the key flow is a wonderful game honestly it was my number one game for a while and then I ended up thinking about it a little bit more and I ended up downgrading it kind of at the last minute a few days ago I decided to put it into the two slot so that alone tells you a lot about this game being at number two is great and the fact that it was a serious contender from one is also so I think I've talked about this one too much so let's now talk about the final game on this list and that one is Concordia Venus yes that's right to end

expansion to a game that came out two four so years ago is my number one game from 2018 and I don't want that to sound like a slight because this expansion is amazing and honestly Concordia Venus turns Concordia into a completely different gaming experience and that is the reason why I decided that putting it on this list of games made the most sense obviously in general expansions kind of get relegated to other style lists but what Concordia Venus does is it adds partnership play to the game of Concordia now if you're not familiar with Concordia this game came out many years ago and it is a brilliant game it's honestly one of my favorite games anyway so I was already pre supposed to like this expansion but Concordia is a game where you have a hand of cards and on your turn you play one of them down in front of you and then you read what the card does you do what the card says it does and then the next person takes their turn next time you have a turn you have less cards in your hand because that card that you played will stay out in front of yourself and at a certain point you play a specific card in the Tribune to pull all of your cards back and then you can play your cards again now as you are playing Concordia you are able to purchase new cards from a central tableau and you have those right into your hand and that means you are doing hand building as you playing the game trying to get the right actions into your hands that you can do multiple actions within a given round before you have to spend a whole turn resetting everything back up but then one of the most brilliant aspects to this game is the fact that at the bottom of every single card in this game is an endgame victory point multiplier essentially every single card has an action but at the bottom it might say

something like this card in particular that one card is worth one point for every non brick city that you've built throughout this game or maybe this one card over here is worth two points for every colonist that you have at the end of the game so what that means is as you are playing the game you not only want to build your hand out with the cards that have actions that you want but also that have the endgame score multipliers that match up with the stuff that you have done now that is the quick synopsis of how Concordia works but when it comes to Venus you can now play a four player game with two teams of two or you can play a six player game with three teams of two and the way it works now is whenever it is your turn you play a single card from your hand down onto the table you do everything that the card says and then your opponent who is across the table from you gets to do that action as well now the the hitch to this game is that you are not technically allowed to talk with your partner across the table so they don't really know what's coming and that means that as you are playing this game you now not only need to consider what is good for me in this moment what am i building up towards right now but also what is my partner trying to do over there and were they furiously trying to beam over to me with their eyes try to communicate to me what it is they actually want me to do because the best way to play Concordia Venus is to be as efficient as you can where every single turn you you play an action that is best for you and your partner now obviously that means you do that turn and then the next the people who keep taking turns now your partner takes return and you don't even know what they're gonna play and they're gonna put something down and suddenly you're like holy cattle I'm doing an architect action this turn okay let's see what I'm gonna do and hopefully they've decided to do that

because they looked over at your stuff and they decided that you were in a good position to make use of that action now when it comes to the partnership all of your resources are your own however money is shared between you which adds an interesting level of kind of tension between you and your partner because it's easy to sometimes play a little selfishly on accident just be playing Concordia and just like do to do I do this I spend the money to do that and then you're like okay partner you do your turn to and they say you use all the money so they can't really do something because you used all of that communal money and that's important to try and pay attention to that now in of my several plays of this one now I can say that I have never really seen that much actual tension between players it's cropped up once or twice but in general it's just such a fascinating puzzle of playing a game of Concordia but then also playing a mind game of trying to be inside the head of your partner as you're trying to play things well because when the game is over you effectively all score all of your points independently and then you add your points to the points that your partner has and that's gonna be your final score so just getting points for the both of you is fine you don't have to try and bounce things out between you in fact it might make sense to have one person score the vast majority the points compared to the other one based off of how the game state went now when it comes to other aspects to Concordia Venus there are new cards that come out on that card row that are specifically oriented around the partnership basis of in this expansion those cards have two actions on them they might have like a Mercator and an architect and essentially that means the Mercator

means you can buy and sell resources and architect means you can move your colonists and you could build that stuff out on the board so now when you play that card the person who plays it decides do they want to be the Mercator or do they want to be the architect and then their partner across the table does the other thing so now you can set up some really cool combos where it might be a situation where I have this card in my hand I'm not in a great spot to actually architect but my opponent obviously is they want to I might sorry my partner obviously is so I'll play this card down and maybe I will Mercator because we don't have that much money so I will sell some stuff to make money into our communal pool that my partner can then use to actually do the architect action on their turn now things can get even wackier because in your starting hand you have a card that is called the legatus and what this does is it lets you play it down and then you get to look at the cards that your partner has and you suggest one of them for them to play and then to both of you do that card so now you can also kind of play the cards that your partner has and then when you add onto the fact that you have original Concordia type stuff like diplomacy means you can have these bunker situations sorry uh the diplomat lets you copy another card so one time we were playing the game where I put a leg on us down to look at my partner's cards I suggested they play a diplomat they do they ended up copying one of those architects / prefect cards which lets you get resources for whole regions of the zone to then do an architect so now we're getting all of these cards played with these wacky kind of bouncing a round of actions and it just these moments can be so satisfying when they work out really well for you now at this point I do need to mention the length of time it takes to play this game because

I know I talked about it at somewhat significant length about underwater cities now if you are sitting down to play a regular game of Concordia with no expansions from my experience if everybody is familiar with Concordia you could play a five player game of this easily in ninety minutes sometimes even less than that now I have played to six player games of this and won a four player game and in those the first of those six player games every single person was experienced with Concordia and they played the game multiple times and the game took about three and a half hours so that is a huge multiplier that's more than twice as long than that five player game took to play and when that first happened I was like well maybe that's just we're at a convention and we're all new to it so then I played another six player game where all but one person was very familiar with Concordia in fact several of the people in that play had already played Venus the prior time and that game still took over three hours now and the next time I've tried that I played a four player game and that was easily a two and a half hour game so what I'm saying here is that this expansion really makes the game a lot longer I think it makes the game fascinating I think it makes it significantly deeper and I think that there's an argument to be made for me personally where I'm not sure if I'm ever gonna play Concordia without Venus ever again because I have found the decisions to be made to be so fascinating it's just a fresh situation like how many partnership euro games are there out there it's very rare and this pulls it off so well and the fact that it's built on the backbone of Concordia which is a game I love just adds further credence to that I have just been so excited about this game I've talked the ear off many people

about it and that's the reason why it's up here at the number one slot but again do you have to preface this by saying this is gonna be a long game of Concordia like if you're used to Concordia being 90 minutes and you like it being in at 90 minutes then maybe Venus is not necessarily gonna be for you but I can say that from my perspective I've enjoyed essentially every second of those three and a half an hour and two and a half hour games because it is a partnership based game in a six player game you are still taking a turn every third action and in that four player game with two teams of two you're taking an action every other turn so even though the game went long and we were just doing all sorts of stuff now it is true that there can be a decent amount of downtime when particular people are having a really hard time parsing what their partner actually wants but overall just the enjoyment that I've had has been worth it and every time I play this game at least one person at some point while playing has exclaimed holy cow this is amazing like just when it finally clicks like how all of these interactions work and how you play this card down and how they can bounce around and just all of those things to be thinking about it just felt so fresh and it's really won over all of us and I am really looking forward to playing this game again many more times it's likely I'll play Concordia at the regular version at some point in the future but my emphasis is very much on the Venis aspect and I will look for opportunities to play six player games of this because wow did that really work I will look for opportunities to play this at four players even though it might be a two and a half hour game because it's just been such an exceptional fresh and a fascinating new way to play a euro game that I already loved all right we have

now finally reached the end of this list and I hope you have enjoyed it I think it's very likely if you've made it all the way through here and looked at the overall list that I have maybe missed a game that you loved from 2018 if you curious why it's not on here then feel free to comment down below about it I can already kind of imagine some of them that people mentioned one in particular is probably going to be Teotihuacan that one I really liked when I first played it a couple times but as I played it more and more like came just really started to actively frustrate me with the the vast amount of bookkeeping that you had to do and just getting nickeled and dimed when you're trying to pay for cocoa to do a ton of her things I just kind of felt like it had one more track than it really needed I feel like there was one of my favorite games ever inside of Teotihuacan but that was not to the game that was actually in the box and other people love the game and that's fine but for me that was enough to knock it off the list because I'm not actually that interested in playing it anymore pioneer days was a game that I really liked the first time I played it but then when I played it a second time it just I started to see a lot of kind of cracks in the design that I really didn't like and we ended up having a pretty frustrating experience with it so that one fell down pretty quickly crown of Amarra I was very excited about when I played it at Essen last year but after playing it several more times I now think that it is a fine game but it's not as innovative and exciting as I was as it originally seemed to me and there are lots of other games that I considered like Ghanshyam clever and many more that are not directly in my head right now but overall I feel really confident about this list I think that 2018 was a really good year for games I can these are all excellent games on this list and there

are many games that are excellent that are not on this list as well I think that some really innovative neat stuff came out in 2018 especially when it comes to different action selection mechanisms with Scorpius Raider as well as underwater cities with the way you patched up your workers along with the cards and others that I can't think of right now because man my brain is just falling out of my ears I've been talking to for a while so I think at this point we should probably wrap this one up as always I'd like to thank everyone who's been supporting this channel including all of these producer level patreon backers if you two would like to directly support the channel and the creation of videos like this one then please go to John gets games.com slash support to see a variety of ways with which you can do that also if you enjoy this video please click the like button down below as well as the subscribe button for the channel thanks for watching

Progress saved