Top 50 Board Games of All Time 50-41 (2021-2022) Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody and welcome to the first installment of my top 50 board games of all time for the 2021 into 2022 season so this is the definitive list of my favorite games so i was really in two minds this year was i going to do a top 100 or was it just going to do the top 50. i've settled for best of both worlds where i'll do the top 50 in the normal format are you doing 10 games at a time and then as a final blowout i'll do it do by 50 to 100 or sort my 51 to 100 at just one big live stream we can talk about some analysis and what's client what's fallen and the reasons for that so this was a really tough list to do this year because again just some amazing games just didn't make the cut it was really hard to jockey things around just to get it in the right order where i'm happy with it but i'm happy with it now some truly amazing games here and something i say every year is i'm always surprised about how much my least my lists change every year because last year i was very happy with my list of course and i wasn't expecting it to change so much and it really has you know i've got 19 new titles in the top 50 here um that's that's been new to me in the last year so a big change you know almost half the list is new from last year and normally that's a bit more surprising than this year because i've played so many new titles and probably more games or more new games this year than i had in the probably the last three years combined so let's get started with the top 50.
at number 50 i have frenze by andreas steading this was last year's number 30 and it's placed as high as 26 and as low as 30. so this is actually the lowest position it's ever been in at number 50 but i don't like it any less than that than last year and to be honest if any game has fallen it's probably not because i like it any less it's simply because i like some new games more than it so that's going to be a general running theme but anyway forensic is a really interesting game and it actually uses one of my favorite mechanisms in all of board gaming where the more you neglect something the more the incentive to take that is and in that in this case it's going to be these cards which work on this sliding scale and you're basically trying to acquire these cards not only for the powers on those cards which can let you do some really cool things give you some kind of empty build benefits or even some really nasty take that benefits um but also you're taking those cars based on the bricks on those cars because the idea of this game is you're building these towers of different colors and these different colored bricks range in their kind of scarcity you know some of them are really rare which is going to give you more points depending on how high you build those towers and something are a bit more common um but it's simply just take one of these cards um and basically the first one in that row is going to be free but the further you want to go along this row to collect cards further away from you you're gonna have to deposit a brick um to build up the incentive of the ones lower and i really like that system and this is probably one of the best examples of that mechanism being used correctly um a really interesting game very smooth light streamlined and one of the things you know i really take away from this game is yes it can
feel nasty at times so there are some pretty destructive cards here which can pretty much knock your opponent's towels over and stuff but you really do have enough time to see that coming and you know if someone's going to do that to you they've probably paid quite a lot in order to do that so it doesn't really have that idea of just people putting the wool over your eyes and just smashing the card in your face and not having any anticipation for it you know they did have to pay in order to do that for to you so i do think that really does make the game feel a bit more settling for me personally but the game works wonderfully it has this cool racing aspect where you want to be the first to build a certain amount of towers um and you're getting points based on how high those towers are but a wonderful game so different and nothing else like that out there and i'm andrea stelling a really well-rounded designer and do you want us this was one of the games that was on my grail list or my kind of my grail games list for a long long time because it was so hard to get hold of there was a reprinting a couple years ago and you know sometimes when a level of expectation is that high it can be very difficult for a game to live up to that hype and this one certainly did that it's remained on my top 50 since i've had it and um you know just kept on that list this year but who knows maybe if i play it more in the following year then it could boost up again but still an amazing game um a real classic feeling euro that is forensic at number 49 i have citrus now citrus was last year's 38 so it's fallen slightly and last year was its debut on the list this one is another kind of throwback feeling euro i don't think it's tremendously old but it feels it
feels older than what it is but in a good way this is a tile placement game of area majority and area control as you are laying out these tiles of these different colors which are representing these different orchards and with these orchards you're trying to build up these chains to not only surround these fingers which are your kind of um point scoring hubs ready so that the area control things where if you surround them completely whoever's got the majority of orchards surrounding it are going to get the biggest amount of points who have got the second amount is going to get the second or the second amount of points but this game has one of the coolest mechanisms in fact a few cool mechanisms that i really don't see very often first of which is the way you acquire tiles in the first place i love this as you are have this kind of cross-hatching of almost like this matrix and at some point so it's as narrow as two thousand at some points it's as wide as four tiles and you're gonna have to pay a coin for each of those tiles you take on either row or column and as people are taking tiles things are constantly changing so you might think you know i hope you take that row so then i can just take these two pink tiles and not have to worry about taking a tile i don't want and that's really cool in the first place but the way you lay these tiles is also interesting because when you lay a new batch of orchards or these tiles you're going to have to place one of your workers on there to claim that that orchard is yours but you only have i think it's five or six of these workers to place a full stop and you really do want to leave things on the board as much as possible because you can link these fingers together meaning that you can almost kill two bears with one stone with the same worker and you know get loads of points from a
single worker but at the same time you need to make sure you have an income of money and you only really get money by removing workers from the board and putting them onto your player board but the fewer workers you have on your player board means that you get less money for doing so so ideally you want to have a perfect balance of keeping workers on your playable but on the main board as well so that not only can you manage your money but also manage your coverage on the board an extremely clever game one of agonizing decisions scales remarkably well especially for an area control game you know you can play this at two three or four players and it works perfectly fine i might go to five players like i'm not sure but once again this one is it feels classic it feels dateless and um i still absolutely adore this one probably one of the most underrated games i have my collection and i always kind of sing from the rooftops about how great citrus is at number 48 i have my first debutant on the list this is viceroy so viceroy is a really interesting game uh as you are trying to collect these cards with this bidding mechanism so you have these four different currencies or represented by these different colors of these kind of jewels or gems and you are acquiring cards by simultaneously bidding with the other players but you can only have a bid one gem and if you bid the same gem as somebody else you basically wasted that building and you throw that away and gonna go again and but if you go for different um cars then you're gonna acquire these cars you're gonna add them to your hand and then potentially build them to contribute to this big pyramid of cars that you're building throughout the game and these cars do really cool
things depending on the layer that they're built on so on the base layer they're probably going to get weaker abilities but as you start building up and up and up towards that pinnacle then they get more ramped up and stronger abilities but at the same time you've got to be really careful at what you're doing because if you line things up correctly by matching the gem colors on these cards then you almost get free income which obviously keeps you going and keeps you being able to bid and compete for future rounds a really nice flow and tempo to this game very streamlined you know only a couple of phases in this one and i love the vast vast variety of ways you can score points in this one because you can score points based on the level you buy things on you can kind of combine these scrolls and these points together to really wrap up and multiply your scoring you can try and attack other players and they have to get like shields to counteract you or they can end up losing points as well so loads of paths to victory um a bit like citrus as well this one is massively flown under the radar not nearly as popular as it should be i think this one strikes a really great balance between being appealing to more experienced eurogamers as well as being relatively accessible for less experienced games but still having an amazing amount of gameplay there gorgeous artwork great production and i'm really happy and still really enjoying viceroy at number 47 i have power grid so power grid was last year's number 36 so a slight fall from me asked last year but i think a big portion of that is because i don't get to play this game very often because it does require a bit more of a niche group to play it and
it's it can take longer when it comes to the higher play accounts but that doesn't detract from the gameplay experience this is a wonderful economic game about you know building these power stations and trying to power up as many um of these houses as you can all these cities as you can but i love how easily this game is broken down into different phases the first of which is where you're trying to buy these power plants in um in these auctions which is a very simple straightforward auction just call in you know when you want to raise the bid you can do um but these these power stations are really interesting because they all have different criteria on them and they'll require a different type of fuel so some might say you need you need garbage in order to fuel this one and if you pay two garbage then you can fuel up to all these power up to three cities or some might say you know you can play um you know to oil in order to fuel uh five cities and this really does escalate as the game goes on but that really ties into the next phase where you are acquiring the different resources in this really cool supply and demand mechanism so the more and more people compete for the same type of fuel the more expensive it's going to get and only so much replenishes each round so generally the needle is going to go more and more expensive as the game goes on if people keep buying that type of fuel or you can diversify and go to a different type of fuel and therefore get things for cheaper because you're not competing with anybody and from then on you are just basically trying to place these buildings onto the map i'm paying coins or penny playing your currency in order to not only establish
those cities but to connect them to other ones as well there's this real scarcity you want you want to grab the best locations because it's cheaper by getting in there first and one of the best again one of the best economic games out there very mathematical very dry in its approach but that again that doesn't really take away from the fun of the game you can really map things out to the you know to the the amount of precision that you want to because again it's very deterministic you can really calculate things to the smallest degree and when you do that and it pays off it's very satisfying love this game it scales great and um i think it's an absolute classic that is power grid at number 47. at number 46 i have last year's number 31 with luna so this is the first of the stefan feld games on this list so if you regularly watch my content you might know that i'm a big fan of stefan feld so you know spoiler alert there will be more stuff and fail games on the list this one despite him stuff file games generally being quite weird this one is probably one of the weirdest of them all as you are trying to manipulate these acolytes um on these different islands to get these different bonuses with the idea of trying to almost sacrifice them to claim spots on this temple in the middle of the table and all these different temple spots have a number assigned to them and if you place these workers on them or your your colored acolytes on them then you can potentially knock off anybody surrounding that with a lower number than yours so it really does have this kind of almost like domino effect where if you place things you can really affect the game state which can obviously affect
things when it comes to scoring points because you get points based on your coverage of the main temple but on top of all that you've got this dynamic state where you've got this um this priest desk traveling around the map and you want to be having the most acolytes on the spot where the moon priestess is because you get more points for doing so we've also got this apostle which goes around which gives you negative points for having the majority on there so you really have to spin a lot of plates it flows wonderfully it's one of those games where you start the game not being able to do too much but as you really wrap your head around things you can start stringing bigger and bigger moves together and getting more mileage out of your turns very clever but very weird quite a quite cerebral game but i think it's wonderful so yeah one of the best seven file games and um one that doesn't really get talked about too much but still wonderful game that is luna at number 46.
at number 45 i have another new game despite being an older game this one is tigress and euphrates by dr reiner kunitzia so this one is regarded as probably his best game and one of his more grand games in terms of his scope there's quite a lot going on in this one and it's definitely a change of pace from his normal quick card style games this one is quite a confrontational area control style game where you are trying to collect points by not only controlling these cities and adding tiles to the cities of certain colors to boost up your points in that color because you've got four different categories of scoring in this game and are all depicted by a different color but only your lowest value in that in each of those colors at the end is going to be your final score so if i had uh you know five uh black tokens i had five red tokens i had four blue tokens and only two green tokens then my final score is going to be two because two is my lowest but i love this game how the conflicts work as you can sometimes you're joining these cities together and if there's ever a kind of a an imbalance on who's controlling those cities then there's going to be a big blowout and a big battle where you are counting up the tiles in each of those cities and you can potentially contribute more as well for behind your screen and then whoever wins is going to remove an amount of tiles from the from the opponent then you're going to gain that many points a really dynamic game i love the way the board changes all the time new opportunities arise you can claim these temples which keep these um keep points ticking in certain colors the more you control them just a really clever and unique design
that really hasn't been replicated other than its sister game yellow and yanxi which is you know very similar shares a lot of the same dna and you know if tigers and new faces wasn't on this list then yellow and yankee probably would be in its place but i like this one slightly more because i find the combat slightly more intuitive but a wonderful game and i can really see this one climbing um over the next year because i think it's pretty timeless that is tigress and euphrates at number 45. at number 44 i have another new entry with anno 1800 by martin wallace so 2021 was really the year where i started dipping my toe into more economic games and starting to find out you know these games are really my jam and of course martin wallace this is really his his field of expertise but the thing i really take away from anno 1800 is this idea of tech tree building as you start off with being able to manufacture some pretty basic goods but the more and more you invest in types of goods you can start almost spraying out into these different more lavish goods and building more and more distinguished goods to get more and more points and to appease more more demanding customers or more demanding um i suppose settlers in your in your town and it works really well a very logical flow to it you know it's first you might be able to just make wood and then steel and then you might be able to build some fabric and because you could do that you can start building boats and then because you can build boats you can start sailing out into distant lands and start importing more luxury goods or some more exotic goods i should say and i just love this this flow of this game it also again it works so logically
and i love games that work like that and i think martin wallace does a really good job of embedding that kind of feel into the game um this game does have a weird flow and a bit of a weird pace to it as the more and more you build up your population in this game you start to acquire more and more cards so you've got to be careful when you're doing stuff and it sometimes can feel like you're chasing your tail and not getting anywhere but sooner or later there will be that curve where you start getting on top of things and start smashing out these demands of these people and ultimately trigger the end of the game but works so well a really easy rule set to learn and understand but still having a lot of depth in this game loads of paths of victory loads of things to explore and i also like the subtle player interactions you can capitalize on the on your other players town or the other your opponent's towns in order to use their goods and export them in or import them into your town uh really interesting game i think there's some room for improvement here but you know that being said and it's still number 44 i think this one still has room to climb higher in future years so number 44 anno 1800 at number 43 i have hannah makoji so hanover koji has actually climbed this year from number 56 but has placed as high as number 17.
my journey with hanumakoji has been quite a full-on one because this is probably one of my most played games ever i'm definitely my top five most played games ever this one is a very clever very delicately balanced two-player only game as you are trying to acquire these cards to gain the favor of these geisha girls um and if you require a certain amount of girls or get a certain amount of points based on those geisha girls then you're going to be the winner but i love the way you have to manage your hand in this game by using this ice i choose sorry i split you choose mechanism so you might have a hand of say five cards you're gonna pick four of them you're gonna put them in two pairs of two your opponent is gonna take one of those pairs and you're gonna get the remaining one and put them on your side of the table really clever some agonizing decisions that you really do require a bit of a poker face at times you don't want to give away your strategies you want to be clever about which cards you're going to discard from the game because that's one of your actions you also want to be very clever which ones you're going to save until the end of the game for the big reveal at the end because again that very slight mistake in this game can cost you but that one bit of savviness can make you win the game so this game really is a genius design and one way or another this game will always be my top 100 floating around because objectively this game is tremendous i do sometimes go through peaks and valleys of this game because depending on how much i play it you know sometimes if i play too much i might get a bit burnt out and it will fall again but then the incentive to come and play it and the the desire to want to play it climbs again so again this one has time because of that reason i haven't played it too much this year but when i have played it
i've really enjoyed it and i can't really fault with this game it's perfectly designed and one of the best two-player games ever made that is hanumakoji at number 43. at number 42 i have awkward guests now this was actually last year's number 24 so quite a significant fall um and it has placed as highly as 21 but 24 was actually its lowest place that has ever been up to this year but i still love this game it's still my favorite deduction game of all time this one it takes that classic murder mystery feel to it almost like clue cluedo-esque feel but it really does bring it into this era of board gaming using this very intuitive very clever deck building system or this brilliant deck system which you pull out a bunch of cards and somewhere within those cards will be the answer to the murder mystery you're only getting a few cards each round and you're ticking things off in your sheet you know could this person have been in the murder scene otherwise you could these people and give someone else an alibi could they have gone this route you know were they seen by one of the maids could they have passed this way and picked up this weapon and i love this real logical flow and logical puzzle of the games you're taking things off from this blueprint of this building um to to work out who the culprit is and it also has this really cool mechanism of what information am i going to share with my opponents in order to get um information in return because every bit of information has a number assigned to it which almost shows the the important or the pertinence of that bit of evidence so you've got to be careful about what you want to give away to your opponents and hopefully give them stuff
that they already know or give them stuff that you know is not going to really help because you might have already debunked that that alibi so one of the yeah one of the coolest games a great system with infinite replayability and as i said definitely my favorite deduction game and if you love deduction games and you haven't played awkward guests yet you are really doing yourself a disservice because this game is phenomenal so number 42 awkward guests and at number 41 i have babylonia by reina kenitzia which is actually another new entry to this list so this one really does take the dna from a lot of his more classic games such as through the desert uh blue lagoon and samurai but really did tailor it more to my personal tastes in this game you basically have a hand of tiles or tokens with different symbols on them and then all your tone is going to consist of is placing one of those tokens onto the map with the idea of trying to surround these icons trying to build up big networks and chains of these icons in order to score as many points as you can you can also choose to surround these ziggurats in order to score in order to claim unique player powers such as maybe being able to place a number of tiles at once or being able to have more of tokens in your in your immediate supply so that you can have more options and more flexibility or even just getting a big injection of points so i love how streamlined and how smooth this game is next to no rules overhead but loads of depth a real scarcity in getting to the best spots
and that that demand of claiming a spot before your opponent gets there because despite the board looking open at first it does get gobbled up pretty quickly and you really do have to choose when to prioritize doing certain things and you really do want to do everything at once but of course you can't do so um this one really does have the hallmarks of a game that's going to stand the test of time it does feel like an instant classic for me and one that's going to be evergreen for for pretty much ever because it does feel like a game of years past but what a beautiful game this is i adore this one another versatile game that's gonna really appease people who've been in the hobby for a long time and love that strategic depth of a game but still has a very low barrier to entry for anybody to play and to appreciate so adore this game is going from strength to strength that is babylonia at number 41.
so that concludes this installment of my top 50 board games of all time i really hope you've enjoyed the list and have found something on here that maybe you didn't even know about so if you have enjoyed the video please hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other videos too alternatively if you really want to support the channel i do have a patreon account which i'll leave the links below for that one for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye