Top 10 Board Games That Should Have Been MEGA HITS (Vol. 2) - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody and welcome to another chairman of the board top 10 video today I'm going to be talking about my top 10 games that should have been Mega hits so every now and then a game comes out that seems to hit all the sweet spots for a a wide audience as in these games are pretty to look at they are easy to play but still have some good strategic and tactical decisions um and just have that engagement factor that keeps you coming back uh for more for some reason these games seem to have slipped under the radar and didn't quite hit that Pinnacle of popularity um or success despite me thinking they have all those Hallmarks of I'm being a game capable of doing that now before I get started on these 11 games because I do want to give one game an honorable mention um I want to give a shout out to the show sponsor ker.com who are my go-to online retailer and if you use the link in the show notes or the QR code code then you can get 5% off your first order okay so before I get started on the 10 games I wanted to give a mention to my number 11 which is ohanami so ohanami is a small box card game where you are trying to create three columns of cards which will score you points but each of these cards have a unique number on them and whenever you're drafting these cards through a simple pass and draft system you can only place these cards higher than your highest card or lower than
your lowest card meaning that as the game progresses your restrictions or your options get squeezed and squeezed and potentially you not be able be able to draft a card um at all and I like the fact that these cards score in different ways so for example some cars which are worth fewer points will score every single round some will score only the second and third round and some will score only the final third round but there's also some points some cars that will score points based on a sliding scale and it's about trying to optimize these but bearing in mind that you are restricted to what you can play so you do always want to keep your options open so that you can keep on playing and keep on placing cards and it becomes so frustrating but in a good way when you end up being forced to take a card and creating a huge gap that you know you will not be able to fill in later just an absolute blast to play and placing around 15 minutes and for me this one should be one of those quintessential um small boox card games that every G should have in their collection I'm talking about games like um like no thanks or games like six n this one for me should be up there with those a brilliant game as ohanami my honorable mention at number 11 okay so let's get into the bulk of the list here and at number 10 I have District Noir now this is a small box two-player only game it's actually a retheming of an older game called throne and Grail it was an Asian design but this one has this kind of
more of a gangster theme to it um and I love the mechanisms in this game as you're trying to collect sets of cards but on your turn all you're going to do is you're going to add a new card to this Row in between you and your opponent or you are going to take the last five cards in that row and these cards range from the sets you're trying to collect for points they can just be simply pure points at face value they can be negative points or they can even be these kind of um sudden death style cards where if you collect three of those you will instantly win the game and I love the way that you are forced to either play a card or take that or take those five cards but as soon as you've taken those five cards you're going to be forced to play the rest of your cards in your hand which could just lay you know lay points at the feet of your opponents it's all about knowing when to strike when the iron is hot you can use a bit of bluffing here by you know luring some good cards down there um and then smashing down some negative cards so your opponent are forced to take those those um and of course the your opponent is trying to do the same thing to you um a lot of game in only say 20 minutes to play this one and for me this is up there with the two player great know your Lost Cities at games like that this one is as good it's fast it's punchy the decisions are quite you know agonizing at times and it's just a fantastic design so that is District Noir at number 10 at number nine I have re so this is actually a Wolf Gang Kramer and Michael keing co-design
they've made some you know colossal hits in terms of board games this one is an area control game that actually uses a domino mechanism in order to you know increase your coverage on the board you have a very nice looking board and these lovely kind of wooden dominoes that you going to be placing onto the board and whenever you place one of these dominoes you can choose to um you know increase your influence in the adjacent regions by putting these bushes down there and yeah the bigger the region the more points you're going to get essentially there's a few extra little wrinkles where if you are say tying for a region it will go down to the next player so you can use some blocking going on there and you know to be honest um subjectively this game was a little bit too light for me but I can turn on my objective head and think you know what this game um hits so many marks that are are you know generally Hallmarks of popular games you know it's it's very pretty to look at it has um those nice components it has good decisions it has a simple core mechanism of that Domino placement but a few extra wrinkles in terms of those little twists and it's all just a lovely package plays in around 45 minutes um and it can get pretty damn nasty as well if you want to um know engage in that style of gameplay so yeah this one is definitely um a wolfin sheep's clothing but this game in itself is such a pure and clean design that um I think should have blown up to you know know popularity as those kind of more popular nature themed games you
you're talking your wing wingspans and things like that this one I think is a better game than wingspan yet it didn't quite reach that level of popularity and I think it should have done so that is renat at number nine at number eight I have pergamon so pergamon might be a little bit of an anomaly on this list because I did say they're generally or these games should be very attractive to look at or have that mass Market appeal I think this game kind of did its own legs by making it look a little bit Bland from the uh the box cover alone because the gameplay here is got it should be so more widely played but again the box art is a little bit misleading and it makes it look like a a stuffy boring style game when that is simply not the case so this is somewhat of a bidding Style game with some set collection as you trying to collect uh these artifacts and string them together to get kind of um big displays exhibits of these items and display them in order to get points but what I really love about the game is the bidding mechanism here it's so distinct and unique unlike anything else I've seen before where each round there's going to be um kind of a an undetermined but you can make a pretty fairly accurate guesstimate of what is going to be in these bags of money and you you kind get these chests or these money bags and you are going to be placing your meeple on this track saying how much money you want from those bags do you want to go early and not get many coins but guarantee
yourself an early um spot in terms of turn order um or do you want to go later try and be greedy and get tons of money except that you'll go later in the um in the turn order but perhaps that all the money will be taken by the other players by the time it gets to you so I do love that speculation know do I want to you reserve myself an early place in the turn order because all the artifacts I might I want might be taken by the time it gets to me yeah I could be flush with coins but there could be nothing for there there for me to buy or of course the vice versa of that it's only about 45 minutes I think the game itself is very attractive You know despite the um off-putting box art and for me this is that perfect entrylevel Euro that are always you know widely popular um and it has that unique mechanism as well you know how many games nowadays have unique mechanisms pergamon has a completely unique mechanism I've never seen before you know I've played hundreds of Euro games I've never seen this mechanism and I think it's an outstanding mechanism that holds its own and could differentiate itself from the pack of you know hundreds of similar style games but you yet to have that that magical ingredient I think this game has that magical ingredient and is an absolute joy to play it's a lovely game and um one that is criminally um kind of overlooked and it shouldn't be because it is a solid design accessible know not overwhelming um but still has enough going on to keep you interested so that is pergamon at number eight at number
seven I have hoba so hoba is another area control game but this one uses the foundation of Sudoku as a mechanism uh wonderfully elegant where all you're doing on your turn is you're deploying these little Stones onto this grid and trying to control these different regions each Stone has a different number on it the higher the number the more the influence and more like that you control a region um but the lower numbers are useful because if you deploy them next to these kind of COI pons then you can potentially get these koi tokens and double the points of another region and I love this idea or this restriction as as I said with the sidoku thing going on where you cannot place the same number token in the same row or column as an existing token or even in the same region as an existing token of that number so you are always squeezed down on what you can do and you have to optimally place all your different markers knowing when to balance the high influence with the low influence plays in around 20 minutes lots of decision space here um again almost zero rules blow at all I mean there's no exceptions to the rules is simply just topl those tokens onto the map but the decision space is there you know you do have to make those meaningful uh decisions um Elegance personified in my opinion and I have no idea why this one didn't take off it looks it looks distinguished it's a sophisticated game um easy to play I've never had a bad game of this one but
even more seasoned gamers are going to get a lot from this because as I said there are meaningful decisions to be made from the get-go so that is hoba at number seven at number six I have the buunk so the buunk is a betting and bluffing Style game that does tailor more towards those higher player counts you know you want at least four players to play this one one but it's nice to have a game with a bit more meat on the bones than your traditional party style games when you are looking at that five or six players that you have around the table this one the objective is to get as much money as you can by taking money through these kind of gambling tables that are put in this big Rondell each round there's going to be more money being put into the fold and placed on these tables and I love this system of each round you have a number of these cards that you're going to be assigning to particular tables and these cards can be like double cars that will really increase the value of that cash there could be things such as traps so that if other people land on those tables you will get the money instead of them and even a bluff car that you can of course use to distract and misguide uh your opponents um a wonderful game that actually has that huge fun Factor it has that Real Las Vegas um feel to it um huge Stakes at times you even if you're falling behind you can you've always got that potential for a big score and get get lots of money get right back into the mix and I think this is actually one of the best games in terms of having a catchup mechanism that um that is just seamless because if you are winning as
in you have the most money you start moving your porn first so you are drip feeding more information to the other players and maybe letting them know where you're deploying your cards just uh again it blows my mind how this game isn't more popular because this is a game that almost anybody can play it has that mass Market feel to it but it still has some gaminess um again laugh out loud moments high stake moments high pressure and it's just an absolute joy to play so that is the bunk at number six at number five I have cursed court now this is actually another betting and bluffing uh Style game but this one uses a little bit more deduction um as each round you are given these cards that you are going to be sharing that information with your opponent so only you and your neighbors are going to know a particular card type so for example me and the players to my right will know a card me and the players to my left will know a card but nobody else will see those particular cards and as the game progresses you are going to be deploying your little wagering chips on the main board to guess which characters are currently in the mix because there's going to be quite a substantial amount that are not in the mix so for example you might say well the king I've seen two of those so I'm going to wager quite heavily on the king and hopefully get a lot of points that way maybe I'm going to bet on the top row of characters or maybe the um the middle column or maybe I diagonal because I seen all those but what I love about this is the way that you can misdirect your opponents because again everybody only has a small piece of the puzzle and if you say bet on a
character that you know isn't in the mix and people might think well they know something I don't therefore I'm going to use my tokens to outbid those each time you outbid somebody you have to bid at least double the amount so you're going to quickly go through your wagering tokens but that character could have never been there in the first place therefore you've tripped your opponents into betting on something that never existed which is always um you know a laugh out loud uh moment uh very simple when it's designed very clean and um you know straightforward but the decisions are there you know how are you going to pace yourself when are you going to go all in on something are you going to spread your bets a bit more evenly are you going to take that punt and Gamble and bet on something that might come out later but not out yet yeah just an absolute Joy um to play again another game you probably want at least four people to get the most from you it does work okay at three but at that four five or six player count it is a you know a fantastic U game um and I think one of the biggest things for me about this game is that I I really do um you know wreck my brain of why this game wasn't a hit because all they needed to do with this game is to repackage it in a number of different IPS you know you could make this a Pokémon theme you could make this Harry Potter you could make it Marvel Lord of the Rings whatever it doesn't matter there's no theme in it anyway but the artwork is going to sell this one because all those different characters are just particular characters just because they are so for me there is a lot of money being left on the table with this one um I think this one could be you know a game that could be in so many people's collection even non-
Gamers could get a lot from this game um because again it's so so clean and you know the rules don't get in the way of this game it's all about wagering and trying to know take those risks and those choices um great game again very much flew under the radar it's quite a few years old now I think this about 7 years old and yet it has not found its place in the board game Space so that is cursed caught at number five at number four I have thinker so thinker is an entrylevel euro Style game that uses the Rondell mechanism where you're going to be moving your porns around these different kind of um different sections or segments on this wheel and wherever you land is going to be the amount of fruit that you will take but there are little things within that wheel that are interesting because depending on the amount of characters on the the wheel you just left is the amount of space that you move and on the space you land on is the amount of fruit that you get or the quantity of fruit that you get so if there's four people on this orange space then I'll get four oranges and what you're trying to do is you're collecting these resources or these fruits and cash them in against these different contracts on this um on this board trying to get as many points as you can collecting sets and so on but there are wrinkles in this game for example you need to go around that rondale set amount of times before you can get these donkey tokens do cash them in in the first place otherwise you will not have that option but my favorite twist in this game is that if you end up stockpiling too much fruit if say
somebody takes enough fruit some some more of that type of fruit and there's no more in the General Supply then all of that fruit is going to go back into the General Supply and go to waste if you've hoarded it and then start being distributed from there so you cannot be too greedy uh in this one or you're going to certainly be at the risk of wasting all of your effort and there's an additional twist as well where as you start cashing in um all these resources and burning through these contract tokens or tiles then there's going to be one remaining tile uh on each of those regions and if you have the majority of that particular fruit type you'll get some bonus points so timing really does come into play here as you want to be depleting these Stacks when they suit you and not the other players otherwise you'll be just giving them points um for me this again is so accessible it's so playable those few twists make it interesting it's bright it's colorful it's lovely to look at very family friendly a Gateway level game but not boring you know you're not going to get tired of this within a few plays it's going to keep you coming back and um it's just yeah a lovely lovely game and I cannot understand why this one didn't blow up so um maybe it'll get a reprint maybe it will get kind of um released to a wider audience and more people will know about it but as it stands I have no idea why this didn't take off a because it's so Superior to a lot of those other kind of widely regarded Gateway style Resource Management games so that is thinker at number four at number three I have first
rat so first rat really is a hybrid style game because it's like a Euro game with some Resource Management you have some engine building you have a race Factor um so lots of things going on here but it all condenses down to one of the most simple mechanisms you could imagine which is almost like a roller move but not quite where you can simply move your rat a certain amount of spaces you know I think you can move one rat up to five spaces up this track or you can move several rats I think I believe two or three spaces and depending on where you land you'll start collecting resources you can collect the or trade those resources in to contribute towards the spaceship and get points that way um but I love there's I love that there's additional things going on here so for example you can reach these certain checkpoints and go back to the beginning of the track and get like um permanent abilities to maybe take shortcuts or um you know get gamebreaking abilities by being able to share spots with other people or things like that additionally um you can climb up the separate track and start increasing the yield of resources you'll get when you land on those particular spots and everything in this game has a sense of urgency to it you know you want to be the first to reach the top of the track because you get a ton of points you be you want to be the first to contribute to those different spaceships to get ton of points to donate cheese um you to be the first to do everything really even like there's some public objectives and things it's all just um it's all just so well hard kind of harmonized despite there being quite a lot going on you know I found this I
find this game remarkably easy to teach but when you really break it down into the SE separate kind of compartments of this game there's quite a lot going on here and for me it really does work walk that perfect tight rout between being accessible but Euro tactical yet a little bit strategic IC constant decisions to be made when to sacrifice one thing to do another again what to prioritize at any time it looks great and you has a Charming appeal to it which which younger audience will like and more Gateway fans will like but it still has enough going on to appease more experienced Gamers so for me this one has such a wide audience I mean so many people could enjoy this one and um I think it is a wonderful wonderful design I know people who like or who know about this game tend to be really big fans of it but that audience is small at the moment and I think it could be way way bigger and it should be bigger because it is that good of a game so that is first rant at number three at number two I have Vikings so Vikings is a Michael keying design who has made so many colossal hits you know aul being uh one of them this one is a tile placement game with a bit of drafting as you are drafting these tiles and these Viking meols hand in hand and putting them on your own little kind of scoring board now you are trying to create these little Islands um and each of these different Islands Go in different rows and have a particular Viking type
assigned to it so for example uh you might have these yellow Vikings which will generate you income when it comes to the income phase or some of them will just simply get you points some of them will feed your workers because at the end of the game everybody needs to be fed some of them will repel off these threats that come and invade and so on it's all about kind of spinning as many plates make sure you've got a constant income to keep on buying the Vikings and tiles that you want as well as fighting off those threats as well as you know being able to feed your workers and of course get points uh in the first place the drafting system in this game is quite interesting because the the prices of everything varies depending on what what it's taken and when so for example if there's a really cheap item on there you might buy that cheap item the wheel will then rotate and make all the more expensive items cheaper from that point and you even get rewarded by spending a lot of money and going for the expensive items right out of the gate so there's always an incentive to do everything in this game um this one is like it is a Step Beyond games like carcasson but not that far beyond yet the decision space is so much richer um and there's so many things you need to consider here with with this remarkably um elegant and playable game um they it bridges that gap between kind of um a hobby game and a Gateway level game there's enough to stick your teeth into yet it's very playable and easy to um you know easy to latch onto and get involved in from the get-go so for me this one is like one of
the first games I thought about when I thought about making uh this list because it hits so many checkpoints and again when I think about games like you know everel and your carcasson and your wingspans and these styles of um you know hugely successful games I think they're all inferior to Vikings a and yet they all kind of go for that same demographic so I have no idea why some latch on and some don't um has a little bit of a mature look to it has that more traditional Euro aesthetic but I don't think it's an unattractive game and maybe even with a fresh lick of paint um this one could you know go above and beyond and it all it takes is that that word of mouth to start spreading and this game could have been you know as big as those aforementioned games so that is Vikings at number two and finally at number one I have Caesar's Empire now this is a root building and set collection style game um set in the asterisk and Obelix Universe um where you are going to be placing these Legions out from Rome and of reaching new locations on the map and when you reach a new location you're going to collect a couple of um tokens which are going to score you points based on set collection so different types of these tokens you collect they going to score you a ton of points but you're also going to get rewarded by collecting duplicates of you know of the same type but what I really love about this game is this subsequent scoring mechanism where after you've collected your tokens you are going to trace the route back from that location all the
way back to Rome and for every Legion that you've passed through that player is going to generate a point so whether that be all of your own units or other players units you you know they will generate points so even when it's not your turn you are invested because you will passively start generating points as you kind of piggy back of other players and so on this is almost like a filler game really because it's you can play in around 30 minutes you know despite being a big box and a big board and tons of these kind of lovely plastic Legion components it's so Punchy it's so Snappy and every turn is Meaningful there's different approaches you can go for do you want to focus on those roots do you want to focus on the sets um and so on it's it's just uh yeah know such a pure design and for me this completely blows games like ticket to ride out of the out of the water um it's cleaner yet it's still more engaging the decisions are a bit more meaningful in my in my opinion um and it's much much faster too so really I don't see any negative this game has I think it's um deceptively involved you know I think maybe at first appearances this one might seem like a a very Gateway level you know throwaway Style game um and if you want to go in that mindset that might be what you get from it but if you start understanding the nuances and the different things you can explore here what to prioritize at any time I think the return on investment with this game is off off the charts and this is like a a never going to go from my collection I think this is
kind of the Hallmark of what I like you know almost no rules tons of decision space everything matters um different approaches um set collection done right and rewarding turns passive player into reaction without being nasty but still being you know a little bit um you know a little bit mean at times but not in a bad way um and yeah just an absolute Triumph of a design that just somehow never really took off and never had the wind um under its CS when I certainly believe uh it should have so that is Caesar's Empire at number one so there we have it that concludes the list hopefully you have enjoyed this video and discovered a game or two that you were not aware of if you have enjoyed the video please be sure to hit like And subscribe uh to the channel and check out my other content too and for everybody else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye-bye