Skip to main content
Loading video...

Arkham Horror (1987) - Where the Madness Began

Transcript 2:20:35

hey everybody welcome back to the dungeon dive Daniel here I hope you're doing well and if you're not I hope you are soon okay and welcome to the first episode of the Arkham Horror retrospective in this series we will be taking a detailed look at the Arkham Horror family of board games now I'm calling this the Arkham Horror retrospective and not the Arkham files retrospective mainly because it will not be entirely comprehensive I won't be devoting a lot of time to the living card game nor Mansions of Madness first edition so this first episode here is called where the madness began and in this episode we are taking a look at the Genesis of all of this awesome stuff so we have a interview with Richard lonus who of course is the creator of Aram horror uh the first edition fantastic interview he was such a fun guy to talk to I can't wait to talk to him again I want to get him back on the channel and yeah I just I really really enjoy talking to Richard lonus uh we will also be doing a brief primer history of cthulu Mythos fiction uh looking at different authors and kind of putting together a timeline and we will end this episode with a look at and review of archam horror first edition the original from from

chaosium the next part of this series will feature a deep dive into Arkham Horror's second edition and uh that part will be around nine episodes along we will have one episode for the base game and then one episode for each of the expansions with four small and four large expansions uh inclusive um after that we will move on to Elder Sign eldrich horror Mansions of Madness second edition and Arkham Horror Third Edition um spoiler alert I love all of these games that I'm going to be covering all of them they all have something unique to offer I am so happy to have them all in my collections I it's hard for me to say I prefer one over the other you know I rank Arkham Horus second edition the highest but I really do love them all and I really I don't have any time for that kind of um addition Wars that people seem to enjoy so let's try to avoid that and recognize that there are some great things in all of these games um along with the games we will also be discussing in pretty great detail cthulu Mythos fiction because if it wasn't for all of these amazing stories written by all of these uh great authors we really wouldn't have any of these games um in this series it is my desire to present a comprehensive reading list by the end of the series

for an example the episodes devoted to Arkham Horror second edition will be featuring we will take a look at I will make a recommendation for a story about each of the great old ones and I think that'll be really really interesting of course we will have to do something a little different when we cover the small box expansions for second edition because uh those didn't come with any new great old ones so for those maybe we'll do some fun things like maybe some rankings of some of the investigators I want to do my top five favorite locations in Arkham and at some point a top 10 Mythos movies list I think that would be a lot of fun as well so these episodes will come out about twice per month and the entire series is probably going to take uh a year at least to complete I imagine maybe maybe a little bit shorter but probably right around the year right around the year there is a lot of reading to be done in between each episode and I'm a pretty slow reader so that's why I'm kind of spacing these out but hey now let's get to the interview uh I'll see you in about an hour and some change and then we'll start talking about some books hey everybody welcome back to the dungeon dive uh Daniel here I hope you're doing well and if you're not I hope you are soon and uh today I am very happy to be joined by Richard lonus uh the designer of games like Defenders Of The Last Stand Defenders of the realm uh Alien Uprising and the uh

topic of today's discussion Arkham Horror uh Richard uh thank you so much for coming on to the dungeon dive how are you doing I'm doing great thanks for having me on and uh thank everybody for listening yeah so um I did something a little crazy in the last month I did track down a copy of the original uh I felt it was kind of like my my responsibility there you go to finally own the original um I never played the original when it came out my my kind of original uh game for Adventure Gaming was Talisman when I was all right I remember so yep so um I'm calling this episode where the madness began and we're going to take our viewers all the way back in time to kind of pre-1987 so G give us a little bit of a of a snapshot of that time how did you approach a game like Arkham Horror with being Co-op being soloable because those things weren't they weren't as prevalent then as they are today yeah it's a first of all it's an interesting time you go back into into the uh late 70s early 80s there were not a lot of games come out you mentioned Talisman I remember the day Talisman came out and it came out along with I think the mummy or something like that both of them from curse of the mummy's Tomb curse of the Mummy tomb and and I remember seeing those on the shelf and going wow you know two two games coming out you know uh you know in themes that

that that I'm interested in because the majority of games that came out were war games uh coming from Avalon Hill or SPI uh and and they made great games but uh you know I was one who wanted different types of games so that kind of sets the setting that they're just wasn't a big variety of games at that time role playing was taking off getting stronger most of it was DND d uh kak cthulu had come out from Sandy Peterson which is you know just a brilliant piece of work by him uh and uh you know the first I remember going into the little game store I lived in in Eastern Tennessee at the time and lived in the tri states there so I had to drive to Johnson City to go to a game store we didn't have one in Bristol and you know it was one of these typical small stores with a few shelves it had some role playing it had some comic books it had you know had a few box games uh and some models things like that not much else maybe a few Miniatures but there wasn't a lot of Miniatures even at that time and I remember when I walked in he said I think I've got a game you're going to love and he handed me the box set of kak athula and I said well if you think I'm gonna love it I'm gonna try it and I tried it and I really really just love the whole theme area of it was it like a so this is the reproduction here this is the the anniversary edition yeah a thinner box like that it was a thinner box like that but yes that's that's exactly it and uh so took it started playing that really enjoyed it within about six months we transferred to to Upstate New York Rochester New York and

I didn't really have when we got up there we had uh two small children and uh so my wife worked ER so she worked in the night times I worked in the day times I was with the Yellow Page company uh you know subsidiary of AT&T and uh you know I would come home she would leave you know I would take care of the kids get them in bed so like from 8:00 on I had nothing to do okay keep in mind there wasn't L there wasn't computer games back then was there wasn't anything else so so I I said you know I I'm gonna design col Cula so I can play it as a board game that was just my idea I'm gonna make a game I can play by myself or I could play with others but it's going to be a game that does not require anybody else to be PR and I just started drawing the board out uh started coming up with you know different Adventures from you know I I I'd look sometimes I look into to to call cthul and say okay well that was fun they went to that church and this thing happened or whatever uh you know read some Lovecraft picked up a few things there but but in the end I was just making an adventure game and that's how I viewed yeah and uh so so uh I put that whole thing together everything was hand typed okay uh everything was hand typed and and uh uh and hand drawn either either I found a copy of it managed to get a Xerox copy of it somehow or I drew or I drew it in fact I'm ashamed to say that some of those items in in that original game you picked up like they're like the 45 is

just my little hand drawing of it okay that's your that's your original that that's your sketch yeah I was kind of embarrassed when I said oh my God they didn't even redo this they just put it on here okay um and uh uh so so I I made the game started playing it I'd met some friends by now that that that like gaming uh especially some of younger teenage boys and they would come over and we would play it and they would always like to play it and they people begin to tell me well you know you need to get this published okay now um I had done a few things with chaosium before I you know they oh they had done different worlds magazine and I'd actually written talk through the scenario for them in different worlds uh was that was that as a was that as a fan capacity or were you hired were you paid to do that not paid just just s it and said hey I put this together if you guys want it uh you know publish it and uh and they they did and and so so I I I didn't really have a relationship with them but I had a contact so so I sent the game off I finally said okay I'll send the game off and I'll be honest with you I I didn't want to okay now that was your only that now that I want to make sure that people realize this you sent your your copy one copy of the game yes you had done all this work and you sent that out through the US Postal Service and and you sign a docu you know they have documents you can get online to say okay you can submit things to us but we're not required to return them so I I I was okay well you know if I send it off to

him it's probably the end of it you know yeah I mean I I didn't know so I sent it off and uh about six months went by and I can vividly remember it I was out on the kids swing set my kids had this Sesame Street swing set that's how I can remember it so much they had like a big bird swing on it and a you know a Cookie Monster slide and all this kind of stuff and I was out watching them on it and my wife says Uh there's a guy named Greg Stafford on the phone who wants to talk to you and I'm like I don't know who Greg Stafford is she said well he wants to talk to you okay so I went in it was long long distance back then you know long distance cost money not like today okay so I get on the phone and Greg Stafford's on the phone he introduced he said I'm I'm you know I'm the president of of chaosium he said and I I suppose you know that we love your game and I'm like no I no no idea how would you know are you psychic yeah so he he basically told me that really you know they're having trouble getting the play testers to move off it and go play the different role playing stuff because they want to come in and just keep playing the game and and part of the secret of that was in my original design there was no shutting the gates to win to win the game you played as long as you wanted to play you just scored hero hero points okay and you would say we're going to play for two hours or those hero points wins or we're going to play you know today tomorrow the next day and the next day and we just keep going okay and that's kind of what they were doing uh so so uh you know uh signed a contract with them

to publish it uh went to they invited me uh when we had a prototype of it to go to Origins first time I ever gone to Origins it was Baltimore it was huge back then uh Jin con I don't even know if J con existed but if it existed it was in no competition small I think yeah at that time yeah yeah and so I went and ran demos the whole time I was there you know met uh the various people in in their crew including uh include including Sandy Peterson who was doing a lot of C cthulu stuff with him and uh you know was constantly I guess surprised and then not surprised about how much people loved coming and playing this game that we were demoing okay because it's not a short game okay and then we okay the the demo is kind of up now well I want to keep playing well if we don't have anybody we can okay so we'll just keep playing it and uh so yeah so that's that's kind of the origin of of Arkham Horror so where did the idea of the gates come from okay now the gates was yeah yeah I vividly remember if you look on the very front of the Box you're gonna see Lyn Willis's name and Charlie trank's name Y and uh those guys added the gates okay okay uh that basically what they said you know uh was it has to have an ending we have to put an ending in the game so they're like let's let's have you know let's put uh a way that we l and let's put a away that we win in okay and of course keep in mind you know I

played it a lot before I sent it to them but they played it a ton once they got it so they were able to to Really develop the game okay and I I didn't know a lot about developing games back then that that's that's kind of my very first one so they knew a lot about developing games so so they they brought that that to the game which um obviously he's become an iconic part of the game afterwards so uh so they deserve their names absolutely deserve their names on the front of that box so you know yeah I was thinking about the concept of the gates uh I'm right now I'm rereading Brian lumley's myth cthulu Mythos books his Titus Crow books and and he specifically mentions a gate opening in England near hadron wall and needing to close the gate so things don't come through and I was like man is that that might be one of the first times I I've encountered a gate in a piece of myth of Mythos fiction and so that kind of made me uh wonder about I wonder where the gate you got you've also got it it's not called a gate well there are places that is called a gate in love crft riding but obviously you know a search for unknown kadath okay he travels through the clock okay which is clearly a g one of the gates to the dreamlands you can get there by Dreaming or you can get there by passing through this gate and when he's on the white ship and he sails to the edge of the Earth there's a gate there you don't know exactly where it goes you believe it goes into the abyss or or whatever but so you know and and there's going to be some love crap people out there say no Richard you have that wrong whatever okay that's what I got out okay and and so uh so so basically there there was some mention

of it but uh it it it obviously we've did now I had people going through Gates I mean that they there were Gates that opened you went through them you had encounters you came back you closed the gates that was already in the game uh it just didn't drive the game toward a Finish Line I see ah interesting so you kind of saw your game as being a way to play Call of cthulu solo um the D the dungeon dive here we are all about solo uh we love solo gaming and uh the you know there's a lot of solo RPGs now there's quite a bit of difference between the mechanisms that you used in Arkham Horror and and the mechanisms that were already established in the call of cthulu RPG why did why did you move from a D100 system to a D6 system with Arkham Horror okay well there there there's two or three different things first of all I I really moved to a totally different game if you think about it uh the the the system of Encounters in role playing uh going insane fighting using you know combinations of dice and all these different things really lends itself uh to what I would call the mental exercise of role playing which is why role playing is so exciting you can do whatever you want to do uh when I when I designed Arkham Horror and really for every design after that I I create a world that's limited to to the you know whatever size I draw the box to all right so you're gonna you I'm gonna give you a lot of opportunity to do different

things but I'm going to restrict you down to this particular level uh so part of it is I like to simplify the process part of it is that that I believe a board game experience was different than a role playing experience I do believe I and there's been people say that Arkham Horror is one of the truly first straight Co-op board games and and I I I think I think it definitely is uh I don't know if it's the first but it's among the first it's certainly in the top five I think uh but I think there's a lot of things that come out of it that influence everything else and and and for example the heroic aspect of the character okay uh is much different than the heroic aspect of the character in in kak cthulu in kak cthulu when you play a campaign at the end of that campaign if you played with four characters you are going to have somebody who died maybe a few people who died you're G to have some that have gone insane you're you you're you're you're going to face this truly horrific thing at the end that's going to really tax whatever abilities you have left uh I bring some of that in into Arkham Horror but I basically made it so so that you can play it as almost like a a a TV hero you know P it's a more of a pul hero type of thing you have a better chance you have a better chance of not going insane you have a better chance of not dying you have a better chance of overcoming uh my Arkham wh and there are people who told me you know you not really love crafting because my Arkham hor actually has more hope there's a problem going on but you actually

believe and and can defeat it and and I I would agree with them than that so I I I well yeah I agree with that but I also think that Lovecraft doesn't really hold he doesn't control the Mythos that's what's great about it is it was open up to all kinds of different interpretations and ab absolutely have different ideas he had he had his version of it which was very dark for the most part unless you unless you take the the the dreamlands as a as kind of a separate Cannon uh that his is all very dark except for that uh whereas what I've done in Arkham hor even more so than what they've done in in kathula I think I think is is make it more of a pulp hero type type of thing where you're working together with other pulp Heroes yeah now were there people at chaosium who were in charge of their cthulu Mythos Bible and did they kind of apply their idea of the Mythos to Arkham Horror to get it kind of in line with what they were doing at all I would say no but I don't actually know uh you know I mean Sandy Peterson wrote wrote the the the you know cthulu there was a couple other people who did stories but that was basically it it wasn't really CRA as far as I know it wasn't really crafted out to a whole bunch of people doing different things but a here's how we're going to stay you know we've created these creatures uh here's the book in the base game that shows you all the creatures and show they give you a broad range of creatures then they do a companion where they give you more creatures so so if if there's

anybody it was in fact Sandy Peterson but no they didn't really apply that and bring it over the game that came out was pretty close to the game that I sent them okay okay uh with the exception of changing the end uh they did create listen I think they created Monteray Jack yeah they created Monteray Jack they wanted they wanted that kind of character in there I didn't have I didn't have Monteray Jack in the game uh my first character that I created was uh was Joe Diamond uh the character that I wanted to play and and kind of character I always played when I did play K Cula and the second character I created was Jenny Barnes so those were the first two iconic iconic characters that that I created for the game so I love so uh reading in like the the the little setup story in first edition is so great how uh the investigators arrived to Arkham after already having tackled some great conflict and they go to Arkham to relax right right that's humor I think so I love that I love that that was really cool and so there's and that part that part was written by [ __ ] at the time they they they I learned a lot from them they were obviously roleplaying Riders so they they you know I did a kind of Welcome to Arkham thing but they they definitely expanded that and and buil on to it and then yeah so you created Joe Diamond Jenny Barnes all of these great characters that are still being played today that must feel pretty awesome but

I was a little surprised at there are no really backstories to the characters in first edition did you have backstories in mind to these characters did did you have things written out or what what I had name or what well names yes I mean for example you know uh uh you know Carolyn Fern my my wife's name is Carolyn and my mother name was Fern so I just took those two names and I and I wanted to create you know uh in that I I looked at iconic roles okay we needed doctor uh we need you know we we we need a psychologist we need so I so I created I created the names of people that I thought okay this name goes with that that archetype character I think so that's how I went about doing it uh uh and a lot of the names were different people I knew I would take their first name or their last name or somebody else's first name and last name and I would I I I would you know uh you know create I I would go from that and I would I would create something okay uh you know so like Wilson Richards in the second edition was uh you know Kevin created him off of our two names okay so so so so that was kind of the way we did it uh I would like to say yeah I did all this forethought thing and created backgrounds and all that kind of stuff but I was really more interested in actually playing the game uh you know than than creating a whole uh mythology Cannon around the characters and everything that came later okay and and certainly at Fantasy Flight they did create a Bible around everything that

the characters regardless of what G what game we put them in they have to do this okay so so you know I remember me meeting with Christian Peterson and him talking about how we're putting together the Bible you know we're going to make sure we manage your product correctly and so on and so forth and uh so that was that was all great this was a few years after it come out when we were talking about that because by that time uh you know it was one of the pillars as he told me that that they were building Fantasy Flight on was was Ark yeah completely that was that was my Arkham Horror second edition was my reintroduction back into the hobby after about a five-year break and um man things had definitely changed a lot dur during that five-year break coming back to something that was quite a quite a bit more advanced in absolutely well abely anything i' had played I I had Advanced it I mean uh you know chaosium had had run into some financial problems and basically disconnected to the discontinu the game so it returned back to me um uh I sat on it for a few years then I I decided you know what I'm gonna I'm gonna revisit this I actually called it welcome back to Arkham uh was was what I did and and that story you've probably heard in the past I built that game repainted a new board added great old one out to the side that that kind of influenced things uh changed a lot changed a lot of the game brought it up and uh i' taken that game to Origins was planted out in the Breezeway they used

to put tables out in the Breezeway and we could play out there and I'd never met Kevin Wilson before he came by and said hey can I sit down and play I said yeah he sat down we played we were having a good time we played for about an hour he had to go he said I gotta go to something um I found out later that he had just taken a job at Fantasy Flight but uh he went back and told Chris he said look we have we have we have to get the Arkham Horror Game and uh you know the rest is kind of history and and Kevin brought so much to the game uh you know know his ability and his his Brilliance at at helping develop it to where it became that second edition far beyond what my idea of the second edition was uh you know at one point uh and he was great because he would call me up and say okay I'm trying to work through this problem I remember the the first big problem we had to face was uh Christian Peterson said no no more Gazette everything has to be on cards so we can expand yeah yep you know and I said well how many decks cards are we going to have I mean you know and so I remember Kevin and I were talking for about you know an hour and we came up with the idea okay let's group each location into three locations per card you know and make the neighborhoods yeah that's basically what we did okay uh because he said look it's non-negotiable uh you know so we got to figure out how to do this and and so we came up with that plan but uh then at at a later date uh I remember Christian called me up and said look you know Kevin has done a lot of great work on this game do you have a problem with him also you know being listed as code designer I said

absolutely not what he's brought to this game certainly qualifies as Cod designer so and he's always been a pleasure to work with so he's I don't know if you know him but he's a brilliant mind you get a chance to talk to him you will hear you you will hear some great ideas and some great stories so I'm hoping to be able to talk to him in a in a future uh Series so this is going to be a long Series this this retrospective probably 10 15 episodes or or something I try to do one of these a year um so in that in that between time between uh first edition and second edition that what would become the Fantasy Flight uh version that introduction of the great old one as kind of a a game modifier a almost almost a scenario yes and so so were you developing that in between I was I I had started the idea but not not near where it ended up okay I mean Kevin Kevin took that so far that uh I I had the idea that you know and I would I would put in the game I think two or three great old ones and they would have this little effect on the game Okay Kevin came up with the idea of not only have this effect on the game but but you know at the end when we get to the Doom thing you get to fight him okay I I I didn't have anything like that so uh so I I was not you know all the special skills all those kind of things put together uh that was all Kevin I had little you know each thing did like a little impact so it changed the game a little bit but

nothing like what they came up with so uh and and I I will tell you it's hard to think back and we're going way back in time so it's hard to think back and remember who who did what but Kevin did so many uh he was so skilled at doing so many of these things and he had a team there to work with him which is a plus you know yeah I always tell people you know when when you're working like me alone at your house it's a lot yeah I I think I'm pretty productive for what put out considering it's me you know uh for the most part and uh uh but having a team like that it's great because you get a feed off those ideas all the time especially if they're you know very well versed in in what this game is supposed to be yeah when you were playing Arkham Horror did you and did the people you play with did you guys ever develop any kind of uh oh I don't know superstitions about the game uh for instance when my group of friends when we would play We always had to have Jenny Barnes we thought Jenny Barnes was like our our lucky charm if we had Jenny Barnes on our team we had a good chance of of survival well we we had a couple different superstitions I mean one Superstition that we had applied to all games I'll come back to that the other Superstition that we had what was simply you never talked about if you were doing well okay so like we was set like so we didn't have an end of game but we had points we were trying to achieve so we're trying to see we got to get these extra points X number points in two hours for us to win so you would never like hey man we got this made because

the game would get up and kick you in the teeth as soon as you said something like that and and still and still does so uh so so we always kind of make it an un Unwritten rule that you don't ever you know kind of uh talk don't you don't Trash Talk the game because the game somehow can hear you okay game knows man yeah and then we had these other thing that basically we believed that there was some you know uh mythical god of dice that would bless you if you ate enough chocolate during gam playay and so you know we'd have people you know when they had to make a critical rle throw some M&M's in their mouth or something so you know it'd be amazing how many times that worked out have nothing in common but we we all started just started the kind of thing where we we' just say okay yeah that worked you know um we had we had one where you know in a dice pool system we had a saying that um all at once you're a dunce one at a time you're doing fine I've seen yeah don't just roll it one at a time man you'll hit that five or six I promise yeah I i' I've seen I've seen people do that before too so yeah and and I've seen some terrible dice rollers who are always rolling as a group Chris Kirkman is that's why he made dice hate me he it is the he is the worst dice roller on on the planet okay uh you know I remember we were working on fate of the Elder gods and we were uh you know playing playing it uh in really its final rendition and he had to roll eight dice one time and all he needed

was one he rolled all fails not not a single success out of eight dice you know I'm like only you could do that no one else on the planet could end up doing that probably uh well yeah let's talk about dice because I love dice I love dice rolling well I do too clearly so yeah I know yeah so they create drama right at the table I mean they create these moments of of high highs and high lows but those are the moments that I think your games really excel at is that that ability not to tell a story but to create story to create memorable moments and I think a lot of that does have to do with the luck your games do have quite a bit of luck well yes they do but they also have controlled look I give you a lot of ways to control look I give you I give you the ability to roll I give you the ability to add dice I give you the ability to do a lot of different things okay uh can you lose the game because of bad luck absolutely I can lo I can lose life because of bad luck I I make this argument I can get in the car a day drive out and you know somebody just runs into me on the street when I'm doing nothing wrong so so I don't I don't find luck is the issue what I try to do what I try to do with my games and this is all my games and it goes back to the very beginning is I try to give you a heroic character yeah okay somebody who can be heroic okay it's up to you how heroic they get but somebody who that can be heroic all right and I try to give you enough tools to manage that to some degree and I tell people a lot of times oh I always roll bad I said it's your attitude then man you know I remember walking up one time and people

were playing they were playing Elder Sign at the table and they needed to roll I forget what they needed to roll but uh guy was going I can't roll that there's just no way that I can roll that he I've only got one die here I just can't do it and I said here give it to me and I toss rolled it and I walked away because I couldn't do it again and they're all like holy smoke take it control the dice you walked away with an explosion behind you all cool exactly exactly drop the mic and walk away because I didn't I didn't really know if I could roll it but the but my point was lamenting about the dice is a waste of time especially in one of my games okay when you end up at the dice roll you're at the dice roll you've either prepared to where you've still got some things you can do or you're out of options and I always tell people like I'll move to Elder I always tell people if I come by a table and I see all of the characters on the same Adventure I know they're in trouble okay they're all failing that particular they're all failing that D that D and so they they've wasted all of their resources and and and they're in trouble at that point and uh so so I I think dice rolling is is a great mechanic I think you can use it a a lot of different ways but what I try to do is I don't really create a lot of new mechanics in fact I don't know if I've created many new mechanics what I try to do is Merry the mechanics that the game requires when I design a game my whole process and I

start with this I always start with theme and then I go to experience this is the theme and this is the experience I want them to have and everything is built off of that okay uh I think I'm different than most designers on that many designers are brilliant at making mechanics so they come up with a mechanic and then they go okay what what what what what game fits this mechanic all right I start with the theme and the experience and say okay what mechanic can I put in this that works with this since I like to do heroic games that means I need tension and with tension you need dice I mean uh you can do cards but it's the same okay I'm drawn from a deck okay that's not that's really not any better if I'm just playing cards out of my hand and I just need a combination then really what excitement is there in that I've either got the combination or I don't have the combination uh but I get people and this happened to me again this year I was at tantrum com I had two or three people come up to me and start telling me a story in great detail of an Arkham Horror game they played 10 or 15 years ago I mean in great detail like it was them it actually happened to them I was in the dreamlands I I caught a zebra but I I had to roll like a success to get back and close the last gate and you know and they just told the story like that and to me that's very reward because they're getting what I wanted I wanted them to have that experience that's the experience I want players to have in the game and i' I've said this before and

I'm not being critical of of Euro style games or economic style games I I think they're brilliant I enjoy playing them uh but but but that's not the kind of game that I make because I I don't find it exciting to say I traded two blue cubes for a Red Cube and then man I took that Red Cube and I bought that card you wanted the card but I got the card nobody talks about that stuff later you think think about the victory it's a great mental exercise and certainly you have to do a lot more thinking in those games than you might have to do in mind from time to time but strategies do pay strategies do pay off okay um another example is you know I don't know if you're familiar Thunder Rolls came out a few years ago we didn't distribute you can only get it at cons or or or through Mr B but uh you know we've run leagues we got a league that's run eight years now one and it you're rolling eight Dice and and going for Maneuvers in racing we got a guy who's has won four seasons in a rows a championship you don't do that out of sheer luck okay there are there are strategies to how you use Dice and uh you know I so so I like dice I like him in games especially if they apply to the game yeah yeah I remember so after Arkham hor second edition I think that game kind of opened the floodgates of uh Co-op you know they did it did I think yeah and one of the first huge ones after that I mean the one that really open the floodgates it was of course a pandemic and I remember playing pandemic for the first time for as a CO yep as a

co-op yeah and I was like well this is basically just Arkham Horror without the cool stuff without without the Spells and without the weapons and without the dice and like what like you said in that game you were matching cards you were collecting a set of cards to do the cool stuff and and I personally even though I think that game is pretty great I felt that lack of excitement that I felt when I was playing Arkham Horror however it did open the gates for me to introduce those kinds of games to other people where they might be yeah they would be intimidated by Arkham Horror yeah yeah it is and you know uh um it certainly sparked my ideas for Defenders of the realm uh that's what I was wondering yeah it absolutely did because I sat down and I played that and I thought okay there's some neat ideas here about you know you know stuff spreading out and all that kind of stuff I said but the rest of this I just find totally boring so uh I always wondered if I always wondered if Defenders of the realm was kind of a direct response to it wasn't a direct response but it but it sparked the idea so I actually built a game off of that uh it didn't work the first time I built it there was just a lot of pieces that still didn't work so I started building on more pieces okay we we we need to Quest in this we need to do this we need to do that uh you know uh the players need to be extremely heroic okay and uh and and I don't know if I can stress that enough because we

you know right now greater than games they'll be introducing very shortly the second edition of of uh Defenders of the roomm and uh you know once I built that and gave them we we moved to uh we it's really a new game okay I mean we moved into a new generation game uh where everybody has a deck of cards you play at simultaneous your your characters in your deck of cards and one of the things the Mantra I kept using with them as we would play and develop each character was more heroic more heroic and I remember Daryl lder said okay well we got to make the then we got to make the creatures you know tougher I said exactly right I said but the player has to feel they are the most heroic person regardless of which one they play they got to feel they're the most heroic person on the planet okay and uh so so that's kind of the way I I I go about the design process and one of the things that I made sure I put in Defenders of the real and really all the Defenders lines is uh I've eliminated the idea that one person can quarterback everything oh yeah this is the move because pandemic you know it kind of kind of everybody you need to do this you need to do that we you do that you do that and and so I I I wanted to eliminate that process and and make it very very difficult for um and I remember when we first came out with it with eagle games and we had it at Origins and some big time Gamers came down and said it and they did a demo and they left very very quickly and um you know the publisher was concerned and hunted down you know one of the guys in

the groups and said did did you guys not like this game at all and they said no no we thought it was great but we're used to playing a game where you know our leader of this group kind of tells us all what to do and he he there wasn't there wasn't to tell us what to do in this game so so uh you know he said well I think I think yeah I think the dice do that because you could say okay you go over here in pandemic okay if I have the cards yes I will do what you tell me but in Defenders you could tell me to go over there but I'm still having to roll those Dice and your your plan may not work out right but the dice are just a small part of it I also let you know I really want to go on this Quest because I can get something good I know I know these minions need to be attacked I really need to collect some red cards I might need to go over here to the end and try to get some cards so so so basically you know you end up if if you're trying to coach another player in the game you end up saying well you could do that or you can do that or you do that okay which are the things they probably saw anyway and and if they ask you is one better than the other only if you make them all only what only if you make it work I mean whatever you choose to do if you make it work then it might get better than the other other than that you just don't know and U I think that's that's the the the driving force that I've tried to use so dice are a piece of it but but it's it's also to where what what one player needs to do may be different than what another player needs to do because if you've truly designed the characters different then there's some some things that some

characters are are are just naturally better at uh yeah well I think if yeah even more than any other game I've played I think I think I can say this with with with with some Authority but the characters and Defenders Of The Last Stand they every time I sit down to play that game I think oh man this character is overpowered but then I go to the next character oh no this is the most powerful character oh the next character no this guy is actually way more and because every character is awesome in that game yeah yeah and and and that's I got the same thing when I would when I would develop uh you know put out different uh uh Heroes for for Defenders and and you're right and of course that's the offshoot of Defenders the room which means it's the Next Generation and I I I I love Defenders of Last Stand because we we did set down and write kind of like okay you know what is this group like what are the these teenagers like over here that throw out the leaders when they get to a certain age you know what what are the bikers like we did get into all that stuff but then we got really into the characters and and the mutations and the stories and all this kind of thing so we kind of kind of took that to to the next level but I constantly had people coming back and saying oh you know this guy that you just added or this female that you just added is is way overpowered and I just asked this I said did you win yeah well no no we didn't win I said okay then they must not be overpowered if you didn't win and did you have fun because that's exactly one of the things

that's so great about Arkham Horror is it's just as fun to lose as it is to win oh absolutely actually it's about the story I always tell people yeah in fact I was up at uh what is it the uh Raven Castle or whatever the castle up in in Ohio I can't remember the name of it again uh but they have they have like um you know they asked me up for a weekend one time and uh I I went up there and and and of course they they have all these people that come and stay it's like a bed and breakfast and it's beautiful I I wish I could remember the exact name of it but I'm old so I'm gonna use that as an excuse okay that's fine you know uh I tell people another another five or six years I'll be old enough to run for president but uh basically uh I remember getting there and the bartender said man I love Arkham Horror I got to work the whole weekend I would just love to play Arkham hor I said what time you get off work he says well I get off work at midnight I said well why don't we play at midnight he's like oh man It Go five hours I said no I said I never had a game go more than two and a half hours I said it I said what we'll play and I'll bet you when we play tonight we it won't go more than two hours you'll be home by be in bed by two he because oh if we can do that that'd be great so I set up and I remember it was just going to be me and him and we go in and had this one big room it was kind of kind of like a board room room and uh we were setting up on the table and people just started showing up so we ended up with like eight players okay and maybe five people watching all right and we played we won and when I had

boxed it up at the end I looked I said oh look it's 2 am uh he's like he's like I watched how you ran this game I'm gonna run it like that from now on I yeah it can stay on track if you want it to stay on track so oh man what a great what a great uh memory that guy have that like just it was a lot of fun yeah it was I'm sure he does it was a lot of fun and what was fun for me was seeing that not only were the people who came in and wanted to play were having fun but there were five people watching and they were having fun okay they were kind coaching from the side you got shut that gate up there you know you better move up there uh so a game that you can play like that you can you can play vicariously through yeah other people because it's it is kind of that team that team feel right yeah they were like when we won and you know shut the last gate they were they were they were cheering they were you know they were cheering and clapping so that's the that's the experience that that you want to have and uh you know uh I run a game when I go to cons now we used to go up to uh I put it together I kind of wanted uh Fantasy Flight to publish it but I I I don't think that's going to happen but it was I called it Arkham classic I took the first edition and merged it with the second edition uh so it does old school movement rolling move rolling you roll move you get your encounter we move to the next player okay and uh the game plays in like two two and a half hours and and uh I I'm just amazed at how much people enjoy just that old school feeling because it has all the

stuff that all the generations have and the heroics that go along with it so uh yeah it's it's it's fun it's fun to go run stuff like that and H and see people enjoy it that's that's the one thing I enjoy I I I literally got into game design because I wanted to play the games it's great when I see other people want to play them yeah yeah now after after second edition uh you you were pretty instrumental in the design of of Elder Sign correct I designed ersin yes so you designed so so Elder okay the story on Elder Sign is um I had a dream okay uh my my my middle yeah yeah my middle daughter does not like big games she just doesn't like okay yeah yeah and so my older daughter she loves them my son younger son he he loves them he'll they'll play anything my my older daughter she she loves Euros she she loves everything okay and uh but the middle one it had to be a simple game and I remember I I I thought you know ought to design a game for her at some point I just design a game and I and I had a dream of Designing this dice game uh you know um in in in in the you know Arkham Horror world so so I designed the game in a week I think I did did it in a week it was fastest design ever put together and um origin was not Origins Gen Con was coming up in like three weeks I contacted Kevin I said look Kevin let's

let's get some time while we're at uh J con I'd like you take a look at this game so I got with him we went up to his room we played it I remember I I remember playing because I made it to where the box top was like a was like a you know a dice box You' throw it in there oh yeah so we went end we played it and he's like oh yeah this is this is great I like he said I really like it and I said well let's do it just like we did Arkham Horror I said you know uh you show it to Christian uh if he's interested in it uh you know you take development I'll work with you on that however we need to and uh so he showed it to Christian and Christian liked it uh Kevin really redefined the he I had like Monster cards he changed those to the tiles he did he he added to the characters and kind of balanc he is great at balancing characters and all that kind of stuff uh making sure added more locations we had I had a lot of locations he haded more locations and encounters and all that kind of stuff and uh we came out with it so yeah that's exactly how that one came out how how involved are you in when a game you design gets expanded is that is that usually some some not not a lot not a lot what first of all it depends on depends on who's expanding it okay if it's Fantasy Flight I will say not a lot I will usually submit things like okay like Arkham Horror second edition I submitted this whole thing uh on enouth okay uh right after the first edition second edition came out and it was doing

good so I submitted all this stuff on outh and and and and Kevin called me up he goes OU's last we're not doing this stuff yet okay okay well what are we doing he's like you know looking at that and uh but but they drive most of that now with a smaller company like Eagle games 100% okay there there's no there 100% on on any expansion that gets done so on most with the exception of Fantasy Flight with most games I do you know 100% of any expansion that's going to come out with Fantasy Flight um I might talk to them they might send me part of the idea they might ask me what I think about this I might share an idea with them but but you know they they had a big staff working on things so you know I'm you know I'm several hundred miles away so I can only I can only do so much but uh I really appreciated uh that group of people and that staff up there because anytime they were coming out with things like even the the the Arkham Horror card game uh I remember they sat down with me and showed it to me before it came out and said do you see anything you know and and I really appreciate it because I did see a couple of of verbal things that I thought they should change and they did change those uh you know but other than that um no not not a lot with Fantasy Flight they have they have a large very very talented staff I I tell you I enjoyed working with Kevin I've enjoyed working with Corey kic I yeah he's he's

fantastic uh you know uh what about Nikki valin did you have any uh did you have any interaction Nikki I did I you know um Nikki Nikki had a brilliant Storyteller mind and I remember I went up and I played the Third Edition and I really liked how the story aspect worked but uh but realistically it it has this kind of Euro mechanic to it of I can do two actions on my turn and I can't repeat an action okay I think it's two action I can't repeat an action that takes the heroics out of the game I got two monsters on me well I can attack once okay what can I do after that well you can evade well I don't want to evade I want to kill this mon moner okay uh you know great storytelling but but I really that part uh you know and I've learned that more over time but I do say that they did a really good job with the storytelling aspect people who like storytelling aspect should definitely play Third Edition uh the expansions made the game better and better I will say that yeah but that that heroic piece uh went down solely because I can't do anything I want to do okay I can move but I can't move twice I can fight but I can't fight twice you know uh I can interact conf find the uh made the sandbox a little smaller I think but but I also do appreciate I I really like Third Edition a lot as well I appreciate that it's a little more directed uh you you have a little bit more of a gaml and narrative Reon to do what

you're doing yeah you don't know what you're doing till it gets further along so so the story aspect and I'll come back to this actually you know eldrich horror really is the third edition of Arkham Horror yeah all right I'll talk about that and working with Cory on that in a minute but but while while eldrich is that Arkham third is really a different game if I remember Tom vassel said which game should I keep and I said well you need to keep both of them second and third because they're not the same game okay I agree I agree and I would say the same to anybody when they get to the new Defenders of the realm do I get rid of my old Defenders realm for the new Defenders no they're two different games at this point you know when you see the new Defenders it's not the same game okay so uh uh it's going to have the heroic stuff but it's not the same game so that's what I would say about this one so the one big thing I brought to that one was you know I play test I was play testing as it was getting ready to come out uh you know uh with with Nikki I always felt that she was very driven and really believed in her process okay so she was not like if I made a suggestion to Kevin Kevin or I made a suggestion to Corey a lot of times they would sees on that suggestion Nikki was not the same she was like okay he's an old guy making a suggestion okay and that's what it is the suggestion I'm not doing that and that's not all bad okay because what she was trying to create was different than what I would create but the one thing that that she was wrong on and I did get changed was you used to just draw the monster off the top of the deck so I not only knew

what the Monster was that would come in next I knew where they were coming in so I told her I said Nikki this does not work I said there has to be at least that much mystery in the game and uh I said we got a draw from the bottom of the deck and she's like H I don't think so and so I did talk to Corey I said Corey you know I actually Corey had called me and said are you pleased with where this is at and I I basically told him yeah yeah me I'm pleased I said but that there's this one issue I just think's wrong and I explain it to him he goes oh no we got to change that okay so they did change that okay uh but so my involvement all I'm poting out is my involvement is is minimal I think there's some brilliant things in Arkham Third Edition that that that she brought in how you go have to pick up Doom out of neighborhoods how the story folds uh so I highly recommend it to people but it's not Arkham second as a third okay yeah I know I agree I think I think the game would have been better received had it not been called Arkham Horror Third Edition I think you're probably right uh you know would have been a new game a new Arkham Horror Game right because like you said uh Arkham Horror files but not not not Arkham Horror like like with with eldrich horror now you know we we called eldrich horror something different Corey brought me in to work with him that for three days pretty much at uh you know after he had already put some ideas together but it was still very much in in the formation and we played it you know four or five times Nikki was there she played it also and so we were crafting the

changes and we crafted several changes during that period but uh in my opinion eldrich really is the Third Edition because you know it it just the way just the way it operates it's what I call Globe trotting you know Arkham essentially y we we we took this we didn't take we didn't make the story be condensed like it does in Third Edition where the story makes sense as you go along and unfolds but what we did was we we tied everything to the ancient ones in story so you just didn't have Random Encounters okay you the deck of card the the trying to gather Clues you you you actually had to solve real Clues Associated to the real you know ancient one that you were playing with you could travel to all the same you know World especially once we started expanding it uh you know uh the characters felt the same they feel the same even in in in Arkham third but uh uh it's just a game playay if I'm on a stack of monsters in in the in Eldridge it's just like being on a stack of monsters in in in Arkham Horror I can fight I can choose the order I'm going to fight them in and I can fight I don't beat one okay uh where just comparing it to the combat in in in the third I get a fight one time you know no matter how many monsters I've got on me and so you know because the focus wasn't heroics the focus was story in Arkham third so uh but but in my opinion Elder hor truly was the third edition of of Arkham it's it definitely a standalone but but it but it feels

like Arkham moved up a level if you want to look at the second moovie up a level yeah I kind of look at eldrich as Arkham Horror second edition refined um it's it's uh getting rid of people will often accuse second edition of being fiddly and I think when they think of that they think of the sliders on the stats right how each turn you have but I like that I like that planning phase you're like okay what am I going to do okay I need to I need to boost his luck or boost his speed but that is fiddly and Elders right that is fiddly uh timing can become fiddly but you know I've already in my mind started putting together what a what a fourth edition would look like uh and who knows if you'll ever green greenlighted but hopefully hopefully if it does I can work with you know Corey or if not him well with and he still got a design house with him so hopefully Corey Kevin's off run Kevin's off running things with a different company now so uh but but I think what you do is you increase the characters by by them having a specific deck of cards that replaces that whole Focus process and the deck of cards help subsidize them and the stuff that they're doing so they've got to manage their hand uh you know I I there's a number of different things I think can be done but that's one thing is you know let's make the characters even bigger once again kind of like I've done with with some of the

other games now I know you you start a lot of your games with with a board right you the board is a really Central focus of your your board games that's correct have you thought of have you thought a board it is a board game exactly so have you do you have a mental image in your mind of a fourth edition board of of what you want to focus on on that yes yeah I do yeah uh you know but once again what I dream up and what becomes reality can change even in my mind dramatically Al so but but definitely I you know I want to personally I want a big 3D City uh that's beautiful at night uh you know I don't know if you've seen freedom five City that that we we put together for I not yet I have not seen that that's I'm not familiar with that one yeah we I I think we almost killed the artist on that uh you know driving that back back back no NOP no gotta gotta do this gotta do this gotta do this uh but but I I I I really want you I want this beautiful city that you're moving around in and that was one of the requests I made for the Third Edition is I want to see the buildings better and stuff like that which they did so I I really really did appreciate that in the neighborhoods but but I still I still want a board uh I don't want to be abstract if possible but I think it can be abstract uh because I think it's really all about it's mostly about play the board helps provide that experience for in my opinion so I I I want to I want a a really good-look board but uh uh so in

my mind that the board is is a lot like uh the the board that we put together for for freedom five which hopefully will come out one of these days we've been waiting a long time for that one uh but was that was that kickstarted it was kickstarted but but what are we we're two two years late now on that uh the reason being is that so much happened with it okay uh first first of all you know it was a mill it was a million-dollar Kickstarter uh one of the things they did which I think is great but terrible say it's it's great and terrible it's both of those painted Miniatures okay once you get to Painted Miniatures you just slow down the process dramatically okay and and then you throw in covid uh supply chain issues and all these other things you end up where we're at okay and then to to make it to make it more interesting is I had to come back and write some more scenarios some other people had to write some more scenarios because when you have a great Kickstarter you start promising a lot of things that haven't been in the game so I think I had six original comic books in the game and I think we ended up with like 16 or 18 oh man holy crap double okay so so I I don't believe and I don't believe in adding anything that's not real okay in other words I'm not just G to repeat one of the comics with a okay I'm Not Gon to Gloom Haven it where I'm doing the same thing but the mon you know one monster tougher those time okay you got to have a different experience

in each one of the tutorials okay the the villain's really doing something else this is going on on the side these things are changing so and by the way I'm not trying to be critical groom Haven it's it's a great game but one of the things is people told me it's got like 120 you know adventures in it yeah it's you know it's it's got like 20 adventures in it where the things change you know and and you count them multiple times but uh uh so so my take on it was we had to write all these things so that added time to it but uh hopefully with any luck uh this next quarter it should finally come out and it it it truly is a it's not only an excellent game but it's you really do get your superhero fix in it now so that's like like Defenders of the realm world then you'll you'll really get your fix in it yeah all right well that's exciting because you got that on the horizon and then also Defenders of the realm version of that coming out la1 which I kind of intended to be you kind of last Tow on it but I keep designing games so I'm not going to have a last tow you know de I decid I decided being a game designer is not what I do it's actually who I am so yeah I'm just going to keep designing games and people want to publish them fine if they don't want to publish them I'm fine with that too but uh I don't know if you're M la1 I think it goes on Kickstarter in the next month or so uh August September at the latest uh it's basically you're a detective

in in in in a city state of La which is a three tiered City uh the angels are Towers their their buildings are above the clouds from the nuclear Wars that taken place la1 is the surface City that constantly dark constantly Ash falling constantly you know radioactive rain and all different things and then underground is where the mutants and the gangsters and all that stuff resides so you reside on la1 and you actually get cases to to solve and it's not a deductive game is because you can replay the cases because I've made multi counter multiple encounter cards for everything and uh so basically you play this detective agency that's got a case to go solve you know oh that sounds awesome yeah it's it's and I took the mechanic in the game uh is not dice which everybody will be shocked about I guess is that new is that is that your first big diceless game no my first big diceless game was uh Legends of the American frontier okay and leg Yeah that's right I have played that I liked that game I I enjoyed that one yeah I love that one too Legends of americ Frontier had a big deck fate deck though that you cards out of but in this one here there's a small fate deck that goes between you know zero and three okay of each skill and so you Shuffle it each time or don't Shuffle it the clar gets and you basically have to complete your things by coming in number but the thing

here's the part here's the part that's really first of all I love I love the smaller fate deck better okay and some ways it's more controllable you can spend Karma to get redraws and all that kind of stuff but here's the part I love about it everything in this city's trying to kill you okay you got the big steam up above they don't like any of you down there below you've got the gangsters you got the mutants you've made enemies at the police department you've got everybody who's on your case so when you do a fate draw you're trying let's say you're trying to hit the number you're trying to hit the number three it's a small and easy to do well I'm sitting here in my hand and I've got three muscle right here so I just play three muscle I'm gonna automatically succeed here's the problem I still do a fate draw so if I get muscle I keep doing a fate draw just like Legend American free if I get if I get the fake card I keep doing the draw if I exceed my number by more than two okay then I have to put one of my tokens in heat which means the gang I drew attention to the gangsters who don't like me the police who don't like me the bad guys who don't like me are paying attention and so making too much noise you're you're making you're you're making too many waves so there'll be events that come up in the game where whoever's got the most heat over there you know you might get drugged down to the police station roughed up a little bit you know uh question you you might even get arrested so so there's all these different things that happen but I really I really like that game it's coming out from trick-or Treat Studios which is kind of new to the industry um I designed this game a long time ago one company had it they failed during the

pandemic came back to me trick-or treats got it now but uh I think they're doing I think they've done an excellent job with it uh we're just a little little long in getting it out but uh uh once we get it on Kickstarter uh it I I think people people who like my games I think are really gonna like this game I've run it at that cons and the feedback is always the same so if you like the whole Blade Runner uh you know Dark World type dark city type thing uh you'll you'll you'll enjoy la1 oh man that sound that sounds perfect yeah I'm GNA have I definitely I'm glad that's on my radar now and like all games you can play solo you can play it with players so I that's just that's one of my rules when I design a game is it's got to be got to be able to play it solo and feel like I can play it solo okay not just I'm running four guys over here you know uh you know uh you feel like you can play it solo excellent well hey Richard man I really appreciate apprciate you taking the time to talk to us today this has been super fun and I learned a lot and it was great to get a glimpse into your design mind and just kind of the history of I don't know how does it feel to be you're kind of an important part of the history of the development of of board games is that that does that sink in a lot uh no you don't really it's like everything else you don't really think about it when you're out there doing but what I will say is I I have been know blessed by being able to interact with some of the greatest people in the industry I I

I just have to tell you uh everybody who's added their name to Arkham Horror has has has been great they've they they they've really wanted to make it better you don't get that with every game you don't get you don't get that with everything you deal with but uh you know all the people I've mentioned and a ton of people I haven't mentioned have have made Arkham Horror what it is and and I'm appreciative to all of them and I'm appreciative to the players because I tell you what the thing that I like best you ask me if it rates when I go I went to or I didn't get make it to Origins this year but I was at Origins last year and when I went back in where they were doing the play areas where people signed up to play and I saw them one day playing four they had they didn't had they one copy and they copied it of the original Arkham Horror so they they had copies they had made up uh and I saw four games of that taking place and the next day I saw you know uh Arkham Horror second edition taking place and then I then I saw him playing Elder Sign you know and people coming in and and and still big tables and these are games that that that are pretty pretty old and I saw them playing Eldridge uh you know and I'm sure they played the third I just I just didn't walk back there not when I was doing that when I see people enjoying the game um that that is the that is the greatest reward I think any game designer gets is is is that people are enjoying your game so yeah well that's awesome man thanks a lot have a great uh rest of your Sunday afternoon and uh maybe we'll talk to you later maybe we'll talk uh during la1 or something that would be yeah feel free to contact me any time and goodbye to

everybody see you later thank you all right everybody well I hope you enjoyed that interview with Richard lonus um I had so much fun talking to him I was a little star struck at the beginning just because he is kind of one of my game design Heroes I love so many of his games and his games have been really uh an important part in my life and so getting the chance to talk to him to hear about some of those early stories about the the development of Arkham Horror first edition and some of his other games was really really fun for me so while Richard lonus was the creator of the board game Arkham Horror we really can't say that the madness began with him he was just a conduit uh to see where the madness really began we could go all the way back to a bit before even HP Lovecraft and we could go all the way back to the 1870s but don't worry this isn't going to be a concise history starting with the 1870s up through the present that would be way too long and I'm not actually an expert on this subject at all I'm just a guy who likes some things and likes talking about them what I want to do is just present a bit of context and about how all of this great fiction fits within the world of these board games or I guess you could say how these board games fit within this great world of fiction so with the cthulu Mythos there really is no official Cannon and I think

that's one of the best things about it the seeds or the spores as it were for the Mythos predate even HP Lovecraft uh with the work of authors like Robert W Chambers Lord denan Arthur mockin and Ambrose beerus so Lovecraft was an incredibly well read author and as an influential author in in his own time he was an important Link in the chain that bridged the old and the new and while he did spawn many of the Mythos most lofty beings and ideas he wasn't really the owner of the Mythos it's bigger than HP Lovecraft and yes it's even bigger than old cthulu so I want to read a little bit now from Lynn Carter in his excellent kind of overview of the Mythos called Lovecraft a look behind the cthulu Mythos and this is a fantastic book if you want to learn more about the Mythos I do highly highly recommend this book it's part of Lyn Carter's Valentine adult fantasy series so I want to read a little bit from the uh from the introduction here in discussing a certain body of interconnected stories by HP Lovecraft and other writers we use the word the word is Mythos we use the word in a special sense which might be defined as a corpus of fictitious narratives which share as their common background a system of invented lore Lovecraft certainly did not invent the term and he never once used it in print

not even in his voluminous correspondence in fact he seems to have been completely unaware that certain of his stories could be singled out as belonging to the cthulu sequence as far as he was concerned all of his work was interconnected the term came into use among Lovecraft correspondents as a convenient label no one today seems to remember who used it first but it was most likely August derith who used the term in print derith himself thought it was first used in his biographical critical monograph hpl a memoir uh published by Ben Abramson of New York in 1945 but my research has uncovered an earlier use of the word Mythos to describe the story sequence and the actual phrase the cthulu mythology used in the same manner in the derth wand Dr introduction to The Outsider and others which was published in 1939 perhaps the most unique thing about the Mythos is the fact that it spread Beyond Lovecraft himself other writers became caught up in it wrote stories based upon it extended and elaborated and developed the background lore which Lovecraft invented at first it was only some of lovecraft's closest friends and correspondents who wrote new stories in the Mythos writers like Clark asan SMI Roberty Howard Frank Bop long Robert block August darith but before long writers like hler cutner Garder Fox Hugh

cave Manley Wade Wellman Robert W Robert W londis Henry Hass and Robert Johnson who had a little to do with Lovecraft in the main began contributing stories and poems which have been described as belonging to or bordering upon his Mythos and throughout this series we will be taking a look at stories written written by many of those authors that I just mentioned and more okay because there is no official Canon or core group of stories that codifies the true source of Mythos knowledge and Aesthetics there are as many truths and styles of Mythos tale as there are authors who have contributed to it there are many ways to tell a Mythos story in my opinion the Arkham Horror family of games the Arkham files games style is more influenced by the pulp stylings of authors like Brian Lumley and others it is this style of story that feels the most like the Arkham files Games lumley's characters of Titus Crow and HRI dearne feel like the prototypical investigators in these games they're ready to take on the CCD the cthulu cycle deities headon with physical altercations a lumely talks specifically about a certain kind of gate that needs to be closed to prevent an invasion of the ccds into Earth and

he was the one who really asked what if Humanity could fight back he gave Humanity hope when facing off against the great old ones and their minions Like Richard lonus lumely injected a bit of Pulp heroism into the cthulu Mythos and he wasn't the only one to do this Lumley compressed the power level of the cthulu cycle deities he brought the power level of the great old ones down and brought the power level of the humans up and by arming his human characters with the right kind of knowledge and the right kind of alien scientific devices he allowed his human characters to fight back in very much the same way that we are able to fight back as the characters we play in these games we should also look of course to chaos and the work done by Sandy Peterson and others on the call of cthulu RPG the original Arkham Horror was indeed meant to be a call of cthulu RPG board game it says right on the box even the box of second edition says that it is a call of cthulu board game the call of cthulu RPG did as much to popularize and to mold the cthulu Mythos as any of the works that came before it or even the works that came after it as did the original version of deities and demigods from TSR for advanced Dungeons and Dragons this version of deities and demigods has a

whole chapter on the cthulu cycle deities the really are four different sources of cthulu Mythos knowledge and styles and that is the pre-craft Mythos the beginning the kind of the prehistory and then we have the Lovecraft Circle Mythos this is kind of the the direct source from Lovecraft and the other authors that he worked with and who worked with him then we have the derth Mythos and that grew out of his uh taking all of this work and codifying it and then publishing it in his uh publication house Arkham house uh books and then we have the expanded Mythos and this is all of the other off offshoots this is the new school we have the RPG Arkham files uh new Authors books about the AR the the world of the game books based on the game books that directly influen the game and authors that came out of the game uh video games comic books and movies uh the cthulu Mythos really has become one of the most important pillars of geek culture in terms of longevity it's older than even DC and Marvel and in terms of mass popularity it is of course uh well behind things like Star Wars War like DC and like Marvel but for a collection of dark weird creepy Cosmic horror stories it's insanely popular and then all of these different things all of these

different eras and styles and sources of knowledge have been mixed up mashed Twisted turned around upside down inside out stretched out and mangled together into what we call the cthulu Mythos that's why I think it's best to refer to these games as maybe C thulan and not love cfan because most of these games really have strayed far away from the Lovecraft style of the Mythos all of this is to say that I often hear a point of criticism leveled at these games and that says that these aren't lovecraftian as if as if that's something bad and yes that's right they are not lovecraftian the games have moved pretty far away from hpl's cosmic horror Style dings the cthulu Mythos is a large umbrella under which exist many subgenres there is Cosmic horror from people like Lovecraft Thomas lagotti and others there is Western cthulu Fiction with the maabo Rider by Edward M erac fantastic one of my favorite series of all time um even erac also wrote some fiction here of James Bond versus the cthulu Mythos and then we also have weird modern kind of body horror takes on the cthulu Mythos from authors like Michael Shay and we also have works of sword and sorcery mixed with cthulu like the stuff from

Richard El Tierney with his Simon of Gita character in sorcery against Caesar and then there is the planetary romance style or the sword and Planet style the Dreamland style fantasy and Lovecraft wrote some of that with his dream cycle uh the dream quest of unknown kadath is one of my favorite stories or one of my favorite stories from HP Lovecraft and that is definitely more of a fantasy style take on the cthulu Mythos and my favorite Mythos author Brian Lumley wrote in that style with his Titus Crow books and please remember it is perfectly okay to prefer one of those Styles over the other it's perfectly okay to to not like one of those Styles but that doesn't render the other stories a wrong interpretation they're just different the cthulu Mythos as a whole is bigger than any one of these subg genres it's the combination of all of these Styles and all of these different voices that has allowed this Collective Mythos to flourish for so many decades and it's why we even have the Arkham files games today for us to enjoy okay so now I want to do a very brief chronology of important authors to the Mythos and we're going to go all the way back starting with Ambrose beerus who was born in 1842 and he introduced two stories one the inhabitant of carcosa in 1886 and the other hea the Shepherd in

1891 and these were early Mythos seeds that were planted and then we have Arthur mockin born in 1863 and his story The Great God pan was published in 1894 and that kind of had the folk Horror in inspiration for the Mythos and then we get to a big one Robert W Chambers born in 1865 and his very important work the king in yellow one of the best uh published in 1895 it actually has my favorite short story of all time the repairer of reputations and here is where we start getting more of the hastur Mythos and the King in Yellow and hastur was a thing that kind of connected the old with the new it is kind of the through line that has been there since the very beginning and then we come to maybe the most important uh author of the pre-craft era and maybe even extending into the Lovecraft era and that is of course lur denani who was born in 1878 and his super super influential and important work the gods of pagana which was published in 1905 the importance of Den's fiction on HP Lovecraft and the Mythos cannot be over stated the gods of pagana is a direct and vital influence on HP Lovecraft and the entire cthulu Pantheon I want to read a little bit more from the link Carter book on dunan and his importance to HP Lovecraft

dunen's first book however was something quite oddly different this slender little volume of the Gods of pagana had been published at the expense of its author in 1905 danzan wrote it the year before while staying at rude Ashton in wilsh this is literally what denan did a sequence of brief Pros poems or sketches presents the gond of his imaginary Kingdom outlines their Legends and the whole has a very biblical flavor to it and for some time in the stories he wrote after this book denani utilized this pagana Pantheon in his tales eventually he drifted apart from pagana obviously feeling too tied down by the preconceived Mythos this notion fascinated Lovecraft although it was not to turn up in his fiction in recognizable form for some years but the B the basic notion of an invented mythology used as the background lore for fantasy stories intrigued him greatly and thus was planted the seed that would eventually mature into what we call the cthulu Mythos okay after Lord danzan we have kind of the first kind of Proto culian author and that would be a Meritt born in 1884 with his amazing Story the people of the pit in 1918 which feels like a kind of a rough draft of at the mountains of Madness it's really really good and really early and man it is such a fantastic story and now we get to the Lovecraft Circle starting of course with

HP Lovecraft who was born in 1890 Lovecraft had a wildly inventive imagination and also the foresight in how to harness it and how to encourage other and allow other authors to write in in his world we have the call of cthulu published in 1928 The Dream quest of unknown kadath in 1943 and kind of the story the small story that started it all was the nameless City originally published in a small fanzine in 1921 and it is in this story where we are introduced to the character of Abdul alaz who of course would become the author of the Necronomicon and it is in the nameless City where we get the famous couplet that is not dead which can Eternal lie and with strange eons even death may die and so now we get into the whole Lovecraft Circle his contemporaries the direct correspondence and these people they shared ideas and information and most importantly they referenced each other and each other's work in their own work thus mixing this kind of fact and fiction creating this Mythos but there was never really an attempt for any of these authors to get together and create a Mythos Bible they weren't really interested in that kind of consistency but we have Clark Ashton Smith born 1893 Frank Bop long born 1901 Robert E Howard born 1906 Donald

wandry born 1908 August derith born 1909 derth and wandry would of course co-found Arkham House books together this is the first time that the cthulu stories were collected as a unified Mythos in the tales of the cthulu Mythos and then we have Fritz Liber born in 1910 C Moore 1911 and her husband Henry cutner born in 1915 and then the youngest of the original Lovecraft Circle would be Robert block of course the author of psycho born in 1917 and I kind of consider block to be kind of a bridge between the old between the Lovecraft Circle and the knew because he was younger I think he had a more youthful style he was more playful and more modern and then we go into the large group of authors that have come after there is no way I could list all of them there are so many but here are just a few we have Brian Lumley Ramsey Campbell Robert Price Lynn Carter Thomas latti Michael Cisco Joseph Pulver Senor lar Baron Michael Shay Richard El Tierney wh pugm Carl Edward Wagner Colin Wilson Edward M erac Matthew M Bartlett and so many others and throughout the life of this series I'm hoping that we can at least touch upon some of the stories written by many of these authors if you're looking for something close to a Canon something that does a good job of laying the foundation of what the cthulu Mythos might be what a story

might read like I would encourage you to pick up what is considered to be the very first official collection of Mythos fiction and that is tales of the cthulu Mythos edited Ed by August derith it's about as close to a canonical Anthology as you're going to get so some of the highlights of the original 1969 version are the call of cthulu by HP Lovecraft the black stone by Robert E Howard the hounds of Talos by Frank bnob long the shambler of the Stars by Robert block the Haunter of the Dark by HP Lovecraft the Salem Horror by Henry cutner cold print by Ramsay Campbell the sister city and cement surround ings by Brian Lumley and return of lore by Colin Wilson so this original version is very out of print and very expensive but it has been republished throughout the years and you can find this new this newer version tales of the cthulu Mythos by HP Lovecraft and others it's a very similar Edition it has probably about 90% of the stories crossover this one includes a few new stories that weren't included in the original including a story by Stephen King called jerus Jerusalem's lot which acts as a prequel to Salem's Lot and it does mention some Mythos things in it so pretty cool to see how the Mythos even influence people like Stephen King and finally today for this segment I want to read a bit of an essay a bit of an article written by Richard El Tierney who we just took a look

earlier at his sword against Caesar book a fantastic author really really cool um he also worked with David C Smith in writing the red Sonia books and this is a an article that he wrote called the derith Mythos but he says the cthulu Mythos is largely the invention of not HP Lovecraft but August derith Lovecraft of course did the groundwork he invented the gods the demons and servatur and above all he provided the spooky Gothic atmosphere necessary to the genre yet it seems to me that it was derith who established the concept as a Mythos to comprehend all the love craf and Concepts derith probably coined the term cthulu Mythos if he did not he certainly developed the attitude that goes with that term consider the basic premises of the Mythos a cosmic cluster of good guys the Elder Gods protecting the human race from the bad guys the ancient old ones the great old ones who are striving to do us Humanity in darith maintains that all uh that this is all a parallel of the Christian Mythos with its bad against good and with Humanity the focal point of it all evil ancient ones are striving to take our planet from us but the Angelic Elder Gods always intervene in time to save us the whole basic concept of darless good versus evil Mythos seems as non- lovecraftian as anything conceivable Lovecraft actually

regarded the cosmos as basically indifferent to anthropocentric outlooks such as good and evil the Shocker in his best Tales is usually the line in which the narrator is forced to recognize that there are vast and Powerful forces and entities basically indifferent to humanity because of their overwhelming superiority to man to sum up the cthulu Mythos as it stands is at least as much darless invention as it is hpls the line of Lovecraft development remains open no one has really taken up as yet where he left off uh I think maybe Thomas lagotti has Thomas lagotti seems to have a very lovecraftian outlook on the universe and in life and it leads towards the cosmic yet if one wants to get to the heart of what Lovecraft felt about the cosmos one must sidestep derith and his followers so personally I am more a follower of derith school of the Mythos than I am HP Lovecraft to the extent that I really appreciate the more pulpy and heroic styles of that Mythos my all-time favorite author of Mythos fiction is of course Brian Lumley I'm pretty sure that my views of the world of the universe and of humanity align more with lumely than they do Lovecraft and I'm able to connect with his characters and stories on a more meaningful level however that's not to say that I dislike HP

Lovecraft and other styles far from it as far as the old stuff goes you know the the King in Yellow contains one of my all-time favorite short stories my alltime favorite with the repair of reputation uh Lord danan is one of my favorite authors and I also greatly enjoy a lot of HP Lovecraft stories and I love many stories from the hpl circle I will however be a little kinder to derith and Lumley in these videos than a lot of people are so that's just a warning I know there are a lot of people out there who really hate darith and really hate Lumley but I am not one of those people all right so that was kind of a a brief primer on the cthulu Mythos a little bit of a history mentioned some stories and some books now let's get down to the table and take a look at Arkham Horror first edition all right hey well over an hour into the video and look we're finally uh we're finally at the table we're finally talking about a board game but um as if you couldn't guess this series is about a whole heck of a lot more than just the board games so when I originally planned to do this series I wasn't going to start with Arkham Horror first edition uh up until about a month ago uh mid 2024 I had never even played the first edition I had never even seen it in person there is I believe one playthrough and it's actually a very recent playthrough on YouTube and that's on Paul Darcy's Channel and if you want

to see a good playthrough of the game I highly recommend going to his channel and checking it out so we've learned a little bit about where the madness came from uh Richard lonus Lord denan HP Lovecraft Lumley and others and now let's partake of the fruit that that madness has given us um a day or so before I recorded this segment I sat down to spend some more time with the game and while I was looking at things flipping through cards and reading through the manual I was reminded of a song by one of my favorite bands Tears for Fears and that song is mad world all around me are familiar faces Worn out Places Worn Out faces bright and early for their daily races going nowhere going nowhere and I find it kind of funny and I find it kind of sad the dreams in which I'm dying are the best I've ever had I find it hard to tell you cuz I find it hard to take when people run in circles it's a very very very mad world and I think that's just a perfect song for this game we have familiar faces in some of the investigators like Jenny Barnes and Joe diamond and Monteray Jack we have worn out places in Arkham like City Hall the sanitarium the hospital The Boarding House on the board we have uh people running around in circles around the

neighborhood of Arkham and of course when we go to Earth's dreamlands we are uh the have the potential of dying in a dream and yeah that song just really struck a chord with me while I was thinking about Arkham Horror first edition finally being able to experience first edition for myself has been kind of like playing a board game in the dreamlands I see faces I hear names that I recognize I see places that are familiar I see items and objects that I remember but they're all just a little bit different a little soft around the edges they don't appear like how I picture them but they're familiar just the same going in a reverse chronological order and how one experiences something can be a bit awkward sometimes for sure I sometimes imagine Gamers who uh were interested in video game like Elden ring going all the way back to its Genesis in something like Kingfield and that would be in for a world of shock but they would still see that kind of familiarity I approach my look at Arkham hor first edition as I might a video game Dake uh for those of you who are unfamiliar with a Dake they kind of they they they purposefully make an older version of a newer game so that's kind of how I looked at Arkham Horror and armed with that knowledge of what would become later I was able to frame things properly in the case of Arkham Horror first edition it's been mostly a good and positive thing if a little bit on the expensive side Arkham Horror first edition has what most people would

recognize I from the much bigger and much more polished and infinitely more popular second edition but everything is a little more primitive a little flimsier in the cards uh and in the board the board's just kind of a fold out paper map but everything is here if a little bit more reductive but what's most important is it's still really fun and it still does a fantastic job of creating memorable moments at the table and that's really what all good Games should do as a matter of fact I'll never forget my first game of Arkham Horror first edition I actually won I had an insanely Lucky Draw of initial items and each of My Three Investigators I was playing as Jenny Barnes mon Ray Jack and Harvey Walters each of them received an Elder Sign from the item deck and through a luck of the draw of the gate cards I was able to get every gate closed and sealed in just a few turns it was totally wild I probably didn't play Everything correctly because the rule book or the rule books I should say leave a lot to be desired but that doesn't really matter it was still fun and exciting and I wanted to play more again those are all good signs of a good game uh let's take a look at one thing right off the bat here and you can kind of see the difference actually I was really surprised when I first got first edition at the size of the box I didn't realize what a small box it would be in for a comparison's sake uh here is a

Talisman expansion box from a second edition and you can see it's that it's that old kind of U uh bookshelf box size and yeah I was really shocked by how small it was and one thing stood out to me on this amazing cover of course we have a design by Richard lonus and as you heard in the interview Lynn Willis and Charlie crank but here we have a board the board game for Monster Hunters and I think that's a really good clue as to signify that this is different than a lovecraftian style Mythos story this is more focused on the action and I think that's just having that subtitle there I think is a really good clue of where lonus was coming from in his attempts and I think his his successful attempts to create an adventure game a pulp Adventure game set in the world of the cthulu Mythos let's take a look at the back of the box here and read a little bit about this from Beyond Space and Beyond Time extra extra extra extra extra mobs of monsters massively metastized by jath Maple Thorp special to The Gazette hordes of monsters appear early this morning making of Arkham a perilous Battleground mayor Maple Thorp has requested intervention by the militia appealing for public calm Town officials nonetheless expressed the helplessness towards the unprecedented situation no loss of life has been confirmed the hospital and the sanatorium acknowledged that many patients have been admitted

several more than once heavy property damage occurred in the miskatonic University grounds and that the Silver Twilight Lodge Sheriff Engel stated that damage and injuries might be worse safe for the courage of a few visiting investigators who discovered the horrors and began dispatch of them in all nearly 100 drawings and Silhouettes and remember what lonia said some of those drawings are his original prototype drawings that he just sketched out by hand chaosium didn't even take the time to make new art that is hilarious what investigators do whack monsters right there the first thing that this game is focusing on is killing monsters it's it's direct confrontation that already is entirely non- lovecraftian uh blast blast gates to other worlds encounter weird characters discover Toms and artifacts buy and sell wheel and deal we have nine origination classes and 21 monster types colorful components uh here we have let's see a little bit about the game here the year is 1926 and strange things are happening in Arkham Massachusetts a town with a Sinister past strange lights glow in the graveyard a local citizen has vanished Without a Trace here the odd fluting in the woods the people are of Arkham are near panic and only you Brave investigators can rescue them from Imagine unimaginable evil um Arkham Horror is playable with up to eight players and it's Co-op yes as Fearless investigators the players seek to uncover the strange events and stranger

beings behind the Placid facade of this New England Town Duty and Fortune May uh May separate the investigators injury mental shock or magic can affect or remove them from the game the Arcane powers of the cthulu Mythos a Sinister amalgam of alien beings and human cultists have come to Earth by means of magical Gates if the investigators destroy these Gates before the SpaceTime Continuum is a revocably strained then the players win if too many gates open the players lose and Arkham is overrun exploring its streets buildings woods and Parks the investigators meet helpful and hindering people find magical Laden books and discover trade for or purchase helpful items no player loses unless all the players lose nor is any player eliminated from the game before it ends losing one investigator another is chosen and play is renewed so yeah as you can tell from the description it sounds a lot like Arkham Horror's second edition and it kind of is we have a lot of the things that we all love about the later editions of this game and let's take a look at some of those things starting with the investigators so we will see some very familiar names and possibly some familiar faces here we have Jenny Barnes we have Joe diamond we have Monteray Jack rvy Walters Carolyn Fern Mandy Thompson Gloria Goldberg and Vincent Lee all of these characters have appeared in

other Arkham Horror games and I did not even I never even thought about them being in this game I was kind of surprised when I found out they were and I think that is really cool however there are some differences here are some of the differences we don't have any backstories we have nothing really to differentiate these characters the characters don't have backstories they don't have their own desires they don't have their own background and they also lack in a skill that makes them different from each other they do have some different uh stats though and the four stats are fast talk fight knowledge and sneak and so those are the things that you are using to roll under when you do your stat test in this game Arkham horr first edition does not use a D6 dice pool system it uses a D6 system and you're usually trying to roll low you're usually trying to meet or beat under your skill so if you were to do a fast F talk check you would have to roll a three or under for Jenny Barnes to do fast talk and fast talk in this game is something that can be used when you buy something to barter and to lower the price so her fast talk is three her fight is three her knowledge is four her sneak is four and here we have fast talk of Joe Diamond four five 2 and three for his stats now one of the only really kind of pieces of background information we get in Arkham Horror first edition is in the the uh Subs the the um the the the rule book that talks about your investigator and I actually really like

this piece of information I think it's a really neat way to set up this game so he uh here it says that a weary Victor you've styed another threat from the cthulu Mythos but at Great sacrifice you need to rest you go to Arkham a peaceful college town to recover little do you dream the fate of awaiting you I think that's really cool I love that setup I love that these investigators in this game are already well aware of the cthulu Mythos they have already done something somewhere else to thwart some kind of scheme from the ccds from the cthulu cycle deities and now they're coming to the nice peaceful quaint town of Arkham Massachusetts for a vacation and they arrive at the train station only to find the city being overrun by Gates and monsters and having to deal with them yet again and I think this also translates to how you set up your investigator at the uh an investigator in tiptop shape in perfect health both mental and physical health would have seven sanity points and seven strength points however at the beginning of the game you have 10 points to divide between those two with the caveat that you can't go less than three so you can have a spread of seven and three six and four or five and five I have been playing my games of Arkham Horror first edition with a variety of spreads going

from six and four six and four five and five so if I was playing as Jenny Barnes I might take Jenny Barnes and have her set here to a five and five okay so we'll put a five there so she will start with five sanity points and she will start with five strength points and then I would take Joe diamond and I want Joe Diamond to be a little more on the physical side so I'll start him out with six and I'll start him out with six strength and four sanity and then let's say I was also going to play as let's let's play here as as Harvey Walters and I will have him be more kind of a book nerd guy so he'll start off with um I'll put six sanity and four strength like in Arkham hor second edition having three in one of your core stats is pretty big detriment because it's very easy to lose three four seems to be a lot safer now let's take a look at the Miniatures that you get with this game so here we have Harvey Walters as you can see Harvey Walters here with the detail there and we have here we have a Jenny Barnes there's a look at Jenny Barnes I'm sure people who like managers can paint these up and make them look really cool and then we also have Joe Diamond here and you'll get a picture of each of the other Miniatures on the uh cover there there we have Monteray Jack or on their

their character card there we have Carolyn Fern and Mandy Thompson Gloria Goldberg and Vincent Lee so yes the miniature craze was going all the way back to 1987 yeah okay uh so we have our investigators here and when you set up the game all the investigators R arrive into Arkham at the train station so they all start here at the train station each of your inventor uh inventors each of your investigators will start with three items and here we return to that kind of dreamlike familiarity where a lot of these things will be familiar but also slightly different so let's take a look at the items we have the sword of Glory is a magical item so again in this game there are monsters there are things that are um immune to that are resistant against physical attacks or maybe magic attacks so you have to have certain types of attacks to uh to beat certain monsters so we have magical we have a shotgun here it's a physical attack and uh combat is is pretty simple in this game you will take your fight skill and you will add any bonuses you will roll and then you will try to hit a target number or above to do damage so pretty simple um a little more straightforward than the dice pool system but I do prefer the dice pool system that was used in second edition here we have a dragon's eye a magical

item in this black Gem of unnerving aspect is dashed to the ground it banishes any one Mythos monster from Earth or Clos as any one gate lose D6 strength points from the concussion used once then discard we have our alien spectacles that's kind of a tri a trional or a tri spectacle or something um here we have the lamp of alhazred its Blaze adds a plus three magical attack whenever you wish this is one a one-handed weapon used for the rest of the game we have our 38 revolver we have our taxi whistle because as you move around on the board you can take a taxi to get to certain places much faster we have a knife we have a healing stone another shotgun brass collar we have an auction and this is a really weird card because because this is a well it's interesting to think about and this kind of points to maybe one of the design flaws that lonus came up with or that that that is is apparent in this game and that is even though it is Co-op there is also still a little bit of a competitive nature to the game and I think back then it was just really hard for people to wrap their hands heads around a game that wasn't competitive in some way and so we do have this pamphlet here the welcome to Arkham p pamphlet and this tells you a little bit about the game actually has some AA on here that they discovered after they uh printed the game and we do have our our our

component listing there but here we have the role of honor and here is where you write down the winner of your compe of your Cooperative game because the winner is whoever collects the most gate trophies and monster trophies and so even though this is cooperative there still is that competitive Edge and the auction card works that way however I think modern Gamers who want to play 100% cooperatively could actually use this card to Great Advantage because what this card does is when somebody plays this auction card you draw a certain number of items and then you have an auction well if you're playing cooperatively nobody should bid anything except for the one player who really needs it can bid $1 and get any item for $1 so it does kind of break that style of play and playing this game solo some people have come up with some house rules to use this auction card usually if I draw the auction I just kind of ignore it and draw something else here we have a submachine gun here we have our Elder Sign I believe there are four Elder signs in this deck and like in a second addition this sign can be used to destroy a gate and also sealing a gate sealing a location so that more gates can't appear there and the way you win this game is at the End by the end or not starting at the end of the second turn you need to have all of the gates closed and a gate opens every turn the way you lose is every time a gate opens

you move up on the Doom track and if you ever get to 14 then too many gates have opened and uh you lose the game if any of your investigators uh reach zero sanity or zero strength while in Arkham they go to this hospital or the sanitarium and they can get well if they ever lose they go down to zero strength or zero sanity in the other worlds here like in the abyss or the other dimension or um arer or Yogo or the Earth's dreamlands then they perish they get lost in time and space they're out of the game and the player will roll up a a new character with new starting abilities and they will start back at the train station so we have our Elder signs there we have our flute of the outer Gods we have our blue Watcher of the pyramid another Elder Sign the ruby of arer another auction card the silver key the Silver Bullet a silver bullet is used to kill one of the monsters you have a werewolf we have dynamite and 45 and yeah so just just a whole bunch of the same kind of style of of items that we see in Arkham Horror second edition and it's really cool to see where those came from so if we give those a mix and then let's just build out uh Jenny Barnes here as an example so Jenny Barnes would start with three items we'll discard the auction she'll start with the the brazened head she'll start with an 18 daringer and a silver bullet

so not a great collection of starting items but hey sometimes you get that great collection and sometimes you don't uh characters investigators will also start with one spell and once again we're going to see a lot of similar spells here and to cast a spell you roll under your knowledge uh stat here so Jenny Barnes would have to roll a four or under to cast a spell here we have the mist of arer and that is to successfully avoid an enemy to sneak past an enemy uh we have the bind Monster uh banish monster from Earth monster attacks Target or gate so you can control the monsters to have them do your bidding we have a power drain we have the dread cursed of the dread curse of azathoth uh we have power drain again we have a find gate we have flesh Ward and bind monster find gate shriveling bind Monster uh the power of I gazi we have a healing spell another bind monster bind monster wrists uh Mists of Harley the wrist of Harley of AR a healing spell the power of I Gaza find gate so not a ton of variety there was more variety in the Spells but you'll recognize a lot of them and each of the investigators also starts with one spell so let's see Jenny bar starting spell the power of ibben Gaza it's a plus seven magical attack I have to do a successful knowledge check to cast the spell and it also cost one sanity but that gives me a plus seven to attack

monsters who need magical attacks to defeat them okay we also start off with a charity card and the charity card is a card that you can take down here to the dayon mission and if you go to the mission and you are character that has the lowest amount of money the fewest items or I believe also the fewest spells the order of daygon will give you some of those items to make up the difference but then you are in debt to them and the next time you kill a monster or close a gate that trophy gets donated to the mission and so again that kind of points to that semi Cooperative semi competitive nature of this game if you are playing to be the number one investigator you don't want to use that card because you will lose a victory point for your total at the end and then finally each of the characters actually each of the characters will will also start with $13 and so we have our $5 bills here with uh lovecraft's face on there he's also on the 10 wow Lovecraft was on the five and the 10 maybe they could have put like Clark ason Smith on one of these or something but we have two $10 there and then we have our $1 bills here with old George Washington and so each of the investigators will start with $13 and also one skill and so here we have our skill cards now these are in

different colors and the game says that they did this on purpose so that when you draw one at random you might remember what the different colors are so you have a better chance of knowing what's coming I don't know that seems a little weird to me but these skills will just add one to one of your ability such as fast talk fight knowledge and sneak so we have a sneak plus one knowledge plus one knowledge plus one fast talk plus one fast talk plus one fight and fight plus one and sneak plus one so pretty boring skills but they don't they don't really have names or anything they're just something that adds one so let's Shuffle these up and draw one at random for Jenny Barnes here and so she is a fast talk plus one so that brings her fast talk up to four all right so that would be how you set up an investigator so Jenny Barnes would be all set up and then she would be at the train station here we've taken a look at items we've taken a look at spells we've taken a look at the investigators now let's take a look at all of the different locations and I really do like the look of this map I think it has a nice kind of quaint and just a a pleasant look to it and I believe this was the original board that very similar to the original board that Richard lonus Drew and I think you can see his original map I think I've seen a picture of his original map on online before but we have uh places like the hospital the sanitarium the newspaper uh Harney Jones sha the graveyard the city hall the

black cave the Silver Twilight Lodge miskatonic University the Curiosity shop The Boarding House velma's Diner uh the historical society and so on and so all of these locations all so many of the locations that we remember from Arkham hor second edition are here now what is missing are the location encounter cards and that's because this game didn't use cards for its location encounters it used a series of lookup tables and the lookup tables were used for the gates to other worlds and for when you land on one of the locations and this game also uses a rooll to move and we'll talk a little bit more about rooll to move and why I actually think it does work in this game game in just a minute but here we have all of our lookup tables for the different uh gates for when you go into your other worlds so if you were to go to yoth there and on one of your encounters you would roll a D6 and you would look up two the cylindered head mocks your hopes you'll never return it cackles lose two sanity points from Despair and like second addition you have two Encounters in each other world before returning to a gate in Arkham and having the chance to to close it now when you land on one of the spaces such as the city hall then you open up your Gazette here and you find the city hall and again you roll a D6 two uh a mail clerk gives you an envelope containing payment from enigmatic magazine collect $6 very cool

so here we have all of our different lookup tables for the black cave the daygon mission The Boarding House dark's Carnival Devil's Beach City Hall the Curiosity shop founder Rock the graveyard Harney Jones Shack Lake miskatonic the library the Historical Society uh the lighthouse miskatonic University the hospital and hibs Roadhouse we also have the newspaper Silver Twilight Lodge North Church the train station velus Diner police station shunned house the sanitarium and the woods and so in second edition these would all be decks of cards and what's interesting is they handled it very simp similarly in that when you go to hary Jones Shack here you will always roll a six and so you H you will roll a D6 so you have the opportunity opportunity to have the same encounter multiple times in a row and that is kind of the same in Arkham Horror uh Second Edition because you're supposed to shuffle those decks after every encounter so you have the chance to come across the same thing more than once now there was a planned expansion for Arkham Horror first edition Edition and it never came out but some of the files can be found on Board Game Geek and some of those files introduced alternate lookup charts for all of the existing locations and so you if you get this game you can actually print out the new lookup charts so you will have D more variety in what you're

trying to do the expansion the planned expansion also had a different map that had different other worlds so instead of the Abyss another dimension city of the great race Earth's dreamlands the Great Hall of salano the plateau of Lang ARA or Yogo we had Atlantis carcosa formal hot the Hall of narot the Hideous Caverns Frozen hyperboria interior of the Moon irm city of pillars the nameless City Saturn the Throne of azathoth and valua and so I guess you could play where you could just substitute these for those to have a little bit more variety but you don't get the monsters Associated to these new gates but I think that it was pretty cool that they did allow this kind of old uh piece of of documentation to be reprinted and made available on on Board Game Geek so in addition to the investigators and the locations being similar the monsters are also somewhat similar and you will recognize a lot of them what you may not recognize is the great old ones and that's because in first edition here the great old ones are not scenarios they don't really change up the game as a matter of fact they are just on small tokens just like all of the other monsters what's different is that they are called powers and they come out with uh with Gates because you will draw monsters randomly from a bag I don't have a Crown Royale

bag to draw my monsters from in this game because one won't fit in the box so I have I have a small bag here to put all of my monster tokens in but let's set up a gate first because uh that's what you do at the beginning of the game you set out one gate and three random monsters now my copy of the game was missing one gate card so I had to make one and the color is off a little bit but hey you know what that doesn't really bother me too much but you will Shuffle up your gate cards and then you will actually roll 2d6 and you will look at this gate appearance table just off the camera here to determine where they come from if you roll a seven a gate will appear at Founders Rock so Founders rock is kind of the most unstable uh location in first edition and you will also have extra monsters so you have a really good chance of of hitting Founders Rock but let's see where our first gate would show up a four so if we look up four it will show up at the Lighthouse and the lighthouse is right here so we will draw our gate we don't know where that goes until we investigate it so we put a gate token or gate card right here on the lighthouse and then we would draw three U monsters at random but if we return back to the goo back to the great old ones those are represented by these black tokens and they're called powers and they don't move they just protect Gates they are gate Guardians and when you destroy the gate that they are guarding then they get sent back to that realm and so as far as the goo go we have iqua we have gatona we have yo

cthulu and shab naroth so those are the great old ones and again they are just gay Guardians and then we also have our our kind of standard uh creepy monsters and those are represented by these black tokens here and so we have things like the maniac the maniac we have a vampire we have a ghost we have a werewolf another Maniac another ghost a maniac and a zombie and so these will all get thrown into the bag to draw randomly now if you look at the monsters here and this is a little fil this is where first edition is a little fiddly and how the monsters move they will have a facing corner so the monster moves around the board towards that arrow that it's facing and it has a direction that it wants to turn when it reaches a Crossroads when it reaches a junction and the maniac here will always turn towards the right towards that Circle and it moves five places so if the um let's say say that the uh the maniac was here on this taxi space it was the Mythos turn we have to move our monsters we would move the maniac five so one two now it comes to this Junction and it turns right so two three four and again it turns right five and so that is how the uh the monster how the maniac would move around the board some monsters turn

left some monsters turn right sometimes that traps monsters in a little area in a corner so a monster might be guarding just this area or guarding just this part of the neighborhood or maybe just this part sometimes they wander more aimlessly around I think that's pretty cool it's a little fiddly to keep track of but it does make it so the monsters do have a rudimentary form of AI that keeps them moving around and that kind of points to why I think that the role to move Works in this game because almost all of the monsters except for I think the hounds of tendal uh they they stay out of the locations the monsters don't move into locations Guardians the powers they will stay at the locations cthulu does not walk around the streets of Arkham neither does yog Soo although I think that would be pretty funny if cthulu was just kind of stomping around Arkham there but um you really want to race from one location to the next you don't want to be caught in the streets of Arkham in this game because you will get attacked by a lot lot of monsters and I think rolling to move kind of simulates the danger of moving from one location to the next to avoid that kind of peril so that's why I do think that that roll to move does kind of work here and then we also have all of our other monsters and those are kind of colorcoded to the different gates to the different dimensions so here we have the abyss we have our Yellow Monsters and those are things like

Ghouls and formless spawn and so those will go back in there we have our another dimension and those are kind of our reddish color and here we will have things like dimensional shamblers we will have our hounds of Talos there dimensional shambler and Talos and on the back of your monster chits you will have their movement you will have what you need to roll meat meat or or or beat above in order to do damage you will also have how much damage they do to you when you fail or even when you succeed a sanity check so it is possible to avoid sanity damage but sometimes you take it no matter what we have our city of the great race and from those we have our absolutely Dreadful flying polyps the flying polyps were just terrible in this game and they're terrible in second edition you never want to face off against a Flying Pop we have our Earth's dreamlands and so there we have our night gauns night gauns can pick up uh investigators and drop them in nearby Gates we have our gugs and our night guns there and then we also have our Great Hall of celano now the colors I feel really bad for color blind people here because there are no symbols and a lot of the colors just kind of like flow together here we have yellow red uh light orange and dark orange and then we have blue blue and purple and all of those kind of look the same especially

to me and we do have green there but uh Great Hall of celano we have the byaki we have the star spawns and there are also flying monsters which kind of work the same in second edition they will move towards the closest investigator in the street but they do stay on the board they don't move off into the skies like they do in second edition uh from the plateau of Lang of course we have our Elder things and our shog Goths and then in ARA of course we have our star spawn our deep ones and star spawns our little cthul guys there and then finally from the realm of Yogo we have our Migos and we have our dolls and so at the beginning of the game you'll uh put your bag together you will randomize these you will draw three monsters that start in your initial gate so let's see what we have here okay so we have a ghoul ghoul from the abyss we have a ghost and ghosts don't move ghosts haunt locations so they're one of the uh creatures that can stay in a location so we have a ghost haunting a lighthouse perfect so thematic I love it and then we have oh no a hand of Talos so yeah these guys are nasty too you don't want to face to off against a Hound of $10 okay so we basically have everything set up and now we can do a little bit of a just a little bit of an example turn this isn't a Teach video because I'm sure I will get some rules wrong the

rules in this game yes the the the rules do leave a lot to be desired so we have two rule books one about your investigator one about the rules one about Arkham we do have our order of play so unlike second edition an investigator takes their full turn here we don't divide things up into uh into phases but you could play like that and I think in Paul Darcy's video he does play more like second edition where all of the investigators move then they all have their counters and then the Mythos phase and so on but I'm pretty sure that the rules as written you do all the steps and then it's the next investigator's turn so the first thing we do is we we the investigator acts we can wait we can move or we can move and take a taxi uh we could wait at the trading station and have a random encounter there to see what happens or we could move it's hard to get to a location on your first turn unless you roll really well for movement or you have a taxi whistle uh one of the things you want to do one of the strategies is the outer locations are a little more unstable so you have a better chance of things appearing in some of the outer locations you want to kind of make your way towards the city center to hopefully buy some things I really actually I want to get over here towards the Curiosity shop but having this gate at this Lighthouse makes the Curiosity shop a really dangerous proposition that really bumps me out

let's roll here and see where we're going okay an eight all right so 1 2 3 4 5 six I could get to the black Gate 1 2 3 4 5 6 I could go to the shunned house I could investigate the woods I could go to Harney Jones Shack there and come around the outside going there 1 two 3 4 five 6 78 I can't quite make it to the North Church uh let's head to our hary Jones Shack so 1 2 3 3 4 5 6 okay so I'm at Hardy Jones check and now we have our encounters so we can either wait we can roll for an encounter we might need to have sanity checks or strength checks here uh we can earn or lose money we can purchase fine items use a skill use a charity card or meet and meet a monster and if you meet a monster that's when you enter into combat okay but we are at hary Jones Shack so let's open up our Gazette and roll up our D6 to see what we find and oh one okay that is probably really bad hary Jones Shack a monster appears yes so a monster is hanging out at hary Jones Shack and so when a monster appears you draw a random monster and what do we have here we have a dimensional shambler and so we would have to fight this dimensional shambler now because the monster appeared it doesn't actually stay on the board we go through our rounds of combat or I can't sneak by it and and avoid it because it doesn't have Ambush or anything like that and so and then it would actually just go back into the bag and so combat

again is pretty simple we have to hit an 11 or higher in order to hit that dimensional shambler but the first thing you do when you face off against the monster is you have a sanity check if we pass our sanity check we take zero sanity damage if we fail it we take two sanity damage Jenny Barnes has a five of of Sanity so as long as I don't roll a six five I pass the sanity check and I don't take any damage damage now she can fight the dimensional shambler the dimensional shambler is not immune to physical damage so I can do a fight check so that'll be a three and let's see do I have any weapons I do have my daringer which gives me a plus two so that's a five if I was fighting against a werewolf I could discard My Silver Bullet To Kill The Werewolf so I'm getting a plus two and a plus three of five I would have to get a six in order to even uh do damage to the the dimensional shambler and a six yes 11 all right so we hit the dimensional shambler I take the dimensional shambler as a trophy uh it's off the board if it stayed on the board that's when it would go back into the bag now if I didn't uh kill the dimensional shambler it would do a D6 damage to my strength so yeah a single Monster can wipe out an investigator very very quickly okay so that would be my encounter phase and then we would have a Mythos phase and uh there isn't really any story in the Mythos phase here there's no flavor text you just roll

your 2d6 and you look at your chart over here in eight the Silver Twilight Lodge we would draw a gate card we would put the Silver Twilight Lodge there a monster always comes with a gate and so we have a vampire and then we would do our movement okay so our movement here the vampire we moves in that direction and he it turns towards the right towards that Circle so it moves five it would go one turning right 2 3 4 5 okay then down here our ghoul turns right and it moves six spaces so it comes out of the lighthouse 1 2 3 4 5 six like that our flyer here just moves towards the uh the the the investigator on a street and so I'm a little unclear about how these guys move if there are no investig ators on the streets and so I think they just kind of move towards the investigator that's at a location and they are moving eight so 1 2 3 4 5 6 78 and then finally our ghost our ghost stays haunting its Lighthouse that's where the ghost lives so unfortunately we'll have to deal with that ghost let's fast forward a bit and say that I was over here at the Silver Twilight Lodge and I was moving in and I wanted to close this gate I wanted to to investigate the gate on your encounter phase you would turn the gate over and this is a gate to

the city of the great race and this takes a 13 or higher to destroy and you do that just as the same with combat but you can add bonuses and you can add die rolls and you have to either 13 or higher to destroy or use an elder sign but once you find the gate then you teleported to the first space of that other world and so we are going to the city of the great race which is at here and we are at spot number two and then we have an encounter in the other world and again you turn to your Arkham Gazette and I would being the city of the great race here and a four the canonical entity teaches you a spell draw a spell card nice all right so I would get the bind monster spell very powerful and then on my next turn for movement just like in second edition you don't have movement points now you just move to the next encounter you have another encounter and then on your next turn you move out to any of the corresponding cards that correspond to that space so there if there were more gates to the city of the great race you could come out on another one and then you have a chance to close that gate if you have an Elder Sign you can place the Elder Sign there to to seal it and then every time you draw a new gate you move up on the Doom of Arkham and there is a limit to uh how many gates can appear per player count and total so if you ever get to 14 here on the Doom track you lose the game and your main goal is to just close the gates and that's how you win uh starting at the end of the

second turn you want to have all of the gates closed and that is how you win the game so overall I was surprised by how much I enjoyed my time with this but I don't think I would encourage most people to seek it out uh and paying those collector's prices as a matter of fact I bet with some clever Google Fu you could probably find the things you need online to create your own DIY copy and it would probably be um as good if not better quality but there is a lot to like about Arkham Horror first edition and I'm really happy that I decided to start this series with this game and I'm very happy that this game is now part of my collection at first I wasn't sure if I would ever play this game um in Li of a second edition or Elder tour or Elder Sign you know it is is so old it is kind of archaic it is primitive it is simple and reductive but it's still really fun I think this game has a has kind of a different feel than the other games it's smaller it's easier to set up it's uh faster playing and it's not nearly as fiddly as the other games and so I think there are times in the future where when I want to play an Arkham files game I would actually choose first edition over second edition however I still like second edition a lot more because I enjoy that art and that they used in the Fantasy Flight games and I like just it

has an abundance of stuff that is super cool I like eldrich horror more I do like Elder Sign more and the other games more but I'm so happy to have this as part of my collection and just kind of this historical uh piece of of gaming history here it also comes with a few other things we have a chaos Inquirer uh this is a 1989 winter product list so we have some thing I love seeing these old advertisements we have the miskatonic U graduate kit that you could buy for $9.95 and we also have some more ARA there for uh some certain things they talk about some of the colors and how they weren't able to get the colors to match because as you close certain Gates Monsters of that color also get destroyed and with some of the monsters some of the chits it's really hard hard to tell what color they actually are but uh yeah overall I am very happy with Arkham horor first edition I'm so happy that I got the opportunity to experience this game it's one that I've known about for a long time and I kind of feel I just feel very happy that I was able to experience this kind of uh piece of of of gaming history and to see where the board game style of call of cthulu of of the cthulu meos began and to see the seeds that Richard lus planted here and how those seeds would grow and flourish into second edition into all these other games has been a really really great

time so all right you guys well I hope you enjoyed this super epic first episode of the Arkham Horror retrospective we will see you next time take it easy bye-bye

Progress saved