Board Games I Got Rid Of (And Why) - Episode 28
Transcript
hey everybody and welcome to another edition of board games I got rid of and why now in this series I talk about games that I've previously had in my collection but for one reason or another no longer do I've got another 10 games to talk about today but before I do I want to give a shout out to the show's sponsor keyienda dot Co dot UK who are my go to online retailer and if you use the link in my show notes or the QR code then you can get five percent off your first order the first game I'm talking about today is Letters From White's Chapel now this hidden movement game was actually in my collection for many many years we did get some plays out of this one and out of all the hidden movement games I've played I think this one is still my favorite one as one person takes the role of Jack the Ripper they're going around London trying to kill these prostitutes and all the other players are police officers trying to track down Jack and track them basically and find exactly where he is so he can be arrested and it's got some nice Simplicity to this one there's no super Superfluous rules there's no fiddliness so it's quite nice and pure and which is what I want from a hidden movement Style game because all the other ones I've seen to play just are a bolting more and more things on to try and differentiate them once this one stays true to what hidden role or hidden movement game uh should be but I think more of a personal thing uh I do find these games quite frustrating um because Jack did have a few a few
Tools in his toolbox that could really throw the police off track and it became quite difficult to recover from that yes after a few rounds in the game you could probably narrow things down more and more and more but um the process was long and it took a long time to get um to that point and because of how long this one took it did keep it from getting played it was sat on the shelf for many many months or even years at a time before it would get played again and you know with space being a premium I need to be getting these games played regularly for them to Warrant a place on the Shelf so you know if I did have infinite infinite space this would probably still have its place on my shelf because I don't have another hidden movement game um but yeah this one's just a little bit too long and just a little bit too frustrating for me personally the next theme I'm talking about is Mob now mob is a pretty unknown game actually I believe the designer for this one was Dr Steve Finn of biblios Fame and this was another two player only kind of tug of war game as you are deploying these gangsters on these different streets and having a bit of a face off and um you know a little bit of worker placement a little bit of Track Climbing um I absolutely hated this game I did not like anything about it apart from the visuals very stylish and I'm deluxified looking game it looked a really premium product but the gameplay itself was very lucky it was really rigid for me and I got next to no fun out of this one um at all so I only paid it once or twice through my memories of the game is pretty hazy and but I just remember
having a very negative impression of it so therefore of course it was never going to stay next up we have Hippocrates now Hippocrates is a strange one actually because there were some things I really did not like about this game and there's some things I really did like about the game um and this was a a kind of a contract fulfillment game but it had this networking mechanism where you'd have to get the right doctor the right kind of potions and treatments um linked to the correct patients in order to cure them and get points um of course and I love the way that all these targets would slot together and you could use different doctors Specialties to cure these patients sometimes even happen to combine their powers together um I loved that part of the game and for me that should have been the core focus of it now the problem was that to get to That Fun Part there was a lot of Hoops to jump through like the drafting process to get the patients and the doctors was long and drawn out it was fiddly and tedious and it just seemed as a you know all bolted on um and it definitely did kind of drag you away from the fun part of the game so I really do feel this game needed to rebuild from the ground up or rebuild focusing on that core mechanism because it was definitely a fun game there and quite a cool little kind of spatial puzzle there but the rest of it should have been simplified it should have been a simple draft it should have been some very simple Trident test mechanism mechanisms rather than get going through all these motions just to get to the actual enjoyment of the game so you know for an hour and a half game that was not good enough I'm afraid um so therefore it did
not manage to hold its own on my shelf and it had to go next up I have a lawyer up now if there was ever a game that I wanted to like I think lawyer up might be right at the top of that list because I love the theme and setting with this one as one player is the kind of defense lawyer and one is the prosecution lawyer and you're trying to sway the juror to believe your side of the story and you're going to do that by playing cards and um influencing the different jury members through this tug of war system but unfortunately this is the kind of ton of war game that I find immensely um frustrating and a waste of time because it seems like no matter what I do you have a car to undo what I've just done so what that means is that throughout the first kind of three quarters of the game all your turns are completely useless and you know complete complete waste of time because the only thing that matters is the situation of those jury members at the end of the game so again it's all just a time wasting exercise going back and forth and back and forth until when it actually matters Anna because it's quite a long game they're not a lot but too long for what it is that was just not good enough and yeah another game I'd love to see reworked I'd love to see that theme and setting really explored and I think I have a deep dive into how to make it work mechanically but this was just not it but yeah a reasonably Valiant effort I just don't think it pulled it off at all next up we have the Guild of merchant explorers now this is essentially a flip
and right Style game as you're flipping these cards which will reveal a territory then you're placing these cubes rather than actually writing down on this big map which has been broken down into these hexes it's kind of an old school a cartography star map that looks very cool on the table and then you're kind of reaching out and spreading out reaching new places to get points in different ways essentially covering characteries and all that good stuff now I actually did like the game a lot and I actually think this game did a did itself a massive disservice by the way it was published because basically when you um well rather than having actual you know a pen and paper and actually just writing and scribbling out with ease at this one you'd place these cubes down and the map itself would become extremely congested and fiddly um and if you've got like big fingers or if you're a bit of a clumsy person then it's going to be an absolute nightmare to manage because everything is just so small whereas it could have just been a bit of a bit of paper and you could be taking boxes off as you go um it also felt like it did go on a little bit too long for what it was so I think this one really did get in its own way to be a kind of an evergreen game really because it did have a lot of good things going on it was probably one of the best flipping right Star Games I've played but for those reasons you know just pure usability issues that I just wasn't going to play anymore because it was just too much of a nightmare to get it to the table and actually um you know keep it going and actually keep on rejiggling things around so yeah sadly it could have been good one definitely a near Miss for me but those production
issues just um cost it his place on my shelves next up we have steam Time by rudiger Dawn now this is kind of a worker placement engine building Style game um as you're placing your workers down on these action strips and it does have this kind of Time Track system where when you go somewhere you cannot go back in yourself for the remainder of the round so you do have to jump ahead to get these real good action spots that you want you're collecting these gems and these gems are going to temporarily increase your ability to do different things so it was quite interesting how gems were like a points gaining resource but the longer you hold on to them it make you better at doing different things so it had a conflicting mechanism where do I want to hold on to these and be stronger or do I want to cash them in to actually get points and I do like the way that works but I generally tend to enjoy engine building games where once I've got something I've got it for the rest of the game therefore I'm always getting stronger and stronger and it does have that upward trajectory of what you want an Energy builders game to be with just one was a bit more start and stop start and stop which made you feel like you weren't really progressing too much now despite that I think the main issue in the kind of nail in the coffin for this game was that it was not colorblind friendly at all and me and my brother are both quite badly colorblind and this came became nearly unplayable for us because we could not decipher the different components from one another so you know I probably would have gave this one more chances if that wasn't the case
but sadly it was so therefore it's just a straight clean cut no it has to go because we cannot even play the game next up I have stroganoff which is the second game by game Brew on this list the first being a Hippocrates and this one I almost feel the same way as I do about Hippocrates because this one definitely did suffer from over engineering I had a lot of good things going on there as well as I had this kind of another time track system which you're pushing forward and collecting resources collecting abilities and fulfilling contracts climbing tracks and lots of traditional Euro style stuff but my main issue with this game and it was a huge issue was the actual turn structure and the actions you could selected because it became very confusing about what your options actually were because you'd have kind of bonus a basic actions you could do another basic action you could do main actions one of those main actions was like a basic action you could spend coins to do something else you could pay fair to do like a a repeat of an action tons of different things where you had to kind of go through this Advanced flowchart and know what you could even do and what you were capable of where it would have benefited much more if you had a very simple action selection system where said you know your operas are this this and this on your turn those are the games that I like they're much easier to teach they're much more playable and this one you'd have to kind of relearn the game each time you played it because not because of terribly complex but because it is so fiddly and needlessly so so if you're interested in this one because it does look lovely um
production quality isn't the best but it does look nice uh I would recommend you check out my review of this one because I do go into some detail about that action selection system which is just again completely over engineered and overwrought and that was enough for me not to keep it anymore next up I have Madame Ching by Bruna kathala now this is a full-size board game but it does feel more like a card game as you're stringing these cards along trying to play them in a numerical order and you're traveling along this map from the kind of left-hand side of the board to the right hand side of the board and as you do you're kind of falling down in this kind of downwards diagonal pattern trying to get as far as you can and collect these points cards now the game was fine and I did like this degree of full planning where if you'd run out of cards you'd decide to keep some back for the next round so you can go further later but my main issue with this one was the lack of Crescendo it did feel like the game had an anti-climax to it because you would find that pretty much early in the game or Midway Point everyone would be getting right across the map and getting a whole chunk of points and that mean that that meant that all the high points scoring tiles were taken quite early and after that you'd have to kind of stop earlier and earlier and earlier to get the next highest so rather than getting stronger and stronger and traveling further and further you do the opposite which just felt a little bit strange um for me I thought the carplay was fine it wasn't terribly interesting um and ultimately it just left me feeling pretty meh I didn't really feel
anything strong about it just a pretty much Bland and just another board game I suppose so yeah one that I would really recommend I think it's completely forgettable that is Madame ching and ultimately we're talking about Pay Dirt another game with a cool theme as you are harvesting this dirt and trying to drag out these gold nuggets from that dirt you'll you've got this kind of heavy equipment you're constantly improving your equipment to make you more efficient and faster at doing it um so I love the premise of this one very logical in the way that it worked however it did have some very obvious issues the first of which is quite minor which meant that when you drafted uh these new kind of upgrade cards they weren't in a layered deck meaning that sometimes the best cards will come out early and you'd get those cards and then never go back to that work replacement spot therefore rendering that part of the game board pretty much void and that one forgivable the next part I thought was completely unforgivable and that is the ketchup mechanism in this game so every round you would draw these hardship cards and they were drafted in order from the people with the fewest points eventually going to the person with the most points so the winner would get the worst of the bunch and those cards um were huge in um and how much they could impact your turn like some of them were completely debilitating and made your next turn completely useless and therefore it was like a very arbitrary enforced way to make people behind catch back up with you through no fault of your own so I
definitely think this one game could have rained back on that part of the game just made it a little bit more forgiving for people actually doing well at the game because you think like why do I even bother why even try I'd rather be in you know second place or you know last place until later in the game because I don't want to be absolutely smashed by the game itself so for me it was just way too ham-fisted it was too much to overcome and just yeah just not subtle at all so therefore Pay Dirt had to go and the final game I'm talking about today and it's probably my favorite of the bunch uh this is Okanagan so Okanagan is actually a really nice hybrid tile placement area control set collection contract fulfillment Style game so it does all those things but it Blends them together in a very nice way as you're drafting these um tiles playing them on a communal map and then you're placing one or three different types of these pieces you're using to control these regions some would kind of touch all the different regions on the tile some would be in very specific locations and some will go in the border between two different types of terrain and then you are trying to basically have the majority in order to collect the tokens in those trains in order to complete end game contracts that's pretty pretty much the flow of the game and I liked pretty much everything about it except one thing and that is the way that there were certain points in the game and certain abilities you could use to draft new end game scoring cards which would generally you know divided
out at random and sometimes you'd be collecting these towels you'll draw one of these new cards and it will not match your tokens you've collected at all sometimes you draft them and it would match perfectly what you've already collected so there's this huge swing of luck about that card draw is it going to fit what you've collected already or is it not and that has been enough to swing several games of this that I've played you know where I've drawn a lucky card it's completely matched what I've got and I pretty much doubled my points through sheer luck so I think it would have been a lot nicer if the cars were divided out in a more deterministic way maybe that could be house ruled I don't know but with so many great games out there I'm not really willing to do that work myself and it should have been a rule in the rule book so you know maybe that's a petty thing for me to say I don't know um but this game takes so many boxes for me probably one of the nearest misses I've ever played uh that is Okanagan so there we have it that's another 10 games that have left my collection if you've played any of these games and you feel differently about them than I do then please do let me know and if you have enjoyed the video please be sure to hit like And subscribe to my channel and everybody else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye-bye