Skip to main content
Loading video...

10 RED FLAGS to Watch Out for in Crowdfunding Campaigns!

Transcript 29:29

hello welcome to crackalope thank you for being here today we're talking to you about good advice around kickstarters yeah like you should keep in mind the things that you should be wary of uh are tips and tricks for how to work our way through the platform and maybe not invest money where we'll never see a good return uh whether that's the product not showing up which is few and far between or the more likely case it coming in and sitting on your shelf for Nair a eternity yeah now there is some construction happening in my house so if you hear some Rumblings in my tummy from far away I guarantee it's not just my unrelenting hunger for your brand new game fractured Sky it is also someone actually replacing the floor down to the kitchen this looks great I'm Austin Harris in from IV Studios uh you all are the Publishers of soon to be four titles yeah Mythic mischief moonrakers veiled fate an upcoming fractured sky this video is not an advertisement or promotion for fractured Sky it is a lovely game but we're going to be giving you advice to look for before you go back in and any other yeah project but I want to have this conversation because I come from a consumer uh and content creator perspective yeah so we are both purchasing a lot of games going through the cycle of getting everything and then backing off for a season I'll be honest like for the people watching I'm right now in the season where I'm backing very little I just don't have the money and I have so many other projects that are currently on their way to me and that

happens every probably six to 12 months from me I got ebb and ebb in and out of that type of habit you come from the side of a bubble publisher I also still back a ton of stuff we're super Baggers yeah it's usually I get into this like cycle where I don't back that much and then when my friend launches a game you're back in I get in there but then I see all the other stuff and I'm like yeah and that and that and so there's so much cool stuff there's a lot of cool stuff on there it's it's really if it's like you have to be on the lookout for it can become an addiction yeah and it's one of those things like you shouldn't go look at it if you you shouldn't be spending money and then from a content creator side we do things that clearly advertise products like we are excited to be covered covering your new game yeah we're doing gameplays of it we're taught doing previews of it we're gonna be talking about the stuff that we think is awesome about it because and I tell people this I'm very open with this I want everyone to back your game yeah I also want no one who will not like your game to back your game both of those statements can be true at the same time my Approach when it comes to content creation is to show off and get games in front of your eyes the viewer as much as possible I want you to back the games that you're going to fall head over heels in love with and there are some audience members out there that this will be your favorite game for the next year once it arrives I guarantee that and at the same time if you don't like slight area control if you're not looking for bidding or bluffing I should give you all that information so that you also know that this isn't a game for for you because a bad backer not only hurts my reputation if I'm telling them

that they might like this game but also they're the people that are going to be complaining in the kickstarter they're the people are going to be leaving bad news they're the people that are going to be telling their friends not to play not to buy not to invest in games that are good yeah because games are games can be amazing and be the least favorite game from a multitude of people yep terraforming Mars you know it probably has some of the biggest controversy out there in the world people either love it or hate it I find very few people who are stuck right in the middle being like here's all right take it or leave it yeah you know they're either they're high or low all right so our advice around Kickstarter we'd love to hear yours what strategy have you developed while we go through ours I think you have ten I've ten and I wrote down five so I'm Gonna Let You Go I bet we have some overlap we probably do I'm Gonna Let You Go twice though before I go once okay so my first two are pretty close so I'll put it together when I'm looking at a page and I'm trying to decide whether it's a project that I'd be interested in backing or just I think that is ready to be at the stage where it should be on Kickstarter sure is a rule book there has to be a rulebook link you want a public rule book I want a public now you're not going to read the rule book are you no you're just gonna see that it's there I am going to see that it's there now someone else will read that's the right answer yeah I don't have time to read it but looking and seeing that there is a rule book yeah is important and I might glancer to make sure it's like got design and it's finished it's got examples and you know has an index but if if there's not a rule book that tells me there isn't a game it's a fair point it's funny because I think that's a newer tradition on Kickstarter it didn't used to be that historically it used to be a good

artwork picture and a promise yep a rule book though is a litmus test for yeah do you have a mechanic system that you can teach to someone and can be operational it doesn't have to be the final rule book it just needs to be somewhat functional sure sure that is an alarm going off very nice of my phone too alert me amazing great what's the alarm for that's fine it's for afternoon prayers okay uh just a reminder that sometimes you're gonna go no no no I don't go to a minion it's just it's just sometime around this time I need to be reminded or else it'll be 7 p.m and I will have I will completely have forgotten nice so that's what that is so after after this I'll go I'll go down that sounds good uh my second one about that TTS I was wondering if this is going to be on your list yeah so it's a little bit if you want a TTS or something okay equivalent mod it doesn't have to be it's not as big as the rule book for me because some people just aren't you know technologically savvy sure or maybe TTS doesn't work there's a mancala game that I was playing and they're like well we don't put it on TTS just because like how would you do this well sure and I agree it just wouldn't translate very well but so many games are actually play tested and finished on TTS digital all of our games are finished on digital spaces okay um now an open TTS mod no it doesn't have to be so if they are linking to a Discord where they have people that'll teach you the game we've done that in the past okay um and that was like a nicer control environment it's a little bit more like a way that you can get demo a way that you can demo the game if you want to is a major plus okay it's because the consumer has a chance then to take a little bit of the control that

the content creator has into their own hands right they can read the rule book they could demo the game if they want if they want to put in the time to double check their investment they have that option there and what I and what I'm clear about too is like well doesn't the game needs to be done and I think there are games that need to be done when they go to Kickstarter there are some games that don't a campaign game you can have a first mechanics right they don't have everything done because the story that is a thing that can be built out yeah once you've got the framework for the game system you're playing within that as you move forward I think like a campaign game needs to have you know session one or a or a session that is maybe a little bit further than session ones like an actual flavor of the game yeah but it doesn't have to be the whole game they don't need to be giving away the farm it's a crazy video we've got the rumbling in my tummy we've got my alarms perfectly perfectly planned my point number one I'm Gonna Let You Go to again don't buy games for a future you're unwilling to build oh wow this is so deep advice yeah well no I mean if I'm looking at a campaign and it's a solo game I could ask myself the question do I currently play solo games and if the answer is yes great I can go in if I'm interested I'm fine but if the answer is no I have to be committed to playing solo games at the point that I'm backing this I have to be willing to actually do that if I'm buying a game that is best at five players I have to be willing to build a group because I don't want to tell people not to buy games that don't fit the group they have currently because we are talking a year down the road but if you're unwilling to build that group if you're unwilling to go out

on a limb to make sure that the thing that you're backing is within the realm of what you can play you're not willing to prioritize yeah a game group that has five players consistently or at least once a month then this game doesn't need to come home no matter how cool it looks yeah it doesn't need to be with you I I like the way you phrase that because if you had said don't buy something that you're not interested in like um the van Rider uh final girl game series like if I was like thinking about getting in Solo games but I wasn't sure and then I also loved horror that would have been the perfect campaign to back yeah um but only from the perspective that I am backing this I know it's a solo game maybe two player if you're like me yeah yeah I know it's I know it's a solo game puzzle I don't do that yep am I willing to change am I willing to that's a good one because it takes games are work games it takes effort to prioritize the time arrange the people coming together the host at someone's house learn the rules table the game and many people end up myself included I'll watch you know all of Wednesday instead of getting final girls to the table right right which so totally get you there all right outstanding projects past projects this is actually easy to check on Kickstarter you didn't Switch app and you can say how many are still you go don't get there go look at their updates yep um and so that's something that I look at and then um I I'll compare that one with the shipping date so if they have a shipping date that is you know a year out

and they're still like oh this is not final and like we haven't submitted files yet and you know the rule book's still in process and like I start to question whether they can hit that date sure um and then I look at their past campaigns and if they've hit it in the past then they probably can but they haven't in the past then I'm going to start saying okay is it okay with me if this doesn't come for a year and a half if it doesn't come for two years and that's a really hard thing and it's also really start in the industry because we've had veiled fate was very late now it was right in the middle of the pandemic and the factory shut down but still lots of excuses I can make it was very late it was it was eight to nine months late I think um and so that's very late now at that point we hated that feeling and so we said we're gonna deliver Mythic mischief and failed and tighten very very quickly and you're doing it and we're doing it um and so you know you just have to look at track record like people looked at our track record when Mythic mission was live and they're like oh man build fade hasn't even delivered yet and that probably hurt us and I think it probably should have sure um and so you just need to make sure that they're able to deliver but they're also needs to be some Grace there I'm not saying like if they don't if they've missed their timeline like believe me stuff happens we thought we'd delivering to everyone in Titan in January everyone was in their timeline yeah the question is are they likely to do it again are they or are they a month late or two years later yeah like there's a big difference yeah it's a big difference yeah number four for you uh so shipping date was my kind of time with that group together yeah like you need to know and it's this is totally separate you need to know when it's expected to come because I have people all the time that email me and they're like hey I just

back Titan like three months ago I'm kind of surprised I haven't gotten it yet yeah and I'm like oh well did you look at your pledge and it says it's coming next year um and I got an email and they're like uh they want to change your address and they were like it's finally delivering and I was like well I mean it's not even supposed to deliver until next month so like finally delivering is the wrong is the wrong word there I mean it has been timed it's been eight months you know it's been forever finally delivery uh so my point number two then yep uh is going to be go all in go all in or not not on everything okay so one of the fun things about Kickstarter or any of these crowdfunding platforms is the opportunity to be invested in something yeah I'm gonna spend 800 bucks I'm gonna spend 300 bucks I'm gonna get I'm gonna get the whole package right and when it comes in this is going to be my lifestyle game for six months right I have the minis I have the standees right I got two copies of the chord I got every expansion I got the mat the custom dice the plushies the T-shirt they sold yeah I went all freaking in and that's amazing that is great it'll burn you out if you do it on every project so choose a few have a budget maybe give yourself a range I'm not here to judge anyone else's personal financial you know system right what you work within for your household what I can say though is everyone uh other than uh maybe a few backers out there that just have enough that they don't need to worry about it no uh anyone in in in in my realm that I know of has to look at

Kickstarter and say hey I've got this much to spend and anything above this I start getting into morning of a situation so give yourself permission whether that's one project a year or five projects a year depending on what you're able to afford to really just kind of go crazy back it all get the giant mini from scene on go insane and then with the other stuff be comfortable picking and choosing recognize that you gave yourself permission there and don't try to do it on everything because you'll find that you're not only deeper in the hole than you wanted to be yeah you're not using the expansions and the extra bits and components that you got from everything because if every game's selling a dice tray and dice you're coming up too many you don't need that I got an Alexa alarm going off everything's happening crazy this is either way so that's that's my thought is on a mission to go all in on something I'm gonna piggyback on that I will say most times I see someone go all in and then they don't like the game if they have gone all in they can usually sell it for what they pledged or hire sure and if you don't go all in and you buy the the basic copy I mean that that's at retail now like that there's like other ways so like I'm not saying like you should do it with that in mind like I like your point I go all in because you enjoy it I don't Advocate and I don't think people should look at Kickstarter as a potential no I don't think there is a way to secure your loan right but you're still costing yourself a year and a half of a cash in hand no no so the interest in on that is is not necessarily profitable there are companies and I myself you know have am

not opposed the idea of looking at something and being like hey this is a cool project I think people are going to love this more than I expect yep I'm gonna buy 10 copies of them I'm gonna help the publisher out right have copies on hand but it shouldn't really be it shouldn't really be the the main objective yep like we did that with uh Townsville tussle that was when we were like hey I think I ordered six copies off the back of that right and we had it available for our patreon members we had it available to you know for for ourselves to play we did a few giveaways alongside of it yeah the giveaways that is a monetary value for our channel right that game is worth 400 on eBay we bought it at a hundred and we're giving away a 400 product all right having it available to our patreon members is something that allowed us to uh you know sell the game have it at a better deal than they could get it anywhere else but still be able to recoup some of the costs currently has a project live right now maybe not at the time of this video but they have an expansion set out right now so that's exciting yeah um all right so um my next one is the two ways that I most often would say are the ways that you can figure out if you would like a game and that is the Game Boy section and it's art and you could combine theme with part at the same time so gameplay sections have gotten really really good on Kickstarter where there is usually like a gift series that's walking you through sure you're gonna do this on your turn you're gonna do this on your turn you'll like start that kind of no no it was uh um no no no uh for me what I stole it from the idea is um Druid cities tidal blades okay how to

play section was fantastic it was really really good I've seen a few companies that do it well I know you all were some of the first when it came to like that animated graphics yep and and that it was animated on on Druid City's page so we we mirrored that go a lot of ways that was a great campaign page really really one of the best um anyway so um yeah the the how to play section in the art like I can get a feel of the mechanics and I'm going to feel if I like the theme and the art obviously that's not like super groundbreaking but what is groundbreaking is if one of those things is missing if the gameplay section is pretty sparse sure that's gonna make me be like okay and this actually happened recently the shortest campaign page I've probably ever seen was a slate spider sure there was almost no gameplay sure I backed it in a heartbeat because I love slave Aspire getting questions there were some gameplay videos out there sure sure but on the page wasn't on there there was no description of how the game played almost at all there was some card art yeah and there's a little bit description and that was it because it's just like it's kind of like the video game honestly honestly like me and Sam talked about like that was really smart because they they could have talked people out of backing it by explaining too much sure there's no way I wasn't backing it like I was just there I mean we were all in as well yeah yeah so anyway uh that was my two of mine okay moving on down be excited and engaged and I get a little like this is a piece of advice that I give often and people in my own game group kind of like stub their nose

at me a little bit for this but I really do think if you're going to be a hardcore Kickstarter backer no you should be engaged in the campaigns you're backing especially if you're putting money in if you're putting 500 into a project and you're not bothering to read the lore updates watch any of the coverage that's being produced check out the new stuff that you're unlocking during the campaign Publishers put effort into these yeah as a way to have you be part of the community so if you're a super backer if you're big on this project you should be excited about it if you're not excited during the course of the campaign I question the degree to which you're going to be excited when the game actually arrives as opposed to your theoretical hype and sometimes being excited in The Campaign Will Reveal things that make you decide that you're not actually interested in backing I mean what are some of the events that you've done in the past with with your titles like I know moonrakers had crazy stuff failed fate and crazy stuff so one of the biggest ways people are invested in build fate was we had a full ARG game where you were you were doing like a puzzle through the temple um and you were learning icons at lore and there was all kinds of like little mini puzzles she was voting on holographic color graphic cards constantly yeah that was I think we did like over 80 votes for that um which was a lot that was like daily there was new unlocks and new voting Mythic Mischief they helped pick new factions they picked new factions which is really fun which those are coming out real soon yeah uh and so if if you're going to be investing in a campaign it should be more than just your money it should be a bit of your energy your time your attention your care not only will it help the campaign do better you'll be

able to oftentimes speak into what actually delivers so you can customize the campaign to fit you more but also if you're not excited you're not excited why are you spending money yeah all right my next two um external review and comments section so these kind of tie in together it's how do you know kind of like the overall Vibe of the company okay and and this I I'm gonna say you need to be in the middle because they're going to be view videos and they're going to be comments that are like oh these aren't like super positive should I not like back these people uh and you know that's just common we always have a negative comment or two somewhere usually it's me but you know yeah Jesse coming in there and saying quack all the time um and then on the other side I'm looking for positive comments like oh my gosh like I loved your past games I can't wait to back this one thank you and so you're kind of trying to see like okay what is the feeling of people that have backed in the past the external review is more just what are people like Jesse saying about the game um and that's not just to see whether they liked it or not it's to see the mechanics and that ties into to what you were saying earlier just like you know the game needs to be something you're excited about so there's and there's there's different demarcations of content creator out there so for instance on our videos if we were a sponsored you know if we're gonna sponsored coverage which could be a gameplay a preview takes time so gameplay sometimes take 10 to 15 hours worth of production time for us to create as a team it makes sense for us to monetize that but from a viewer perspective there's a few things that you can check every content creator that's doing monetized content has to check a little box that has a little flag in the top Corner that says hey this video was directly sponsored by

some product that's in it that could be an ad read or that could be a specific sponsorship for the thing they're actually talking about uh something along gameplay content or or stuff that we do we also put a link in the description where we say hey this is a sponsored video or this game was provided by the publisher even if it was once a sponsored video because some people want to know that yeah and so uh oftentimes we'll have people that are watching our preview or gameplay content the Publishers will take that quote over to the side they'll have our video linked so you should just double check and uh and and find reviewers that match with your style and your your taste in games and then see what they're saying about it this ties really well into another one of my points which is know how to read between the lines there is a difference between a content creator or someone taking a quote from a content creator that says something along the lines of the area control and asymmetric player powers in this game are really interesting yeah because you could read it like hey the area control and asymmetric player powers in this game are really interesting but if that's the best line they could find it really interesting right whereas there's a difference between that and something that you have to hold you can hold their feet to yeah this game was incredible we laughed the entire time yeah this is one of my favorites that could be a negative too if it's a really serious game sure but it's like you know this is one of my favorite games of the year yeah that isn't sponsored review content but that is like things that people say during the course of gameplay things that people uh mention and talk about and so

you can read between the lines when it comes to content creators and what they're saying or what they're denoting uh on the page itself I always check for uh the variation in content creators like I don't want to just be me on a page I want a variety of different voices all saying that the game's cool right I'm excited when other people agree and like the things I like yeah and then on top of that I'm gonna read through the quotes and I'm gonna say like hey are any of these uh offensively positive yeah or are they all kind of weird in the Middle Ground giving you another back of the box style description but not actually saying the game itself is amazing totally so uh my next one is to fill out your pledge manager um number one way to not get your game that you spend a lot of money on is so Shira has started filling out mindful oh that's good it's amazing that's great because I just would let them ride I have definitely at least two times emailed Publishers going like hey I didn't fill up my pledge manager by the way I'm Quack a little uh please send me my I really like my game you don't have that you don't have that ability he has a little bit more weight no no but if you email me about then you know anyway no it it really is no because we as Publishers base all of our numbers off of things on that and you know people are like well you do extras and stuff like that yeah but if a hundred people don't back they don't fill out their pledge manager like it's really hard to know what would that hundred percent I have a hundred percent missed I I can there's at least one game that I know for a fact I have not

received and I am not receiving and I backed it because I didn't fill out the pledge manager it doesn't matter if I'm quackled or not and that's fair for the publisher if they don't have copies they don't have copies just for you of course not and that happens um following up on that is changing your address um most Publishers and this all breaks down to reading both of those reading videos like they'll tell you when the pledge manager is live they'll tell you when uh when you need to change your address but without fail like every campaign like that just it I want to help you I want to help you as much as I can I'm here to help you but once we move past certain timelines it becomes a lot harder to help you um it doesn't mean we're not going to try it doesn't mean we'll not make it right as any way we can but occasionally that just becomes a situation where it's like hey you didn't change your address and you moved to Canada and we already shipped your game to Denmark and so like your game that you paid for is in Denmark you gotta we can't get that back and and you're now in Canada like I can't ship you a game to Canada because I don't know where that game is yeah and that's like a hard situation to be in as a publisher because I want them to get their game I I kept for the longest time all of my pledges just going directly to my parents house yeah that's my parents weren't moving yep and I was moving every year yep and I was never gonna go back and find I forgot to change my Frost statement after yes I got the delivery uh thing I drove to my old house which is like 30 minutes away wow and I knocked on the door and she said did you get a board game delivered here and I was like yes how did you know she's like it was a massive box I figured someone would show up it was hilarious and I was like oh my

God so I but I literally like got the shipping notification and drove there now I've got stuff I've got stuff just coming here but yeah yeah that's that's a it's a risky thing my last piece of advice buy again play a game people say it all the time I really think it's good advice if you're and this counts I'm gonna I'm gonna extend this and say it's not just bringing a game into your home if you're backing a new game on Kickstarter play a game you already have that's unplayed or else you're gonna find yourself in a pile like I am where you have seven calyxes full of board games and you only have time to play through like seven of them a week yeah I'll never finish the I have I have a calyx worth of games downstairs that I desperately want to play yep I do not think I ever will yeah it's hard not perfectly piggy reacts on that but um mine's about supporting the community I like it when other Publishers join the community I think probably one of the best examples of that is Jamie from stonemeyer he talks about other games all the time or Brandon Sanderson Brandon's successful campaign okay went through and he's not in board games though what are you talking about okay also great Brandon says great we can talk about Brian sanctions um there are a lot of other people I could talk about here that that back other people's games I know that um yeah City James Hudson backs a ton of games it's actually one of the things that I look for when I'm I'm checking out a new publisher yeah have you backed other projects because those are public at least not the projects you've always backed are but at least the number of other projects you've supported but it's also not just aspirational it's not just like oh yeah they're supporting the community they

know how a Kickstarter functions or game found functions because they have gone through the process on your side yeah and and that's important well and also if you follow people who have created campaigns that you back so if they go and follow Ivy Studios because they can because you're a Creator and Kickstarter and you all back a project they get an email I I have backed things that uh you know Patrick leaders back to back things that that uh you know Tom vassal is back because I got an email ping that said hey this person just backed this project and I thought to myself oh interesting why is that worth checking out they saw something here that I didn't see so I'm gonna go support this yep and then the last thing is just go check BGG see what their other projects have done and see what the comments are about them most of their projects are like a 6.5 on BGG yeah it's probably this will probably be a 6.5 on BGG it's probably worth at least checking the designers BGG credits too like because like I mean Publishers work with a bunch of different designers so that's not necessarily going to be good yeah the Publishers are also the litmus for a lot of the development work that happens in the final production runs I should think it affects the number yeah and I'm not I have games that I adore that are a six zombies of course I'm not saying I'm not saying don't don't bag it I'm just saying it's a good info I'm saying if everything's right in the middle yeah you know it's not a it's there's some games that you back like for instance I I could say IV Studios yeah but I'm not going to I'm going to say the the company that made endless winter and uh unconscious smile you know what I'm talking about I have I have endless winter I don't have unfortunately on them so so that that

company uh specifically someone will leave a comment down below that company so far has made like five out of five games for me yeah perfect games same thing with orange nebula orange nebula is a company that has made perfect games for me doesn't mean I love every single aspect of their game but like their games are about as good as I can imagine a game being yeah and so if orange nebula launches a title I'm back in their project yeah there are other companies out there that have had hits and misses for me and there's some that have had just misses yeah and so from my side I'm either avoiding them or I'm doing a little bit more research right I don't need to do any research on an onep game no I don't I'm backing them of course yeah they're amazing Spirit fire yeah coming out I'm in this year I I've not been emailed about it I have an email but I have no information about it and I think it's supposed to be this year I hope it's still supposed to be they've said it's it's their you know uh uh I desperately hope that I'm excited I am working on that they've been working super hard on so yeah they don't they've been in their burrow they don't come out and talk to us content creators until they've got something well Vindication delivered maybe they were waiting for that to maybe it started starting to deliver yeah I should have a copy of that as well maybe you didn't maybe you didn't do your pledge manager strong chance strong chance cool there's some tips and tricks thoughts about the kickstarter Marketplace and uh board game industry as a whole let us know what yours are and uh have some Grace that's not what we're supposed to have some grapes Grace Grace it's hard to publish that grapes do you like definitely seedless are you like

seedless seedless red I like green it just depends on the day what about the concord grapes like fresh picked in the fall I like them in Juice not just like they don't like just eating them though chewing on them they're a little bitter sometimes the skin can be I like yeah I like that this video derailed so hard because I said Grace not grapes let us know what type of grapes you love and we'll respond to you sometime I probably won't down below about grapes yeah I was thinking about board games if you leave a comment about grapes I'm going to screenshot it and send it to Austin meaning that I will have at least some type of response from him whatever the case we'll see you next time

Progress saved